The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) engages in the world’s most comprehensive campaign of transnational repression, targeting exile communities, members of the diaspora, and supporters in dozens of countries around the world with digital surveillance, attempted censorship, and even physical attacks. This campaign has also reached university campuses in the United States, generating discussion among faculty, students, administrators, and policymakers.
As a new academic year begins, experts on transnational repression, Beijing’s influence on university campuses, and the persecution of Falun Gong shed light on how CCP surveillance, slander, and censorship impinge upon free expression and belief at American universities, and what university administrators and government officials can do to respond.
Hosted by the Falun Dafa Information Center and moderated by leading Confucius Institute expert, Ian Oxnevad of the National Association of Scholars, this webinar offers new insight into the key challenges facing universities and recommendations for action to best protect freedom of speech and belief for all students, faculty, and members of the campus community.
Right. So, to follow up question, a follow-up question I have with that is,
has, how much do you think the broader sort of campus culture has affected this? In the sense
that there's a lot of political clashing and sort of ideological things occurring on campus,
more broadly, aside from just this issue. And a lot of research suggests that open dialogue
is basically extinct on many modern American campuses. And do you think that this is a
symptom of that, from at least the administrative side of them not doing anything? Or do you think
it's more of an issue-specific ignorance, or maybe co-option by organizations like
Confucius Institutes that have contributed to the climate that you're facing?
I think specifically, at least within the case studies that we've conducted over this year,
on all of this university repression and silencing and censorship, we've actually seen
that a lot of it is actually, like you said in the latter part of your question,
coming from the CCP proxies. And even in Chinese language textbooks, in Chinese language
classrooms, courses held at American universities, there's a lot of language that's very
false and kind of demonizes Falun Gong in the exact way that the CCP continues to demonize
Falun Gong on CCTV, Chinese state media. And that's also a concern, because you talk about
how there's no open dialogue, right? But the students are still going to these classes,
trying to learn Mandarin, trying to either pursue business or pursue whatever career that they want.
And whenever they go to these Chinese language classes, the first thing they hear about
spirituality in China is that it makes you go mad. Falun Gong forces people to not eat or not
sleep and all of these crazy depictions. And they think of it as true, because it's their textbook.
The professor is teaching it to them. And you would think that in a university, especially in
America, that it's very honest and independent and truthful. And so I think I wanted to highlight
that point. I think it really does come from all of these tactics and all these channels that the
CCP is actually already installed inside of our universities. Right. No, go ahead. Go ahead,
please. I just have two brief thoughts on your question. So one of them was that, you know,
the thing about open dialogue. In our open letter, we actually addressed this issue that, you know,
I think the Falun Dafa Club did a lot to open up that dialogue. We specifically invited the
CSSA to the event. We actually invited them to every single one of our human rights screening
events, you know, especially after that first instance where they, you know, Chinese students
complained that we were allowed to advertise in the newsletter. You know, we didn't want any
misunderstandings to continue to occur, you know. So we invited them to every human rights film
screening event. We specifically invited them to In the Name of Confucius. We also invited the
Temple University Confucius Institute to this Confucius Institute event. You know, our purpose
was to open up the dialogue. You know, we're not trying to create, you know, this closed room of
just echoing voices of the same opinion. No, we want to open it up, come to this event, you know,
ask critical questions. I think that was in the description, you know, like critical questions
are encouraged, you know, like come have a discussion with us. Of course, nobody took up
that offer. And then the other thing I wanted to mention was that, sorry, I'm sort of losing my train
of thought. If I remember it, I'll let you know. Well, I think, sorry, I think I would say that,
again, there is generally a lack of awareness in terms of the wider problem of transnational
oppression. I do think universities know that some of these incidents are happening
on their campuses, but they may not necessarily know the wider context that play. And when they
do, when they do actually consider that this is a problem, there may be other factors that
contribute to the reluctance to, I guess, defend some of these students more vehemently. I mean,
there are financial interests and international partnerships at play that may also factor into
the decision-making process when it comes to responding to these incidents. So I don't
necessarily think it's a, I think it's somewhat issue-specific in that regard.
Right. Grady, I have a question for you, and this relates to not only this issue,
but transnational oppression more broadly. There's been