Day 8 Intermediate compounds and Phase Diagrams
Oct 13, 2023
0:00 learning objective, reading quiz
8:59 review of Gibbs Phase Rule
15:37 labeling phase diagrmas 1:2:1:2:1:2:1 rule
18:40 peritectic reaction
24:40 intermediate compound formation
31:33 calculating intermediate compound chemical formula
44:04 congruently melting vs incongruently melting compounds
49:16 lever rule introduction
Okay, so today let's talk about learning objectives first and then we'll do the quicker quiz.
So if you just come in, be getting logged on, you can see the channel ID and the session
ID, you can get ready for the first quicker quiz.
Meanwhile, our learning objectives for today, we're going to pick up where we left off last
time, which was with the eutectic binary phase diagram, and we're going to learn the
next thing, which is, all right, if I gave you a blank one of those where nothing was
labeled on it, could you go ahead and label it?
And there's some tricks for that.
We'll then talk about a series of important reactions that can take place in phase diagrams.
There's not just the eutectic, there's other things like eutectoid, paratectic and so forth.
We'll learn how to identify the formula of intermediate compounds.
So it's not just like AB, but you can form maybe AB in the middle of that.
We'll talk about how we identify formulas.
We'll briefly talk about ternary phase diagrams.
We'll spend time describing the lever rule and how it describes the amount of the different
phases present at any point on the diagram.
We'll describe the lamellar structure, what are grains, and we'll even practice drawing
some of these things.
And if we have time at the end, we'll go over some examples of all that in the context of
steel.
The steel phase diagram, or iron and carbon, is one of the most important ones for us to
know in this class.
We're going to come back to it over and over and over throughout the course of the semester.
So a real quick announcement before we do the clicker quiz.
There's about 10 or 15 students, and I've got the lists of you guys, but you can see
just as easily who it is.
If you haven't finished registering, you should be getting all zeros for your clicker assignments
on Canvas.
As soon as you register, we can backdate those assignments with the scores that you got.
So don't worry.
We have a record of what you did, but it won't show up on Canvas until you finish your clicker
registration process.
So you either didn't register your device, or you didn't buy a subscription.
One of the two things.
If you have a bunch of zeros for your clicker assignments on Canvas, come talk to me and
we can figure out which problem it is, okay?
After class or sometime is fine.
Okay, let's start with a clicker exam for today, or a reading quiz for today.
Let me make this bigger.
Okay, first question says, how many degrees of freedom exist at the eutectic point?
And I'll just do a quick reminder.
Degrees of freedom, that has to do with Gibb's phase rule, which is P plus F equals C plus
N, where P is the number of phases, F is our degrees of freedom, C is the number of constituents
or components, and N is the number of non-compositional variables.
So at the eutectic point, is it 0, 1, 2, or 3?
Okay, another 30 seconds, wrap up on this one.
Okay, we're going to wrap it up.
Is it 0, 1, 2, or 3?
It is definitely 0.
The reason we know it's 0, again, at the eutectic point, that's where this reaction takes place.
A liquid reverses between alpha plus beta, so you've got three distinct phases in equilibrium
at that point.
Therefore, you've got 3 plus F. There's two components in these diagrams, so it's going
to be 2 plus temperature is the only thing we plotted against, so F has to be 0.
There's no degrees of freedom.
What this really says is we can't move anywhere on that diagram and still be at the point
on the plot, which makes sense.
All right, let's do our next one.
So if you look at C plus N, C is the number of constituents in the system.
Because we're talking about a eutectic, that has to be a binary phase diagram, it doesn't
exist on a unary phase diagram, and so you have at least two components.
You have pure A going to pure B, and then the number of non-compositional variables,
you could do this against either pressure or temperature, or technically you could do
it against both, but as we described in last class, it's almost always just against temperature.
So that's just one.
So 3 plus F, equals 2 plus 1, F has to be 0.
All right, our next question is the following.
How many degrees of freedom exist along the solidus line?
Let me remind you what the solidus line was.
The solidus line, say if we were going between copper and nickel again, where you've got
liquid, a solid plus liquid, and a solid, the solidus line refers to this line right
there, right?
So along that solidus line, it's asking how many degrees of freedom do you have there?
Okay, another 30 seconds, get your answers in.
Okay, we're going to wrap this poll up.
How many degrees of freedom exist along the solidus line?
People think, yeah, one degree of freedom.
What this, again, what this means is that on this diagram, if you want to change something
either composition or temperature, you can only choose one of those, and then the system
will choose the other one.
If you want to go down in temperature, then the composition has to go over in order for
you to exist on that solidus line still, is what that's saying.
Then last question, how many degrees of freedom exist in the bottom central region of a binary
eutectic diagram?
For example, in this region 1, how many degrees of freedom exist there?
This one's a little bit tricky, so make sure you actually punch this in and think about
it.
Okay, another 30 seconds.
Okay, we're going to end the poll.
Is it 0, 1, 2, or 3?
People think.
So, I was afraid most people would guess 2 here.
It's actually wrong.
Let's go through it.
And don't worry, on a question like this where most people get it wrong, I'll go back through,
and I can make either answer.
Okay, so I'm going to end the poll.
Is it 0, 1, 2, or 3?
People think.
So, I was afraid most people would guess 2 here.
It's actually wrong.
Let's go through it.
And don't worry, on a question like this where most people get it wrong, I'll go back through,
and I can make either answer.
And don't worry, on a question like this where most people get it wrong, I'll go back through,
and I can make either answer correct.
Right?
And it'll retroactively give you a point for this.
So, don't worry about it.
Let's talk about why it's 2.
So, if you've got a binary eutectic, they typically look something like this, right?
We're talking about this region down here in the middle.
If we were to label this, it would be liquid, alpha, beta.
This would be alpha plus beta.
So, if you're at some region in here, say at that point, we're going to do P plus F
equals C plus N. How many phases are present at that point?
Two phases plus F. How many components are present in this binary phase eutectic diagram?
Just two.
And then how many non-compositional variables is there?
Just one.
So, F actually has to be one.
Question, Matt?
That's a great question, yeah.
Does alpha plus beta count as a phase?
No.
Phases are individual different types of crystal structures, which we'll be describing next
in two chapters, actually.
So, alpha plus beta, that is a mixture.
That's a multi-phase mixture.
And again, if you put two degrees of freedom, don't worry, we'll give you credit on this
one.
We're going to talk about multi-phase regions a little bit more.
Another question?
So, very good question.
Why are they both not solids?
So, they are both solids.
The eutectic reaction is one liquid converting into two different solids.
But one of the key things we talked about, for example, with the iron wire demo, is that
a solid is not a solid is not a solid, right?
There's differences between them.
In the case of iron, the high temperature phase, even though they're both solids, the
high temperature version of the iron has a different crystal structure that causes it
actually to contract, right?
So, one of the key things I want to get across to engineers is that when we talk about different
phases of matter, different crystal structures or different ways that we arrange atoms, that
constitutes a different phase.
And those are important.
They have different physical properties, mechanical properties.
Josh?
So, where would it have two degrees of freedom?
Well, we can work backwards.
How about that?
Where would it have two degrees of freedom?
Let's do P plus two degrees of freedom equals two plus one, right?
In order for this to work, we would need to be in a region that has just one phase present.
So, right here in the alpha region, in the beta region, or in the liquid region, we would
have two degrees of freedom because those are all single phase fields.
So, in any of those three regions, we'd have two degrees of freedom.
What does that really mean?
It means that we can go left or right, or we can go up or down, and we still just have
liquid, right?
But if we try and do that here, what we do is we still have alpha plus beta, but we change
the amounts of alpha and beta, and that's what's key, right?
If you're right here, you have a different amount of alpha and beta than if you're right
here.
And the way that we know how to do that is with the lever rule, which we're going to
talk about today.
Conrad?
But then if you're right, and you go up, then, I mean, technically, the alpha phase is like
your A with B incorporated, and you're still changing it.
Yeah, so composition can change, but Gibb's phase rule doesn't talk about composition.
It talks about equilibrium of phases, not composition of those phases, yeah.
So it talks about the amounts of each phase, right?
That has to do with equilibrium, but not the composition.
Yeah, Rob?
Wait, so C is 2 because alpha and beta are both present, right?
No, C is 2 because in this system, we're having a mixture between pure A and pure B, so there's
two possible constituents, right?
Sure.
A and B. That could be copper and nickel.
That could be whatever else, right?
Okay.
And then, so is that why P is 2?
So P is 2 because depending on where you place it in this diagram, there might be two phases
present.
Yeah, okay.
And in this field right here, there's two phases present.
There's also two phases present right here, alpha plus liquid, and in here, beta plus
liquid.
So it's the maximum number.
No.
F is...
So we can only use Gibb's phase rule at a certain point on the diagram, not for the
entire diagram.
It exists for certain points.
Can I answer more questions about this?
Yeah, Logan?
When would N equal 2 or 3?
If we had a diagram that...
So this is plotted in two-dimensional space.
If you made a 3D model where you not only had temperature going up, but you had pressure
coming out, then I suppose you could have more degrees of freedom because then you'd
have more than one non-compositional variable.
So we don't typically do that, but you could.
At the end of class today, I'll show you a ternary phase diagram where we're briefly
going to talk about that.
Other questions?
Yeah, John?
So if we have one degree of freedom, right?
One degree of freedom means you can either choose to go left or right by changing your
composition, or you can choose to go up or down, but you can't do both, meaning if you
do one, the system says, alright, if you still want to maintain equilibrium, I get to choose
the next thing, right?
So for example, let me change the color real quick.
If you're on this line, then you have a mixture of alpha and alpha plus liquid, right?
That's the reaction.
That's what that line represents.
So if you choose to change your composition and add some of component B, and you still
want to maintain that mixture, the same mixture that you had before, then you have to go down,
right?
That two-phase field, it says that alpha and liquid are still there, but if you want to
maintain the same amounts of them as were present on that line, then you have to still
be on that line.
Okay, more questions?
Yeah, Rosa?
No, this isn't about the system taking an action and changing what's in your beaker.
What this is saying is that if you want to maintain equilibrium, if that's the goal,
then you only have a limited number of options and actions that you can take and still maintain
equilibrium.
That's all this is saying.
Yeah.
If you wanted to maintain the exact same ratio, say, of alpha and beta, right here, you're
right there and you wanted to change the temperature, you wanted to go up a little bit, and you
still wanted to have the exact same ratio of alpha and beta, you'd have to change your
composition slightly to be right there.
We'll talk about how we know that it's right there when I get to the lever rule today.
Other questions I can answer about this?
Yeah, Elsa?
Yes.
Can you explain, so...
Okay.
So, if you want to...
Can you just explain how...
In the alpha plus beta.
Let me get to the lever rule, and then it'll be easier.
Okay?
Can we move on?
And then we'll come back to this if there's more questions.
Let's do lever rule, and if there's still questions, we'll keep going.
Okay?
First, let's talk about how we go about labeling these phase diagrams, right?
Let's label one that's kind of weird.
Well, yeah, let's start with the paratectic, actually.
Let's label this one.
In a paratectic phase diagram, it might look something like this.
Okay?
How would you go about labeling this phase diagram?
Again, we're going from pure component A all the way to pure component B, and it's against
temperature that we're plotting at.
So when you label these phase diagrams, the rule is the following.
When you go left to right, or right to left, at a constant temperature, you have to go
1, 2, 1, 2, 1, 2.
You have to alternate between single phase region and two phase region.
Single phase region and two phase.
Now the way you get started, the easiest way to always get started on these is to start
really up high.
Up high, everything's going to be molten, so it's going to be liquid, right?
So at the top of your phase diagram, that's where you start, this unit right, liquid.
Now at any given temperature, I'm going to switch a different color here, if I pick a
temperature, say right here, and I go left to right, or right to left on this diagram,
I need to go from a single phase region to a two phase, back to a single phase to a two
phase.
So out here, that is clearly going to be a liquid still, that's in the same phase field
as the liquid, so we've got liquid over here, that's a single phase, that means what about
this region in between?
It must be a two phase region.
So we're going to say that this is actually liquid plus, and we get to pick a Greek letter,
any one you want, use a weird one, use zeta if you want, right?
The convention is to start with alpha, but do whatever you like, right?
So that means if you keep on going left, that must be a single phase region, and because
you label these things with what's on either side of it, you've got liquid on one side,
that means that this must be your zeta phase, okay?
Again, zeta's just Greek Z, right?
So then how do you keep going, how do you fill out the rest of this?
Well now you know that this whole region here, that's all a single phase region, which means
what about this phase?
This is actually two phases, right?
So we can give it a name, it's going to be zeta plus what?
Pi somebody said?
Great, pi.
Pi's a great name, right?
So that's our second phase there.
We don't know what these phases are yet, but we know it's distinct, it's distinct from
zeta, right?
What do we know about this thing then?
That must be just pure pi, right?
What about this phase?
Pi plus what?
Let's do pi plus gamma, and we'll see if this works.
What would then this region be?
There's a problem, that's not supposed to be there, sorry, that's my fault.
Now we knew it was a problem because we're doing this 1, 2, 1, 2 rule, it didn't work,
our rule didn't work, so we knew that didn't work.
This had to be pi here, my mistake, that's pi, which makes this region what?
That must be pi plus liquid, my mistake, pi plus liquid there, right?
This diagram, the reason we draw this to talk about labeling phase fields is because there's
a new reaction that we have to talk about.
It's the peritectic reaction.
So just like the eutectic reaction, this is another special type of reaction.
In this case, it's one solid reacting with a liquid to form a new type of solid.
So where in this diagram do we see one solid reacting with a liquid to form a new type
of solid when you go up or down in temperature?
Yeah, the formation of pi, right?
So right here at this point, as you go down in temperature there, it's only briefly, but
you're going to have the equilibrium of liquid plus zeta and pi.
So that would be a peritectic point.
Now in this reaction, if you were to keep on going down, you'd only be in pi for just
a moment and then you'd cross over to pi plus zeta, but sometimes these diagrams look more
like this.
Let me erase that.
They can look like this instead, like that.
In either case, it's still a peritectic point, okay?
Any questions about peritectic points?
Yeah, Rosa?
Yeah, for example, if you were cooling it down, I'm going to switch to a different color
to talk about cooling things down here.
If you start out with a composition of liquid up there, right?
So liquid with that given composition, and you slowly cooled it down, as soon as you
touch that, what's called the liquidus line, your very first solid starts to crystallize,
at least from a thermodynamic perspective.
Again, we'll talk about kinetics actually means it happens later, but from a thermodynamic
standpoint, it should start to form your very first solid.
And as you slowly cool it through this region, you're going to have a mixture of liquid plus
zeta present.
And we don't know how to say how much yet, because we haven't learned the labor rule,
but we're going to do that in just a moment.
But as soon as you get to this peritectic temperature, that flat line, and then go below
it, your liquid and zeta disappear, and you're left with just pi, okay?
And because that happens where you had one solid and one liquid converting to a different
type of solid, that's a peritectic reaction.
Any questions?
Yeah, Brad?
What's the difference?
The eutectic?
Yeah, let's go back up.
The eutectic happens right here, where again, if you're cooling it down, you went from one
liquid simultaneously to two different solids, which is different than going from one liquid
and one solid to a different type of solid.
Fair enough?
Yeah.
Remind me your name.
Cody.
What is it?
Cody.
Is it also...
Yeah.
So just like a reaction, chemical reactions can go forwards or backwards.
This reaction, if you were to take it and you were to heat that thing up and melt it
into a mixture of liquid plus zeta, it's still a peritectic reaction.
It's just one that you're heating up rather than cooling down.
Takara.
So at that point, it would usually have the pi phase, the zeta phase, and the...
At that point, you would have all three in equilibrium.
So your degrees of freedom would be zero.
You can't change anything.
And that makes sense, because this point only occurs at one point on our map here, not along
a line or anything like that.
Yeah, remind me your name.
Kyle.
Good question.
So that represents this entire phase field.
And because this is not a single line where it occurs at, this means that this crystal
structure must be relatively compliant.
It can allow a pretty big mixture.
If this was plotted in like mole percent, it can go all the way to pure B, whatever
that element is, bismuth, whatever it is.
And you can stuff in...
You can take out half the bismuth atom and put in whatever atom A is and keep the same
crystal structure.
That doesn't mean that the lattice won't change.
If you remember from Vegard's Law last time, the separation between atoms can change, but
the type of crystal structure does not change.
Therefore, it's still one phase.
It's just one phase that can exist over a pretty big variety of compositions.
Yeah.
So let's say you're from a liquid or a beta, and say the line below it actually applied?
If it went that way?
If that, yeah.
Yeah.
If this line wasn't here, but it went how I originally had it?
Yeah.
If it went to beta, is it still a beta point?
It's still a peritectic point, but if you were to cool straight down, you would actually
only exist at that peritectic point for a moment, and then you'd cross into a two-phase
field.
So I have to go from a two-phase mixture to a liquid and one solid to a different type
of solid.
That's a peritectic reaction.
By the way, you're going to start to see things on phase diagrams that are indicators that
something's up.
Anytime you see a perfectly vertical line or a perfectly horizontal line, those are
points to pay attention to.
Something's happening there.
Horizontal lines represent one of these key reactions, and vertical lines we'll get to
actually, I think, next.
Can I move on?
Or are there more questions?
Yeah, one more.
Jeff?
So these reactions...
So basically, yeah.
If you were right here, you're going to have a mixture of liquid and zeta.
If you cool it down, what we're going to find out is that the peritectic reaction occurs
all the way along this horizontal line.
What does that mean?
It means whatever amount of liquid you have right here, as soon as you cool below that
line, all of that liquid must undergo the peritectic reaction, right?
But you had some zeta from before.
That zeta doesn't have to change.
The liquid has to change, because that's what the peritectic reaction says.
Fair enough?
Oh, I'm sorry.
Peritectic means that some of the zeta and some of the liquid.
But definitely all of your liquid has to be gone.
Other questions I can answer about this?
We're going to do lots and lots of examples, so let's keep going.
Okay.
What if an intermediate compound forms, right?
Up until now, we've been showing A and B, right?
But let's talk about what if an intermediate compound...
What if A wants to react with B?
So first off, what causes the formation of an intermediate compound?
Or in other words, another way to think of it is what prevents solid solution?
So turn to a neighbor and talk about why should a new compound form in the first place?
Why can't it just dissolve all the way across?
Okay.
What do we think?
Why should a new compound form?
Anyone want to hazard a guess or volunteer what your neighbor said, if you're feeling
shy?
Griffin, what do you think?
Different materials.
Okay.
Yeah.
Different melting points and boiling points, things like that.
Yep.
That's fair.
What else?
What causes the reaction to form?
Well, how about this one?
Oh yeah.
Or is it Connelly?
No, it's Spencer.
Not even close.
By the way, it is so warm in this room.
I'm dying.
Something about Gibbs free energy.
Something about energy, you say?
The Gibbs free energy.
Yeah.
Clearly, if it happens, it's because what happens to Gibbs free energy?
It goes out.
Something happened to lower the Gibbs free energy.
So what might happen to lower the Gibbs free energy?
So I think one of the easiest ways to think about this, copper and nickel, we know that
they have a complete solid solution.
Because both of these have the same crystal structure to start with, with just slightly
different lattice parameters.
And so because they're so chemically similar and everything, you can just substitute for
another all the way across and you end up with an alpha, right?
But what if you start with something that just fundamentally has a different crystal
structure, right?
So you've got alpha, which is maybe cubic, and this one, which is hexagonal.
You cannot, by definition, go all the way across and keep the same crystal structure.
So you at least have to have something like a binary.
Now why do they react to form some new compound?
Typically this is due to what?
Anybody want to take one last guess?
It wants to bond.
What makes things want to bond?
Lowers the energy.
Lowers the energy, right?
Yeah.
Either you have ionic or covalent driving forces, right?
So maybe there's a big difference in electronegativity.
If your atom A and atom B have a big difference in electronegativity, we know that that should
lead to an ionic bond where there's this exchange of electrons, right?
So that typically is one reason.
If you have very different oxidation states, if this is typically 2 plus and this is 3
plus, that usually leads to the formation of an intermediate.
So there's a couple of rules that the book talks about, but what I'm interested in teaching
you guys is how do you predict the formula of one of these lines?
If you look up a phase diagram and all it says is, it shows this vertical line.
First off, how is that a new phase if it's a vertical line, right?
Because this seems like it breaks our 1, 2, 1, 2 rule, right?
If you look at this, let's label this one.
Let's label this phase diagram.
At the top, we have liquid.
So those are liquid regions.
Well, that means this must be liquid plus alpha, but where is alpha?
What this means is that pure A basically has no, you can't have any solubility of atom
B in A, right?
Maybe as if this was like a single phase region there, but it's so narrow, it looks just like
a line, okay?
So pure A is in the crystal structure of alpha.
So that line itself is a single phase region.
That means that this is then going to be alpha plus what?
Let's call it beta, right?
And then if you did the 1, 2, 1, 2 rule, 1, 2, if that's a 1, this would have to be a
two phase field as a line.
That doesn't work.
So it's the exact same thing on the other side.
Let's call this liquid plus gamma.
That means that this line is gamma.
Again, what that means is that pure A is so intolerant of atom B, for whatever reason,
it doesn't allow any solid solubility.
You can't dissolve any of atom B in A or A in B, right?
That make sense?
Now you can complete this.
You can say that this is gamma plus beta, therefore this compound right there, that
line must be a single phase region of what we're going to call crystal structure beta.
Any questions about this?
Thomas?
Well, it's just a phase.
It's a solid phase.
This is still in a binary crystal system, right?
Because it's still just two components, A and B. It's just a third, it's what we call
an intermediate compound.
It's something that forms when these two things react to form a compound in between them.
And I'll show you some examples on a real phased area in a moment.
Does it make sense that you can have a single vertical line that represents a phase?
Logan?
So, if you were to heat that phase up.
Beta?
Right?
You're exactly at 50-50 mole percent of beta, yeah.
What happens to the beta?
That's a great question.
As you heat this thing up, what happens is you cross that line.
It would go completely 100% beta to 100% liquid at this temperature, at it's melting point.
And that's called a congruent melting point.
We'll talk about that probably later today or on Wednesday.
Other questions I can answer about this?
Yeah, Rizzo?
So, A?
At pure A this means that of all your atoms they're all one type.
And the type is atom A. Same thing over here.
This means that you have, because it's in mole percent and I drew it right in the middle,
that means that it's 50 moles of A and 50 moles of B where it's a one-to-one ratio.
So, it is in a crystal structure together because we've labeled it beta.
Which is different than alpha and different than gamma.
Yeah, so pure alpha has a crystal structure, let's call it cubic, right?
If this one's cubic and this one's hexagonal, imagine some new one, we'll call it tetragonal.
We'll describe what that means later this semester.
This is just a new way of arranging atoms.
More questions I can answer?
This stuff's a little bit confusing, so bear with me, we'll do lots of examples here.
Let's take a look at a common, this is one in the book, I'm going to draw a phase diagram
from the book for magnesium and lead.
The diagram looks something like this.
You've got pure magnesium on one side, lead over here, you have a eutectic point, there's
your eutectic point, right?
And then you've got this vertical line, and any time you see a vertical line, almost always
it represents what's called a line compound, meaning a single phase region that exists
at a very narrow region of stoichiometry, right?
And then you've got another eutectic over here.
So what can we say about this system?
Well, we could start labeling it, for one thing.
So let's go ahead and label this.
We've got liquid up here, we're going to follow our one-two-one-two rule.
So going left to right from liquid, we can call this liquid plus alpha, we'll call this
alpha.
That makes this, that region right here is going to be liquid plus beta, and this must
be beta, this must be beta plus something, this must be alpha plus something, therefore
you know that this has to be a line compound, because on either side of it you have two
phase regions, therefore that line itself must be a single phase region.
So let's call it gamma, beta plus gamma, gamma plus liquid, gamma plus liquid.
Any questions on labeling that so far?
The next question is, that doesn't occur, this is in weight percent, as a function of
weight percent, excuse me, that's supposed to be lead.
When you plot this again, weight percent lead, this line occurs at 81 weight percent lead.
81 weight percent lead.
So the question that is totally fair game on a midterm would be to say, what is the
chemical formula of the gamma phase?
You know it's a mixture of lead and magnesium, but what is that mixture?
Is it a 1 to 3, a 3 to 1, a 1 to 5, a 5 to 1, what is that, and how do you figure that
out?
So how do we go about solving this question, how do we predict what the chemical formula
of gamma is, what do you think Josh?
So how do we make sense of having two gamma plus L regions, right?
So again, at any point, our 1-2-1-2 rule has to work, so I bring this down where I can
reach it.
If I go this way, I go 1-2-1-2-1-2, right, that works, up here it also works, I got 1-2-1-2-1-2.
So what it's really saying is that whether you're here or here, you're going to have
a mixture of gamma plus L. What is different about those two fields?
The weight percent depends on where you're at in these regions, but it's the composition
of the liquid, right?
If you are right here versus right here, you have two different compositions of liquid.
Your liquid will be this composition over here, and your liquid will be that composition
over here.
Right, so they're different.
Fair enough?
Now, somebody help me, what's our strategy, if we were going to try and predict the formula
of this intermediate compound gamma, again, gamma must exist right at that line, how do
we predict this formula, I think Rob?
We can predict the chemical formula, how would you do it?
Yeah, Brendan, what would you do?
Yeah, because we're given in weight percent, so imagine you start out with 100 grams or
100 kilograms.
Yes, exactly right, so we're going to set 100 grams to start with, right?
If there's 100 grams of our total product and we know that that is 81 weight percent
lead, that we know that in our product we have 81 grams of lead, excuse me, and we must
have, what is that, 19 grams of magnesium.
If we can figure out the number of moles of lead and the moles of magnesium, we can
take their ratio, and we can figure out the composition of this, the chemical form of
this.
So, why don't you take a stab at that, that'll be our next clicker question, which is, again,
what would be the chemical formula of this intermediate compound?
Okay, so again, you can follow along, I've written out how many moles of lead and how
many moles of magnesium I get, I'm going to keep working on it.
Once you have the number of moles of each, then think, okay, what's my ratio?
Once you have the ratio, you can use that to determine the chemical formula.
So if you have questions, raise your hand if you've got some TAs here.
Okay, getting lots and lots of questions about how you want me to, how you're supposed to
type this in.
If by the time you take the ratio and you figure out that there's twice as much magnesium
as lead, for example, you would just punch in Mg2Pb into clicker, all right?
So this is a free point for being here.
You don't need to do subscript, just type in Mg2Pb, and again, on a test, we're really
flexible in interpreting this, clicker's not, super flexible, so it has to be this way to
put it in.
Generally, how do you know which way to write this formula?
The general rule is you do it in alphabetical order.
Because M comes before P, you typically would start with magnesium.
They break that rule sometimes, but that's the general rule.
More commonly, they'll write cation than anion.
So it's either alphabetical or cation than anion.
Okay, so go ahead and type in that answer, and we're going to go ahead and wrap it up.
Okay, we're going to wrap up this poll.
Everyone should be getting this right, so I'm just going to skip ahead.
So that is, it's pretty straightforward.
If these things are plotted in weight percent, you need to convert, you need to go from weight
percent to number of moles, and then you divide it.
What if when you divided it, you got moles of A over moles of B came out to be 1.5 or
something, not an integer value?
What do you do?
Multiply it until you get integers, right?
So multiply both by two, that means that you'd have A2B3, right?
The ratio still is one and a half, right?
But make sure it's integers, is typically what we do on these.
If this is plotted in mole percent, it can be really easy, right?
If this is in mole percent, B, going from pure A to pure B, and you see a lying compound
exactly at one-fourth of the way across, what's the chemical formula?
Well, one-fourth of the way across means that you have, if you divided that into four sections,
three of them come from A, and one comes from B, so it would be A3B, right?
A3B.
If it was exactly half and half, we know it would just be AB.
If it was three-quarters the way across, it would be AB3.
If it was at 80%, which is dividing it into fifths, that would be AB4, right?
So these ones are pretty easy.
If it's plotted in mole percent, it's pretty easy to do.
If it's in weight percent, you've got to convert it to moles first, and then divide to get
the ratio.
I've done an example problem of this, I've posted it on the list of MSC example problems.
By the way, if you haven't seen that, there's two playlists for this class.
One is the lectures we do in class, and one is example problems.
So I've posted one where we do actually calculations more on this, so if you have more questions,
take a look at that.
I'm going to keep going for now.
Can I answer any last quick questions about this?
Yeah, Rosa?
This one?
Good question.
Well, if this is at one-quarter of the way across, that means that there are 25% B. So
let's say there's 25 moles of B, but there's 75 moles of A, and 25 divided by 75 is a one
to three ratio.
Okay, let's take a look at this diagram here.
This is going between pure aluminum and pure calcium.
In this phase diagram, there exists what's called a congruent melting temperature, or
congruently melting compound, and an incongruently melting compound, right?
So congruent versus incongruent melting, what's the difference?
A congruently melting compound is one that goes from liquid to solid with no change in
composition.
So I think Logan asked this earlier.
If you take a line compound and you heat it up, right, this line compound is exactly 33
mole percent calcium, and as soon as you melt it, you end up with liquid, which has the
exact same composition, 33 mole percent.
So that would be an example of a congruent melting point.
Yeah, if it goes between liquid and solid, either on heating or cooling, and there's
no change in composition, we call that congruent melting.
So there's actually two other congruent melting points on this diagram, but they're a little
bit tricky.
Where are they at?
Yeah, Spencer.
Not the eutectic, because there you go from a liquid and it splits to two different compositions.
We'll show why in a moment.
20, nope.
It's actually the pure component.
So right here, if you have pure calcium, it would actually melt to pure liquid calcium.
So the composition doesn't change, and pure aluminum does the same thing over there.
So why is this point, let me change colors now.
Why is that point incongruent melting?
Well, because above that point, you're going to be cooling it down.
You have a mixture of what we'll call liquid plus, it's Al2Ca, let's just call it beta,
that Al2Ca compound.
But as soon as you go down, you're going to form a solid, which is Al4Ca.
So your liquid, right above that point is going to have this composition, just as you're
cooling it down.
Your solid is going to have that composition, but when you cool it down across that peritectic
reaction, you form a new solid, and it has a different composition.
So any peritectic point you see is always an incongruent melting point.
Can I clarify anything on congruent versus incongruent melting?
Why is the eutectic not?
Change color again.
This is not a congruent melting point, because there you go from liquid above to two different
solids.
The liquid has this composition, but the solid has this composition and that composition.
So there's definitely a change in composition as you cool below that point.
Yeah, Reza?
Composition, same as chemical formula?
No, it's related.
Usually from composition, you write the chemical formula such that you have integer values.
Composition would be something like this.
Like what's the composition of Al4C?
You'd say that it is 20 atomic or mole percent calcium.
That's its composition.
And therefore, 80 atomic percent aluminum.
Sorry, one more time?
If it's at a fixed point, no.
Anything else I can answer about this?
Yeah, Anthony?
So these points are...
Good question.
This is the congruent melting point right there.
This is not a congruent melting point.
The point itself is a congruent melting point.
Okay?
Yeah.
You can't do the...
Oh, I'm sorry.
Yeah.
I think I need to zoom.
Right?
So at the top here, this is our congruent melting point, that big red one at the top
of that.
Because if you were to heat it, it would go to a liquid with no change in composition.
Or if you were to cool it, it would go to solid, no change in composition.
But right here, just above this point, you have solid with this composition.
You've got liquid with that composition.
If you cool it down, you have a new different type of solid with a different composition
from the solid before.
Incongruent melting.
It's a change in composition.
Or in other words, what this requires is it requires diffusion of atoms.
Right?
Meaning atoms have to move around.
So right here, you have more calcium than you have here.
So, as you cool this down, you have to diffuse calcium from one of your...
Sorry.
You have to lose some calcium to form this compound.
Okay?
Yeah.
Okay.
Let's do...
We've already done that one.
Let me just do one last example.
Let me just prime you for the lever rule, which we'll have to get to next time.
You'll need this on the homework anyways.
How the lever rule works is if you have a two-phase region...
Let's call this just alpha.
You've got liquid plus alpha.
And you have a certain composition.
Right?
At any given temperature, we can use the lever rule to tell us how much these phases are present.
So, for example, right here...
We can make this big.
Right there, we could draw a flat line all the way across this thing.
And we can use the lever rule.
How the lever rule works is you take the total distance when you take the intersection of these two points,
that total distance from there to there, right?
And you need to figure out the distance of each segment above.
So from here to here and from here to here.
And if you want to figure out the weight fraction of the phases present, you're going to divide these things.
So this is how it works.
Let me change color one last time.
The weight fraction of the alpha phase is going to be equal to the purple divided by the blue.
And the weight percent of the liquid phase is going to be equal to the green divided by the blue.
Or in other words, if you want the phase...
Let me lower that just a little bit.
If you want the phase on the left, then you need to take the line opposite it divided by the total length.
If you want the phase on the right, you take the section opposite of it and divide it by that.
How are you going to remember that?
The way to remember it is if you're close to this line, you should have mostly this material.
And the only way that will work is if you're taking this length of longer than...
Right?
If you're over here, you should have mostly alpha phase.
So you're going to want to take that length of line divided by the whole, not the small section.
Right?
That is the lever rule.
If the plot is given in weight percent, as it is in here, then the fraction of your phases will be in weight percent.
If this was given in mole percent, you'd be calculating the mole fraction of your two different phases.
Okay.
We'll pick up here next time, and then we'll do a little bit of review and get ready for the test on Friday.
Can I ask a quick question about that?
Yeah.

