Caravaggio: An Overview

Caravaggio
8 followers
Thank you very much. It's a great pleasure to be here this afternoon, and thank you for coming.
I think it's a real tribute in this wonderfully sunny day.
It's a real tribute to the genius and the appeal of Caravaggio, but also to the
importance of our distinguished speaker today, Michael Freed,
J.R. Herbert Boone Professor of Humanities and the History of Art at the Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore.
Michael Freed is
best known as art critic and art historian,
who is also a literary critic and also a poet.
As an art critic,
he's closely associated first with high modernism, as practiced by artists such as
Morris Lewis, Kenneth Lolland, Jules Olitski, Frank Stella, and
Anthony Caro, a good friend of him.
And more recently with photographers such as Jeff Wall, Thomas Truth, Thomas Deman, the sculptor Charles Ray,
whom we know well here at the Getty since one of his
major sculptures is exhibited here on the stairs
leading up to the museum. He's close to video artists like Anne Rizzala and Douglas Gordon, and the painter Joseph Marioni.
So this is one side of
Michael's interest and personality as an art historian, his interest for
contemporary developments of art.
But as an art historian, he's best known for his masterful trilogy of books on French painting and art
criticism from the middle of the 18th century through the advent of Manet and his generation in the early
1860s. Three very important books that signed also our
training as art historians, or at least my training as art historian, Absorption and
Theatricality, Painting and Beholder in the Age of Diderot from 1980,
Courbet's Realism
1990, and Manet's Modernism, or the Face of Painting in the 1860s
from
1996.
In
2010,
Michael published The Moment of Caravaggio, based on the Andrew W. Mellon Lectures in the Fine Arts
delivered at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, a
transformative account of the artist's revolutionary achievement,
displaying a unique combination of
interpretive brilliance, historical seriousness, and theoretical sophistication,
providing sustained and unexpected
readings of a wide range of major works by the great Italian painter.
In
2016, this book was followed by After Caravaggio,
where Fried examines the nature of the engagement with Caravaggio of the following generation of artists, which includes major
painters like
Giuseppe Ribera, Bartolomeo Manfredi, Valentin de Boulogne, Nicolas Tournier,
Cecco del Caravaggio, and also, a little bit unexpectedly, Guercino. And I
would like also to remind you that
several masterpieces by some of these painters, some of the painters
I mentioned, are also present in our collection.
So you can see in the gallery nearby where the Caravaggio exhibition is displayed in the East Pavilion.
of the museum.
Michael Fried is therefore one of the best equipped historians to introduce us in the groundbreaking art of Caravaggio,
and I'm really grateful to him for accepting our invitation to come to Los Angeles.
Please join me in welcoming Michael Fried.
Thank you, David. That was
beyond
beyond the strict truth, but I appreciate it. So what I'm going to do today is
three paths through Caravaggio.
The three paths are, each one is determined by one of the three paintings in this remarkable exhibition.
It's a fantastic opportunity to see these paintings.
So we'll begin with the basket of fruit, and then there will be a series of paintings
following that that I'll talk about. Then I will have the Saint Jerome, and
finally, we will have the David with the head of Goliath and the paintings that relate to that. This will
enable us to look at and talk about a significant number of Caravaggio's
masterpieces, but by no means all. I mean, there will be major paintings that won't come up today.
My focus all the way will be on looking at the pictures.
So it's going to be, it's not basically a
talk with a lot of art historical information that you can find.
Caravaggio,
Michelangelo Merisi de Caravaggio, Caravaggio is a place name,
was born in 1571 in Caravaggio, not far from
Milan, and died in 1610. So he makes it to the age of 39, and given his lifestyle,
he did well to make it to 39.
We can all be impressed.
In,
he represents something like an earthquake in the history of painting.
He's a
remarkable figure,
together with a family of painters from Bologna, the Carracci.
They and Caravaggio together, at the end of the
16th century, in the very beginning of the 17th century,
just establish
serious European painting on a new footing.
The condition of painting was actually in some ways critical,
not long before the 1580s and 90s in
Italy and elsewhere, and then
Caravaggio and the Carracci between them,
profoundly reoriented, and we have
largely as a result, an extraordinary century of painting, 17th century of painting, everywhere.
Italy, Spain,
France. So let's start out with
the boy with the basket of fruit,
from 1593-94.
Caravaggio studied in Milan for a number of years with a painter named Simone Petrizano,
and then he came to Rome.
We don't have a lot of information about his earliest years. In fact, all the information we have about him
tends to be somewhat later.
But we know that he
worked
making paintings for another painter named the Cavalieri d'Arpino, and one of his specialties were
still life and the like, and
this would be an early painting. So it's 1593-94. He's
22-23.
And you can see, I think,
the marks of a
certain kind of youth in this painting.
On one level, the mastery is incomplete. This young boy looking at us,
lips parted,
holding this basket of fruit. On the other hand, the power of the painting is extraordinary,
and it's extraordinary relative to the painting of its time.
The quality that I want to
emphasize,
right from the start, is the quality of
presentation. The way the boy and the fruit and the painting are given to us by the painter.
A large
portion of Caravaggio's
originality and power
has to do with his
from the start discovering and
exploiting a new
intensity of the relation of the painting to the viewer.
It's not that
the relationship of a painting to a viewer had never been interesting to painters before Caravaggio, but with Caravaggio,
this becomes, I would say in some ways, the very center of his art. And the force of this painting's
address to us, and the sense of this painting's, you might almost say,
bestowal of itself to the viewer through the vehicle of this
extraordinary basket of fruit. And then the boy himself,
I mean not wholly unlike the basket of fruit, just extraordinarily pretty and with rosy
cheeks and deep hair. A boy who
probably looked not unlike Caravaggio. My claim here is not that this is a self-portrait.
But as you'll see, the self-portrait too plays a very important role in Caravaggio's art.
It's not surprising if what his paintings are doing from the start is
thematizing, bringing to the fore their relation to the viewer. The first viewer of any painting is the painting's maker. And
in Caravaggio, as in the work of certain other artists, later this will be true of Gustave Courbet, the French realist,
that
relationship of the painting to its maker in the process of making
becomes built into the painting, becomes part of the deepest content of the painting.
So already with this picture, that
dynamic, that dynamic between the painting in its richness given to the viewer, implicating the viewer, is already there.
The other thing that I'll just point out, I just am always struck by it, this wonderful bowl of fruit.
And you'll see still life's baskets of fruit, should have said basket, not bowl,
come back in his art. But notice too these leaves. And the leaves for me also have a little bit the character of
hands.
Caravaggio is going to be very aware that we have only one hand in view here,
which is his right hand. And notice how it turns into the painting,
turns into the painting the way the painter's own right hand could almost match with it.
This is something that's going to occur later very powerfully with Courbet.
So I want to emphasize something about, in that sense, the
transactional nature of his paintings. They are not simply on the wall,
indifferent to us,
and for us to sort of look at in a detached way. They are engaging with us.
They want something from us. And the first person they want something from is the painter.
Shortly afterwards, there are two pictures like this
called Boy Bitten by a Lizard. One is in
in Florence in the Longhi collection. The other, this one, is in the National Gallery in London. Boy Bitten by a Lizard from around
1594.
A very similar boy,
also with a flower behind his ear.
This, the lizard, is here.
It's hard to see because it's dark, and it's biting a finger. And he is reacting in pain and surprise. We get that
bare shoulder.
Beautiful, beautiful floral still life here with water and reflection, other still life elements here, and this strange left hand
like that.
My own kind of serious engagement with Caravaggio, I mean the point at which I realized that I had something to say about him,
happened standing in front of this picture in the National Gallery in London.
Again, partly because I'd been prepared for it by having worked on Courbet and Courbet's self-portraits.
And it started to strike me that there was a sense in which this could be seen as a certain sort of self-portrait.
I'm going to flip to another later picture
where I see the same structure, so that you'll be able to see what I'm talking about.
This is a self-portrait by Matisse
from 1918.
The structure of this self-portrait is fascinating. In the first place, it's mirror reversed.
You see the palette is in his right hand, the brush is in his left.
So we know this is the image as he saw it in the mirror.
He's looking at
himself in the mirror, in effect, and you see his canvas is just off picture to the right.
It's at right angles to the mirror.
So I'm the painter. I'm seated there. I'm looking at my image in the mirror, and I'm painting it onto a canvas
which is set at right angles to it. Now,
you see the same structure in the
Caravaggio. If we take that left hand to be something like a displaced or disguised
image of his
reflection of his own right hand working on a canvas that's there,
the left hand would be a left hand holding a palette, and he's pivoting between the two just the way
Matisse is. So the deep structure of the painting is of something like a self-portrait.
The process of making the self-portrait is going to be something protracted over time in a way that you can see in the Matisse.
Here, what we have is this moment of surprise,
instantaneousness, shock. This is going to recur again and again in Caravaggio, and the significance of it for me is
always that it comes,
it's secondary
to an earlier stage of kind of protracted
effort on the painting when the artist is, so to speak, immersed in the making of the painting.
Then, at a certain point, the painting has to be
set free. The painting has to be released. It has to be severed.
It has to be sent out into the world, and in Caravaggio, that's the moment of shock, of
severing. It will later in his art turn out literally to be a moment of decapitation,
of an absolute cutting out of the painting,
in some ways from the artist himself, so that the painting can fully enter the world.
Anyway, to me, this was a
sort of thrilling moment of
seeing a deep structure in a painting that
put all the emphasis on instantaneousness,
but where the deeper structure was that of a kind of protracted process of making
through this structure, what I call right angle mirror reflection.
This is a painting called The Musicians from
1594 to 95. It's in the Metropolitan Museum in New York.
It was, at a certain point, really very badly destroyed. A lot of it is repainted. It's repainted extremely well.
It's a picture that I grew up in New York. I went to the Met a lot as a kid. I loved this picture.
I kind of
fell in love with her, though it later emerged that that was Cupid.
I had to make various emotional adjustments.
By this time,
Caravaggio in Rome acquired various very influential patrons, so we have to think of him during these years as
literally living in one or another palace,
being treated very, very well,
having lots of time to make the paintings in as refined a fashion as he wanted to, and
being sponsored by these very wealthy, very, very cultured, powerful people.
So that he knew the paintings would be bought, they would be acquired. He had a really ideal situation.
He then sort of relentlessly set out to destroy it, and finally did.
But nevertheless, it's an important fact about his production during these years. Now, look at the,
again, look at the structure of this painting.
What emerges is, in the first place, a powerful structure of something that we could call a dress.
This central figure,
who is sort of tuning
his lute
preparatory to
making music,
facing us. And then this
element that's going to come back and back and back in Caravaggio, which is a figure seen from the rear.
So we're putting together a figure who faces a dress and a figure who faces away.
A figure who faces away, you realize, is facing in the same direction as
the painter making the painting.
And for that matter, the same direction as the viewer, say us, standing before the painting.
So Caravaggio realizes, and this is something, this becomes explicit in his painting as in no painting before him.
But it's going to become very, very important in the centuries to come.
It's there in Courbet, in another way, it's there in Manet. It's the awareness that a
painting, in a certain sense,
faces in two directions.
Most obviously, it hangs on the wall and faces the viewer. But if you think of the depicted space,
the painting, as it were, faces away into itself. And that
lines up with the orientation of the viewer or the painter making the painting.
In other words, it's key not just to the presence of the viewer,
but to the viewer's own sense of, in this case, his, if we're talking about the painter,
but if we generalize it, his or her embodiment. Their own sense of themselves as an embodied being
with a front and a back standing before the painting. These paintings
acknowledge
human embodiment and work with it, make it part of the medium of painting as no paintings before them.
This is important because the standard account of Caravaggio and of Caravaggio's remarkable realism or naturalism is
that it was, and we should think of it as,
essentially optical. As if it represents simply a new, more acute way of seeing the world.
But his paintings aren't just about his realism, isn't just about seeing the world.
It's conveying the sense of what it is to be a physical being in a world,
in a physical world.
And that involves a sense of embodiment, that involves a sense of front and back, that involves a sense of the painting,
not simply as something you might call an image, but as a material artifact,
which itself faces, but gets made in a particular way. All of these
considerations come into play in Caravaggio with a, I won't say as never before.
It's not that there's no hint of this before, but now with tremendous
force.
Something else to remark is that that's Caravaggio. It's another of his self-portraits.
He puts himself, and he's a self-portrait holding a cornetto.
He's going to be playing the cornetto, and you'll notice that he's depicted himself in a way that's
kind of consistent with that right angle structure, right?
So you think of that boy, and then you think of how he's presented himself there again with his mouth slightly open.
Does that mean that he made this painting, this image of himself in that painting using that right angle mirror configuration?
I don't know. I even rather doubt it.
But that he depicts himself that way shows how acutely aware he is of that structure.
This is an artist who knows what he's doing. Whatever else is true of Caravaggio, he's an intellectually extraordinarily acute painter
about his own enterprise.
This is the Bacchus of around 1597 in the Uffizi.
Again, it's a time when Caravaggio still
has these very strong sponsors, and he's produced this
remarkably compelling, strange image. A beautiful still life at the bottom.
Then this
strange figure, and you see how this goes back to, I could flip back to the boy with the basket of fruit right at
the beginning. You sort of see the consistency in his art
with this remarkable gesture of the left hand
extending
this shallow
goblet of wine towards the viewer. Of course, that extended left hand is also
something like the mirror image of the painter's own right hand
extended with the brush
towards the painting.
So that we have here something that is simultaneously, again, that going back to the boy with the basket of fruit, an image of
presentation, as if this gesture
offers the wine, but in by doing so offers
the Bacchus himself, and by so doing offers the painting to the viewer. The sense of
being addressed by this painting is, again, amazingly powerful.
This is all something essentially new, and
at the same time, we have that right hand sort of playing with
this wonderful
tie to his
ostensible toga.
Something that you can't possibly see, but it's true, is in this
flask of wine there is, around here, a tiny reflection of,
and if you come up close in this strong light,
it's a tiny reflection of what seems to be a painter at his easel. I had read about this,
and I was very interested, already very interested in Caravaggio, and had very close friends,
two art historians, a man named Charles Dempsey and a woman named Elizabeth Cropper, and they were in Florence,
and I was coming to Florence, and I said, could you, and they had lots of
connections in the world there,
I said, could you arrange for us to go into the Uffizi some morning before it opens, and
they'd have powerful lights, and we could see if there really is this little figure there,
and they did, and so one morning, I and my wife and Charles and Elizabeth all went to the picture with
powerful lights, and the guards immediately said to us, ah, you want to see the little guy?
They knew all about it. They'd been looking at it for years, and so, trust me, the little guy is there.
So that structure of
reflection, and in that sense, of
self-portraiture, even in that sense, is built into this picture. We're going to look at this picture again later,
because it
establishes a certain kind of paradigm for Caravaggio,
of address and
presentation, in this case,
figured through the presentation of the wine. I'm showing you this
just because it's so remarkable.
It's strange seeing it so large, because of course, it's not large. It's small. It's a small basket of fruit. It's in the Ambrosiana
Library and Museum in Milan, and it is simply breathtaking.
In a way, no image, this is not a bad image of it, but no image can convey the precise quality that it has.
One really doesn't know. When you're standing in front of it looking at it, it kind of defeats
your imagination
as to how
Caravaggio painted it. I mean, it doesn't seem quite possible that he just looked at the fruit and painted it that way.
Maybe he had some mirror that he looked at it in, because there is a way in which it is, in this case, rendered
very, very optical, as opposed to
massively physical. I mean, this is a picture that just
exceeds my capacity to describe it or evoke it, but I wanted you to see it. I also want you to notice,
I mean, I am very struck in some of the still lifes,
this goes right back to the boy with the basket of fruit, by these leaves that are like hands.
I mean, Caravaggio's paintings are made artifacts.
He, as an artist, is acutely conscious of the act, the process, the duration of making.
His paintings, in all sorts of ways,
acknowledge their
madeness, their
madeness by the painter, therefore the viewerness, and here I can't help feeling the sense of something like
the hands that went into the making of it. I'm struck, too, by that
branch that goes off,
as if it were, I don't know what, even like a paintbrush or something. And then,
this very famous painting,
the Supper at Amalus of 1601 in the
National Gallery in London. So it's that moment where, after Christ's crucifixion, when he
meets two of his disciples
on the road, they have a
dinner. Christ is
unrecognizable to them, and you see the brilliance of Caravaggio's depiction of Christ.
He gives us a Christ who is extremely non-canonical. I mean, this doesn't look like the traditional images of Christ.
And they recognize Christ at the moment of his giving the
Hebrew blessing over the bread. And that's what happens here, and the painting focuses on
Christ's act of blessing, but then the responses of the two
disciples.
One of them, you can see, pushing back violently in his chair in surprise. The other flinging out his hands in that way.
And in the foreground of the, well, first of all, you see this
chicken with these sort of, in a sense, pitiful legs, which
but I mean that in a,
I mean one has to laugh, but I mean it also seriously, in that it is some kind of prefiguration of
what is going to come in the narrative.
And here we have this, yet another beautiful basket of fruit,
and
coming off the edge of the table. So you have this, this, and that.
A standard account, the standard sort of
art historical account of this picture would say something like,
by virtue of the fruit, the basket of fruit protruding off the edge of the table, that puts the viewer all the more
intensely in the scene. I think that's exactly wrong.
I think the structure of those gestures, plus the fruit pushing off the edge of the table,
pushes the viewer away.
It's addressed to the viewer, but it just builds into the painting an element of shock and
separation, distance, what I'm going to call severing. Part of what the painting's autonomy as a painting is
confirmed by the force of the gestures that actually
thrust the viewer back.
Of course, there's some kind of very intense exchange with the viewer. In that sense, it happens at close range.
But within that close range, there's something like a split second of distancing. And that's going to be very fundamental to Caravaggio's art.
Okay, that's our first path.
Our second is going to take off from this,
to my mind, amazing painting of Saint Jerome
from around 1605 or 1606.
And it brings to light instantly
another
fundamental resource of painting for Caravaggio. And it's a resource
that is
from this moment on going to become a
fundamental resource for European painting, period. And I call that resource
absorption. The depiction of absorption. The depiction of figures
totally
absorbed or immersed in what they're thinking, doing, or feeling. In this case, it's Saint Jerome
completely absorbed in his study of the Bible as he makes his early translation of the Bible.
I think from Aramaic to Latin.
Okay.
The force of the painting is inseparable from the force of our conviction in his absorption in what he's doing.
There's this brilliant structure of the extended arm
holding a pen or writing implement. Needless to say, this is anachronistic.
That's not the way
there were no books in Jerome's time.
This is something that happens again and again in the painting of the period. This skull is looking on.
He is so absorbed as to be unaware of the skull. And we feel, this is, Caravaggio is
brilliant in his, I mean, unbelievably brilliant and creative in the
actions that he gives to his figures. In this case, by extending that arm,
it makes us so aware of the force of the
suspended action of the arm. The arm was reaching out to do something. It is suspended because at that moment
Jerome is so much in the grip of the thought of what he's doing.
What's fascinating about the depiction of absorption is how minimal
its indications are. I mean,
fundamentally, Jerome is depicted as a brightly illuminated
bald head, right? And then we get a little bit of his eyes in shadow and his lower face.
The force of our conviction of
his inwardness is tremendous. That's what absorption can do. It can give us this
conviction of the inwardness of those figures, the depth of feeling within them.
But the way it works is
almost paradoxical because we are given just the most minimal
expressive indications in the faces of the figures. As you'll see in the next painting we look at, this is carried even further.
The next two paintings.
So you might ask yourself, where does our conviction of that inwardness come from?
What is the source of it? The standard rhetoric, again, is going to be
there is no depth of the psyche that Caravaggio cannot
find out. And this is said by a very great art historian,
that he has this capacity to render spiritual depth.
But the magic of absorption, it is a discovery.
It's not as if there are no absorbed figures in painting before Caravaggio, but just as he
radicalizes
address,
he radicalizes absorption. And he becomes, for the first time, an
absolute
powerful resource for painting, which painters after him are going to seize on and pursue for centuries to come.
My own impulse is to say
that sense of inwardness and feeling has only one place it can come from, namely us, namely from the viewer before the painting.
Somehow the magic of absorption is that it works to lead us to project
our own sense of vitality, our own sense of feeling, our own sense of something like empathic
identification into the figure, so that the depth of feeling, the depth of thought that we discover there, is
ultimately grounded in something we are led to do by the painting.
I take this particular painting to be a really stunning
example of the power of absorption in Caravaggio's art. And then today, looking at it,
I saw something that I should have seen long ago,
but I had never seen before, and that Caravaggio is one of the great
masters of the painting of drapery in all of European art. Drapery is an extremely important part of
representational painting during all these centuries, because there's the body and then the drapery, and the drapery
extends the realm of the body in all sorts of, in a sense, you could say expressively very free ways.
Here Caravaggio has done something utterly stunning.
This man is totally absorbed in what he's doing. You might say he's gripped,
he's excited by it, and look at his red drapery as it kind of wraps around him,
almost as if it is responding to, it is expressing the kind of intensity of the feeling that he's expressing in this very
minimal way. Then that arm extends,
making us again all the more aware of the suspension of action in absorption. The skull is looking on, and here is
a drapery that belongs to this end of things, death, mere materiality, and it just falls.
So part of the drama of this painting, it's not just the drama of the skull
versus the living man, it's the drama of the
excited,
corporeal,
moving,
movemented red drapery versus the fall of the white. I mean, this
Caravaggio is that kind of,
it's no accident that Caravaggio is a contemporary of Shakespeare.
I mean, what we have in him is a certain, very often a certain kind of poetic power
within the image of just the highest level for the handful of the greatest painters
that we have in that sense.
The first painting where he really
discovers absorption,
the Penitent Magdalene comes up. It's from 1595-96,
and it's in the Doria of Pamphili Gallery in Rome. It's the Magdalene as she'd never been represented before,
and
even at the time, it's criticized as being just a girl of the streets who he just brought into the studio and had her just
sit there. I mean,
it took some doing for people to find. Viewers now find in this
something very powerfully moving and affecting in the vein of the Saint Jerome.
There she is absorbed in her grief and remorse over her past,
and
in this completely quiet, absorptive mode.
But there were people who couldn't see that. I mean, the expressive minimalism of it
took a while for it to take, for it to work.
It then becomes something that the painters who come after him are very excited by and seize on.
Here's the fullest version of this in his art, and that's the death of the Virgin.
This is 1605-1606, and this is in the Louvre.
Here we have
the Virgin
stretched out having died.
This is controversial in its own right. When it's submitted to the church for which he painted it,
it gets rejected, probably because they're unhappy with the portrayal of the Virgin.
But here, what I want you to focus on is the figure of Mary Magdalene. Now we don't see her face at all.
We just see her bowed head and shadowy head in grief, and we have these
disciples all themselves. Also, their faces almost completely hidden in shadow.
But people find this a deeply, deeply moving painting.
It's of this painting that the great art historian said,
there is no depth of the psyche, the human psyche, that Caravaggio cannot find out. I'm not saying for a minute that's wrong,
but it is, so to speak, to concentrate on the effect of the painting, the total overall effect of the painting, and not quite
realizing
the means by which that effect is achieved. And the means by which that effect is achieved,
remarkably, are so
excessively minimal. We are barely given the faces at all.
The handling of lighting, light and dark, chiaroscuro, plays a very important part in
sustaining, bringing about that effect as well. This is the Incredulity of Thomas, Doubting Thomas,
1600, 1601. It's in the gallery at Sanssouci in Potsdam, Germany. And here you see something else.
You see it's a brilliant composition. Caravaggio is a fantastic inventor of
compositions.
This is a very unorthodox composition. And one point, something you might say, is that in this picture you see that Caravaggio
absorption does the work of
composition. I mean, the whole
composition of the painting is simply based on the total intense absorption of all of those three
disciples as
Thomas puts his finger in the wound. Christ looks down to brilliantly direct
Thomas's hand into the wound. And then look at the subtle difference.
They're all absorbed, but look at the subtle difference in expression between these two and Thomas. Can you see the difference?
I mean, I think if I were to put this to you as a question, you'd get the answer.
He seems slightly surprised,
more than they seem surprised. And it's almost as if there's the sight of the wound,
but touching is believing.
So the finger is thrust into the wound and then it's as if
seeing is necessary to believe the touching. It's like, is my finger really in that wound?
So in the end it is a seeing of a touching
that itself is motivated by something that has to go beyond just seeing.
This is characteristic of Caravaggio's,
again, I want to say something like poetic genius,
imaginative genius, to reconceive traditional subjects in such an obvious, but
radically original way.
Something else again, we talked about the drapery. I want you to see what happens here.
See, drapery in Caravaggio will often share
the mood of the picture. So we have this kind of extraordinary, almost like excitement in the drapery,
just not here, not here, but just in the area of that extraordinary action.
And then
one more
tremendous painting on this path.
The crowning with thorns, Christ being crowned with thorns in the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna. This for me is one of my
favorite
two, three, four, whatever
paintings by Caravaggio. I think it's a kind of sheer masterpiece.
It's actually been doubted by certain scholars, but I can't see why it
should be doubted. And when I've talked to the people in conservation in Vienna, they say it's in remarkably wonderful condition.
So we have Christ
submitting to these torments before the crucifixion.
This is the
reed scepter that he has mockingly been given as king of the Jews.
The crown of thorns is being shoved onto his head by these two people.
The image of Christ is
of
the most profound
passivity.
This again is part of the imaginative genius I'm talking about. It's presenting Christ not as
pathetic,
not as someone who's just been tortured and tormented,
but what he's focusing on here is the idea of Christ's, at this moment,
complete acceptance of what is done to him. And the most
remarkably, again, poetic
expression in the picture of that
profound passivity is
the way he holds the reed scepter. The reed scepter has been forced on his hands.
He doesn't grip it. He holds it between those fingers as lightly as it can be held,
but he does hold it. And this
passivity, this
completely minimal
action is, of course, the most
efficacious action that's kind of ever taken in the history of humanity from a Christian point of view. It's going to be
Christ's
acceptance of his sufferings and death that is going to
change the world
for the rest of time.
Then we have the complete absorption, the astonishing absorption, of this figure in armor who seems to be something like the
supervising officer, the guy who's in charge of this whole operation.
And if you ask yourself, and we barely see his face, it's cut off,
it's in shadow, but we sense again, in the way we have been, the depth of his absorption in what's taking place. In this
case, his absorption seems so great.
He's taking, that it's,
it starts to take on the feeling of a kind of
identification with Christ. And then Caravaggio does one of his other strokes of utter
representational genius.
And that's that hand, and the proximity of that hand to Christ's hand.
I mean, that hand doesn't have to be there. That hand could have been there, could have been anywhere.
He's, you have to imagine that hand
moving without the man even being aware of it, in a gesture of identification coming as close as possible to Christ's hand.
So what we're seeing is something for which there's no
textual authority in the Bible. This is just Caravaggio working off of
the image that he's making of this absorbed figure's
identification with the passive suffering Christ. It's an incredibly profound picture. It's pictorially utterly beautiful.
It's worth going to Vienna to see.
Third path.
David with the head of Goliath.
This astonishing painting that you all have seen upstairs.
You know the story.
In this case, you also probably know that that's a self-portrait of Caravaggio.
So question as to when this painting was made.
We're not sure of the dates of numbers of his pictures.
Davide and the Getty have put it very late, around 1609, with Caravaggio dying around 1610.
I and certain other art historians think it go for an earlier moment, something like 1606.
You shouldn't care at all what I think. I'm just not an authority in
dating in that way, but there are serious people who argue both ways.
For art purposes, it's not crucial whether it's 1606 or 1609. Again, it's
staggering, you could say
Shakespearean quality,
poetic invention. The young David, who's based on a young painter who lives with Caravaggio, named Cecco del Caravaggio,
who becomes a remarkably fascinating painter in his own right,
holding
the severed head of Goliath,
which is the head of Caravaggio. This beautiful sword coming down, again, this brilliant handling of drapery.
This extraordinarily subtle expression of something like at once, you might say, absorbed
beholding of the head, a kind of sympathy, but also a kind of
hesitation, drawing back at the mixed, the quality of mixed feeling. But look,
you saw the picture before.
You saw the picture before. It's the same structure as the Bacchus,
but where the Bacchus
gives us the wine by way of giving us the picture, along with the
still life,
all kind of
thematized by the tiny reflection here.
Here, instead of the wine, instead of the still life,
is the painter himself.
And what we're getting, again, in Caravaggio's art, you'll see other examples. Let me show you other examples.
Decapitation,
cutting of a head off, it starts to emerge as a major theme. And I associate that
decapitation with something like, this is a moment, the larger argument would be to say that this is a moment, Caravaggio's the moment, of
the emergence of a new kind of painting.
A painting which, at this moment, we can call something like the gallery picture, made for new kinds of galleries in Rome,
where the picture has to aim at a new kind of absolute autonomy in itself.
It has to be framed and separated from what's around it, with a new force. In that sense,
it has to be cut out
from its environment, in that sense severed. But also, and this is less obvious, but I really want to
emphasize this,
it has to be severed from the artist in order to be released into the world.
So it makes sense that in this
extraordinarily decisive and emblematic picture,
the head is the head of the artist himself.
Right?
So the self-portrait, the recurrence of the self-portrait in Caravaggio, is not because he just keeps wanting to see himself in his art.
It's all part of a structure of trying to separate from the art. So the self that appears there is a kind of vestige.
Or afterblow from a kind of act of severing. This is a stupendous painting, needless to say.
To go back to a slightly earlier painting, this is the most vivid
portrayal of, or one of the two most vivid portrayals, of the act of decapitation in his art.
This is Judith and Holofernes, an earlier moment, 1599. It's in the Palazzo Barberini in Rome.
And here, I find myself wanting to see
this almost as
an allegory for the act of painting itself. As if what's taking, as if she's a stand-in for the painter.
As if that cutting of the head off is
also at the same time a depiction of something like the act of painting as it has been emerging in Caravaggio's art.
There's this great stress on this instant again, like the pained instant of the boy
bitten by a lizard. And that's expressed also in these
glass-like jets of paint. So the stress is all on the instant. And then there's this
counter-structure of the total
absorption immersion of the maid
next to Judith. Notice how Judith's face has something of the feel of
David's face.
Committed to what she's doing, but with a certain kind of ambivalence. Whereas the maid is completely now
wrapped in relation to the picture. So Caravaggio, in paintings like this, is actually sort of allowing himself to
sort of depict or give expression to
something like different successive, let me call them moments, within the process of painting.
The moment of
deep immersion in the painting, of the doing of it, the moment of separation. And if the moment of separation is powerful enough,
it might actually lead you to re-immerse. His paintings are full of this kind of complexity of structure,
in my view.
Another related painting.
We're getting towards the end.
Truly fascinating, beautiful painting. Salome receiving the head of John the Baptist from around
1607 in the National Gallery in London.
Okay.
Again, that structure goes right back to the boy
with a basket of fruit. It's a structure of presentation.
Right? In this case, the presentation is
by the executioner, who's got his hand on his sword down here, and then gives us the head of John the Baptist in this salvo.
This is again in that realm of a certain kind of imaginative Shakespeare quality poetry. Her gaze is averted.
Her gaze is averted as if to
put off the moment of really seeing that head. As if to put off the moment of something like
the full separation from the painting. At the same time, her maid, and look at the way in which they virtually share a single body.
This is something else that Caravaggio does. So it's as if
not just two different persons, but something like two different moments in the same
protracted act of painting and releasing the painting, is
completely spellbound by the head. And notice the tremendous affinity between the two.
Right? It's as if one of them reflects, is identified with the other, with this extraordinary fist.
Fist of making in the very center of the picture. This is what we're dealing with, with this guy.
The
structures of this kind of
complexity, this kind of pointedness. I can well imagine
that some of you in the audience, this would certainly be true of lots of art historians, would say
everything that he's saying is going too far. Okay, it's going too far. It's pushing it too far.
Okay, fine, but then you have to account for it.
Right? If what I'm saying doesn't persuade you, that's fair enough. But one can't pretend that,
can't pretend that those structures aren't there.
And if
the kind of account I'm giving you is unpersuasive, then the onus is on, let's say certainly an art historian,
who would just need to come up with another account.
Simply ignoring what's going on won't do it.
This is probably the last painting that Caravaggio ever made, and it's one of the most profound.
It's in slightly ruinous condition. It sits in a bank vault in Naples, if you can believe it.
It's the martyrdom of St. Ursula.
This is the King of the Huns. He wants to marry her. She says no, and he executes her. In this painting,
he executes her by shooting an arrow into her at this extraordinarily intimate range.
Kind of range that I think of as something almost like painting distance.
The distance he would be from a painting, as if she were
the painting, and that is something like the making of the painting. That is Caravaggio himself again,
up against her. You have to imagine her body pressed against his. There's a soldier here. There's another soldier there.
His hand sort of extends through here as if to stop the thing. So you have to imagine something like Caravaggio himself
trying to witness the actual making of the painting, the moment of the making of the painting.
As the arrow goes into Ursula, who has this extraordinary response to it, looks down as if
with a kind of grave surprise at her own mood. We have the same kind of structure in the head of the
King of the Huns that we have in those other figures like Judith and David. I mean, it's not
simple pleasure in what he's doing. But it's like Caravaggio straining to see
the inception of the act of painting as it carries out in this kind of mortal operation.
And there on the breastwork of the King of the Huns, we have a lion, who's kind of a symbol,
a traditional symbol for the sun, which is to say for light, this basic condition of painting in this
painting that is otherwise so dark. So the last painting we have by Caravaggio is, to me again,
this very profound painting, is maybe the most profound and sustained of all of his meditations
on something like the internal, tragic, fatal structure of the act of painting itself.
Okay, thank you for your attention.
