Meine Kamera: Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ300 die Schnittsoftware: Da Vinci Resolve 18, die Audiospur wurde mit Audacity 2.1.2 bearbeitet.
Vielen Dank an meine Familie für die Unterstützung.
Let's see if Hollywood is right, if there were really fighting women in the Middle Ages, and if so, how many?
Really? You want to talk about that?
Why?
There are a lot of discussions.
So what? Discussions are okay. I have nothing against it.
Not everyone has to agree with me.
But on the other hand, apart from that, facts are facts.
Hello and welcome to a new Vigant video.
If you already know my channel a little bit, you know that I don't just deal with the Middle Ages,
but also, for example, with the depictions in pop culture,
i.e. TV films, TV series, feature films or movies.
Especially what Hollywood understands as the Middle Ages,
or how the Middle Ages is depicted.
Especially in recent years, most people have probably noticed
that more and more women are depicted as fighters in the Middle Ages,
or fighting women somehow appear,
sometimes even, for example, like this or like that.
This is a phenomenon that used to be depicted less,
at most as an exception, and that is really omnipresent today.
And then the question arises to me,
is that actually true?
Did it really exist?
Or are our traditional, traditional ideas
about what a woman in the Middle Ages was allowed to do or not allowed to do
possibly even wrong?
And Hollywood is right.
I looked around a little bit,
did a little research,
looked to see if there might be something to find on the Internet
or in popular books.
And the surprising answer, first of all,
yes, there were fighting women.
And in all eras.
So it started with the Antiquity.
In the Antiquity, as many people know,
the people of the Amazons are described by the Greeks, for example.
But you're not really sure if that's a legend
and maybe also a bit of an erotic idea
or a counterpoint to the Greek world of imagination
that men have to fight or in war
only men fight.
And here you may have created
such a fantasy world.
That in any case, in addition to some, others say
that there are actually also archaeological finds.
So there is, for example, near Tiflis,
a grave with a warrior
or a woman with warrior talents.
Whether that always indicates exactly that
there is actually a warrior buried there,
I want to clarify that again in a moment.
But in any case, there is the possibility
and there are also people who believe
that there was actually a similar people.
Especially in the Black Sea region,
so where maybe Scythians
and other ancient peoples could be found.
In any case, the Greeks have of course
also left a few names here.
There is once the Penthesilea,
in which Achilles falls in love with Ilias.
However, dying, so Penthesilea attacked Achilles,
is fatally wounded.
Well, of course, nothing can be done out of love.
But that is of course fiction,
because whether there were warriors
in the Trojan War, we do not know.
We don't even know exactly
whether Homer gave it to the author of Ilias,
or whether it was perhaps also an invention.
That is all quite controversial
and maybe somewhere in the realm of legend.
But what we know exactly, for example,
is that later,
in the first century AD,
there is a Celtic princess
named Boudicca,
who rises up against the Romans.
And that's because her injustice is done
and her daughters above all.
Because the Romans are there
in southern England,
today's Kent in about,
also perform impossibly.
And well, here Boudicca starts a revenge campaign
and he is quite successful.
And that's why he is still known to this day.
Another well-known name from the Late Antiquity,
for example, would be Zenobia,
who lived in the middle of the 20th century AD
and was the ruler of Palmyra.
Here you can actually imagine a bit
the role model for the Khaleesi
from Game of Thrones.
Maybe not quite so blonde,
but she must have led armies in a similar way
and annoyed the Romans quite a bit.
And it's actually worth
to read a little bit here,
but antiquity is not really my topic.
That's why I didn't deal with it that much.
Of course, I looked more at the Middle Ages.
And if you come to the early Middle Ages,
then of course you are immediately
with the shield maidens,
for example Lagertha or Latgertha,
who may have actually lived.
But again, you don't know that exactly,
because she is only mentioned
in Saxo Grammaticus,
a Danish chronicler,
the Danish chronicler of the early Middle Ages.
And there is neither archaeological
nor other historical evidence
whether Lagertha really existed.
Nevertheless, she is of course known,
and her name has been used in Vikings.
And here she plays a very important role.
Yes, as I said,
we don't know anything exactly here.
And in this context, of course,
the famous grave 581 in Birka
is always referred to.
After all, a Viking warrior
has also been found there.
The press has stumbled upon it at the time.
But here I just refer to a few videos
from other pretty well-known channels
that have already dealt with this in great detail.
And that's why I don't want
to go into that further.
So maybe only so much.
It could be that there is a warrior there,
but it doesn't have to.
It could also be that grave donations
that don't necessarily reflect her life,
but have a very specific symbolic meaning,
are also buried in a women's grave.
And then to indicate
that she was possibly
even an army leader
or necessarily a professional warrior,
that's a bit too high.
As I said, it can be,
but it can't be.
So let's see where we actually have evidence
or at least well-documented
historical evidence.
And there it starts with a figure
that I find totally exciting,
so super interesting.
A woman with, I find,
from Salerno.
The good one lived in the 11th century
and we know that the Normans
not only conquered England,
but also very large parts of southern Italy,
for example Sicily and around Naples,
have started successful conquests.
And here Siegfried Geiter
has a large share of it,
the wife of Robert Giscard,
the later duke of Apulia and Calabria.
And Siegfried Geiter
was a Langobanian noblewoman,
a Langobanian princess.
The Langobans are,
as you may know,
the last Germanic tribe
that still moves towards Italy
and settles where Lombardy is today.
Langoban, Lombardy,
that sounds similar.
And this Langobanian princess
becomes the second wife of Robert Giscard.
And the marriage
seems to have been quite happy.
First of all, it can be seen
that the two have eight children together.
It is also reported that Siegfried Geiter
was really desperate at her husband's deathbed.
So she must have loved him very much.
She is described as a big, strong woman.
And it is proven
that she herself took up the sword
and even led troops,
was involved in the siege of Tarent, for example.
So if you ask me,
the two are an absolute power couple.
On the other hand, Bonnie and Clyde look like a sandbox love.
If you read into it in detail,
it's unbelievable what the two
have experienced together.
I think that, for example,
the author of Game of Thrones,
or rather the lead of Fire and Ice,
George R. R. Martin,
because purely by chance the brother-in-law of Siegfried Geiter,
i.e. a half-brother of Robert Drogo,
you've probably heard the name
if you know Game of Thrones.
So it could well be that Siegfried Geiter
is the role model for her.
And now, in the Middle Ages,
a couple of really well-documented,
very strong women follow,
who either fought or led armies.
There is once Mathilde of Canossa.
Mathilde of Canossa
was the marquis of Tuscany.
And the castle Canossa,
maybe one or the other has heard of it.
Exactly, that's the castle
to which Heinrich Büsend,
Heinrich IV, Saljak Büsend,
runs over the Alps
and gallantly
sets foot in Canossa.
And Mathilde
intervened.
In any case, Mathilde always quarrels
with Heinrich IV and sometimes
sends troops against him
to defend her land for several years.
And also has a share in some battles.
The next really well-known
and also definitely fighting woman
was Urraca of Leon,
also still in the 11th century,
on the threshold to the 12th century.
Queen of Castile, Leon and Galicia.
That was one of the first women
who was actually a sole ruler
and not only her husband,
but was the highest judge
and of course also
military leader.
Then we come to Eleonore of Aquitaine.
We are already in the 12th century.
After all, she was Queen of France,
later also Queen of England.
And she definitely mixed strongly politically,
but it is known from her
that she also followed her husband,
King Ludwig, to the first crusade.
So separated from him.
And with her were possibly
armed warriors,
who were also dressed exactly
like the male knights.
And of course she chose that very consciously.
The wife of Frederick Barbarossa.
She also led a army of knights
across the Alps in 1159 to support her husband.
So Barbarossa has always
fought in Northern Italy
and Beatrix definitely mixed there,
and actively.
And finally Blanca of Castile.
So again we have the link to Spain.
Blanca of Castile has proven
to be representative for her
too young son Ludwig,
the Saint,
at the top of the troops
fought against noblemen
and also defeated them.
There we now also have a historically
proven fighting nobleman.
Most of all, the name
Johanna of Orléans or Jeanne d'Arc comes to mind.
She is now so legendary again,
that you have to be incredibly careful again.
What is really history
and what is legend?
And as always, the historians argue
about what was written about her.
And that goes so far again that it is partly
whether she was really a woman,
was she really involved in the fights?
Isn't it just a symbol?
I don't really like to get involved
in such things.
I try to take what is reasonably
secured as far as possible.
Speculations that take it all apart
or put something on it,
it's best to read it yourself.
There is really a lot of material about it.
And of course there are a lot of films
and series about Jeanne d'Arc.
She is also an interesting figure.
I found much more interesting
two other Johannas.
There is Johanna of Flanders,
who also lives in the 14th century
and who is proven to have organized
the defense of Hennepont
and is also very successful there
and was respected accordingly.
And another Breton woman,
I find even more exciting,
also actually Johanna or Jeanne,
Jeanne de Belleville.
So she was in the 14th century
Jeanne de Belleville.
So she was the Breton countess
and pirate.
Because she fought out of revenge
against the French king,
fled to England,
equipped a small fleet
and fought successfully for 13 years
at sea against the French king.
So she just didn't let go
of her revenge and annoyed him so much.
So I find that totally exciting
and also very respectable
what the woman did there.
It is worth reading a little further here.
Jeanne de Belleville, as I said.
And finally maybe Katharina Sforza,
an Italian nobleman from the 15th century
who also always participated
in a very bloody time in Italy,
in northern Italy.
She was Duke of Imola
and is said to have participated
in the defense of the castle Fauli herself.
And she was also known for being
a good fighter.
So here we definitely have something
Well, if you see such an impressive list
and that quite obviously
in so many different countries
at such different times,
does that mean Hollywood is right?
Were there really equal rights
just as many women?
So is Hollywood doing everything right
at the moment to represent so many fighters?
Of course, that's just my opinion now,
but according to what I've read,
the exact opposite is the case.
This list is a proof that women
always perceive the exception.
Because whenever there was a fighting woman,
she was particularly mentioned,
mostly even as an example for the men
that you can be so brave
in such a situation,
if you are a woman.
And practically always there are nobles
with very, very few exceptions
who are just born into this situation,
get married into it
or just have to go through
in some way.
And who may also have a similar
education and who in all
rules of course also have to
enforce themselves politically
accordingly.
And that was almost only possible
at the time with violence.
Of course, there are also many other
noble women who are simply known
to let them fight,
but with other means
and who do not necessarily fight.
So yes, it is an impressive list
and yes, there were actually women
who took up arms,
but read it yourself,
there are always exceptions.
I have you, so that you can read
extra down a few links in the info,
for example also to an interesting
English-language Wikimedia page.
To enjoy this a bit with caution,
so it is a bit inaccurate,
you should definitely still
look for other sources,
so that you know more precisely
what is true and what is not.
And what else I found,
take a picture yourself,
see if you may also find parallels
to what you then get shown
in series and films,
or vice versa,
whether perhaps a lot is also
contradicted by it.
I am far from printing
a world view or
a world view,
so that everything we get shown at the moment
can be classified a little better.
Yes, as usual, the note that I am always
very happy about comments,
that is also a topic that is
perhaps a bit more controversial
and where you have your own opinion,
where you have a different opinion,
where you have found interesting figures.
I would be very interested in all of this,
as always, I would be happy if you
put it down here in the comments,
or in another channel,
for example Facebook, Instagram,
or you write to me by e-mail
and as usual I will always be there
and as usual I will report to you
and don't forget to subscribe.
In the next video it should be
about medieval sword fighting again,
but this time not about steel,
but about the question
whether there may be other materials
with which you can train show fighting
or sports medieval fighting
better, maybe,
and I want to present everything
that I have brought together there
and maybe also give a recommendation
what is best for it.
So I would be happy if you are there again
and thank you very much for watching this time.
Until then, bye.