Hello everyone, and welcome to Seiei Rondan. I'm Mr. Seki, your host.
China's continuous economic downturn is currently the most important issue in the world.
China's economy is not only affecting China, but also the world economy.
So, after a brief meditation, last week in Beijing, a policy to save the real estate market was announced,
which is to recognize a house, but not a loan.
This has led to a sharp increase in sales in some cities.
What exactly does this policy mean, and how can it save the real estate market in China?
And where is the greatest risk in the future of China's economy?
Today's guests are the editor-in-chief of Daikigenjiho, Mr. Kakkun,
and the TV producer, Mr. Ligun.
Mr. Ligun used to teach economics at Peking University,
and now Mr. Kakgyoryo, an American economist, will join us online for our discussion.
Welcome, everyone.
Before we begin, we recommend that you subscribe to our YouTube channel, Ganjin World.
Seiei Rondan airs every Saturday on Ganjin World, so please support us.
First, I'd like to ask Mr. Ligun.
Can you explain in detail about the recently popular policy of recognizing a house, but not a loan?
Before discussing the policy of recognizing a house, but not a loan,
it is necessary to understand what the policy of recognizing a house, but not a loan, is.
Xi Jinping proposed a series of financial policies to prevent investment in real estate.
One of them is the policy of recognizing a house, but not a loan.
Recognizing a house, but not a loan means that if you buy a second house,
your capital will increase by 30% to 40%.
In addition, the interest rate will increase by 4% to 4.9%,
and there is a possibility that it will increase by 0.5% to 1%.
This is aimed at preventing real estate speculation.
In other words, recognizing a house, but not a loan,
means that even if you bought a house with a loan in the past,
if you do not own real estate at the moment,
you will be able to buy a second house, and you will be able to get a commission on the interest rate and interest rate.
This is a policy that the real estate industry and real estate buyers have been waiting for.
In a sense, it is an abandonment of Xi Jinping's policy.
Currently, the policy does not seem to have changed on the surface,
but in any family, if one of the family members does not own real estate,
the purchase of the person's house is seen as the first purchase of the house.
For example, let's say a family of four.
Previously, when purchasing the first house, it was necessary to include a house loan.
And when purchasing the second house,
it was the target of recognizing a house, but not a loan.
However, if one of the family members does not own real estate,
the purchase of the person's house is seen as the first purchase of the house.
This allows you to gain the benefits of the first purchase of the house.
Specifically, the interest rate will be lower and the interest rate will be lower.
At present, this policy has a very limited range of influence on real estate buyers.
If you buy a house for the first time, you will not be affected by this policy,
and those who already own a lot of real estate in their own name will not be affected.
This policy affects people who are thinking about buying a house,
and it actually encourages real estate speculation.
In other words, it encourages a lot of housing purchases for people who buy multiple houses.
If you buy a lot of real estate, it will become speculation and will not be used as a place to live.
But now, who is speculating real estate?
The price of real estate in China continues to rise,
and there will never be a time when it does not fall.
I saw a story on the Internet about this policy.
One person persuaded another person, saying,
because now may be the last chance to sell the house,
so hurry up and use the present to sell it.
As a result, he found out that he had a friend he really wanted to sell.
After that, strangely enough, his friends in Shanghai and Canton want to sell,
but his friends in Beijing do not want to sell.
The reason is that the price of a house in Beijing is rising.
In other words, the conditions for real estate are emerging as a rule of law in the real estate market.
Real estate brokers in Beijing are very sensitive and quick to act.
In the past few days, they have been calling and advertising real estate customers.
In fact, the media continues to advertise them.
However, many customers are not very interested in this.
If you buy real estate now and can save 100,000 or 200,000 yuan in the end,
there is a possibility that the price of real estate will fall by 100,000 or 200,000 yuan after that.
It will be easily demolished.
The risk is very high.
The real estate market in China has been in a tough situation for the past two years.
Mr. Ka-gyo-ryo, how effective do you think this policy will be?
First of all, I have confirmed some information about the policy called
real estate denial by some media such as Shinkasha and Shina.com.
As Mr. Lee Gun mentioned earlier, I would like to add one more point.
Even if you have purchased real estate in the past and have now sold it,
it will be applied unless you own real estate by name.
There is a possibility that you will be treated as the first real estate buyer.
In other words, you ignore the real estate history and only look at the real estate ownership status by name.
Therefore, there is a possibility that people who want to buy real estate will be provided with a certain amount.
The government, of course, hopes that the real estate market will recover through this policy
and that the expectations of the pessimistic market will change.
We aim to restore trust in the real estate market and promote development.
The real estate market is well known to have an impact on many related industries.
In the past, the Chinese economy depended more than 36% on foreign trade,
but trade could not contribute to the growth of the industry, so it relied on the real estate market.
If the real estate market and the stock market cannot boost the economy,
there will be a problem of how to stimulate the economy.
Currently, the Chinese economy is stagnant, and under such circumstances, they are trying all means.
In my personal opinion, this policy is not actually a very wise strategy,
but rather a temporary measure.
However, since there are no other options, I think we have no choice but to launch such a solution.
Next, let's take a look at how this policy will unfold.
First, revitalize the real estate market in Shenzhen and Guangzhou,
and then revitalize the real estate market in Beijing and Shanghai.
In a country with a market economy, in order to promote real estate purchasing,
the ratio of initial payment and capital is very low.
For example, 20%, 15%, 10%,
and in the most extreme cases, it can go down to 5%.
However, as far as I remember in China, capital has never been below 20%.
The lowest is 20%, the highest is 30%, and more than 30% is general.
Currently, in Beijing and Shanghai, capital is usually 35% to 45%.
It is necessary to observe whether this ratio will be adjusted in the new policy.
If the capital ratio is reduced to 20% or 25%,
young people will feel the intention to buy real estate.
However, as you pointed out,
this policy currently has only a short-term effect,
and it is highly likely that it will only affect some people.
According to official media,
in addition to this policy, various advantages will be gradually introduced.
This includes a reduction in the capital ratio,
a reduction from 30% to 20%, and so on.
In addition, a reduction in the second housing loan rate,
and a reduction in existing housing loans.
The government is trying to stimulate the real estate market in these major cities
and stop the decline in prices.
By realizing economic recovery like the end of the year,
the government is hoping to gradually restore the real estate market throughout the country.
Can this policy solve the macroeconomic problem facing China?
It may be very difficult at the moment.
Because in the macroeconomic environment,
it is necessary to consider the cost of banks and fixed interest rates.
Just by reducing interest rates significantly,
it is possible to put a great burden on banks.
Some banks are already under too much burden
and rely on the government's special protection policy.
There is information that four major commercial banks in Japan also hold a large amount of negative assets.
The government has disposed of these negative assets several times,
but it is the same as all the people are burdened.
Even so, new negative debts are still accumulating.
Therefore, will banks be able to cope in the future?
In addition, the problem of interest rates is closely related to the actual rate of inflation and inflation,
so even if you look at a single indicator,
you may not be able to cope with other problems.
This is also a big problem.
It is necessary to understand the overall situation,
and to make a more comprehensive and comprehensive macroeconomic policy.
I think the government is now in a state of confusion.
They are trying to find a way to solve one problem,
introduce a policy, and improve it
if there are undesirable effects or other effects.
In other words, it is like a rescue team that repairs a hole if there is a problem.
Therefore, in my opinion,
this policy will eventually be abolished and will not have much effect.
Yes, it is similar to the phrase,
I am a faithful servant who works as the master's assistant.
I am not the master of the house, but the servant of the house.
This house is always raining,
and I put paper on the place where I was hit by the rain.
If my understanding is correct,
if you lower the interest rate or lower the interest rate,
it means that banks will take the risk of real estate.
Do you think that banks in China will increase the risk significantly?
The Chinese government does not seem to be able to see many of them.
However, it has to solve the current crisis.
The policy of human trafficking is actually putting a risk on people who buy a house.
China is different from other countries.
The housing loan of other countries is a low-income loan.
If you can't repay the loan,
the bank will hold back the property and sell it,
and if the difference is large, it will be refunded,
but if it is insufficient, it will be replenished.
If the property price drops,
the bank will bear some of the risks.
However, in China, if a person can't repay the loan,
the bank will buy the house and sell it.
Even if the house is sold,
if the loan cannot be repaid,
the person will bear a debt for the rest of his life.
The law of China protects the bank.
If the price of the house drops too much
or there is too much debt to repay,
the person may not care about repaying the debt.
There is a saying that if there is too much debt, the person will not be bitten,
but that is not the case.
People are not afraid of being bitten.
If everyone does not repay the loan,
the risk will be even greater,
and the bank will be closed.
The Chinese government is trying to put the risk on the individual
and send the overall pressure forward as much as possible.
The current problem is that real estate developers have a lot of capital in the bank.
For example, real estate has 2.4 trillion yuan,
which is about 48 trillion yen,
and most of it is in the bank.
If real estate develops,
the bank has the lowest rate of debt repayment.
This is because real estate assets are currently only 8 trillion yuan,
which is about 16 trillion yen.
The bank has the potential to collapse.
If real estate can be sold, it will be even better for the bank.
However, real estate currently has 2.4 trillion yuan,
which is 1.3 trillion yuan,
which is about 26 trillion yen.
If you add the two,
it will be about 4 trillion yuan, or 70 trillion yen.
This kind of huge debt
has the potential to cause financial crisis.
However, the Chinese government is currently
trying to prevent the reconstruction
and sending the problem forward.
The final result is a decrease in the price of real estate
and a decrease in capital,
which is no different from the current financial crisis.
However, the current Chinese government
is trying to take coercive measures
to gradually make this reality a reality.
It will absorb the losses of many people
and increase the risk.
However, through management,
you will not be able to reduce the risk,
and step by step, you will make this risk a reality.
Will the current real estate market improve?
Do you think there is a possibility
that the real estate market in China will rebound?
There may be a bigger crisis in the future.
It is a credit crisis for the Chinese people.
What do you think my friends in China are doing now?
They are getting a house with a loan
without receiving a large amount of money.
Are you giving them a house with a loan as a gift?
That's right.
For example, I bought a house worth 2 million yuan,
which is about 40 million yen,
and I set up a loan of about 30 million yuan.
If I can't repay the loan
when I still have 1 million yuan
and about 20 million yuan left.
Currently, many people are unemployed,
so they have lost the ability to repay loans.
So if you can't repay the loan,
you can buy a house without receiving a large amount of money
and get a loan repayment in return.
In other words, I'm asking you to repay my loan.
These examples are not one or two.
It is seen in many areas,
and there are reports that many people actually do so.
The price of used houses is still falling slowly,
but in fact, the government is behind
to suppress the rapid price fall.
Wait a minute.
In other words, I'll give you that house for free with a loan.
You don't have to pay me for it.
You just have to borrow a bank loan
and borrow this house to repay the remaining loan.
If you calculate this amount,
it will be 35% and 40% capital in China,
so you lost the amount of the first capital.
That's right.
Since you lost the first capital,
this housing price is actually at least 40%.
In other words, the house was split and became 60%.
Most people are pessimistic now.
Some of the people involved and experts
have been saying things like this for a while,
and we recommend that you sell as soon as possible.
Even in new houses and used houses,
the atmosphere that those who can let go
should let go of everything
has already been adjusted.
In addition, the real income situation
of real estate prices and Chinese citizens
has completely changed.
Unless this problem is solved,
no matter how much housing purchases are approved,
ordinary people will not be able to buy a house.
Why did the real estate market continue to develop
in the past?
It is because real estate prices are constantly rising,
and many people are not able to use real estate
as an investment target.
Regarding the problem of existing loan interest,
it is said that this part will also be slightly changed.
First, how much is the existing loan interest?
For example, in the past, I used to buy a house
with a loan of 5% interest,
but assuming that the interest was reduced to 3%
in a new policy,
the 2% difference is clearly
a big loss for those who own a house.
Because I already bought a house.
In this case, what to do is
probably in line with the general trend,
and I think that the percentage of people who are already
receiving interest will also decrease slightly,
but this is called a decrease in the existing interest rate.
On the other hand, the increase means
that a new loan is set up to buy a house.
Therefore, these two aspects
need to be adjusted together.
However, if only one side of the adjustment is made,
there is a possibility that your dissatisfaction will increase.
One of the most common phenomena now is
that the house was originally 3 million yen,
and now it is 1.5 million yen,
about 30 million yen.
People who have just bought a house
often go to the company that sold the house to protest.
This has happened many times.
Therefore, the government needs to consider
the impact it has had on the policy.
Do not look only at one aspect.
If the policy is implemented only on one aspect,
the social dissatisfaction will be accumulated by its reaction.
The most concerned issue in the international community
is whether there is a possibility
that real estate inflation will occur.
What do you think about this issue?
I think this is a concern that everyone has in common.
After the creation of real estate,
the general public, including some middle-class Chinese people,
are most concerned about reducing their assets.
For example, in the past, real estate was considered
a relatively safe way to deal with inflation.
However, the value of real estate is decreasing now,
and in some areas it is half the price.
For example, a house worth 3 million yen
is worth 1.5 million yen.
In such a situation,
ordinary Chinese people feel that there is nothing safe.
The financial assets left in the bank are not safe,
and there is a possibility
that you will lose them completely
even if you buy products for asset management.
Once you fall into a trap,
you will basically lose your investment assets.
In other words, the current situation is that
ordinary Chinese people feel that they do not have
a safe option to protect their assets.
They cannot exchange their own currency
for U.S. dollars or highly trusted currency.
It is because the people are not allowed
to freely exchange currency.
However, as Mr. Ligon said,
ordinary Chinese people are losing confidence.
This sense of uncertainty
is likely to have a major impact
on China's new macroeconomic policy.
Originally, the effect of the new policy
should be waiting for a certain period of time,
but the actual effect is not expected.
Therefore, it can be seen that
the world's major banking institutions
are also reviewing China
and recognizing that the risk factors are very dangerous.
Therefore, if there is a financial risk
or financial crisis throughout the system in China,
the situation may not be
as bad as the former Southeast Asian financial crisis.
In the test, if there is a financial crisis in China,
it will be difficult for Western countries
to support China.
It's not just that China can't support it,
but there is no reason to support it.
There is no reason to support it.
You've seen a large-scale withdrawal
of foreign capital over the past two months, Mr. Ligon.
Since 2023, the withdrawal rate
of foreign capital has clearly accelerated.
This is called a cliff-like fall.
According to data published in China,
foreign capital investment in China
in the second half of the year
decreased by 87%
and was only $4 billion,
about 590.4 billion yen.
This decline is very large.
People do not call this an economic decline.
It's called a cliff-like fall.
The EU has an executive board
and is conducting several surveys
on its own companies
investing in the United States.
The EU executive board
is also conducting surveys on companies
investing in China.
As you know, the EU has a relatively high interest
in China,
and 30% of the companies in the EU
are already withdrawing from China
or are preparing to withdraw.
In addition, as a result of the survey,
40% of these companies
are also withdrawing from upstream
and downstream companies.
Therefore, the withdrawal rate is very large.
As for the capital market,
according to the data,
foreign capital investment in China
in the first month of July this year
decreased by about $3.7 billion,
about 5.45 trillion yen.
This is by no means a small decrease.
Of course, on the contrary,
investment from China to the United States
has also decreased significantly.
It was about $3 billion,
about 4.42 trillion yen,
but now it has probably decreased
to several billion dollars,
and the decrease rate is also about 70%-80%.
It seems that there is a withdrawal phenomenon
in the financial market.
Both are happening.
Withdrawal from China to the United States
I checked yesterday,
and the withdrawal rate of the yuan was 7.3.
Even if I pulled it, the yuan didn't go up,
so I was just dragging it a little in front of me.
Mr. Kakkun, do you think that the withdrawal rate
of the yuan will continue to be cheaper
in such a situation?
The probability of withdrawal is very high.
There are a lot of survey reports
and I think it's even worse.
This is because foreign capital
has been exported from China in the past two months.
Almost one-third of the foreign capital invested in China
was invested in Chinese real estate.
It was mainly invested in the reconstruction
of local governments and real estate companies.
There was also the reconstruction
of the U.S. dollar and the People's Bank of China.
The pressure on the people's money market
has become very strong
due to the large number of foreign companies
and the withdrawal of foreign capital
to other countries.
The pressure on the people's money market
has become so strong that
the Chinese government can no longer
print its own money.
Is it true that most of these foreign investors
are Wall Street investors?
I'm sure they are.
This is the U.S. dollar.
The relationship between Wall Street
and China is very complicated.
In the past, it was very close
and if there was a personal relationship
with people in the Middle East,
it would be very difficult.
Over the past 20 years,
they have seriously thought about it
and put in good words for the Middle East
and helped to make a profit in Washington, D.C.
Now the situation has changed
and there are more and more people
who think that the future of the Chinese market
is dark outside the Wall Street.
In fact, one of them is to investigate
the high-tech of the U.S. capital invested in China.
About a month ago, President Biden
signed a presidential order
that excluded some fields that did not allow investment,
such as high-tech chips and semiconductors.
The other is to investigate the funds
invested in the Middle East outside the Wall Street.
For example, many of the U.S. foreign investment funds,
such as California,
must be withdrawn from China.
However, it is a huge amount of money,
so it can only be withdrawn slowly.
There is a very high possibility
that it will become a large-scale human capital.
Foreign investment is decreasing,
but in fact, Chinese private investment is also decreasing.
Recently, there is a very interesting story on the Internet.
It is said that the Chinese government
has also established a bureau for private companies.
In other words, the Development Reform Committee
has established a bureau specializing in managing private companies.
It's scary just to hear it.
Why is China's private capital
not brave enough to invest more in China?
China is not a healthy nationalist country.
In other words, China is not a true nationalist country,
and it is not a perfect market economy,
but an anti-market economy,
a pure market economy.
The role of the planning department in recent years
in such a situation
is somewhat similar to the era of the planning economy,
that is, to return to the era of Takutou.
At that time, the planning department was
a being that no one should do anything.
The original direction of market reform
was the purpose of the planning department
gradually losing its function
and making the market play its role.
It is now back to normal again.
Now, the authority of the National Development Reform Committee
is getting bigger and bigger.
For this reason, a private economy development bureau was established.
Officially, it is said that you can track and understand
the development of a private economy.
In addition, it is said that it establishes a permanent mechanism
for communication by establishing a policy
that is advantageous to the development of a private economy.
This means that there was no such normal communication mechanism
before, and there was no normal production environment
to promote the development of a private economy.
In other words, it is said that the government
did not hit its own face in the past,
and the government did not hit its own face in the past.
However, please think about it.
China has been singing about market economy
for decades, so these problems
should have been solved a long time ago.
Why is it that the establishment of a private economy development bureau
is now treated differently
and it is in this state?
If I were to say,
the fact that there is discrimination
means that there is no fair treatment.
If there is a fair treatment,
there is no need to establish a special bureau
to represent the interests of private companies
and serve private companies.
So this is very strange.
The Chinese Communist Party has not admitted
that it has committed terrible acts
However, it is a fact that
when the private economy is in danger,
it becomes very difficult
to take advantage of it to help it.
Moreover, it becomes more difficult
to take advantage of it when it is difficult.
On the contrary, even when the development of the private economy is smooth
and no one needs money,
the bank approaches to lend money,
So, as I said earlier,
the establishment of a so-called private economy development bureau
can play a real role in promoting
the development of the private economy?
It's a test, but I think it's fundamentally impossible.
I think the only exception is the Kodai Group.
Because you have to borrow enough money.
There's too much money I borrowed,
and if I collapse,
I'd like to interrupt here,
but I don't think Kodai Group and Hekikeien
are really private companies.
The top of Hekikeien later said
that Hekikeien was not a private company
in the true sense.
I think there is a very deep meaning
in what the top says.
In the early stages of development,
Hekikeien was a private company,
but after that, many companies
became non-private companies.
Can you say that companies like Farway are private companies?
It's about time.
Thank you to all the experts
for your wonderful opinions.