The first stars and galaxies formed in the early universe had very distinctive properties we've only just begun to understand. With the help of +Frontier Fields, we've looked back into time as far as #Hubble will allow and we've learned some remarkable things about these early times.
We await the launch of #JWST to learn more, and this hangout will feature Massimo Stiavelli, an astronomer who specializes in the early universe and manager of the JWST Mission at STScI.
Please join +Tony Darnell and Dr +Carol Christian as they look towards the exciting science the James Webb Space Telescope will provide to help us understand the first stars and galaxies in the early universe.
Bring your questions and comments and we'll read them on air throughout the hangout!
Hello, everybody, and welcome to the brand new 2015 season of the Hubble Hangouts.
My name is Tony Darnell.
I work at the Space Telescope Science Institute, and we are back from our meetings and all
of our other stuff.
And this is our first back to our normally scheduled Hangout.
And so we're glad you're back.
We hope you had good holidays and got all that out of your system.
And Carol and I just got back from the 225th meeting of the American Astronomical Society.
And Carol, do you know that we did 11 Hangouts in like four days or something like that.
It was like crazy.
That was exhausting.
It was amazing, though.
Yeah, so we're still kind of decompressing from all of that, but we have a great Hangout
planned for you today.
We have Dr. Massimo Stivelli.
He's the JWST mission head at the Space Telescope Science Institute, and he is going to tell
us a lot about the early universe, the first stars, the first galaxies.
And we're going to learn all about what this sort of interesting time in the history of
the universe was like.
And so before we get to the discussion, let me welcome, let me say hi to Scott.
Scott, happy New Year.
Happy New Year, Tony.
How are you?
It's good to see you again.
I'm glad you're back.
Good to see you, too.
Good.
So one of the things that 2015 is bringing in for us is it marks the 25th anniversary,
and I'm sure you've heard us say this already, of the Hubble Space Telescope being in orbit.
25 years.
So throughout the year, we at the Institute have got a lot of different things planned,
a lot of content we're going to be creating, some special Hangouts we're going to be doing.
But if you want to follow along on what is going to be planned and where it's going to
be and when and all of that kind of stuff, we have set up a website.
It's called Hubble25th.org.
Don't forget the th part.
That's important.
It's H-U-B-B-L-E-2-5-T-H dot O-R-G.
So we hope you'll visit that site.
It's where we're going to post all the, that'll be the centerpiece around which we make sure
all the information gets disseminated and put out to people.
So we hope you'll check that website out and let us know if you have any comments or questions
or things like that.
Now, one of the things I wanted to do, Carol and I are currently putting together the list
of Hangouts for this year, and I would like to shout out to you guys.
Let us know if you've got any ideas for Hangouts you would like to see in the coming year so
that Carol and I can take that into consideration when we do the scheduling.
Because we'd like to hear from you.
We want to make sure that you're getting the most out of these Hangouts as possible.
So if you tweet out your ideas using the HubbleHangout hashtag, we will see it and Carol and I will
talk about it and see if we can make it happen for you.
So we hope you'll do that.
Which brings me to, finally, interacting with us on this Hangout, HubbleHangout hashtag.
That's the easiest way.
You can tweet on that.
You also can leave us questions and comments at the Q&A app.
I'm already seeing a couple here.
You can also leave some comments on the YouTube page, and we're monitoring all of that.
And we'll bring them up as the conversation progresses.
And if it's relevant to what Massimo's talking about, I'll bring it up.
So without any more ado, let's get started.
With me today, as I said, is Dr. Massimo Stievelli.
He's the JWST Mission Head.
Hi, Massimo.
Welcome, and thanks for coming.
Greetings, everyone.
My pleasure.
Good.
So you, tell us a little bit about, one of your big research interests, and one of the
things I love talking with you about, is this period in the early universe where first stars
and galaxies formed.
Give us some idea.
Can you tell us, first of all, what do we mean when we're, is there a specific range
of dates or times when we say the early universe, or is it just a very nebulous concept?
What is the early universe?
So to speak.
Yeah.
It's a little bit of a...
Oh, I was punny right there.
Yeah, you were.
You were punny.
I didn't even notice.
It's a little bit nebulous.
Some people would split it between the very early universe and the early universe even.
But roughly speaking, as you go back in time, you get to the point where the universe looks
very different from what it looks around us today.
And how very different is a little bit of a matter of personal taste.
But roughly speaking, I would say, if you get to a point where you don't have any galaxy
around, you could call it early universe.
And before that time, you have a number of events, you know, you have the formation of
the first stars.
You have a number of phenomena that, you know, happened very early after the Big Bang, including,
you know, that rapid expansion of the universe that we call inflation.
So essentially, inflation to the formation of the first stars, of the first galaxies
could be a good definition of early universe.
Okay.
So, I want to, one of the reasons, and this is a hard question for me to ask in a way
that would make any sense, but what I'm trying to get at is, how is it that we can see back
in time?
Do you understand the question?
How is it that when we look at the, when we look up with powerful telescopes in space,
we're actually seeing this past period of the universe?
What makes that possible?
Well, that's, it's the combination of the huge size of the universe and the finite speed
of light.
You know, when I look around in my room, or even across the street from the window, I
don't notice that the speed of light is finite because the distance is very small.
But in fact, when I see somebody walking down the stairs in the building in front of me,
you know, I'm not seeing them now, I'm seeing them, you know, some microseconds or fraction
of a microsecond ago when they were going down the stairs.
So the difference is not important for many practical purposes.
Once you go and look at galaxies and these more and more distant galaxies, their distance
is so large that the light travel time is actually important.
And so you see these objects in the past.
We see the Sun as it was 8 minutes ago.
And we see, you know, the nearest big galaxy as it was, you know, 2 million years ago.
And it gets more and more remote as we go to more distant objects.
That to me has always been a great consequence of the finite speed of light.
I mean, it's one of the things that the universe is so large and it's been around for so long
that, you know, we keep seeing further back, the dimmer the objects are, the further away
they are, the further back in time we are seeing them because it took a certain amount
of time for that light to get here.
Now, let's talk a little bit about the size of the universe.
You mentioned already there was a period where the universe went through a rapid expansion.
I'm presuming you're talking about inflation at that point.
But this is a period after inflation that you're interested in, correct?
Yes, yes.
So the universe, we all know, is expanding and it's accelerating as it does so, which
implies that in the past it has been smaller.
So in this period that we're talking about, this early universe period, how big was the
universe, roughly?
Well, there are two sides to that question.
One is that we don't really know how large the universe is because we have a horizon.
We have, and the horizon is set by what is the most distant point or sphere in the universe
that is distant enough and still allows enough time for light to get to us.
There could be parts that are even more distant than that and that's the observable universe.
So what happens beyond that can be defined by mathematical models, but is not observable.
We think that inflation will actually grow the universe from a tiny little speck to something
which is much larger than our observable universe.
So there is a lot beyond our horizon, at least based on our current models and understanding.
So for all practical purposes, the point beyond the observable universe is not really relevant
to us in any way because we can't really get any information from it, since we're bound
by the speed of light, correct?
Yeah, and whether we will see something or not depends also on the degree of acceleration
of the universe.
Because in a universe that was decelerating, we would be seeing more and more of the universe
as time goes on.
But if it accelerates, actually, that's not the case.
That's a good point, actually.
It's not necessarily a linear thing.
The further back in time, let's say half of the universe's age before, the rate at which
the universe was expanding could have been different than what we're seeing now.
So there could be, and we don't know the answer, like you said, the rates of expansion could
have been different throughout different points in the history of the universe.
So that's an important point to consider.
And of course, dark energy, they're saying, which is another topic we won't go into right
now, is supposedly responsible for some of this acceleration.
So let's get to the stars and the first stars and galaxies themselves.
So set the stage for us.
What's the conditions of the universe for the first stars to form?
Stars came first, presumably, and then galaxies, right?
So after the Big Bang, the universe expands and cools down.
And at some point, we use a quantity called redshift that is essentially has to do with
the ratio of the size of the universe, the scale length of the universe today and at
the time that we are looking at.
So for simplicity, we define it with a 1 plus z.
For simplicity, so everybody understands what we're talking about.
So when we talk about redshift 9, we are talking about a universe that was 10 times smaller
than it is today.
At redshift 99, it was 100 times smaller than it is today.
Bravo!
Outstanding explanation, by the way.
That's the best explanation for redshift I've heard so far.
So at a redshift of around 1300, the universe got cold enough that hydrogen, which is the
most common element that was ionized, separated in protons and electrons, recombines and the
universe becomes neutral.
Now radiation, the photons, interact strongly with electrons.
Once those electrons make it back to an atom of hydrogen, the interaction of light and
radiation and atoms become much less good.
And as a result, we have effectively a decoupling between the radiation and matter.
And that's the epoch when the cosmic microwave background radiation is released.
Of course, at redshift 1300, it was not cosmic microwaves, it was actually light.
The wavelength of light also scales like the redshift.
So the wavelength of light at redshift 1300 was 1,300 times smaller than it is today.
So what we now see as microwave was infrared and visible radiation.
So that is a milestone in the universe and once matter is neutral, it can cool down even
further.
At the same time, dark matter was starting to feel the pull of gravity.
The universe was not absolutely uniform.
It had little ion-homogeneities, which are in fact the things that you see in the sky
maps from cosmic microwave satellites like WMAP.
And those little fluctuations of density start collapsing.
Maybe Scott, could you find us a WMAP or something image at some point?
Yeah, I've got some.
Oh, you've got some.
Alright, cool.
Sorry, go ahead, Massimo.
If you have it, maybe we could show it right now and then go to the first movie.
Otherwise, we can just go to the first movie.
So there will be…
So the little overdense, yeah, I believe that the red spots are places that are ever so
slightly like one part in 100,000 more dense than the rest and the blue parts are less
dense than the rest.
So the things that are more dense will tend to grow because of their attractive nature
of gravity.
And so, that's the seeds from which the first structures in the Universe are formed.
And this is a snapshot of the decoupling you were talking about.
Yeah, that's a snapshot, exactly, of that time when what radiation was doing and what
the matter was doing were the same.
After that, the two get decoupled and radiations carry the same signal while matter starts
collapsing.
So, if we could go to the first movie, that shows a numerical simulation of how those
little density perturbations grow.
And this is just a snippet from one of the larger simulation efforts that people do these
days.
It's called the Illustrious Simulation.
Oh, yes.
We've seen this.
It's beautiful.
So you start from a more or less uniform background and things start coalescing to form filaments.
Now these filaments, what are they, stars or galaxies?
So in the simulation, this is just dark matter.
But hydrogen, once it's released from its equilibrium with radiation, can actually fall
into these gravitational potential wells defined by dark matter.
So it folds in and starts forming structures.
So one important thing is that that simulation describes what we call cold dark matter.
Cold dark matter is the prevailing theory these days and essentially is the idea that
dark matter has structure down to very low masses.
So some of those first structures have the mass of the Earth or the Sun and dwarf galaxies
and big galaxies and it's a bottoms up model.
So you first form the very small structures and then they merge together to form bigger
and bigger objects.
For instance, today in the Universe, this is the time when clusters of galaxies form.
A lot of the smaller structures have already formed.
So that's the stage for the future, basically the shape of everything that's going to follow.
Yes, but the reason I was making this distinction about cold dark matter is that even though
most people believe that dark matter is in the form of cold dark matter that has also
these very small components, we actually don't know for sure.
And there is actually a small parameter space, free as the opportunity, not ruled out by
present experiments, that dark matter could be warm.
That is made of particles that are a little bit less massive and so they were moving faster.
And by moving faster, they have smoothed out some of these smaller structures.
And so the figure that I have that compares from a recent paper, a simulation done with
cold dark matter and one done with warm dark matter, shows what I'm talking about.
OK, so let me just make sure I understand the difference here.
So cold dark matter is a slightly larger, less massive particle, so they were moving
slower, as opposed to warm dark matter, which is slightly smaller particles that can move
faster.
And so the slower particles can form very low mass structures, while the faster particles
smooth out structure and you end up with only somewhat larger structures.
So that's why that distinction is important, it will have an effect on what we see.
The large scales are very similar in the two, but the cold dark matter one has a lot of
graininess.
And those are very small halos of dark matter, around 10 to the 6th solar masses, a million
solar masses, or 100,000 to a million solar masses, that are essentially absent in warm
dark matter.
OK, Scott, do you know that figure he's referring to?
OK, can you put that up?
OK.
So I believe the left is the cold dark matter scenario, and the right is the warm dark matter
simulation.
Sure, that's what you mean, it looks a little smoother, smoothed out on the right.
So the warm is smoother, but the reason why we care is that the first stars actually would
form in those very little halos, a million solar masses.
So our prevailing ideas on the formation of the first stars would dramatically be altered
if dark matter ended up being warm.
And now that's a problem and an opportunity, because since we don't know for sure, it means
that our predictions about the first stars could be wrong.
It's an opportunity, because if we see that the predictions are not verified, it could
become even a test on the type of dark matter that we have.
OK, well that's an important distinction.
Now I want to get to the stars here in just a minute, but I've got a relevant comment
from Hugo Burnham who's asking on the Q&A app, what is the largest redshift we can observe
from Earth?
And presumably it would be what you were talking about, the CMB, correct?
So yes, in terms of the most distant redshift where we can see a light signature is the
1300.
If we were able to observe neutrinos much better than we can now, we would actually
be able to see neutrinos from a little bit of a higher redshift.
And if we were able to observe gravitational waves a lot better than we can do now, then
we would even be able to probe perhaps even down to the inflationary period.
Yeah, that was big news last year.
Yeah, so it really depends on what it is that, well the news last year was a constraint on
gravitational waves coming from the Cosmic Microwave Background.
But in principle you could imagine building something that would let you see the relics
of those waves directly.
I mean it's extremely difficult.
Cool, that's great.
So thank you Hugo, good question.
So you've set the stage for us, you've told us the importance between the cold dark matter
and the warm dark matter and the formation of the structures that may have brought the
first stars into being.
What's next?
What's the next stage?
So in those little halos, the little grainy structures in the cold dark matter image,
gas falls in, cools down and at a redshift of around 50-55, so you're talking about
40-50 million years of age for the Universe.
So very early on, you would form the first population three stars.
These are the first stars.
These are extremely rare objects.
And the second simulation actually gives a little bit of an indication of what would
happen in one of these halos.
So while Scott pulls that up, let me just summarize what I think.
So we've got a Universe, it's got either cold or warm dark matter and a lot of hydrogen.
And I'm assuming cold because that's the prevailing assumption and we know a little
bit less of what would happen with the warm.
Sure, sure.
And so we've got all this hydrogen swirling around and being attracted by gravity and
presumably influenced by the dark matter around it.
So here he goes.
So go ahead.
So I'm not seeing the simulation yet.
Click on his thumbnail.
It might come up.
I can see it.
OK.
It's hard to comment.
So this is gas now.
As gas collapses, it forms little dense knots.
Those knots form these very massive first stars and then these massive first stars explode,
producing the little supernova explosion.
Pretty soon in the bright knot that we see now, we'll have another explosion, I think,
coming up.
OK.
Yep, there it is.
So it shows the formation of a small and then you see the supernova remnant going up.
So these stars, the first stars, are very unusual.
Most of the stars that we know about in the local universe are actually a chemical composition
that includes other elements beyond hydrogen and helium.
Astronomers call everything heavier than helium metals.
Yeah, I always thought that was weird.
I'm assuming with the disapproval of everybody with a chemistry degree, but anyway.
So the local stars have metals.
Some have more, some have less, but they all have some.
One of the things that happened in the early universe is the primordial nucleosynthesis.
This is when the nuclei of atoms are formed.
The primordial nucleosynthesis forms helium and very small traces of other elements.
Very very little lithium, very little deuterium, not much at all.
So most of the elements that we see around us today are made in stars.
But it's a little bit of a chicken and an egg.
And since all the stars we see have some metals, who made those metals?
Well, the previous generation of stars.
If you push it a little bit, you get to the first generation of stars.
So there must have been a generation of stars that formed from the material that came out
of the Big Bang with the primordial composition and made the first elements.
Because they were so different in composition than present day stars, we think that those
objects would be much more massive, they would be much hotter, they would live shorter lives
and they would end their lives with gigantic supernova explosions.
Great, that was a great summary.
And that's primarily just due to the fact that they coalesce from these bigger clumps
at the beginning of the universe?
They come from bigger clumps and because they don't have a lot of metals and because there
are no structures around that make them spin, we think that they would probably not be able
to fragment into a multitude of smaller stars and so they would just form single, unusually
large stars.
Oh, that's interesting.
I never thought about the effect of spin on these things.
I guess it would make a difference.
And the other effect is that we know that stars and winds, they lose material in the
outskirts and those winds are large because of their chemical composition.
Essentially, radiation pushes on the metals in their atmospheres.
So if you remove the metals, the winds are much less strong and so the star retains a
larger fraction of its mass and this enables it to undergo a much more violent supernova
explosion.
In fact, it's an explosion that we call a pair instability supernova.
I love that.
I like saying it, it makes me feel smart when I do.
The star is so hot that in its atmosphere, it forms little pairs of electrons and positrons.
So it forms little amounts of antimatter.
When you form, since it takes a lot of energy to form a little bit of matter, when you form
these electron-positron pairs, you remove a lot of energy from the radiation field of
the star and that radiation is what's fighting gravity.
It's what's compensating gravity for these massive stars.
So when you do that, when you remove that energy, the star tends to collapse and become
even hotter.
But then, since it's hotter, it will form even more of these electron-positron pairs.
So it will collapse even more and get even hotter.
And so, as you can imagine, this doesn't end well.
And we think that these pair instability supernova explosions destroy completely the star and
you are looking at explosions that are potentially hundreds of times brighter than the 1987A
supernova.
Right, which was relatively close by.
So with a telescope with infrared sensitivity, like the James Webb Space Telescope, you would
be able to see these objects essentially anywhere in the Universe.
Ok, so let me back up just a second.
These first stars, they were bigger than most of the stars we see today.
They are hotter, they didn't live as long.
When they died, they died in these spectacular, it is believed, supernova explosions, some
of which could be called pair instability supernovae.
Yeah, it depends on the mass of the star.
Exactly.
So let me ask you this.
Since these supernovae are so bright, has Hubble been able to see any of this?
Are there any observations of these first supernovae?
Occasionally, there are rumors about a pair instability supernova being observed.
This is always a very debated issue.
In principle, a star in the Universe around us should not form such a supernova, because
even starting with a very massive star, since it has a chemical composition that is different
from primordial, it will lose a lot of mass.
So the core of the star, when the star is ready to go supernova, is just not massive
enough to make a pair instability.
Of course, as they say, where there is a will, if you imagine a pair of these stars, each
does its own evolution and they merge at the end, merging them could be a way to exceed
the mass threshold and have a pair instability even in something that didn't have any right
to go pair instability.
So we don't know for sure.
There may be ways to make a pair instability supernova in the local Universe, but certainly
it's not the preferred mechanism and if it happens at all, it's pretty rare.
And how would you know that you're looking at it?
Are there any characteristics that make it different?
One of the characteristics is that this supernova would remain bright for a very long time.
It would have the variation of luminosity with time, we call it a light curve, and they
have a very flat light curve.
So that would be an indication.
And then another indication would be looking at the material, the chemical composition
of what's left over.
So what he was talking about as far as the light curve goes is brightness versus time
and a lot of supernovae are very bright and they go down pretty quickly with time.
So he's saying that they would be bright for a very long time and that's one way we
would know that you're looking at a pair instability supernova.
So that's really great.
If you want to learn, Massimo actually helped me make a video on this a couple of years
ago.
It's called First Light.
If you do a search on our YouTube channel, you'll see it and we talk about pair instability
supernovas in there.
So I would encourage you to work on that.
Massimo was instrumental in getting that script or helping me write that script.
So I want to give a shout out to that.
Okay, so those are the stars, the first stars in the Universe.
What about the galaxies?
How much longer do we have to wait for galaxies to form now?
So there is where Hubble and the Cosmic Microwave Background Experiments have helped a lot,
because Hubble has pushed the frontier to higher Redshift.
Now we see galaxies with reasonable confidence up to Redshift 9.
There are some claims of Redshift 10 objects.
So we know that there are galaxies, Redshift 10 is 380 million years of age, just to give
a reference.
So we can go well within the first billion year, in fact within the first half a billion
year of the Universe.
At some point before Redshift 10, the first galaxies must have formed.
According to the prevailing models, and again, this is all predicated assuming that we know
that dark matter is cold.
If it's not, almost everything I said needs to be either corrected or is just wrong.
But anyway, in the cold dark matter, we expect that the first galaxies will actually form
from parts of space that have already been polluted in metals by the first supernovae.
So several generations of stars will have come into being.
Yes, one or two.
And so, the first galaxies that we see, we expect them to be not made of primordial galaxies,
or primordial stars, but made of stars that are low metallicity, but have some metal content.
So the composition would be somewhat intermediate from the lowest metallicity stars we see around
us and the primordial.
The supernova explosions spread a lot of material around.
Just for reference, I believe that the 1987A supernova released the 0.07 solar masses of
iron, of nickel, and the type of supernova that I'm describing would release 130 solar
masses.
Wow.
So that's a much more serious amount of metals.
That's a lot.
And we're thinking about the mass of the Sun and hundreds amount of just one element.
Yes.
So you can imagine that if in a large cloud you have even one supernova, it will produce
enough metals to pollute the whole cloud and then the next generation of stars will form
somewhat differently.
So we expect these galaxies to be low metallicity, but to have some metals.
How do we verify that that's true?
That's one area where Hubble is actually helping JWST observations.
These objects are very famed, the first generation of galaxies.
You could be pragmatic and say, whatever object I see at the highest ratio, I call it the
first galaxy.
But if you want to have a little bit of a more thought-out definition, you really want
to observe these objects that are the first galaxy-sized structures forming.
And we expect them to be famed even for James Webb.
Right.
And you're talking now, folks, he's talking about, if you look at the ultra-deep field,
the red dots in there are the kinds of galaxies he's talking about.
Very small, very faint.
So yeah, these are very difficult.
These are going to be extremely, I just want to interject that these are very difficult
to discover and then the verification, which you're talking about, is really not easy.
It's pretty clever.
But the red dots you see in the ultra-deep field are things that are reasonably easy
for JWST.
I knew he was going to say that.
I'm talking about the red dots that you don't see in the Hubble Deep Field.
And the thing that Hubble has done recently is to look at the frontiers field, look at
a bunch of clusters of galaxies that are natural telescopes, natural gravitational lenses that
amplify the objects behind them.
And having well-characterized gravitational lenses is going to be extremely helpful because
you would want to combine JWST with those lenses to really get to the faintest objects
that you could possibly observe.
Wow.
That really would be the absolute first galaxy.
I mean, that would be amazing.
That's the idea.
So what were these galaxies like?
Assumably, they were among the earliest stars, maybe not the first generation, like you said.
They've been through...
There are some metals in there.
But they're still pretty big, pretty hot, and they die pretty quickly, right?
Or have we calmed down a little bit in the stars?
Yeah.
It doesn't take a lot of metals to help these clouds from which the stars form fragment.
So we expect that already at the second generation of stars, you will have somewhat a more normal
mass distribution, some massive and some smaller ones.
And in fact, some might even be sufficiently small to live, you know, the billions of years
that are needed to have them survive to the present time.
Of course, the problem is that if you have a handful, say a thousand of these stars,
in the Milky Way, it would not be easy to find them.
Okay.
But we could have some of those that have remained, you know, from those days.
So tell us a little bit...
Oh, I have to read this.
Hugo Burnham is saying, I'm looking for the red dots I can't see in the Ultra Deep Field
but struggling to see them.
That's because...
Because some of them aren't there or not observable.
I'm looking for the red dots I can't see but struggling...
That's pretty good.
I like that.
Thanks.
So tell us a little bit about the galaxy shapes.
Were they markedly different from the galaxies of today or are they more or less the same?
Were they spirals or what about the sizes of these things?
We expect them to be pretty regular.
So in terms of mass, you're looking at things that have a mass lower than the lowest companions
of the Milky Way, than the smallest companions of the Milky Way.
So these are very small galaxies and they are probably just irregular fuzz in those
stages.
Certainly there is no time or way to form anything like a spiral structure.
A spiral structure needs a well-defined disk to form and this requires a very nice, well-established
rotation pattern in the galaxy.
These objects will probably have a lot of irregular motions.
You can imagine the kind of things that we were seeing at the end of the first movie.
They are still accreting matter from filaments.
They're very regular.
So they're kind of clumpy, not really well-defined shapes at all.
What about the number of stars?
Are they smaller, more or less?
Some of these would start with very few stars.
Even in the ultra-deep field, we see as we go to higher redshifts in the Hubble Ultra-Deep
Field, that you see less and less regular objects and more and more of those objects
that people refer to as train wrecks.
So we see that tendency to more irregular shapes even after 1 billion years, in the
more recent universe.
So I would imagine that the train wreck type of object would become dominant at earlier
times.
OK, you've touched on this already, but I'll bring it back up again so we can focus
on the spacecraft, on JWST.
You've mentioned already that Hubble, through surveys like the Frontier Fields, where we're
looking at these deep fields that are being gravitationally lensed, that are giving Hubble
a little bit more of an insight than it would ordinarily get because it's using the help
of the gravitational lenses.
So we've taken our first steps into this science and into getting more observations
to sort of back up some of the models that you're working with.
Give us a glimpse of what your hopes are for JWST in this field when it launches in October
2018.
What are you hoping to see?
So let me say first of all that what's limiting Hubble is not so much its size, but its temperature.
So Hubble, initially, the Ultra-Deep Field was done with the advanced camera.
It was a visible light instrument.
And so, if you look at objects that are distant enough that their light gets red-shifted in
the infrared, it's not a matter of sensitivity.
It's a matter that you're just blind to that light.
When Wide Field Camera 3 was installed, Hubble gained significant sensitivity to some near-infrared
wavelengths.
And that's what allowed Hubble to push from red-shift 6 to red-shift 9.
The Ultra-Deep Field in the infrared doesn't represent more exposures than the Ultra-Deep
Field in the visible.
It's just exposure with an infrared-sensitive camera.
So if you could add an instrument to Hubble that goes to even longer wavelengths, it could
see some objects at higher red-shift.
The problem is that Hubble, the primary mirror of Hubble, is at ambient temperature.
And so, even if you built an instrument for going to this infrared wavelength, the mirror
itself would be glowing red-hot from the point of view of that instrument.
So the background would be so high that you wouldn't be able to see.
So Hubble is designed as a great imaging instrument, but for visible or near-infrared wavelengths.
And so, the advantage of JWST is not only that it's bigger, but also that it's cold,
and so it can observe at these longer wavelengths.
I was also going to point out that Hubble is sensitive in the ultraviolet.
One of the things that's interesting about that in the 2014 release of the Hubble Deep
Field with the UV channel is that you'd see a lot of galaxies with a lot of star formation.
And then, when you think about that being red-shifted, that information is pretty important
to understand that process is when you kind of look at those galaxies closer, so that
when you go to JWST, you can say, oh, we've seen this stuff with Hubble at high resolution
in the ultraviolet and the visible, and now we can see stuff in the infrared and we might
have a clue how those galaxies work, or if they're different from the galaxies that
we analyzed already.
Yes, that is correct.
The other point is that some of the best fields for JWST to observe are the Hubble fields.
The reason is that when you go to objects that are this faint, you tend to use just
imaging data to select them, at least.
So, you might have interlopers, things that look like a high red-shift galaxy, but are
just maybe a little red, dust red, local galaxy.
Something that has the color of a high red-shift galaxy, but is not at high red-shift.
So, having the Hubble data for this type of object would be extremely useful, because
if you see anything with Hubble, it means that it wasn't at that high red-shift.
So, it would complement the selection with JWST by vetting the objects.
Oh, that's a good point.
Okay, well, tell us a little bit more about, so JWST will be cooler, it will have a much
larger mirror, so you'll be able to actually see, you're pretty confident that you'll
be able to see these first galaxies and even stars, correct?
Well, the first stars, it's very difficult.
We could have indirect evidence, or we could see their supernovae.
But even a very luminous star, it's too faint for JWST.
Okay, but maybe not the pair instability supernovae.
Yeah, we have enough sensitivity to see the pair instability supernovae, and then the
gain is related to how rare they are.
And so, one would need to do a search.
But the first galaxies, at least as interpreted as objects at red-shift earlier than 10, bigger
than 10, so within the first few hundred million years of the Universe, I'm pretty confident
that we will see them.
There is evidence from the Cosmic Microwave Background Experiments that there was something
at those red-shifts that was emitting ultraviolet radiation.
The reason is that with these experiments, you get essentially an integrated view in
the Universe that crosses all the times from now to the year of recombination, to this
red-shift 1300, when matter becomes, roughly speaking, neutral.
And those experiments are sensitive to how many electrons you have along your line of
sight from here to the 1300.
They can provide a measurement of how many electrons you have.
And if you have electrons, it means that some UV radiation ionized the hydrogen to produce
those electrons.
So it actually provides a constraint that is not very specific, but it's statistical
that says you had output of ionizing radiation at red-shift greater than 9 or 10.
That's the type of indication that we get.
So we know statistically that there are galaxies, I hate to say statistically, because people
have a negative reaction to that.
But there is evidence from the electrons that there are galaxies at red-shift greater
than 9 producing this ionizing radiation.
So we should be well positioned to see that.
Good.
Okay, well let me get to some comments, because we've got quite a few on the Q&A app.
Daniel Nassato from the Q&A app is asking, what would be emitting the light that we would
see beyond the CMB red-shift mentioned before, before or during inflation?
I think he's asking, what would the wavelengths be beyond the CMB?
Yeah, we wouldn't be seeing any light.
We would have to use, to study things happening before the CMB is released, we would need
to use other sources of information, like neutrinos or gravitational waves of light.
Right, because it was so dense, light actually wasn't able to get from it.
Okay, and we'll have a Hangout on that part of the Universe as well, because that's an
interesting time.
To be clear, no light means no light, no infrared radiation, no radio waves, nothing electromagnetic.
Yes.
Okay, Adam Synergy is commenting, Hubble 25th makes me feel really old.
Tell me about it.
Tony, shall I send my 25-page list of suggestions for Hangouts to you or Carol?
Yes, send them to both of us.
But yeah, if you've got some, I'll PM you my email address and you just send them to
me.
Or if there's a gift package involved, you can send it to me.
In fact, if I can chime in, Tony, I remember, I was actually already an active astronomer
before Hubble launched. I remember some colleagues claiming to see 30th magnitude galaxies with
other telescopes. These are the faintest objects that you can see in the Ultra Deep Field.
Somehow those claims disappeared after Hubble was launched.
I wonder why.
Yeah, they were getting called on to that.
Evidence does a lot of things, doesn't it?
Yes, Bob Harkins is asking, do the very large Population 3 stars, when they go supernova,
create black holes?
So, of course, this is model dependent, because we've never seen one. But we think that the
parent stability supernova actually leaves no remnant. Everything is dispersed.
For certain masses, they would produce a black hole. Essentially, it all depends, going through
the process that I described, where it gets denser and denser and hotter and hotter, it's
a race between gravity and radiation. So, the only issue is whether it bounces or not.
Does it get to a point that it's so dense that it manages to bounce, or does it keep
going? If it keeps going, it forms a black hole. Very little matter and metals are released.
If it bounces, it explodes. There may be even masses where it actually oxidates a little
bit before going either way. So, probably the first stars will do both, both form black
holes and do the parent stabilities, but depending on their specific mass.
Awesome. Good question. That was really good. This is from somebody that has characters
I can't read from the Q&A app, asking, hello, are there any other means of discovering the
first galaxies, etc., than the almighty JWST? Perhaps some plans for some far future telescope?
So I guess, JWST is up on deck next, but there's also WFIRST and the High Depth Space Telescope.
Will that give us better? Those are further down the road, right?
So for instance, there could be a nice synergy with WFIRST, because the parent stability
supernovae and the first stars may be very rare. So it may be impractical for JWST to
look for them, because it would take a lot of time with the field of view of JWST. With
an overlap with WFIRST, WFIRST has a large field of view, and at least at the RESH is
where it would be sensitive. WFIRST is sensitive enough to see the parent stability supernovae
just because they are so bright. So WFIRST could identify them as little red blips, and
then JWST could steer and take the additional data to confirm that it's really a parent
stability supernovae and so on. So that is a synergy. I could imagine another synergy
for radio experiments, looking at what we call the 21 cm radiation, experiments like
LOFAR that are ongoing to study this early Universe, because they would again provide
a different indication of possible areas where JWST could look for the first galaxies. The
High Definition Space Telescope is bigger, and so that helps, because it gives you higher
resolution and more sensitivity. It all depends on whether it will be designed to have sensitivity
at the infrared wavelengths of JWST. Otherwise it would be in the same position as Hubble.
It would have the sensitivity, but it wouldn't have the right wavelength coverage.
So we're looking at WFIRST in the 2020s, and I guess HiDEF in the decades following that.
So we've got a lot of exciting stuff coming up, all of which will contribute to the science.
Hugo Burnham is asking, Mesimo, taking into account the current shape of the Universe,
which I guess is flat, if we keep looking up, would we actually end up looking down?
Are you being a smart aleck? Yeah, he's being a smart aleck. That's my job. That's
what I'm here to do. There is actually a serious angle to the question. There were
people that were asking themselves what we call the topology of the Universe. When you
think about the Universe, you think of the Universe as a sphere, a giant sphere or cube
or something. But it could be a torus, like a donut. So if the Universe had the shape
of a donut, and you look along the axis, you could conceivably look at a fool looking in
the opposite direction from the back. And then Cosmic Homer would be very happy.
But a few people have tried experiments to constrain, statistically, that's the only
thing we can do now, the topology of the Universe, and they've come out empty-handed. There
is no evidence that there is any repetition in the number of objects we see.
I've got one more from Argentina on YouTube. This is an interesting question. Does dark
matter change over time? In other words, does it lose energy or mass? And is the only way
to see dark matter, is it at a cosmic scale? So there are two questions there. Does dark
matter change over time? And how do we see dark matter?
Yes. The sort of embarrassing point is that we don't know what dark matter is.
That's a bit of a sticking point. Most of the matter in the Universe is only
made better by the fact that we don't know what dark energy is, and that's the biggest
energy density in the Universe. So, in principle, many of the dark matter candidates are particles
that you could, in principle, produce in accelerators. So that would be one avenue where you actually
see the dark matter candidate in the lab. And other candidates are actually unstable
over very long timescales. They don't decay immediately, but over cosmic timescales they
would decay. So dark matter would actually be evolving, because a little bit at a time
it would disappear, and we would be able to detect the energy released when it decays.
And, in fact, there are already, in the scientific literature, some claims of these detections.
The issue is still debated. No claim has been accepted. But there are claims of detection
of decaying dark matter. The best places to look at it would be the centers of massive
clusters of galaxies, or our own galaxy, where you expect a lot of dark matter. And so you
have a bigger signature for the annihilation.
So how do we see this stuff? I've seen dark matter maps. They've made maps. So how do
you know?
So the dark matter annihilation, some of the claims, for instance, are based on Fermi.
You use X-ray or gamma ray satellites. So people have looked at Chandra data or Fermi
data trying to find that. The dark matter that we constrain, its existence has been
discovered thanks to its gravitational effect.
Yes, Scott is showing an animation now of gravitational lensing.
We can use gravity to produce a dark matter map, as you say. And the technique that we
use is less beautiful than the strong lensing that you see in clusters of galaxies.
Where you have these gravitational arcs. And it's called weak lensing. Weak lensing is
essentially the fact that the dark matter will tilt ever so slightly galaxies from the
position that they would normally have and would maybe squeeze them a little bit. Makes
them a little bit more flattened.
That allows you to track the distribution of matter if you know the properties of galaxies.
Again, this is a very difficult experiment. Again, I would have to invoke the word statistics.
You really don't like doing that, do you?
Because a single gravitational arc has a lot of information by its own. With lensing, you
need to look at millions of galaxies. And WFIRST would actually be able to do this type
of science. It's one of the primary reasons why it's built, to look at weak lensing.
We're out of time. Let's go ahead and stop there. Massimo, I want to thank you very much
for taking the time out to explain this.
You guys were great with all of your questions. Thanks for giving us so many great questions
and comments. We appreciate you doing that.
If you have not subscribed to our YouTube channel, Hubble Site Channel on YouTube, you
need to do that. Follow us on Twitter at Hubble Telescope. And don't forget, Hubble25th.org.
If you've got any suggestions or ideas for future Hangouts this year, please tweet your
ideas out using the Hubble Hangout hashtag or Hubble 25 or whatever. I'll be looking
at those and Carol and I will definitely take them into account.
Speaking of which, Carol, I don't recall what we're doing next week. We haven't finalized
next week's Hangout, have we?
Yes, we have.
We have. What is it?
You didn't get that memo Tony?
Apparently he didn't, even though I did send it to him. And Elena got it too. Andrew Fox,
who is from the Space Telescope, recently did a press release at the American Astronomical
Society where they have looked at the Milky Way Galaxy and they have detected these bubbles
that are coming out from the galaxy. It's a very clever technique and he's going to
talk about that and perhaps one of his colleagues will join us as well.
Great, you're right. I did get that memo and I'm all foggy from last week still. Please
join us next week, same bat time, same Hubble time, same Hubble channel. Next week, Thursday,
3 p.m. Eastern Time. That's it for this week everybody.
Easy for you to say.
Bye bye.
Thank you Massimo.
Thank you guys for watching and as always, Keep Looking Up!