An isolated plateau in the highlands of southeastern Uzbekistan in Central Asia, looks like an expanse of rolling hills. But look closer and a shard of pottery or the stony remnant of an ancient wall might hint at an archaeological secret hidden for hundreds of years.
Now a team of archaeologists have used drone-mounted LiDAR to virtually peel back the layers of sediment and vegetation. Revealing two ancient cities, much larger than previously imagined, built 2,000 metres above sea level.
The finding of these urban centres, called Tashbulak and Tugunbulak, at such high altitudes, may mean that highland areas may have played a more important role in medieval trade than previously thought.
This plateau in the highlands of southeastern Uzbekistan
has held a secret for hundreds of years.
There were some inklings in historical records.
9th century Arabic sources talk about cities in the region.
Nobody thought there would be such a large settlement of medieval period
located in such an island area.
Now, laser imaging has peeled back the surface
to reveal an unprecedented discovery.
What we can see is in very, very great detail,
all the constructions.
It gives us literally a roadmap.
We have realised how dense was the build-up of the area.
The history of Central Asia is changing with this finding.
In 2011 and 2015, archaeologists working in Uzbekistan
in the mountainous nexus of Central Asia's historic Silk Road
discovered two ancient settlements,
Tashbulak and Tuganbulak.
These sites are located between 2,000 and 2,200 metres above sea level.
Even today, only 3% of the world's population live above this altitude.
But nomadic peoples had inhabited the area since the late Bronze Age
and later perhaps settled to these mountain plateaus
as they looked to secure economic and political power in the region.
This elevation of 2,000 metres above sea level is six months of winter.
Nothing grows over there.
That's why archaeologists never went there.
Today, these regions are almost completely unoccupied
in terms of permanent occupation.
We actually first arrived there on donkeys.
We rode donkeys up the mountainside.
We get snow in the summertime.
We get really serious wind and storms.
We've had very serious logistical challenges.
It's all covered with thick sedimentation of soils and grass.
If you look with your eyes, visually,
you can only spot several lines of ancient walls which were decayed and destroyed.
That's why we needed to use either geophysical instruments
or LIDAR attached to drone.
LIDAR, or Light Detection and Ranging,
is a technique which uses laser pulses to map the precise topography of an area.
Archaeologists can use it to virtually peel back vegetation and sediment
to reveal what's underneath.
In this case, what the team found surprised even them.
We thought the site maybe was 25 hectares.
25 hectares was already almost double the size of most known cities
or most known settlements in the high mountains of this region.
That's because of what we could see in terms of major mountains,
major fortified or structural elements.
You'd say, there's one, there's one, there's one.
Draw a circle around them and that makes about 25 to 30 hectares.
What the LIDAR began to show us and be able to illustrate in very clear detail
was that this basin, this high altitude basin,
is contained by architectural features,
walls, towers, guard towers, fortifications,
all sorts of other built elements that enclose
what we believe to be at least 120 hectares.
That's on the order of 10 times the number of any known site
that we're aware of in the region.
The team may not have expected a finding on the scale of Tugan Balak,
but historical records did hold some clues
that there was something to find in the mountains.
There are a few Arabic sources which talk about places
in the region where we're located.
Some of them describe huge cities, the roads, the gardens,
how people lived at that time.
In this area, which is called Ustrushana, the land of Ustrushana,
they say in the mountains of Ustrushana there is a place called Marsmand.
This is a place where the water freezes in the winter
and where there's a large market, a mosque,
this is now the Arabic period, a mosque,
and where they trade and sell some of the best iron and steel known in the region.
People have been trying to locate precisely the city of Marsmand
for many, many decades.
And even now, we can't really say we found it,
but what we can say is that there were sources
that led us to think that there might be more
in these mountains than had been previously known.
A question that remains is what happened to cause these sites to collapse?
One idea the team have is that the iron production
that made these locations so attractive
may also have contributed to their downfall.
Whoever had iron in their hands in medieval times was very powerful
because having technology, having the sources of iron
was a very strategic for that period.
We know that they were developing a metallurgical industry
and that industry requires resources.
It requires both ore as well as resources to make the ore.
So you have to burn something in the kilns.
They had started cutting down the trees.
This area used to be covered by thick juniper forest,
but they cut all of the trees for making iron
because this is the only fuel at that time.
So they cut the trees, but when they cut the trees,
the area became environmentally very unstable
They cut down a lot of trees
and there may just simply have been a tipping point
at which those resources could not be in balance
and the marketplace just fell apart.
So that's a speculation still.
We have a lot of work to be done to demonstrate that,
but we think that the ultimate failure
is a combination of environmental resource availability,
political structure, you know,
what was happening during the time when all this was going on.
There's lots of political and social conditions
that were also simultaneous.
So you get this kind of trifecta or more of factors
that I think shaped the ultimate unsustainability
of the last stage of the occupation of the cities.
There is still work to be done,
but the scale of these findings could suggest
that these mountainous regions
are more historically significant than previously thought,
positioning them centrally in the culture
and politics of the time.
This area was central in its own way.
We cannot ignore the significance of nomadic tribes,
nomadic polities, nomadic political bodies,
which were at that time occupying
very important strategic spots
and dragging the roads towards them,
dragging the caravans,
dragging all of the people who were ignoring previously
LIDAR has provided a map both for this work
and for archaeologists worldwide
to challenge ideas about living at high altitude.
You know, we know that populations live in mountains.
We have communities in the Andes,
we have communities known in the Himalayas,
but there's a lot of mountain areas
that are just simply seen as wild territories
or areas that are only used for resource extraction.
Here what we see is a community investing in this mountain zone
and in a sense, taking ownership of it,
building a city for quite a long time.
In fact, what we're seeing now is that mobile populations,
nomadic communities, various social organizations
can have the complexity to maintain major urban centers
in places that even today would be quite hard to live in.
I mean, if you were to ask your average individual
to go up there and figure out how to live
over a couple hundred years,
they'd have a hard time innovating that city.