MCB529 3-13-13: Circadian Rhythms of the Immune System
2 Video Views·Sep 5, 2023
in our class today.
He is an expert in the immune system and really
cancer in the brain, the interface of those areas.
Let me say by way of introduction
that this is a real opportunity for you guys to hear.
This is not exactly what he works on.
I've asked him and Josh Foley last week
to speak a little bit out of their comfort zone
because they don't work on rhythms,
but basically to take where they are
and look at how it interfaces with rhythms.
So a lot of this is new to them.
So that's one of the fun things about the class.
And so some of them are getting their minds expanded.
Now, is most of immunology funded out
of the National Institute for, what's it called?
Allergy and Infectious Disease?
Vitamin C?
A lot of it, yeah.
Because they're having a workshop.
I heard, I was in Chicago at a meeting last week.
They're having a workshop on clocks and the immune system.
But Fred Turek is going to go speak at this spring.
So this is a new, very new area, just the interface of clocks
and immune system.
So, OK.
This is our last session before spring break.
I hope you guys all have a great spring break,
because I tell you, I plan just to write a few papers, right,
guys?
And then we meet the Wednesday after spring break.
And I'm not sure what's on that week, but we'll find out.
We'll send that out to you.
But anyway, I'm just going to go all the way around.
Take my place.
OK.
So as Martha said, the reason I agreed to do this
is because, not because I do know about the immune system
and it's OK to really speak, but because I don't know about it.
And I thought I should find out what there is to know about it.
So I have been reading, and as usual,
it's a very complex area.
So probably, and actually to tell you
the truth in terms of some specific application
kind of things that I wanted to get to as I looked
at those papers, a couple that I put on reserve for you
kind of indicate this.
The effects are not overwhelming,
so it's difficult to judge how important they are.
So this is one of those fields where circadian rhythms could
be important, but it's not clear.
And I'll get to why that may be in a minute.
So yeah.
So that's why I was a little reluctant to have it filmed,
because it's not one of these prepared lectures presenting it.
It's sort of early in the exploration of this.
OK.
So I thought, I mean, you guys have already
heard a number of lectures about the circadian rhythm system,
and you know that everything is affected by circadian rhythm.
So it's no surprise that the immune system
is affected by circadian rhythm.
But in order to explain that and talk about that,
I figured I needed to spend some time talking
about the immune system.
So what are your backgrounds, generally?
Neuroscience or?
There's a whole range.
So we have a mixture of undergraduate and graduates.
Why don't we go around, John?
Yeah, tell me who we are.
My name is John.
I'm a senior, and I'm majoring in integrative biology.
And tell me that, and tell me if you
have background in circadian rhythms, or is it?
I have no background in circadian rhythms.
This is my first course taken.
OK.
I'm Harry.
I'm a fifth year grad student in Martha's lab.
I'm an MSB student, and I actually just
took immunology in the med school, so it's pretty fresh.
I'm Allie.
I'm an undergrad in molecular cellular biology,
and I work in Martha's lab.
I'm Lacey.
I'm a junior in molecular and cellular biology,
and I'm in Martha's lab.
I'm Alex.
I'm a senior in molecular and cellular biology.
I'm Giselle, first year in neuroscience,
a grad student in Martha's lab.
My research is in circadian rhythms.
I'm a second year grad student in molecular and nuclear
physiology, and I'm in Martha's lab.
You're a visitor, but go ahead and introduce yourself.
Oh, OK.
I'm Jenny.
I'm a junior in molecular and cellular biology,
and I have no type of.
I'm Grace.
I'm an undergrad in molecular and cellular biology,
and I also work in Martha's lab.
I'm Liz.
I'm an undergrad in molecular and cellular biology,
and I also work in Martha's lab.
I'm Liz.
I'm an MTB undergrad, and I was in the class,
so no experience with circadian rhythms.
I'm James.
I'm a third year CDB grad student in Martha's lab.
I work on circadian rhythms.
I'm Sam.
I'm a third year grad student in Martha's lab, and an MSP as well,
and I just took immuno with you as well.
OK, so two people who have immunology,
so you can, if I'm forgetting something, you can.
So the reason that the immune system
is important with respect to the title of this seminar, which
has to do with health and disease,
is the immune system has a big effect on health and disease.
It's the purpose of the immune system to recognize pathogens
and get rid of them.
Now, that's one aspect, but that's not
the only aspect of the immune system that
makes it important for health and disease.
Part of the processes by which they get rid of pathogens
includes the inflammatory response,
which is an early immune response to pathogens,
and thus creates all kinds of changes in physiology
to help get rid of those pathogens.
But very frequently, the inflammatory response
occurs without the pathogen, or when the pathogen is gone,
or just the tissue damage, or to stress,
or to all kinds of things that are not necessarily
pathogen-related.
And very frequently, the inflammatory response itself
is the disease.
And so there's been a lot of interest
in inflammation in many other diseases
where it had not been recognized.
So for instance, Alzheimer's disease.
For many years, Alzheimer's disease
has been attributed to amyloid accumulation.
Well, you can have amyloids if you
don't have an inflammatory response to amyloid.
You don't have Alzheimer's.
It's the inflammation that actually
causes the disease process.
Similarly, in cardiovascular disease,
inflammation plays a key role in that as well.
Cancer, in some cases, actually, cancer goes both ways.
In the system, it's chronically surveilling the body
and gets rid of tumors that you don't even know you had.
And on the other hand, inflammation
from low-grade immune responses creates cancer, particularly
the types of cancer.
Besides all those things, there are specific responses
of the immune system against self-tissues
that create diseases.
So 5% of people have some sort of autoimmune disease.
And that could be arthritis.
It could be diabetes.
It could be hepatic sclerosis.
These are diseases where the immune system inappropriately
is activated against self-tissues and causes damage.
So there's all those disease things.
And then also, a lot of people don't make the connection
that the inflammatory responses and immune cytokines
are necessary for wound healing.
So even if you have no pathogen, no chronic inflammation,
the immune system is important in wound healing.
And there are variables.
I haven't seen, I couldn't find anything on wound healing
and getting rid of this.
I'm sure there are other things like stress hormones affecting
cytokines affecting wound healing.
And those are some of the studies that I like
that actually reduce wounds in people.
You can puncture your roof of your mouth
or make a blister on your arm and look at the changes.
And those are affected by stress hormones.
And as I'm sure you've probably heard already,
stress hormones are one of the big things
that fluctuate the circuitry.
Have you heard that yet?
So what do you, yeah, which?
Well, I always talk about that.
Okay.
Any time of day with respect to heart,
heart attacks and things like that.
Okay.
But not much on hormones.
No, we haven't had much on hormones.
Okay, you haven't done the cortisol.
Okay.
So how many of you have ever
used hydrocortisone creams?
Probably everybody, no?
Maybe not.
That's cortisol, okay?
The reason, why do you put it on
when you have a rash or some inflammation?
It's because cortisol is anti-inflammatory.
Cortisol is anti-inflammatory for pretty much
every component of immune response, everywhere.
And cortisol has that same effect
during normal physiological fluctuations.
And cortisol has a nice circadian rhythm.
So a lot of the things that will,
would be affecting the immune system
and give the appearance of a circadian rhythm
could be caused by just the fluctuations in cortisol.
So we'll go into some detail on that.
So there's sort of separate issues
as to whether there's a circadian rhythm
in the immune system itself,
inherent, intrinsic to the immune system,
and whether there's a functional circadian rhythm
due to other mediators in both things, actually.
Okay, so that's the immune system.
Besides that, I think it's particularly interesting,
just inherently.
I was in, as a neuroscientist for 20 years
before I became an immunologist,
and I think both of them are equally interesting.
They're clearly responding to pathogens
is an important thing for the whole body,
and as much as 10% of genome is related
to things that are involved in the immune system.
It is a complex system,
and there are very many self-amplifying responses.
And this is one of the issues as to,
in terms of trying to figure out
how important circadian rhythm things are.
Circadian rhythms and other things like aging,
that probably are very important,
have been ignored by immunologists
for years and years and years
because immunologists are used to seeing huge effects.
Okay, so when you give a pathogen,
you get at least a 10, if not a 10-fold change in something.
And when you look at things like circadian rhythms,
there may be two-fold, or maybe 20%.
So, they haven't been as impressed
by those kind of changes,
but most of the responses of the immune system
are self-amplifying one way or another, or self-inhibiting.
So, you get in these feedback cycles
where it's sort of the butterfly effect, right?
If you have a small effect that's amplified,
that can be critical in determining
the outcome inside the world.
Similarly, they're self-limiting.
So, a lot of things that,
one thing that people don't realize about the immune system,
and it's really just much within the last 10 years or so,
is that shutting off an immune response
is a very active process.
So, it's not just you have an immune response,
the pathogen goes away,
and your immune response just kind of dribbles out.
There are everything that induces an inflammatory response
and activation of the system
also sets in motion things that will shut it off.
And then once things shut it off,
those things are self-limiting and further shut off.
So, you get an induction of regulatory T-cells,
for instance, those change the image-representing cells
that induce more regulatory T-cells.
So, these positive feedback things
that shut off as well as amplify.
So, because of that, these basically are nonlinearities,
that makes it difficult to predict what's gonna happen.
And it makes it difficult to assess
how important is a 20% change in a response
in the light and the dark.
So, health-wise, again, there's a lot of data out there
suggesting there are factors,
but when you look at some of them,
they're not always that impressive.
So, I'd say, clearly, there's an involvement
of circadian systems in immune responses.
And the more we know about it, the better,
but it's because of these factors
it's taken a lot of new knowledge to appreciate.
And so, what is the immune system
when we're gonna talk about that?
It's a lot of different things.
So, it's both cells and soluble proteins
that, together, eliminate pathogens,
but some of those cellular mediators are local,
there's a lot of paracrine communication,
and some of them are endocrine,
so things that we circulated in the bloodstream.
A lot of them are very local,
like there's synapses between the immune cells.
So, there's a lot of chemical communication.
The other thing is that pretty much every cell
in your body is part of the immune system,
but it's not specialized for that.
So, in terms of an antiviral response,
you get an interferon alpha response
that's inherent in all the cells in your body
to start trying to get rid of the virus.
Some things that we don't typically think of
as the immune system have major roles
in directing the immune response
and release cytokines that affect the immune cells,
so like the skin.
That was a big component of the immune system,
not only because of its barrier function
to keep the pathogens out,
but it initiates responses,
cytokines are released by skin cells,
and a lot of the inflammatory conditions
are related to that aspect of the skin function.
So, what people typically talk about
when you talk about the immune system
is those cells that are specialized for that function,
and typically white blood cells
that are circulating in the body
and also in particular organs.
There's some localization in specialized organs,
and some of them are distributed
through tissues throughout the body.
So, every tissue pretty much has some
resident macrophage-type cell,
so like microglia are that cell in the brain,
proofer cells in the liver, and so forth.
So, some of them are resident.
Mast cells are also resident
along points of entry in the body,
in the gut, for instance, in the airways, in the skin,
and these are all points of entry for pathogens,
so there's especially heavy local immune cells
that are distributed in those systems.
So, I like to also,
just because my background is in neuroscience,
make some of the analogies of the nervous system
and the immune system,
because the more I have learned about them,
the less different they seem to me,
and I would also include the endocrine system,
so hormones, the nervous system, and the immune system
are really, they're all part of the same thing,
they're just somewhat specialized,
they're not separate systems.
In fact, pretty much everything that's a neurotransmitter,
immune cells have receptors for it,
and everything that was discovered
as a cytokine in the immune system
affects brain function, neurons directly,
and is used as a neuromodulator within the brain,
so there's a lot of parallels that way.
Also, functionally, to me,
the immune system is like a mobile brain, okay?
So, we don't have a lot of long processes
that make you stay in one place,
but it has the same functions.
It has the sensory function.
The main purpose is to recognize pathogens
in a specific way, just like the sensory modality
for light versus air pressure changes,
for hearing versus, so the different modalities
of pathogens are recognized by specific receptors,
and so they're responsive to environmental stimuli.
The input from these is integrated
in a central place, in lymph nodes in particular,
and then there's a motor output,
which is in the immune system,
where cells are dispatched to get rid of the pathogens.
There's also the parallel that memory
is an aspect of both of the immune system,
and this is the basis for vaccination,
the fact that once an immune response
has been stimulated against a particular antigen,
there's amplification, and then those cells
are at higher baseline incident,
and they respond more quickly on the next time you see them.
So, immune memory is a classic component of the system.
And then, again, I mentioned already
the chemical messengers are identical,
and even to the point where the immune system
has synapses among the cells,
and there's intracellular communication as well.
So, where are they?
So, they're circulating in the blood,
in the lymph cells, in the resident tissue.
They're categorized according to whether or not
they're in organs that are in the early development
of the immune system.
So, the bone marrow and the thymus
are considered the central organs,
and bone marrow is where B cells differentiate,
and thymus is where T cells have differentiated.
And then, after they develop there,
they go out into the lymph nodes and spleen,
and those are the peripheral organs,
and the site where antigens are actually presented,
and cells are activated.
Okay, so, and this is just,
there's also a separate circulatory system
for the immune system, the lymphatic system.
So, something that's not necessarily heavily
emphasized in physiology,
but it contributes to the circulatory system.
So, every time your blood passes through capillaries,
there's some leakage out of those capillaries,
and that fluid in the intraspecial space now
has to get back someplace.
It actually goes into the lymphatic system.
There's lymphatic vessels that then go back to the heart.
There's no beating that forces it back.
What's actually required is contraption muscles,
because what the lymphatic system has to generate that flow
is just one-way valves.
So, there's no pump, but there's one-way valves.
So, any time you squeeze the lymphatic system,
it moves one direction and doesn't flow back.
And that's why, if you don't have that operating properly,
you develop edema.
If you're in the hospital,
they put these little squeezy things on your legs
and squeeze it a little small.
That's to just keep the extracellular fluid
that's leaked out of your circulatory system
going back through the lymphatics,
and then goes back into the blood,
by the subclavian vein.
So, I just wanted to emphasize
that that's part of the circulation of the immune system.
Okay, the other thing within the immune system
that's important in terms of a very rapid overview
of the whole immune system is,
and this is a kind of an artificial separation,
but things are described as being part
of the innate system or the adaptive system.
It's not completely artificial
because there are animals that have only the innate system.
So, it can be separated.
But in mammals, they function, they're totally integrated.
So, the innate system activates the adaptive system,
but then the adaptive system uses the innate system
as its effective function to actually kill the pathogen.
The difference is the innate system
is the initial recognition of the pathogen.
So, this would be macrophages, dendritic cells,
things that don't, that are recognized general patterns
of pathogens, but they're not really highly precise
like the adaptive system is.
What they, they've been evolved to respond
to conserved aspects of pathogens.
So, but if you get a different flu version every year,
the innate system can't handle that
because it's not changing.
It's only these long-term aspects of pathogens
that are conserved, it's responded to.
But then, and also it doesn't change much
with a second exposure to a pathogen,
but it's ready immediately because it's there and waiting.
Whereas the adaptive system is also called
the acquired system because it takes some time.
And this would be what a lot of people
classically think of as the immune system,
the B cells and T cells, and the B cells make antibodies,
and that's what recognizes the pathogen
and the T cells are specific.
So, what's unique about the adaptive system
is the recognition is extremely specific.
So, and that's because there's a huge diversity
of different specificities waiting in your body
and the two B cells that recognize
a particular molecular pattern.
But when that happens, they expand exponentially.
That takes some time.
So, your innate system has to hold off the disease process
long enough for your adaptive system to expand
the cells it recognized with precision.
Once they do, though, the next time you're exposed to that,
then you have immediate protection.
And that's the basis of vaccination.
So, you're exposed to a piece of a pathogen
that isn't gonna kill you, and you expand those cells,
and now you have those cells,
some memory cells ready to go if they are exposed to that.
Okay, so, that's the T cells.
I mean, actually, I wasn't gonna include that.
There's, you know, more.
Okay, so the adaptive system requires
time to become effective.
There's a lot of interest in terms of molecular biology
of how that diversity of B cells and T cells is created
because genes actually rearrange.
They're not encoded in the germline.
And there's been a lot of interest in that for a while.
People thought that might happen in the brain, but no.
Okay, the cells that are effective
against a particular pathogen proliferate
in response to that.
There's memory, and then the second exposure is faster.
So, the way that would happen,
typically the way they would work together,
if you have a wound, then the components
of the innate system, like mast cells,
and macrophages, and dendritic cells,
down at the bottom, the green one,
would take up pieces of the pathogen.
They would start an inflammatory response.
Basically, an inflammatory response is,
what it does is allows things to get out of the blood system.
So, all the features, classic features
of an inflammatory response are due
to that effect on the vasculature.
It becomes leaky, so you get redness,
you get swelling, you get heat.
And then, after the pain, it's also related
to things that are released from the blood cells.
Okay, that allows neutrophils to come in,
and they're a major part of the innate system as well,
that will start killing things in the general way.
The innate system tends to be like napalm, right?
There's a lot of collateral damage.
And so, you don't want to really depend
on the innate system.
You want to get something to be a little more selective.
So, that's why the little green dendritic cell,
after it's activated, takes off,
and heads out through the lymphatic system,
and heads to the lymph node.
All right, well, that's him leaving to the left, right?
And then, once the dendritic cell gets to the lymph node,
it takes up residence there,
and puts out pieces of the pathogen on its surface.
And then, all the T cells just mingles,
like a big cocktail party.
They're just going from one to another.
And then, finally, if there's something magic happens
between them, then they engage in something more prolonged.
And that would activate the T cell.
It goes and proliferates.
Now, once it's proliferated and activated,
it goes back out and kills the pathogen,
whatever it is in the bucket.
This is the central processing of the response.
And this is where the innate system
creates the activation of the adaptive system.
And B cells come into play as well.
Okay, so, what's that?
Is there a circadian rhythm in this?
Of course, there's a circadian rhythm.
Immune responses fluctuate across the 24-hour period.
But the next point, I think, is the key point
that makes it complicated,
is some components of the system peak in light,
and some peak in dark.
It's not like you can say the immune response
is better at one phase than the other.
It all depends on which component
of the system you look at.
So that's probably why it's complicated,
is it's not.
In terms of how it happens,
I mentioned before that there are systemic mediators,
in particular, hormones.
And the two most important hormones are cortisol,
as I mentioned, but also epinephrine,
or the sympathetic nervous system.
Both of those show circadian fluctuations,
and both of those have major impacts on a component.
I think what Marco was referring to
with this now interest among immunologists
in circadian things is that the clock genes
do fluctuate in immune cells.
So there is an intrinsic component
to the immune system circadian rhythm as well.
And as I understand it from general things
with circadian rhythms, is the SCN tends
to entrain all these peripheral rhythms.
Is that still where you're coming from?
So there are clocks in these cells,
and there are clocks in macrophages and T-cells,
BMAL, CLOCK, PER, 2, at least, and 3.
Those things fluctuate if you take immune cells out
and put them in a dish and look at them.
So there are intrinsic clock gene fluctuations
that affect the cells,
but some circadian rhythms and function
seem to be due to the mediators,
and some seem to be related to the intrinsic fluctuations.
And then what I feel bad that I really haven't gotten clear
is what the implications for health are.
Today and once before, and it's still, okay.
Now, besides the neuroendocrine mediators
we've talked about, the other big,
so when there's disruptions to circadian rhythms
that people typically look at for health reasons,
most people talk about either phase shifting
or sleep deprivation, things that would affect.
Well, when you do either of those,
one of the big things besides the circadian rhythms
that you shift is the sleep,
and sleep itself has effects on many of these variables.
So it's difficult to disentangle the effects
of alterations in sleep versus alterations
in the circadian rhythm patterns.
So that's a big one that people look at.
The neuroendocrine mediators, in some ways,
it doesn't really matter if it's secondary to cortisol
or epinephrine changes,
but in terms of understanding the biology
is something that we definitely want to look at.
Some of these neuroendocrine mediators
peak in the active phase, early in the active phase,
and this would be, these are things that typically
are opposite for diurnal and nocturnal species.
So if you look at mice that are active at night,
their cortisol rises as they're going into the dark phase.
In humans, their cortisol rises early in the morning
because that's their active phase.
So it's not related to light and dark,
it's really related to the circadian activity.
Some of them peak in the active phase,
some of them peak when you're asleep,
during the dark phase,
and growth hormone and proactin are two hormones
that have that pattern.
Okay, so here's some examples,
and what this does is separates
whether or not the, in this case, this was a human,
is allowed to sleep or is kept awake, right?
And so some of the rhythms are dependent upon sleeping
and some are not.
So like with a growth hormone,
the weight condition is not really much of a rhythm.
Same thing with proactin.
Cortisol doesn't seem to really matter,
so it's not dependent upon sleep or not sleep.
Epinephrine, again, they show similar rhythms there.
And norepinephrine, like epinephrine.
And then some of the immune responses, again,
if you just look at aisle six in monocytes,
that's the macrophages, there's a rhythm there.
TNF outside production, aisle 12,
again, some of these disappear
when you keep the person awake.
Aisle 12's a critical cytokine
for activation of dendritic cells.
And then the most important,
one of the more important suppressive cytokines
or inflammation-resolving cytokines is aisle 10.
It also has a circadian rhythm.
So there are clear circadian rhythms,
some of which depend on sleep and some of which don't.
This was a nice review that showed that
different components of the immune system
have opposite effects,
and some are related to epinephrine
and some are related to cortisol.
And the sort of metaphor that they used for it
was that there are day workers and night workers.
And these are some of the changes that occur
in different kinds of immune cells.
So there are fluctuations in naive cytotoxic T cells,
those are CTLs,
there's in naive T helper cells.
But the ones that have actually been activated before
and are now a memory phenotype,
they have different fluctuations than some of the,
in particular, the,
okay, well, I'm not sure what I was,
the point I was getting at there.
Okay.
Some of these have the opposite,
so they're higher in the light than in the dark,
so natural killer cells.
And the T cells are higher in the dark.
Okay.
And this is the epinephrine.
So there's an inverse relationship
between ones that are responsive to a decrease in cortisol
or an increase in epinephrine that they respond to.
So different components of the immune system
respond differently.
And this is to just sort of highlight
that the rhythms that are described here
are the same for mice and humans,
but opposite with respect to light and dark
because one's not terminal and one's active.
So when rodents, when humans are asleep,
rodents are active.
And these are some of the study,
the endpoints that have been looked at
in terms of the functional cytotoxicity of NK cells
when you take them out in the dish.
And lymphocytes, their ability to proliferate,
their ability to respond to mitogenic stimuli,
all of these things fluctuate across.
So as I said before, the way they describe this
is that some cell types are like table prisons at night.
Naive T cells are higher at night.
And some of the activated cytotoxic T cells
are higher during the day.
So, and the idea, or at least the justification
of that or rationale for why that might be
is at night you're restoring,
you want to build up naive T cells,
but you want to have your cytotoxic cells
that are actually going to respond acutely to a pathogen
higher in anticipation.
That's the time of day or night
when you're more likely to actually be facing a pathogen.
So it makes sense that way.
Also, in terms of how circadian rhythms
in the immune system interact,
there's some suggestion that the immune responses
have feedback on affecting the circadian rhythms themselves.
There is evidence that cytokines can affect
the phase of rhythms by melatonin, TNF-alpha can.
There is direct effects of TNF-alpha
on an SCN and a splice preparation.
So inflammatory cytokines there
affect the neuronal activity recordings.
There was one that claimed to be changes
in the SCN following sepsis, which is,
it's actually, in this case, it was just LPS.
It wasn't actually the bacteria itself,
but the pathogen that's the active part of it.
But the effects were pretty subtle.
So it was like just a small change in the,
so there was no difference in the period
or phase of the rhythm, but when they re-entrain,
they re-entrain a little quicker.
It would be a pretty subtle effect.
But they did also see prolonged activation
of microglia within that.
So how big are the functional effects?
So this was an old paper, and it even looks like an old paper.
It looks like the shady that there's a pencil in.
This was from 95, where they showed
that there was a circadian difference,
circadian variation in proliferation of T-cells
in response to tetanus, praxis, and pancreas.
So this is taking T-cells out of the mouse
at different times of day, and then just exposing it to,
this one was not exceedable.
This is actually, and there was a reduction
at 10 in the morning circadian time
compared to other times, and they correlated it
with the difference in cortisol, which is highest.
Again, from an immunologist's point of view,
what they're more interested in
is the difference between this and that.
So this is baseline without the tetanus toxin.
And so they're interested in, here, a 50-fold change,
and this is maybe a 20% reduction in that.
So that's why it got too exciting.
But again, these things could have implications.
So this was from another review
of what some of the factors are.
Circadian, I was interested,
I haven't been following the circadian system enough
to realize how much the COCK genes change
in the arcuate, too, the tannosites.
So are those components driving,
or do they respond to SCN?
Are they trained by SCN?
Sam can answer that.
Yeah, there's direct efferent projections
from the SCN to the arcuate nucleus.
But who drives whom?
The SCN drives the arc.
The arc, without the SCN, in slice culture,
dampens and desynchronizes over time.
Okay.
The SCN can live and maintain its rhythm,
like amplitude and period, for even years.
Well, at least a year.
Years in a dish?
In a dish.
What?
Shinya Ozaki kept the SCN slice in the dish for over a year
and it still had its rhythm.
The arcuate nucleus dampens out of its brain.
That science fiction movie
where they keep the brain in the dish.
Yeah.
Takes over the odor.
Yeah.
For a year.
Whereas the arcuate nucleus dampens out of the body.
Well, I remember Dan Green's from a few days was good,
but at least this guy did it.
I don't know.
I wish I knew.
I wish I could do what he does.
Yeah?
Do you think he makes it up?
I hope not, but.
He's well known in the field, so.
I guess so.
Hopefully not.
But.
You can't visit.
But the evidence is that the arcuate
is driven by the SCN, but it does feedback.
It has projections back to the SCN, too.
And what are those?
They synapse on.
But do they functionally do anything for the SCN?
I believe so, yeah.
They can shift.
I think the SCN can shift in response
to signals from the arcuate.
I assume.
Okay, so that was kind of news to me.
I knew about, so,
outputs to CRH and the PDN,
so that's corticotropic releasing hormone
in the paraventricular nucleus,
and then there's autonomic activity from the catecholamines.
And also from the adrenal cortex, the good corte cords.
Those are the two main drivers
of the extrinsic modification of any circadian rhythms.
The pineal gland has gotta be involved in some way,
but actually, I have done a circadian rhythm experiment
in my life.
Some 30 years ago, I found circadian rhythms
in estrogen receptors in the hypothalamus,
and it was due to melatonin.
Anyway, we did some melatonin.
But the melatonin literature,
I don't know if it's gotten any better.
But back then, it was like,
it was so confusing and so contradictory,
and melatonin would do anything and everything.
And it was like, I don't know if it's still,
is it still true?
It's a little better, but melatonin was thought
to do anything and everything, yeah.
Yeah, yeah, until you tried it in your own lab.
Okay, so I guess that's all I wanted to get done in that.
So then, what's new is this increasing evidence
for inherent circadian aspects in immune cells.
So in one paper in particular found,
they talked about, I think it was in PNAS,
about the clock gene enhancing NF-kappa-B transcription.
Okay, so NF-kappa-B is nuclear factor,
kappa-beta, kappa-B for B cells.
But it's a main transcription factor
for inflammatory responses everywhere.
And so the fact that there was direct interaction
between the clock and NF-kappa-B transcription
was news and exciting for how intrinsic that is.
So, functionally it produced circadian variations
in responses to lipopolysaccharide,
which is a classic TLR4 agonist,
which means it's a P cell or pathogen.
Okay, so this showed that the response to pathogens
was modified by the intrinsic rhythms of clock genes
in isolated immune cells.
So in particular it was shown that the clock complex
was a P65 subunit of NF-kappa-B.
So it was a direct interaction of the clock gene products
with the main transcription factor for inflammation.
In terms of the functional implications of this,
I'm really just showing this for the one little chart A,
that when you, so if you treat animals with LPS,
depending on how much you give them, they may die.
So it's like septic shock, which is a,
septic shock is responsible for, I'm going crazy,
so a lot of people in hospitals,
what they ultimately succumb to is septic shock
when infections become, basically once infection becomes
in the blood, then it's spread
and you get all these inflammatory responses
happening everywhere instead of localized.
So if when you get an inflammatory response locally
and you get vascular leakage, that's a good thing.
Okay, because it brings cells and proteins
to the wound and helps it respond.
If you get vascular leakage everywhere, you die.
Okay, it doesn't work.
So many people die from septic shock.
And what this shows is there's a related to
a clock gene variation is a,
circadian, a clock gene related difference in survival.
Clearly in that situation,
there was another recent paper we found
and I think this actually might have been,
this was supposed to be discussed,
so maybe we shouldn't discuss it now,
but maybe we should all discuss it.
Since, let me at least get through that.
This is, so this was one I thought was worth,
and this is, this was a phase shifting.
So a lot of the functional implication of things
are looking at shift work,
because that's where circadian rhythms get disrupted.
But this is also an area where I really knew even less
in terms of what happens when you just phase shift
an animal or person repeatedly.
Have you talked a lot about that in this class?
A little bit, but one of the papers about it,
but we started out talking about,
it shortens your life if you're a chronic phase shifter.
Yeah, I mean it does everything bad.
So all kinds of diseases are common.
And so, but in terms of how that happens.
No, we didn't talk about it just as a phenomenon.
Why circadian rhythms, why it's better to stay in sync.
So, but you do re-entrain.
Right, but these conditions are where they shift them
and give them a few days and they shift them again.
So you never really get re-stabilized.
Right, okay.
So that's what I found interesting about this one.
So they did phase shifting of animals repeatedly,
and I couldn't really, I wasn't,
I didn't really know whether this was convincing or not,
because they said that it disrupts the NK cell proteins,
but there's still, and these are isolated NK cells,
and of COCK genes in NK cells.
And it looks to me like there's still rhythm, it's just.
It's just wrong.
Yeah.
It's like at phase with the other.
So the other thing I didn't understand,
in several of these studies that I looked at,
which I'm not gonna do here,
but is when they did repeated phase shifting,
and some of them were like, yeah,
repeated phase, and some, they said some of the animals
re-trained some, then how did they get the data
from a certain circadian time point,
if they don't know where the animals,
how do they get group data
when individual animals respond differently?
Well, it's like they just reckon it
from the new lighting cycle, you know?
So they put them on a new lighting cycle.
Right, but an animal could have a rhythm,
it's just not trained to the new light cycle rhythm.
Exactly, yeah.
And so it would look like,
because you're doing group data,
and you pull the group data from all the animals,
and you say there's no rhythm,
because it's, you're basically on the clock
with the animals, they don't have guts.
Well, that's, yeah, and that's one of the issues,
is how fast does it take to re-train?
You do different parts of the body,
different tissues, you re-enframe at different rates.
And what's the individual variation?
In humans, it's a lot.
You know, hopefully in experimental animals,
it's, you can control that better.
But what,
so NK cells are the natural killer cells,
and they've been shown to be important
for some kinds of cancer, so NK cells
don't generally attack all kinds of cancer,
but certain kinds of cancers are sensitive
to the natural killer cells.
And in this case, this was an incidence
of lung tumors developing in these animals,
and what they showed was the animals
that had been repeatedly shifted
had a much higher frequency of developing the lung tumor.
And the percentage that had the tumors
basically doubled, and the percent
with more than one tumor was more than that.
But what I found particularly interesting
was the last graph, which was some of the animals
they said re-trained, and some were free-running.
And the ones that were free-running
didn't develop nearly as many tumors
as the ones that were re-trained each time.
But it was like, if you say, to help with light and dark,
I'm gonna keep my, there was another
when the space shift jet lag experiments
done in the animals with showing adverse effects
in the animals, and again, this one, I think,
was, this is the one that also, right?
Okay, so this is a huge effect, right?
So this is on body temperature in response to LPS.
So the typical body response, temperature response
to LPS is a drop in body temperature.
Okay, you go hypothermic.
And then when the, the ones that did not
re-phase shifted came back, they pretty much
lost their rhythmicity, which was good.
But the ones who had been repeatedly phase shifted
had a greatly reduced body temperature.
This is 26 degrees, that's chilly.
So, and then I kept this rhythm,
but this, I don't know if you've noticed,
read closely, nothing in the paper,
that this rhythm was due, they said,
to the chamber temperature, right?
So this is just the animals passively following it.
And that, they said, persisted after the demise
of the animals, right?
So, I mean, talk about a bizarre experiment.
It's like, we're gonna let these animals die,
and they continue to monitor their temperature
for a couple of days.
And sure enough, there was a circadian rhythm
in their body temperature.
So they were not, it's like, completely dead.
Get that one by the eye, but we would not allow that.
Catnip measurements on video.
So, but then when you look at the cytokine responses,
they weren't all that impressive.
They're showing the response to LPS,
but they're not showing the baseline.
So, you know, it's like from virtually zero to there.
So, I guess that's what I had other than just paper
that was assigned for this kind of, so I'm done, eh?
Any questions?
Yeah?
Do these own large-scale electrometers?
Yeah, a normal, so an initial response to a pathogen
would be a fever.
When they go into a sepsis, then they go down.
But they have a normal fever response.
So was that the drop here?
Well, they didn't really show a fever response,
but this is sort of beyond a normal sepsis
where the animals are close to being dead.
And that's what happens to these things.
But I, oh, go ahead.
I'm just gonna make a comment, so you go ahead.
I was just, in a lot of these,
they're challenging them with LPS,
challenging with LPS after the shifting scenario.
So then the death is resulting from an uncontrolled
response, not from an actual infection.
Right, right, so there's no actual pathogen.
Right, and one of the things I wondered about with this is,
because that was so dramatic,
was there's circadian variations in liver function.
And LPS is pretty, it's a pretty sharp dose.
So if you had a very, if you didn't clear LPS as well,
it could put you over.
So a lot of people here that rely on these LPS
just to induce mild sickness,
and have a chance to compare the doses.
There's also like 800 different variations on LPS.
So, but it's typically, you get a transient effect.
But if you give them too much, then you get this.
So I didn't know whether if the jet lag
could be modifying liver clearance,
because it is conjugated to the white blood cell.
I tried to study that, but I couldn't find
what happens to the liver with jet lag.

