News from Hubble and Across the Universe! April 2014

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
Sep 5, 2023
It's that time again, time for +Tony Darnell and Dr. +Frank Summers to get together and fill you in on all the latest science and happenings with the Hubble Space Telescope.
Hope you can all make it, please bring your questions and comments!
Hello everybody and welcome to our latest Hubble Hangout.
And this month, if it's the first Wednesday of the month,
it must be time for our Hubble Hangout with Dr. Frank Summers,
the Outreach Astronomer-Astrophysicist at the Space Telescope Science Institute,
who met with us most months at this time.
We didn't do it last week because we were occupied last week
with South by Southwest and couldn't get to it.
But we're back this month.
We had our public lecture series last night.
It was a really interesting talk by Dr. Armin Rest
and it is on our website, which I will provide a link to
here as the Hangout progresses.
But don't forget, we're here not only to present you with the latest news
and information from Hubble Space Telescope,
we also want to get your comments and questions.
So please leave a comment on the Google Plus event page.
I've just tweeted about it.
And also at Dr. Frank Summers, he's also tweeted about it.
Just follow that link and start commenting.
You can also tweet using the hashtag HubbleHangout and I'll see that.
And finally, there's also the YouTube page
where this is also being broadcast on our channel.
I'm monitoring those comments as well, as well as the Q&A app.
All kinds of ways to talk to us.
So we hope you'll do it because we don't want to just hear our own voices.
We want to hear you guys, at least in the form of comments and questions.
So please let us know what you think.
Frank, welcome.
Tony, how are you doing today?
I'm good.
It's April.
It's getting warm out, or at least trying to.
I am so ready for this winter to be over.
I'll tell you, it is like the worst season.
As I said last month a bunch of times,
I can tell you when the vernal equinox is going to happen,
but I can't tell you when spring is going to come.
That's right.
Or at least when it's going to feel like it.
I lived in Boulder, Colorado for like 30 years.
It got colder in January, sure,
but the snows didn't really hit until March and April.
That's when we really got inundated.
And right now, they're getting inundated again.
So those spring snows are usually measured in feet.
I mean, that's how much snow they get this time of year.
So I'm glad I don't have to deal with that.
But anyway, it's good to be on the upswing,
at least on the warming trend.
Most definitely.
How'd it go last night?
So last night you did the public lecture series.
Yeah, we had a great public lecture series.
We do it the first Tuesday of every month.
And Armin Rest really had a great talk about light echoes.
And the point is that, you know,
one of the points I made at the end of the talk
was that the speed of light seems infinite
in our everyday life, but in astronomy,
we can actually see the propagation of light
across light years of space,
and we can actually see things happening in the past.
And so the use of light echoes
to actually observe things that happened
a hundred years ago, a thousand years ago,
is actually a really cool prospect,
and that's what he's exploring.
So I suggest everyone find that webcast on our site
and take a look at it.
Yeah, I'm getting the link together right now,
and I'll post it on the event page.
But what Frank was talking about,
one of the issues that Armin brought up
was he was studying these light echoes
where you could actually see from subtracted images
from one year to another of a supernova,
you could see these expanding light waves,
or light echoes, he called them.
And what Frank's talking about is that, yes,
this is an example of the distances in astronomy
are so vast that you can actually see
the speed of light in operation there.
So it really was a great talk,
and I'll post the link here in just a second.
So Frank's going to give us a little summary
of some of the stories he's got his eye on,
and I'm going to go ahead and let you get started, Frank.
Go ahead.
In the meantime, I'm going to post that link right here.
All right, so I'm going to talk to you
about news from the universe for April 2014.
And every month at the Public Lecture Series,
I give an update on recent Hubble discoveries,
and sometimes I include other discoveries,
but this month I only have some Hubble things.
And so my first story is, I called it a Clockwork Galaxy.
Now, I did this because, well, you'll see why I did this,
but one of the cool things we've been able to do with Hubble
that really it wasn't particularly intended to do
was to do really high-precision astrometry.
Now, we've got these instruments on Hubble
called the Fine Guidance Sensors.
And the Fine Guidance Sensors,
in association with some really cool computer techniques,
have allowed us to measure really, really, really high precision
of the positions of stars.
And so the first example I remember from a few years ago
was in this image.
It's a score of the globular cluster Omega Centauri.
Now, Omega Centauri contains about a million,
maybe 10 million stars.
So this is a really, really small patch of it.
But what they were able to do
is by taking images of this field several years apart
and by using computer processing
to really measure the centroids of these star dots,
they were able to measure the motions of these stars
only over a few years
and then extrapolate them to what they would be
over 10,000 years.
So based upon several images like this,
they were able to take those stars in that white box
and they were able to figure out
that these are their motions, these are their speeds,
which is where they will move
over the course of the next 10,000 years.
Is there a way to tell which one is the extrapolated data points
or does it matter here in this?
Well, in this one, you're seeing lines,
which basically are dots plotted for each of the stars
at a specific interval.
So the longer ones with longer tails
are ones that are moving faster across the image
and the ones with the shorter tails
are ones that are moving slower.
Ah, okay.
All right, so what they did is they took the star
from where it was and they trailed it
to show where it will be moving to.
And do you have an idea how many images was it based on
to get the initial starting?
To get this, this was only a few years
and I think it was on order three images
in terms of how to measure it.
The key point here is that each of the stars
has a point spread function, right?
And so the spot of light spreads out
and that star isn't going to move even a pixel's worth
over the course of a few years.
But if you model the point spread function
really, really carefully,
you can actually measure the motion of the centroid
of that point spread function on sub-pixel scales.
Now you should clarify that a point spread function
is something that the telescope does
to the point source of light
as it enters the optical tube assembly, right?
Exactly.
So it's a function of the telescope that you're looking at.
So in this case, the Hubble Space Telescope
as well as the filters that it goes through.
Right, so the stars are so far away
that they would appear in our images as a point of light.
They're just too small to be resolved.
So that light of that star is going to get spread out
over a certain region.
And due to the mirrors and the optics
and the camera that you're using,
you'll get a different point spread function, right?
And so by removing it, by modeling that
and then removing that effect,
you get a point again
and you're able to then be able to get
these measurements you're talking about
that take less than a pixel.
Well, it's not really removing the point spread function.
What it is is you're measuring the centroid of it.
So in as much as if that point spread function
moves just like a tenth of a pixel to the right,
well, then the pixel to the right of it
will get a little bit more light
and the pixel to the left of it will get a little less light.
Got it. Yeah, okay, sure.
So you're measuring on sub-pixel scales
down to like hundreds of a pixel
or even thousands, a few thousands of a pixel in some cases.
And so here they're able to measure motions
within a globular cluster
without having to actually wait for the stars to move
and help understand, you know, the gravitational thing,
the amazing amount of gravity and interactions
that's occurring inside a globular cluster.
Then just a couple years ago,
we applied that same idea to the Andromeda galaxy.
So on the right you see the Andromeda galaxy
and then you see that small pull-out box
where there are some Hubble observations
spaced over five to seven years
looking at the stars in Andromeda.
Wow, that is crazy. Look at all those galaxies.
All right, and so the idea was that
because you're looking at the halo of Andromeda
well away from the center,
the really dense disk of Andromeda,
you can also see not only the stars in Andromeda
but also the background galaxies.
And so you can use the background galaxies as a rest frame,
things that aren't going to move,
and try to measure the motions of the stars.
And again, using this point spread function technique
where you're really trying to measure it,
they were able to measure the motions of these stars
down to seven one-thousandths of a pixel.
Wow.
All right, so you're really able to measure
incredibly fine motions of these stars.
And as you remember, Tony,
for the first time we were able to measure
the sideways motion of Andromeda across the sky,
what we call the proper motion of Andromeda.
And the result was that the velocity vector
of Andromeda galaxy is consistent
with it coming straight towards the Milky Way,
and perhaps in four billion years
our night sky will look like this,
with both the Milky Way and Andromeda
smashing through one another,
ripping each other to shreds in a galactic collision.
I don't know about you, but I'm going to be there.
I'll have my head in one of those Futurama domes there.
You know, I'll be there.
You and Richard Nixon, right?
Yeah, exactly.
That's my plan.
That's your plan.
All right, so we've done this already,
but now we're able to do it
in another really cool way.
All right, and so the really cool measurement
this time is for another galaxy,
not the Andromeda galaxy, but this one.
And this is the Large Magellanic Cloud.
And the Large Magellanic Cloud
is one of the dwarf galaxies around the Milky Way.
We have two major...
Can you see it from the southern hemisphere?
Yep, can see it from the southern hemisphere.
Two major galaxies around the Milky Way,
the Large Magellanic Cloud and the Small Magellanic Cloud.
And then we've got like a dozen other or so smaller ones.
Now, the LMC is classified as a dwarf irregular galaxy.
And I've always thought of it as an irregular galaxy,
but it isn't quite as irregular as one might think.
There is actually some structure.
You can see across the center of this image, there's a bar.
All right, there's that long straight region,
which makes it sort of look like,
well, maybe it resembles a barred spiral galaxy
or the center of a barred spiral galaxy.
So if you take a deeper exposure of the LMC,
you'll get an image like this one that's coming up.
It's taking a second to come up.
Network of problem.
All right, there we go.
This is a deeper exposure.
This is an image from Stephan Guisard,
who gave us permission to use it.
Thank you very much, Stephan.
That's a marvelous image.
But you can see that not only is there that bar across the center,
but there are also hints of spiral arms
extending off either side of the bar.
And images like this, deep exposures like this,
have had astronomers ask,
well, was the LMC a small barred spiral galaxy,
but that just got distorted
or its process got ripped apart a little bit
by interactions with the Milky Way
or with the small Magellanic Cloud.
We see definite evidence that it has interacted
with the small Magellanic Cloud
and perhaps with the Milky Way.
So perhaps those interactions have changed its morphology.
So it leads you to think,
well, maybe this could have been a small barred spiral galaxy.
However, if it was a spiral galaxy,
it would be rotating.
And there would be a disk structure,
you know, all that faint stuff that you see there
would be a disk structure.
So how are we going to measure the rotation?
Well, you can do some Doppler shift stuff,
but it's pretty much in the plane.
But really what you want to do is
you want to measure motions of stars.
So we applied that same really fine astrometry technique,
that really fine position measuring technique,
to the Large Magellanic Cloud.
And this next image is not a photograph.
It's actually just an illustration.
So here's an illustration with a really overexposed version
of the LMC.
And those red velocity vectors
show the motions of the stars in 22 fields
within the Large Magellanic Cloud.
And you'll see that, you know,
not all of them are perfectly into a nice rotational pattern.
But enough of them are that you can see
that there is a rotational pattern to the LMC.
And it lends credence to the idea
that it does have a disk structure
and could have been a small barred spiral galaxy.
And does it say anything about the interactions
with our own galaxy at all?
Or is it just its own proper motion?
It will be able to in the future.
Right now with the 22 fields they've just measured,
they're able to only really constrain things.
But if they get more fields,
and in particular they measure the Small Magellanic Cloud,
they might be able to say more about
the potential of interactions on things.
In particular, the differential
between the LMC measurements and the SMC measurements
will give some really good information on that.
You know what I love about this picture?
Somebody put the time to put the moon in there.
Well, that's done for scale, okay?
Oh, okay.
This is an illustration.
You can see the mountains in the foreground
are just added in as a thing.
And the image is an overexposed thing with stuff on top.
And they put the moon in there to give you a scale
such that the LMC on the sky,
when you really expose it,
is 10 to 20 times larger than the moon.
So the full moon up in the sky is about a half a degree, right?
That's right.
So if you extend your thumb out at arm's length
and try to cover it, that's about a half a degree.
So you can get a sense just how much bigger,
how much that fills our sky.
That's amazing.
That's really a great image.
And the LMC, which you see with the human eye
when you go down to the southern hemisphere,
is going to be much, much smaller.
But a fully exposed, deep image of the LMC
really does cover about 10 degrees across in the sky.
For example, the contrast, the Andromeda Galaxy
only covers about 3 degrees across in the sky.
How far away is the LMC?
About 170,000 light years.
And the Andromeda Galaxy is 2.5 million, right?
2.5 million, yep.
So that's quite a difference.
So these stars in here are also pretty old, aren't they?
Well, the star...
Well, what do you mean in terms of old?
Because a lot of them are really new
because we've got the Tarantula Nebula here,
which is the biggest star-forming region anywhere.
That was a poorly framed question.
Let me rephrase that.
So I'm always hearing that dwarf galaxies like this
are among the oldest galaxies in the universe.
And so that doesn't necessarily mean the stars are old,
but what is meant by that when we say
they're among the oldest galaxies?
I think that's actually a misconception
that people promulgate.
The point being that when we look to the early universe,
we see objects that resemble,
that have as much star-bursting activity
as these dwarf irregular galaxies do.
So they're just projecting what they're seeing
in the distant universe.
Now, the idea in hierarchical galaxy formation
is that small things form first, right?
And then those small things gather together
to form bigger things.
So you don't form a giant elliptical right away.
You actually form small things
and then they smash together and merge together
and then they end up forming a giant elliptical.
But there is another problem with that,
is that the small things that form early
are the ones that are going to get built
into these giant ellipticals.
For a dwarf galaxy that exists today,
if it was formed at the beginning of the universe,
it probably got incorporated into a larger structure by now.
So the dwarf galaxies that we see
that are still on their own today
probably didn't form really early in the universe.
They probably formed middling in the universe.
So that they still survive through today.
Because, you know, gravity is a one-way street.
Once you merge together, you're stuck together.
You're not going to separate.
Despite what the accelerating universe says, okay?
Until that happens.
Okay, cool. Thanks for the clarification.
That really helps.
All right.
So our next story,
and this is one that we're going to be coming back to a bunch of times.
This is a preview of a Martian visitor.
Now, that is not a Martian who's going to visit Earth,
but instead an object that is going to visit Mars.
Now, we remember last year, Tony,
when we talked about Comet ISON.
And we talked about Comet ISON a lot.
Well, this is Hubble's picture of Comet ISON
from about a year ago, April 10, 2013.
And Hubble, because it has the finest resolution
of any optical telescope,
is useful in characterizing these comets on their way in.
It can see what no other telescope can see, right?
And so we studied Comet ISON
because Comet ISON was going to take a really close pass by the Sun.
All right?
And so this is a plot of ISON's orbit,
and you can see that it comes diving in,
kind of came really close to the Sun,
and then exited.
Unfortunately, Comet ISON didn't live up to its total hype
because it had that wonderful breakup last November.
And so here is the plot from the SOHO camera
of the time lapse of Comet ISON
as it comes in at the bottom, passes by the Sun,
and slowly disintegrates as it exits off the top of the screen
and becomes just a great big cloud of ice and dust
orbiting around the Sun instead of a comet itself.
Yeah, but I still thought that was cool.
I don't know about you, but we didn't exactly see it that way,
but it was still pretty neat that that happened.
Yeah, I really enjoyed it too.
I was following this as much as I could
because, remember, I was on a cruise ship at the time,
and downloading the information was difficult.
Yeah, that was a hard time.
So we had a close encounter with the Sun last year,
but this year we're going to have a different close encounter
by this comet.
And this comet is Comet Siding Spring.
This is Hubble's picture from March 11, 2014.
And Siding Spring was discovered by a guy
who's discovered a lot of comets, Robert McNaught.
I don't know if you remember Comet McNaught from 2007,
an amazing, gorgeous comet,
unfortunately only visible in the Southern Hemisphere.
We didn't get to see it up here.
And there's been a couple other Comet McNaughts,
but he discovered this comet,
and instead of calling it another Comet McNaught,
they called it Comet Siding Spring after the observatory
where he discovered it,
the Siding Spring Observatory in Australia.
So this is the view of Comet Siding Spring that Hubble has,
and the reason we're looking at it
is because Comet Siding Spring, come next October,
is going to have a really close pass near Mars.
So on October 19th of this year,
Comet Siding Spring is going to make a close pass towards Mars,
and you're going to, of course, ask,
well, how close is that?
Well, on this diagram...
How close is that?
Thank you, Tony, I'm so impressed.
On the left side of this diagram,
I've got the path of Comet Siding Spring
drawn in as a line.
It's going to come by at such a sharp angle,
it's going to effectively align.
And on the right side, that orange spot
is, to scale, the size of Mars.
Mars is about, what, 6,800 kilometers across in diameter.
So the distance is going to be 135,000 kilometers,
or 86,000 miles for those who work in English units,
and that seems awfully large or small,
but let's put it into some perspective.
The distance is actually going to be
only 20 Mars diameters away.
That's kind of cool, all right?
It's going to pass within 20 Mars diameters.
If you note, at Earth,
one of the things I have memorized about Earth and our Moon
is that our Moon is about 30 Earth diameters away.
So relatively, it's even closer than our Moon.
And actually, the distance of 135,000 kilometers
is half the distance from Earth to the Moon.
So it's passing, you know,
half the distance from Earth to the Moon, all right?
So this would be like having a comet pass right directly,
yeah, like, you know, right in the middle there.
So that would be scary to watch from Earth.
But from Mars, I'm happy with this.
But from Mars, Mars' moons are actually much closer.
Phobos and Deimos are these tiny little asteroid,
captured asteroid-type things.
They aren't really respectable moons, in my opinion.
But you can see that they orbit relatively close to their planet.
All right, so Phobos and Deimos
are still well inside the passage of comet Siding Spring.
The really cool thing about this is
that the coma of the comet
is already about 20,000 kilometers across.
Whoa!
All right?
The comet itself is only going to be a few kilometers,
maybe at most, like, 10 or 20 kilometers.
They still don't have a good estimate
for the measurement of the size of the comet.
But its coma is at least 20 kilometers across already.
Yeah.
20,000 kilometers across, right?
And it could grow to be about 100,000 kilometers across or more.
That's right, as it gets closer to the Sun.
Right.
And so right now it's out by Jupiter.
When it gets in towards Mars,
if that coma is large enough,
that coma will actually pass across Phobos, Deimos, and Mars.
And then we have the really cool prospect
of seeing meteor showers on Mars.
All right?
Because all that stuff that's in the coma
smashes into Mars' atmosphere,
and we got the rovers on the surface
to sit and watch meteor showers on Mars.
How cool would that be?
So can you imagine what that's going to look like?
I mean, that would be amazing.
I mean, the Martian sky is going to be
just full of activity during this time.
So do you know if the rovers are going to be in a position
to be able to see something?
I mean, they're not going to be on the other side of the planet or anything, are they?
They are definitely going to try.
Okay?
The scientists who now know about this
and the engineers are feverishly working on this
to make sure that Curiosity and Spirit and Opportunity
are available to have good looks
in case there are meteor showers.
Okay.
That's going to be cool.
But, you know, meteors generally happen
due to very small pieces of the comet
that pass through the atmosphere.
But not everything is going to be these really small
dust-grain-sized, micron-sized objects.
There might be some larger ones.
You know, bolides occur, you know,
because there's a crab-apple-sized type rock
coming through the atmosphere.
And you have to remember that we also, at Mars,
have experiments orbiting around Mars.
In orbit. That's right. Good. I'm glad you brought that up.
Right. So this is Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter
here in this picture.
But we've also got Mars Express
and we've got Mars Odyssey.
And the brand-new experiment, MAVEN,
will be arriving at Mars in September of this year,
one month before Comet Sliding Spring passes by.
You'll have to batten down the hatches right away.
So we've got another reason that we really want to monitor this
so that we know how big is it going to be,
how much danger could it pose, possibly pose,
to our missions in orbit around Mars.
Now, right now, the folks there say,
it's nothing to worry about yet.
But we're going to monitor it to see what happens.
So we've got another cool comet passage
come October of this year.
So how do you...
Why aren't they more nervous about it?
I mean, how can they be so sure that things are going to be okay?
I don't think they're sure that things are going to be okay,
but there's no reason to get nervous and crazy about something
until they have more information.
Well, it's not like there's a whole lot they can do about it either, I guess.
But I was just curious because, I mean,
if a comet comes that close to a planet
and you've got things in orbit,
all kinds of things could happen.
Right. So the only things you could do
is try and make sure the satellite is on the opposite side of the planet
when it passes by or something,
or if there's a way of closing up any instruments that might be vulnerable.
Put the lens caps on, yeah.
Yes, exactly. Stuff like that.
If we were Hubble, we might close the lid or something like that.
Put it into safe mode.
Whatever you need to do to make sure that it survives nicely
and then bring it back up.
Yeah.
But right now, they would not predict that that is necessary.
Okay. So for Comet ISON, what did Hubble do last year?
And on the left is the image of Comet ISON
and on the right is a specially processed image
where we have subtracted a coma.
Okay. A model for the coma.
So as we said, the comet is really, really small
and all of this gas and dust is coming off that comet.
And if it came off in a nice spherically symmetric smooth distribution,
you can subtract off that idea of a smooth distribution
to try and see if there are any jets of material.
And with Comet ISON, you can see we saw what looked like,
you know, possibly some jets coming off of it last year.
With Comet Siding Springs, we did the exact same thing
and we take that March 11th image, subtract off a smooth coma model
and you get, again, what looks like jets coming off.
Now, what we've done actually is we've taken several images
of Comet Siding Spring and we've got three epochs of it.
And so here in this, you can see October, January, and March
and you can see the relative changes in what looks like these jets.
Now, in the analysis of this, they say that they have definitive proof
that there are at least two jets coming off of Comet Siding Spring.
And the orientation is a little bit difficult to interpret
simply because, remember, Earth is orbiting between October, January, and March.
Earth actually moves a good amount through the solar system.
So the angles aren't the same on all of these.
But they can use these jets to measure the rotation rate of the comet
and what its orientation is and have a good prediction
for which directions material will be spewed out greatest in.
So, I mean, if I look at these in my own little animation in my brain,
I can kind of see the rotation anyway.
I mean, maybe it's an optical illusion.
But, yeah, I can see that it changes orientation with each frame.
But like you say, they don't know that it's difficult to pinpoint exactly, I guess.
Right. Well, you have to take into account the Earth's motion through the solar system
and so the different angles that we're viewing it at.
And so unless you do that mathematical analysis,
you're not going to be able to get the true rotation.
And the results I saw did not clarify that
as to whether what we're seeing here is true rotation
or whether it's just apparent rotation from our motion.
Sure.
So we now have some cool ideas, some initial measurements on Comet Siding Spring.
We know that there are jets to monitor.
And so we will be monitoring it throughout the summer
as it comes in and makes its approach toward Mars in October.
So that will be a cool event to look forward to.
Can you say something about what we can expect to see from here?
That's actually one thing I forgot to mention last night.
So, unfortunately, Comet Siding Springs is coming in from the Oort Cloud.
It's got about a million-year-long orbit at the best estimate right now.
It's not going to get close enough to Earth,
and it's not going to get close enough to the sun to make an interesting sky.
So it will be visible from Mars, but it won't be visible from Earth.
Okay.
You're making it up a little bit more.
What we got now was that the sun will be visible from Mars,
obviously, so it's not going to start from Earth.
Yeah, you're frozen, and the sky, unfortunately.
Okay, so we were doing so well.
Okay, well, I'll go back to me.
Okay, so just a little bit of what we had.
I'm not hearing something now.
I'll be back.
Okay, so he's dropped out again.
All right.
Okay.
Hopefully, he'll be able to join us again soon.
So we'll see you on our way here.
We'll be back here with our comments and stuff.
We've got anything going on?
I'm seeing a lot of comments.
Here's one from Katie.
Okay.
From Katie on YouTube is asking, asked a question,
I just want to know what you hold of the image of the first image.
I don't think we need that in conversation,
but it might be something like with the camera on board,
and I don't know how they're going to choose which object to look at first,
but it will be almost certainly to evaluate the cameras on board.
Are you back, Frank, or are you still working on that?
You're coming through as being totally choppy in the text.
Hmm.
Okay.
Now you're back.
That's weird.
Okay.
Somebody says, sound is robotic, or is it just me?
Yeah.
It's like from 4.30 to 4.33 Eastern time,
we got a network problem that's affecting, you know,
this isn't affecting my laptop, which is on visitor land.
It's actually affecting my base workstation here.
Oh, okay.
And that's on the base network.
Yeah.
Okay.
Well, you seem to be back now, so I think we're good.
Okay.
Am I screen sharing?
Okay.
Yeah.
Right now your screen share is not up.
I don't see it.
Let me get back in screen share.
There we go.
That should come back up in a sec.
Okay.
Yep.
I see it.
Wonderful.
Okay.
Go ahead.
So I think we got to the end of the Siding Spring story, or was –
I can't remember if we got there, but the point is –
Yeah.
We were – I was asking you about what it would look like from Earth
and what, you know, what we would see, and your answer was that
while Mars will have a good view,
it won't get close enough to the sun to make a very good show for Earth.
That would be it.
Yeah.
Okay.
So we get to our final story, which is actually a very short story
because it's a to-be-continued-next-month story.
Okay.
So I call this story an early anniversary present.
So if we remember back 24 years ago, on April 24, 1990,
that is the space shuttle launching from Cape Canaveral,
carrying the Hubble Space Telescope in the payload bay.
The largest –
Good old good days.
Very good day.
The largest object that could even fit inside the payload bay
because that was sort of one of the constraints of Hubble,
that it had to fit in the shuttle payload bay, being carried aloft.
And it's also funky to notice that they were doing some testing on –
they actually had another space shuttle on the other launch pad at the same time.
They were doing some testing on the other shuttle.
So we had two shuttles on the launch pad back in 1990.
And then the next day, April 25, 1990 –
I love that picture.
Isn't it?
That's an awesome picture.
And that was taken for the IMAX film that followed it.
So this is – I think this is from the IMAX camera sitting in the payload bay
as it was deployed.
And so on April 25, Hubble was deployed into space.
One of the few times you're ever going to see that front gate closed, too.
I recently learned they don't close that unless they absolutely have to.
Right, yeah, that's never closed.
I can't tell you if it's ever been closed since 1990.
Yeah.
I think the thinking is it'd be like, you know,
if we close it just to work it out and then it doesn't open again.
I suppose we've got to close it when we do the servicing missions on it, right?
Yeah, yeah, but now there's not going to be any more.
So if they close it now and it doesn't open, it's like, oops.
Yeah, why take that risk?
Yeah, really.
All right, so every year for Hubble's anniversary,
we have to do something special, right?
And the Hubble Heritage team for the last several years
has decided to come up with a really cool observation.
So, you know, we've done the Horsehead Nebula.
We've done the Whirlpool Galaxy.
One year we did those 59 different images of galaxy collisions
for our 18th anniversary.
We did Mystic Mountain for the 20th anniversary.
So it's become tradition to have a really cool image to release
to celebrate Hubble's anniversary.
Now, of course, that doesn't occur until later this month, all right?
But this last month, in March, they had a conference in Rome.
Science with the Hubble Space Telescope,
I guess the fourth version of this conference.
And so the powers that be here at Space Telescope decided that,
hey, you know what?
It would be really nice if we could release the image
in association with this conference.
And then, you know, the folks at the conference could, you know,
see the anniversary image early.
So we did that, okay?
But we still saved something for the actual anniversary.
So here what we did is we looked at a star-forming region,
and we looked at a small piece of a star-forming region.
When you form stars, those bright stars actually eat away the gas of the nebula,
and they form these famous pillars that we've seen in many other images, right?
And so we looked at a pillar in what's called the Monkey's Head Nebula.
And we didn't look at it using visible light,
because visible light, you know, you see a dark pillar.
We actually, this time we looked at it in infrared light.
And so Hubble's 24th anniversary image is a pillar in the Monkey's Head Nebula.
And now that I've built it up for minutes and minutes here,
I'll actually show it to you.
And there it is.
Ah, ooh.
You know, I never did see the monkey head in this, but anyway.
You're not going to see the monkey head in this image, right?
Because this is just one pillar within the whole Monkey's Head Nebula.
The Monkey's Head Nebula is much, much bigger.
But I wasn't going to show you the Monkey's Head Nebula until next month
when I actually show you our 3D visualization of flying into the Monkey's Head Nebula.
Oh, nice.
I half expected you to show me a picture of that angry monkey from Family Guy in the closet.
Well, maybe we'll work on that as an Easter egg for our visualization next month.
Okay, great.
So this is something we do every year to mark the anniversary of the Hubble Space Telescope.
And this is this year's anniversary image.
So this is amazing.
This is a really cool image, and it's in infrared.
So not only do you see all sorts of stars in the image that you wouldn't see using visible light,
but you'll notice that you'll see lots of galaxies in this image.
You're looking through the nebula on through the stars of our galaxy behind the nebula,
and you're seeing distant galaxies behind that.
And there's all sorts of cool details in this image that I didn't want to go into today
because I'll be able to show them off really cool next month
when I not only show you the image and the whole Monkey's Head Nebula,
but also a 3D visualization of a fly into the Monkey's Head Nebula,
the pillar in the Monkey's Head Nebula.
So in the optical, this is just one big dust cloud that isn't very remarkable,
but in the infrared you can see all kinds of glowing dust and gas that's inside this star-forming region.
I would say it's a nice pink emission nebula in optical,
but you get a lot more detail and structure with the infrared
because the infrared light has longer wavelength,
so it penetrates deeper into the dust clouds,
and also these dust clouds are at temperatures where they glow in the infrared.
They aren't hot enough to glow that much.
Only portions of them are hot enough to glow in visible light,
but more of them are hot enough to glow in infrared light.
What's the characteristic for these pillars?
We see them a lot in a lot of Hubble images.
What causes those pillars usually?
The pillars come from the high-energy radiation of newborn stars
that eats away the low-density gas.
So the ultraviolet light and the strong, stiffer wind from massive newborn stars
eat away the low-density gas, leaving only the highest-density regions,
and behind those high-density regions forms a pillar.
So you see those in lots of the same areas where stars are being formed
and solar winds are creating these variations in density.
Exactly. You get a lot of pillars, star-forming regions.
Okay, cool. Thank you.
Well, as that is, do you have more to show us, or is that the last slide you have?
That's all I have for this month.
Okay. Well, thank you, Frank. This has been really cool.
I like that we do this every month, because Frank is able to get us caught up.
He has a perspective that nobody else does,
because he keeps an eye on a lot of different areas,
not just Hubble science, but things that would be of interest to others
and lots of audiences.
I remember we were doing ISON stuff planning last year.
He was already talking about this comment, the one that's passing by Mars.
I really appreciate you taking the time out, Frank, to get us caught up on stuff.
I am looking to see if we've got any questions, and I'm not seeing any.
I had one earlier that I'll ask you about, Frank,
and you can maybe have something to say about it.
Katie Stokoe from YouTube wanted to know
what we hope we'll be able to see with JWST when it takes its first image.
I was just curious what your thoughts are on that.
The first images off of JWST are probably going to be relatively unremarkable,
but that may be wrong.
Okay. Well, the very first images from JWST will be like they were from Hubble.
They'll just be calibration images.
We'll be calibrating the telescope and such.
But the first publicly released images will be ones that will be specially chosen
to have some scientific as well as aesthetic value.
Maybe I'm reading the question a little too literally.
So in case I am, let's go ahead and expand that a little bit to think,
what do we hope will be some of the first things JWST looks at scientifically?
First things I would look at are dust disks around other stars
because JWST will have the resolution and the infrared wavelengths
to be able to look deeply into those dust disks
and try and see planets forming around them.
There are a number of dust disks in the Orion Nebula
that I think would be absolutely beautiful first targets
to go take a look at and see what's going on there.
So when you say dust disks, you mean these protoplanetary disks?
Protoplanetary disks.
Pre-planets, these pre-solar systems that are just forming?
They're solar systems in formation, but because the dust is dense and dark,
when we look at it with visible light, we need infrared light to look deeper into them
and see the warm gas clouds forming planets within them.
So that's one of my first observations that I would do with it.
Okay, so this one, let me select this question here.
This is from Michael Jobin again.
Hi Michael, it's good to see you.
I'm glad you take some time out to always comment on our stuff.
Hey, I just bought a C-band satellite Earth dish
just to get good live and complete coverage on NASA Select TV of the HST launch
just to record it all on VHS.
So you had this high quality thing and then you got it all on VHS.
That is one of the things.
Actually, with Neil Tyson doing the Cosmos series,
I looked up in my closet and I have a pristine version of the original Cosmos
by Carl Sagan on VHS.
Yes, so do I.
Let me ask your opinion on that, Frank.
I get a lot of questions about this.
Let me get your take.
What do you think of Cosmos?
Do you watch it every week?
I don't watch it every week because I do astronomy for a living
and when I get home, it's not that relaxing to go listen to somebody else talk about astronomy.
I hear you, brother.
I feel the same way.
I actually don't watch it right away.
I kind of let it queue up on my DVR a little bit.
I have episodes queued up on my DVR
and I have watched some of it.
You know that my specialty is scientific visualizations.
I don't have any problem with Neil.
I don't have any problem with the writing.
I don't have any problem with the story.
They go too far this way or too far that way
and everybody is going to do it when they present the universe.
I'm going to pick on what I know best
and it's the depictions of astronomy in the visualizations.
There, I got to say, too much power was given to these Hollywood computer graphics companies
because they made basic scientific errors in some of the graphics
and that's what really has bothered me about it.
Again, I'm just saying that because that's my specialty
but when they have that spaceship of the mind
dodging asteroids in an asteroid belt,
I got to say, what the hell?
Because Neil knows much better that the asteroid belt is relatively empty
and the depiction from the Empire Strikes Back is just wrong.
That's right.
It's not really close together.
So, whoever was supposed to do scientific oversight of their graphics,
the beautiful stuff that they're coming up with,
there are several really bad errors in the graphics.
They depict the Great Red Spot on Jupiter as being a depression,
like the eye of a tornado.
Well, that's exactly opposite of the truth.
The truth is that the red clouds in the Great Red Spot
are actually 8 miles higher than the surrounding clouds.
So, they gave it to some Hollywood guys who said,
oh, this looks like this
and then they put it together and put it on TV in front of 8 million people
but 8 million people got to see the wrong thing.
That's what I don't like.
That would be my pick on the show.
Yeah, I hear you and I agree that that's probably a pretty important part
you want to make darn sure you get right
because that's the part that people are trying to connect these ideas and the text
and they need something visual and that's what's going to make the connection.
So, I see your point and I agree with you on that.
I guess from my perspective though, I loved Cosmos a lot.
I really did and it was the first show of its kind that had ever been done.
We learned about astronomy.
I couldn't believe I was getting astronomy information in my living room
in the 70s and 80s and I was hooked.
There was something about Carl Sagan.
There were these ways in which he did things.
There was this one where he was sitting on a boat talking about whales
and just doing these weird isms that only he could do.
That was endearing but it's also not duplicatable in my opinion.
I think that Neil could have done a show that was his and not Cosmos
and there's just some things I don't think we need to do again.
Time passes.
I think that they did a show called Cosmos
because that's what's going to get funded, right?
I know and that's what's going to get the attention.
But the major difference I find in the storytelling here
is that these aren't Neil's stories that he's telling.
They have script writers, Andrean and Steve Soder,
who wrote the script and Neil is the host who's using their script.
Now, I worked with Neil for five years.
I actually knew him for several years before that.
We met when I was doing a postdoc in Princeton
and his office was right next to mine in the Princeton Department of Astrophysics.
When he gets on a roll and he's telling one of his stories,
he's fantastic, absolutely amazing.
I can just feel that he's telling not quite his stories.
There are times when his passion does show through
and I think the sincerity that Carl did came because it was really more his.
He chose the stories. He chose the way he was going to tell them.
He had a little bit more control.
That's well said. I agree 1,000%.
You hit on, I think, the real key there.
I know what you mean. I've seen it in interviews with Neil.
He's all over, but you see him.
I was watching him one day talking with Bill Boyers on Sunday morning
and he was giving an interview.
They were just asking him all kinds of random questions
and his answers were very passionate and you're right.
I saw what you're talking about.
Every once in a while he would get on a roll.
You do it too when you're out in front of people.
You get on a roll.
You start to get into a groove that you have your own style
that when you're telling your story your way,
there is simply no other way.
You're making your own unique and indelible mark on the story
and that's more memorable than trying to duplicate something else.
I love the way you put it because you're right.
That is it.
Neil is not doing Neil.
Neil is doing Carl or at least a version of him.
I think that's where it kind of, I don't want to say falls flat,
but it isn't as inspiring as it could be.
It's not that it's not inspiring.
It's good stuff. It's really good stuff.
It's just we always pick on the edges to see what could be just slightly better
or what might make it reach the level that Carl gets.
It may be inspiring to people who've never seen anything like it before
and that's good. That is good.
Michael Jobin is asking how my ping is
and I think that's in relation to the problems we were having earlier.
I just did a test while we were having the problems
and my ping is 19 milliseconds and I have plenty of bandwidth,
so it's just not me.
The fact that both of us were having the problems
says that it's not either of our connections.
Right. Both of our connections were having problems at the same time
and it came on again just a little bit later on.
I don't know if you heard that.
I think it's just part of being at the mercy of this technology.
I just think that there are periods of congestion or whatever
and not necessarily at our end
because I have had my internet connection diagnosed with a fine tooth comb.
Anyway, thank you guys for your patience.
It seems I've gone away though.
Okay. I'm looking here to see if there's any others real quick before we go.
Carlos Fartburger. Really?
Oh my gosh. I just got to show this.
It's just like crazy. Carlos Fartburger.
He's from YouTube. Great stuff, guys.
I'm going to watch this. It gets uploaded later.
Thank you for watching at least as long as you could.
I just had to show Carlos Fartburger. That's all.
Okay. I guess that's it for this week, guys.
Frank, do you have anything else you'd like to add?
Any announcements? Anything you want people to look out for?
Just that we have two public lectures this month, April 29th.
We have an amazing guest speaker from the Library of Congress
and Denver Museum of Nature and Science.
I'm blanking on his last name. Do you remember, Tony?
David Grinspoon.
David Grinspoon. I was going to come up with some Harry Potter type name.
David Grinspoon will be speaking on the human era on Earth.
He calls it Terra Sapiens.
Then May 6th, we have Bonnie Meinke, a Saturn expert,
who will be talking on the making of moons.
Saturn really has the coolest moons in the solar system.
Well, some of the Jupiter moons are cool too,
but Saturn just has such variation across their moons.
She should have a really good talk then.
Yeah, I wouldn't put Europa in any slouchy moon.
I'm hoping that – I don't want to promise it yet
because I haven't talked to anybody at the Institute,
but I'm hoping to get permission to live stream
those public lecture series on YouTube as well
so you guys can leave comments.
You'll be notified if you subscribe to our YouTube channel
and you had better be subscribed to it.
You'll get notified and you'll be reminded
when those public talks are coming.
Also, Frank, I spoke to you about this briefly,
but I just want to make sure – I kind of want to have a hangout
with you and David when he gets here.
Can we maybe do that?
It depends on David's schedule.
I've talked to John Davis about it,
but I haven't gotten a response.
So, yeah, we're going to try and do that.
And you and I should do a hangout on our new video page
in a couple of weeks.
Yes, yes, we'll be talking about that.
I don't want to give – you told me not to talk about it,
so I'm not going to.
Just let people know that we've got lots of cool things upcoming.
Okay, yeah, we do.
And so that's what's on tap.
Look for another public lecture series late in April and early May.
I'll get one hangout.
If I can get David Grinspoon and Frank in a hangout together,
I would love that because David is my old professor from the University of Colorado,
and I have a lot of questions with him.
He's a great expert on Venus as well,
so we can get a lot of good stuff from him.
And I will let you know.
Follow us on – subscribe to our YouTube channel.
Follow us on Twitter at Hubble Telescope.
I'm at Deep Astronomy.
Frank is at Dr. Frank Summers.
And hopefully we will see you guys next time.
Thank you for watching.
And as always, keep looking up.
