We pulled out

HowNOT2
100 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 6, 2023
We tested a lot of twist bolts from http://bolt-products.com/Catalogue.htm and never made a video about it. This summarizes all of our findings or you can see the chart with all the information in the Book of Numbers https://www.hownot2.com/post/bolting-bible-numbers
SIGN UP FOR THE NEWSLETTER https://www.hownot2.com/sign-up
Learn all about bolts at https://www.hownot2.com/boltingbible
👉 Learn and shop at https://www.hownot2.com/
👉 10% off Rocky Talkie by clicking https://www.rockytalkie.com/HowNOT2
👉 Our merch is at http://www.hownot2swag.com/
👉 1000 Patrons makes us viable https://www.patreon.com/howNOTtoHighline
👉 1 time donations really help also https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/slackcessfund
How many break tests is this? 31 break tests. We are going to talk in depth about the world's
strongest climbing gluon bolt that we know of. This is a bolt in epoxy that we will be giving
away. Now, ironically, this is a mechanical bolt, even though this episode is specifically about
gluons, but anybody who opens up their email on Saturdays in September is eligible to win.
It's that simple. We just want you to know what we've got coming out because not everything we
have is video related. A lot of it is written content that we want to be able to update you on.
Now, what's crazy about the episode you're about to see is that we tested over 30 gluon bolts,
some of the strongest in the world. And so that is an enormous amount of work, probably over about
a hundred man hours. And we weren't, didn't quite have all the answers yet. So we broke some more
and then, and then we broke some more and Bobby and I were like, Oh my God, we never made an
episode about it. And that's what you're about to watch. And I have a really cool surprise that
I've been working on for two months that I am only going to tell my email list for a little while.
So make sure you go sign up. This is the twist bolt from boltproducts.com and Jim Titt makes
these in an eight millimeter stock rod and six millimeter stock rod. This is rated at 79
kilonewtons, which I believe is rated to be the strongest bolt around for climbing. We did a lot
of tests over the last few years and actually never made any videos about this, which is a shame
because it takes like a hundred man hours in order to get the information that we have on the book
of numbers and the bolting Bible. And these are my favorite bolts. When people ask what bolts do
you use? What do you recommend? These are the ones that I generally recommend because they don't have
any welds that could be a problem on some bolts. They fit very nicely in the hole that they say
they're going to fit into with a little bit of interference. So they don't like ooze out while
the glue dries and they're pretty reasonable price. I've probably put in 600 of these or those.
Yeah. So this is going to be awesome video. If you trust your life to bolts and you see these around
they're both stainless and that's important that you use stainless. If you have a bolt outside,
these are both three 16 L stainless. So as you'll see in the break test, we have
epoxy or glue doesn't stick to metal, at least stainless. It, it will slide right off. If this
was a smooth shaft, the benefits to having it twisted is you have a bunch of grooves and stuff
in order for it to grab in order to get the most strength. And this is a pretty simple and efficient
way to get all of those points where it can connect. Usually you'll see in a glue in bolt
or in a U shaped staples, they'll have little notches they've cut and grooved in, which some
people debate if that compromises the strength. If done well, it doesn't, but there's a lot of
ways you could do it that would compromise. Everything we've tested except for the fringes
of stuff you're not supposed to do is super good enough. And it's nice to know that when you trust
your life to a, uh, super good enough looking bolt that it probably is. Now, if you're using
stainless near the ocean, it could look safe and be corroding right here and just snap off under
body weight, but that's where you're supposed to use titanium. We have been working on the
bolting Bible for weeks now, or technically last two years, we've been trying to improve it.
If you haven't seen that thing recently, please go check it out. It's got all the different sports
segregated now. So you can see what's specific to you. And the old Testament is all the general
stuff you need to know about bolts. And if you trust your life to bolts, I think it's worth skimming
over for an hour. It's free. And I think you'll learn a lot. So the first test we're going to talk
about is six millimeter or the smaller ones that are a hundred millimeters long or six inches or
four inches. They're rated for 40 kilonewtons. Your carabiners you're clipping to are only rated
for 20 ish. So all of this is super good enough, but it's interesting how they fail. And I think
that's important because that one number is just a little piece of what can happen, depending what
you're doing with these. And let's just cover this real quick. Yes. Some bolts get pulled in tension.
Climbers think they're only being pulled down. There are roofs. You can stick it in. There are
highliners that are highlighting in the middle of a cliff, pulling it straight out.
Cavers are trying to get the ropes, not to rub rocks. So it's not as common, but they can be
pulled in tension. Anyways, we get very different numbers when we do that. So in concrete, we pulled
in tension and we got 37.32, 41.92. And the load cell was off for the last one, but it broke like
the others. And the concrete failed. This was well aged concrete. It was a driveway that was about to
come out. But you can see after the concrete spalls or breaks near the top, that the bolt is coming
out with a twisting action because the metal is no longer engaged in the epoxy and it's kind of
unscrewing itself. Even with that, it's not like once you get one turn, you're going to pull the
bolt out. It still takes force. You have to maintain an unreasonably high force in order to
get it to ultimately fail. And the way you've set your anchor has to be able to freely twist.
It's just interesting. When we pulled these same six millimeters in concrete with Liquid Rock 500,
but in sheer, we were getting 39.52, 37.52, and 39.64. And then the bolt failed on each one of
them. For these tests, we used a soft shackle because it's the strongest thing we could think
of. And we were having lots of problems with quick links seizing, not being usable. We had to cut
them off. What's interesting, no matter what you pull it with, if the rock or the glue doesn't fail,
they fail here. And that's what we've seen with all of these P-shaped glue ends that
don't have welds. This is the point that fails. There's no weak point back here. It's literally
going to pull through the metal. We are learning a lot of other things other than just about these
bolts. Quick links will break around 60 kilonewtons, but you're not going to open them if
you take it up to 20. And so that really wasn't the right tool to be using. And soft shackles,
I love soft shackles, and they're in theory strong, but you'll see soon those started to
break. So the next test we did were these eight millimeter big boys, and they're rated for 79
kilonewtons. That's a lot. What is that in English? 17,759 freedom units. Did we get 79
kilonewtons? Well, no, is the short answer. Let's talk about that. We were actually,
because this is the strongest bolt, we're curious about different glue types. So when we started
testing these, we actually had Liquid Rock 500, which is an epoxy, AC 100, which is a polyester?
Vinyl ester. Vinyl ester. And we had Simpson XP, which is also an epoxy. And we're more or less
shit testing the glues, but we learned a lot about these. And that's what we're focused on right now.
When we did the tension test again with Liquid Rock 500, with the big ones, just like the six
millimeter ones, it was pulling out. It would damage the concrete a bit, but then it would start
to spin out of the hole. And we were getting between 45 to almost 52 kilonewtons when it
would disengage, which is a little bit more than we were getting with the six millimeters, more
contact surface area. We did those same tests with AC 100, which is generally considered to be a
bit weaker, but still super good enough for most things. And we got a wide range,
42 kilonewtons all the way up to 64 kilonewtons. A wide range on what, Bobby? Not the bolt.
On our soft shackles. We learned about soft shackles and how good AC 100 can be,
especially when pulling in shear. So we were struggling on how to break these because they
were in the driveway still. A note about breaking these bolts is we put in this glue the day before
and it was summertime, it was warm out. So the glue's cured, but we have to predetermine what
we're going to break. And usually you find out information as you go and that steers what you're
going to do next. We just put all these in and had to come back the next day and break. So we had
Simpson XP. We also tested in shear because we had basically four of these. The two that we did in
Simpson XP, the bolt failed. We got the bolt to finally fail at 54.60. The other one broke at
57.96, broke our soft shackle. So test 54 went higher, but we couldn't break the bolt. We had
Helty V3 500 that we wanted to test, which is one of the nicer glues out there. It's that red one.
And in tension, it was disengaging from the bolt at 41 to 44 kilonewtons,
which is a little bit less than we got on Liquid Rock 500. Oh yeah, consistently. Liquid Rock 500
is cheaper. Will work with a normal caulk gun instead of the fancy gun that you need for the
Helty V3 500. So in the granite, we were curious. We tested a dirty hole. We're going to be pulling
in shear with a big bolt with great glue, good rock, but we're not going to clean the hole. So
what we did, we just drilled it, pulled the drill bit out, no brushing, no blowing, nothing,
squirted the glue in, put the bolt in. Which is taboo. You're supposed to clean the hole
so the glue can adhere to the side of the rock. We just wanted to see what would happen.
Everything we connected to it failed. What else is there to say about that?
We broke like $200 worth of gear trying to get those three bolts to break.
Pretty frustrating. But something to note is we did get up to 67, 68 technically,
kilonewtons and all the way down to 50 of where the range of our stuff was breaking.
So it was breaking higher than the one that we did actually get to break up to this point in
our story of 55 kilonewtons. It's a big range. It's not just like a carabiner's usually consistent
in when it breaks. But all of those numbers are massively overkill for climbing.
Or any sport. This is a chain shackle. It's U-shaped with a bolt going through it. And
this doesn't deform like a quick link at the forces that we're taking it. And that's really
nice to know since we were going to test all of these in sandstone and I really didn't want the
same thing to happen when we were in the granite. Sandstone is a softer rock. And that is really
nice to know if these longer gluing bolts are going to perform really well in softer rocks
since that's where they shine. You can use a wedge bolt in hard rock, but well, you'll have
to see the video on how those did in sandstone as well. But when you're using a big bolt in a long,
deep 150 millimeter hole, you're not doing it for the strength of the bolt in this case,
you're doing it in order to get more contact area around the rock and you're able to hold
more rock. Because you can see that when we pulled these in tension, the 100 millimeter ones,
that it was sort of disengaging from the glue, but it was mostly a rock failure,
still around that 42 or 46 kilonewton range with the Hilti V3 500 that we used. No, yeah, no,
it twisted twice. It went pop, pop, and then broke all the rock. And then the rock just totally
fell down. Wow. So it was a combination between this getting disengaged from the glue or epoxy
and the rock failing. But you can see that the rock will fail. And you can see that it spreads
out over quite an area. So that's why you don't put them right next to each other. You have them,
well, the bigger they are, the longer they are, the more you're going to want to spread them out.
If your bolts are too far apart, then it kind of makes it weird to build an anchor because then
your angle's really big or you have to make it really long. And sometimes there's a stance there
that you actually want to be on. We also tested these in shear and we were able to get the bolt
to fail, which is nice to know that only the hundred millimeter was necessary in this wind
gate sandstone in Moab. There's a lot of different kinds of sandstones out there. There's a lot of
different kinds of sandstones just in Moab and Zion has a softer sandstone. It's going to perform
differently there. This is just nice to see in one area, what's happening at some crazy high forces.
The first one we tested, we did get 70, almost 72 kilonewtons, not quite 79, but it is still
pretty damn high. The next two were quite different. 58 and 66. It's quite a range.
Oftentimes when we test metal products, we're typically able to get a really consistent
result than a small narrow of window. It's soft goods that I usually get this big of a range.
I'm not a metallurgist, but from what I understand talking to people that know way more than I do,
a lot of it has to do with the speed that you're pulling, especially when you get into higher
forces. And if you let it rest and there's work hardening involved, but if you know more,
tell us in the comments below. Yeah, let's make the comments a super useful
part of this video for anybody who wants to get into the weeds can read through those.
Now, how I believe no one's just making numbers up. There's a reason there's an NBS number,
right? So boltproducts.com has 79 kilonewtons on these and Gemtech can get those numbers.
We're not pulling it the same way he's pulling it. I don't know what size shackle he's using.
Go with anything smaller or bigger. I don't know. But how I believe he might be able to get that
is pull it really hard, eight kilonewtons, maybe over and over maybe eight times and then slowly
pulling it. So actually that'd be that way, but how you pull this will generate different results.
But what's interesting to me is how different my results are pulling at the same speed from zero
to ultimate failure. I don't know. None of those numbers matter because they're twice as strong
as the carabiner. So much higher than anything else in the system. Oh, we have a video of Bobby
installing these top down bolting where he repelled and installed these and that was in volcanic
Russia five or six years ago before I knew Ryan. And before we'd done all these tests,
I wanted to make sure I had a good bolt. So I bought these after I did the test,
after I bought in 300 of them, I realized, whoa, these are definitely overkill for how good my
rock is. Uh, so now I use these, but in the anchors in that video, um, I'm still using
these cause I have a lot of them. So with two of them, you have a hundred to 150 kilonewton anchor.
If you go climb on those, you can equalize it with a span set. I also tested these longer ones,
150 millimeter intention and twisted out of the rocket 53, 49 and 54 kilonewtons. So we did get a
higher result with the longer bolt. I couldn't pull them fully, fully out. They were disengaged
from the rock, but, uh, yeah, I only have like that much stroke in that tension set up. We have
what happens if the sandstone's wet and that is a big concern. Uh, you shouldn't be climbing
sandstone if it's freshly been raining because you could damage the features.
That's in the Southwest. There are many areas with harder sandstone, like such as the Southeast where
it's generally not a problem. Yeah. So be mindful of that. And disclaimers, we tested wet sandstone
because I tested these in Waco's where I could pour the water and let it sit for
one to two days, put the healthy V3 500 and the night before on a 30 degree night, like I was kind
of crunching to get this thing done. And, uh, the numbers are pretty impressive. The shorter
hundred millimeter bolts in wet sandstone, the bolt failed on one of them at 68 kilonewtons.
And then the other one pulled out at 64, the longer 150 millimeter bolts also broke at 68
kilonewtons and then at 65, but it did not pull out. So our lowest result was 54 when we got the
bolt to actually break on these eight millimeters and the highest was 72 and a whole bunch of 60s.
Super good enough. It's not 79 though. It's funny.
