We destroyed a sport route for science...

HowNOT2
100 followers
Aug 23, 2023
Bobby Hutton drop tested an all natural dummy on bolts in the wild. We tested his measuring tool in our drop tower. This is a really cool test we've wanted to see for years.
Learn all about bolts at https://www.hownot2.com/boltingbible
Subscribe to his channel https://www.youtube.com/@bobbyhutton1989
👉 Learn and shop at https://www.hownot2.com/
👉 10% off Rocky Talkie by clicking https://www.rockytalkie.com/HowNOT2
👉 Our merch is at http://www.hownot2swag.com/
👉 1000 Patrons makes us viable https://www.patreon.com/howNOTtoHighline
👉 1 time donations really help also https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/slackcessfund
Today we're going to do a test that I've been wanting to do for years. We're going to be
testing bolts that have been in the wall for about 30 years to see if they're still viable.
They've been sitting here oxidizing and rusting. To do a drop test we need things to drop. Here are
our organic free range dummies harvested from the forest floor over there. These are oak.
There is a cable looped through both of these. My goal was 500 pounds. I have no idea how much
these weigh but if they generate enough force to break stuff it's good enough. This is a little
carabiner from Black Diamond rated to 20 kilonewtons. I am not using dynamometers on this
test because I don't like breaking dynamometers. If this carabiner breaks it means the bolt is at
least 20 kilonewtons strong and we'll do some collaborating tests at the lab up in Seattle.
30-ish year old wedge bolt. The electrical tape is to keep orientation so things don't get
cross-loaded and we don't like explode from a gate. We have the snap shackle through the wire
rope right here. That is backed up with our quick draw in case for some reason the snap shackle
opened up while we're hauling. This little blue cord is our snap shackle and...
Yes! This is now loose, spinning. I have never seen a climbing hanger get deformed like that
from a fall. Awesome, that did exactly what I expected it to do. So if we constructed this
test properly that means we saw at least 20 kilonewtons at the bolt carabiner and the
carabiner failed first. So that bolt, in my opinion, is still super strong enough to climb on.
Three, two, one...
Some of you might be saying, what's that purple thing? Climbers don't use that
and that's absolutely correct. This is a industrial round sling which is very static.
A climbing rope is dynamic and it absorbs a lot of force which is a good thing because it doesn't
transfer all that force to your body or to the gear. In tests that we have done it is really
hard to generate more than four kilonewtons in a climbing fall and we wanted to generate 20.
Five-piece Metolius hanger. We ended up breaking the hanger. It is hard to get good help. This is
a black diamond neutrino and not the same as the other carabiners we're using. So it is rated a
little bit stronger at 24 kilonewtons and you can see that hanger really chewed on it before
it failed. Here we have a 5 16th button head Metolius hanger. We've got the correct carabiner
again and a really strong carabiner. We've got some faux am steel here to a chain puller and
we'll see if we can generate enough force to break this. Things are deforming. Yeah,
I don't want to do that again. Loosened it up. Deformed the hanger a bit at the bottom
but the carabiner failed. Button head number two. A little deforming of the hanger.
Definitely now loose. Bolt is slightly pulled away from the wall but the hanger survived and
the carabiner lost. So Bobby's load cell is rated for 20 kilonewtons but let's find out how strong
these carabiners are and we put it on an old hanger on this chain shackle to our soft shackle
to our line scale to our all-natural drop tower. Now I have a span set here but I put a knot in
here to kind of shock absorb enough to slow it down before it breaks so our 1280 hertz is going
to be super fast enough and these are all of my anti-crossloading mechanisms here. This is 160
pounds or about 72 kilograms. Please break it. Oh, that's not what I was trying to break. I have
no idea what happened. That is not the same shape but it is not broken. Are you kidding me? Hey,
I didn't break a line scale. Wow, we're in the ballpark. I just can't have the wrong things
breaking. Okay, let's try this again. We've got 1280 hertz. We've got a stronger hanger on here
now. We're gonna take this to destruction. The gate is closed. We should get, well, a compromised
full strength out of it. I had my eyes closed. I have no idea what happened but wow, that's pretty
good. Fun fact, the hangers deform around 8k in and that's what happens when the shock load is fast
around 27. So, I have stakes holding up my wall except for that one area. Damn it. I definitely
am not going to be finding this missing piece but that's how it broke. Peak mode is on. Fix hanger
slightly bent. New carabiner with the anti-crossloading technology. A fresh knot because
that one is fused and I want it to be slow enough and I think we're ready to go.
Oh god, I had my eyes closed again. What happened? It's working. Oh, that was, how was that one lower?
I had a fresh knot. I definitely did not miss the peak force. Interesting range. If you're curious
how I do the all-natural drop tower, let me know in the comments and maybe I'll make a video about
this. Now, what a lot of people are curious about is do drop tests produce similar results as a
slow pull. So, now let's slow pull a few of them. Wow, slow pulls are so much easier than drop tests
and I can find the parts. So, it broke down at the bottom. The notch have a little damage. 21.7
cents. Technically over MBS. It's lower than the drop tower though. This one broke at the top and
the notch looks a bit damaged. Pretty consistent with our last slow pull. That is pretty funny,
we got a much higher force on the compromised elongated carabiner in the first drop test,
but they're all breaking above MBS, which means those bolts were surprisingly good, sort of enough.
So excited that we were able to do these tests. The first conversation I ever had with Ryan,
these were the tests that were going through my mind. As far as I know, no one has done similar
tests. If you know about any, I'd love to see that data. Takeaways. These tests really not going to
change how I interact with bolts. First of all, super small sample size. There are a huge variety
of factors that affect corrosion. I will say that you never know what's going on in the hole. So,
it could look fine on the outside and be just like flaking away inside the hole. You don't know until
you remove it. Though in most cases, a little bit of surface corrosion is not going to affect
the strength of the bolt in any meaningful way. The button head split shafts though can break
during installation and there have been failures that have led to fatalities with those bolts.
I've removed some that I've just tapped on the hanger to orient it and the bolt popped out of
the wall. So, those are scary. Always should be replaced. You'll notice that the hanger had very
little corrosion on it because it was stainless. It only had corrosion where the bolt was actually
touching it. Bolts like these are now being replaced with stainless or titanium where it's
appropriate. And of course, we replaced all the bolts that we damaged during this test.
If you like climbing on safe hardware, support the people and organizations that are placing
and replacing good hardware. And if you'd like to learn more about the bolts and hardware that
you trust your life to, check out the Bolting Bible. Thank you guys so much for watching.
