News from Hubble and Across the Universe! February 2014

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
It's time once again for +Tony Darnell and Dr. +Frank Summers to get you caught up with the latest happenings from around the universe and from the #Hubble Space Telescope.
We missed January because of the AAS meeting, but now that's over and there's lots of really cool stuff to catch up on. We hope you can make it, but if not, you can always watch it later on our YouTube Channel.
Please leave your question or comments for us as well and we will discuss them during the hangout. See you there!
Hello everyone and welcome to our latest Hubble Hangout.
Sorry we're just a little bit late.
My name is Tony Darnell and I'm the Social Media Manager
at Space Telescope Science Institute.
And today with me, as he usually is during at least once a month,
is Dr. Frank Summers, also from the Space Telescope Science Institute.
And he is here to give us our monthly update on some of the news
from across the universe and from Hubble.
And we nominally try to do this every month,
but we missed January because the AAS was going on
during the same time when we usually do this.
So we missed January, but we're back for February
and we should be back on track for our regular schedule for these kinds of things.
So thank you guys for joining us.
A couple of ways you can interact,
we've got the Q&A app running on the event page here at Google+.
So I'm looking at your questions and I already see some of them.
And you can also tweet with us using the hashtag HubbleHangouts
as well as leave comments on the event page itself
because we're monitoring all of that.
So we hope that you will have some questions for us
as we move on a little bit later on in the broadcast.
So Frank, we had a little bit of technical difficulties,
so we finally sorted those out.
I think that Logitech and Microsoft are somehow in some sort of battle
to see who can screw up each other's system the worst.
Oh, I know. I had a hard time.
You wouldn't believe the panic I was in.
At 3.30 I went to go start the Hangout
only to find out the event had disappeared.
And nothing I did would let me find the event.
So I was a little bit in a panic.
I somehow got it back.
So I'm here and we're able to do this.
So sorry about the four-minute delay on that, folks.
So Frank, before we get started, I have a quick question for you.
You're obviously an astronomer.
You've been doing this for quite a while.
You work in the Office of Public Outreach as an educator.
And also you work on scientific visualizations an awful lot.
But when you first got started, maybe when you were a grad student,
did you have any astronomical research interests?
Did you have an area that you studied in astronomy itself?
Or were you always doing outreach or visualizations as your main focus?
No, actually.
I did my Ph.D. at the University of California, Berkeley.
And the, I don't know, sometime during the first year I was there,
Mark Davis, as you go through your coursework first,
and as you start looking for a research mentor,
Mark Davis was looking for a programmer.
And I was very good at computer programming.
And in particular, he did N-body simulations of how galaxies form in the universe.
Now, he was doing, he and his, what, the famous gang of four in astronomy,
did just gravitational simulations of how material in the universe gathers together,
which could form galaxies.
But they didn't have any gas in the simulations.
And so he was bringing on a post-doc named Gus Everard
to do smooth particle hydrodynamics.
And he wanted a graduate student to work with Gus and him
on these cosmological simulations of how galaxies form,
involving both gravity and the gas dynamics.
And that's where I did my research for, I don't know, the next 10 years,
with Mark and Gus and various other things,
and doing cosmological simulations,
taking educated guesses at the distribution of matter in the early universe
based upon the cosmic microwave background and other ideas,
and then evolving it forward in time to see what type of galaxies form,
how many galaxies, how large galaxies, how small galaxies,
and seeing if we could get, reproduce the galaxy distribution,
the types of galaxy shapes, et cetera, that we see in the observed universe.
So I was a cosmologist.
Well, thanks for that.
I was curious because I know that ever since I've known you,
you've been doing these visualizations and doing the outreach
and teaching work that you've been doing.
But I was just curious about where you started.
So it wasn't a big leap then for you to go from these simulations,
these multi-layer simulations that try to describe the universe
to go on into visualizations.
It seemed like a pretty natural progression there.
It was exactly that.
I was at Princeton doing a post-doc,
and we had this grand challenge cosmology consortium,
a whole bunch of people who did these kind of simulations.
And we were approached by a group that wanted to do an IMAX film.
The IMAX film was Cosmic Voyage.
And they wanted to do a sequence in time showing the formation of the universe,
the Big Bang, all the way through the formation of galaxies,
up through the creation of the Milky Way and Earth and so on,
and all the way through the development of life to man.
And so they said, well, tell us what the early universe looked like
so our artists can draw it.
And we said, well, let us show you in our simulations.
So we showed them some visualizations from our simulations.
They looked at that and said, wow, that's so complex.
Our artists could never draw it.
Could we do scientific visualizations of the formation of galaxies in the film?
So this was like my second year at Princeton,
and my Ph.D. thesis simulations were sitting there.
And I said, well, I could take these.
And we scaled them up by a factor of 10,
took them out to the National Center for Supercomputing Applications in Illinois,
and ran them on the biggest supercomputer they had.
They had a brand-new supercomputer.
And in this time before it was fully commissioned,
I got to steal a month of CPU time on a supercomputer
to do this simulation 10 times larger than I did previously.
And that's what appears on screen in Cosmic Voyage is my Ph.D. thesis.
Wow. That's really cool. That's a neat story.
That's the transition from simulation to visualization.
And from that project I learned how adept I was at presenting to the public
and translating the science for these presentations.
Most definitely.
Well, that brings us to what we're here to talk about.
So you've got some stories that you've gathered for the past month or so
that you want to discuss.
But before we leave this topic, let me just tell everybody,
as a little bit of a preview, it's not quite ready yet,
but on Hubble site there will be a gallery of a lot of Franks and Greg
and other people at the Institute who have worked very hard on some simulations
coming forth, so we keep an eye out for a new gallery
that has a lot of Franks visualizations in it.
So I wanted to kind of plug that because it's coming down the pike
and we're going to be highlighting a lot of this stuff at South by Southwest
when we're there the first weekend of March.
So we hope you guys, or not the first weekend, the second weekend of March.
So we'll be showing a lot of those then.
So stay tuned for some of this stuff.
Okay, Frank, what have you got this month?
Okay, I'm going to start my screen share and pull up my PowerPoint
and hit the magic button hopefully.
Yes! We have our news from the universe from February 2014.
There we go.
I'm full screen. I can't really see you.
That's okay. I can see. Just go ahead.
Just go ahead and speak up if something goes wrong.
I've got your screen share full screen and we're listening, so go ahead.
All right, so our first story tonight,
and Tony you've got the link for this one for the News Center,
yearbook photos of the Milky Way.
Okay, so this is what our Milky Way looks like.
Actually, when you go out and look at the night sky,
you won't see this because more than likely you're in an urban center
or even in suburbia.
You don't have dark enough skies to see something like this.
But this is if you could take the entire night sky,
unravel it, and put it out onto an image.
This is what our night sky looks like.
And this is the Milky Way,
that band of light running across the center of the image is our galaxy.
And we, of course, live inside the Milky Way,
so we have a really bad view of it
because we're inside the disks, this flat disk,
and all of this dust that you see across the center of this image
is blocking the light.
We can't see through it.
If, however, we could get outside our Milky Way,
this is a map of the Milky Way, an annotated map of the Milky Way.
Now, Tony, can you guys see my mouse cursor if I move around?
Yep.
Okay.
So you can see the sun down here.
This is the center of where we view the universe from.
And to the north of it you can see the center of the galaxy
and the long bar of the Milky Way
and then all these spiral arms,
two of them stemming from the bar and others in the inner arm regions.
And we live in a barred spiral galaxy.
And as astronomers, one of our most important topics
is not just to study things as they are,
you know, we can categorize galaxies,
but really to wonder how did they get to be this way.
What did the Milky Way galaxy look like long ago?
What did it look like in its infancy?
How did it develop this beautiful structure?
Now, when we look out into the universe,
this is two of our deepest fields,
the Hubble Deep Field from 1996 on the left
and the Hubble Ultra Deep Field from 2003 on the right.
And these are very deep images of the universe
and fans of Tony are very familiar with the fact
that as you look out into space,
you're looking back into time
and seeing galaxies as they were billions of years ago.
Now, we can't do this for the Milky Way, right?
But we can use these deep images of the universe
to look at galaxies at progressively greater distances from us
and progressively greater times back in the universe.
So, this is the GOODS survey,
which is about 30 times larger than the original Hubble Deep Field
and has so many galaxies that we're able to assemble
a nice little look into the galaxies across time.
So, the GOODS is another survey run that Hubble did
and it just looked at a larger area of the sky,
very similar to the deep fields?
Yeah, it looked at the...
Actually, the Hubble Ultra Deep Field is this region.
If I drew a rectangle, a diamond in here,
that's actually where the Hubble Ultra Deep Field is.
The rest of the GOODS field was done in not as deep,
but much larger.
It was about 15 times larger than the Ultra Deep Field
and about 30 times larger than the deep field in area in the sky.
And so, what we did is we went in there and we found spiral galaxies
and we knew their red shifts,
so we could tell their distances and their times in the universe.
And so, we made this diagram
showing galaxies out to about 3 billion years ago,
you know, the way they look, right?
And then the middle panel, galaxies from 3 to 7 billion years ago
and then the top panel, galaxies from 7 to 10 billion years ago.
So, using these deep surveys, we're able to look out into space,
back into time and see the development of galaxies.
But there's one other thing you should notice about this diagram,
is that the bottom panel, galaxies are mostly white,
yellow creeps in in the middle panel
and red is dominant, is very strong in the upper panel.
And why is that?
Well, that's because the light that travels across the universe is red shifted.
So, the light of these galaxies is being stretched by the expansion of space
and we're seeing these galaxies in different wavelengths of light.
So, the galaxies that are very distant, their light is started out, say, in ultraviolet
and now gets stretched to visible light.
And so, what you're really doing is you're comparing ultraviolet views of galaxies
in the top with visible light views of the galaxies in the bottom.
And that doesn't really give you a full understanding of it.
What you really want is you want to be able to compare apples to apples,
visible light or infrared light images of the galaxies at different distances,
which means you actually have to observe in different wavelength bands for each distance.
It's kind of complex.
But, Hubble has done a lot of surveys.
So, in this diagram, you can see over on the left in the center,
that's the tiny portion of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field.
And you can see that size compared to the full Goods Field that I just showed you,
which is smaller than the full GEMS survey, another survey done with Hubble.
All of these are surveys done with Hubble and the Advanced Camera Surveys.
And that's even smaller than the giant COSMOS survey that you see on the right,
which you can see is about nine times as large as the full Moon's apparent size in the sky.
So, the larger the survey, generally the less deep you go.
So, you can't go all the way back to the really high redshift stuff that you can get in the Ultra Deep Field.
But, you can get enough to look through for what we were trying to do.
And what we're trying to do is trying to find analogs of the Milky Way at different distances.
So, they went through this. They went through all of these galaxies.
And the other key piece they had to have,
so they went through the COSMOS survey, which you see here on the right.
They have the good survey here on the left.
And then they had the...
Hey Frank?
Yeah?
I'm afraid I'm going to have to stop you for a sec. We're having technical difficulties.
I don't think your screen share is coming through.
All people are saying they're seeing is your icon.
And I wonder if it's because the Internet connection that you had to be on is not up to the task.
I can see it though.
So, when I see...
So, I'm not quite sure why it's not going out.
So, I...
Oh, man.
This has been a lot of difficulties.
I'm seeing it as well.
What's that?
I'm logged in on my other computer.
Are you seeing it?
Yeah.
Oh, okay.
Then perhaps it's working.
I'm just seeing some...
It says we cannot see the diagrams, guys.
This sounds interesting as hell, but we can't see any pictures as they are too small.
And I don't know...
Let me pull up my Hangout and...
Oops, there.
I get the infinite regression of it.
Yeah.
I pulled off my screen share.
Now you can see...
You should be able to see my picture, right?
Okay.
Yeah.
All right.
So, yeah.
They're not able to see it.
I'm getting responses here that they're not able to see your screen share.
I can see it though.
That was crazy because I could see it too.
Pull off my screen share.
So, you guys tell me what you're seeing when Frank does this so that I can better able to see what's going on.
Because I can see it.
So, yeah.
They're not able to see it.
I'm getting responses here that they're not able to see your screen share.
I can see it though.
That's totally crazy.
Now I'm seeing it.
I'm on the Google YouTube page.
So, you guys tell me what you're seeing when Frank does this so that I can better able to see what's going on.
Because I can see it.
If they're only seeing the Microsoft PowerPoint, they're not seeing the overlay?
Hold on.
Let me try this.
How about if I do it from within PowerPoint and I don't bother?
I can see it though.
That's totally crazy.
Now I'm seeing it.
So, in the delay that I'm hearing on your side, do you have it playing somewhere?
I do have it playing there.
Sorry.
And you see your screen share coming through?
I see my screen share coming through.
We'll just keep going because it's got to be working.
I don't know what's going on with the event.
If it's coming through YouTube, then it seems to be.
Okay.
Tony?
Yeah.
I think what they're saying is when I take PowerPoint into a full screen mode, they're just seeing the PowerPoint behind it.
They're not seeing the full screen mode.
Okay.
So, Hugo Burnham is saying that Frank's screen pops up for an instant and then goes back to his icon.
I will tell you, folks, this event has given me a lot of trouble.
At first, when I tried to even find the event, it was telling me it was deleted.
And so, I could not find this event anywhere when I tried to start it.
And I somehow miraculously got there, and now we're just having all kinds of technical issues.
I can see your screen, Frank, just fine.
Right now, it's in Photos of the Milky Way.
Yeah.
And so, if you guys try and go to the YouTube page instead of the event page, maybe that's a better way to go.
I'll post that link here.
Maybe that will work.
See if that works, guys.
Boy, this is really ‑‑ I'm so sorry.
Okay.
I'm seeing it on YouTube.
So, I'm just going to ‑‑ let's just go ahead and go.
Guys, if you can't see it in the event, please go to the YouTube page, and I can see it there.
Frank's screen share is showing up.
So, that would be the place to go.
I think the problem may lie with Google Plus and the event page.
I'm terribly sorry about that, guys.
I really am.
And, Frank, I'm really sorry I had to interrupt your train of thought.
Are you going to be able to pick back up?
Absolutely not.
I'm a diva, so there's no way.
I just can't work in these conditions.
I can't believe you.
I wouldn't believe you for a second.
So, I'm really sorry.
But, yeah, I do see it coming through.
So, folks, I apologize again for the technical errors.
Okay.
So, what do you want me to do?
Where would you like me to start, my friend?
So, let's see.
Well, I got so distracted by trying to troubleshoot the problem, I forgot where you were.
Oh, you had the three images up of the three different stages of galaxy evolution,
and you were saying that the bottom ones are really big.
They're mostly white.
But my question is, are the sizes right, too?
Are they physically larger, or is that just for artistic?
No, the sizes of these galaxies are all scaled to their sizes in the good survey.
Now, of course, the farther away galaxies are going to appear smaller on the sky to a certain extent.
The angular size with distance scale, usually you think of it the further away it is,
automatically the smaller it is.
But if you go far enough away in the universe with the expansion of the universe and the way things happen,
it actually doesn't get much smaller after a point.
So, the difference between the bottom and the middle are definitely strong because of distance
and not as much between the middle and the top.
So, those galaxies at the top, they look kind of ratty.
They don't look so…
They're as they were 8 billion years ago, so that's actually a good piece of time.
Yeah.
A million years doesn't matter to a galaxy.
Galaxies, they don't change much in a million years.
A billion years?
8 billion years?
Yeah, they change a lot, and you can see it in this diagram.
Yeah, and they seem to lack a lot of structure.
They're certainly redder in color and things like that.
But, okay, anyway, that's pretty cool.
Okay, so, next, we were talking about…
Nope, that's actually a slide I deleted.
I'm not going full screen on this.
Do you think I can go full screen on this, Tony?
I think it's fixed.
They're saying that they can see it now.
Okay, well, then let me just keep it the way it is.
Yeah, maybe we shouldn't touch it.
There are a couple of hidden slides that I'll just have to…
That's all right.
This was the slide where I was talking about over here is the size of the HUDF,
and then here's the bigger size of goods, about 15 times the size of HUDF,
and then GEMS, and then COSMOS.
These are various surveys Hubble has done to look out into the universe
and the statistics of galaxies.
These are just larger fields of view, and they sacrifice depth to get that area?
They don't go as deep?
Exactly.
I mean, to do COSMOS at the depth of HUDF,
you'd probably have to give up every observing orbit on Hubble for a year or two.
You just can't get that much time on Hubble.
So given that the maximum size of an observing program on Hubble
is going to be capped at a few hundred orbits,
to do COSMOS, you really can only go so deep to cover that large of a field.
You get better statistics because you cover more things,
but you don't go to the depth in the universe.
Okay?
Yep.
All right.
So the CANDELS survey,
which is the Cosmic Assembly Near-Infrared Deep Extracolactic Legacy Survey,
you can see how hard we astronomers work on our acronyms,
combines stuff from GOODS and COSMOS,
as well as the Extended Growth Strip, the AGES survey,
and another survey that's ground-based called the UDS,
and looks at galaxies inside them.
But what it does also is it gets the spectra of them.
Okay?
Oh, I'm sorry.
CANDELS got uniform observations of these galaxies.
And I'm sorry.
And it combined with the 3D HST survey
that got the spectra of the galaxies in these surveys.
Okay?
So combined with the imaging of CANDELS and the spectra of 3D HST,
the spectra of the galaxies will give you the redshift
and allow you to adjust their wavelengths.
Right?
Because if the light has been redshifted,
if the galaxy is at redshift 2,
the wavelengths that reach you are three times longer
than they would have been when they were emitted.
So you need the spectra to be able to compare apples to apples,
to adjust what wave band you're looking so that you can say,
okay, this image of this galaxy is the same as this image of this galaxy.
We're looking at the same rest wavelength.
Okay?
So the results of that are finally out.
And what we're trying to do is,
given in this diagram that I pulled off the web,
we're going to say what age, here's a gallery of kids,
ages from 0 to 18, and you can see how they change.
Right?
Your voice dropped out, Frank.
Can you repeat the part about the ages?
Okay.
Oh, no.
So in this diagram, they're showing kids from 0 to 18,
and what we want to do is show galaxies like the Milky Way at various ages.
Okay?
So this is what this next diagram is going to show you.
All right.
So this is why I call this yearbook photos of the Milky Way.
They had 10,000 spectra of galaxies,
and from them they called out galaxies that are similar to the Milky Way.
And here on this plot we have the vertical axis doesn't mean anything,
but the x-axis is billions of years ago.
Now, let me note that the x-axis is not linear.
Okay?
One tick mark is 5 billion years.
The next one is 7.8.
Okay?
So the distance between tick marks is not linear in billions of years.
It's probably linear in redshift or something.
They didn't specify what it was.
But don't be fooled by the diagram thinking that it's linear.
But all of these galaxies have spectra that indicate they are similar to the Milky Way,
and they are geared to show the galaxies as they were in a similar wavelength of light.
So what we found out from this study, first of all, it's nice to have a gallery of this,
but that star formation occurred a lot very early on.
Okay?
So you can see that in the 11.1 to the 9.4,
you still have some really bright galaxies coming up in here.
The core of the galaxy is getting bright.
The disk is getting bright.
So we knew that there was a lot of star formation early on.
Here we have a good pictorial representation of it.
And then the second major finding was that the bulges of the galaxies,
the core of the galaxies, and the disk of the galaxy seemed to grow together.
There are some hypotheses such that you'd form the bulge first,
and then the disk would form by later infall.
And that's not what we see in the evidence.
The evidence shows that the amount of light that you get from the bulge
and the amount of light you get from the stars in the disk actually grow together.
All right?
So a galaxy will form a core first, but it will get a disk relatively quickly around it,
and then the two of them will grow together as galaxies grow up.
So the star formation rates in the arms or in the disk and in the bulges
are pretty much the same in terms of…
During their growth periods.
Okay.
The light that will end up through it.
The bulges generally consist mostly of older stars,
so we don't expect star formation rates in the bulge to continue much past
about 7 or 8 billion years ago,
whereas the disk should continue the star formation rate in the disk.
But using that, they're able…
In as much as that, they're able to grow together up through its formation years.
Okay?
Okay.
That's an amazing picture, though.
I like how the galaxies in the early universe are a lot…
You can just definitely see the color characteristics in this picture, too.
It's a lot brighter as well.
Okay.
So let's move on.
Oh, yeah.
And so finally, since that picture was only so pretty,
we had one of our artists here take the present Milky Way on the top of this slide
and modify it so that what would it look like if we were there in the early Milky Way?
And of course, this was well before the Earth even existed,
so we wouldn't have been there, but it's always nice to imagine.
So if there were some planet in the Milky Way, looking with our similar point of view,
you can see that there's more dust in the bottom one,
but there's also more star-forming regions.
The thickness of the bulge and the stars away from it is very thin.
You can see there's not much scattered light above or below the Milky Way in the bottom picture,
and all those pink regions, which are the star-forming regions,
indicate the rapid early star formation.
So just a nice pretty visual to accompany the more scientific graphic we had in the previous page.
So the star-forming regions are those bright pink spots there?
Yeah, the bright pink spots with the white cores.
Wow, that's really neat. That is neat.
And this is our wonderful astronomical artist, Zolt LeVay, doing that.
Oh, Zolt did that. Okay.
Yeah.
Okay.
So next, our next story is Ripples of Light at R.S. Pappas.
Might be a good time for you to put the link up on the page.
Yeah, I'm doing that now.
Great.
Okay, so I need to actually go into – let me see if I – let me try EADGADS.
This is an animated GIF.
Let me – all right, if I go to full screen, is that showing up for you, Tony?
I can see it, yes.
That animated GIF?
Mm-hmm.
Okay.
So this is a Cepheid variable.
It's actually a very famous Cepheid variable.
It's called Hubble's Variable 1,
and it's famous because it was the Cepheid variable in the Andromeda galaxy
that allowed Edwin Hubble to figure out that Andromeda was a separate galaxy
way back in the 1920s.
But what it shows you in this animated GIF is that the light of these variable stars
brightens and dims and brightens and dims.
Okay?
And here are the four images of it.
And especially if you look at the upper right and the lower right,
you can see the distinct differences between these stars.
Between the star, it's the exact same star compared to the other stars in the background.
Right?
So we have these Cepheid variables,
and this plot sort of shows you where those four images were taken,
but it also shows a lot of other observations of that variable.
But the main point is that its brightness goes up and down,
and this can be subtle for being just like half a magnitude of star brightness,
or it can be really strong to about four or six magnitudes of star brightness.
So these variable stars can really get bright and really get dim.
Okay?
Now, that's part one of what we need for this story.
All right?
Part two is exemplified by the star V838 Mon.
And on the left, we see here a picture of this really ordinary nothing of a star before it erupted,
and on the right is a picture of it when it erupted in what we call a nova.
Okay?
It suddenly brightened.
It was a flash brightening, not a periodic brightening like a Cepheid, but a flash brightening.
And then Hubble followed V838 Mon for several years,
and that light from V838 passed out an illuminated gas around the star.
Now, in these pictures that start in the upper left and go through to the one on the right,
it's not gas that's moving out away from the star.
It's rather the light that's moving out away from the star,
illuminating gas that was already there from the beginning,
but wasn't illuminated until the star had this flash.
It's like a light bulb, a flash bulb going off in space,
and that light is expanding in this bubble, illuminating the gas around it.
So it's kind of like standing in a fog bank or something and setting off a strobe or something.
Yeah.
Well, setting off a flash, and if you could watch the light move, propagate across space.
Now, on human terms, light moves much too fast for us to see this,
but in space where you've got light years of space,
it takes a year to cross a light year of space,
so you can actually see the propagation of the light across space.
Okay.
So that's the two components.
You've got a Cepheid variable that rises up and down,
and then you've got this light echo from gas.
All right.
Those two ideas come together in this star.
This is the star RS Puppis.
Okay.
It is a Cepheid variable, and it brightens and it dims on a regular basis.
Plus, RS Puppis, as you can see, is surrounded by gas that is doing this light echo thing.
All right.
The gas is illuminated by RS Puppis, and so we're seeing the light from RS Puppis across it.
Now, what you might notice is you can see these sort of stripes.
See these stripes in the gas?
I do.
Why is this nebula tiger striped?
Because the light echo is going to brighten and dim with the variation in the star.
Like ripples in a pond.
How cool is that?
Okay.
So, all right.
I'm going to do a movie here,
and I gave you the link to the movie so people can see it on their own screens if they can't see it here.
All right.
So, this is the movie, and it starts with the RS Puppis image I just showed you,
and then it zooms into a black and white image,
and then watch those light echoes ripple across the nebula.
All right.
The observations, I think there are only about six or eight of these observations,
so it loops through them over and over again.
All right.
I'm going to play this again because this is just cool.
So, there's another cool thing about Cepheid variables, too, aren't there?
Isn't there another neat little fact about them that has to do with their variations?
You can tell their intrinsic brightness, right, related to their period?
And this is what Hubble used when he was determining the distance to the Andromeda galaxy.
By measuring the pulsation period of the Cepheid,
he could figure out its absolute brightness,
and then once you know its absolute brightness, you can determine distance,
and that's when he found that, you know, by his calculations,
it was, you know, five times farther than the edge of the Milky Way.
You now know that it's, like, 20 times farther.
But, you know, hey, let's not – that's what we didn't know.
There were two types of Cepheids, and he didn't know them at that time.
Right?
Okay.
So, that's that story.
Any other questions on that story, Tony?
Nope.
I'm just reading some of the comments.
I'm just hoping that we're still coming through okay.
Okay.
Now we're doing the third story, an infrared view of the tarantula.
Now, if you took that story title at face value,
you'd imagine I'd show a picture like this.
And this actually is an infrared view of a tarantula.
And tarantulas are ectotherms,
so the temperature of a tarantula is determined by its surroundings.
And so you can see it appears awfully dark or cold in the infrared image
compared to the human that's holding it in their hands.
And their hands of a warm-blooded creature appear bright and warm in infrared light.
But that's not what that title actually said.
The title said infrared view of the tarantula, not a tarantula.
And the tarantula is in this image.
This is the image of the Large Magellanic Cloud from Stéphane Guizart,
a wonderful astrophotographer, does some great stuff.
But he has a nice wide-field image of the Large Magellanic Cloud.
And here is the bar of the LMC across the center.
You can see a little bit of a spiral arm down bottom,
a little bit of a spiral arm up top.
The LMC is actually a disk galaxy,
although the bar is its most prominent feature.
Its second most prominent feature is this big pink region up here.
Just above the bar and to the left is a huge, huge star-forming region
that we lovingly call the Tarantula Nebula.
How big is it?
It is the biggest star-forming region anywhere in the local group of galaxies.
It's larger than any star-forming region in the Milky Way or in Andromeda
or in any of the other two or three dozen galaxies in the local group.
And since the LMC is a dwarf galaxy,
it's only about less than 10% the size of the Milky Way,
that's pretty impressive that it has a star-forming region that big.
So if we look at the Tarantula Nebula in detail,
oops, there's my arrow to show it,
here is Hubble's image that we released of the Tarantula Nebula.
Let me guide you through it a little bit.
Up here, up in the top, just left of center, you can see a big star cluster.
You can see a sort of open region around that star cluster.
There's another one star cluster just to the left of center, a giant star cluster.
And then there's an open region around that.
The star clusters form.
There are high-energy radiation and wind blows into the gas,
creating these loops and bubbles around it.
Over on the right, we've got some much more mature star clusters
where there have been a lot of supernova explosions,
which has also blown away the gas.
There is more star formation going on here than any region in the local Universe.
And it's really cool, except there's a lot of dense gas here.
And in this region right here, for example, I'm going to blow that up,
and here you can see all that dense gas in the Tarantula Nebula.
Now, this dense gas is good because it's the stuff of which stars are made.
The dense gas collapses to form the stars,
but we can't see all of the other stars inside it.
We can't see all the details.
And so we wanted to do a view of the Tarantula Nebula,
but not in visible light, using infrared light.
Because infrared light, with its longer wavelengths,
can penetrate deeper into the gas and see deeper into these star-forming regions,
as well as the lower-mass stars irradiate most in the infrared.
Stars that are just forming, warm gas, emits in the infrared.
So using infrared at the Tarantula would be even better.
So we went back to that image that we had from Hubble,
this huge image, and we tried to cover as much as possible as we could in the infrared.
So here's this small region in visible light.
Now I'm going to go to the infrared.
And you can see just how many more stars you can see,
and how that dark gas sort of slightly disappears.
It's still there.
If we go back to visible light, and then we move to the infrared light,
you can see the detail that you can get by covering it in infrared.
And so at the AAS meeting this year, actually part of a different press release,
we released this image here.
And this image shows the infrared portrait combined with some of the visible light portrait
of the Tarantula Nebula.
By the way, I should also mention that the Tarantula Nebula is also known as 30 Doradas.
When it was originally discovered, people thought it was just a star,
because they had horrible telescopes, and they named it 30 Dor, which would be a star name.
And then when they resolved it, they said, oh no, that's a star cluster.
But the name 30 Dor is stuck.
But the Tarantula Nebula is a nice, more poetic name that I like to use.
So this is the infrared image combined with some visible light.
And it's just, first of all, gorgeous.
I mean, look at all the stars that you can see in here.
It's just amazing.
But as an astronomer, it allows us to see deeper
and gain more of the understanding of how stars form
in this really important star formation region, the Tarantula Nebula.
The reason I'm not talking too much is because I think that I'm getting some comments
that whenever I talk, it automatically switches to me.
But the thing is, I do what I always do to control what's big.
And for some reason, that doesn't seem to be working.
So I'm not commenting as much, only because I want your screen share to be the one that was large.
That was really cool.
So the great thing about your presentations, Frank,
is you always have these really awesome pictures.
And those were just unbelievably beautiful.
So let's get to a couple of comments.
Early on, before we started having technical problems, Craig Landon asked,
what is Dr. Summers' opinion on most worthwhile –
I guess on the most worthwhile NASA ESA missions, ongoing or upcoming?
What is your opinion on some of these – what's your favorite?
Let's go there.
Besides Hubble.
I was going to say, I mean, we work at Hubble, so we're the –
But what else is out there that you really like to pay attention to as far as missions go?
Well, I'm always a fan of the infrared missions.
Of course, me too.
What you just saw with the star-forming regions,
we get to see deep into these star-forming regions, really start to see these things.
Also, you know, protoplanets.
When planets are forming around stars, they're in these dusty disks,
and you have to look inside those dusty disks in order to see what's really going on.
So Spitzer is on its downside.
But the WISE mission, the Wide Field Infrared Survey Experiment,
has produced some really cool stuff.
If you go to the WISE website, they've got some really cool images,
if you just want to see the images.
But it's also doing some really great surveys
of where the most interesting infrared portions of the universe are to look at.
Spitzer did a lot of that.
We go back to the 2MASS, the 2-micron all-sky survey, did a lot of that.
WISE is doing a tremendous job at it as well,
and it does really good science in its own right,
but it's also finding out what are the most interesting objects for J2ST to explore.
That's right, yeah.
That is a really interesting mission going forward.
And so, of course, there's a lot of ground-based stuff.
They're not NASA things, but there's a lot of cool ground-based stuff coming up too,
most notably things like LSST.
And I should point out the Dark Energy Survey is also currently taking a lot of –
they're imaging giant swaths of the sky over 500 nights,
and they're going to be able to look at a lot of different things as well.
Let's see, one more here.
Ken Morrill commented that this presentation was needed
during the Bill Nye versus Ken Ham debate last week.
Did you hear about that?
I heard about that.
I don't know what you thought about it,
but I think Bill Nye took a bit of heat on that one.
He took a little bit of heat.
It's probably not the best thing to do, I guess.
You know, Bill, I'm really glad that people like Phil Plait and Bill Nye
want to engage the crazies,
because somebody needs to talk to the crazies and go,
look, look, look, look, your arguments don't make any sense,
and do it in such a way that the public, the thinking public at least,
can listen to it and go, yeah, their stuff doesn't make any sense.
Yeah.
I'm not willing to waste my time on that.
Well, that's true for a lot of, I think.
But, you know, and we're having a debate about this right now
at the Institute and doing social media stuff more and more now,
and talking with NASA people as well.
It's really challenging to know when to engage and when not to engage,
and these science debates are, well, I won't call that a science debate.
I'll just call it a debate on a topic on the age of the universe
and the various things they were trying to discuss.
But, you know, it's difficult to know where to draw the line.
At some point you want to educate,
but you want to make sure that you're not feeding trolls at the same time.
So, anyway, it's…
Let me tell you the coolest comment I heard about this.
It was from somebody's daughter who said,
well, wait a minute, this is all unfair.
This guy over here gets to just make shit up,
and Bill Nye actually has to use facts.
Yeah, it's easy when you don't have to worry about facts.
So I thought that was…
If he accomplished that with enough people, that was definitely worth it.
Well, okay, yeah, that's a good point.
I hope that did happen. I really do.
So, guys, I'm getting some comments about the technical issues
on both YouTube and the event page.
I'm convinced the problem was on the event page,
because this all works on YouTube.
I've been monitoring the YouTube feed,
and Frank's screen share was coming through.
The only thing that may not have properly worked
was the voice recognition thing.
Whoever's mic was on was the one that got shown,
and that shouldn't have been what happened,
because I have control over who's big,
and I had Frank selected the whole time, but it wasn't working.
And like I said, that event,
that was a very tweaky event trying to get it started.
So I think it might have been on the Google Plus side.
Thank you guys for your patience on hanging in there with that.
I'm sort of at the mercy of this technology,
so I can't explain what's going on,
but I can tell you that I appreciate your patience,
and thank you for hanging in there.
We will be back next month, but it'll be the first...
Is it going to be before we go to South By, Frank?
Oh, God.
Or are we going afterwards?
Let's see, the talk...
I will prepare this on the Tuesday,
but I leave Wednesday for South By Southwest.
So next month might be a problem.
We should wait, like we did this time,
wait a week afterwards.
All right.
But while we're discussing South By,
look out on our social media channels,
Google Plus, Facebook, the Hubble Telescope Twitter feed.
We're going to be giving you guys information
on what we're going to be doing at South By Southwest.
Frank will be there.
He'll be giving a talk on Thursday night
before South By starts.
I will be live-streaming that talk on this channel,
so you'll be able to see it.
And we will...
Alberto will be...
I think Alberto will be there,
and maybe we'll get a chance to chat with him a little bit
that night as well.
He'll certainly be at South By Southwest,
so we'll meet with him more.
Bonnie Meinke's going to be there.
Amber Strong's going to be there.
So lots of really great people from NASA are going to be all...
And some Northrop Grumman people will be there as well
as we not only talk about JWST this time.
This time we're going to have a focus
on the Hubble Space Telescope.
And in particular, our main goal is some of the visualizations
that Frank is going to be making available.
So I can't wait to see that page.
There's going to be a whole gallery
of brand-new scientific visualizations.
And you can be sure they're going to end up in my videos.
So I can't wait to see them.
There's some really great stuff.
Frank has got...
He sets the gold standard for these things.
When he...
You know, I saw the Ultra Deep Field,
made the most important image ever taken.
That was great.
But then in 2009, I saw that fly-through that he made,
and I couldn't believe it.
It was like the icing on the cake.
And so, you know, ever since then,
I have been a huge fan of Frank's work.
So this and our website will have a whole area
showcasing his work and his visualizations.
So I highly encourage it.
Tony, just to interrupt, you know,
Thursday night, I will be giving a talk
that I call Truth and Beauty in Astronomy Visualization
and telling you about the, you know,
the ways that we do the visualizations,
the scientific discoveries that we elucidate,
and the trade-offs that we have to make,
the philosophical way we have to approach it,
because we can't be absolutely truthful
because sometimes things are just boring
or you can't see dark matter, stuff like that, right?
That's right.
So how do you visualize that stuff?
On the trade-offs we make.
And then the other cool thing is that at South by Southwest,
we're going to have a really cool 82-inch touchscreen monitor
in which to show these things and show off things
like Microsoft's World Wide Telescope.
So we've got some cool stuff for you next month.
Yes, and if you happen to be going to South by Southwest,
then please, we're going to be in the Gaming Expo.
I believe it's free,
and you don't have to pay money to go in there.
And we're going to have a booth toward the back
where you can come by, take a look, talk to us,
and interact with us,
and let us know what you think about all this stuff.
And so we'd love to see you there
if you're going to be at South by Southwest.
So I guess we'll leave it there.
Frank, thank you very much for your time, as always.
You do such a great job with these stories,
so I really appreciate it. Thank you.
All right.
All right, so we'll see you guys next month.
Look out for us the second week of March
where we'll do this again.
The second Wednesday in March.
And we'll hope to see you at South by,
so keep us on your radar for that.
Thank you for your patience.
Gosh, I am so sorry about all the technical issues.
But thank you guys for watching.
And as always, keep looking up.
