A golden age? - with Brian Schmidt and John Mather

nature video
11 followers
Sep 5, 2023
The Hubble Space Telescope has shown us distant galaxies and planets orbiting other stars, deepening our knowledge of the Universe. Nobel prizewinner John Mather works on Hubble's replacement, the James Webb Space Telescope. He believes we are in a golden age of astronomy. But the young researchers he meets are not convinced. There are too many unanswered questions, they say. For example: what's causing the accelerated expansion of the Universe? Hear how Mather and fellow laureate Brian Schmidt, who first observed this expansion, handle their queries.
We know that our universe is expanding.
Brian Schmidt showed that the speed of this expansion is accelerating.
John Mather detected cosmic background radiation, the echo of the Big Bang.
Both of these revelations fundamentally change our view of the universe and pose huge questions
for today's physicists.
The laureates met with three young researchers to discuss the current state of astronomy
and whether this is indeed a golden age in that field.
The golden age of astronomy, so I guess we want to know if it is.
From my perspective it is, because this is a time when, well I'm not saying that there
isn't going to be another golden age to follow, but we are now at a place where discoveries
are being made at an extraordinary pace.
But there's also a lot more astronomers.
And there are a lot more astronomers.
So we have more astronomers and we also have more wonderful equipment.
The number of telescopes that are in space and on the ground or being built is just fantastic.
My impression is the rate of discovery is continuing to increase.
And so it can't always continue forever, but I think astronomers have at least a century's
worth of marvelous ideas.
If you look at the things that were submitted to the Decadal Survey, it'll take us a century
to do them all.
So there's an issue there though, which is that although we've had a period of exponential
growth clearly with a couple of hiccups from when you came out of graduate school.
And that has made life very golden for us because unlike your generation, our generation
there were enough professorships for almost every student created because of the exponential
growth.
So I think astronomy itself is going to continue to grow, but I think our ability to increase
funding, my guess, has leveled off.
I think we have seen the end of exponential growth and we are going to go into an equilibrium
situation.
I think that we will be judged on how we are able to resolve the problems that have
been presented to us.
So I think that we have been presented with this incredible problem of the cosmic acceleration
and alongside that, the question of the cosmological constant problem.
Honestly, I think that in 50 years time, we're going to be judged on whether we were able
to come to any conclusions about the problem.
So I don't disagree that progress on the cosmic acceleration has been woefully slow
in the last 13 years.
Not for lack of trying.
Certainly.
We're using a sledgehammer, going out trying to chop down trees in a very large forest.
Yeah.
But are we looking at the right thing?
Well, I don't know.
So I think that we need to be very open to ideas, but astronomy and physics is bigger
than just cosmic acceleration.
Sure.
It's been very good to me, but it's bigger than that.
We have the idea that we're being able, for the first time, to look back to when the first
stars, galaxies, black holes formed.
Okay.
There are some big questions.
We still don't know what dark matter is.
How should we go about answering these questions?
We've got all these people are doing studying, looking at stars, galaxies, looking at all
this incremental stuff.
Should we refocus astronomy?
Should we tell the people that aren't doing good astronomy what or how they can actually
do it?
Who is to say who is doing it?
Right.
Exactly.
But then I think this is why I disagree that it's a golden age.
John Mather was correct when he said it was a golden age for observational astronomy.
I disagree with that.
Like 20 years ago, they were saying exactly the same thing.
They launched the great observatories.
That was 20 years ago.
20 years ago.
Maybe that's probably the same age.
It's not up to us, let's say, to decide if it's golden age or not.
I mean, this is really something that, you know, people within, exactly, future people
will decide what is the golden age and which one was it.
It's not people within this age that can actually decide if we are the good ones or not.
I mean.
I don't think there's any way to hypothesize that it's a golden age for theoretical physics
that touches on questions in astronomy and astrophysics because we haven't had any really
new innovative ideas.
But in observational astronomy there have been, right?
Yeah, that's true.
We've discovered cosmic acceleration.
We've discovered extrasolar planets.
But we don't even know where those are.
We can only see 5% of the material that makes up our universe.
Astronomers call the rest of it dark matter and dark energy.
But we don't really understand what these are.
Well, my thought is, well, if we don't know something, that's the golden age of astronomy.
It's a question to work on.
The questions that we don't know answers to are really hard.
Dark matter is actually transparent.
It's invisible.
Astronomers can tell that it's there because it has gravity.
But this is a fundamentally hard problem.
The dark energy that got the Nobel Prize this last time is even harder to study because
not only does it not emit light, it doesn't even change what you see very much.
So it's a very hard thing to work on.
We may never find out what that is, or we may need a discovery from some completely
different direction like the Hadron Collider or a theorist.
Do you think that we are making the right decisions on that front?
It is my honest belief that dark energy will be figured out by a theorist, not by an observer.
I might be wrong, though.
That's why WFIRST is interesting.
If I had my druthers, I would be spending more money on theorists and people.
I like that.
But?
I have a similar feeling.
I've been on committees about the dark energy and what we should do.
I kept asking the theorists, well, what theory are we testing?
And they didn't, any of them, have a theory that we were testing that they liked.
So I thought, well, nothing we can do as astronomers, as measurement people, is going to change
any of that.
We need the next Stephen Hawking or the next Einstein to actually come up with this thing
that makes sense, which we don't have yet.
So what would you like from a theorist, let's say?
One model or some feature which characterizes more model and that he can actually test?
I can measure.
Give me a signature that I as an observer can go out and test.
But another way of thinking of it is you can't always look under the light post for the keys.
You have to sort of be alert to other things where maybe we're just not even thinking of
the right thing to think about.
And so you really can't devote all of your effort to just one big project.
We better do everything else that might relate.
So I actually really appreciated that they both emphasized that there was room for theorists
and emphasized the importance of theorists.
I found that really refreshing because, well, since we're theorists, but it's particularly,
it's great coming from observers that they are really understanding.
And maybe in that sense, we are in a golden age of understanding.
The universe is sometimes subject to revision.
It's a good thing to go out and measure and see what the universe does because the one
thing I have learned in life is that one should not prejudge the universe.
The universe does what it wants and our job as scientists are to figure it out rather
than to assume it should be the way we want it to be.
I never imagined in my wildest dreams 30 years ago we'd be able to simulate the formation
of diverse galaxies with moving particles of dark matter.
It shouldn't be surprising that invisible matter and dark energy are a complete challenge
to see.
And they're going to remain a challenge until some breakthrough happens.
It could be 50 years or 100 years before that smart person appears.
And I think theory is really important to solve those things.
But on the other hand, observers like me, the question is, should we be doing these
great big projects?
And the answer is, I say, yeah, 20% of our effort should go into those big problems.
But we need to continue to look for planets, to look for stars and understand how the galaxy
was born, understanding how, you know, stars are born.
All these questions.
It's a very rich subject still.
And so it is still a golden age, although I would say maybe not quite as golden because
golden age is not the absolute level, it's the rate of change.
And so I think we're in the exponential growth that's going to slow down a little bit.
But it's still a great area to be in.
It's not going to crash, I think, tomorrow.
The thing is, though, there's so much pressure to publish.
If you don't publish, you're not going to get a job out of your PhD.
If you don't publish, you're not going to get another postdoc after, you know, there's
no time to actually sit there and think about the big questions.
There's so much incremental science going on.
How would you say we can combat this problem?
And is that actually the best way for science, for postdocs and graduate students to be under
that kind of publication pressure?
I had that, actually.
I was hired as a civil servant.
They couldn't fire me, but they also couldn't promote me until I wrote papers.
So I had to write some papers, too.
So in my case, I started off with a bunch of papers after my PhD.
And then I started the project that eventually I got the Nobel Prize for.
And that did slow my publication rate down.
And for me, I took the risk.
I said, well, this is a big project.
It was a high-profile project.
And it was very clear we weren't going to have a lot of papers initially.
So from 1996 and 1997, I effectively didn't publish any papers those two years.
But 1998, I published papers that got 15,000 citations.
So it was worthwhile.
I was blown away when John kind of started out by saying I was as tired as a civil servant.
And then I was presented with this challenge of, well, they can't promote me if I don't
get any papers published.
And they can't fire me.
And like, look, you know, not getting a promotion is your biggest problem, then I'm happy.
I don't think it's actually any harder for students today than it was 10 or 20 or 30
years ago.
But each student has to go through that period of worry about what they're going to do.
So when I was a student, people said, no, you can't do what you want to do.
There's no job in that field.
So it happens to me.
It happens to most people.
You can come to me and say, I've got this problem.
I can be like, well, we can do this, this, and this with the current telescope.
Yes.
We can't do that until this.
Keep going on and trying to solve the mysteries of the universe.
But don't worry too much about your exact future.
Go in, work for the present, do the best you can, because the future will sort of take
care of itself.
And, you know, I can't guarantee you're going to get a job as an astronomer, but I think
you will have a good, happy life if you do something that you enjoy.
