Copenhagen: For forests, a deal almost done

nature video
11 followers
Sep 5, 2023
A global deal on protecting forests is likely to be one of the triumphs of the Copenhagen climate talks. Nature's Olive Heffernan gets the inside story from Paraguay's chief negotiator on how close we are to sealing a deal to reduce deforestation.
On the last day in Denmark, the UN gave to me
Pathetic little targets, no demand-side measures
Ecosystems crashing, farm oil aflowing
Emissions are leaking, no indigenous price
Well here in Copenhagen it's the final day of negotiations
But behind closed doors, negotiators are still struggling to work out the details of a climate deal
A deal on forestry looks much closer however
Known as REDD for reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation
This could be the most successful outcome of the Copenhagen climate talks
If it is passed, it will provide a financial means for nations to protect their forests rather than destroying them
REDD is a huge issue here, deforestation accounts for up to 20% of world emissions
So designing a system that addresses that is really the low-hanging fruit here
It's something that has to be done in Copenhagen
That was Sinanda Cray, a journalist who this week received an Earth Journalism Award here in Copenhagen
For her expose of disturbing practices among those receiving money to protect forests in Papua New Guinea
Ensuring that the money ends up in the right hands is one of the most challenging aspects of REDD
Another really contentious issue is how to preserve the rights of indigenous peoples who live in forests and who want to remain there
Arguably the biggest issue for REDD though is ensuring that the carbon actually stays locked up in the forest
And that means that governments will have to be honest about the extent to which they're logging and burning trees
And that might be a big ask
I think the lesson is that without accountability and transparency, this system won't work
It won't work for the indigenous people who live in the forest
It won't work for the carbon traders, it won't work for the carbon market
And it certainly won't work for the forest
So I think it's really important for the leaders who are here this week to ensure that they come up with a REDD system
That works for everybody and doesn't just benefit a select few
So that's exactly what negotiators here in Copenhagen are trying to do
Working late into the night to try to hammer out a deal on forestry
Today I met up with Chief Negotiator for Paraguay to find out just how close we are to reaching agreement on REDD
Yes, we're very close
We just need ministers to erase one of the few remaining brackets and we'll have a deal
You mentioned that there are some areas still in brackets which means they're unresolved
Can you tell us what those issues are exactly?
Yes, as usual, money of course, funding, who's going to pay for this and how much
And actually what's going to be the role of recipient countries is not really clearly defined
Of course we have to protect the forest in our territory
But there are many other details like monitoring, evaluation and reporting of the actions to stop deforestation
So that's all in brackets and we'll need our ministers to really put the best political will to get rid of them
Some of the NGOs here were concerned that the final REDD deal may not actually protect natural forests
But would protect forests more generally
Can you clarify what the overall goal of the REDD deal will be?
Well, we have safeguards against the conversion of natural forests
But we still have REDD, especially REDD+, as it's being called now
Has the potential of promoting monoculture tree plantations
Because of the dubious definitions used by this convention
So we still have that problem
You mentioned financing earlier, a couple of days ago there was an announcement
That 3.5 billion would be put forward over the next three years to kickstart REDD financing
Does that fall very short of the mark of what's needed?
What's really needed in terms of financing and how close are we to getting that?
It's very difficult to put a number because forests are not just carbon
Forests are an incredible wealth of different values
So it's very difficult, that's a very tricky territory
We of course think that we need much more than that
In the order of about 10-15 times more just to get started
But to hazard a guess you're saying maybe 30 billion a year
Is that the sort of financing we're talking about?
Well yes, that's getting closer, much closer
So you mentioned the importance of forests
Can you tell us a bit about how important forests are in Paraguay
And why you're so keen to protect them?
Paraguay used to have very exuberant and lush subtropical forests
From the almost 9 million hectares we used to have 50 years ago
We have scattered patches adding up to about 700,000 hectares now
So that's tremendous loss
So if we don't see an overall climate deal agreed here in the next couple of days
Where does that leave the REDD deal?
Do we need an overall agreement from COP15 for REDD to get kickstarted?
The agreement here is not going to be enough, we know that
But the national processes will not get started without an agreement at this level
So we do need the highest level of political commitment to back the REDD efforts
So I hear that you were up late last night negotiating
Can you tell us a bit about that?
Has it been a long haul and do you think it's over just quite yet?
Or do you expect another all-nighter this evening?
As you can see from my face, yes, we were really until very early this morning
In the negotiating room until about 4.30
That's late enough and it's the second time in a row
Or actually the third
So we haven't been sleeping that much
We have to be prepared for tonight as well
Because we want a very substantial, very meaningful deal out of Copenhagen
We just don't want any type of deal
We want to work extremely hard to get the best we can get from this process
We're still waiting to get the final word on REDD
Today is the official deadline by which world leaders must agree to a climate deal here in Copenhagen
But talking to anyone here, it seems that that might be postponed by a day or two
Once that happens, we'll be back with a video giving an assessment of what's been agreed here at COP15
In the meantime, I'm off to do some star-spotting now that Obama's arrived
On the last day in Denmark, the UN gave to me
Pathetic little targets, no demand-side measures
Ecosystems crashing, palm oil aflowing
Emissions are leaping, no indigenous rights
Feedlands are draining, endangered species
Forests converted, crap and money
Too much fossil fuels, tree shade, so no springs attached
And a big fat logging subsidy
