How did the Holy Roman Empire Form? | Animated History

Frederick Barbarossa
2 followers
8th Century Europe After decades of relative stability, a new
threat has appeared on the horizon.
The Umayyad Caliphate, a Muslim dynasty whose territory stretches from Morocco to Central
Asia.
The Umayyad armies pour across the Straits of Gibraltar and easily wrestle control of
the Iberian Peninsula from the Visigoths, leaving the Muslim Empire poised to conquer
all of Europe.
But ready to resist are the Franks, distant cousins to the Visigoths who had taken the
former Gallic regions of the Roman Empire.
In 732, Frankish forces under the command of Charles Martel prepare to meet the Umayyads
at the Battle of Tours.
The Franks hope to deliver a stunning defeat to the invaders, blocking an Umayyad conquest
of Europe and opening the continent for Frankish war.
Hi, I'm Griffin Johnson, the Armchair Historian.
The fall of the Western Roman Empire was one of the most influential events in European
history.
Innumerable kings, princes, and minor states rushed to fill the power vacuum left in the
Empire's rubble.
By the 8th century AD, Europe was mostly controlled by the various Gothic kingdoms who had dealt
Rome its death blow.
Remarkably adaptable, the Goths settled into their new lands as nobles and administrators,
even taking up their own brand of Christianity, Arianism.
Today, we will be discussing how these Germanic kings would go on to form the Holy Roman Empire,
and how those who had once torn down the Roman Colossus would become their successors.
Before we begin our deep dive into medieval politics, I'd like to highlight our sponsor
for this video, MindStone, an innovative new tool designed to help you learn and process
information as quickly and efficiently as possible.
When confronted with a subject as complicated as history, especially medieval history, it's
vital to maintain focus on the important details.
Fortunately, MindStone helps you do exactly that with features such as notes, annotations,
and commentary directly linked to your reference material.
You can also highlight sections of text, then enter the highlight view to review them across
multiple articles, giving you an instant summary of all of the information gathered so far.
MindStone is ideal for group study projects and community endeavors, with features designed
to help a team coordinate their efforts and make the best out of their time together.
Furthermore, if you sign up for MindStone before June 30th, you'll become a free founding
user for life.
During research for this video, my team was able to collect a large amount of information
on the Carolingian Empire that was extremely useful for both the scriptwriting and art
departments.
If you want to gain access to this shared library on MindStone for yourself, all you
have to do is click the link in the notes section and you'll be sent right there.
Charles Martel's dramatic and unlikely victory at Tor dashed all hopes the Omayyads had of
moving beyond Iberia.
It also marked the beginning of the Carolingian Dynasty, with Martel's son Pepin the Short
becoming the King of the Franks in 751.
Despite his diminutive moniker, Pepin was a wise ruler who cultivated a strong relationship
with the Church, greatly expanding the power and influence of the Papacy by granting Pope
Stephen II control over a number of Italian cities that Pepin had conquered from the Lombards.
Thus were born the Papal States.
However, it would not be until the reign of Pepin's own sons, Charlemagne and Carloman,
that the possibility of building a true empire to rival Rome presented itself.
Despite splitting the kingdom equally between Charlemagne and Carloman in accordance with
the Frankish Inheritance Law, the two brothers began plotting against each other.
With lawsuits not having been invented yet, the two brothers prepared for the next best
thing, civil war.
But conflict was averted when Carloman died in glory, armor covered in the gore of an
acute nosebleed.
With his only true rival dead, the energetic and capable Charlemagne was now King of all
Francia, and the reunited kingdom soon became the most powerful nation in Europe.
It was a power that would soon be tested.
In 795, the consecration of Pope Leo III sent shockwaves through the Catholic world.
Leo was a commoner with no political allies or influence, and the election of a low-class
pontiff was unheard of.
The nobility within the new Pope's flock quickly sought to gently persuade Leo to
abdicate, and he was forced to flee Rome in 799 after nearly having his eyes and tongue
torn out by hired thugs.
Thanks to his family's positive standing with the church, Charlemagne was the logical
person to turn to for help, and Leo was soon back in Rome under heavy Carolingian guard.
But with his enemies accusing him of crimes ranging from adultery to perjury, Pope Leo
was left with little choice but to swear an oath of purgation, stating his innocence
before God on pain of eternal damnation.
Unable to challenge this declaration without calling their own religious integrity into
question, Leo's enemies were forced to admit defeat, and most were promptly exiled.
With his power unquestionably restored, Pope Leo presided over Holy Mass in old St. Peter's
Basilica, and as a reward for his service, Leo christened Charlemagne Imperator Romanarum,
Emperor of the Romans, before the dumbfounded faithful.
To say this was a controversial move would be an understatement.
For one thing, the mantle of Imperator Romanarum was already taken by Empress Irene in Constantinople.
Despite having lost control of Italy, the Roman Empire had preserved, thanks to its
prosperous eastern territories, and its inhabitants viewed themselves as being part of the exact
same national and political entity that had existed since the founding of Rome itself.
The papacy had even endorsed this viewpoint, having maintained for centuries that the person
sitting on the throne in Constantinople, Empress Irene at this point, was the legitimate ruler
of all former Roman holdings in Europe.
With a single declaration, Pope Leo III had unpended political and religious conventions
which had been in place for over 400 years.
Why was Leo so ready to flout tradition?
The relationship between the Church and the Roman Empire had been initially one of mutual benefit.
The Pope endorsed the legitimacy of each new Emperor in exchange for their assurance that
the Empire would come to their aid in any time of need.
But over the years, the papacy had come to regard the title of Emperor as ultimately
originating from God, designated specifically by the Pope, and returned to him upon the
death of each Emperor.
Finally, it was unthinkable for a patriarchal organization like the Church to be seen as
declaring a woman as Emperor, so Empress Irene remained unrecognized despite her holding
the title Leo had just given away.
Due to the belief that the imperial title could only be granted by the Church, Charlemagne
was barred from declaring a new imperial dynasty, and his intense piety prevented him
from questioning this state of affairs.
Furthermore, Frankish secession laws meant that the vast territories he had amassed were
inevitably split into separate nations by his heirs.
Within just a few generations, mighty Francia had reverted into squabbling petty kingdoms,
and the imperial title was reduced to little more than a bribe dispensed by the Pope to
ensure the loyalty of Italian nobles.
When Berniger I of Italy was assassinated in 924, the title was rendered all but defunct.
However, the coronation of Otto I as King of East Francia in 962 AD would resurrect
the title Imperator Romanarum in stunning fashion.
By this point in history, East Francia's culture and politics were distinct from its
western neighbour, causing many to refer to it as the Kingdom of Germany.
The early days of Otto's reign were marked by endemic political intrigue.
The impractical Frankish inheritance laws responsible for tearing the Carolingian Empire
apart had long since been discarded in favour of an elective monarchy, with the electoral
vote being carried out by the most powerful dukes of the realm.
But Otto's father, King Henry, disregarded tradition by naming his son heir apparent
without consulting the electors, leading to much resentment.
The situation came to a head in 937, when civil war broke out between Otto and his nobles,
who promptly sought aid from West Francia.
In the bloody series of conflicts that followed, Otto distinguished himself by crushing the
rebellion and re-establishing control over Germany.
Having consolidated power, Otto now began seeking to expand it further, beginning with
the subjugation of the Kingdom of Italy, a key part of the old Carolingian Empire.
In a bid to consolidate his grip on the peninsula, Otto allowed the defeated Berniger II to style
himself King of Italy in exchange for Berniger's fealty, but he was resentful of his suzerain,
and when Otto became distracted by affairs back in Germany, the King of Italy launched
a revolt.
Crucially, Berniger's forces besieged the city of Rome, causing Pope John XII to petition
Otto for aid.
Seeing a chance to demonstrate his ring-kissing, Otto raced south with an army and quickly
forced Berniger to retreat.
Upon entering Rome, Otto met with the Pope and swore a solemn oath to defend the Church
against all adversaries.
Having secured a powerful and influential protector once more, the Pope was more than
happy to dust off the imperial title and declare Otto Emperor of the Romans.
Byzantines be damned.
Unfortunately for John XII, Otto was no Charlemagne.
He was contemptuous of Pope John's alleged depravity and worldliness, and chastised the
Pope for his lack of piety.
Incensed at this ridicule from a mere earthly ruler, the pontiff began plotting against
Otto from the moment he left Rome.
But the new emperor was no fool, and discovered the papal plan within a year.
For his treachery, John XII was ignominiously deposed, and a new pope was elected in his
place.
This set an important precedent, demonstrating that any sufficiently powerful emperor could
easily defy the papacy and get away with it.
Otto secured imperial power by having his son, Otto II, crowned his co-emperor by Pope
John XIII in 967.
This skillful political maneuvering cemented the creation of a new imperial dynasty, which
would reign until 1024.
Although Otto's actions secured a lasting claim to the title of Roman Emperor, his Roman
empire was not yet holy.
His behavior also created a lasting animosity between the new emperors and the papacy, with
both claiming to be the main inheritors of the church's divine mandate, and the legacy
of ancient Rome.
Additionally, Otto's autocratic rulership alienated his nobility, and as the power of
his dynasty slowly waned, they were able to take back control of the elective monarchy
and extract numerous concessions from the new emperors.
This complicated relationship casted a shadow over the rule of Frederick Barbarossa I, the
man who would finally make the German lands a so-called Holy Roman Empire.
Barbarossa was elected Emperor of the Romans and King of Germany in 1152, but with little
intrinsic power, Frederick had to politick his way through the courts of Germany to accomplish
anything of substance.
However, Frederick's boundless ambition drove him onward, and he began planning to
wrestle control back from his quarrelsome nobles and restore the glory of the imperial
throne.
His opportunity came just one year later, in 1153, when Pope Eugene III appealed to
him for aid.
This was a dark time for the papacy, with the abject failure of the Second Crusade
having weakened their political sway in Italy to such an extent that the citizens of Rome
had ejected the Pope from the city and were calling for the Church to renounce all of
its worldly possessions.
Not one to let a good crisis go to waste, Frederick signed the First Treaty of Constance
with Pope Eugene, promising to restore the Pope's position in Rome in exchange for
a grand and public coronation as Emperor.
This last point was critical, as up until now, Frederick was merely an Emperor-elect
and had yet to be crowned in a holy ceremony.
His attempts to enforce the treaty faced innumerable setbacks.
Before the year ended, Pope Eugene was dead, with Pope Adrian IV replacing him and nominally
upholding the agreement.
After a year-long campaign in the south of Italy, Frederick arrived in Rome in 1155 only
to refuse to follow the ritual displays of subjugation to his holiness demanded by tradition.
The deeply offended Adrian refused to move forward with the coronation until he had been
sufficiently honored.
Frederick eventually gave in, but is quoted as muttering, Pro Petro, non Adriano.
For Saint Peter, not Adrian.
The hasty coronation that followed was punctuated by yet another revolt, forcing Frederick to
spend his first few hours as Emperor re-establishing control over the streets of Rome.
He was then informed that his kingdom was in disarray after his year-long absence, forcing
him to retreat from Italy and leave Pope Adrian to broker a humiliating peace with his amused
opponents.
Ironically, this embarrassing affair would be the basis upon which Frederick established
the true Holy Roman Empire.
Bombarded with a series of angry letters from the Pope that could easily have been interpreted
as threats to revoke his new title, Frederick made the fateful decision to sever all imperial
ties with the Church for good.
In 1157, he declared his nation a Holy Empire and granted himself full power to appoint
or dismiss members of the clergy within his domain.
Finally, the embittered Frederick decreed that the title of Roman Emperor was now intrinsically
holy, that the leaders elected to the throne were Holy Roman Emperors, ruling with the
backing of God.
From this point onwards, no future Emperor would ever seek to gain or consider the validity
of their title based on papal endorsement.
Thus was finally founded the Holy Roman Empire.
Its foundations were not built upon glorious wars of conquest or even great acts of personal
valor.
Instead, they were constructed upon a centuries-old legacy of frustration, mistrust, and bitter
arguments between Church and State.
After centuries of petty rivalries, civil wars, and papal politics, the Holy Roman Empire
was finally born, at least in concept.
Notwithstanding until 1806, the HRE was more a set of kingdoms unified under a loose set
of ideological principles than a homogenous political entity backed by an absolutist state.
The citizens of the HRE were also largely Germanic, with no claim to Roman ancestry.
And the Protestant Reformation shattered any religious unity within the Empire, forever
dispelling any hopes of it being seen as holy in the eyes of God.
But this very lack of centralized identity allowed the HRE to endure centuries of internal
upheaval and external conflict.
Special thanks to Mindstone for sponsoring this video.
If you want to improve your learning skills and expand your knowledge of history or any
other topic in the fastest, most efficient way possible, and join my library to have
a look at some of the reference material for this video, don't forget to check out the
link in the description below.
