10/19/2016 Intro to MSE microscopy and mechanical properties
Oct 14, 2023
Callister Intro to MSE, materials science, microscopy, slip planes, ASTM testing, tension, compression, shear, forces, poisson ratio, modulus from atomic forces, yield strength, stress and strain curves, ultimate tensile stress, necking, work hardening
don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't
know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't
just go anywhere on the surface it's gonna find where there's an edge already
formed and then keep growing and you can see that here so this is an image we'll
talk about how they made this image in just a moment but you can see they they
take a bunch of still images and put them together and make a video and see
like these sheets of materials they grow because Adams sit on the ledges and
that just grows outward and if you leave this it's slowly coarsening and growing
over time, right?
So films grow like this.
If you do what's called physical vapor deposition sputtering.
Let's show that one more time.
If you grow these things by just bombarding a surface
with atoms, they could sit just anywhere.
They could just sort of speckle it like spray paint would.
But if you do it by giving it a little bit of slow time
and then giving it energy, sorry,
do it slowly so it has lots of time,
it's going to grow specifically by going
on those ledges, which makes them a nicer, more uniform
film.
So there's that for today.
So how did they collect that image, right?
Those were actual atoms you saw growing along there.
So how did they collect that image?
What do you guys think?
Taylor?
Why?
That's a good question.
Oh, yeah.
Why couldn't they fill the gap?
Eventually, it would.
And you notice it actually was kind
of the direction it was going.
If you look at how it was in the beginning,
it had some deep canyon sort of thing.
Those slowly are getting filled in.
By the time you're done, it's starting
to look a little bit smoother.
And if you gave it, basically, there's a competition.
You're bombarding it with atoms.
So that's adding more atoms.
But then it takes time for them to find the lowest energy
position, and they have to be able to diffuse and move
around to find that lowest energy position.
So it's a competition between adding too much
and not giving enough time for them to move around.
If you do this really slowly, meaning
your flux of atoms to the surface is low,
and you give it plenty of energy for them to move around,
it'll give a more homogeneous, nicer surface,
but at the cost of growing very, very slowly.
So it's a trade-off you have.
So how do we make this image?
They say STM.
What's STM?
It stands for, anybody heard this one?
It stands for Scanning Tunneling Microscope.
So it's a type of electron microscope.
You could also make this with AFM.
And that was the last thing that we didn't get to last time.
So let's briefly talk about AFM.
So you don't need to know the details
of these different microscopes.
It's enough to know that, here's a good question.
This would be something that I could ask you on.
Why are you able to achieve a higher resolution
with an electron microscope as opposed
to an optical microscope?
That's about the extent I expect you to know.
So turn to your neighbor and take a stab.
Why can we get higher resolution with an electron microscope
as opposed to an optical microscope?
OK, what do you guys think?
Let me pick on Tyler in the white shirt in the back.
That may not be your name.
I think it's Tyler.
But you don't know the answer.
Phone a friend.
All right, next to him, what's your name?
Anthony, what do you think?
Why can we get better resolution with an electron microscope
instead of an optical?
OK, that's a good point.
You basically said your eye wouldn't
be able to process it.
That's not actually terribly off from the right answer.
The answer to this is that the wavelength of light
that you hit the sample with is way, way too small.
If we use something like an electron microscope,
if you let that hit your eye, it would actually
damage your eye.
And it certainly wouldn't be turned into an image,
because our eyes can only turn things
into image light that's between, I think we said,
like 300 and 700, roughly.
We can't see outside of that wavelength window.
But an electron microscope doesn't have that problem.
It can convert any wavelength into a signal.
So you're actually not terribly far off on that.
Now, why can we go to smaller resolution?
It's because if you use, imagine,
wavelength of light, 300 nanometers,
how are you ever going to see something smaller
than 300 nanometers, which atoms are?
You can't.
You have to move to a light of a wavelength
at least as small as the atoms, which
an electron microscope can do.
So we talked about scanning electron microscopes.
We talked about transmission electron microscopes.
Basically, one, the beam of electrons
bombards through the sample.
And one hits the sample and bounces back.
And you can make cool images.
The very last thing we said was EDS, elemental analysis,
where basically, you can not only
capture an image, which the one on this left right here,
sorry, let me give it a color, this one,
you can barely see two different colors there.
But it's not very clear.
And then when we move that to backscatter,
you can distinctly see two different phases
because the contrast is proportional to the density
of your sample.
And all of a sudden, you've got two different density pieces
that you're looking at.
And then we did even better when we
added elemental information.
And that's where we left off last time.
So there's one more thing which we
should talk about, which is scanning probe microscopy.
One of them, the most common one,
is AFM, which is atomic force microscopy.
And how this works is actually pretty clever.
Atomic force microscopy, or AFM, works
by taking a tiny little tip, right?
And they try and get them atomically sharp, right?
And they put it on a cantilever beam
so this thing can rotate up and down.
And they tap along a surface, right?
So if I'm a machine, and I've got this little cantilever
going tap, tap, tap, it's looking flat.
And then I hit something slightly higher.
I say a little bit higher, tap, tap, a little bit lower, right?
So it's only a surface measurement.
This will only give you information at the surface.
It doesn't probe underneath it.
But it can produce very nice topological images
of the surface, topographical images of the surface, right?
And some of these are actually incredibly sensitive
to the point where you can visualize atoms,
which is amazing.
Literally, this funky organic molecule,
they were able to sort of hold it in place.
I don't know how they did that.
Probably just cooled it down so this thing couldn't
reptate, which is when a polymer sort of rotates a little bit,
or diffuse around the surface.
And then they tapped it.
And they were able to produce an image of the structure, which
is pretty stinking amazing.
So I think that's what they did here.
They used a scanning tunneling microscope,
which is using a similar technique
to visualize a surface.
It's not tapping it.
I think it's actually using STM, I think stands for tunneling.
In that case, what it does is it brings this surface,
it brings some sort of probe near the surface.
And if you apply a voltage across here,
as a function of how far away from the surface you are,
you can actually get electrons to trickle across to it.
They tunnel across the energy barrier.
I'm pretty sure that's how it's doing it.
But it's the same principle.
It's measuring the surface.
And if you take a bunch of those images
and then splice them together over time,
you can create images like this one, where now all of a sudden
you can see films growing based on how atoms would be moving
and choosing where to sit.
OK, that's chapter five.
We're going to skip chapter six and come back to it
in a couple.
Let's go to chapter seven, which is mechanical properties.
So our objectives for today, what do we want to learn?
We're going to review basic stress and strain, which
you guys should have seen in high school, I'm guessing,
and certain mechanical engineers in your intro course
you saw it.
So we'll be brief on that.
We'll talk about Hooke's law, which again, most of you
will have seen.
You've all taken physics, so you would have seen Hooke's law.
We'll identify yield stress, the proportional limit
and ultimate stress.
We'll talk about strength, toughness, resilience,
and how we get these from stress versus strain curves.
And I think we'll have time to get to Poisson's ratio
by the end, OK?
So we've talked about solids.
We've talked about defects in solids.
And we left off last time saying some things
like remember sterling silver.
When you put a little bit of copper in with your silver,
you made it stronger, right?
And we just started to explain that.
So before we can get into the mechanisms of how things
get stronger and tougher, we need
to talk about what is strength, what is toughness, right?
So why do mechanical properties matter?
Well, forces are applied to all the materials
that are in solid time.
Every one of you is sitting in a desk
where some engineer somewhere had
to figure out how thick does this aluminum have to be
or steel have to be or is this going to deform?
Is it going to deform too much?
They had to do these calculations
because it's all around us, right?
A lot of things that break that lead to accidents or safety
concerns have to do with mechanical forces causing
an object to fracture.
Not always, but oftentimes.
And maybe your material has a deformation
that's supposed to happen.
Maybe that's its critical function, right?
A pole vault. A pole vaulter, when he uses pole vault,
whatever you call that, the pole for pole vaulting,
that thing is supposed to deform in a certain way.
They designed it to deform in a certain way.
And many applications might have that, right?
Skis, I mean, half the stuff that we design,
they're meant to have a certain amount of deformation.
So we need to understand how deformation
works in material in response to applied loads.
So in this chapter, we'll be able to answer questions
like how strong is the material?
How much can it deform?
Is that deformation reversible?
Or am I permanently deforming it?
OK, and we'll talk about it in terms of classes of material.
So if we're going to be testing materials
for strength and deformation, one
of the first things we need to get to
is how do we make sure that we're all
doing it the same way, right?
If I send a sample to Andrew and I send a sample to Tyler
and I say, tell me the ductility of the sample,
I have to give them a means whereby they can both test that
the same way, because ductility is a kind of a nebulous term.
They're like, well, I can flex it a little bit,
and what do they come back telling me, right?
So there needs to be ways where everyone
can test it the same way and test it the same way such
as you get the same answer, whether it's
done in China or the United States or wherever else, right?
So for that, there are actually whole organizations
that dedicate themselves to trying
to answer this question of how do we test things and have
a uniform way that everyone agrees on this material is
such and such strength, right?
And so the American Society of Testing Materials,
ASTM is one way.
ASTM International, they put out what
are called standards, which are a set of procedures
for testing pretty much anything you can imagine.
If there's a product out there that has a property of interest,
there's probably an ASTM standard
for measuring that property.
That might be how long it takes for cement to set up and cure.
There's definitely those.
That might be strength under tensile loading.
It might be all sorts of things.
And some of them get pretty specific,
like here's one that we had to do recently.
A company, since I run the characterization lab at the U,
they asked us to figure out how well does their lining
material stick to the substrate underneath it, right?
It's a thing like a composite.
There's a steel substrate.
There's this polymer that's on top of it.
And they have to peel this thing off.
This is not our video.
This is someone else's.
But this is a test we did.
And they said, we need you to do ASTM D1781, right?
And we said, all right, what is that?
We looked it up, and it's called a climbing drum test.
And how it works is you clamp the sample.
The sample up here, you can see it just barely.
It's got a steel substrate, probably.
It's got some sort of lining on top of it.
You clamp onto the bottom, and then the lining
itself is connected to this rotating drum, which
causes it to slowly peel.
You can see it.
It's a short video.
As they run this experiment, you'll
see that drum slowly climbs apart.
You're basically peeling this thing off.
So the diameter of this drum, the rate at which you do it,
the force that you can apply, all of that is prescribed.
And you measure the pounds per linear inch
of this to get delaminated, right?
And since this is an ASTM standard,
it doesn't matter if I do it here, or in New York,
or wherever.
They can say, hey, our product complies with ASTM D1781.
And it has such and such a delamination strength, right?
So some of these are strange, right?
They're out there.
But it's necessary that we have them,
because otherwise, it would be totally subjective.
A group could say, hey, we have this super strong material.
But that's only because they measured it in such a way
that it exaggerated the strength.
So we all need to have something that allows for even comparison.
OK, let's talk about types of loads and forces.
This is stuff you would have seen before.
There's different types of loads that you
can apply to a material, right?
There's tensile.
So imagine that we initially had a material
with this dotted sort of profile, right?
See that sort of ghost shape there?
After you apply a load, this is pulling it apart
by taking the force and loading it perpendicular to the face.
We get this final shape with now the not broken lines,
the solid lines.
So it stretched out, and it got a little bit skinnier, right?
If you apply a load in compression,
we now call this a negative force, just by convention.
We call negative forces compression, right?
And its initial shape was here, but its final shape
is now shorter and sort of squattier, right?
You can do shear.
Shear is now when you apply a force,
but it's no longer perpendicular to the face.
It's parallel.
So when I push on this table, right, when I'm leaning on it,
part of my force is still pushing down, right?
Because I'm not glued to the table.
So there's a component of regular compression,
and there's a component of shear,
where I'm actually shearing this table.
The floor is holding it, so there's
an equal and opposite force.
I'm pushing it this way.
The floor is holding it with an equal and opposite force
that way, but the table technically
is deforming a tiny bit.
So there's not much that we can see, right?
Some things are very compliant in terms of shear,
and you could squish it and see a major change, like rubbers.
You can see those things change quite a bit, right?
And then torsion is just a special type
of shear that produces rotation about a longitudinal axis.
So we'll talk about these each in turn.
First up, tension.
Tension is almost always done under uniaxial conditions.
It doesn't make sense for me if this is the thing I'm testing.
I usually would pull it like this.
I would pull it like this and have another wire
trying to pull out some funky angle.
That wouldn't make sense.
We're generally talking about uniaxial tensile tests, right?
By the way, if this is anybody's, it's here.
And they often have a pre-described shape,
which is called in the industry a dog bone, right?
Looks kind of like a dog bone.
If you look at the ASTM standards
for any sort of tensile strength,
it will say exactly what shape and size and conditions
it's allowable to have for your samples, right?
It'll even say, what is the radius of curvature
on these curved-in sections?
What is the, you know, it's very, very detailed.
Why does it have to be narrowed in like that?
Let me pick on one of my MSc students,
since I know you did this yesterday.
Daniel, let me pick on you.
Yeah, this is the dog bone.
When you grab onto it, you're using something
kind of like vice grips, which have
a bunch of little tiny teeth, and you clamp onto it.
So you actually can see, after you test this,
it has like a bunch of little lines like that
from like the vice grips clamping onto it.
If this is at all the brittle material,
that's just a complete non-starter.
You can't vice grip onto your dinner plate at home.
It would just break, right?
So ceramics just, they just don't work for this.
But polymers and metals, you can do it.
However, you're gonna have some stress
that's amplified local to that little thing.
So to avoid it from breaking right there,
and therefore not giving you a real feel
for the strength of the material,
since it's now an effect of the loading,
we actually wanna narrow it, right?
So this has some cross-sectional area up here.
This is gonna have some smaller cross-sectional area
in that part, right?
The point being that if you go down a cross-sectional area,
what do we do in terms of stress?
We go up, right?
Because stress is equal to the force divided by the area.
So if you go down an area, we magnify the stress
in that middle region, which causes it to fail,
you know, somewhere in the middle, where we wanted it to,
rather than where it's being gripped onto,
which we don't want.
So there'll be either clamp on,
or sometimes screw in dog bones,
where we can screw them in.
But that's a standard shape that you'll do
if you wanna test your material.
So if you guys end up working for Wheeler,
or Caterpillar, or Kennecott,
and you guys need to talk about strength of your materials,
you'll have to send your materials out
to be machined first, and then tested
according to some ASTM.
So stress is a force, but it's not just a force,
it's a force divided by an area, right?
Force over area is stress.
And then we have to have strain, epsilon.
Epsilon is our strain.
Think of that as the change in length,
so L final minus L initial,
the initial, or the instantaneous minus the initial,
over the initial, right?
L final minus L initial over L initial,
change in length over L naught, right?
That's what's called engineering stress,
or engineering strain, because we don't take into account
real-time conditions, right?
We're just saying, what were the initial conditions, right?
If you had a rod, and its initial cross-sectional area
was known, you apply a load to it,
that's its engineering stress.
That's different than the instantaneous stress,
which we'll get to in a minute, right?
A few things here, that force is always in newtons,
if we're not barbarians,
and area's gonna give me a meter squared,
so newton per meter squared, that is a Pascal, right?
So you'll see PSI, for barbarians among us,
that do pounds per square inch,
it's not a very useful thing,
because a pound is not a force.
A pound is a unit of mass
that you then have to apply gravity to.
It's just a terrible unit.
It's a terrible, no-good unit, but it's sometimes used.
So use Pascals, right?
And a newton per meter squared is a Pascal,
and a million of those is a megapascal, right?
Strain has no units, right?
To go back to strain, it was just change in length,
so like one centimeter minus half a centimeter,
still units of centimeters,
divided by our initial length, you know, a centimeter.
Centimeters cancel out, so there's no units.
So sometimes it's given as a percent,
or as a parts per million,
but it should have no units, right?
Now there's compression tests.
We said before that force,
if it's pressing down on a material,
we call that a negative force.
These are less common.
They're still useful for a lot of things.
They're just less common.
There's shear and torsional tests.
The big thing to remember here
is that the force is now applied parallel to the face
rather than perpendicular.
Yeah, Kelly?
Sorry, one more time.
Is it tensile strength?
No, no, they're not.
It's just that it's more commonly reported.
It's easier to do, I think.
Well, actually, compression would be easier,
but more commonly, yield strength
is as a function of tensile loading.
For ceramics, that could be wildly different
than its compressive strength.
Their compressive strength is about 10 to 15 times
higher than tension, right?
For a lot of materials,
they just don't report compression.
They report tension.
I know, but they're not the same thing.
Definitely not the same thing.
If you have a material that's being sheared,
it started out like that,
and after you shear it,
it's now deflected at some angle.
See that angle there?
If you take the tangent of that angle,
that's gamma.
That's our shear angle, right?
And then in the real world,
there's not just one load.
It can be combinations of load.
And one way to see that is,
imagine you had a cylinder to start with
that wasn't broken in half.
This was together.
If you apply a load to it
directly perpendicular to that face,
right, it's perpendicular,
then you think that you're applying
pure tensile load to this,
and you are.
However, we could imagine
that somewhere within this material,
along this plane,
which is tilted by some degree theta,
that on that plane,
you now have both tension, right?
We'll call that the,
oh, that's a terrible color, sorry.
You have tension.
You have a resolved tension on that plane,
and you have a resolved shear on that plane, right?
So resolved tension and resolved shear
is as a function of whatever plane
you're talking about, okay?
So we have formulas for those, right?
The normal, the tensile stress in that plane
could be given here if you knew the angle,
and the shear could be given through the angle.
We're gonna come back to that in a minute
because a lot of materials,
that becomes important because they slide,
the atoms slide past each other
along certain planes.
Remember when we did Miller indices
and we figured out planes in a crystal?
They slide past some,
but maybe not past another.
So we need to figure out the angles
and calculate the resolved stresses.
So we'll come back to that next chapter.
Sorry, chemistry never goes away.
Okay, there's elastic deformation.
When you guys took chemistry,
or physics, actually,
you probably saw the example
where they took a spring, right,
and they put a mass on it,
and they started it oscillating,
and they talked about, oh,
the different mass or the different spring constant
can change the rate of oscillation
and the amount of deformation,
the deflection of the spring, right?
So that is just a manifestation of Hooke's Law.
Hooke's Law says when you apply a stress,
right, sigma, you're gonna get a strain,
and how much strain you get
is just proportional to the constant of proportionality,
which in this case is Young's modulus,
sometimes called the elastic modulus
or modulus of elasticity.
Those are all the same thing.
Young's modulus, modulus of elasticity,
all the same thing.
And since strain is unitless,
this must have the units of stress,
so it has just megapascals,
and more commonly gigapascals
because it's much larger, right?
If a material is proportional,
then we call it elastic deformation,
and this means that it's non-permanent
and it's reversible.
So I take a rubber band and I stretch it.
The amount of stretch that I get
for a given load would be the Young's modulus,
and since it goes all the way back
to how it started after I take the load off,
we call that elastic deformation,
like an elastic band.
It's elastic.
It goes back.
It's not permanent.
There is a point on an elastic band.
If you pull it too much,
it's now permanently stretched out.
It'll be a little bit more stretched
than when you started,
or it'll even break, right?
That's plastic deformation,
meaning permanent, right?
So our first clicker question for the day,
when we plot stress versus strain,
think of our equation here.
Stress equals the constant of proportionality
times strain.
Some materials are gonna be more compliant.
They're gonna give a higher amount of deformation, right?
And some will be lower.
So which one of these are which?
Let's start with the first one.
Which material on this plot,
pause it while you log in,
which material is the ceramic?
Is it the blue, red, green, or purple line?
For those that may be colorblind,
that's purple, green, red, blue.
Purple, green, blue.
Okay, so which one is the ceramic?
When you apply a load,
think of what happens.
Should it stretch a lot or a little?
Okay, people think red.
Oh no, blue.
I saw the red color, I was like, what?
Sorry, my brain.
Good, most people think blue.
How did you know?
Somebody who got it right,
tell me what you thought.
Pick on somebody.
Who got it right?
Anybody?
Rachel.
So there's not going to be any sort of curve.
Yeah, this one's got that little hook.
It technically does start to plastically deform,
which we'll get to in a minute.
Since there's no plastic deformation with ceramics.
Can rule that out.
And basically, when you apply a huge stress,
you don't get very much strain.
If you take a dinner plate,
you can pull on it pretty hard.
It won't actually break at very low loads.
Ceramics can be strong,
they just aren't necessarily compliant at all.
They can't deform very much, right?
They're not ductile at all,
but they can be fairly strong, okay?
So our next one then,
which one's the polymer?
Okay, people think that it is D, mostly.
A quarter of us think green, but mostly D.
Okay, good.
And I think there's one more here.
Oh no.
Hold that thought, we'll come back to that one.
Okay.
All right, so which one would be a brittle steel
versus a ductile steel?
Red is what?
That would be our brittle steel,
because it can't deform very much before it breaks.
It might be stronger, right?
But this would be our ductile steel, right?
Because even after the point
where it's no longer proportional,
look, it just goes quite a bit more strain
before it finally breaks, okay?
You can technically have non-linear elastic deformation,
meaning you pull on it and it's gonna go back to normal,
but it maybe gets easier and easier the more you pull,
or even harder and harder the more you pull.
But it will go back, right?
So rubber does this, cement does that,
some polymers will do that.
Meaning you could stretch it out to this point,
but it might still go all the way back.
Just depends, right?
If it's elastic, the key thing to remember
is that it's reversible,
there's no permanent deformation.
Skip that.
I think we've talked quite a bit about forces
and inter-atomic distances in this class,
but let's do it one more time.
We said that if you've got some inter-atomic distance,
R here, and you have a net force is zero,
that corresponds to R naught, right?
R naught is when there's no net force,
so force is low here and then it comes up and comes down.
We said that the modulus is just,
that's a really bad line, let me fix that.
I don't approve of that line, right?
This is better.
At that point, the slope of that line, right?
Remember this is force against separation, distance, right?
So the slope of this line means,
the higher the slope of that line means
the more force you have to apply
to get a very small change, right?
So that's a stiffer material, that's like a ceramic, right?
And if it's a polymer, then it's something
that would be way lower slope,
because the same force would produce
much more change in the x-axis.
So what are some typical values
that you should know for materials?
Ceramics are higher than metals or higher than polymers
in terms of their elastic modulus, right?
Ceramics can be gigapascals, right?
Some of them like 400 gigapascals,
maybe 50 to 400 is okay regions.
Remember gigapascal is a billion pascals now,
10 to the ninth.
But polymers could be less than a gigapascal,
it could be 0.1.
And metals are gonna be somewhere in between, okay?
Modulus decreases with temperature, generally speaking.
Some rubbers don't do that,
they stiffen as you heat it up.
But most materials you heat it up
and it becomes more compliant.
You should probably have experience with that.
Most things you've probably experienced that in your life.
You heat it up, it's a little bit more compliant.
Now just like that, that was with shear,
or sorry, with tensile load,
and you got a modulus for tensile modulus,
you can get the same thing for shear.
Eric, question?
That's a very good indicator of it.
I don't know if that's 100% of the time,
but that's a very good indicator of it.
Because it probably means as you're heating it up
that you're cross-linking process is continuing.
It's using that thermal energy to further cross-link
or maybe thermally cross-link.
And therefore if it's cross-linked, it's not gonna melt.
So it's a very good indicator.
Because as cross-linking goes up, it's getting stiffer.
So it's a good indicator.
There's probably exceptions to that rule.
Okay, just like for elastic modulus
with under a tensile load or a compressive load,
you also have it under shear conditions, right?
If you shear something, you're gonna end up
that the shear stress will produce a shear angle
proportional to the shear modulus, right?
So shear modulus is something that you can calculate
just like the other one.
There's anelasticity.
Anelasticity means that instead of getting
an immediate elastic response,
there's a time-dependent nature.
We're gonna come back to this,
because it becomes really important.
It typically means that there's some sort of microscopic
or atomic process that's happening that takes time, right?
Polymers are a great example of this.
Imagine you're climbing a rope.
If anybody goes rock climbing,
you've got a big tangle of rope, right?
If you wanna pull that thing,
the coils have to sort of align themselves
for it to stretch it out, right?
It's taking time for these coils to align.
Same thing in polymers.
If you stretch something that's polymeric like this is,
it's cotton, so it's polymer of some sort.
If I pull on it, it would have some sort of time response
in terms of I apply a load
and it doesn't instantaneously change.
It's slowly gonna change in response.
And some things are really dramatic
like silly putty we were talking about.
Some of them change really dramatically
and some not so much.
We'll come back to that.
Okay, there's Poisson's ratio.
Poisson's ratio says that as you pull on something
or push on something,
sure, you get a change in terms of the strain
in the direction that you're pulling or pushing it,
but you also get change in the dimensions
transverse to that.
What do I mean?
So if you're pulling something,
we know that an object, if I pull on this,
it's technically stretching out a little bit.
That's obvious.
Poisson's ratio says it's also,
Carl says, right, so it's contracting, right?
And alternately, if you push on something,
it's technically getting a little bit wider, right?
So we need a way to quantify that
in case it becomes significant.
In a lot of cases, it is significant.
So they defined Poisson's ratio.
They said it's negative
because they wanted to have a positive value.
Positive, if you're loading it in the Z direction,
so up and down,
then you take the strain in either the X or the Y direction
and divide it by the strain in the Z direction,
which might be stretching, right?
So under tension, you should get a positive value
for Poisson's ratio, right?
What are values typically?
Somewhere between maybe a quarter and one half, right?
That's typical.
And for a lot of metals,
it might be between 0.25 and 0.35.
Some things are really far out there.
Cork, for example, is the example I usually give.
Cork has Poisson's ratio of, let me get this right,
it's zero.
Why does Poisson's ratio equal zero for cork?
And then alternately, Poisson's ratio for rubber is 0.5.
It's the maximum value.
So why?
What's going on there?
Anybody have a guess why cork versus rubber?
Yeah, Matt?
It would, if you pull it apart, it breaks easy.
Let's talk about compression.
If I compress cork, if it has a Poisson's ratio of zero,
that means as I squish it down,
it's not getting any fatter.
Why?
Its density can increase.
Cork is not a fully dense material.
It has tons of pores in it, right?
It naturally grows that way.
It's got tons of pores.
So as you squish it, you're just compacting those.
So it technically is getting wider.
It's kind of a trick question, right?
It's getting wider because its density can change.
It's filling in those voids.
If you had a cork somehow that didn't have those voids in it,
it wouldn't be cork anymore, but it would now expand, right?
Now rubber, rubber is the other extreme.
As you apply something, it's so compliant,
it's so easy for it to deform,
that it just expands very, very,
the maximum of any known material, obviously, 0.5, okay?
If you have these values, right,
if you have Young's modulus and shear modulus
and Poisson's ratio,
there are expressions like this one that can relate them.
So this is a super common test question, a homework question.
I'll give you information to solve two of these,
and then I'll ask you about something
relating to the third, right?
I'll give you a plot for Poisson.
Maybe I'll give you a plot for like stress versus strain.
The slope of that would give you Young's modulus, right?
And then I say the final dimension was this
when you applied a load of that.
So that allows you to figure out Poisson's ratio,
because I told you how much it contracted.
And then I might ask you what a shear angle might be
if it was loaded under some shear stress.
So you have to figure out what G is from these two,
and then solve for a shear angle, yeah?
So we are talking about isotropic materials.
I think I mentioned that right here.
Yeah, if a material is isotropic,
then we say that strain in the X direction and Y direction
is gonna be equal to one another.
If you have anisotropic materials, it throws it off,
and we're not gonna cover that in this class.
In your mechanics classes, you will see it,
not in this class.
Any questions on this, on this equation,
on anything we've covered so far?
Seeing some sleepy eyes.
Let's shake it up.
Let's do something different, right?
Okay.
How do we know when a material is yielding?
What is yield?
First off, what is yield?
Turn to your neighbor.
What does yield mean with material science?
Hint, it's right around point three.
Okay, how do we know when a material is yielding?
Let me click on Kara.
I think it's Kara.
Good guess.
You're guessing, then, the definition of yield
has something to do when the thing breaks.
That's a good guess.
It's not right.
It's a good guess, though.
Anybody have another thought?
In the red.
I don't know why.
Yeah, it's when plastic deformation begins,
and that's a super hard thing to do,
because if you look at this plot,
that's about at point three, right?
Here's our Young's modulus, meaning you apply a load
and you get some sort of strain,
and technically, the very instant
when it starts to have permanent deformation,
that's when you have yield, the onset of yield.
In reality, that's super hard to measure,
because it's gonna be really, really small,
so you'd have to have
really, really sensitive equipment on there, right?
So instead, we as a community, we've gotten together,
we said, how do we talk about yielding materials?
We said, well, let's just pick a point
where everyone can easily measure,
and that is when you pull it, and then when you let go,
and it goes back, and there's a leftover strain
equal to 0.2%, that is our yield strength,
just by definition, totally arbitrary, right?
So that's what we've decided on.
What that means is that if you load this
one to two, and then you let go,
it'll go right back to zero.
It'll have no leftover strain, totally elastic, right?
If you load it to three, anywhere beyond three,
technically, if you unload it,
it will go back with the same slope as its young modulus,
and you'll have some leftover strain, right?
That's plastic strain that you've left in your material.
So we just, as a community, we said, all right,
as soon as it gets to a point, which is four,
where the leftover strain is equal to 0.2%,
we'll call that our plastic, or sorry,
our yield strength, right?
So yield strength, sigma y is what that's usually written as.
Questions on that?
Yeah, remember your name?
Katie.
No idea.
I have no idea the history of the 0.2.
That is what it is.
I think it's probably fairly easy to measure.
I don't know the history behind that,
but that is what it is.
So when you look up on your spec sheet
for your steels, or your coppers,
or whatever you're using, and you see yield strength,
technically, it is yielding a little bit
at the value that you've taken it to.
It's just a small amount, permanent.
Yeah, Kylie?
If you have what percent?
Like if it went back?
It just depends on the application.
Depends on the application, right?
If it's a piston in your car,
how much, what's the tolerance of the piston
inside of the cylinder?
Pretty small, right?
Would 0.1% make a difference?
Maybe, I don't know.
Just depends on the application.
Oh, absolutely, yeah, that's absolutely true.
You keep on loading this, this is gonna keep on adding up.
That's actually true.
We'll talk about that in a minute.
What happens when you unload something
and then reload it again?
We're getting to that in just a minute.
The thing to remember here that I want you to remember
is that when you let this go,
let's say we load it up to here,
and this corresponded to like, I don't know, 0.6% strain.
When I take that stress off,
you're not left with 0.6% strain,
you're left with 0.2, because it's gonna go back
by whatever its modulus was, right?
Question?
Yeah.
Great question.
If you have a material that is anelastic,
right, go back up here,
we said anelasticity means time-dependent,
then you have to technically,
then these should be equilibrium, right?
You should let it sit for infinite amount of time, right?
Most materials aren't strongly anelastic.
Metals, for example, at some temperatures,
they might start to become anelastic, right?
But yeah, technically, just like phase diagrams
are under thermodynamic equilibrium conditions,
technically, yeah, this thing, if it's still changing,
you should leave it there.
Make sense?
No?
So some materials, if you load it up to something
and you unload it right away,
you might see no permanent deformation.
But if you let this thing sit for a good long time,
those polymer chains maybe might slide
past each other to the point where now,
when you take it off, it just stays put.
What do we call that?
There's a term for that, we learned about it earlier.
We called it plastic deformation
that's not there instantaneously,
but over time, it is there.
We call that creep, that's creep.
So you're talking about creep.
So to solve this, like,
these plots don't take into account creep.
You'd have to have a more sophisticated
stress versus strain plot to account for creep, right?
So this thing, the macro.
For this material, however long they left it there,
when they took it off, it had 0.2% left over.
So when you report these,
yield stress has to be as a function of conditions, right?
So that's why there's ASTMs.
It would tell you how long you hold it for,
how long you, how many times you have to do this, maybe,
what temperature this happens at.
That's why ASTM standards have to exist
because there's all these other variables
that could give you unfortunately incorrect values,
or just confusing, like multiple values for the same thing.
But there's not actually multiple phenomena happening,
or sorry, there's not multiple values.
There's multiple phenomena happening.
It's just different things, creep or no creep, basically.
Any questions else on this?
Those are great questions.
Okay, let's keep going.
Okay, further than I thought we'd get.
So we have more learning objectives, right?
So let's talk about ultimate tensile strength.
We'll come back to this next time, maybe.
So when it does start to yield,
it might be nice and gradual, right?
It might be like this, where it just slowly bends over.
Or you could have something really funky happen.
It could like do this, and then go back up, right?
So that's what's happening here.
They call this yield point phenomenon,
where basically you're pulling on something,
it's looking totally elastic,
and all of a sudden, it might all of a sudden,
the load might drop in it.
You might see a sudden increase in the strain, right?
It might do something here,
and then it'll pick up at a more normal rate.
That's actually a really common thing to have happen
when it starts to yield.
At the onset of plastic deformation,
it can do something a bit funny here, okay?
Yeah.
No, good question, though.
That one's interesting.
Remember on the wire we had that we heated up, right?
That thing went down because we were heating it up,
and at a certain temperature,
it went from BCC iron to FCC iron,
which is a more compact structure, right?
Higher atomic packing fraction.
So if it compacted, the wire had to contract,
so it actually went up,
and then when it kept on heating, it kept on expanding,
and then in reverse happened.
So that had to do with a phase change,
not to do with a yield phenomenon.
Good question, though.
So what are some typical values for yield strength?
Just two that you ought to have in your back pocket
when you think about engineering materials
is that aluminum is about 35 megapascals.
That's not very high.
Aluminum bends pretty easy, right?
The point at which you bend it and it's permanently bent,
35 megapascal.
It's not very high.
Steel is an order of magnitude almost two higher than that,
1,400 megapascals.
Yeah, question?
Oh, absolutely, absolutely.
There's whole fields dedicated to that in material science
where they'll put things
in what are called diamond anvil presses,
where it's a press that applies
just ginormous pressures on something,
and then they'll try and look at what phase is present
using complicated diffraction,
and they show that you can change phases
by just applying stresses.
Yeah, in that case, it would be.
The one that we talked about
is just a thermodynamically favorable change in structure,
which corresponds to a change in stress,
or sorry, a change in length,
because it has a different packing ratio.
But you could force it to happen in some materials,
and that's definitely studied.
So these are some typical values you should have.
Okay, the next thing is what Kara was talking about.
Kara said, well, you're gonna pull in,
it's gonna break at some point, right?
It's gonna fail.
That is now the tensile strength, right?
Tensile strength of TS.
Sometimes they'll call it ultimate tensile strength, UTS.
But this is basically the maximum stress
that you can apply something,
even if you don't care if plastic deformation's happening,
there's still, right, this point
is definitely permanently deformed at that point.
Tons of permanent deformation.
Doesn't matter.
This is the maximum stress you ever reach, right?
So that is our tensile stress, right?
After that point,
and you guys probably have experience with this,
once you're pulling on something,
you get what's called necking occurring here.
It starts to stretch, maybe,
but it's getting easier and easier to pull
until it finally breaks, right?
So this region is necking at the end.
So the next, did we pass the question?
Oh no, it's right here, good.
Where is it?
Oh, I've lost it.
Okay, right here.
The question is, is the material,
so the material seems to be getting harder and stronger
up until tensile stress, right?
Up here, it's getting stronger and stronger, we think,
because to stretch it,
you have to keep on adding more and more stress, right?
The question is,
is it true that it's getting harder and harder
and stronger and stronger up to TS,
and then begins to get weaker?
True or false?
Does it begin to get weaker after tensile stress?
So, what do you think?
True or false?
Okay, Eric had a good question.
In this question,
we're ignoring this yield point phenomenon,
this little bit where it got weaker.
We're talking about,
the question is, right here,
stress seems to be going up,
harder, stronger material,
but here it seems to be going down.
Is that a true statement, that it's getting weaker?
That's all.
True or false?
Okay, phone a friend, get your answers in.
Wow!
That's amazing.
I can, let me make a,
somebody should be an email,
like, Danny, can you send me an email
and say give points for either answer on this one?
I'll change it after class.
Right now, only one of these is right, but I can change it.
I'm surprised, very split.
So, somebody argue one way and somebody argue the other.
Andrew, which one did you think?
Okay, you chose true.
You thought it's getting weaker.
What was your argument?
Okay, so you think that as you're pulling it apart,
it's just getting weaker,
and we can see evidence of that,
and this thing is going down.
I've lost it.
All right, I've lost it.
Anyways, it seems to be going down, right?
So, what's actually happening?
Who wants to think the other way?
Martin, what do you think?
Yeah, that's absolutely right.
So, that's the right answer.
Wake up my pen real quick.
So, what is necking?
Necking is when you're pulling on something,
and all of a sudden, the gauge starts to decrease.
I think I've got a picture right here.
Right here, right?
Necking is not what you're thinking of,
those who are giggling.
Necking is this, right?
You start to stretch it,
and so this distance from here to here
is getting longer at first.
That's just elongation,
but after the tensile stress,
the ultimate tensile stress,
all of a sudden, you get a region
where something funny's going on.
This thing bends in.
It forms a little net, right?
So, that's necking,
where you have a region
of extreme local plastic deformation.
There's general plastic deformation
all over in this thing,
but you get a region where locally
it's doing something even more severe.
So, this cross-sectional area is smaller
than we started.
Therefore, if it got smaller,
the actual stress is actually quite larger there.
So, these plots,
these are engineering strain plots, right?
This is engineering stress and engineering strain,
meaning it takes into account
just what the initial cross-sectional area was.
In reality, that thing got smaller.
If you were to account for that,
it would look like the following.
It would look like this.
So, here's our regular plot.
It went like this, right?
If you counted for the real
or the true engineering stress,
sorry, engineering stress is the original,
true stress and true strain would look like this,
meaning it is actually getting stronger and stronger
because of something called cold working,
which we'll get to later,
like the more plastic deformation,
the harder something gets.
It's just that it looks like it's getting weaker
because it's necking down, right?
So, if you were able to plot
the instantaneous cross-sectional area,
which means you'd have to have some sort of thing
to measure that area constantly,
even when it's necking down,
the plot would look like the red one, okay?
So, that is false
because it doesn't take into account
the change in the instantaneous cross-sectional area.
And I'll give credit for everyone on that.
Kyle?
Yeah, but stress, yeah, you're absolutely right.
The force is the same, maybe,
but stress equals force over area.
So, if this goes down and that stays the same,
that goes up.
It goes down on the graph
because it's basically saying
that the perceived stress is going down, right,
is what you're actually perceiving there.
Does this make sense?
Literally, the stress that you're applying to something
based off of your initial calculation,
it's just going down,
so it's taking less and less force.
So, force is what's changing, actually, here, right?
If you pull on something,
it seems like you don't have to pull it as far.
At the very end, imagine Silly Putty, right?
Taffy, I should bring Taffy for this, right?
You got Taffy, you're pulling on it.
After it starts necking down,
you don't have to pull as hard.
It's like finishing up, right?
So, you're applying less force,
but stress, in actuality, is actually still going up.
It's just that the cross-sectional area is going way down.
So, maybe this is a better way to put it.
This goes way down, right?
This goes down just a little bit.
So, overall, the stress should still be going up, right?
This should be going up.
Does that make sense?
That's a good question, actually.
I think it makes sense linearly.
It means the following.
At this point, right,
if you want to get a little bit more strain,
you've got to add a little bit more stress
than you had before, right?
For every little bit more stress,
or every little bit more strain you get,
you have to add a little bit more stress.
That means it's stronger.
It's getting harder and stronger, right?
It's called cold working, and we'll come back to it later.
Whereas the plot, without taking into account
the instantaneous area, looks like,
oh, it's getting easier and easier and easier
to pull it apart.
There's less force, but it's just because
the area is radically reducing.
Abby, or Alicia, sorry.
Years of discussion.
Exactly right, and the reason that is
because sometimes it's hard to measure
the instantaneous cross-sectional area.
You could, like if your experiment's running
and it's going nice and slow,
you could sit and watch it, watch for necking,
and then get your little calipers out
and start trying to measure it
and hope that it's like some nice shape
that's easy to measure, but because that's hard,
it's just not often done.
Like, the right way to do it would be to count for that,
because that's technically what's going on instantaneously.
So let's talk about the instantaneous change real quick,
right?
True stress and true strain would be now,
the true stress is gonna be the force
divided by your instantaneous area, not your initial.
Sorry, I means instantaneous.
The not means initial, right?
True strain is written as natural log
of your instantaneous length
divided by your initial length.
Where in the world did natural log come from, right?
Where'd that come from?
So strain, we knew it as your additional length
over your initial length,
or your additional length over initial length, right?
But the change in strain would be delta sigma, right?
Which is delta L over L,
which means you have to take into account,
you have to sum up all of your successive strain, right?
So you're gonna take the sum of all your changes in length
over your initial length,
which is another way of saying sum in engineering,
we say integral, right?
We're gonna integrate over it.
So you're gonna take DL over L,
which gives you natural log of instantaneous length
over initial length.
And if we use the constant volume approximation,
meaning whatever your area initial was
and length initial was, that'll equal your area final
or instantaneous times your length final,
meaning volumes conserved,
then we can rewrite these expressions as follows.
Meaning if you have a plot
and you have engineering stress and engineering strain,
which we have generally from plots,
we can turn those into true stress and true strain
using these two functions, right?
And it'll probably be a homework question
to do the proof of this, right?
Are there questions?
We're about out of time.
Any last questions before we pick up next time?
Okay, see you next time.

