The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) engages in the world’s most comprehensive campaign of transnational repression, targeting exile communities, members of the diaspora, and supporters in dozens of countries around the world with digital surveillance, attempted censorship, and even physical attacks. This campaign has also reached university campuses in the United States, generating discussion among faculty, students, administrators, and policymakers.
As a new academic year begins, experts on transnational repression, Beijing’s influence on university campuses, and the persecution of Falun Gong shed light on how CCP surveillance, slander, and censorship impinge upon free expression and belief at American universities, and what university administrators and government officials can do to respond.
Hosted by the Falun Dafa Information Center and moderated by leading Confucius Institute expert, Ian Oxnevad of the National Association of Scholars, this webinar offers new insight into the key challenges facing universities and recommendations for action to best protect freedom of speech and belief for all students, faculty, and members of the campus community.
To everybody.
I'd like to bring Cynthia in here, but this has kind of given
us a good sense of the problem.
I'd like to ask if you've seen anything that universities have done, right.
And the reason I ask this is because there's a tension between universities
sort of being these places of open idea, or at least in theory, these arenas
for the exchange of open ideas.
At the same time, universities because of their openness are
Institutionally left vulnerable to misuse by authoritarian
governments and their influence.
So I'm kind of wondering how has the university managed to do
anything right in this regard?
Or are they just kind of unresponsive or do they seem to be co-opted by, by
the Chinese government in this case, as the office of international student
affairs done anything like to open that up to the three of you.
Clue, Cynthia, and, um, just, just briefly on that point.
Um, and this, this might be a low bar, but, uh, there are at least 45 universities
around the United States that have allowed the following bone club to be
established, um, or for meditation events, different campus events and documentary
screenings, right.
To be held.
Um, and like I said before, that's a very low bar.
That's a right that every single student in any college in America should have.
Um, there was another case in New York where, uh, the phone gone club had met
with a lot of this reprisal and they were worried about physical attacks.
Um, and so they actually contacted, uh, the campus police and there were security
put into place before, um, the event began.
So these are two things that I wanted to bring up real quick.
Um, I have one that is sort of discussed in the film, um, in the name of Confucius.
So it's about Confucius Institute.
So the, the sort of controversy over Confucius Institutes, uh, sort of
started when, um, this one student, you know, from mainland China, she had signed
a contract with Confucius Institutes and then she was working, um, at her
university in Canada, I think it was McMaster university.
So, um, I believe they're the only university to close down a Confucius
Institute because of discriminatory hiring practices.
So, because in the contract that she signed, it specifically said, you know,
you cannot be a Falun Gong practitioner, um, and work at Confucius Institute.
So basically exporting that discrimination outside of China into Canada, you know,
not allowing Falun Gong practitioners to be hired.
And from what I have read, um, that that is the only university to ever
cite that as the prime example of why the prime reason why they closed
down the Confucius Institutes, Tufts university, when they closed theirs,
it was sort of this, you know, our two year contract is up, you know, we have
decided to go different directions.
You know, most universities are not stating this as the reason why they're
closing the Confucius Institute.
So that's in my opinion, like one of the, one of the best examples of
something a university can do directly cite the problem, you know, don't,
don't beat around the bush and, you know, not point out this problem.
But from what I understand, McMaster university is the only one to
actually specifically say that most universities are just like, you know,
we've decided to go different directions.
We're not going to have the Confucius Institute anymore.
They're not citing the reason why, you know, these discriminatory hiring
practices and the transnational repression of dissident voices outside of China.
I would, sorry.
No, go ahead.
Yeah, I would like to echo something that Emily said earlier about
the importance of solidarity.
I think in general, as we've all acknowledged, there's a sort of a lack
of understanding and awareness among universities when it comes to the
scope of transnational oppression.
So when a high profile incident occurs or report emerges of this harassment,
administrators often failed to kind of adequately speak out
in support of effective parties.
However, there was one instance that I would like to highlight as a, uh, as
a more positive response to this issue and something that we would like to see
more of, uh, following the publication of a pro public article in December of
2021, uh, on the threats faced by students from the PRC, Purdue university's
president's office, um, released a statement to condemn this targeting of
one of his universities, one of the, uh, of one Purdue students, uh, targeting
that was mentioned in this, uh, report or in this piece, the president made
it clear that quote, uh, any such intimidation is unacceptable and
unwelcome on our campus input.
Well, it's always preferable as Emily pointed out for universities to have
more proactive responses, uh, and to establish some sort of response
mechanism before an incident occurs.
I do think that these types of firm statements in support of international
students' rights and safety may make these students feel less alone.
I do think the solidarity in general is very important.