The Orion Nebula, Part Deux

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
Sep 5, 2023
The Orion Nebula, Part Deux
Hello, Hubble huggers. We are still waiting for people to show up, but I wanted to go ahead and get started
because it is way past time for us to start and I didn't want to keep people waiting.
So, my name is Tony Darnell. I'm with the Space Telescope Science Institute.
I'm the Social Media Manager here and we are, all this week, we are having something called,
the Institute is holding something called an Orion Nebula Workshop
and basically what they are trying to do is highlight some of the most recent research that is being done
in the Orion Nebula and today is our second of two Hangouts that we are going to have on this.
Now, yesterday we had some of the workshop participants in there with Massimo Roberto,
one of the astronomers who is chairing the workshop and I have, he is probably, I imagine,
having some technical difficulties because last time he joined straight from the conference room,
which was right outside one of the venues there. So, hopefully he'll be joining us soon.
I'll be checking my email to make sure that he's going to be able to join us here pretty soon too.
And usually, who is also with me here is Scott Lewis, but he apparently moved to Somalia
because he doesn't have any power. That guy is always running out of power.
Every time I call, I got to go to the office in the astronomy department or something
because he doesn't have any electricity or his internet is out or something like that.
So, I think he lives in California, but I can't be sure based on the reliability of his infrastructure.
The biggest city in the country? I don't know.
Yeah, I don't know either. So, anyway, he should be joining us shortly, I hope.
He's getting set up somewhere and he'll be able to participate at some point.
Also with me today is Michael Phillips. He was here yesterday. Hi, Michael.
Hey.
Hi. He's an amateur astrophotographer who has taken quite a few images of the Orion Nebula
and we showed some of them yesterday and he was also showing me some of his right now
and we're going to show you some of them as well after I do a little summary
and introduce Dr. Ian O'Neill. Hello, Ian.
Hi, there, Tony. How are you doing?
I'm good, thank you. Thanks for joining us.
He is the commander-in-chief over Discovery News, right?
Of the space section, yeah.
Of the space section.
I'd love to own it all, but I can't.
Well, it's the only one worth it anyway, right? It's the only one worth it.
Yeah, you know the deal.
Anyway, thanks for joining us.
My pleasure.
Yeah, it's a real treat.
So I was just telling people right when you were joining that all this week at the Institute,
the Space Telescope Science Institute, we're having this Orion Nebula workshop
and one of the things I'm experimenting with here as my new job here with social media at the Institute
is I want to try and get some of these workshops and some of the science,
some of the talks that we're doing at the Institute out to the general public.
So this is the first one I've tried this year.
The workshop's going on from Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday.
It ends tomorrow, but tomorrow we won't have a hangout based on that
because there's just too many other things going on.
And Roberto and I or Massimo and I had talked about getting some astronomers together
to talk about their latest research and we did that yesterday.
I don't know where he is today.
I hope he may not make it.
I don't know.
I'm still waiting.
I'm still checking my email furiously to see.
I sent him the link to the hangout.
Oh, here we go.
Running late.
Should be on in five minutes, he says.
Okay, good.
I hope they didn't lose power too.
I hope.
No, things are fine here.
Well, Baltimore tends to do pretty well.
So yesterday we learned, just again to sort of summarize what happened yesterday
for those of you who couldn't watch the hangout, although you can go watch it on YouTube,
there was a lot of really cool things.
We had Dr. Lynn Hildebrandt on here and she taught us a lot about,
she was really interested in stellar distributions of what's going on in the Orion Nebula.
And I guess the thing that I came away with the most yesterday was this sort of amazement
that with something so familiar in our night sky like the Orion Nebula,
we are still out there actively studying it and learning new things about it even today.
The Hubble Space Telescope actually spends a lot of time observing the Orion Nebula.
I didn't know that.
Another thing I learned yesterday was that Massimo said that there was a sort of a,
I keep wanting to use the word bias, but that's not what I mean.
There's a predisposition of stars that sort of stop,
most of the stars in the Orion Nebula that get formed are right about the same size
as when a stellar fusion first starts.
And then they stop.
They don't get any bigger, which I found was a pretty interesting statistic.
I mean most of the stars that form in that complex tend to get to the stage
where they just ignite stellar fusion and that's as big as they get.
That's the masses of most of the stars.
And of course there's a lot of blue giants and giant stars there as well as brown dwarfs,
a whole distribution of those as well.
But I thought that was a pretty interesting thing that I did not know before.
And finally, the sort of the, I don't know, maybe I should have known this,
and this is probably one of the things I should have known,
but Massimo was also saying yesterday that most of the stars in the constellation Orion,
that's not just the nebula complex but the entire constellation,
most of those stars are about the same distance away.
They're kind of in a plane.
Do you guys remember that Cosmos episode where Carl Sagan showed the Big Dipper
and then we kind of went around the Big Dipper in some big circle?
And then we could see when we got like 90 degrees away from the Big Dipper,
you could see that it didn't look like the Big Dipper anymore.
It looked like something completely different.
Do you guys remember that episode?
Yeah, and there was some cool 3D graphics with it you kind of felt.
Yeah, 70s style.
Yeah, I remember that, a nice 70s style computer graphics.
Well, that was a good illustration.
It was the first time I had ever learned that the stars in the constellation
weren't in the nice little flat plane that they look like they are to us.
Some are really close, some are very far away.
Well, the Orion nebula more or less is in a plane.
The stars make up the Orion constellation, I mean.
So that was something I guess I should have known but I didn't.
They're more or less in the same plane.
So it looks like Massimo is with us.
Let me get him in.
Hi, Massimo.
Can you hear me?
Hi.
So thanks for joining us.
I was getting a little worried.
We are cooked, I tell you.
This was a very long day.
Oh, really?
They could not stop asking questions,
and the chair of the sessions were trying to stop, stop, stop.
It's a fascinating conference, and this is the price to pay.
Yeah, and that's why you do that, right?
That's why you all get together.
But at 6 p.m.
So can you give us a summary of what some of the highlights were today?
What were some of the highlights?
Today, you know, yesterday we touched basically the Orion nebula cluster,
so what we see inside the nebula.
This evening, this day, we went basically in two directions.
One, we considered the nebula but under the point of view of
as seen basically by different instruments at different wavelengths.
So we talked about X-ray emission and infrared emission,
and this has been very fascinating because this space satellite
has done a fantastic job, and basically what they have discovered is that
it's much more, you know, when you're not too much, it's sort of bad
because you cannot do any more of these easy models,
not the spherical cows, as they say, the astrophysicists do,
the astronomers do.
So it's very complicated, and the point that scared me a lot is the fact
that the variability seems to play a critical role.
We have these thousands of stars in the Orion nebula that are forming.
We would like to study them to understand one by one their mass,
their luminosity, their age, their accretion, if they're still growing,
when they will start burning hydrogen.
So you take these pictures with the Hubble, with the Benz instrument,
then you return after two weeks, after eight days, after two years,
they're completely different because they're variables,
because everything is changing, and sometimes it's regular,
so there is an oscillation, we call them periodic variables,
other times it's just sort of chaotic.
And of course to learn, to study this, you need a lot of patience,
you need time with these telescopes, which is expensive,
you have to convince the committees to award you the time,
it's hard stuff, it's complicated and it's hard.
That's a good point, I mean a lot of people are clamoring
to use the Hubble Space Telescope,
so to make the case that you keep wanting to look at the same things
over and over again can be difficult, I'm sure.
Absolutely, the Hubble and the Chandra for the X-rays, Spitzer,
Spitzer is dead, so now we don't have any more Spitzer.
Herschel is also run out.
So all these satellites have a limited lifetime,
and actually I tell you, a lot of work can be done
by amateur astronomers here, because you really see,
even at optical wavelengths, which are the basic ones
that we consider the first, the easy ones,
you can do this from the ground.
We have this long-term monitoring program of Orion,
not only the Nebula, but the entire Orion constellation basically.
And there are these huge gaps, because even the observatories
that try to do three weeks, then there is day and night.
There are the clouds, there is the bad weather.
So a network around the Earth of 3, 4, 5, 6 centers
that decide to spend time and to go night after night
on certain selected regions, that would be fantastic for us,
and we really miss this long-term monitoring.
So you could get a good handle on this variability
just in optical, the infrared variability,
just based on the optical wavelengths.
Yeah, but what is interesting is that they have shown today
that when you do a comparison, so there have been campaigns
done with the infrared and the optical, maybe even from space.
So the real, true, far infrared.
And you see in the infrared this nice periodicity,
and in the optical, maybe tracks, and you go to another star
just next door, and that's completely uncorrelated.
They basically don't talk each other.
We don't know why.
So it's a zoo.
Are there any resources available that amateurs can go to
to see what kind of data you guys need?
You said amateurs can be helpful.
How can they find that out?
Is there a place they can go?
So I'm not an expert here, I must tell you.
I have colleagues that work much more with amateurs,
and it would be an interesting conversation to have
if we can have a wide range of people.
I know that there is this Association of Variable Star Observatory,
Observers, A-A-V-S-O, I think.
I know that they have a fantastic web page.
And I know too little about that to throw here ideas,
but I would imagine that we could have a brainstorming at some point.
Yeah, you're giving me ideas.
A team of hardcore people that decide to monitor selected targets.
Of course, you cannot do this by eye.
You need the CCD, you need a decent place,
and the energy and the time to stay up a few hours.
We have a robotic telescope.
I know little about that.
Most professionals don't.
They just go to the telescope where they get their data.
I tell you, after a day like this, it's exactly what we need,
at least for the optical, starting with the optical.
And then if you find a billionaire that does this with an infrared telescope,
or from space, if Bill Gates wants to do it.
That's a real billionaire there.
Let's go get in touch with our billionaire friends, Tony.
Okay, man in the shadows.
Actually, it's just so bright outside.
Oh, I thought you were still talking from a hand-turning crank generator or something.
It's true, yeah.
Go ahead.
No, I'm late.
So Scott's late joining us because he's transmitting from Somalia or someplace like that.
He doesn't have any power.
So guys, go ahead and jump in.
Ian, I want to invite you, if you have any questions, please.
By the way, let me introduce who this is.
This is Dr. Massimo Roberto.
He is the chair of the workshop that's being held this week,
and he's an expert in the Ryan Nebula and star-forming regions and things like that.
So by all means, if you guys can think of anything, go ahead.
Michael, you acted like you wanted to say something a while ago.
Did I cut you off?
No, I fully agree with the amateur-professional collaboration.
I was telling Tony before, I'm very involved in a lot of planetary stuff,
and I know there's a lot of sharing between the professionals and the amateurs,
and I, too, would be interested to hear more about the variable star observing programs and things like that.
Yeah, AAV has a lot of really good things going on.
I know one of our astronomers, Peter Lake, from the Virtual Star Party, is really involved in it.
We've done some photometry data live in a hangout on air like this before.
We did a transit of an exoplanet live in a hangout,
and he was able to show the light curves.
It was beautiful.
So there's a lot that the amateurs are able to do to collaborate worldwide,
because he's out of Australia.
So there's a lot that's able to be done.
So the Orion Nebula is the richest region within 2 kiloparsecs, 6,000 light-years from the sun.
So it's a pretty decent area, and this is the place where you should look at,
because it's very dense.
There are many young stars.
We still have to discover a planet around one of these stars.
It must be there, a transiting planet that has never been seen,
and it would be very, very interesting,
because it would be not a planet around a star which is all the same age of the sun.
It would be a forming planet.
So if we could just discover it, then we could go with the Hubble, with everything.
We could see the atmosphere.
We could learn a lot, but still we don't know where to look at.
What about an accretion disk?
Excuse me?
Go ahead, Ian.
I was just going to ask, how many stars?
What's the standard population in the Orion Nebula?
So in the Orion Nebula, the entire constellation, basically, is north-south.
There is this monster filament.
Actually, it's even more complex.
The Orion Nebula is like the hotspot of the region.
So the Orion Nebula hosts like 2,000, 3,000 stars.
It depends.
If you go in the infrared, you can see stars that are not visible wavelengths.
Let's say 3,000 stars overall.
It's about one million years old.
One, two, we discussed.
It's very hard to say.
When they are too young, it's hard to be accurate,
because they are not born on the same day,
so they are scattered around, and they are variable.
But they are young, one, two million years.
So all these stars, most of the stars, 80%, more or less,
have still their circumstellar disks,
which is the last remnants of their forming cocoon.
And within the disks, they are forming, possibly, we think,
is where they form planets.
Our solar system forms within a disk.
We are on a plane.
The ecliptic plane is just the leftover fossil of the original disk.
In Orion, with the Hubble, we see disks around stars,
not around every star, because maybe these disks are too small.
But we have about, I don't know, 100 disks that we can really detect, resolve.
But we think that almost every star has a disk.
And in these stars, planets must form.
We also see stars where this disk starts to be gone.
This is not really the Orion Nebula, which is a little bit too young.
One million years, the disks are still there.
But if we look a little bit around Orion, but still in the constellation,
there are other associations.
We call the cluster is dense.
But when they start spreading, they get older, 4, 5, 10 million years.
The disks are gone.
The planets are still forming there, are still, you know, collapsing, condensing.
They go around the star.
We are still to discover the first one.
But they are there, because all these stars had the disks last week.
A few million years ago, the disks were there.
They are just gone.
And these stars are variable.
They are sort of easy to find because of this crazy activity.
It's a goldmine for us.
It's almost like a Petri dish.
It's almost like a Petri dish of science, you know.
It's a Petri dish of science.
Of course, the variability of the star adds confusion
if you want to study the passage of a planet,
because you have to find this little occultation in front of the mess.
So it takes time.
It takes quality of the data.
It takes patience.
It takes luck.
But the astronomers, it's so hard to point the telescope in a certain region
and spend several nights.
You can do – maybe they give you a week.
But, you know, the long-term monitoring that you need has to be done.
I was going to use the word –
Oh, go ahead.
I was going to use the word accretion disk, I think,
to maybe describe some of the things that the Hubble has actually seen and witnessed.
But it sounds as though – if that's the right term to use –
but it sounds as though you see some of those and then they go cold
and then they're gone or not observable.
Right.
So, yeah, accretion means that the disk is basically the entire idea
is that when you form a star because of gravity, right?
So if you have everything standing there fixed,
gravity will imagine a sphere with arrows that all point to the center.
So all particles will collapse to the center.
But if there is any tendency to rotate in this cloud,
together with the collapse to the center,
material will start to basically spiral down
because it goes down but also keeps going around.
So you see those things, though, right?
You actually have observables.
Yeah.
You see, you know, when you have molecular material,
you can see this type of – the spiral has never been seen so easily
because it's sort of a hard signal.
But we have clear evidence that the disk is basically the last phase of the accretion.
Basically, the star forms – all the material that has not a lot of angular momentum,
as we call it, goes straight to the center.
So heavier elements that you can observe,
so you get a compositional structure for these things, too?
At the beginning, yes.
So at the very beginning, we see the formation of the core,
and we see maybe the core elongated within a sort of an ellipsoid.
And then when the star gets hotter and hotter,
it starts to blow away the material,
and we can see it in the visible with the Hubble.
We see the star, the real photosphere.
And then around, we see this tiny disk of neutral, obscure material still hanging there.
And with a little bit of mass that is still falling on the star.
And this is what we call accretion.
So these disks are still accreting.
Eventually, the accretion stops.
And what happens is that actually when the accretion ends –
and we know that ends because there are certain phenomena that accretion produces,
H-alpha emission, ultraviolet excess.
We know how to measure accretion, actually.
It's a very cool measure that we can do.
But at some point, we don't see anymore these signs.
And then we understand that the disk is basically dissipated almost immediately.
So the lifetime of the disk is correlated to the time of accretion.
The disks either are accreting or they disappear soon.
When they disappear, the fossil, what remains, we believe, are planets.
And do you think those planets would –
if I'm remembering right from what we talked about yesterday,
didn't I hear you say that some of these disks are within a pixel of Hubble?
The pixel scale is such that it doesn't fully get resolved?
The solar system.
If you take the solar system, then basically you can say that the solar system
depends if you do radius or diameter,
if you take where it ends at some point, what is the solar system.
But where the planets are is basically within one or two pixels of the Hubble instruments.
So the region of planet formation to resolve a planet,
like a little point away from the star,
you will need a resolution, a special resolution,
which is higher than the one of the Hubble today.
You will see a planet more easily through the transit.
So if the planet, if you have 1,000 stars,
the chances are that there are a few of them where the planet is passing in front of the star and back.
So transits and eclipses are something that you should expect when you have enough statistics,
and especially it's easy if you get the planet close to the star.
So this is what you would like to get.
And then disentangling that though,
that sort of transit variability for the planet moving in front of the star's light,
you've still got to disentangle it with this other variability you said you were worried about at the beginning, right?
Yes, yes, absolutely.
So now you've got to somehow figure it out.
Absolutely.
I mean, if you have enough signal to noise, if you have good measure,
there are ways to disentangle this.
For example, a planet typically, and we may discuss as much as is true,
but the planet is like a black disk.
And the black disk eats light at all wavelengths in the same way.
It's like a screen.
If you have spots, if you have dust, then there is a modulation
because a cloud tends to be transparent in the infrared and more opaque in the optical.
So the effect of clouds or hot spots or cold spots tends to be,
when you have multicolor observation, tends to be different.
What would be nice is just to see a sign and then we may go with better instruments.
The professional will go and say, ah, this is where we have to go.
The fact is that we don't really know where to go.
That's the search that is.
Is it possible, do you think, that any ground-based telescopes,
I doubt it, if resolution is such an issue,
would be able to help much with finding or resolving any of these planets?
So, as I said, the eclipse is easy because you just measure light.
So what you need is a good CCD camera, a clear night.
And actually it's sort of easy because when you take a picture,
you take a picture of hundreds of stars.
So it's easy to measure if one is blinking versus all the others.
You subtract one image from the next one, five minutes after five minutes,
and you see immediately if there is any residual that pops up.
So the transit, the variation in luminosity of the star is doable, is done actually.
The direct resolution of a planet close to the star
as a tiny point next to a very bright star,
that's, I would say, beyond the reach not only of amateurs,
but of professional astronomers today in Orion.
Because we do this, but much closer.
Orion is 450 parsec.
And in this type of business, it means far away.
Right. Well, I guess what worries me though is that, you know,
you'll see these transits or these variable brightnesses from the stars,
but just because you can't resolve anything,
you just don't know really what causes.
Because, as you said, there's already this variability in the star to begin with.
You know, but if you know where to look, for example, the Hubble,
I don't know if our friends know this.
Think about this.
You can have a planet that passes in front of the star.
The planet has a little atmosphere around.
So the passage of the planet has this atmosphere that is, for example,
rich in sodium.
So this atmosphere may selectively decide to absorb this line of sodium.
So when the planet passes, the entire spectrum goes down,
but the part where there is the sodium goes a little bit more down
because there is an extra absorption, which is the atmosphere.
It's like the planet in that line is a little bit larger.
This has been done.
So with the Hubble, we have been able to measure, in certain cases,
the chemical composition of the planets around other stars.
This is Star Wars. This is science fiction.
Think about that.
Think of the atmospheres of planets around other stars.
It's fantastic.
Oh, wow. This is really great, Massimo.
If the amateur astronomers tell us,
we suspect that there is a planet there, we look at it.
It's sad that we don't know where to look today.
Well, you've given me a great idea today with this.
I want to provide some resources to let amateurs know
what kind of observations they could make to directly support your work.
And I think this would be something we'd get a lot of interest in.
So I'm hoping, you know, I'm going to have to think about this some more.
No, I think Peter McCullough here at the Institute is actually working on this.
And he has two or three amateur astronomers that help him.
And they have some results.
They have discoveries.
But he's not observing Orion.
So that's why I'm trying to give you more information.
Okay. Well, we'll see about getting you some support for this too.
So you're saying that long-term observation is what's really needed right now.
Something on the order of a campaign or synoptical data
that we could see over many weeks and months.
If you ask me what came out today,
I would say this was one of the main points of the day, clearly.
The need for long-term monitoring to understand what's going on.
Not only for the planets, but really for the status of the stars.
Okay. Well, let me get some of these other guys in here.
Go ahead, Ian.
Yeah, I just have a quick question, actually.
You're mentioning we need to have more focus on this region of the sky.
Could the upcoming transiting exoplanet survey satellite,
the test satellite that's going to be searching basically Kepler upgraded,
would that be able to perhaps slew to that area of the sky and perhaps do a survey?
It could, but I don't know what they are planning.
Sure.
I know about Kepler.
Kepler wanted to find planets.
And if you want to find planets,
you want to point a region of the sky where you have a zillion of stars.
And you don't want to see variability.
You want just to have numbers and find a lot of them.
The case of Orion, it's not the easiest place to go.
So I don't know if you want to take a mission of that caliber and start with Orion.
Maybe they do three years somewhere else and then they decide let's go to a young region
and Orion would be an excellent place to go.
But I don't know and I suspect it's not the easiest place to go with the new mission.
I don't know what is their observing plan, their strategy.
Yeah, I suppose when it comes to the variable stars,
I don't know if you know this,
but how many variable stars have been observed with exoplanets?
Because as you say, Kepler isn't necessarily going to be looking at variable stars
because it's very difficult to distinguish whether there's a dimming due to the transiting exoplanet
or just variability in the star.
I don't actually know with these variable stars how many exoplanets have been discovered.
I mean, they can do some fancy tricks with computing and software
to actually distinguish whether there's a signature of an exoplanet,
but that strikes me as a hard job to do, as you say.
It's a hard job, but I tell you it's even more fascinating
if you think that the presence of exoplanets makes the star variable.
Because you have to think about the fact that the exoplanet,
when it is close to the star, going around the star shows you always a face.
It's like Venus around the Sun, seen from us, Venus, as a face.
So the exoplanet going around the Sun, around the other star,
actually introduces a modulation in the light curve.
Together with the eclipses, the primary and the secondary,
when it goes on the back and in front,
the exoplanet has the capability of modulating the light curve of the star.
I'm talking about big exoplanets and very close to the star,
so it's like a giant moon going around.
But we see this and actually seeing these different wavelengths in the infrared
is a formidable diagnostic power about, for example,
how much light the planet is reflecting.
Because if you study this modulation of the light
and you think there is a planet showing me a face,
then you try to model.
Can really a simple white screen do this?
No, actually the planet must have a sort of a structure.
Basically, I'm telling you, they start to model the weather around the exoplanets,
just studying how these curves oscillate in time.
More clouds, less clouds.
They do this in California.
We do a lot of things in California.
It's a problem, but it's even a product of the presence of the planet.
There was a Space Fan News story I did a couple of weeks ago
where they had mapped the clouds of one of the exoplanets.
They had found that one side had more clouds on it than another.
So you're right, they are starting to get weather information from these things too.
Which is phenomenal to think about.
I mean, we're looking at weather on exoplanets.
Well, there's more clouds on one side than another.
It's hardly weather, but I guess it is.
From a point to where we couldn't really even know
any sort of atmospheric information on the planets within our own solar system
to any great detail.
But now we're seeing things light years away from us.
That's amazing what we're able to do now.
I mean, you start seeing Mercator projection, the oval of the surface of the planet.
It's incredible.
And the stuff like what Michael is able to do from his backyard.
Imagine 100 years ago, you just walked in with your 14-inch, Michael.
If you just walked out, hey, look what I can do with my CCD and my tracking.
You'd be a wizard.
It's too big, I have to use wheels, but I don't want to.
You need what we call signal to noise.
You need photometry.
So space, and this is not the size of the telescope.
It's really the fact that the atmosphere starts to be a problem at some point.
So I'm talking about special observations,
either with Spitzer typically, and Hubble as well.
So maybe, I don't know, in 20 years it will be possible
because technology for the ground always lags a little bit behind,
but they're catching up.
But just finding where to look at with this big beast would be great.
When you're saying, Massimo, with the ground,
are you talking about the adaptive optics that are able to adjust
for the atmospheric perturbations?
You know, I'm not an expert in the sense that this is a hot point.
Adaptive optics do a monster job for creating beautiful images,
very crisp in the infrared in particular.
They have a harder time to, how to say, preserve the flux.
Because you measure the flux within a certain area, 3 pixels,
and you return and the atmosphere changes.
Adaptive optics can put in 3 pixels 60% of the light,
70% of the light, 50%, 20%, 90%, whatever.
Adaptive optics does the best, but it's hardly consistent
because it's fighting against the variability of atmosphere.
So if you get within your measure field a different amount of light
every minute or every second, it's very hard to get the signal
which is flat and see little dance.
You will always get noise.
Adaptive optics will always give you something that looks very sharp,
even better than Hubble.
But if you redo it, it will look very sharp, but not exactly the same.
For this type of measure, you want consistency.
Absolutely.
One of the things I do, I don't have any adaptive optics,
I'll say that first.
But one of the things that I do to take pictures of planets
to steady the seeing is this concept of lucky imaging
where you take as many frames as you can and you average them all out,
which tends to reduce a lot of the variability.
While it's not a complete picture like you're saying,
it does tend to flatten out some of those peaks and valleys
and you end up with an average of 55.2% and it's a measurable thing.
And it tends to be that specific pixel coordinate, let's say.
Absolutely.
Of course you eat your signal to noise because you spend one minute
and you have one second of exposure if you do.
So it's always a trade-off.
I tell you, like space, it's harder.
I mean there is nothing like the Hubble at the moment.
For this type of precision, for this type of work.
So let me ask you this then, Massimo.
What about the James Webb Space Telescope?
I was just about to ask that.
You beat me to it, Tony.
Well, that's my gratuitous…
I wanted to see, do you anticipate your research getting better with Webb?
So Webb is Hubble on steroids.
Yes.
No doubt.
So we're going to put an asterisk next to everything?
The only problem is that Webb is infrared.
And I say it's a problem because it will open a new window,
but we are going to lose another one.
We are going to lose the UV, the optical.
So as I was saying before, we see that the variability in the infrared
does not always correlate with the one in the visible.
You would like to have both.
Right.
Always.
And we may be lucky to have Hubble and Webb together for a few years.
That's what we hope.
Especially if Webb stays on schedule, as we hope.
If they don't, you know, in D.C. they don't do anything strange as we do.
But Webb is infrared.
Right.
So we need to hope that Hubble will stay there.
Well, good.
I guess we'll look forward to seeing what it can add at least.
Any other things you'd like to bring to our attention today
that struck you at the workshop?
Let me think.
I think this was basically, at the moment, this is the point that I remember.
I'm tired.
I mean, I can, everything comes up.
Okay.
Well, Massimo, I don't want to take up more of your time.
I know you're busy and you were gracious enough to take time out
to talk to us about this stuff.
This was awesome.
This was really great.
We really had a great meeting today.
And I'm hoping that maybe we could get together again sometime in the near future
and we'll sort of follow up on some of the things that we talked about.
Absolutely.
Let me remind that if you go to the website of the Space Telescope Science Institute,
you easily find the link to the conference.
If you open the page, you'll find the webcast,
which means that first, tomorrow, you can still follow the conference.
And in the future, everything is archived.
You can click on the talk on variability, for example, and hear the real stuff,
not my easy chat here.
But you can get the talk.
We like your easy chat.
And correct me because probably I missed something.
Well, no, that's a great point.
I'm glad you brought that up.
I have put a link to the workshop on this event page.
So you can go there and follow along.
All the talks are posted and you can watch them yourself and make your own comments.
Or get the information firsthand.
So Massimo, you're welcome to stay.
I thank you so much for joining us.
I think we're just going to kind of chat a little bit and kind of take some comments.
I don't see a whole lot of questions.
Did you see any, Scott?
I'm looking through them right now.
I'm not seeing a ton.
We did hit a lot yesterday, but I know we missed a couple yesterday,
so I'm trying to pull those up.
Okay.
Well, we still have Massimo.
Maybe we'll see what we got here.
Yeah, don't go anywhere, Massimo.
Okay.
You and your haircut, it's just looking too good.
We need to stay in the same hangout.
Actually, I got a guest here.
So if you have any.
Okay.
Nicola Dario, which is here, is the leading expert today of the stars in your Nebula cluster.
He has done the best measures, knows everything, really.
Not really.
I'm sorry.
I think I missed your name.
What's your name?
Nicola Dario.
He's Italian, was my student here, actually, and now he's at University of Florida.
Awesome.
So what are you thinking about the workshop today?
What are your insights?
Was there anything stuck out in your mind today?
Today, I think the major point that I liked about the workshop was this extension,
from the smaller Orion Nebula cluster to a larger complex in Orion
that could host different populations of different ages with different properties.
We heard quite a lot of talks about this, explore that whole wavelength,
investigating the properties of this complex in the larger scale.
What are some of the properties there?
For example, the fact that there were some talks focusing on the fact that
it seems that along this region called the Orion A filament that contains the ONC,
the Orion Nebula cluster, as a denser part, but the entire structure,
which is much larger, contains a looser, lower-density population,
that in total, since it is a larger structure, has a mass, total stellar mass,
comparable to that of the center of the Orion Nebula cluster.
And if we look in detail into this population and try to distinguish sources with disks
or sources without disks, it seems that they are not equally distributed,
but there are sub-clusters with sources that appear in an earlier stage of evolution
and others that appear slightly older.
So probably this means that the formation of this entire region has not been
like a single smooth event, you know, that happened everywhere,
but it started in some places and then progressed to other nearby regions along the filament.
Was that surprising to you? Were you expecting it to be more homogenous across there?
I was not, but I think that until one year ago, nobody suspected this.
For the first time, one author that gave a speech today proposed the fact that
there is a foreground cluster which is older, just south of the Orion Nebula cluster.
This was very controversial, and today several pieces of evidence confirm that this is the case,
and this is not isolated, so the properties of the population change along the region.
I'm sorry, what was the controversy? I didn't get the controversy.
The controversy was the fact that it was suggested by Joao Alves
that just to the south of the Orion Nebula cluster, where there is a population of bright sources,
which is accompanied by low mass sources, and it was thought to be part of the system,
and he suggested that in fact there is an older cluster which is not related to Orion,
it is in front of it.
Basically, we knew that in front of the Orion Nebula there are a few stars that are passing in front,
and you expect this because stars have been forming and they are moving in and out around.
The new result is that actually these few stars are the tail of a condensation
that is centered south of the Nebula, it's older, and it's substantial.
And if you move even further south, you see other minor condensations,
so the entire filament, because this is actually a filament of star formation,
is not a loose association of stars passing by that are there by chance,
but really sites of older star formation, and they have been discovered this year, basically.
And they are not part of the Orion complex, then?
The Orion complex, as I said earlier, is a hotspot in this history of events,
but we are understanding better what's going on around,
and actually we are thinking, as Nicola was saying, that to understand Orion,
we cannot only concentrate on Orion, we need to basically look at the big picture,
otherwise we miss why is there, what is going on, what triggered this event,
and how Orion may trigger maybe new generations.
To clarify about your question, so this cluster just to the south of the Orion Nebula cluster
seems not to be related with the region, seems to be something much...
I see, and that's a new discovery, that's something that's brand new,
and is it or is it not a part of the condensation that Massimo was talking about?
It seems to be not part of this filament, the Orion filament per se,
it's part of the much larger structure that includes basically the entire constellation of Orion,
where we also have older populations.
Okay, so what Massimo was talking about was part of the bigger picture,
the larger structure of the Orion complex, what you're saying is that there's a southern cluster of stars
that were not part of the Orion Nebula, but are part of this larger structure.
Exactly.
Got it. Thank you.
Okay.
Okay, that's what I was having trouble getting it all sorted out,
because I wasn't sure which one we were, you know, the Nebula versus the complex.
For us, if you're talking about the Orion Nebula cluster, which is the main topic,
this is interesting also because of the contamination,
because if we want to study the properties of 1,000 stars and see what's the main age,
you know, all the statistical numbers that we get to have a feeling of what the round numbers first,
all these stars that do not belong are confusing.
And one of the problems for us is to understand which is which, to whom they belong.
Okay. I would try to pronounce your name again, but I know I'd mess it up.
I want to ask you a question.
You look like you're pretty young, like you're just getting started out there in your career.
Am I right, or have you been around a while?
Well, I finished my PhD a few years ago, three years ago.
Okay.
I'm a young scientist, yes.
So good. I'd like to ask you a question then.
Do you have any advice for people who are just now starting to embark on their graduate careers
or they're thinking about becoming an astronomer?
Do you have any advice for those guys?
What would you say surprised you the most that you didn't expect as you progressed into your career?
Well, I could say several things, but, you know, some advices are pretty standard.
I would say, you know, even the choice of the field of research is important.
You know, not all the fields of research can lead to a career.
And, of course, a lot of work and dedication are important.
And if I have to say one thing that really struck me the most is the fact that, you know,
during the graduate years, sometimes it can be stressful.
It can be frustrating when, you know, a young researcher has just started and start to work
and things don't work out, you know.
But later on, you know, this effort is paid off, I would say.
Are you saying it's just a little stressful?
I've heard that.
I think it's a little more than that.
From the grad students and postdocs I know, it's a little more than that.
But I think you have a really good team and support structure that you can go to for that.
Is that right?
Yes, that's fundamental as well.
So, Massimo, what would you say to that question?
I mean, what advice would you give to prospective PhD students,
students thinking about getting into astronomy?
Follow your dream, which is what I did.
And, you know, I studied in Italy, not in Harvard or Caltech.
I started my career in a small observatory.
I was enthusiastic.
I was in love with this job.
I was curious.
And you still are now, right?
I still am.
When I run into him in the halls these days, he's still just very animated, very full of excitement.
No, no, I mean, you know, and actually I think the right question is,
someone asked me, what do you want really to know?
You know, not just write another paper,
but what is the question that really will keep you up in the night,
that you know where your curiosity, what is the big, the big.
This is, if you feel this push, if you feel this type of curiosity, this is your job.
Otherwise, you make more money elsewhere, I tell you.
If you are, you know, if you are intelligent and bright, et cetera.
But if you have this curiosity for nature, for reality, if you keep, you know,
if you can be amazed and ask always the new and better question as we try.
Do it.
That's absolutely right.
I mean, everyone I've come across, you see some people that just get burnt out by it.
They don't have that passion anymore because somewhere along the line it's just fallen off.
But if you're able to maintain that curiosity to find out more about the natural world,
and it's something that keeps driving you and driving you, that's, you know,
no matter what you're doing, especially in science, that's what you do,
is you're trying to discover and explore what you didn't know yesterday
and solve those problems that keep you up at night.
So if we're able to keep that, maintain that, and support those that feel that,
I think that's really important right now.
And a lot of that's being lost.
There's a lot of frustrations going on, especially here in this country with science.
But if we're able to take those people that are motivated
and that want to keep their passion alive with that,
we really need to help them foster it and support them through those times.
It's a lot of fun.
It's the best job of the world.
Go for it if you like it.
All right.
I think on that note, that is a perfect note with which to end this broadcast.
We're out of time.
I would like to thank Dr. Massimo Roberto.
Thank you very much for joining us tonight.
This has been a lot of fun.
And can you please say your student's name one more time, please,
so I don't mess it up?
Nicola Dario.
Nicola.
Nicola Dario.
Thank you.
I'm a visual person.
That helps me.
Thank you, Nicola.
Nicola, that's exactly what I needed.
Thank you also for joining us.
Michael Phillips, thank you for joining.
And Ian, thank you.
I love having a chance to work with you.
I hope to do more of this kind of thing.
Thank you, Tony.
No, I'll be back.
This is very cool.
Oh, good.
I'll be definitely inviting you back.
And so that's it for this time, space fans.
Space fans.
Hubble huckers.
I did it.
That's Friday.
That's right.
Thank you all for watching.
And as always, keep looking up.
Bye, everyone.
