Planetary Aurorae in Our Solar System

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
6 Video Views·Sep 5, 2023
Did you know that Earth is not the only planet in our solar system to have magnificent displays of aurorae?
For over two decades, the +Hubble Space Telescope has observed planets and aurorae within the confines of our solar system . Please join us as +Tony Darnell +Carol Christian and +Scott Lewis explore the aurorae of other planets with astronomers who have made these observations.
As always, please interact with us by commenting and leaving questions, we'd love to hear from you!
Hello everybody and welcome to our latest Hubble Hangout. My name is Tony
Darnell. I work at the Space Telescope Science Institute and today
we have a really interesting Hangout planned for you. We're gonna be talking with
Dr. Laurent Lamy from the
University of Paris in Moudon about planetary
aurorae, auroras, aurorae. One of those three are right. I'm not sure which one but they
all sound wrong.
So we hope that you will interact with us and talk about
all things planetary aurora today.
Before I get to the introductions, let me just say very briefly that we hope
you will interact with us. You will give us comments and questions where you can
do it in a wide variety of ways. The Q&A app
is the best way to do it. You can see that on both Google and YouTube. So you
just click on that thing and type in a question
and it will appear magically onto our little panel here and I'll be able to see
the question. You can also
tweet at us with Hubble hashtag or Hubble
Hangout hashtag. Dang it. One week I'm gonna get that right
without stumbling. As well as all, you can also comment on YouTube and the Google Plus event page
where this is being broadcast. So we hope
you'll do it. Please leave us questions and comments about anything related to
Hubble and we'll try to get them as well.
So with me this week, as I said before, is Dr. Laurent Lamy from the
University of Paris in Moudon.
He studies auroras and he's with us today to give us, he's been using the
Hubble Space Telescope to look not
at the ones within our own planet, but ones within our solar system. So welcome Laurent,
we're looking forward to
talking with you. Also with me as always are my very good friends, Dr.
Carol Christian from the Space Telescope Science Institute.
She is an astronomer here and
wonderful insights and great feedback
and information from Hubble. As well as my good friend Scott Lewis
from knowthecosmos.com and he's here to also help out. So welcome everybody.
Let's get started. First of all, what's the appropriate, what's the right way to say
the plural of aurora?
Since I seem to struggle with that. It was not planned at all. Actually, I'm personally using
aurorae, the Latin form and I think
auroras is the U.S. translation of that, but feel free to use
the word you prefer. They all sound wrong to me, so whichever one.
I prefer, I'm going to use auroras just because it sounds
better I guess. So Laurent, go ahead. Better in that case is to speak about
auroral emissions, so that you cover all these curious emissions
as a bunch and you do not have to think about the correct word to use.
There you go. I like that. Alright, well, good advice. Okay, so
let's talk a little bit about the general topic of these
auroral emissions, as you call them. We see them here on Earth.
As you are going to show us, you've seen them on other planets.
Can you give me the most general definition
of what these things are? What is this phenomenon?
That's a good way to begin with, since people do not generally agree on
what to call aurorae these days, but historically
auroral emissions refer to these intense lights that were seen
on Earth's atmosphere for decades in the visible
light, visible domain. So
this remained then as, I mean,
these categories of luminous
emissions from the atmosphere and then
with the study of the other planets and
I mean the study of auroral processes from space, we discovered
aurorae also above the atmosphere and so now we are
more generally speaking about auroral emissions, which consist actually
in a series of different emission processes.
So both in the atmosphere and above the atmosphere
in the surrounding environment of the magnetized planets.
In the atmosphere and above the atmosphere. Exactly.
So what, but that doesn't, I still don't get it, what are they,
what is causing these emissions? Is it different depending on the planet? Is
that why
we can't get more specific than that? We could say that we have
the same series of production processes
which exist at all planets, but the species which are excited,
the atmospheric species in particular, may be different. So
for instance, on Earth, the visible lights we see in the sky
come directly from the collision between
charged particles, which come from the neighborhood of the Earth
and which collide with the neutral atmosphere. So the neutral atmosphere
acts as a screen where energetic particles
fall down, actually we say that they precipitate, and they transfer energy
which is then re-radiated by the atmosphere.
Thus, the light we see, the wavelength domain
they consist of, depend on the atmospheric composition
and at Earth, the most radiative species
are nitrogen and oxygen, which are able to radiate
in the visible domain, essentially.
I have a question. So do you need, on every planet in the solar system, do you
need a magnetic field to get those charged particles?
Or can you have aurora without magnetic fields?
So, generally speaking,
auroral processes are actually only seen
on magnetized planets. So to generate these particles,
which at the end will excite
the atmosphere, you need a magnetic field,
which then produces what we call a magnetosphere.
So I think, Tony, Scott, if you agree
to show the first picture with magnetosphere, you can show
graphics where you have
the schematics of the solar system with various magnetized planets.
Scott has it up now.
So basically,
a magnetic field is created in the neighborhood of the planet's
cavity, which we call a magnetosphere, and this is this cavity
which has the ability, via complex phenomena, to
accelerate charged particles,
which then will be guided along the magnetic field line
down to the polar region, where they can collide with the neutral atmosphere.
So, sticking with Earth just for a minute, before we go off to these other planets for a
second, we have,
obviously, we have a magnetic field. The particles are coming from the Sun,
charged particles from the Sun,
presumably electrons from the solar wind, coming in, following the magnetic field
down,
and as you say, hit these neutral particles, high in the atmosphere, primarily
nitrogen and oxygen, since that's what the Earth's atmosphere is primarily made of,
and they glow, they emit this light, which is generally, on Earth,
green, right? Greenish.
And the reason for that?
The reason for that is due to quantum physics,
which means that when you have a molecule or
an atom, it's able to radiate in a specific series of transitions,
which produce light. So, actually,
the Earth's oral emissions in the atmosphere are not simply green,
nor red, nor only purple. I know, that was an oversimplification, but they're mostly green.
Okay, they cover a wide spectrum, with a few very intense lines,
which give the impression that these emissions
are very colored in very specific
transitions. Okay, so other planets...
I would like just to come back on something that you said quickly.
Actually, the charged particles we are dealing with
are not directly coming from the Sun,
or more specifically, from the solar wind.
Actually, this cavity, which is produced by a magnetic field, a planetary magnetic field,
is, at first order, deviating
the solar wind on the edges of that cavity.
At first order, this is plasma-proof,
we may say. The particles of the solar wind cannot penetrate into the magnetosphere.
So, those charged particles, and there are some complex phenomena,
may be able to enter in some way, because
this is not always plasma-proof, but
these particles, before to produce aura, have to be
sort of reprocessed by the magnetosphere,
which will accelerate them, transfer energy to them,
before they will be able to emit auras. So, the link
between solar wind and the lights we see in the atmosphere
is not direct. I don't understand. So, you're telling me that
the particles from the solar wind
are following the field lines, and if you look at what Scott has up,
those field lines are shown in those yellow lines there.
What we actually see emitted, by the time we see the light, is not due
to the solar wind particles? So, if you want to understand this simply, we can
just consider the fact that the charged particles, which are
carried by the solar wind, are not energetic
enough to produce aural emissions, right? This is the first point. So,
we need something to
transfer energy to these particles, because they can be
good candidates to produce these emissions. This is the first point. The second point is
that, at Earth,
aural emissions are mostly produced on the night side
of the planet. So, the night side means that you are not facing the Sun.
So, there cannot be a direct link between these particles, which are coming from
the Sun,
and these powerful emissions, which are seen
on the night side of the planet. So, I was simply
saying that these particles, which are
transported by solar wind,
are not directly responsible for the emissions we see.
They need first to enter into the magnetosphere under some complex
conditions, and then to be reprocessed, to be warmed,
to be accelerated, before they can then give rise to
aural emissions on the night side of the planet. Got it.
Okay. So, the keyword was accelerated, it seems to me like. You
need to get these particles
more energy than what they would have out in the... I get it now.
Okay. But are you sure they don't happen during the day, and we
just can't see them?
Or they really don't happen during the day? The situation is always
less simplistic than that we are trying to explain.
So, I was referring to intense aurorae,
which are seen on the night side of the Earth. Of course,
there are aurorae all around
both magnetic poles, and so that's why we are speaking about
polar aurorae, and not simply Borealis
aurorae Borealis, because Borealis just refers to the northern hemisphere,
and there are also aurorae in the southern hemisphere, so Australis
aurorae. And so, there are aurorae all around
these magnetic poles,
forming what we call auroral ovals.
But the ovals, the auroral ovals themselves, which are centered
on magnetic poles, are more intense on the night side. So, you have
faint aurorae on the day side.
The issue is that, as these emissions are very faint,
we are generally not able to see them, because the contrast is too faint
on the day side to catch them in the sky.
Carol, I think I cut you off when you were trying to say something. Did you want to
add to this? No, no, no. Laurent explained that the
solar wind particles can then interact with
stuff in the magnetosphere, which then can cascade
and interact with the atmosphere. So, there can be a transition zone.
And acceleration was one of the keys,
is that they have to accelerate, too. And the magnetic field helps with that.
Okay, well, I think we've established what these things are in a
general sense. Laurent, let me ask you this now. What is your...
What got you into this? What is your research interest
in studying these things on other planets?
What got you going on this? So, my purpose of interest is to try to
take advantage, take benefit of these
oral emissions, which can be sensed remotely by telescopes,
as Hubble, for instance, to diagnose,
to study planetary magnetospheres. Because,
generally speaking, a magnetic field cannot be
studied other than in situ, with special measurements
that can be done with spacecraft exploring the various planets of the
solar system.
But, when we do not have the possibility to send spacecraft
around a magnetized planet, oral emissions remain
a useful and powerful tool to investigate remotely
the physics of this magnetosphere. So, my purpose is to try to
take advantage of these emissions, to take
all the information that they carried on, and then to
explain the physics of the magnetosphere
so that they are able to diagnose. And you've been using
the Hubble Space Telescope for a lot of this, correct? Yes, that's correct, because
as for the outer planets, so the planets beyond the orbit
of the Earth, the composition of the atmosphere
is, as for the giant planets, generally dominated by a
hydrogenic species. So, the atmospheric composition is different
from that from the Earth.
And this atmospheric composition
has the capability to radiate in the UV window
that Hubble is particularly
able to look at. So, Hubble is a very powerful tool
to look at the aura of other planets
than the Earth. You know, Carol, one of the things I'm noticing in these
Hangouts lately
is that an awful lot of people are using the UV capabilities of Hubble.
You know, the last few Hangouts we've had, we've talked about this. That's been a
really important part
of people using the Hubble. I guess I always looked at it as more of an infrared
instrument, but, you know, we have a lot of people using the UV
as well. Yeah, and I think what started was, of course,
because we have a lot of experience in ground-based astronomy, we started with
kind of the visual. So, we do a lot of the things that we know in the visual and
then pushed into the infrared.
But the UV capability and the fact that we got new instruments
that assisted with that capability has really been powerful.
And when Hubble no longer is working, we have no other UV capability in space and
we can't get the UV
on the ground. So, right now it is a... Why is that?
It's called money.
On the ground, we can't see the UV, very far into the UV.
That's where I was at. I know, I know. I was being facetious.
On the ground, we can't see because the atmosphere
happily blocks it so that we're not all fried.
It's a good thing. I'm glad you mentioned that. It's a good thing. The visual comes through a little bit of the
infrared in certain places, but the water vapor helps block the infrared and some
of the radio as well.
So, we need telescopes in space and Hubble right now
is the one that has UV capability. It may be that after 2020
there might be another telescope proposed to NASA
that will have some UV capability, but you're right. The people are really looking to
the UV, to use Hubble in the UV
because you need to know a lot of these phenomenon that you can't see in the
visible or the infrared. So, it is an important aspect.
Yeah, it's an important wavelength. One that I'm just now starting to appreciate with Hubble
because of the
recent hangouts we've had. Not to mention this one and as well as the
Ultra Deep Field, which just added UV as well.
I had two questions. One is,
when did astronomers first realize
that the other planets had Aurora? Is this one of these things we always knew, but we
didn't,
you know, we didn't suspect it or we just didn't ever observe it or
when did this interest in other planet Aurora start?
And the second question is, do the colors on other planets tell you anything
about the composition?
So, as for the first question, we
spoke since the beginning of that hangout
about visible emission in the atmosphere, starting with the Earth.
Actually, there are also auroral emissions which are produced
above the atmosphere. We quickly mentioned them at the beginning, which are
actually radio emissions. So, atmospheric
emissions are produced by, we say, precipitating charged particles,
essentially electrons. And these electrons, when guided by magnetic field line down to the
atmosphere,
have the possibility to drive
resonance instability to produce radio waves. So,
radio emissions are also of auroral nature
and they are found around all magnetized planets of the solar system.
So, back to your question, the first time we found
Aurora on another planet than Earth was thanks to radio
observations from the ground with radio telescopes based in the US
and discovering the decametric emission of Jupiter.
And actually, this was the first proof that Jupiter
possesses an internal magnetic field. And then,
with the space exploration,
thanks to the Voyager spacecraft, which explored
the four giant planets in the 80s, mainly,
we had the possibility to look in situ
with small telescopes on board the Voyager spacecraft
and, in particular, a UV spectrometer, which was able to identify
auroral emissions at all these planets. So, Jupiter, Saturn,
Uranus and Neptune. Laurent, before you go any further, I just want to interrupt real quick and say
Scott's got a pretty picture up,
so that we can emphasize that. What are we looking at here?
So, this picture is a sort of a collage
of UV observations acquired by the Hubble Space Telescope
for the three giant systems, which are
those of Jupiter, Saturn and Uranus, and showing
basically the emissions, which can be seen in the UV
window. So, on these figures,
you show the planets and sometimes the satellites
that have been caught by HST
as well. And you see that
there are different sorts of emissions.
The solar light is reflected generally by the atmosphere of these bodies.
So, this is why the planets or the satellites
are bluish all over their surface.
In addition to this, you see bright emissions,
which are the aura we are speaking of since the beginning of this talk,
which are these powerful emissions, you see very white,
and which are very localized. So, we see at Earth that
these emissions are distributed along two main
so-called auroral ovals, so say two circles
centered around magnetic poles. And you can see here that
looking at a specific planet, for instance Jupiter, the situation is
both similar, you see an oval, which is likely centered on the southern magnetic pole
here,
but also different. The phenology is much more complex and variable
than at Earth. And this can be transposed to the other planets as well.
So, I'm noticing with this image here that Io seems to have
aurora as well, auroral emissions. Is that what I'm seeing there
in this image? Which one?
Io? The Moon?
So, Io is an example of aurora
which can be found on a satellite, because
we briefly say that such lights
are produced when there is a beam of energetic particles which collide with a neutral
medium, say an atmosphere. And so, as these
satellites, say Io, Ganymede, or
Europa, possesses an exosphere, or at least a surface,
with which
this particle can collide, this witnesses
the arrival of
beams of charged particles. So, these materialize
auroras of satellites.
And Titan there, right next to it, looks pretty quiet to me. Does that mean
not so much, or what is that? Titan was
put there because it was observed, but no auroral emissions were
detected on that satellite, because it's not very well
coupled in an electrodynamic
to his planet, contrary to Io and Jupiter.
And just to come back to the second question of Carol, what may we
infer with these emissions about the atmospheric composition
of these bodies? As for the atmosphere of giant planets,
Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, we know that the atmosphere
is dominated by hydrogenic species. So, this has been shown
with spectroscopic observations of Hubble, in particular,
that we are facing emissions, auroral emissions,
reflecting H and H2,
mainly, species. So, this is a diagnosis of
the atmospheric composition. As for Io, the situation is quite different,
because Io is emitting,
is possessing an exosphere,
which is made of different atmospheric species, exospheric species,
and mainly dominated by oxygen. So, on the
image of Io, what you see, the aurora that you see, are produced by
oxygen. So, the UV window is able to
pick up specific transitions, which can come from
either hydrogen for the atmosphere of giant planets, either oxygen
or dioxygen for their satellites.
So, we all know that Io is a pretty active place,
geologically, and with lots of activity going on there. And the reason
that you're confident these are auroral emissions
happens to be the fact that they're so bright in the UV, then,
correct? And not something else that might be going on with Io.
Yes, they are bright, they are localized, they are transient.
So, these are properties of auroral emissions. This cannot be
something due to the reflected sunlight, for instance,
because it would affect the whole
enlightened face of the satellite. Okay, I have a really good
related question from Patrick Calhoun
on the Q&A app, who's going, do you think a planetary filter will ever be made
someday for us to see the aurora
from Earth? A planetary filter? Yeah, I guess the question is, should we see,
would we be able to observe planetary aurorae
from Hubble of the Earth? I think
this has been done, not by Hubble, but by
another X-ray telescope orbiting Earth,
pointing to the night side of the Earth and tracking X-ray emission.
But I don't think Hubble tried to do that because of the risk to
point the Sun in the field of view and then to damage the instruments.
But Carol, you may correct me? No, that's right, we can't point at the
Earth, and in fact, when Hubble goes around
the Earth, we have to make sure we're not pointing
towards it, because it's too bright. And so, we can't make any observations
of the Earth. I think there are also,
there may have been some Earth-looking, you know, like Landsat
and GOI and some of those Earth-looking
satellites. Certainly, the astronauts
saw aurora from the space shuttle, and they took
lots of pictures. That's a better platform for observing. It's a great platform.
The issue with Hubble is really the sensitivity and the size of the telescope,
the primary mirror that
the STSCI team does not want to
damage. And you're right that many spacecraft have taken
images of the Earth's aurora from space, and so imaging both
auroras on the day side and on the night side. And
you're also right by pointing that the ISS team,
the astronauts on board the ISS station,
are continuously taking photographs and making beautiful films that you may find
on the Internet, and that show, actually, very well the dynamics
of these emissions. When we are on the Earth, we can
look at these emissions from very far, actually,
and that's the same situation for a telescope, which is orbiting the Earth
very far, but with the ISS station,
the auroras are seen by the edge, actually. So,
the level of details is really impressive.
Yeah, good question. There's a webpage, too,
for those that want to see the aurora from space. It's for the Gateway
to Astronaut Photography of Earth, and it's where I use, when I've made some of my
compilation videos, I use a lot of the source material here,
which are from the time-lapse photography that are done by the astronauts from the
International Space Station.
I'll put it into the Google Plus event and I'll tweet it out there, but for those,
and actually, I'll put in a comment on YouTube, too, but it's
google.jsc.nasa.gov, and you're able to go through and actually get
all the full-resolution images, if you want them, or also see them in a movie
file
for the time-lapse. The ISS is probably one of the best spots to try and see some of
these activities, so
that's good. Thanks, Scott. Okay, so we've basically...
What I want to know, though, Laurent, is, okay, so you've been looking at these
aurorae from all different planets and using the Hubble,
you've gotten some good data.
What have been the greatest... What's been your biggest surprise
in observing? Has there been a planet that was unusually more active than you
thought,
brighter than you thought? Has anything really surprised you in your
research?
You mean myself or the community in general?
I guess both. I guess both. So, I mean,
looking at these aurorae, what were you expecting versus what did you
find?
If we take the case of Jupiter, for instance,
so, Scott, maybe you may display
the composite figure of Jupiter made of
Hubble images taken in the UV and in the visible range.
You see these two
ovals centered around magnetic poles, right? You have it up now.
Okay, and when the UV observers
looked at these images first, they identified
that strange spot that you see both in the northern and the southern
hemisphere. Do you see it? It's a quarter world of the main oval.
It's a bright spot with sort of a wake, right?
Right below the... Yeah, it's on both sides, isn't it? On both poles.
That's on both sides. And actually, people then realized that
this spot was related to the magnetic flux tube
which was connecting to the satellite Io. And so,
that was a surprise. Let me say that again to make sure it was understood.
So, these spots... The magnetic flux tube, you said it was the magnetic flux tube associated with Io, right?
Exactly. And so, there are other spots
which may be seen on the following picture, if Scott
can display it, which are associated with
other Galilean satellites at Jupiter.
So, the fact that we get a spot at the footprint,
so we call it the footprint of the magnetic field connected to a satellite,
is saying us something. And the most enthusiastic
discovery was to realize that there was a sort of a coupling
between the satellite and the planet, able to accelerate particles
enough to produce such bright footprints
at the foot of the field lines connecting the satellite
to the planet. So, this was a major discovery, actually.
And when you look at this picture of Jupiter
with the main oval and some specific polar emission,
you clearly see different spots which are materializing the different
Galilean satellites at Jupiter.
And which... Scott doesn't have it up right now. I'm trying to...
Yes, I see it. It says the main oval and it has...
Yeah, Scott has it up and it shows Io and
Europa and Ganymede. And so, there are little dots that
then connect the two lines. So,
what Laurent is saying, if I can put words in his mouth, is that Jupiter is an
amazing environment because
some of those satellites, those moons, have atmospheres as
well. And
Jupiter really interacts with some of the main
moons, its main moons.
And so, there's this communication that goes on between Jupiter
and the moons through these magnetic field
lines. And so, they share this aurora phenomenon.
Exactly. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Finish.
Exactly. And this connection
is of electric nature because we have an exchange of charged particles. So,
this means currents. And just to finish, if we take that picture of Jupiter,
if we now exclude satellites, you see that you also have
a main oval together with polar emissions. And all together, we can say that when we
look
at the emissions of a specific planet,
each part of this complex
morphology says something to us
in terms of magnetospheric physics. I mean,
to produce these bright emissions, you need to have an active region somewhere in
the magnetosphere.
And each bright spot or ovals or transient
phenomena refer to something happening transiently or not
in the magnetosphere. Is there any relationship or
connection between the size of the planet and the strength of these
aurora? Like, does Jupiter have more powerful, more bright
aurora than other smaller planets? Or is that related in any way?
Yes. Jupiter is the most powerful
auroral emitter of the Solar System. These emissions that we see in these pictures
are generally two to three orders of magnitude more intense
in terms of emitted power with respect to these of the Earth,
for instance. Saturn is only
one order of magnitude brighter with respect to the Earth.
But then, what is the reason for this brightness, you will ask?
Right? Yes. Well, okay. Yep, I was going to go there.
Okay. And we, to our
current understanding, there are two main phenomena that trigger
the strength of these auroral phenomena. The first is the
interaction with the solar wind. The interaction between solar wind and the Earth's
magnetic field
is the primary generator
for Earth's aurora. And Jupiter is the
other extremal case, as Jupiter is not very sensitive to solar wind at all.
It possesses a very strong magnetic field, so it's not very sensitive to solar wind.
And these bright emissions are essentially internally triggered
by the rapid rotation of the planet. So,
the solar wind effect and the effect of the planetary rotation
are the two main drivers responsible for the brightness of these emissions.
So, if you had a small planet that rotated very fast and had a very bright or
very strong magnetic field, for whatever reason,
you would get equally bright, or at least very bright,
auroral emissions from that situation. Exactly.
And we can quote the case of Mercury,
which has a very weak magnetic field, but which is located very close to the Sun.
And so there, the solar wind acts as the primary
driver for auroral emissions. And as Mercury is
even weakly magnetized, it displays auroral emissions as well.
Oh, I didn't know that. Wow. Well, what about... Okay, so let's talk about that. Mars, for
example, has,
as far as I know, no magnetic field, correct? It doesn't have much of a dynamo
at all.
So, nothing, right, from Mars?
More or less, the question is open. Mars does possess
what we call a crystal magnetic field.
So, this is not permanent. I'm sorry, excuse me, a what magnetic field?
A crystal magnetic field. Crystal, which means that...
Oh, crystal, sorry, I want to make sure I understood, because...
Okay, Chris, I'm sorry. Mars was certainly used in the past to possess
a permanent magnetic field, like those of the other planets,
but it disappeared, and we only have traces
of it now, which is called a
crystal magnetic field. And in the neighborhood of
these traces of past magnetic fields,
there have been some attempts to detect
auroral emissions, but this is not obvious at all. And then to finish with Venus,
Venus does not possess any magnetic field
at all, so Venus does not possess any
permanent magnetosphere, nor auroral emissions.
I'm still trying to get my head around the crystal magnetic field, but there is something there
that's causing some
magnetic interaction in some way. I should point out that you have two
small children in the background who are...
No, it's just me. Oh, that's Scott?
Yeah, I'm sorry. Dean has been meaning to meet me today.
Yeah, Scott, he's... He's late for us here.
Yeah, that's true, it is 6 o'clock.
So, you found that these
satellite interactions were a surprise. These were something you
didn't expect to see
when you began your research. Is there... What's the future? Where are you going to
head for here? What's in store for you next?
So, these satellites were an example of
what surprised not only me, but the community.
Most recently, I've worked with Hubble, thanks to Hubble, on the Uranus magnetosphere,
which was very intriguing because Uranus'
auroral emissions and magnetosphere could only be
investigated once, during the flyby of the planet by the Voyager 2 spacecraft
in 1986.
So, we could study that magnetosphere and auroral processes
only with a few hours of measurements acquired by Voyager 2
along its trajectory. But then, we knew
that Uranus was magnetized and displayed auroral emissions.
And by calculating the theoretical brightness of these emissions,
we found that it should fit
the minimum detection threshold of HST.
So, we recently tried to catch
these emissions again. And to do that, instead of...
So, this had been done twice in two decades,
as for Uranus, but always with negative detections.
And instead of observing randomly, this time we tried to take benefit of a
property we just mentioned, which is the interaction between
solar wind and the magnetic field of a planet.
Because we mentioned this very briefly, but one property of the Earth,
Saturn, and so by extrapolating this to Uranus and Neptune, one property of
this magnetosphere is to react to a strong compression of the solar
wind reaching this planet. So, at the Earth, this is called the
substorm phenomena, which gave rise to the space wave discipline.
When a compression arrives at Earth, the
magnetosphere is compressed and then there is some
of the acceleration processes that are forced because of that
compressed magnetosphere. And this gives rise to very
bright auras, right? And so, to try to catch Uranus auras,
we made the assumption that Uranus may react as the Earth does.
And so, we observed during the past of a series of
coronal mass ejection, which were propagating
in the outer heliosphere along the planets until reaching Uranus.
And then, thanks to Hubble, we could observe at the right place at the right
time and we got a detection, a picture of which
Scott may be able to show you. I'm really glad you talked about this,
because I was going to ask about this, of the cascading through the solar
system and you being able to watch, you know, the mass ejection that comes to
Earth and etc. So, that's very interesting that you can
kind of watch it propagate and then find a really faint signature.
Yeah, sure. Great. And as far as I'm concerned, that was
one of the most surprising results we got,
thanks to these marvelous measurements. So, coronal mass ejections are these
magnetic eruptions from the Sun. They can be enormous and they
go out throughout the solar system with
a lot of very primarily electrons and things going along with it. And
when they hit these planets then, it looks like you can see the signatures
of, as you said, the compression of the atmosphere
and these auroral emissions. Can we talk about Neptune for a minute?
I may be screwing this up, but I remember, I think, when Voyager 2 went
by, they were seeing these white bands on Neptune, am I remembering correctly?
And they were these, it was in the upper atmosphere of Neptune and I was
wondering if those were auroral emissions or not. Well, Voyager
Voyager 2 flew by Neptune in 1989 and as for the other planets, its UV
spectrometer looked carefully at the upper atmosphere of the planet
and actually tentatively detected aurora. But
they are very faint and close to the detection threshold. So, even these
claimed detection is not confirmed yet. So, what we did for Uranus could
certainly be reapplied for Neptune, except that Neptune is much
farther from the Sun and supposedly displays a fainter aurorae.
So, we are really at the limit of what Hubble can do
with the auroral emissions of the planets of the solar system.
Okay, Charles Bell has got a couple of really good questions for us on the Q&A
app. Let me start with this first one. He's asking, have you studied the
hydrogen coma via Lyman alpha emission from
Venus using the Soho swan images? Soho swan,
I'm not sure what that is. No, I didn't. So, what this,
how his name? Charles Bell. What Charles is referring to is the
fact that when Venus is swamped into the solar
wind, it possesses an induced magnetosphere
because the plasma cannot pass through the planet and so it
passes on the edges and it creates what we call an induced
magnetosphere or coma. And this type of magnetosphere has
completely different properties as the permanent magnetosphere we just
discussed and in particular it does not display
any powerful plasma acceleration process which could trigger
auroral emissions. So, I have not studied Venus at all.
I would like to perhaps at some occasion
but because Venus is not a primary candidate for displaying these
emissions. Okay, good question Charles. Thank you.
Soho swan, I'm trying to think. I thought I knew Soho. I don't recall a
instrument on there called that but he's got one more question. Let me just go
ahead and get this out because this is also related.
Have you used NASA Swift ultraviolet optical telescope for planetary aurorae?
This is also from Charles. So, Swift is a plane, right? I'm not sure.
Maybe Carol you may help me. I think that's
this refers to a plane which possesses a telescope
and able to observe at the highest altitudes of the Earth's
atmosphere. This is some mixed mode question because
Swift is an x-ray burster. I'm not sure about a UV optical
telescope above the atmosphere other than
Hubble. So, I'm not sure what we're referring to but Swift
looks in the x-ray. Okay, all right. So, I guess
it doesn't sound like you've used it for that. So, good question and thank you
Charles. One more from Adam Synergy who's got a
good question. He's also asking from the
Q&A app. This is Adam asking, would we see these bright emissions in a
planet containing only layers of metallic
hydrogen and helium or is this more evidence of an iron core
inside Jupiter? Well, so,
hard to answer. Repeat the question please. Could you repeat the question? Would we see these bright
emissions in a planet containing only layers of metallic hydrogen and helium
or is this more evidence of an iron core inside Jupiter?
The fact is that these emissions are produced
at the uppermost of the atmosphere and this does not consist of
metallic hydrogen. Metallic hydrogen is rather found at the core of the planet.
So, this is a different layer of the planet
which cannot be impacted by these particles which are stopped
by pressure at much higher altitudes. Does it make sense?
Yes. Right, and so let me comment.
The aurora phenomena, the fact that it is
related to the magnetic field, one can look at each planet and say
what is it that generates the magnetic field in the core of that
object? And in the case of the Earth, it is
partly an iron core. In the other planets, especially the outer
planets which are largely gaseous, it may be a different phenomenon.
So, the magnetic field itself, although Laurent can
correct me because I'm not an expert, but I think the existence of the
magnetic field just says that there is something
causing the magnetic field in the core. It may not necessarily be
ferrous or anything. It's just something that is capable of
generating a magnetic field. Go ahead Laurent. Sorry, just
to briefly mention that we think,
because we are unsure, we never were able to go into the deep core of
the planet, but we think that planetary magnetic
fields are produced by a dynamo effect, which is driven by the motion of some
dense plasma, so either metallic hydrogen or
lighter ions, for instance in
Mercury, which are having some convection
motion driven by the rotation of the planet, which then gives rise to
a magnetic field. Okay, so a couple things here real quick too.
The SWAN instrument on SOHO is a solar wind and
tropes, so that is a collaboration with the Finnish Meteorological Institute,
so that is an instrument that's on SOHO. And I have a question
from Twitter, from Summer Ash, who's wondering
with the interactions with the natural satellites of Jupiter
on the aurora, is our Moon interacting at all with our
aurora that we're seeing on Earth? So actually no,
our Moon is not interacting at all, I mean
electrodynamically speaking, with the Earth, because the condition for a
satellite to interact with a planet is first that the satellite moves
into the magnetosphere, so it sees permanently
a magnetic field passing in front of it,
and second the satellite shall possess a conductive exosphere,
which is the condition for this gigantic electrical
current to close actually along the fin lines and then
at the satellite. So without a conductive exosphere
this electric interaction cannot give rise.
So unfortunately at the Earth, the Moon does not
possess a conductive exosphere and actually passes
half of its time out of the magnetosphere, so that
an Io-Jupiter interaction cannot be observed at Earth.
That's a great question, thank you for that. Charles also wants to point out,
Charles Bell points out that SWIFT has both
X-ray and UV optical telescopes on board,
and apparently, so I don't think they're being used
right now in the way that Laurent is
studying things, but thanks for that Charles, we appreciate it.
SWIFT is primarily to look at galactic
burst things, they don't in general look at
the solar system, and in the case of SOHO, SOHO is specifically to
look at the Sun. So it can tell you when there's a burst
or an emission from the Sun, but it's not going to turn around and
look at Jupiter in response to that.
Go ahead, do you want to say something to that? Yeah, I just wanted to add that I
retrieved the name of the plane I was thinking to by
discussing SWIFT, which is called SOFIA actually, SOFIA is a
German U.S. plane with some telescopes on board,
which are able to observe at very high altitudes, and which
possesses a UV telescope, but it is too deep in the atmosphere to be able to
observe either Earth's aurora or the outer planets.
Here's this one also from the Q&A app from Alodi Arguello,
and I think I'm gonna, I hope I get this right, is it unusual to have auroras
in the Sun, and if not, what would be the consequences?
So I think I'm reading that right. Can you have aurora in the solar corona?
That's nothing but a charged particle, bath, isn't it? I mean,
there's nothing but a plasma up there. Certainly not the auroras
that we are used to see at the atmosphere, because the medium is not the
same, the solar corona is very hot, very charged, and this is completely
different from the neutral atmosphere we were dealing with,
but so if we leave optical emissions, I think there are some possibilities for
the Sun to drive radio emissions, because
radio emissions only need tenuous plasma
with energetic electrons gyrating around magnetic field lines, so this can
arrive around magnetized planets, but this may arrive as well
around the Sun. Yeah, so the corona... Sorry, I missed you, the sound was cut off.
Oh, you're dropping out, Tony. I am? Oh, so the environment of the solar
corona is a much different environment than what we're
talking about here for planetary atmospheres. When I was working at
NCAR, one of the senior scientists would love to ask
the question, how can we have the Sun, which is 5,500 degrees
Kelvin, how can we have a two million degree
corona? He used to love to ask that
question, and the answer is rather intriguing. I mean,
it's just a very thin, very dense, a very thin atmosphere. However, it's
very, very hot, and it's really a unique
environment up in the Sun, but I don't think
when you think of the atmosphere of the Sun, you think of it as the same way as
you would a planet, but that is a good question, though. Thank you very
much. Okay, Carol, let's get to one here that's
been sitting here. This is from Christian
Timotei, I think I'm pronouncing it right. What is the expected life
of the Hubble Space Telescope? Well, it's a good question.
So right now, everything on Hubble is operational.
Everything that was operational on the last servicing mission in 2009 is in
operation today. There is one part of the advanced
chemistry surveys which hasn't worked and was
unable to be fixed, but everything else is working fine, and that includes not
only instrumentation, but the batteries, the
computers, the solar cells, and there are redundant systems as well. The pointing
systems are redundant. So a few of the gyros have had some
difficulty, and engineers watched the performance of all of these
instruments as well as all of the satellite components, and as far as we
can tell, except for a couple of the gyros
that have exhibited some noise and one failure,
everything is operating fine. So as long as it operates fine,
it can last a long time. And in particular, we are looking for,
now we're on our 25th anniversary year, we just
celebrated the 24th. We believe, we astronomers believe, and
some of the engineers believe, it's going to last until 2020, but it could last
well beyond that. And the reason that we're interested in having it last at
least until 2020 is because we would like two years
overlap with the James Webb telescope, which launches in 2018.
But, you know, it's constantly being monitored,
and it looks healthy. So it's like any other system,
you monitor your car every day, and you do the readings and oil analysis, and
check your tire pressure, and things seem to be running.
We can't maintain it anymore, but it's going to run and run and run until some
major component fails. If everything goes really well,
as Carol is outlining, all the stuff keeps working, then the limiting factor
becomes the orbit it's in. And I think, if I'm
not mistaken, Carol, that will be decided sometime
around 2028. It'll start to have problems with its
orbit, and we may have to take corrective
action by then, somehow. So that's the ultimate, the
ultimate date would be 2028 sometime, even if it's all working
perfectly. So, I mean, this telescope has
exceeded expectations at every turn from the very beginning on up. And I want to
point out, while we're on this topic, that Carol
and Scott and I are planning a history of Hubble Hangouts sometime in September,
where we're going to talk about Hubble, nothing but Hubble,
what it's done, what it's been through, how we fixed it,
what it's gone through. So look for that also in September.
I was also going to comment that it's interesting because the lifetime of
Hubble is a little bit linked to what Laurent is talking about, because
with the emissions from the Sun that can puff up the atmosphere
of the Earth, as well as produce aurora, and depending on how the atmosphere
inflates or doesn't inflate, it can produce drag. If it puffs up enough,
it produces drag on the telescope, which can then
cause the orbit to decay. So the 2028, I think, is a conservative
estimate of the extension of the atmosphere and
how much it will influence the orbit of Hubble.
Excellent point. I mean, it doesn't take into account all the variations
that can happen with space weather and things like that.
People forget that Hubble is, while it is in orbit, it's still kind of in the
atmosphere of the Earth. So it is affected by that a little bit.
And Jean Daramont, that also answers your questions, how long
time remainder for the mission for Hubble. I think we pretty much
covered that part there. Scott, am I missing anything? I do have some
from Twitter as well. Where on Twitter are you looking?
They're not using Hubble Hangout. No, it's communicating back and forth
with me now from a thread. So you're in charge of... I'm driving the
internet, Tony. You've known this for a while. I know that about... I should know
better. So it's actually follow-ups from Summer.
I was wondering, is Callisto too far out to
interact in that way with Jupiter? And also,
are there any natural satellites interacting with Saturn's aurora?
So as for Jupiter, the interaction between Callisto and Jupiter has
been guessed for a long time ago. And to my knowledge,
there has only been one possible detection by a colleague
of Boston, which is unpublished yet. So if any
interaction, this at least shows that this shall be
very transient. So Callisto shall have a different type of
interaction with respect to the other Galilean satellites,
probably a less conductive exosphere. And as for Saturn,
the Cassini mission recently discovered that
Enceladus is behaving as Io does with Jupiter and as Enceladus with
Saturn, which means that Enceladus is producing a footprint
in auroral emissions. And you may see this on a
picture that you may have in your hands,
Scott. I'll get up here in just a second. Which displays actually a picture of
Saturn. We did not speak about Saturn yet.
And you see there these marvellous pictures taken by Hubble, where you see
the very variable nature of these auroral emissions.
In particular, the bright one at the middle was produced by a solar wind
compression reaching the planet. So this is an
illustration. And on the following picture, this is a
figure that was taken by the Cassini UV
spectro-imager, which reveals actually a spot which is
linked to Enceladus
exactly as for Io. And the main
advantage of Cassini was that we were able to get
in-situ measurements. So that's that picture. You see that
when the spacecraft was crossing the flux tube relating
Enceladus to Saturn, it was able to
to acquire in-situ measurements of plasma
traveling along these field lines. And then
remotely observe with a UV telescope the auroral context on the surface of
on the atmosphere of the planet. And so with this set of measurements, we
got these two informations, both remotely and
in-situ. And we could diagnose the full electric current, which
is coupling Enceladus to its host planet. All right, great. Thank you.
So we're running out of time. And I want to thank
Laurent Lamy for joining us and talking about planetary aurora. He's from the
Observatory of Paris and moved on. Thank you, Laurent. I appreciate your time today.
And before I go, I just want to highlight one
comment from YouTube. This is from George Lloyd who goes,
Hi Tony, Carol, and Scott. I'm a subscriber of Deep Astronomy Space Fan News and I've
just stumbled onto this channel. I was wondering how do I find out when
other live Hangouts happen? And the reason I wanted to highlight
that is because I never know when they're on and would maybe like to ask
a question live. Well, Lloyd, the best way to find out is
to subscribe to this channel, which is
your first step. You'll get that notification when it goes live.
If you also follow Hubble Telescope and Deep Astronomy and
Scientific Scott on Twitter, you'll be able to get what we are
constantly letting people know. And finally, I don't shut up. I'm always
tweeting. I know. And so that's another
great way to find out about when we're having these. Also,
Carol, Scott and I are being very, you know, we're working on a schedule that
is, we're going to be doing these for
the most part every single Thursday at 3 p.m. Eastern, which in the UK is
seven o'clock your time. So that's the best way to
find out. Another thing I'll mention, if you Google
Hubble Hangouts, you will find the web page that often has
what the next topic is. Yes. We might take a little vacation at the end of
August, but mostly it'll be every Thursday at 3
unless our guest absolutely cannot be with us at that
time and then we'll reschedule it. But we are trying to have some weekly.
No, you are not. I didn't say anything about you. That's right.
Okay, so that's it for this week, folks.
Next week, we are going to be having a Hangout with some of the
people with the Institute on the process of deciding, we're going
to talk about how do you get to use Hubble?
What's it like? What do you got to go through to get Hubble time? Loren knows
because he's had to go through it. We're going to talk with members of the
Time Allocation Committee and we're going to talk about how
one goes about getting Hubble time, how was it decided, what Hubble looks
at. One of the things that I like, you know, people I think have a little
misconception of what Hubble. Hubble is about as general purpose a
telescope as you're going to find in space, but it was really designed to look
for dim, warm things. And so very, very dim things are what it
excels at. So that's what we're going to be
talking about that next week. On behalf of Carol Christian, Scott Lewis
and Dr. Loren Lemie, I would like to thank you all for watching
and as always, keep looking up. Thank you.
