As a listener of Dr. Brian Keating, you get a special 20% off discount. 👉 Head over to The Economist's website at http://www.economist.com/Keating to get started.
What really happened during the controversy over the discovery of Haumea? Why was Pluto actually demoted? And is there a hidden Planet Nine lurking in the outer solar system?
I’m joined today by none other than the Pluto Killer himself, Mike Brown. Mike is an astronomer and professor of planetary astronomy at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech). His groundbreaking discoveries of dwarf planets like Eris, Haumea, and Makemake shook up the astronomy world and led to the controversial redefinition of what constitutes a planet.
In this gripping episode of Into the Impossible, Mike opens up about the ethical challenges he faced in his career, including the Haumea data theft that caused a massive controversy, the truth behind the demotion of Pluto, and the ongoing search for Planet Nine.
—
Key Takeaways:
00:00 Intro 01:26 How Mike killed Pluto 03:50 Defining planets 08:48 Being an astronomer 13:31 Controversy over the discovery of Haumea 29:56 The search for Planet Nine 39:14 Balancing high and low-risk research 43:43 Did Neil deGrasse Tyson kill Pluto? 44:34 Planet Nine’s effects on the solar system’s evolution 46:47 The relevance of exoplanets 52:52 Outro
welcome to a deadly episode of the Into
the Impossible podcast featuring the
Pluto killer himself Professor Mike
Brown This is the astronomer who forever
changed our solar systems map tearing
down childhood certainties and
rebuilding our cosmic understanding from
scratch From teaching geology without
ever taking a geology course to hunting
a mysterious ninth planet lurking in the
outer dark regions of our solar system
Mike's career reads like a scientific
thriller Today we're asking some
uncomfortable questions for this murder
suspect Was it really necessary to kill
Pluto is there still a massive hidden
planet some 5,000 times bigger than
Pluto haunting the outer solar system
and what happens when scientific
discovery collides with public sentiment
mike spent decades searching for planet
9 after demoting Pluto And the irony
isn't lost on him His detective work
with the Subaru telescope has narrow
down the search to the constellation
Taurus potentially uncovering the fifth
largest planet in our solar system
Buckle up for astronomical controversy
scientific detective work and the raw
human journey behind reshaping our
understanding of the cosmos These are
some of the deepest mysteries in the
cosmos and this is the Into the
Impossible podcast Mike Brown thank you
for making the trip all the way down
from Pasadena Great to be here It is so
nice to have you here You're giving a
talk today about entitled Planet 9 from
Outer Space It is obviously reminiscent
of a famous movie that probably 99% of
my audience is too young to know But the
abstract which is fascinating
astronomers have been predicting and
searching for planets beyond Neptune for
almost 180 years That's how it begins
It's time to give up time to give up the
search 180 years a long time to come up
with nothing Right And everybody who's
been searching and proposing the
existence of planets they're they're
always wrong They are usually wrong for
a sort of embarrassing thing Mhm And you
are known or you were known on the
platform formerly known as X now known
as Twitter No other way around Was
Twitter now as X Pluto Killer but you're
not on there If you go there you won't
find Mike You'll find him but he's not
active But uh names Names are really
important to you Pluto killer Mike would
it have been simpler just to keep Pluto
and then you wouldn't have to waste the
the last 20 years searching for this
other planet and we could have had nine
planets We already had it when you
started I never actually anticipated
that the research I did would lead to
Pluto being demoted I I knew as soon as
that the the Kyper belt was found these
these objects beyond Neptune started
being discovered It was pretty obvious
that that's what Pluto was that Pluto
deserved to be classified with those
instead of with the planets But I never
thought that that the astronomers would
have the guts to do it or that the
public would go along I never thought
this was what I was doing And yet was
the right thing to do Like we now
describe the solar system correctly
instead of this weird way where we had
planets and this funny little thing
called it a planet even though it was
part of this thing So now we at least
have it straight Pretty happy with that
We have a fun game We're we're Jewish in
our household and and there's always a
temptation to find things that could be
kosher but are not For example pigs They
um have cloven hooves So this is very
important for astronomical purposes
people Pigs have cloven hooves but they
do not chew their cud So one of my kids
asked "Well what if you trained a pig to
chew his cud then he'd have both of
these so-called kosher symbols." Other
ones are fins and scales for fish and
other things And you know crustations
you can't can can't get the shrimp on
the barbie in anyway What types of ways
could a clever astronomer a malicious
astronomer perhaps uh evade the current
definition that was used to basically
kill Pluto what could we do say you know
reshape the orbit let's talk first of
all what are the definitions of the
planets i know you're probably you know
you're not sick of this at all but uh
tell us the three characteristics and
then how could a malicious malevolent
Constantine Betagian type figure how
could they evade these things for
objects that already exist first let's
talk about the definition of planets and
the first thing I'm going to tell you is
that the definition is dumb There's a
reason for that We we don't do
definitions of classes of objects in
astronomy very much Like what's the
definition of a star star you know what
a star is right and so there's some
boundaries that that like what's a star
versus a brown dwarf versus a something
else And that's okay We're we're but we
know we understand the concept Galaxies
Yeah there are galaxies There are dwarf
galaxies There are mega galaxies But and
we understand we don't have to have a
three-part lawyerly definition that says
"Oh are you a galaxy you have this many
stars Oh no there's one fewer You're not
of the galaxy Sorry bud." You know
that's we don't we don't do that So why
why did we have to do that in the solar
system and the reason the only reason we
had to do that in the solar system we
didn't have to but the only reason it
happened in the solar system is because
it really was of public interest whether
Pluto was a planet or not Only reason
there's a definition is to answer the
question about Pluto And actually at the
time it was to answer the question about
Pluto and about Aerys the object that we
found that was more massive than Pluto
What what is it to be and so you know
everybody wanted to know is this is this
a planet um is this not a planet what
are we going to do what's a planet and
so astronomers at the time felt the need
to write a definition So the three-part
definition that I do not like and hope
that everybody forgets as soon as I say
it is that um for a planet in the solar
system you have to go around the sun You
have to be you have to be round Check
I'm there And you have to have cleared
your orbit That's the one that people
like to argue about because it's not
very very obvious what that means And
then you know once you have a lawyerly
definition you get lawyers involved who
are like well you know we have this
asteroid that might be about to hit the
Earth Clearly the Earth has not cleared
its orbit or so it's not a
planet It's like when you just like send
the lawyers home and you realize that
it's the concepts that matter What those
three things are trying to tell you is
that in our solar system there are a
small number of gravitationally dominant
objects that are different from the
other things And the ones that we know
there are eight of them and they are big
They're in circular orbits They are not
messed with by all of the myriad small
things that go flitting around the solar
system There are tons of asteroids and
comets and other stuff that just go in
and out of the planets they go flying
everywhere If they come close to a
planet they go ejected in some other
direction The planets don't care They're
the big bullies of the solar system
That's really all that definition is
trying to say is that there are dominant
objects that have cleared the orbits
Even if you don't have to define what
clear orbits mean And this is for you
This is your gift This is delivered by
gravity This is an honest to goodness
fragment of a minor body Hold it up Came
from is this is this is from the uh the
Cello meteorite in Argentina Campo
deello Very good You didn't even have to
taste it Normally I taste I I gave it to
Joe Rogan He like smoked it or something
That one um is highly radioactive The
first one to camp the field of the
heavens Now you cannot get these anymore
uh by exporting from Argentina They've
forbidden it It's actually a crime But
you can get them if you are like uh Mike
or me and you have aedu email address I
give them away to my lovely audience on
brianking.comedu If you don't have an
edu email address try your luck at
briking.comlist And that joins you up
You'll get information about the
meteorites even if you don't win But uh
the reason I bring these up is because
these um objects really are unsung
heroes I think of the solar system in
some ways And the planets the the
planets that make the most sense and the
planets that seem to appeal most to you
are are these big giant gas giants You
know the ones that were explored by none
other than Galileo is my hero We did the
first ever audio book of Galileo the
dialogue with um with Fabola Geonati and
and many other luminaries to Jim Gates
Frank Wilch Galileo was no stranger to
hunting for planets I mean he actually
accidentally discovered Neptune right he
actually saw it Saw it Yes Discovered is
not quite the right word right right He
could have discovered it if he used the
tools in your book And what I love about
your book is that you actually describe
not only what it's like to be an
astronomer on a day-to-day basis but
what it feels like and and you start off
as a student as a kid actually in
Alabama growing up right and then
growing up uh what fascinated you but
you talk about the tools the technology
and so forth this is a plate taken by
the late great Margaret Burbage I'm
wondering if you can spot the planet I I
think I've just no there's no planet in
that it's a galaxy she was teaching
Bureau Rubin how to do uh rotation
curves back here in the '60s talk about
what drew you what ke kept you in
astronomy through those long years using
the Schmidt telescope using using um the
tools uh that would later become your
stock and trade
It was much harder back then right
today's kids like Patigians and so forth
they got it easy right they got it easy
You know the Ver Rubin Observatory is
going to do it all for you You don't
have to do any stuff But it but it's
still even even though the technology
has made it easier the ideas that are
the exciting part you're you're
exploring This is a part of the solar
system where no one has ever been before
nobody's ever seen before and you are
trying to figure out how to be the first
person do it And and when we when we
first started with uh with these these
photographic plates little bigger than
this 14 14inch square photographic
plates you know you would you would get
one of these photographic plates and you
can stick your eye up to them and it's
the universe is just an amazing place
These days again you just call up
whatever your favorite website is and
you can see all these pictures We went
back and and found some of our old
objects on old photographic plates and
you circle it with your felt tip pen
there and you circle it there and and
you think you know this is it These are
the first photons from this object that
that we think ever got collected on the
earth and you're the first person to see
it I like there's there is nothing more
exciting than that Like sitting at your
sitting at the telescope You're not
you're I'm sorry You're sitting at the
computer You're not sitting at the
telescope You're not seeing the photon
but you're sitting at the the computer
looking at these images coming in You
see this thing moving across the sky
that no one's ever seen before How can
it be better than it's so visceral i
mean I I talk about that in my in my
first book I talk about how you know you
can't feel what it was like to discover
the Higs Bzon or to discover you know to
to do a myriad of things in biology and
and anything else But you could feel
exactly what Galileo felt with a tiny
telescope looking up at the moon on a
clear night or Jupiter You can see the
same stars from Pasadena as he saw
mostly You can see the same four
Galilean satellites This he named him
after his funding agency He was pretty
smart guy But he got into a lot of
trouble and a lot of his uh work is
dominated by what I would call um and
what Mario Bajioli who's a historian of
Galileo and Renaissance science and um
the history of science he calls kind of
the patronage kind of almost like a
griff that Galileo didn't release to
tools even his friend Kepler who's a
contemporary of his how to build a
telescope how to use the telescope what
he saw through it he released kind of
the instruction manual the cidius nunius
and I think it was smart and Mario makes
the case that he was kind of being a
little too clever ever now get into
trouble But you had a runin with some
Spaniards I I want you to uh go over
this subject I I know you it's it's an
amazing story and I just want you to
maybe if you can talk about how as you
describe in the book what Galileo would
do to avoid the kind of prying eyes and
this early espionage that took place in
astronomy and how it still goes on to
this very day So let's let's talk about
the Spaniards and the discoveries of the
2005 2006 time period It's a crazy story
that that if you if you told me the
story or tried to you know I saw it on
TV or something I don't think I would
believe it We were deep in our survey of
the outer solar system Every every night
the the telescope up at Palmer
Observatory would open up would scan a
region of the sky It would we would take
three pictures over about 3 hours look
for something that was
moving That morning I would have the
data transmitted down to me and uh we
would look for things and well we would
look for things mostly the computer
would pick out the first round and then
I would I would vet the next round of
things and and then occasionally find um
found real ones there And there was this
one period uh that was just an amazing
period in my life Um where we found over
the course of about 3 or 4 months we
found three three of the four largest
objects known in the outer solar system
Um so it was couple days after Christmas
it was this object now known as as
Hameha We called it Santa
We always have code names So that was
Santa because it was found for Christmas
Couple days after New Year's there was
Aerys which is the one that's more
massive than Pluto which code name Zeno
Warrior Princess and says "Of course
that was the code name." Um and then
just a couple months later was uh found
right after Easter was Easter Bunny one
Um which is now Maki Maki And we had
been finding everinccreasingly large
objects And we were we were good We we
our rule was we from discovery to the
first scientific publication we we had
our rule that it had to be six months We
we could not be any slower than that We
just because we thought it was important
to get that information out there But we
also thought it was important to learn
something learn something about the
object so that our first announcement
was not just g whiz we found something
but hey here's an object Let us tell you
about it Here's a story And these always
got pretty big press coverage So we
wanted to be able to you know tell a
story Was it to in part to avoid you
know what your uh former colleague
Richard Feman said you know the the
problem of being the biggest fool of
yourself and avoiding confirmation bias
was that part of it not in that sense
because at no point was there any worry
that the object didn't exist Once you
see one of these objects in the outer
solar system three times and then you go
observe it two more times like it's
there There's no there's no question of
uh making sure you're right at that
point We know it's there But we wanted
we wanted we knew we had one chance to
get attention from the public for the
outer solar system And we wanted to tell
a good story that that people resonated
with You know every just just the chance
that they would wake up in the morning
open up their newspaper and learn
something cool about the outer solar
system and be excited about it You know
as opposed to opening up their newspaper
and somebody says "Yeah we found
something at 52 a.m Can we convert that
to millions of miles please?" So so you
know we would tell the story about how
it got there why we named it the the
names were important for those reasons
too So this is this is the long version
of the story So we we're doing this and
we we were being very fast but we did
have people mad at us for taking 6
months to announce things There is a a
subculture Yeah there's a subculture in
the in the solar system Um and and for
for good reasons where uh announcements
get made immediately you discover
something you announce because it's a
comet that might be disappearing or it's
a near-Earth asteroid that might destroy
the Earth tomorrow in 8 years Yeah Like
Yeah So so you need to announce those
quickly Makes sense These objects did
not matter They were not going anywhere
but we're still trying to be in a hurry
But there were people who were still mad
And so we got a we got a lot of push
back that we ignored mostly from from uh
from those astronomers In July of um
2005 several things were going on One we
had discovered three of these This is
tough We had where our six-month limit
was coming up on the first one we found
And we have a paper almost done And it
was super interesting object It was it
was shaped like an egg like a squashed
egg rotating once every four hours It
had a moon around it so we knew how
massive it was It was about a third the
mass of Pluto uh just like and it it was
it was covered in water ice If you
looked at the spectrum of it you could
see the reflected light look was was
precisely that of the water ice that you
would get out of your freezer And yet it
had the mass of something that was a
rock So it was clearly like a a a thin
layer of ice with a rock underneath Like
the world's worst M&M I think is is is
what it was So I was finishing this
paper to announce this and the other
thing going on at the time was that uh
my wife was 8 and a half months pregnant
I took a day off to finish writing this
paper uh
and she went into labor Of course that
day literally that day as I I I really
think I would have finished the paper
the next day Um I think it's really true
because it was it was like just Anyway
soon into labor I sort of dropped that
project and started this new project Yes
exactly For a couple of weeks Smart man
right and um in the meantime one of my
one of my graduate students one of my
postocs was going to a conference and he
was going to talk about this object and
he had he had written an abstract He
used the name We had a we had a we had
we our real code name was Santa but we
had like a computerenerated name based
on it when it was discovered So it was
like
K0512 It was something about the data
Anyway I don't remember what it was but
he put that in the abstract title I'm
like why would you use like no one it's
an arbitrary thing Why would you use
that who knows i woke up one morning
when my daughter was 20 days old to a
email from Brian Marsden who was the the
director of the the minor International
Astronomical Union Minor Planet Center
which is where you send all your That's
right One of my proudest accomplishments
is getting this asteroid named after my
mentor Jim Simons And you uh read if you
will for the camera mic Who is the
discover of asteroid that is known the
discovered is unknown clyde Tombbo Nice
one Now the connection is also
discovered Pluto right which is not a
planet The Fulner planet That's right So
we got this name for him and we have one
for Marilyn his wife Um he was very
proud of it except he asked me
immediately when I told him about it
being the you know hedge fund tycoon
that he was and especially with futures
He said "Do I have mineral mining rights
on the asteroid?" And I said "If you can
get there if you have to get there the
answer is yes then absolutely." So amid
these two big bang moments you know that
you're having So so I get this email
from Brian Mars and he's like "As a
professor and a podcaster and a
scientist exploring the boundaries of
knowledge in the lab I crave independent
sources of knowledge and wisdom wherever
I can find them One of my go-to sources
is The Economist I've been reading it
literally for decades The Economist
consistently delivers independent
journalism for independent thinkers like
you and me But the best part for me is
that their science coverage is nothing
short of extraordinary Just this past
week I was captivated by their deep
analysis of the recent claims of quantum
computing breakthroughs that could
revolutionize how we process information
Exactly the kind of forwardthinking
coverage that I discuss on the podcast
and that I crave to expand my own
intellectual horizons The Economist's
rigorous approach cuts through the noise
and BS in a way that you can truly trust
And what sets The Economist apart is
their Simply Science weekly newsletter
It's a subscriberonly exclusive benefit
Each weekly edition delivers beautifully
written explorations of nature
technology the cosmos the human body And
all of this comes alongside stunning
scientific photography selected and
curated by their editors I don't just do
science I love to explore complex ideas
The economist analysis is a perfect
compliment It provides the insight and
clarity needed to navigate challenging
intellectual terrain with confidence And
to get everything The Economist offers
The Economist is offering a special 20%
discount just for viewers of the Into
the Impossible podcast To claim the
special 20% discount visit
economist.com/keing Your pursuit of
knowledge shouldn't end when this
podcast ends The economist ensures that
doesn't have to I had been talking to
him and I he knew that we had some
things and we were talking about how
best to announce them cuz it was coming
up soon And he's like,"I just got a
report of this
object Is this one of yours?" And I was
like "It can't be." I mean who's No one
else is doing a big survey like this And
I I look at and it's a list of positions
in the sky where it was detected And I
look I'm like "Oh yeah That's that is
Santa That's our our object now known as
Hameha." And you know my heart just
sinks and I feel terrible that somebody
has found the scooped you They scooped
us And um he was like "Well what what
what do you want to do about it?" I'm
like "Well I mean they discovered it
This is the way science works You can if
you're holding on to something and
somebody else announces it before you do
they're the discover You're a better man
than me I would get my lawyers in It's
just the I mean it's lawyers It's just
the way it works." And I'm like I felt I
felt bad But I also felt like oh no
these guys are going to announce it and
they don't know anything cuz they had
just put they had just put positions
like from the couple days before and and
then gone back and found it in old data
You knew the spectrum and the water ice
and we knew about that moon We knew
about the mass We knew So they're going
to say it's bigger than Pluto which is
not It's because it's highly reflective
So they're going to think it's bigger
than Pluto So I wrote to them that
morning Um I said "Congratulations I
actually have this email I read this
email back to myself I'm like "Oh my god
I am sometimes I could actually be like
a gentleman." Super nice I wow If anyone
ever just declares that I'm a always a
jerk I'm like "Nope." Only 99% of the
time look at this email I said "Proof."
It says "Congratulations on this
discovery you know amazing I I I want to
let you know so that you know when you
make the announcement I want to let you
know um we have a spectrum of it because
we we found it back here We have a
spectrum of it It's got water ice It's
got a rotation period of this and its
mass is this So it's only about a third
the mass of Pluto Super interesting
object I also said in this email let me
know when you come up with a name
because we'll want to name the moon
which we discover So we get to name the
moon We'll want to name name the moon
something that follows in whatever theme
you come up with I do have to say
because I have a lot of young people
that listen to this podcast a lot of
young scientists in training graduate
students postocs in addition to 21 Nobel
Prize winners but the scientific ethics
is not taught we just don't teach it I
don't I would I don't remember it being
taught at Caltech when I was there uh as
a posttock But but the point being there
comes a time in in every graduate
student's life when they'll have some
crisis some crisis of confidence Are
they doing the right thing should they
do something else they'll have some
issue that will come up and it's not
always as big as this but going through
this without any training The integrity
to do that is very rare You're joking
about yourself but but it is rare So can
we teach that to our students is it
important to have I mean the medical
school teaches ethics the business
school the law school teaches ethics Why
don't scientists teach ethics it's a
really good question I mean we it comes
up more often than than you would guess
as a as a scientist and even as a as a
as a graduate student as a young
scientist I am often having these
conversations with my students about you
know let's step back for a minute and
think is this really the right to doing
and should we do this but it but it's
not there's no there's no guide book
there's no handbook just like being a
parent right so getting back to the
story the reason that this this story
takes in a really devilish twist is
because of what happens next right yeah
How'd you find out yeah I then get
another email from Brian Marson This is
now Friday morning I'm on operating on 2
hours of sleep in the past 20 days Baby
rest Uh yeah I get another email from
Brian Mars He says "What about these
other two are they yours also?" And I'm
thinking "Oh my god what's going on it's
a ridiculous story." And but that these
three objects we had been tracking with
an automated telescope in in Chile just
to learn about them And that automated
telescope the data were not publicly
posted but the logs were posted that had
the names and the locations And one of
the names was K0520 whatever that name
that my postto had had publicly posted
and somebody had googled that
name found the website that had the logs
and then realized realized the positions
where we'd been looking and once you
don't you don't you have to know the
object if it if the position that we
point to is our precise to the arcse
second every single night for 3 months
you know the orbit of the object as well
as we do because That's how well we know
the orbit of the object So that's So
Brian realized that somebody had
submitted all of these as discoveries
that day And I was like "Oh." He's like
"What do you want me to do?" I'm like
"Um hold on Let's hold on." So this is
not like I have independently discovered
it This is like I discovered your
website that had it on it right so I'm
like "Hold on Uh let me let me figure
out what to And we decided on Friday
morning I decided to go to my office for
the first time in two two and a half
weeks And I I went to my office and I
was talking about I'm like I we need to
do a press conference today and analysis
objects on a Friday On a Friday on a
Friday afternoon when there was some
there was some crisis at the at the
International Space Station and some
presidential some all these things like
it's raining and pouring It's when you
announced that you know you you that you
stopped being your wife or something I
don't know So so I called people at JPL
like we need to do this right now and
they're like well we can't we can do it
on Monday I'm like we can't wait for the
sun to go down These positions are not
all there So if somebody actually went
to the sky and got an image of it and
said I found it that it just gets a
little complicated as to what this means
Um so like we have to do it before the
sun goes down I mean the sun was already
down in some places So but still we had
to do it right then So we did we we did
it We put together a press conference on
a Friday afternoon on almost no sleep My
my niece was staying with us at the time
and I called her up I'm like Lauren
bring me a blue shirt and a toothbrush
and and a and a brush That's Let that be
a lesson out there Yeah I always be
prepared Yeah I have the absolutely true
that I do And we announced it right then
and it was exciting you know like on
Good Morning America on Monday morning
mostly as far as I found now learned
because Diane Sawyer's middle name is
Laya which is the same as my daughter's
name And so she and so my daughter was
the first time my mother always ever saw
my daughter was on Good Morning America
So it was all very exciting and
everything was good And like a couple
weeks
later I got an email from um going to
forget his name now Spaniard No I got an
email from uh at Ohio State who ran the
telescope the Smarts Telescope in Kos
And he said "I found something weird."
I'm like "Okay what?" He said "Well the
day or two before this announcement came
out there were there were some I was
looking at the logs for this telescope
and
somebody sort of went through and not
not hacked but went and found like the
URL and changed the last word and like
went through and basically viewed every
downloaded and viewed every log that you
had pointed at." And he said "I thought
that was weird." And it was before this
before the announcement happened And I
was like "Oh that's weird I don't
understand what's going on." And um he's
like "So then I then I went and checked
out where it was and it was in Spain."
I'm like "Oh man." And then he said "And
here's here are the IP addresses." And I
had been corresponding with these guys
and we could trace it It was first the
IP address of this grad student who had
been working with the guy who announced
it and then a little bit later it was
the IP address of the guy of the adviser
of the adviser And you know you can kind
of picture what probably happened I mean
what probably happened is that the grad
student saw this abstract and like weird
I wonder what that is Googled the name
and it comes up It does actually come up
in that one thing and it came up as a
log and then realized that he could find
all these things and then told the
adviser and then again you know here's
where maybe a little bit of ethical
training would have been a good thing to
do rather than announce that they had
discovered it I I I think it's also true
that they were doing a search in the sky
for these sorts of things but they never
they never had found anything And I
think they might it's it's not
impossible that they actually had data
that showed it They just didn't know how
to process Oh come on Mike So I I I
couldn't help when I was listening to
the book on audio thinking of that
famous line from that great scientific
and and philosophical giant Scooby-Doo
that says "We would have gotten away
with it if we weren't so greedy." Right
they would have gotten away if it was
just one object But to claim all three
So they didn't claim the other two Oh
who did so So that was same technique So
they claimed the first one and said they
had discovered it And then an amateur
astronomer in Germany who was mad at us
already because of the whole hiding
object
and works with them I'm sure he that
they told the guy there and he went and
figured out that you could find these
other and he's the one who submitted
those two They claimed that they had
discovered it in good faith and it just
happened to be that the day before they
were going to announce it that they
found the website and accessed it all
and confirmed that it was there right
and like okay likely true What would
have been the right response the right
response would have been to have said oh
wow we just found this too And you
probably contact the person and say hey
what you did we see that your K25 blah
blah blah is the same object here We
were going to announce it I mean we're
going to announce who knows at some
point but you you certainly don't
pretend like you never knew that this
was all that you had accessed all these
data on the web And so I mean obviously
they just they never actually found
right i just they just did this It's
interesting part of the the end of the
story It got to be a big stink Their
their institution disavowed them They
disappeared off the web page for about a
year and now they're back They're still
they're still working active in the
field have never really gotten any push
back for for having done it or anything
else And so now these three objects you
you already given the names They're
known as minor bodies or dwarf planets
planets which is also a pretty that a
great name I'm sure a lot of people are
unhappy with that for dwarf planets are
the ones that fit two of the criteria
They go around the sun and they're
they're round We actually had a word for
that before that we used these rest
called them spheres you know SP actually
we had I had one here Yeah it's a minor
body a dwarf We actually we actually
used the word planettoid for a long time
and uh which is good It's sort of you
know it's like asteroid It's planet
meteoroid right uh I think that's a much
better thing than but these are all
official official dwarf planets And then
there's another whole issue on official
versus unofficial dwarf planets So these
are all dwarf planets It's a the most
massive one And it's it really is the
most mass So take if you take Pluto Mhm
and you add the entire asteroid belt
that's the mass of Aris Wow Yeah So
there's Pluto there So there's Aerys
there's Maki Maki which is crazy object
and Jame which is the most crazy object
out there I love these These are like
It's like your children They're all
They're all my favorite gen That's right
That's what my mom will say I'll say you
know ask "Mom which is the four of the
four of us brothers and which is your
favorite?" She's like "Oh that's like
asking me to choose Do I like my left
hand better than my right?" I say "Mom
you're a lefty You're left-handed." Okay
Well there's an answer We know the truth
She just doesn't want to say So planet 9
is gone immediately There's Pluto's gone
So we have eight planets Now you're on
the hot on the hunt for planet 9 Now
you're working really not back then I'm
saying right now now we are And let's
let's fast forward cuz I I do want to
cover the topics of the talk and get
into some hard-hitting hard ball
questions from two professors One goes
by the name of Constantine And I'll just
get into that What I when he sat in the
hot seat that you are now in you feel
the heat don't you Mark i asked him the
threebody problem is insoluble How are
you doing your theoretical wizardry we
can't even solve the threebody problem
How many objects are in the Kyper belt
or you know Kyper belt like objects how
can he possibly do what he does so first
I want you to kind of steal man what he
does the kind of theoretical predictions
computer Is this all just computer mumbo
jumbo you put in garbage you get out of
garbage or is there really something
behind what he does that we would
classify as true hard science yeah So
I'm going to start to when we first
started looking for for planet thinking
about planet What we really were
thinking about is why are some of these
objects at the very edge of the solar
system why are they all aligned they all
have orbits that go swing off in one
direction It's it's an interesting thing
It's the sort of thing that that it's
the sort of thing that forever anytime
anybody sees anything slightly weird in
the outer solar system they jump up and
down and say it must be a planet And we
did not want to be the 34th and 35th
astronomers jumping up and down and
saying that there was a planet and
that's 18 years being wrong like
everybody else So so and we knew there
weren't any other planets out there
because that's just kind of a dumb idea
that there's another planet We all knew
there are no other planets So we started
trying to do some calculations to
understand what else could do that And
those calculations are really you sit
down and and you write down some you do
the physics you do you do approximations
because you can't solve perfectly for
everything but you can solve for the
general gravitational forces how things
interact and you can write down the
equations and you can see what happens
and and we we did that And usually when
I say write down equations and I say we
it's it's Constantine while I watch And
nothing works There's no there's just no
way to get these alignments going on in
any way that we could come up with And
we spent probably a year trying to come
up with these alignments And then I
think we both just like ashamed of
ourselves said I mean it could be a
planet I mean it's like that sheepishly
Yeah Uh and so we wrote down those
equations and they're not that hard to
write down for the general behavior of
how it would make kind of a a thing like
this And God it works really well And
and then once you do that the general
the general physics equations involve
some approximations that you have to
check on And so that's where the
computer modeling comes in And then you
just do big massive dynamical
simulations where you put in all the
planets you put in a planet and you let
them interact and you see what happens
over four and a half billion years And
it mostly follows those simple
approximations that you made in your
calculations but the details are
different and you check to see if the
details work out And and that's how then
you you carry forward is mostly um with
the computer simulations to to try to
understand okay if we change the planet
from being this massive to a little less
massive or a little further away or a
little closer or in a more eccentric
like how do those affect exactly what
goes on in this part of the solar system
that's how we're really learning what it
is we're looking at Constantine was
sitting there So he has you know um what
does it say um you know one good turn
deserves another or turnabout is fair
play or foul play I forget all these
platitudes But he asked me to ask you
bro Literally this is constant I'm I'm
channeling him Bro I was in Russian next
No I would say uh doing my best
imitation He says bro what about the
systematics though t Ho he spells it So
my answer to him would be like look dog
The first and still the the biggest
public signature that there's a planet
out there is these these these objects
whose orbits all align in some direction
And interestingly enough you know it's
interesting We when we first proposed
this planet we assumed that within days
some other astronomer somewhere would
have an alternative explanation
Astronomers are great at explaining
things You know you you show them a plot
and you say "Can you explain this?"
They're like "Yes this is exactly what I
predict because this this and this."
You're like "Oh no I'm sorry That's
upside down I show you the plot this way
This is what I meant to show you." And
they're like "That's even better It
means this this this and this and this."
So I mean explaining things is easy
easier And so we assume there would be
explanations and there are none There
are I mean it's like some halfbaked
physics explanations but of the physics
of explaining why you would have this
but technically in the cameras and the
telescope So look at the plate again
Were there things back you know in the
good old days you know before Instagram
i mean were there tools techniques that
don't cross over that don't translate
from your days you know licking the
photographic films and the meteorites or
whatever you geologists do and
developing things in the dark when you
were a grad student up at Berkeley what
you know kind of tools techniques don't
transfer through what things are common
between these enormous cameras on on
giant mountain tops um or are they just
so radically different it's almost like
two different sciences I feel like it's
all the same There's the technology is
different The science is the same Like
okay the technology of developing a
photographic plate and scanning it and
getting into your computer is different
than getting a digital image in and
doing that But it's it's all the same
It's all the same stuff And and and so
that gets you back to the sort of what
what the systematics that he was talking
about It's all the systematics of do you
really are you really seeing what you
think you see and you know as in
astronomy we call it observational bias
If you were to look
west one day a week and you saw the
sunset you couldn't really conclude that
the sun sets in the west because you you
it could be that it only sets in the
west one day every week and you don't
actually know what happens the other six
days and you only look that way If
instead you looked everywhere over the
course of the week and you only saw it
in the west then you know that you
actually have something going on And the
the the suggestion the only other
suggestion that really that's been put
forward about planet 9 is that we
essentially did that That we only looked
in one direction and we see these
objects pointing it off in this
direction and we we didn't look in the
other directions And interestingly
enough we did look in the other
directions too Shockingly we're not
actually as dumb as you might think And
so I mean but it is it's a reasonable
question to ask and you have to
calculate the statistics because in
astronomy you deal with clouds and this
and that So you have to make sure that
you have you understand the statistics
of where you've looked compared to what
you've seen and the statistics are good
but it's still something that people
like to argue about because it's the
only other it's really the only other
explanation and it's just wrong We have
the statistics now very solidly in our
favor that there these things are
aligned like this and unless somebody's
going to come up with another
explanation for both this alignment and
the five or six other things that we
have also seen that really matter and
unless somebody comes up with those
explanations they're like there is no
better explanation than a giant planet
that we still haven't found in the outer
part of the Tina there is no alternative
this time is different
so here's what I'd like to say
it Sounds weird to say "Look the
previous 34 astronomers were all wrong
and you shouldn't listen to them but you
should listen to us." That was goofballs
Because we're right but in our in our
defense the previous 34 astronomers were
all wrong and we're right So you just
listen to us That's right So you should
you should listen to us for a reason You
are right and it's we're going to find
it Another question comes from my friend
and two-time guest on the podcast
Professor Daniel Green who's professor
here theoretical physicist I'm still on
X Okay I'm on blue sky too I've only
been called a Nazi once uh since going
to Blue Sky But you can ask questions
You can interact with Mike over there
You a Pluto Killer over there too
Pluto.com because you can make your
address Okay cool So you got a little
merch Get some merch over there Some uh
some swag if you go to that that website
No Um so you can ask questions of me at
both locations Now I don't discriminate
but one of the best places is on YouTube
where I'll be taking questions about
Daniel my friend my professor colleague
here at UCSD in your book how I'd killed
Pluto and why it had it coming He expl
it is a love story It is I mean
seriously you talk about your love for
my I wanted to have that a colon 11 and
my publisher would not let me do well if
Mark Manson can write everything is
after you know a book about hope You
explain how you uh you state you started
your search for new planets in part
because the tenure expectations at
Caltech are so high but then you didn't
find anything until after getting tenure
I would love to know how he balanced
high and low risk research to make that
possible Uh it's a really good question
I wouldn't say that I started it because
tenure expectations are high I I mean
maybe you you were expected to do
exciting big science but it's also I
started it because like I could go
explore the outer part of the solar
system And it's absolutely true In the
in the time before tenure I spent a lot
of time on these old photographic plates
at at Palomar years taking these plates
developing I did not do the developing
There were people who actually knew how
to do this and scanning them and looking
for things removing and and in those
years leading up to tenure I found
precisely nothing And my tenure
committee they're like "It's okay Find
nothing." But it the important thing is
to turn that into a scientific result
And so what you need to do is take that
do a careful calibration and you know
explain what your limits are to what
there could be out there And it's it's
the correct thing to do and I didn't do
it Hm I didn't do it because at the same
time that that that I was failing to
find anything with the photographic
plates we had gotten the first primitive
digital cameras CCD cameras and started
putting them on this telescope at
Palomar And I realized I could either
spend the next year or two calibrating
the survey where I didn't find anything
or I could do a hundred times better
survey and find success And so I'm just
going to ignore my tenure committee's
advice So I pointed out the wonderful
highly you know integrity markup of high
integrity that Mike exhibited in this
interaction with the Spaniard and the
Germans but this is an example of what I
would call survivorship bias I mean you
you were successful You are brilliant
and not everyone's a Mike Brown So So
don't do that Don't don't take this
advice and it's not financial advice
That's not your advice Also look like
this wasn't if there had not been
anything there right to quote Obama you
didn't build that I knew there was going
to be Yeah I knew it was going to be
that I mean I did know it was going to
like I knew that at that next level we
were going to find Yes And and um I
didn't know what we were going to find
Okay next question um comes from someone
by the name of Deep Safe Prevent protect
preserve I was actually going to call
one of my kids that he or she I can't I
can't think of it I thought NDT Neil
Degrass Tyson killed Pluto How do you
react to him claiming it as he does
everywhere he and I have a stickick He
will say it was my fault Um he will say
what is I have an ar weapon We haven't
we haven't actually had I haven't had to
talk about this in a long time with him
So and I forgotten exactly how we do
this but basically uh he he sort of says
like he was he was the sheriff and put
out the search warrant and I was the
posi that brought him in front of it But
when he's when he's feeling a little bit
heat he will definitely blame me for it
And when it's feeling a little bit but
he's I mean he's he is very clear with
what happened and he was important part
of having that conversation start and
and I'm I'm not sure it would have
happened uh the way it did had he not
had started having that conversation
Yeah And there's no one better to kind
of bring it to the masses Yep Yeah He's
a multi-time guest on the show I'm going
back on his show in a couple weeks I'll
bring him your regards and a meteorite
Question from YouTube from Dystopian
Profit That's actually pretty good I
wonder if he's friends with Protect
Preserve Defend Do you think Plant X
Planet X has been around since the early
solar system and if so what effects
could have had on the solar systems
evolution great question So um first off
we don't call it Planet X Planet X was
actually a theory of of uh Vulcan right
uh the Vulcan was from um from Levarian
who also discovered Neptune or who yeah
discovered Neptune and then did the one
bad thing Never name your planet before
you discover it or you'll never discover
it So Vulcan he called it Vulcan didn't
exist Didn't exist There is no name Fine
So so but but planet X planet X was a
theory of um Peral um who was looking
for looking for a planet eventually low
observatory found Pluto but he thought
there was a giant planet out there That
was his actual theory Doesn't just mean
generic planet out there This is planet
9 Mhm It's our theory Yes we get to name
our theory At planet 9 the first part of
the answer to the question is we don't
know the answer We don't know if it's
been there forever We don't um uh we
don't know how it got there But that
doesn't mean we don't have theories for
how it got there The prevailing theory
for how it got there is that it formed
in the Uranus Neptune region It got
scattered out early in the solar system
and it's been lurking waiting to be
found ever since then Now does that tie
into this definitional thing again
because you know if it's round or if
it's you know an object that's round now
may not be round tomorrow if an OB or
you know what if it was round if it's 10
times the mass of Jupiter but it has a
chunk cut out of it because of a hit in
contact with an asteroid I guess the
more relevant question is clearing out
its orbit I mean what if it hasn't
cleared out its orbit but in a a million
years which is a blink of a as Neil
Degrass Tyson would say you know it's
the cosmic clock it's or Carl Sean would
say actually but but Neil would ape him
beautifully Tell me I mean something
that is a planet could it not become a
planet harkening back to the earlier you
know the provocative question I led off
with you know can the pig learn how to
chew chew its cut and I think the answer
it shows you why lawyerly definitions
are not the right way to do these things
right it's just not it's just not the
right way to do Yeah it is true that it
that in the the way that we know this
planet exists is because it's cleared
most of its orbit and we see the parts
that have not yet been cleared and they
will be cleared in a billion years Um so
we see that process going on So it
certainly fits that But you have to know
the whole orbit and then once I mean the
orbit is relatively accessible I guess
but but to know that it's clear do you
have to scan the entire orbit i mean how
does that do we literally have to see
that there's nothing there yeah I mean
because we can we can see its effect and
calculate that it's where it is and we
don't we don't care if it's cleared its
orbit in the sense that like nobody's
like
"Oh damn I can't remember if it's
cleared its orbit or not It might not be
Atlantic Oh yeah It cleared it Yay Now
we're back." It's just that it actually
is like there's a there's a simulation
that I'll show in my talk today where we
start with this huge body of objects out
there and they're almost all gone by the
end of four billion years because it's
clear that sort of this is just what's
going on So what else has it done it's
so it's been clearing its orbit out
there A really interesting thing in into
this slightly deep dive into the physics
of it If you take a planet and that's
that's a little bit less than the mass
of Uranus or Neptune but you put it 10
or 20 times further away out there it
actually carries more angular momentum
than the rest of the solar system So
it's the most the most angular item and
it's at a slight inclination to the
solar system which means that it is
processing the solar system around but
it's not processing the sun So it is
changing the orbits the the orbital
plane of the whole solar system and not
the sun And so that's maybe part of the
reason why according to us the sun is
tilted by about I can't remember the
number six or seven degrees compared to
us maybe it's that we're tilted to the
sun to the sun right as a planet 9 just
that like that's usually I say it
doesn't do anything but it actually does
it's actually a cool little effect that
um that that we thought about I want to
talk about you know some of the work
that you started off with which is
looking for volcanoes on Io and all
sorts of moons What's the status there
and and actually before I do that if
you'll indulge me for you know changing
the subject mid mid question if we knew
for sure that true exoplanets had no
life on them that we're alone that we're
it do you still think the search for
these objects including the types of
objects like Planet 9 has a scientific
moral cultural relevance or you know is
it really hinging on the fact that okay
we know we're going to find life one of
these days what do you think i think I
think I know it's not your field book No
but I think you're absolutely right that
uh the the idea of life drives a lot of
what we think about um when we think
about exoplanets I'm I'm thinking back
to a early stage when I was we were
discussing a a potential telescope in
space that would try to um look at
planetary systems and there was a debate
on the team between like if you found
one that looked potentially earthlike
would you just devote the rest of the
time that the telescope was in space to
staring at that planet to learn for it
or would you keep on looking to learn
the diversity of things like that and I
was I was like no I want to understand
the architecture of planets systems is
because I love the understanding how
planets got there how things get in the
outer parts the inner parts everything
else And most of the other people were
like "No we would stare at that one
Earthlike part." So it is it's a it's a
strong current of what a lot of people
are interested in And I think it drives
why the field of exoplanets is so large
right now Um and why for example going
to Mars is is one of the big things that
we do in the solar system and what's
next going to Europa whether it be life
maybe going to Enceladus where life
might be but but if you think about it
even in our solar system it's not the
only things we do we are sending
missions to Venus to understand not life
living down at the thousand degree
although some Sarah Seager past gas
claims possibly but that's not true okay
um we'll do the debate next time so but
that's not why we're sending missions
right we're sending missions to learn
about the planet understand how planets
work because that's interesting we're
sending sending missions to asteroids to
understand you know sampling asteroids
tasting them Yeah Tasting them to
understand the chemistry And it's the
chemistry that does lead to life It's
true But not like we're going to find
things that are out there So if you took
away that equation um I think it would
the field would would uh get back to
being smaller but I think it would still
be there I think there there are a lot
of people who are interested in I love
understanding the diversity in the
architecture of planetary systems It'd
be cool to find something where there
was life like how how exciting that I'm
not the reason that I think it's it's
cool It's not the reason that I think
even studying uh I I study Europa I
don't study Europa because I think I'm
going to find buds on it Although if
they're there they're there They'd be
better Let me know I'll be the second to
know right but I would but I or some
Spaniard will be the second to talk
about pickle Pickle uh planetary icy uh
ice chemistry laboratory My hobby my
hobby lab uh is Yes the planet planetary
ice chemistry laboratory Our our logo is
a pickle with planets inside a pickle
jar with planets Well you're a geologist
I understand I'm actually an astronomer
I'm not even a geologist No I I now live
in a geology department Yeah but I'm an
astronomer You degrees in astronomy I I
think about astronomy kid You work when
I go to sleep at night You know this is
And but I and I love geology I love I
mean again this kind of my hobby too I
love these hobby things But as an
astronomer interested in chemistry of
things in the solar system the way you
you know you you're looking at objects
in the outer part of the solar system
and their conditions are different from
anything that's on the Earth And so
they're often different from anything
that's been done in a lab And the way
you you make progress is you you go do
an observation you find something
interesting and you often you'll go talk
to somebody who has a lab who studies
these things in the lab and you say to
her like "This is weird I don't
understand what this is but maybe it's
because this is happening This is
happening at this temperature." and this
kind of radiation can you reproduce that
in the lab and does that work and she'll
say you know that's a great idea and I
can probably get an experiment up and
running to do that in like 5 years And
that's like I'm not patient enough for
that kind of things And so I I I asked
my department chair and to his credit
and discredit both um he's like "Okay
you can have you can have a lab Start
start making a lab." forgot how nice it
was to be a it's weird and then then I
was like we started getting it up and we
were starting to make things going and
the only reason it got enough funding to
get going through this first couple
years is uh that asteroid um Jim Simons
uh the Simons Foundation funded the
first five years of this lab and that's
that's uh it's it's so much fun I not
only am not a chemist and didn't have a
lab I had never actually been in a lab
and didn't know what I was doing I I
decided not to give you a lab tour later
on in my lab instead It's really I mean
I literally did not know what I was
doing We had to learn it all and we
learned we do differently things
differently than other labs We learned
you know we just thought from scratch
how would you best do this and sort of
solve problems in different ways making
measurements different ways very
specialist It's it's so much fun It is
fun It's fun to get to play and not not
worry about things like tenure or
publications and age indices or you know
this has been a great joy Your book is
phenomenal It teaches you not only what
it is like to be an astronomer you know
data but what it feels like what the
challenges are raising a family growing
up and it's obvious you're a mentor to
many many many because of your humanity
and that you prioritize the things that
you only get one kid right yeah I mean
some of us have more but but you only
have one kid right you know we only have
one set of parents right but the the way
that you describe what are the actual
day-to-day challenges like along with
the hard science I I love the hard
science but I also like some of the
memoir aspects of it too Mike I have a
tradition here to ask one question
inspired by the namesake of this podcast
or the name giver of this podcast Arthur
C Clark doing a little bit about Jupiter
and its moons and you know some some
shenanigans going on out there But he
said many things He said um for every
expert there's an equal and opposite
expert I could drop that on my
department chair every so often He also
said um the only way of knowing the
limits of the possible is to go beyond
them into the impossible That's the name
of this podcast That's where we get it
from I want to ask you what would you do
you have 20 seconds with a 20-year-old
Mike Brown You get to go back in time go
back to Berkeley or wherever you were at
that time or you know just around 2122
You got 20 seconds What do you tell him
to give him the courage to do as you've
done to go into the impossible i would
tell him to explore and have fun and
don't worry how it's going to work out
That's awesome That's I mean that's the
right answer That's awesome Mike thank
you so much This has been a joy So much
fun Now that we've wet your appetite for
true scientific discovery I want you to
dive deeper And you can do that by
clicking here on this membersonly video
where Mike dives deep into the search
for Planet 9 and doesn't shine away from
all the pitfalls and perilous wrong
turns that it's taken along the way
Click here for that and please do join
as a member Your membership helps me
keep this channel growing