John Martinis won the 2025 Nobel Prize in Physics for proving macroscopic quantum tunneling is real. Less than a year later he’s telling why he left Google’s quantum computing team to start over. Subscribe if you want the physics and the politics of building the impossible.
Martinis is the co-founder of Colab and one of the physicists who proved ordinary quantum rules apply to macroscopic systems. He built his career on the same Josephson-junction hardware his Nobel is built on, then led Google’s superconducting-qubit effort, the same team behind Google’s 2019 quantum supremacy claim, before an internal reorg pushed him out.
We go into Anthony Leggett’s challenge to Schrödinger’s cat, what decoherence in quantum mechanics really means, and whether quantum computing is the first technology ever born from pure theory rather than experiment. We also cover the internal Google reorg that pushed Martinis out and what he learned about building something new inside a large institution.
What you'll hear -Whether quantum mechanics applies to the macroscopic world and -what it took to prove it -Why Martinis thinks quantum computing may be the first technology born from pure theory, not experiment -What negative authority means and why it matters for anyone building something new inside a large institution -Whether the US can win the quantum computing race against China -How Martinis thinks about quantum mechanics interpretations after spending a career inside the math
“Always be on the lookout for the impossible, right?” (John Martinis)
Chapters 00:00 The Nobel call that almost wasn't 01:01 How his wife found out before he did 03:32 Anthony Leggett's challenge to Schrödinger's cat 05:53 Why a Josephson junction, not a quantum dot or trapped ion 07:45 Quantized oscillations: the “smoking gun” and Balmer's ghost 08:18 Measuring the system: the resonance experiment 11:21 Systematic effects: what separates a good scientist from a lucky one 13:42 The Ed Ohm story: the man who found the CMB and doubted it 15:01 Wigner's “unreasonably effective” math and the weirdest thing about QM 16:54 The transistor myth: chewing gum, coat hangers, and germanium 17:34 Microwave engineering meets quantum mechanics 19:26 Decoherence: the friction you can't live without 24:06 The heretical claim: does theory ever precede technology? 28:22 The “paper qubit” problem 29:34 What quantum computers are actually good for 32:27 Should quantum computing be regulated like AI? 33:35 US vs. China: the quantum computing race 35:44 Collapse, Copenhagen, or many worlds? Martinis's answer 37:43 Leaving Google: “essentially demoted” 40:48 Why Colab exists and what “negative authority” means 42:50 The real bottleneck: funding, not physics 43:31 Final advice: always be on the lookout for the impossible
Featured guest John Martinis, 2025 Nobel Prize in Physics Colab: https://qolab.ai/
Get the transcript, fascinating bonus content, and my Monday M.A.G.I.C. Message: https://briankeating.com/yt
Support Into the Impossible on Patreon, get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
A Nobel Prize-winning physicist discusses the journey of proving macroscopic quantum phenomena, the transition from theoretical curiosity to experimental reality using superconducting circuits, and the practical challenges of scaling quantum computing. The conversation covers the nature of scientific discovery, the role of decoherence, and the speaker's transition from Google to entrepreneurship.
Today we're joined with one of my heroes.
It's not every day you get to talk to somebody who not only, you know, is such
a great contributor to physics and has been inspiring not only the work that I
do, but my whole collaboration is basically enabled by work that John and
his collaborators did over the years.
But he's also, you know, once we say a mensch, he's known for his
teaching, for his group building.
You're just kind of the physicist physicist.
So thank you for joining us.
Well, that's very kind.
Not everyone feels that way.
I appreciate the kind words.
You're now the 26 Nobel prize winner I've had on the podcast.
Every, every nine multiples of nine, I write a book featuring wisdom.
And I hope the third version will come out with you in the coming years.
I'll let you know about how that progresses, but I want to take us to
that October morning last year, I was teaching quantum mechanics that day,
advanced quantum mechanics with perturbation theory, and I said, a guy
I know just won the Nobel prize.
What was that like?
What was the, what was the second thing that went through your mind when you
got the phone call at whatever time it was?
Well, I actually didn't get the phone call.
The phone is in way across the house, but my wife was up late reading
and she heard the phone ringing, but she figured she'd get it in the next day.
She looked at her email and there was a bunch of congratulations.
So she knew about it, but she knows that I need my sleep, especially, you know,
the next day when you, you know, you have to be on the whole day.
So she waited till about six o'clock.
There were reporters who showed up soon after that.
So it was actually better because my wife woke me up, but
she was very clever about it.
She had me on the shoulder and said there were reporters coming over.
And I realized, oh, it's the beginning of October.
So I opened my computer and, and, you know, saw, saw that.
Let me share something a tiny bit personal.
There are things called Nobel symposiums, where they look at a field and see if
the field is noteworthy and look at people in the, you know, leaders
in the field and the like.
So you kind of understand a little bit that you might be on some kind of list.
Okay.
For me, that's the biggest honor because the Nobel prize is just so crazy.
Unlikely.
Right.
Just being invited to that is really very special.
And then for some years, you know, I'd wake up in beginning October.
It's like, oh, okay.
And it's just so wrong to be disappointed by this because today, so after the years,
you know, I just stopped kind of, I knew, well, it's beginning October,
but I stopped really thinking about it.
That's why my wife didn't know.
We didn't talk about this at all.
Right.
Because it's just okay.
You know, whatever happens and it's actually better that way.
Yeah.
There's a joke.
I sometimes will, you know, pull out on October 1st at two in the morning.
I'll say I'm working on my best, you know, Swedish accent to cause
somebody, I don't like a heart attack.
We are calling from the Swedish.
When I look at him, I've heard people get pranks like that.
Well, yours isn't a prank.
And the only thing that frustrated me is that I was talking about, you know,
quantum tunneling, but I was talking about single electron tunneling.
And even nuclear tunneling.
So you wanted for macroscopic tunneling.
What was the impetus for, obviously you didn't set out to win a Nobel prize.
Talk us through the history of why you thought macroscopic effects
would manifest themselves instead of just the already mysterious
microscopic tunneling effects.
Yeah.
So this experiment and line of research was very much
motivated by Anthony Leggett.
You can just go back to the Schrodinger cat paradox, where you do a
microscopic atom decay that's connected up.
So the atom decays, it kills the cat.
And then, you know, okay, before you open the box is the cat
in some dead in the live state.
And okay.
I think there, for me, there are ways to answer this that are very sensible,
but Leggett pointed out that there actually is no experimental evidence
that macroscopic entities, especially a cat, can obey quantum mechanics.
And he said that there's, if there's no evidence, we should be looking for
evidence as a way to test quantum mechanics.
And he came up with the idea of these superconducting circuits where you
have a macroscopic number of electrons that are tunneling through the junction.
For me, you know, as a young student, you look at quantum
mechanics, it's really wonderful.
My personal hobby was electronics.
I joined John's Clark group because he was doing things on quantum noise.
Okay.
And, and thinking about this.
And for me, it was the most natural experiment to want to do.
I'm surprised that there weren't 30 other groups doing it at the point
now, everyone can understand that.
But back in the mid eighties, the idea of quantum information and doing these
tests wasn't as popularized as, as it is now.
So for me, it was the most fascinating experiment.
I thought it could be done cleanly.
You know, obviously John Clark, you know, was moving in this
direction, Michelle Deveregg came over.
And for me, it was, you know, a perfect thesis experiment.
And I'm going to say it was also very groundbreaking because then John's group,
you know, we understood how to measure noise in these devices, but to, you know,
build a system and engineer it and think about the physics combining microwave
engineering and quantum mechanics and figuring out how to deal with the noise
and the like to be able to clean experiment was just really fundamental and
groundbreaking.
And of course that's, you know, I find that, you know, wonderfully exciting.
Okay.
Just try to figure all that out.
Why did you start off with a Josephson junction?
Maybe first we'll explain what it is and keep in mind, my audience is highly
technical, very competent, and I've tried to have Brian on the podcast as a fellow
Brian.
Hey, he's gone in interesting directions, shall we say, in consciousness and, and
other kinds of fields, very different from what he did as a young, very young man
when he won the Nobel prize for his work.
But tell us why Josephson junction, why not a quantum dot or a trapped ion?
What made you start with that?
Well, first of all, the Josephson junction is a macroscopic system where you have a
macroscopic number of, you know, Cooper pairs, electrons, paired electrons,
tumbling through the device.
And to test the idea of whether macroscopic variables of a quantum
mechanics, you need that a quantum dot and a atom, they're kind of single, single
atomic systems, whereas this was very clearly macroscopic and, you know, that's
why Leck had proposed it.
And that being in the superconducting field with John Clark's group, that's
of course why we did it.
Now, at the time we didn't know if the Josephson junction was a clean system.
In many physical systems, especially a macroscopic system, there can be dirt
effects, other things that go wrong that, you know, may cause it not to
work as well as you would like.
And, you know, at the time we didn't know any of that.
So we just forged ahead.
But I would say the reason I'm talking to you today about the Nobel prize is it
turned out that there was a clean system and this was figured out by many, many
people over decades of work, you know, testing it.
I mean, we laid the foundation for understanding how to do that, but
building these systems properly, you know, took a, took a while for a whole
lot of people to figure out.
What strikes me as so, you know, kind of magical and beautiful is that you guys
ended up seeing, you know, discretization and quantization and sort of spectral
features.
And it's exactly reminiscent of what Balmer saw, you know, six years before
the invention of quantum mechanics.
Have you ever thought about what it was like to be him?
I mean, grappling with something that wouldn't be determined or even
predictable for, for many decades.
Did you ever have that kind of inkling of like, we're in this weird, mysterious
territory, or was it, if we keep putting one foot in front of the other, we're
going to get to some goal that we've set out for ourselves?
So that's a really great question because the way we were thinking about is, and
we started it, John Clark's a serious experimentalist and I was a new student,
but what he and we decided very early on is we had to measure the parameters of
the system in order to do a careful test of the theory.
And the obvious thing to do was to put on microwaves and have a resonant
phenomenon and see that resonant phenomenon as a way to measure the
oscillation frequency of the system, which is a very fundamental parameter.
And what was interesting is classically, I set up an analog simulator in about a,
I think a day or two and put in noise and then showed that indeed you can
see some kind of resonant effect.
So very early on, even though we knew about that, we had to do tests and doing it.
Now, of course, you know, as we did this, we were quite interested in
what would be the quantum effects.
Now, what happens classically, both in an atom and in our system is that this
oscillates in this nonlinear well, it has a spectrum of frequencies, one frequency
when it's low and a lower frequency when it's high.
So just like when people talk about electrons circulated nucleus, classically
there's a range of frequencies that it would emit light over.
Of course, what you saw was quantized energy levels and quantized light, which,
you know, it was clear we could see in the system.
So I would say the fact that you see quantized oscillations is a key feature
of quantum mechanics, and I think that what we were able to see is like the
smoking gun thing that you're doing that.
Now it could be that you have to realize if you're really being careful about
this, it could be that there's resonances in the circuit you're connecting it to.
So you have to be careful about, you know, claiming that.
And that's why we did a bunch of experiments, detail that are in the
papers, but no one ever talks about to say that we had a well-defined
experiment without these resonances.
The resonance that we saw made sense in terms of the physics
of the system and the like.
But in the end, that was a key observation.
Now, of course, what was also interesting is Leggett talked about what happened
to tunneling when you had dissipation.
That's a very new physics, which you normally don't see in electrons and
nucleus, and eventually we were able to do those experiments really well and
show that that theory made sense too.
So there is a whole series of things we were able to do because it was really
well-engineered, good connection of microwave engineering to quantum mechanics.
One of the things I love to point out to my younger, you know, listeners,
readers, and viewers in my books, when I interview, you know, Titanic physicists
such as yourself, is when, when you do the thing that you really didn't
think you would have to do, you just mentioned it, you can have this
collective phenomena from alternative effects rather than the thing you're
quote unquote, looking for.
And those are called systematic effects.
And I typically tell my students, anyone can get the right answer.
You know, we can get the Hubble constant, you know, and it could be beautiful,
but the real determinant of whether or not you're a good scientist is how you
account for the things that you could be wrong about, right?
Yeah, exactly.
You know, and the fundamental thing about nature is you can
never prove anything about nature.
You can disprove your theories, but you can never prove it because
something else could be explaining it.
But what you do as an experimentalist is measure enough parameters and do
enough of the check experiments that if it's another theory, it would have to
be really kind of, you know, a crazy, not simple theory.
And, and that's what you do.
And that's, for example, why we were measuring the parameters.
Okay.
The other thing to realize, and I talk about, I like to explain this to the
students, is in the beginning, we did some experiments at, you know, one Kelvin,
the four Kelvin to see what was going on and the data didn't make sense at all.
And it was because we were seeing noise.
And very early on, we just did something.
We compared it in a way that was really kind of tricky at the
time and didn't make sense.
And then we started saying, well, okay, we're going to have to
filter it right and the like.
And once we understood the microwave engineering, microwave filtering, we
redesigned the experiment pretty quickly.
And then all the data started making sense.
Okay.
So there were some internal checks that you, you know, you
have to look at very carefully.
There were a few prior experiments that hadn't really done that properly.
And I think the physics community appreciated all those checks and being
able to do a beautiful experiment because of that.
And, and, you know, all good experiments are like that.
They're well-designed and then you think about things can go
wrong and you, you figure that out.
Yeah.
Reminds me, there was a scientist named Ed Ohm who worked at Bell Labs on the
exact same Holmdel antenna as Penzias and Wilson.
You probably know this story and he actually measured the CMB and
he attributed it to a systematic error.
He basically said it's a systematic error or it's an excess noise or all the
atmospheric contributions add cumulatively and they don't cancel out.
And then Penzias and Wilson said, well, let's do a calibration.
Let's measure that with a liquid nitrogen chopped Dickey switch load.
That won them the Nobel prize, but he had actually discovered it, you know,
three years earlier in the same data, but that's, that's exactly right.
And what you said is so important that we can't prove things as physical science.
We're not mathematicians.
You know, mathematicians can prove one plus one equals two.
It takes 200 pages of piano algorithms and all these other things.
But it kind of reminds me of what Eugene Wigner, another Nobel laureate said once.
He said the mathematics is sort of unreasonably effective.
And, and I think about that and I kind of have narrowed it down.
I say that the square root is unreasonably effective because in
classical mechanics, you can make the Poisson bracket, you can make the
commutator of momentum and position, right?
And it's zero, right?
It doesn't matter if you measure momentum first or position first, he gets there.
But if you add the square root of negative one, you get the Poisson bracket
for the Heisenberg relationships and those do not commute, right?
What's the weirdest thing about quantum mechanics to you?
The weirdest thing, it's really a complicated phenomenon and it takes
until at least your third year, typically as an undergraduate, and then you take it
more and I'm going to say after doing this for many decades, I kind of understand
it fairly well at this point, but you know, it's complicated, but at the same
time, there's this mathematical edifice where you can understand, understand it
well, and you know, it's the basis of many fundamental standards.
So it's extremely accurate too.
It's both complicated, but understandable, unintuitive, but given enough time.
To me, it's intuitive right now.
It's kind of strange.
And you know, that it's just a very deep theory and it's kind of amazing that
nature works, you know, at, at this, this very, very deep level.
And like I say, the other thing is, which is what our Nobel is about.
It's not just the physics of the small or fundamental particles.
It's actually a generic physics that everything can obey.
It's just really hard for ordinary objects to get into some parameter
space where you can see it.
So it's actually a generic phenomenon.
That's all, you know, that been potentially could be all around us.
And, and tunneling is that way too.
And what, what really kind of surprised me about ordinary, you know, kind
of electron tunneling is we have this kind of myth in, in both technology
and in pure science that you, you look into the equations and then
you invent the technology, right?
And so like, you know, Bardeen and the transistor, we couldn't have invented
it unless we understood quantum mechanics.
When in reality, I think, I mean, you know, there's much better than me
and I want to get your opinion, but you know, kind of, if you look at the
first transistor, it looks like, you know, a chunk of rock, like the germanium
and a chewing gum and a coat hanger.
And it's all, I want to ask you, we're going to talk a lot about quantum
computers and a little bit, and by the way, our first experiment in Berkeley
was carefully designed, okay.
And you know, but if you look at what's being made now, it's, you know, it's
like, it's like the Bell labs transistor, but you know, there's some physics
there, okay, but that's what you have to do when you're first exploring
something is you do some experiment that's kind of minimal and you can get
it to work, and then once you understand that the principles behind it, you can
then engineer it and look deeper and deeper into it, and that's, what's
beautiful about physics is there's all these levels that you have to
understand to get it to work.
What's been the most, you know, kind of enabling technology on the step, you
know, contributor to the work that you did.
Was it the, you know, advances in superconductors?
Was it, you know, the kind of fluxonian, the 3d cavities, what kind of like
stepping stones on the way to the revolution that you guys worked on and
still do work on, what was the most important keystone?
So what happened at the time is that we understood that this was a microwave
experiment and we went to the astronomy department and got their S-parameter
and started understanding and reading microwave books.
And in the end, what we did and the field did is combine the concept of
microwave engineering with the concepts of quantum mechanics.
And it's interesting because microwave engineering has wave phenomenon and
resonance like quantum mechanics does.
So they're actually somewhat close.
I also always think that you can understand about 80, 90% of our
superconducting quantum devices with microwave engineering, and then you
have to throw in quantum mechanics at the appropriate point to do that.
It kind of reminds me, you have Maxwell's equations, but in terms of
understanding electrical circuit and the like, you use circuit diagrams.
Okay.
And what you've done is you've taken something very complete and almost
abstract, and then brought it down to a level where we can do complex
engineering with it.
And that's kind of what we were able, what we started in that experiment.
And of course, we explored that for many decades and now, you know, we're
doing it and we're still, I'm still exploring that in terms of materials
and other concepts that we have here.
Yeah.
And, you know, kind of makes me think about a statement.
I think you made once, you know, that, that people seem to hate
decoherence until they need it.
So without decoherence, like friction, you know, if you've ever, you know,
kissed a, kissed a loved one, right?
You need some friction, right?
Life wouldn't be fun without friction.
But, but tell me, is decoherence necessary, you know, for these devices
or is it purely a nuisance that must be obliterated?
I'm going to say decoherence is always here in the real world.
And the problem is if you take the Schrodinger equations, that's just, you
know, a pure, simple physics without any decoherence and of course, people know
how to put in decoherence and do that.
And it's kind of like, you know, how do you understand
thermodynamics without, you know, entropy?
Okay.
You know, you have the basic equations which are conservative and then you
introduce entropy and then you could see the real world and this is what
happens with quantum mechanics.
And also for quantum computing, it first, it's, it's a very practical,
important thing because it limits your quantum computer, but also when you
start doing things like measuring real circuits and let's say doing error
correction, in error correction, you're removing the randomness or the entropy
of that and in some sense you need decoherence and I would say decoherence
in my view is kind of tied to how things get measured.
Okay.
And if you look at exploring the quantum by Ramond and Haroche, it gives
you a good description of that.
That's very integral to quantum mechanics.
It sounds like the ugly side of it, but it's actually a
quite important part of it.
At some level, we have to always connect to the classical world, right?
So there's inevitability of, of dealing with classical effects.
And so how do you guard against, you know, kind of these systematic biases?
Like for us, it was just take measuring a superconductor, right?
So if you want to measure the superconductor, you could be very
careful, you could do all the four point measurements you like, and you
probably have been in a lab with my late great friend, Paul Richards from UC
Berkeley, and he was just the most careful person and he wouldn't let you
do a measurement, you know, that wasn't at least four points in his design.
But at some level, you know, can you actually prove that these things
have zero resistance in the junctions?
Can you prove, you know, that the flux is purely being, you know, quantized
in the way that the, you know, Leggett and other equations suggest that they
are, or do you always have to, we kind of have to, we know it's not purely
quantum mechanical because we have to connect to these devices, or is it
truly manifest that they behave as they should be purely quantum mechanically?
It's always a matter that there are certain limits where the flux will jump.
Okay.
And you could be, let's say near to the transition temperature and then, and
then you'll see that flux is not quantized, or at least it jumps in its quantization.
Physicists have been exploring this for a long time.
In fact, the experiment I did in the eighties was all about how, you know,
when you put a current up to the critical current, at the critical current,
it then looks like a normal metal.
So it's superconducting.
And then when you hit the critical current goes normal.
Well, it happens a little bit before that, either doing the thermal
fluctuations or due to macroscopic quantum tunneling.
And, you know, it's an example of physicists understanding the limit.
Now you can look at the limits of these various things and you can understand
that it should be exponentially small.
For example, where a superconductor, there are things, the excitations
called quasi particles that you limit the superconductivity, but there's a gap
and it's either minus Delta U over K T.
And if you do the calculation, that's tiny.
But the problem is, is you have stray infrared light in a real experiment and
then generates the quasi particles.
So it's not exponentially small.
So I would say, you know, physicists are great at figuring out all these
details and figuring out what's wrong.
And over the years, then, you know, this is why it took, you know,
decades to figure all this out.
Lots of experiments happen, looking at all the details and not just taking the
pure theory, but thinking about all the possible ways that things can go wrong.
And then you engineer around it.
For the infrared case, you'd have to do very careful shielding,
which we didn't do at first.
And then we realized we had to do that.
And then there's still a little bit of residuals, but we can deal with that.
So I want to make a fairly heretical claim, and then I want you to demolish
it and put me in my place, but my claim is that no one's ever looked at an
equation and out pops a technology from purely contemplating it, except perhaps
quantum computing, we'll get there in a second.
But if you look at the transistor, I just said, you know, they, they weren't
like looking at, you know, the, the Schrodinger equation and saying, oh,
we're going to get this technology.
If we put the chewing gum, the coat hanger and the piece of germanium
MRI came, you know, from blocks equations being, being understood laser
maser came from population inversion, which was towns is kind of guess is the
quantum computer, perhaps the first technology in history that really came
from the equation outward, or is it going to be, you know, sort of along the lines
of, of, as I said, you know, the high temperature superconductor really, we
didn't understand the theory until, you know, my late great professor Leon Cooper.
Right.
What do you make of this claim that I'm making that we don't look at the, into
the equations and then the technology comes out.
We experiment, guess, and then eventually technology comes and then
we backfill in the explanation.
I haven't studied this and it sounds like you've had, but I've been said,
talk to, I've talked to theorists about this and they say it's very rare that a
theory kind of precedes an experimental observation.
And the one example they give is the Josephson effect where Brian
Josephson, you know, understood this.
And, and, you know, basically you have to do the calculation to second order in
order to understand what the superconductivity does, but the way this
all came about, it was very murky at the time.
And, you know, if you look at it, John Bardeen gave Brian Josephson a very
hard time with this, which is actually kind of amazing because superconductivity
and BCS is a second order calculation.
Okay.
People hadn't put that all together at the time.
So that was one of the few times, I'm sure it's not the only one, but the few
times where it preceded it and the theorist was given a hard time, but of
course he, the Nobel prize, that meant that it was very strange and I would say
quantum computing, I hadn't thought about that, but I'm, that's right.
This came from very theoretical concepts and then, you know, people work through
it experimentally once, you know, they understood it would be interesting to do
that.
Let me tell you what the problem with quantum computing is, is if you
abstracted away to qubits, okay, you abstract a way to idealize qubits and the
Schrodinger equation, and then it looks very simple and very nice.
Okay.
But the problem is real experimental systems are much more complicated.
There's all these dirt effects and it's kind of easy to think that, okay, you can
just build that without having to go through and all the, you know, understand
what's going on.
So I like to say the best qubit out there is what I call the paper qubit, a theory
qubit, and it's only by doing the experiments, do you know that everything
is wrong, everything's wrong with it.
And it usually takes decades to figure this out.
Okay.
And it's not magical thing.
The other thing is a lot of the efforts are actually headed by theorists.
If you, if you look at it, not all of that, but a lot of them are, and that's
because it's very easy to abstract this away.
I actually think again, history will borne this out.
I actually think that this is a little bit of a problem because in actually the
build, the thing requires you to, you know, really understand all the problems.
Okay.
So by abstracting all the problems away, you can be very optimistic and, you know,
do things, but it's only, you know, going into lab and realizing what all the
problems are and then fixing them that you can actually build it because physical
qubits are not perfect by any means.
Some people claim that their technology is great.
They're always problems.
Okay.
That's the way that nature wants to fight back.
But I think in the end we can, we can fight back harder.
Yeah.
Now I want to talk about quantum computing.
And again, I tend to be a little more cheeky and provocative, so don't be afraid
to put me in my place, but in 1981, you know, Feynman didn't say quantum computers
are going to replace your desktop, your Mac book, your laptop, your Chromebook,
whatever he said, nature is quantum.
So we should probably be using, you know, quantum systems to do computation.
I always joke and I've done work with a firm called quantum rings, which does a
lot of software and simulations of quantum mechanical computers, but I kind of joke
sometimes that, you know, quantum computers are the best system to model how quantum
computers work, eh?
And then, you know, they're good.
Or quantum systems in general.
Yes.
Quantum systems.
But it's not clear, you know, sort of like an answer, you know, to a question
maybe, and again, I'm saying this with, with probably lack of humility, but what
are quantum computers really going to be good for?
And you can't use the words, you know, cryptography and you can't use Lagrangians
or material science or quantum computers.
So outside of that incredibly impressive domain of portfolio, I mean, it's like, if
you said my computer can only be used for doing, you know, spreadsheets, word
processing and, and internet browsing.
Right.
I mean, it could do a lot more general computer.
So what can a quantum computer do besides those three things that are very
important and very hyped up?
Yeah, I'm really interested in partly because I'm a physicist.
Okay.
Is quantum computers modeling, simulating other quantum systems?
And, you know, there's a huge amount that it can help with there because right now,
a lot of classical computers or supercomputers are used to do so.
And, you know, you can only model something so big before you run out of memory
because quantum computing is hard and run out of speed.
Okay.
And then you have to do approximation methods, which are fantastic.
But, you know, they only work.
And in fact, a lot of it is that, you know, certain approximations work for this
problem and that problem.
And you have to compare with physical systems to kind of choose that.
It's a little bit cheating, but you know, okay, it's very practical and that's good.
That's what I'm, I'm really interested in.
And, you know, just the example, I don't know if this is a good example, but we all
are interested in rare earths now, let's say for electric motors and electrification
and transportation system, et cetera, et cetera, but they're rare and there's a
supply chain issue there.
And I'm sure ecologically there could be issues with that.
If you could use not so rare earths, let's say by inventing a new chemical or process
or maybe make it more ecological to mine, that's a huge benefit to society.
And you could say the same things with drug discovery and other things.
I think this is actually a big application.
If you like academic industrial applications, but that's more how regular
computers got started.
And then over time, I can imagine there could be other things, let's say for
optimization, it's not so clear.
There's a killer application for that.
I've seen a lot of people are looking at, a lot of people are claiming things.
It's not clear whether a clever classical optimization would be good.
So it kind of can be a little bit like AI where people try various things for decades
before coming on some, you know, the right way to do it.
I also looked at as very important.
So, you know, it's a, it's a powerful computing engine and it's going to take a
while to figure it out.
And, you know, the, the quantum computers we can build right now are, are, are too
small.
If we can make them bigger and then help with the theorists who inventing the clever
algorithms, I feel, you know, very confident we can do something with this.
But the big problem is we're trying to compute, compete against these huge data
centers.
Okay.
Which are getting huger and huger as every day.
Eventually the exponential power of a quantum computer can overcome that.
We just have to make it big enough and be clever enough for the algorithms.
Yeah, that's right.
And that's what you and our mutual friend, Alan Ho introduced me to you and as co
founder of your company Colab.
We'll get to that in a second, but now I want to take kind of the pushback on
myself, you know, I've, I'm kind of, you know, maybe bipolar this morning, but,
but now I'm going to make the argument that these things are incredibly powerful
and perhaps with great power.
I just talked to the foremost AI safety researcher in the world, Roman Jampolski,
who coined the term AI safety.
And he basically says, super intelligence is either almost here or about to be here.
And it's uncontrollable.
It is unaccountable.
It is unverifiable.
We have no control over what we just created.
So I want to make that argument for quantum computers.
And then I want to take us back to, you know, like 1947, you know, the
government didn't let, you know, Oppenheimer set up Oppie's atomic bomb
company, you know, just selling his own little portable nuclear device, right.
He kept it classified.
And, and, you know, should they be classifying, you know, is it okay that
Google IBM and even Colab, you know, hopefully you're going to be just as big
as that, right?
So tell me, make the argument, why shouldn't you be regulated right now before
the genie escapes the bottle as it has for super intelligent AGI?
First of all, we're going to learn a lot from super intelligent AI.
And that's the immediate issue to deal with and that's here and it's coming.
And, you know, I agree.
People should be thinking about this.
I think we're going to learn from that.
Okay.
And we should take the lessons from that and then figure out what we're going to do.
The problem with quantum computing is it's just not here yet.
And yet there's this big race.
And to be honest, the race is the US versus China.
You look at the papers from China, they know what they're doing.
It's a, it's a serious race.
Developing kind of in the wild is actually an efficient way to, you know, get things
done just like with AI happened.
Okay.
Now there was a secret program within the government for quantum computing, but
that's not where the biggest developments happened.
I don't think I have to explain that to readers.
Okay.
And you know, it's just that, you know, this, this competitive landscape, I'll
call it just call it savage capitalism.
Okay.
Actually it's pretty efficient if you want to do that.
In fact, I argue that the way that the projects in China is operating is maybe
more savage than the, the capitalism in the U S I, I don't know all the details,
but it could be, these are very good questions and I I'm concerned, uh, but
you know, on the other hand, we're, we're trying to develop it in our own, in our
own particular way, and, but we're being very careful about who we do.
We know that, for example, the U S government is going to want us to build
our quantum chip in the U S and that's how we're organizing the way that we do
that, some of the other more classical control that can be done worldwide with
our good diplomatic partners.
And, you know, we're, we're being a little bit careful about that, but I
think it's, you know, it's the Google and IBMs and others where they're really
on the forefront and I'm sure there's a lot of discussion that goes on there.
Now, I can't resist asking you this question.
I mean, you're the ideal person to ask.
You, you probably collapsed more wave functions than any human in history.
What do you think is happening, John?
Is it a collapse?
Is this Copenhagen?
Is it some non-unitary evolution?
Is it a many worlds branching?
Tell me about your epistemology.
What are you thinking when you do these measurements?
I explicitly disliked the many worlds interpretation because it sounds very
Trumpian in the sense that you're generating real estate that's, you know,
that's doing that.
So I'm very much thinking that, you know, the measurement and the dissipation and
the decoherence is what's giving you the state collapse.
And again, if you look at exploring the quantum, they have a very nice, elegant
way to talk about how these things called pointer states are exponentially
sensitive to decoherence and a small amount of decoherence can collapse
you into these measurement states.
And for me, that's the clearest explanation around.
I know some people don't like that and that's fine, but that's the way that I
view it.
Jim Peebles once told me to shut up and measure when I asked him about some,
some aspect of-
If you shut up and measure, we wouldn't have done that experiment or people would
have.
So, so these are good questions.
You need to do the experiments and like in the exploring the quantum, they did
very nice experiments to flesh out what the theory was and to argue that this is
what's going on.
So I think it's important to study this and understand that.
But for me, this is a question that has been answered via decoherence phenomenon.
It's just like not understanding entropy and thermodynamics.
So to me, it's the same kind of understanding.
Take us back to the, you know, the quantum supremacy and you had achieved this
incredible result for the first time, but you soon after left Google.
I'm curious, was that a blessing in disguise?
I mean, it led you to co-found a company with, as I know, and others.
It's such a brilliant idea, this company.
The point is the, the divorce from Google, would you be willing to talk about that?
We don't have to, but-
You know, after that experiment, Google decided to reorganize and instead of being
congratulated for leading this project, I was essentially demoted.
Okay.
And there were reasons for that, that we don't have to get into.
And I tried that for about nine months.
And, you know, basically I went from the head of the hardware to,
let's say one over N authority.
It was a very much a socialist thing, but I actually found I had
negative authority after that.
And if you want to understand negative authority, just think
about when you had teenagers.
Okay.
That's your negative authority.
And frankly, I don't think the people in Google thought that I
was that technically competent.
I was okay.
But you know, you, you, you can tell when people feel that way
and it was just time to leave.
And, and what happened is that was definitely lemons.
Okay.
I still regret everything that happened, but it's what happened.
But what I would say is working with Alan and then Robert, we figured out, well,
what is it we really wanted to do?
Not, you know, next year or to meet the next milestone, but if we wanted to
build a million cubic quantum computer, what would we have to do?
And we really focused on the qubit manufacturing and the wiring and scaling
up, and we came up with this series of ideas and we published a paper on that.
We started a company and we're feeling really good about this and we're doing
something that's really different than everyone else.
That's exciting.
And our view is that when we get this to work, it's very foundational
shift, uh, to the field, which is great.
You know, that's what you want to do.
Is do something important.
On the other hand, it's risky because the general consensus out there is that you
need to fabricate the qubits with this liftoff process because it's much cleaner
and the like, whereas you do a complicated deposition and that you have problems.
That's the thing.
And what we've figured out is that's kind of right, but you have to fabricate
it in the proper way and then you can get it to work.
And, you know, we've kind of have figured out what that proper way is.
And we're working very hard to do the steps that you need to make it very clean.
And, you know, in the end, semiconductors are, no one uses liftoff.
I mean, this is just doesn't work.
You use deposition and etch, but of course, I don't know.
There's billions, trillions of dollars figuring out how to get that to work.
We think we understand enough now to be able to do that on
a modest startup economy.
I think your approach is, is, is so fascinating.
It's a sort of a 3d printing, but you know, massive scale.
My teenager made this for me.
That's one of the few things that he does for me with my negative authority.
Look, you know, young people want to do their own things.
I get it, you know, and they want to break free from their family, which is what
Google, what happened at Google, normally the kids leave the house to break through
and that they don't kick the parents out of the house, but okay, you know, that
was the easier thing for Google to do.
And I understand that I had done things that the Google people, uh, I I'm too
much like Elon Musk to work at Google.
Okay.
Put it that way.
Well, I just note that it was exactly at that time that they went peak woke and,
and within a few months, they had things like you ask it to create a picture of
the founding fathers of America.
And it was like Violet Davis, you know, Violet, the black and white hair and
all sorts of interesting features.
For example, um, all the, the co-writers of the, um, the attention paper, which
was the big breakthrough, they all left Google.
I think they're, they're different reasons, but they're similar reasons.
And, you know, it's not surprised that certain people don't
fit into a corporate environment.
They're more entrepreneurs.
And I'm very much an entrepreneur.
And what I've been able to do is I've been able to kind of unleash my
creativity in a private company.
Now we don't have the money.
I think I could be way more productive at Google, but if that's not the way
they want to run it, then, you know, it's great to be doing this in your own company.
And, you know, in our company, we can set our culture and set what we do.
What's the limiting factor just on a technical side.
I mean, we have a dilution fridge, we don't use it that often.
We have deposition facilities here.
What's your limiting, you know, kind of pacing item that, that is, you
know, kind of an obstacle, but, but you're going to overcome it.
If I gave you 10,000 dilution fridges, if I gave you unlimited time
with 300 millimeter wafers, what do you need, John?
You need refrigerators to do a lot of testing, but you also need
professional fabrication facility where you can do rapid turnaround.
And then the third thing you need is a principled understanding
of what's going wrong.
Right now it's a little bit, you know, just people try things.
However, I think we have a principled understanding now.
So we have to work on the other two and, you know, obviously
take more data and the like.
It's all of the above.
In the end, I'm just going to say in the end for us, it's funding because
of more funding, we'd buy more dilution refrigerators and we could work with
the companies and pay for having a bigger effort.
One final question is just related to the title of the podcast.
The only way to know the limits of the possible Arthur C.
Clark said is to go beyond them into the impossible.
John, what one piece of advice you had 20 seconds with your 20 year old self,
what would you give the advice to him to go into the impossible with the courage
that you've had over your career?
Well, what happens is you're a scientist.
You're always working on projects.
There are projects that are kind of incremental and you know what to do and
you're going to advance your field and whatever, but always be on the lookout
for the impossible, something new, something other people don't think will
work that if it's, it does work, it's very foundational and change the field.
Now you'll have to curate those ideas really well because most of your
ideas aren't going to work out.
And I have ideas all the time and I curate them and then you
choose the best ones and try it.
Our company Colab is what everyone thinks is not the right way to go.
I've thought about it carefully.
We understand why it could work and it's looking good, but you have
to think very carefully about it.
But yeah, always be on the lookout for the impossible.
Right.
I love it.
I'm going to make that the motto of the show.
John Martinez, a winner of the 2025 Nobel prize in physics.
Thank you so much for being an inspiration.
You're just a physicist, physicist.
John, thank you so much.
Have a great weekend.
We'll talk again soon.