The Crusade of Frederick Barbarossa, 1189-90

Frederick Barbarossa
2 followers
This is J. Stephen Roberts with Real Crusades History and today I would like to talk a little
bit about the Crusade of Emperor Frederick Barbarossa.
Now as most of you will know, Frederick Barbarossa set off on the campaign that in its entirety
is known as the Third Crusade, which is most famously led in the Holy Land by Richard the
Lionheart and to a lesser extent Philip II Augustus of France.
Frederick Barbarossa's participation in the Crusade is perhaps less well known, less discussed
simply because Frederick himself never actually made it to Palestine.
However, Frederick's involvement in the Third Crusade and his exploits should not be ignored
simply because, well, they're fairly impressive.
So Frederick Barbarossa actually set out before the armies of Richard the Lionheart and Philip
Augustus and Frederick's army was quite large, probably the largest force assembled for the
Third Crusade.
And the size of Frederick's army contributed to his decision not to travel by sea as Richard
and Philip did.
Instead, he intended to take the old crusading path, the one taken by the First Crusade and
the Second Crusade, and that is to march east out of Western Europe into Hungary and then
into the Byzantine Empire to cross the Bosporus at Constantinople and then to continue on
across Asia Minor and eventually head south down into Syria and Palestine.
This is the path that the First Crusade took.
This is the path that, to some extent, the Second Crusade took, what survived of it.
This was Frederick's choice as well and it's an incredibly difficult journey.
As we know, the First Crusade managed to make this journey with some difficulty.
The generalship of Bohemond contributed greatly to the First Crusade's ability to execute
that march across Asia Minor.
And the march across Asia Minor is in particular what makes this journey so difficult.
Asia Minor is incredibly hard terrain.
This is basically the interior of Turkey as we know it today.
Very very high temperatures, very difficult terrain to cross, and of course there is the
problem that during the era of the Crusades it is swarming with Seljuk Turks.
The Crusade of 1101 failed to make this crossing.
Not long after the First Crusade, it was destroyed by the Sultanate of Rum.
The Second Crusade, for all practical purposes, essentially failed to make this crossing as well.
It's interesting that Frederick Barbarossa, as a young man, was present during the Second
Crusade.
He was there with the German army that was shattered during its attempt to cross Asia Minor.
He appears to have learned some lessons from that experience because his execution of the
march across Asia Minor was considerably more effective.
So Frederick Barbarossa understood very well what he was dealing with in marching his army
this incredible distance on this incredibly difficult journey.
He took considerable precautions in organizing this expedition.
He first of all sent emissaries ahead to the two great powers that he would have to cross
through to get to the Holy Land by this route.
He treated with the Byzantine Empire, which at the time was ruled by Isaac II Angelus,
and he treated with the Sultan of Rum, that is the Seljuk dynasty that had control of
portions of the interior and eastern part of Asia Minor, basically bordering the Byzantine
Empire, what it still controlled of Asia Minor, which was mostly located in the west.
Now Frederick had a history of interacting diplomatically with these two powers in the
past and in interacting with them for his planning of this expedition he sought to
establish two things.
First to make it clear to them that he had no hostile intentions toward them and that
all he wanted was to be able to move his army across their territory and eventually get
it into Syria.
In doing this he also requested that his forces be allowed to purchase supplies on the way.
So Frederick sent emissaries to both the Sultan of Rum and to the Byzantine Emperor in preparations
for setting off and he got responses from both of these powers.
Both of these powers assured him that they were in agreement with his plans that they
would allow him to march his forces through their territory.
In terms of why this was feasible, well, traditionally the Christians of the west had relied on Byzantine
goodwill to some extent, not always to their benefit.
In fact, the experience of both the first and second crusade had made a lot of Latin
Westerners rather wary of the Byzantines, especially the second crusade.
In terms of the Sultan of Rum, Frederick felt that he could expect a solid alliance between
himself and the Seljuks because the Seljuks were the enemies of Saladin and so it made
sense that they would not be interested in hindering an expedition that was aimed at
attacking Saladin.
So again, Frederick received assurances from both the Byzantines and the Seljuks that they
were happy to allow him to move his forces through their territory, that they would provide
him with markets for his armies to purchase supplies on the way.
So Frederick sets out with his army, he receives a warm welcome from the King of Hungary.
Once he enters Byzantine territory with his forces, pretty much immediately they are attacked
by the Byzantines.
Frederick sends word ahead to Constantinople, tries to figure out what's going on, see if
he can get the Byzantine emperor to agree to stop this.
The Byzantine emperor does in fact send some rather fork-tongued replies, but the result
is that in fact the attacks continue.
Frederick is going to experience attacks from Byzantine forces the entire time he is marching
through the Byzantine Empire.
It appears that Isaac II Angelos made it a point to act entirely in the interest of Saladin.
He seemed compelled to ally himself closely with Saladin, he threw Frederick's ambassadors
into prison and showered gifts and wealth upon Saladin's ambassadors.
So Frederick continues to experience attacks from the Byzantines throughout his march.
He essentially has to conquer the Byzantine Empire to march through it.
Frederick could have taken control of Constantinople in fact.
We probably should take note of this incident here.
The Fourth Crusade wasn't really the first time a crusading army had conquered Byzantium.
The Third Crusade under Frederick Barbarossa did this as well.
Frederick's army, led by his son in the vanguard, his son the Duke of Swabia, inflicted several
severe defeats upon the Byzantine emperor.
It turns out that Isaac II Angelos made a terrible decision in supporting Saladin, who
really was providing him with nothing, over Frederick, whose army was present right there
in Byzantine lands.
By being hostile towards Frederick and attacking his forces, he invited incredible ruin on
his own domains because of course Frederick's army fought back and inflicted defeats on
the Byzantine Empire, occupied Byzantine cities.
Several Byzantine cities were occupied by Frederick and his forces.
For all practical purposes, Frederick took control of the Byzantine Empire at a certain
point.
He decided not to actually occupy Constantinople itself for a number of reasons that are echoed
throughout his time moving through Byzantium.
First of all, Frederick did not want to be distracted from his primary goal of getting
to Palestine.
He was a fairly old man at this point in his reign.
It was his intention, his firm intention, and this had to do very much so with his spirituality,
his religious convictions.
He wanted to end his life fighting for Jerusalem.
He wanted to get to Palestine.
He did not want to be distracted by a campaign in Byzantium.
Of course, that didn't really matter.
He was distracted by a rather extensive campaign in Byzantium, which he won.
However, he took pains to reduce the amount of time he had to spend there and got his
army through Byzantine territory as quickly as he possibly could.
Isaac II Angelos was an incredibly incompetent emperor, one of the worst in Byzantine history,
and his army simply was no match for Frederick's well-organized army.
Frederick's troops absolutely rode roughshod over the Byzantine troops.
This is just an impressive campaign, really.
Frederick's ability to, if he's very far from home, he was able to subdue the Byzantine
forces and essentially divert Byzantine resources toward his own ends, which was getting his
army through Byzantium as quickly as possible.
Once Frederick was out of Byzantine territory, he entered into Seljuk territory in Asia Minor,
as his army is making this incredibly difficult march through the harsh terrain of Asia Minor.
Now, again, as I said earlier, Frederick had attempted to establish peaceable relations
between himself and the Sultan of Rûm, and in fact, the Sultan of Rûm had agreed to
this.
However, much like his experience in Byzantine territory, once Frederick was actually in
Seljuk territory, he found that his army was being constantly attacked by Seljuk Turks.
The Seljuks were pretty much doing what they had done every time a crusade had moved through
that territory.
They were setting ambushes, they were attempting to break the army up.
This of course did not work during the First Crusade, which defeated them.
It worked very effectively in the Crusade of 1101 and the Second Crusade.
In this case, it also did not work.
Frederick's troops were very well disciplined, his lines were very effectively organized,
and he was able to resist Seljuk attacks.
Now, this doesn't mean that there weren't serious casualties and sufferings for Frederick's
army.
There were.
There were some incredibly difficult episodes, however, in the end, Frederick achieved absolute
victory over the Sultan of Rûm.
His son inflicted a severe defeat over the Sultan just outside of Iconium, which was
the capital of the Sultanate of Rûm.
And essentially, Frederick's army occupied Iconium.
And much like in the case of the Byzantine Empire, Frederick took control of the Sultanate
of Rûm.
He took an array of very important hostages from the Sultan.
Very high-ranking Seljuk princes were taken into his custody as assurance of good behavior.
Once it was clear, of course, that Frederick had completely crushed the Sultan of Rûm
and dominated his forces and defeated him, the Sultan begged Frederick to now engage
in a truce with him, basically throwing himself on Frederick's mercy.
What Frederick did, of course, was to some extent he accepted this.
He agreed that there could be an alliance of some sort of peace now between them, so
long as the Sultan complied with all of his wishes, which the Sultan was happy to do.
And, of course, that was that Frederick was going to take important Seljuk hostages under
his control to guarantee good behavior, have his army well-provisioned and supplied by
Seljuk territories, and then march peaceably out of Seljuk territory.
Of course, at this point, there really wasn't else much that the Sultan could do.
His armies had been shattered by Frederick.
So at this point, Frederick marches on and he departs Seljuk territory victorious.
Now, what has just happened here?
Well, Frederick's army has not gotten even close to Palestine, really, at this point,
but it has just gone through an incredibly difficult and rigorous war.
Essentially two wars, really, one with the Byzantines and one with the Seljuks.
A fighting march, if you will, the most difficult sort of war to fight in the Middle Ages.
And Frederick and his army have prevailed.
It's really a very impressive set of achievements, this subjugation of the Byzantine Empire and
subjugation of the Sultanate of Rûm.
Christopher Tyreman says that this achievement ranks up there with some of the most dazzling
successes of the Third Crusade, that is, Richard's victories over Saladin and conquests
in the Holy Land.
And I think we must agree with him.
Frederick was faced with an incredibly difficult task, marching his army, the land route, to
Palestine, which involved this incredibly long journey across Asia Minor.
And if you've ever been to Turkey and been to the interior of Turkey, which I have, you
will know that this is very, very difficult countryside.
And it's really quite incredible to imagine marching this distance and in this difficult
terrain with hostile local forces all around descending upon you.
But Frederick had achieved this, and it's quite remarkable.
He finally, after departing with his army out of Seljuk territory, enters into Armenian-held
territory.
And for the first time since he departed Hungary, he is now in friendly territory again.
Indeed, throughout Frederick's march through the Byzantine Empire, he had Armenian allies
acting in concert with him against Byzantium.
So once he enters into Armenian-held territory, he, I guess you can say to some extent, his
army can relax.
It's just gone, I mean, to some extent, in a manner of speaking, at least they're not
being actively attacked, but they've just gone through an incredibly difficult journey.
Obviously there's going to be some incredible weariness there, and they have quite a ways
to go still.
It's at this point, really just as Frederick is entering into Syria, that there is an episode
in which he ends up dying.
We don't know what happened really at all.
He appears to have bathed in a river, which would have been a very common occurrence in
the Middle Ages.
Armies on the move often took advantage of rivers as bathing points.
And what seems most likely is that he had a stroke or a heart attack or something.
He was a very old man.
He dies.
Frederick dies, and this thus brings, in a rather strange way, a premature end to an
already very extensive campaign.
It's premature, of course, because the whole point of Frederick's campaign is to get to
Palestine and participate in the conquest of the Holy Land.
However, he never makes it there.
But he does go through an incredibly difficult experience with his army, in which he prevails
against two of the most important powers in the region.
No small accomplishment by any means.
But he does end up dying in this rather anticlimactic way.
This does not actually mean the end of Frederick's crusade.
His army does continue on.
Without him, it's really only in Antioch that the army begins to break down because of the
outbreak of epidemic.
I think that Frederick's crusade demonstrates for us many of the key issues that medieval
Latin Westerners were facing in the larger crusade movement to the Holy Land.
There's several enormous problems facing any Western European army or coalition that
sets out to conquer Syria or Palestine.
First of all, there's getting there.
It's an incredibly long distance.
In terms of the entire crusades movement, this is the longest journey that armies make
for any of the theaters.
You know, if we look at the Iberian Theater, often it's just a short march a couple of
days south from whatever Christian holding in Spain to then attack the Moors in the south.
For example, the crusade of Las Navas de Tolosa was a fairly brief march from Toledo to the
side of the battlefield.
This is largely the same situation for the Northern Crusades in the Baltic.
This is a frontier fairly close to Germany.
A lot of German princes and knights made it a point of involving themselves in the Northern
Crusades to expand their power into that region.
For a lot of the other theaters of crusade, there was an obvious, for one thing, territorial
expansion for a certain party or a certain group or territory in Latin Christendom that
one segment of the nobility had a personal, pragmatic interest in expanding into.
And then, of course, there was the added bonus of the religious aspect of the war, which
attracted participants from other parts of Europe to involve themselves.
For the Holy Land, the issue, of course, is that there's no obvious frontier for somebody
to expand into.
It's not like there's some neighboring Latin Christian territory right there that's already
very powerful and can easily launch a campaign into that region.
They have to travel very far.
It's an incredibly impractical journey.
And just getting the army there is oftentimes an issue in itself, an ordeal.
And for Frederick Barbarossa's army, I think that's clearly exemplified.
Now, obviously, the sea route is the much easier route, and that's why, really, after
this point, nobody else attempted to crusade in this manner.
The First Crusade and Second Crusade both experienced incredible problems in the Overland
March.
At any rate, despite the rather tragic and stillborn quality of Frederick Barbarossa's
effort to make war in the Holy Land, we have to be impressed by what he did achieve.
The main thing that seems to be remembered about Frederick Barbarossa's participation
in the Third Crusade is that, well, before he even got there, he drowned in a river.
And of course, that is a standout fact, and it's unavoidable.
But we also shouldn't forget the fact that he conquered the Byzantine Empire and Sultanate
of Rome before he did that.
These are not simple things to do, and this was an incredible military achievement.
And he was able to do it while his army endured this incredibly rigorous march across Asia
Minor.
So, a toast to Frederick's achievement there, I think it would be fair to say that.
Now, for anyone interested in learning more about Frederick Barbarossa's crusade, I would
recommend the book that is currently showing up on your screen.
That is The Crusade of Frederick Barbarossa, The History of the Expedition of the Emperor
Frederick and Related Texts.
This is from the Crusade Texts in Translation series from Ashgate Press, an absolutely amazing
series.
Really, you're going to want to get every volume in that series.
This volume is translated by GA Loud.
It features a very healthy selection of primary source accounts for the German expedition
written from the German perspective.
There are several longer accounts.
There is also a letter written by a participant back to a German bishop concerning the crusade
and Frederick's death.
It's a very fascinating read, and if what I have discussed in this video has whetted
your interest, then certainly pick up this book.
Another place you can go is the ever-useful God's War by Christopher Tyreman, which features
an excellent segment about Frederick's crusade.
Very insightful comments and analysis from Professor Tyreman.
So anyway, thanks for listening.
Bye.
