The Hubble Space Telescope and Comet ISON

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
47 Video Views·Sep 5, 2023
Please check out the Comet ISON Blog on HubbleSite for new and information about Comet ISON:
http://hubblesite.org/go/ison
Hello, Hubble huggers, and welcome to another Hubble Hangout.
And this one, I'm really excited about this one because this is one of the first ones
I've been doing.
I'm actually doing this as the Hubble Space Telescope.
It's funny because I don't feel like one.
I don't feel any different.
But you know, it says that I am the Hubble Space Telescope now.
And so I'm here broadcasting as the Hubble Space Telescope.
You also see me here as a member of the chat, but I've just got the Hubble Hangout banner
on there.
So let me just show you that because that's really awesome.
That was done by Christine Godfrey here at the Institute, and I think it's an awesome
graphic.
So I just wanted to put that up there real quick.
So before I get started with introductions, let me tell you how you can interact with
the Hubble Space Telescope that is me.
What you do is you can comment on the Google Plus event page if you want to.
And you may be watching this event here.
In fact, let me, I should probably type refresh your browser on the event page.
Also you can leave comments on the YouTube channel if you happen to be on the Hubble
site channel where we are also broadcasting.
You can leave your comments there.
You can also tweet.
Oh, we didn't do a hashtag.
Hubble Hangouts.
That's awful long.
You're going to use up a lot of your characters.
But if you use a hashtag Hubble Hangout, we'll see that as well.
So leave questions and comments.
We'll have plenty of time for that.
Hopefully toward the end where we'll try to get to all that unless I see a particularly
interesting one in the middle and we'll just blurt it out somewhere along the line, we'll
be able to do that.
So new format slightly.
With me also, as he always is, is Dr. Alberto Conti.
Hello, Alberto.
Hey, Tony.
How are you?
Nice to be here.
Yeah.
Thank you.
He's the James Webb Space Telescope Innovation Scientist.
So Alberto, what's new with the web?
Are we still on track for 2018?
We are on track for 2018.
We're making quite a bit of progress in testing.
We have two of the instruments at Goddard Space Flight Center that are being tested
right now and waiting to be integrated.
There's a lot of time.
A lot of time is going to be spent into doing testing for the next few years.
So it's a very exciting time.
And so far, we're doing very well.
So nothing major to report, either negative or positive.
We're just doing very, very well.
We're on track.
We're very excited.
And we're working hard to make sure we stick to that deadline.
Awesome.
I mean, they're building all that right down the road, aren't they, down at Goddard?
Yeah.
It's just around the world.
It's a few miles from here, a few kilometers if you're in the oil country.
There you go.
We'll wait for the wind.
Yeah.
Well, good.
I mean, 2018 can't come soon enough for me, so I can't wait.
I'm glad to hear it.
OK.
Thanks for the update.
And also, brand new addition, Scott Lewis from KnowTheCosmos.com.
He is, you recognize him probably as the co-host for the Virtual Star Party with Fraser Cain.
He also inexplicably goes with the Twitter handle The Bald Astronomer.
I'm not quite sure what that's about.
It's a long story.
It's a very long story.
Anyway, welcome, Scott.
It's a real pleasure to have you with these Hangouts.
I'm looking forward to working with you on these.
And you're an awesome person in these things, so thanks for coming.
Hey.
You know, I've tried to emulate you as much as possible.
I find that almost always serves me well.
Yeah.
You know, if you weren't so humble, you wouldn't be perfect.
All right.
I'm getting fed just by listening.
OK.
And now, as you all know from the title of the Hangout, we are here to talk about comets
and, in particular, Comet ISON.
And I would like to introduce some planetary scientists we have with us today, two of which
work at the Space Telescope Science Institute and the other one at the Planetary Science Institute.
So why don't we start with Bonnie Meinke.
Hi, Bonnie.
Hi.
So why don't you introduce yourself.
Tell us what you're doing.
Sure.
I'm a planetary scientist.
I'm also a content specialist at the Space Telescope Science Institute in the Office
of Public Outreach.
And what I've mostly studied my whole career is Saturn.
But I had one project back when I was an undergrad in college where I studied the possibility
of interstellar comets.
So.
Awesome.
That's my background in cometry.
In cometry.
Oh, that's a great one.
Hashtag.
Yeah, cometry.
I like that.
But we don't need trees on comets, right?
Okay.
And also with me, Max Mutchler, also from the Space Telescope Science Institute.
Max.
Oh, you're muted.
He's muted.
Sorry.
Unmuted.
So my name is Max Mutchler.
I'm a research and instrument scientist here at the Space Telescope Science Institute.
I've actually been here working on the entire Hubble mission, 23 years.
And I'm an expert on Hubble's cameras.
So I really know how to design observations and reduce the data that comes out of it.
And I also am a member of the Hubble Heritage team that is doing some of the observations
of comet ISON, the one that was released yesterday and the one that was released earlier.
And we have more observations coming up.
So I've been involved with a lot of planetary science with the Hubble Space Telescope.
Earlier comet observations, including ones that have broken up.
And observations of asteroids and dwarf planets like Ceres and Pluto.
And so excited to be a part of these comet ISON observations.
And, you know, look forward to a lot more coming forward.
Awesome.
Yeah.
Well, welcome.
It's good to have you here, Max.
And also with us is Dr. Zhenyang Li from the Planetary Science Institute.
Welcome.
Can you tell – why don't you introduce yourself?
Sure.
Hello.
It's a pleasure to be here.
And my name is Zhenyang Li.
And I'm a research scientist at the Planetary Science Institute.
And I mostly work on almost all the solar system small bodies where we have data, of course.
And I actually started as a cometary scientist at the University of Maryland with Dr. Mike O'Hearn.
And if you don't know the name, that's fine.
But I think you must know the mission, Deep Impact Mission.
Oh, wow.
Yeah.
So that's how I started my work on comets.
Awesome.
And then right now I'm also working on the asteroid missions.
I also participated in the Dawn mission as a science team member.
And I also worked on the Dixie mission, which is the extended mission of Deep Impact,
and also Stardust Next, which was the extended mission of Stardust Mission.
And so that's what I do right now.
Yeah.
I'm going to talk more in the coming items.
Well, welcome.
It's awesome to meet you.
I'm looking forward to finding out more about comets from you.
And also with us is Zolt LeVay.
He's been on these Hangouts many times before with other things.
But he is the one that takes the images that Max has provided
and turns them into amazing-looking images.
Welcome, Zolt.
Thanks, everybody.
I'm glad to see everybody here.
Yeah, I'm in the Office of Public Outreach here,
and I'm the imaging group lead in the Office of Public Outreach.
And I'm also the lead of the Hubble Heritage team.
Max was talking about Hubble Heritage.
And some of the observations we'll be talking about were conducted for Hubble Heritage.
Okay, so before we get into the discussion too much,
I want to start right off the bat by introducing one of the reasons we're here
is we want to introduce the ISON blog that we've started at the Institute on HubbleSite.org.
It's set up on the page now.
On the very first, on the very top of the blog is an image that Zolt helped create,
which we'll talk about more in this.
But there are all kinds of posts on here all about not just comet ISON,
but comets in general.
So we're hoping that you will subscribe to the RSS feed on this and see the posts.
Some things that are imminent is I've got a video coming up
on whether or not comet ISON will actually hit us.
It's going to go on the HubbleSite channel YouTube channel,
and we'll post it on this blog.
So look for that in the next, hopefully, the next day or so.
But the URL for this is, unfortunately, I can't get my lower thirds to work
because I'm doing this as a Google Plus page,
and I had all kinds of permission problems.
So hopefully you can see the URL up there,
but I will also be posting it on the event page.
It's HubbleSite.org slash go slash ISON,
and that will get you there to check it out.
So please subscribe to it and follow it and leave comments
and do what you can and interact with us on this.
Okay, guys, so comets and comet ISON.
Hubble is going to observe this.
Now, is this a new thing?
Is this one of the first comets that Hubble has ever observed,
or has it done this before?
Who wants to go? Max?
Go Max. Go Max again.
Yeah, I'll take that one.
No, Hubble's done a lot of comet observations.
I've been involved in quite a few of them.
And, you know, so I would say going back to the very beginning,
probably the most famous one early on was shortly after Hubble was repaired in 1993,
late 1993.
Couldn't have been scripted any better.
We had a comet Schumacher-Levy 9 that broke up
after a close interaction with Jupiter, broke up into a string of comets,
which then slammed into Jupiter just about six months after Hubble was repaired.
So it was just a beautiful, you know,
obviously a fantastic never-before-seen astronomical event of a comet breaking up
and slamming into Jupiter.
But then you have a recently repaired Hubble just primed to actually observe it
the way we can with the full resolution sensitivity that Hubble offers.
So that's certainly the earliest, most memorable one.
But since then, there's just been countless comet observations.
I've been involved with, there was one a few years ago called Shvossman-Vakman 3,
which broke up similarly into a string of pearls
and was just one of the most stunning, you know, breakups of a comet ever seen.
And also Comet Holmes, which was just a ridiculously bright eruption of a comet.
And a whole bunch that I'm sure I can't think of.
I think John Yang Lee can probably remember a few more.
And certainly we expect to have many more going forward.
So Hubble's been pretty active then in looking at comets.
Now the other one, the SW3 one, I don't pronounce it the long way because I don't even try.
But that one's actually going to be in the longer version of the video that I'm making
where I talk about that string of pearls you were talking about.
Alberto, you just had that image of Shemek Levy 9.
That was Shemek Levy 9.
And it was an observation of, you know,
you remember that probably Shemek Levy 9 was very, very interesting.
At least I remember it very, very clearly
because it's actually smashed into something, which is Jupiter,
which is fortunate for us.
It's very fortunate for us because it's like a giant vacuum cleaner
that helps us not being wiped out of the face of the planet.
But, yeah, this was observations of the scars, if you will,
that a Hubble observer of the southern part of Jupiter has comet Shemek Levy hit.
That was astonishing.
But Max is right.
I mean, Hubble has been at this for many, many years, and there are quite a few.
I don't know them all.
Maybe others can intervene.
Actually, you brought up a really good point that I'd like Bonnie to comment on for just a second.
Jupiter acts as a kind of solar system vacuum cleaner.
Can you expand on that just a little bit?
Because that's an interesting point, I think.
Jupiter actually protects us quite a bit, doesn't it?
Yeah, it's this gatekeeper to the inner solar system because it's so massive.
So how does it do it?
Is it just because it has a gravitational field that keeps things diverted
or it just happens to draw things into itself so that it gets smashed into it
instead of other planets?
Yeah, basically it grabs things gravitationally,
diverts them off their original course,
and sometimes those things change their overall orbits,
and they come back around and hit Jupiter itself,
or sometimes they're captured into these little communities of asteroids
that flank Jupiter in its orbit.
And sometimes they're tossed way the heck out of the solar system altogether.
So it does a good job of protecting what's inside of the orbit.
So that's all of the terrestrial planets.
I wonder how likely it would have been we would have survived
had Jupiter not been there.
I never really thought of it like that before, so I think it's pretty close.
So maybe calling it a vacuum cleaner is not actually very nice.
You should call it something of the savior or some sort.
Jupiter the savior? I don't think I want to go there.
No, but it has a stabilizing effect on who gets hammered by comets or something.
It's our Jovian big brother protecting us out in the playground out there.
Yeah, keeping all the bullies away from us.
There you go. That's much better than savior, yes.
Jovian big brother. Okay, so there you go, folks.
A new role for Jupiter, our big brother, our really, really big brother.
Okay, so one of the interesting things about comets in general,
and we'll get to comet ISON in just a minute,
that I think is an important topic is when we started tracking comet ISON
and we decided we were going to make this blog
and we were going to do some articles and some topics on the blog.
The first thing we do is we did some Google searches
to find out what other people were asking,
and of course one of the big ones is, is comet ISON going to hit us?
Now, I don't want to talk about that directly,
but I want to talk about the more, at least not right now,
because we'll get into it a little bit later.
But right now, I would like to address this issue of comets actually hitting a planet,
especially one like Earth, is actually not a bad thing,
because it can bring some important things for life on Earth here.
At least that's the theory, right?
Anybody care to comment on that?
Yeah, I can just add one comment,
which is the way I always put it is that comets,
and you could say asteroids as well,
they giveth and they taketh away, right?
It's a part of the story of how the Earth got its oceans.
There's no reason to think the Earth had water early on,
and I think a big scientific question, still an open question,
is how Earth got its oceans.
Comets clearly seem to probably play a role in that,
but they don't seem to answer the entire question.
So it might be, again, what giveth life on Earth, right?
We need water on Earth to have life and to have us.
And then, of course, you're familiar with the event
that caused the extinction of the dinosaurs,
an asteroid or comet impact that can wipe out life.
So depending on the timing, it can either giveth or taketh away,
and either way, they clearly have a big role to play
in the story of life on Earth.
Well, I think a great question about that, too,
is what's the difference between a comet and, say,
something like this that smashes into the Earth?
So a meteorite coming down, they're different,
and maybe people don't understand the difference
between a meteor and a comet.
Can we go into what the difference between them is
and why they would do different things with an impact?
Sure. I mean, a meteor is a very small particle.
I mean, most of the meteor streaks you see in the sky
are probably like a dust fleck or maybe a piece of gravel.
Obviously, the Russian meteorite was larger than that,
but that was a pretty rare event.
And quite often, what they are is the particles
left over from a comet, you know,
kind of in the trail of a comet that we plow through.
The reason they occur, you know, the ones that occur
on a regular date in the year, it's because a track,
think of it as like a horse that's been running around
the same track and leaving a trail.
And, you know, once a year, we plow through that trail
and we get a meteor shower.
But again, those are very small particles,
so not like, you know, like an entire comet
or an entire asteroid.
I'm sorry, if I may add something to what Max has said.
Yeah, please.
For a lot of, actually, all the meteorites,
they have to survive the atmosphere,
survive a passing atmosphere.
So they have to have some strength.
They have to be strong enough.
And those meteorites mostly come from,
actually mostly come from asteroids rather than comets.
And those particles that jet off from comets,
they mostly just stay very weak.
I mean, by weak, I mean, you know,
if you take a part of it and put it on the ground,
it will collapse right away.
So for that kind of strength,
it's very hard for them to pass the Earth's atmosphere.
Most of them just burnt out when they passed the atmosphere,
making the fireball that we see.
And also, right now we consider that a lot of meteor showers
are actually caused by the bigger particles,
like centimeter-sized or millimeter-sized particles
are left over, left out in the tray of comets,
in the orbit of comets.
And when Earth passes the comet's orbit,
a lot of stuff falls into the atmosphere
and make a meteor shower.
So those comets, are they the ones that were the short period,
the ones that make return visits?
We're going to get to the different kind of comets in a minute.
But the comet, the meteor showers that we see,
you say were particles left over
from some of the comets that have gone by.
Do these tend to be the periodic comets
that leave debris in certain spots in space,
or are they all comets?
Well, potentially all the comets
have the ability to make meteor showers.
All the comets are losing particles in their orbits.
And as long as Earth passes their orbit,
Earth's orbit and the comet's orbit cross,
when Earth passes the orbit,
there will be a chance of a meteor shower.
So, you know, comet ISON actually,
I mean, Earth will pass comet ISON's orbit in January,
and that will be another story.
We might have some kind of meteor shower from ISON too.
Okay, so there's different kinds of comets.
I alluded to this just a while ago.
We have these comets that make return visits.
They come around, and they're called shorter period comets.
Then we also have long period comets.
Bonnie, can you comment a little bit
on the difference between those kinds of comets?
Short period comets tend to come from the Kuiper Belt,
which is that region of icy bodies
just outside of Neptune's orbit.
And so those come back on a regular basis.
They come in periods of, say, under 200 years.
So human history actually has a record
of these things reoccurring.
A good example is Halley's Comet.
It last appeared in 1986.
So everyone, my little sister was born in 1986.
Everyone in her class was named Halley.
So I imagine that might happen on comet years
for these popular short period comets.
Long period comets come from much farther out
and are usually on a one-time trip
through the inner solar system.
So those things come from the Oort Cloud,
which is this huge outer sphere of icy debris
that stretches as far as 50,000 times
as far away from the Sun as the Earth is.
So is that the right way to pronounce it?
I always say Oort. Am I saying it wrong?
I've always said Oort, just because it's easier.
I turned that into two syllables.
Is that okay? Is that proper, or is that wrong?
No, it's completely wrong.
I don't know. I'm just joking.
I did Oort, yeah, the Oort Cloud.
Oort, Oort, okay.
So those are longer period.
They tend to have these orbits that are parabolic
or hyperbolic, and they only come through once,
generally, right?
They wreak all kinds of mischief, and then they leave.
And that brings us to Comet Ison, right?
What kind is it?
Ison is a long period comet.
Ah, so it came from the Oort Cloud.
Yes.
But one thing, maybe it's important to actually notice
that I think the Oort Cloud is also a reservoir,
as Bonnie mentioned, but it's a gigantic reservoir.
I was reading numbers where they might count
the trillions of these objects just sitting out there
waiting to be disrupted gravitationally
and then fall in this very hyperbolic orbit,
which I find actually mind-boggling.
Yeah, agreed.
So let's talk, okay, let me get Zolt in on this a little bit.
So Zolt, you released an image of this comet.
Actually, you released several.
Why don't you talk about some of the images you put out
of this comet that came from Hubble?
Sure.
Let me, yeah, we've released a few.
Okay, here's, Albert just got one up.
That's the latest one.
Okay, the latest one.
Yeah, let me talk about that one first.
Okay.
It's the freshest, and we're highlighting that,
excuse me, on the blog right away.
So let me share my screen.
I've just got a few.
I have it up already, Zolt.
Oh, you do?
Yeah, I have it up.
It's already embiggened.
Okay.
So this image is actually a little different
from ones we've done before for a couple of reasons.
As you can see, it's in color.
So we took images through different colored filters,
two different colored filters, and composited them
into a color composite image.
So that's why you see some of the stars are bluish
and some of the stars are reddish, and in fact,
you see other stuff in the background.
You see galaxies and you see some stars.
So it's a little bit different image from Hubble,
at least, of a comet.
You see a comet fairly small in a larger field of view
with this background of stars and galaxies.
Yeah, that truly is a view that only Hubble can provide.
I mean, that's amazing.
Well, at least of this comet right now.
And the other unusual thing about this image
was that we tracked not on the comet this time
but on the stars.
And comets, as rapidly moving solar system objects,
they move pretty fast across the sky in relative terms.
And so even in a fairly short exposure of a few minutes,
the comet actually trails across the field of view.
So if you look closely, and in fact,
if I do share my screen and show another slide here.
Okay, we're looking at it now.
Okay, so here's the image again.
Right.
But this slide shows all the images we took.
So we actually took five separate exposures.
So there are three exposures in one filter at the top.
There was a visible light filter
in the sort of yellow-green part of the spectrum.
And on the bottom, there are two images that are...
Wait, we're not looking at that.
All we can see is the second slide.
We see the one that says April 30, 2013.
Yeah, are you doing a slide show?
Yeah.
Yeah, unfortunately, that doesn't tend to work.
There you go.
Now we're looking at it.
Okay, now you can see it?
Yeah.
Okay, I'll just show it like this.
Yeah.
So anyway, we took five images.
The three images in V are at the top
and two images in red are at the bottom.
And if you were to look closely at that,
you might see that the comet was moving,
but it's a little hard to see in the separate images.
So in this image, however...
Maybe I can make this a little bit bigger.
There, that's real nice.
Okay.
So these are all the images through each filter composite.
So there are three images in the V filter.
And as you can see, the comet looks kind of funny.
It's actually got this sort of L-shaped little patch.
The stars are nice and pinpointed
because we were tracking on the stars.
But while we were tracking through the three exposures,
the comet moved a little bit.
And like I said, this is not the way comets are usually observed.
We want to actually have the comet be as stationary as possible,
so we usually track on the comet.
But in this case, we wanted to get this background,
this background of stars and galaxies fairly deep
and show the comet in front of it.
But the comet did move.
However, with a little bit of, I won't say trickery exactly...
NASA trickery?
Oh, I knew it!
I knew it!
A little bit of manipulation.
We were able to...
Well, first of all, we applied color to the two images.
So we applied a blue color to the V filter image
and a red color to the I band, or red image,
and composited those together to make the color composite.
So this is the original color composite.
You can see that the comet is a little bit funky there.
Yeah, I can see the L shape now that I saw the other ones.
Yeah.
But what we did was we actually replaced that comet image
with one of the exposures where the comet was trailed the least.
Well, you just took all kinds of liberties here.
We just...
Okay, we didn't make it exactly.
But, you know, we tried to make a nice looking image.
And we cleaned it up a little bit.
There's some retouching done.
There's some artifacts from the chip gap and other things
that we cleaned up a little bit.
And that's something I think you bring up a good point.
Let's talk about that just a little bit,
because I don't think people appreciate...
Well, maybe some people do,
but there's this idea that these images just sort of come out of a telescope like this.
And they really don't, do they, Max?
I mean, they really don't have these real pristine sort of colors to them
and everything else.
The way they come out of the camera,
at least off the Hubble Space Telescope,
is actually kind of messy, aren't they?
I mean, that's one of the things you do
is you help kind of clean them up a little bit, right?
That's right.
I mean, I could screen share as well here
to show what the data looks like before it gets to Zolt's desk.
So I'm going to switch here to screen share mode.
Okay.
So I might be able to show with a little bit higher resolution as well
what Zolt was talking about.
So this first image I'm showing you here
is just one of the long visual band exposures.
And I think you can see right there,
you can see the comet tail looking about the same,
but you can see the comet nucleus,
instead of being a nice dot,
is a little bright line at about a 45-degree angle.
And that's because it moved during the exposure, right?
That's right.
So we took a long exposure.
That's why we got, you know,
you need a longer exposure in order to detect all those stars
and especially the galaxies in the background.
How long was it?
Do you know?
Yeah, this was something like 200 seconds, something like that.
Okay.
So that's how much the comet moves in that amount of time
during this long exposure.
And then if I go to the next one,
so then you stop that exposure, you take another one,
and you can see the comet has moved.
That's the next exposure.
Then I'll click to see the next one,
and you can see it's kind of turning a corner there in the L,
and I'll explain that in a second.
And the next one and the next one.
And if I go to the, let's see,
here's sort of the L image that Zolt was showing.
Oh, wow.
All of them together.
So the comet itself is moving in a linear fashion,
and the reason it looks a little bent like that
is because Hubble itself is moving as well.
During one orbit,
Hubble goes from one side of the Earth to the other,
and so that's called parallax,
which you experience yourself with something that's close to you,
and you move your head side to side.
The thing that's close to you
moves more than something that's farther away,
and so you get that sense of perspective.
So that weird motion you see there
has more to do with the motion of Hubble
than with the motion of the comet itself.
Now, just to show you how messy the image is
to get back to your original point,
I'm going to pull up the same version of this image.
Now, this is after I've cleaned it up quite a bit,
so now I'm going to switch to more what that image looks like
before I've cleaned it up, and what do you see?
Ah!
What a mess.
So this is a raw image, right?
This is what comes out of Hubble.
Right.
So we've been looking at cleaned-up images,
and it takes some effort,
and this last one I'm showing you right now
shows all the junk before I clean it out.
So what are you seeing here?
You've got a mixture of the real stuff,
the comet, the stars, the galaxies,
but then you've got all these big things,
these bright things here,
like this big bright one going right through the comet tail,
and there's an even brighter one right up near the comet.
Those are called cosmic rays.
And all these little flecks, too.
It looks like salt and pepper has been shaken all over the image.
You know, one of the reasons we put a telescope
above the Earth's atmosphere
is the Earth's atmosphere protects us
from all that radiation out in space.
So it's great that life on Earth wouldn't be possible
if the atmosphere wasn't protecting us,
but, of course, you get up above the atmosphere
to get above the blurring effects of the atmosphere,
and now you're exposed to that radiation.
So while we're taking this 200-second exposure,
all this radiation is flying right through the telescope
and peppering every image with these cosmic rays that you see.
And then, of course, there's also detector artifacts.
No camera is perfect,
so there's all kinds of, in a sense,
junk coming from the camera itself
that needs to be cleaned out.
Bad pixels, hot pixels, things like that, right?
Exactly.
And so that's why we take many exposures,
is to not only gather information
in different wavelengths of light, as Zolt described,
to make a color image.
We have different filters.
But we also, within a filter, take multiple exposures
so that we can combine them.
And by comparing the images to each other,
if I take, you know, three or four images in a row
that should be identical,
the stars and the comet and the galaxies
will all be in the exact same place,
but the cosmic rays will be in random locations
so that you can compare the images and say
anything that's in all the images must be real,
and anything that's in random locations
must be cosmic rays and reject it,
and that's how you get a clean image.
So you can see we are contending with quite a bit here,
and sometimes you're lucky in the sense that
you really don't want a bright cosmic ray
going right over the top of your image.
It might be tough to clean out.
You might notice in some of these images,
I'm just going to click through to one,
but for the red exposures, we didn't take as many.
We only took two, and that makes it harder to clean up.
And you'll notice right above the two comet trails here,
there's a pretty bright cosmic ray.
There's that really bright one.
I couldn't get it completely cleaned out.
So it's just sort of a cautionary tale
that no astronomical images are perfect.
There can be artifacts, you know,
hanging around that, you know,
you might look at an image like this
and get excited about and think,
well, that's something to do with this comet,
when in fact it's just a random cosmic ray
that didn't get cleaned all the way out.
Well, I was going to say it might have been a spaceship
or something right behind it.
You know, it's an important point to make
because we have been inviting, normally, historically,
it's mostly professional scientists
who've been getting into our archive, you know,
people who use Hubble getting into our archive,
but we have been inviting the whole world in there
to, you know, have a look at our data.
And, of course, it just requires, you know,
a few more skills in terms of understanding
what you're seeing and interpreting data
and looking at raw data, as I pointed out in the last one,
there's a lot of junk there.
You know, the untrained eye might get excited
about what they see, thinking that this long streak
is something more exciting than just a cosmic ray.
But, so, and that's why we actually provided,
actually posted our cleaned up images.
There's a link to it from the blog
and also from the press release.
So people who are interested in playing
with the actual data in FITS format,
if you don't know what FITS format is,
you probably don't want to do that.
But, you know, a lot of amateur astronomers,
a lot of amateur astronomers,
including professional astronomers,
are familiar with that.
And so kind of getting at the data behind the image,
you know, you can follow that link
to actually get my version of the data,
which took a lot of careful processing.
Unfortunately, our routine pipeline
doesn't do such a great job,
so it really requires a lot of offline,
you know, tender loving care to get the image,
you know, cleaned up image like you see.
Okay, but don't give away too much of our punchline
because that was, that whole topic
is going to be in another Hangout
that's coming a little bit later,
either early next month, I think,
or sometime next month.
So we're going to be talking about
getting Hubble ISIN data
the way Max is talking about right now
and just in a future Hangout.
So we definitely want you to stay tuned for that one.
So, okay, well, I got to move on
to something different here
because one of the things you can do
when you're in a Hangout with a bunch of other people
is you can kind of see that there's this little chat window
that you guys don't get to see but that we do
and this is where everybody makes fun of everybody else
when, you know, like they call me names
or I call Scott a name or whatever.
But there's actually a really cool conversation
going on on the side here
where Scott was reading one of the comments
and the questions
and so,
can you guys kind of talk about what you're chatting about
over here? Scott, go ahead.
Yeah, so the question posed was by
Budini Samarasinha and she's asking
what's the most dramatic example
of terraforming that can be attributed
to a comet, either Earth or another planet
within the solar system?
Thanks.
Well, I think the terraforming in the
sci-fi sense where we go to another
planet and
make it like Earth, that really doesn't
happen. But comets and
all the other small bodies in the
solar system are always terraforming
so to speak. They're always changing
the surfaces of planets.
So, look at the Moon,
all those impact craters.
Mars is full of impact craters, as is Mercury
and a lot of the icy satellites
around
the outer planets, Jupiter, Saturn,
Neptune and Uranus.
And so, there's all kinds of
examples of these impact craters.
And Zhang Yang, you also
had a comment on there. I want you to
say what you were typing in there as well.
Yeah, I was going to say
a very similar thing as what Bonnie just
said. Comets are basically
too small to contribute any
significant mass on any planet.
Mostly, comets are just a few
kilometers in size. And the largest
comet we know so far is Hell
Ball, which I think has
a radius of 35
kilometers. And in comparison,
the Earth has a radius
of 6,400
kilometers. So, that's huge.
So, in that sense,
I don't think comets will make
any significant contribution to make any lands
on any planets.
Maybe they don't contribute a lot to the land
area or actual
real estate, but they do add
a lot of chemistry, right? I mean, there's a
lot of chemical contributions
that they make. Do you have an idea
of the percentage? I mean, we have a planet
that's forming. It's got an atmosphere. These comets
are bombarding it. Let's say, I guess, the early
Earth had a pretty
toxic atmosphere early on and comets
started hitting it. Is it a majority
of an effect or is it just a minute
effect?
Maybe it's impossible to predict. I don't know.
Well, we have to know that the Earth
atmosphere
is only a very, very small part of
the total mass of the Earth. So,
in that sense, comets just need to
contribute a tiny bit of organic
or water to
the Earth to make a very thin
biosphere.
So, it's not
measuring how much
mass or how much percentage.
It's measured by its importance.
Right now, we think
probably it's just the comets
or some kind of asteroids that deliver
organics to the Earth or water
that makes life. That's the importance.
That doesn't matter how much it is.
So, is it adding just more
diversity of the chemistry to
the
iron-nickel planet
that's forming there? It's just adding
some additional chemistry that wasn't necessarily there
because it was outside the frost line
when it was forming?
Yeah, I think most importantly, maybe water
because
very early on the Earth,
it's very hot and there are
volcanics everywhere. I think Bonnie may want to say
something about this.
That kind of high temperature will drive out
all the water, at least on the surface,
near the surface of the Earth.
Later, when the Earth cools down
and cools down to the current temperature
or slightly higher than now,
it can retain liquid water
or water vapor.
At that time, some kind of
comets
or other
things impact the Earth
that deliver the water.
That's what we currently think
about how water
originates from the Earth.
All of it?
I don't know. It's hard to say.
That's a pretty big comment.
The comets make it rain, huh?
That's what's going on.
Scott brought up a term
and he didn't define it. He said the frost line.
Who wants to tell us what that is?
Nobody?
I can tell you what it is.
At least someone knows what it is.
Our credibility is about
to be wiped out there.
I was deferring
by all coverage.
That's rule number one.
Don't be polite. Just go.
I won't be polite.
The frost line
is the line
the distance from the sun
at which certain
I'm going to use another word, volatiles
can exist.
A volatile
is
water is a volatile.
There's a lot of other sorts of ices
and things that are in the outer solar
system that are considered volatiles.
They're things that you add a little bit of energy
to them and they evaporate
or sublimate and go away.
They don't like
to exist around heat.
When you're close enough to the sun
you're not going to be able to
exist as a volatile.
That sets up the frost line.
In our solar system
the frost line is outside
of
I don't know
exactly where the frost line lies.
It's somewhere
around Mars-ish.
It's actually around
2.5 AU
or 2.5 times the distance between
the earth and the sun.
That's actually where Comet ISON is now.
It's right there at that frost line.
Comet ISON is
working on crossing the frost line now.
That's one of those important
things. That's why we care
about the frost line as it relates to comets
because we get this beautiful
tail on a comet
and the coma and all of that
stuff starts
to appear as the comet gets
closer and closer to the sun.
These things are warming up
and these volatiles are coming off
of the nucleus itself
and making
the real structure of what we think of as
a comet.
Since ISON is
now crossing the frost line
does it mean its tail is going to be
a lot bigger and brighter now?
That's what we all hope, right?
Yeah, that's what we all hope.
Exactly.
We can't see it, unfortunately, right now.
It's not saying that Comet ISON
was not active before it crossed
the frost line. It's just saying that
within the frost line
water will be sublimated much faster
than it was before it crossed
the frost line.
Before that, there was possibly
volatiles that were sublimated at much
lower temperature,
most likely the carbon dioxide
or carbon monoxide.
That's what we think.
Now that we're
getting on to more, what do you got there, Alberto?
You've got stuff.
I was distracted by the frost line
and that's why I didn't answer immediately.
Bonnie did the right thing.
I was thinking how much water
is there on Earth compared to the entire mass of the Earth.
The number is a fraction of a percent.
I remember there was a nice graph
that showed if you took the entire
water on Earth and made it into
a little sphere, how would it compare to the size of the Earth?
That's the graph you see.
That big ball is the Earth, just the land.
That little ball right next to it
is if you took all the water off and made a ball
out of it, how big it would be.
What's the little dot?
I don't know.
I think the big dot is actually salt water
and the other dot is actually
fresh water.
Wow, that is a cool graphic.
I remember seeing that a while.
Now we need a dot that shows how many people
are on the planet
and compare it.
Make a ball of 7 billion
people.
That will be the next Hangout.
A ball of 7 billion
people will be on the Hangout.
World record again.
Watch that,
Google+. That's right.
Actually, going back to what
we were talking about in the comment
being active and what Zolt was mentioning and Dr. Lee was
saying, do we have an idea
actually how bright, what are the models
predicted for the brightness of the comet?
I think it was Raya Bagampur
that was asking, what are the
estimates basically? Do we know?
Well, we don't know
obviously. What are the estimates, right?
Well, you've heard estimates
suggesting that it could
be as bright as the full moon.
I'm sure it's very, none of us
are in the game of estimating the
brightness.
It's based on models and it's
very speculative. It's a very risky prediction to make,
I'm sure.
Here's the thing.
Nobody wants to say.
My question is, I read
as well and it goes from
the brightness of the century is
as bright as the full moon to we don't know.
I understand there's uncertainty,
right? We have more
than one comet we looked at.
What is our record? I guess that's the question I'm asking
to be able to predict it.
Very bad.
Okay.
That's good to know.
Well, I think I know the answer to what is the brightest
comet ever seen on Earth and it must be the one
that killed the dinosaurs.
Yes.
That was the comet of the century.
It just wasn't our century.
I'm guessing
it was incredibly bright on the way
here to time.
That's a good one, Max.
Well, all right. So, Max, you've done it.
That's our segue into the topic.
Will Comet Eisen hit us?
Who wants to
predict? Me. No.
Oh, Alberto's pointing a limb and saying
no.
Okay.
I think we mentioned it before.
Maybe the debris
of the tail, maybe we will
go through some of those debris and those debris
will produce nice meteor showers.
Who knows? Comets do produce that.
So, I have this really
cool animation that they came out with
over at JPL.
Can you guys see it?
So, I'm going to make sure I've got it big
so everybody can see. Let me get the right window.
Yeah, there it is. Okay.
So, here's their prediction
of where Comet Eisen
will go. I'm just going to go play this.
There's music associated with it.
So, I don't know if you can hear that or not.
Here it comes.
Okay, good.
Make some music.
Comet Eisen going around right there.
And, here is where
we're now in December 8th.
And, boom. Right about...
Whoa, it didn't stop. It kept going.
Well, that's what comets do, Tony.
I know, but it didn't...
My animation kept playing. What are you doing?
Come back to me. Okay.
So, right about...
I pushed the pause button and it didn't pause.
So, right about here...
What is it? Well, I got to do this
without...
That's really sad. Okay. Right about here.
That's December 19th.
I can't get it right to January.
There we go. December 25th.
There's Christmas Day.
That's one of the closest days
that Eisen will be. And, look.
See how far away it is?
Many, many millions of kilometers away.
So, this is the closest
the comet will get to us.
So, no. It will not hit us. However,
there is a neat little thing
that it will do that will happen
to the Earth. Right here. Did you see that
the Earth on January 17th
is right on top of this trajectory
where
the comet had gone in earlier in the year?
That is a path
the comet has already taken, and Earth will
pass through that.
So, maybe, just maybe,
there will be a nice little meteor shower
somewhere in the middle of
January 2014
from the particles left behind
when Eisen flew through before.
So, that is the little
animation that I had for that.
Okay. I want to go back to the question
though. Okay. It will not hit us, but, you know,
do we know, do we at least know
how, maybe I asked this
already. I don't know. Do we know
how... Do you pay attention to your own questions?
No, I do pay attention to my own questions, but I guess the question
I had was, do we know if it's even going
to be visible to the naked eye?
I guess this is what lots of people are interested
in knowing, right? Yeah, it's a comet of the century.
It's like the third one.
I mean, you just told me that we don't know how good
our brother is going to be. So, how much
do we know about that?
Go ahead, Max. I think
you're well suited to comment.
There's two basic reasons for the hype.
One, as we talked about earlier,
it's a fresh comet coming in
from the Oort cloud, so a bunch of
fresh volatiles
that have never seen sunlight up close and personal
like this. And also, it's a
sun grazing comet, so it's a comet that, as you
saw in that video, is getting very close to the
sun. Not all comets get that close
to the sun, okay?
Again, but we don't
really know exactly
the makeup of this comet or even the size
of it and things like that, so there's some
variables in there. But those two components
alone, the fact that it's on its first trip
in, so it hasn't been worn down from
previous trips near the
sun, and the fact that it's
going to get so close that it's a sun grazer
has expectations
high. But how high?
It's hard to say. And again,
just to follow up on the point earlier about
being as bright as the full moon,
that doesn't mean it will appear as big
as the full moon.
Otherwise, it would be like
the dinosaurs, right?
And also, I think
in terms of hitting
the Earth, as you saw from the video,
it's not even that close. I mean, there's other comets and
asteroids that have come much, much closer to
the Earth than what you just saw.
And so, in
passing through the trail, obviously
it's not really like a collision. That's just
the particles left over in the trail,
just like every other meteor shower. In fact,
on August 11th and
12th is one of the typical
annual meteor showers where we're passing through
the
trail left by a comet.
And so, again, that's not like
colliding with the comet. That's very small particles
left over, debris left over
from a comet.
Okay, while we're on this topic, I want to get to the
comments. J7409
on YouTube goes, if it broke up
when it's close to the Sun, could a chunk
of it hit Earth? Well, breaking
up is hard to do.
Well, first of all, let me
take a step back. How many think it's going
to break up? Of the planetary scientists here,
how many of you think it's going to break up?
That's a good question. I haven't
been asked to
take a position on that.
Alright, I'm taking bets. I'll be the bookie
on it.
I'll go out on a limb here and say
it's going to break up. Oh, okay.
So,
there you go, folks. Wow.
Bonnie, what do you think?
I want it to break up.
I'll say that I want
for that to happen. It'll be so exciting.
Okay, Zhang Yang, your turn.
We'll get some great pictures, too.
I kind of agree with Bonnie.
I think if it's going to
do something bad,
disappear or break up, then break up is better
than disappear.
Oh, okay.
It sort of appeals to our sense of
action movies and death and destruction.
I have actually a question.
What are the variables that determine
if it's going to break up or not?
Max mentioned that it's a
sun grazing, so it's a first time.
How does
the composition, for example,
play into all of this?
There's two things. You touched on it.
The composition, how tightly
or loosely assembled is it?
We know that a lot of comets
are not tightly assembled. They may be
kind of barely hanging together. It's certainly not like
a chunk of iron that's really hanging together.
It's a mixture of rock and ice.
And then the other thing is when it gets really
close to the sun, there's something
called the Roche limit where
tidal forces, so any two gravitational
bodies have tidal forces between them
and
the tidal forces between the sun and the moon
cause our tides. So it's kind of like
how bodies are tugging on each other.
They're kind of torquing on each other.
And so as a comet gets really close,
a very small comet gets really
close to the gigantic sun,
the sun is exerting gigantic tidal
forces that are exerting
different forces on each side
of the comet and possibly ripping it
apart. Hold on, Max.
I know I don't mean to interrupt you,
but Zolt has to leave. Zolt,
before you go, I just want
to say thank you for the great work
you did on the comet image that
we produced on the blog. It's awesome work.
Are there anything, is there stuff coming up
in the future we can look forward to from
ISON and Hubble?
Well, unfortunately, Hubble
can't look at the comet right now.
We're behind this on the other side of the
sun and nobody else can see it either.
But hopefully when
it's visible again
to Hubble in the October
time, we'll get
some more images.
We'll get some more observations and we should
have some more images coming.
Thank you, Zolt. I know you've got to go.
Thank you for taking the time out to join us.
It was a great time.
Take care, Zolt.
I'm sorry, Max. I didn't mean to interrupt you like that.
I just wanted to say goodbye to Zolt before he left.
That's okay. I was just finishing my
point, but I'll just add to what Zolt was saying
is that there are quite a few programs
approved. We have a few that have
executed already. John Yang Lee
is involved with...
He's leading one of them and the Heritage
team has several that are waiting
for the comet to reappear in October
and November.
Obviously, if the comet breaks up or does anything
else, there may be more proposals submitted
to get even more orbits
with Hubble to observe it.
We actually got a question early in
the Hangout about this
from Tony Burkhardt.
How much time has been given to Hubble
to image Comet ISON?
Your answer to that?
I do have some notes.
The coin of the realm for Hubble is orbits.
An orbit is about
an hour and a half long,
although the whole orbit
may not be usable. It may be something like 50 minutes
or so within an orbit.
I'm looking at... I know there's
several...
I guess four different programs that have executed
already,
but not many orbits so far.
Each one being just a handful
of orbits. I know for us we've only used
two orbits so far.
John Yang can tell you about his program
which executed in April.
Going forward, there's
at least three programs already approved.
One is 12 orbits. Another one
is 12 orbits. Another one is 19
orbits. John Yang Lee is involved
in at least one of those, if not more.
And then the Hubble Heritage team,
we also have
four more orbits to do
observations similar to what we've already seen.
And then we also have one in place to do
what's called a target of opportunity
in case the comet breaks up. Now this is why
I voted for the comet to break up.
Because we do
have a five orbit program
to image the comet
on the event that it starts to break up.
Because that's what Hubble could do best.
OK. And John Yang, you want to tell us
a little bit about your program?
Yes. We had
three Hubble orbits
in April 10th to image the comet.
And the main purpose of that
observation was actually to measure the size
of the nucleus. Because
everybody cares about whether
the comet's going to survive the
period, it's going to break up,
or whatever it's going to do.
And the size of the nucleus is
actually the determining factor.
So that's what we did with our
observations. But unfortunately, it looks
like the comet, the size
of the nucleus is going to be very small.
Right now we have a very conservative
upper limit of two kilometers.
Two kilometers, you said?
Yeah. Two kilometers in radius.
That's the upper limit. That's not the size.
That's the upper limit. So it's not going to be bigger
than two kilometers in radius.
And so it could also be
much smaller. We don't know yet. We're still working on
our data. So you're saying that
the size of the nucleus is
related to whether or not it's going to break up?
Well, no.
Actually, I'm sorry.
That's one factor.
If it's too small,
it's going to be front-dropped
very soon, very quickly.
Right.
That means it's going to disappear during
her hitting passage. And whether it's going to break up
or not, that's related to
the closest point, to the distance
of the closest point to the Sun.
And what I can tell you is that
actually,
comet ISON is going to pass the point
where it's just the
boundary of the region
inside of which it's going to break up
and outside of which it's not going to break up.
And we know there's uncertainty for this region.
So that's why we say we don't know
whether it's going to break up.
All right. So, Scott, you have
a question here in the chat.
Go ahead.
This is from Twitter. This is from
Cosmos4U. It looks like Daniel Fisher.
And this is for the NASA
diagram, and I can put the link into the event page.
It implies that radio observation
devices are possible right now.
Are those underway? Does anybody know?
Actually, I don't know.
I don't know much
about it, but I think
this is from when I talked to my
friends who are working on radio astronomy.
And I think right now it's
probably still too faint for radio observation.
OK. Here's the
image.
You have it?
Here's the image you're talking about. So what are we looking at here?
When will it be observable?
Oh, I see. And then there's
different wavelengths.
At the bottom down here, there is
where it'll be visible
in optical, and a little bit higher up, it'll be
in radio. And it started, it
looks like, back in April or so.
Yeah.
So it looks like it should be observable
now in radio waves. But
yeah, I don't know the answer.
Yeah, that's like
from one of my presentations.
And this is originally made by my colleague
Matthew Knight. Oh, OK.
Oh yeah, there's your name. You're right.
You're right there on it.
So explain this thing.
Explain this graph.
Well, you know, what this graph shows
is that it's just
the geometry. And we know that
optical telescopes can point too close
to the sun. But radio telescopes,
and IR telescopes can.
So that's what we show
here. You know,
the shaded areas are when the comet is too close
to the sun. So we cannot look at it
with any optical telescopes, including Hubble.
And radio can get very close
to the sun. So that's why you have, you see
the continuous green arrows.
So in that region, radio can
look at it. But it's also, it's
still limited by the brightness.
The brighter it is in radio wavelength,
the easier we can see it.
So I kind of doubt whether
radio can see it now because it's
still very thin. And then
we have the IR. And then when it's very
close to the sun and it's within the field of view
of the solar telescopes, that's where
solar telescopes are going to look at it.
That's within the perihelion in November.
Do you know if someone
is going to do any LIDAR
observations of it?
What's LIDAR, Alberto?
Mr. Jargon Master?
Yeah.
Basically, we shine
radio waves. It's like a radar
basically. We just shine radio waves. We wait
for it to come back. And from the
delay, we figure out the shape, for example.
We do this with asteroids. We figure out the shape
in there. So I don't know if you can do it on a comet.
Is it going to be close enough for us to do it?
You have to do it very close
to the comet. So I don't think
Okay. I don't know.
And then I'm going to figure out what LIDAR means actually.
I think it's with laser.
Yeah.
Instead of radio.
I forgot the acronym.
It's an acronym within an acronym.
I know because LASER is an acronym itself.
I know. I love those.
I heard you like acronyms.
I put acronyms in your acronyms.
Yeah, exactly. Recursive acronyms.
Those are great.
Well, guys, we are out of time. I want to thank
everybody for joining us.
Dr. Mankiw, thank you.
Max, thank you for showing up.
Dr. Lee, we really appreciated
having you here.
This has been great. We're going to have another one.
Stay tuned for another
Hubble Hangout. I don't know if it will be the next
one because we might do something in between.
There will be a Hubble Hangout coming up
on getting your own comet
ISON data.
Is it MAST or HLA, Max?
MAST.
From the MAST archive.
Mikulski.
Archive for Space Telescopes.
Thank you.
Too many acronyms.
Yes.
Max will be on hand, I think,
to help us sort through that and get
some Hubble data for ourselves and be able to play
things. Look out for that.
Also, look out for my video on
whether or not comet ISON will hit us.
That will be coming out in the next 24
hours or so. I'll be posting it to the Hubble
Site Channel YouTube channel.
Make a Vine version of it. Six seconds.
No.
It will be real quick with Alberto going,
no.
With Grumpy Cat right next to him.
Thank you.
I want to thank you guys
all for attending. Alberto, Scott,
as always, it's been a lot of fun.
Thank you for joining us. I really appreciate it.
We'll be back for another one very soon.
Hubble Huggers.
Stay tuned.
We'll see you soon.
Thank you for watching.
As always, keep looking up.
