An interview with Diana Rodgers on the war on meat and whether eating meat is actually bad for the environment.
- Epoch Original Documentary DVDs: 🔵 Check out 'The Real Story of January 6' documentary DVD here: https://ept.ms/3cxGVEO 🔵 'The Shadow State' documentary takes a deep dive into the environmental, social, and governance (ESG) industry. ORDER DVD: https://ept.ms/3XxcWir 🔵 'The Final War' Documentary DVD: https://bit.ly/41PTIWC
you
Right now, politicians across the entire world are waging something like an actual war against meat.
Meat is being blamed for many of the different problems in the world.
Health problems, water problems, ecological problems.
Cows are even being blamed as some of the chief culprits behind the so-called climate crisis.
And the concrete manifestations of this war on meat are seemingly everywhere.
For instance, right here in New York City, the public school system,
which happens to be the largest public school system in America,
they instituted something known as Meatless Mondays.
No meat is served at all in school lunches on that day, Monday.
But they didn't stop there. Soon afterwards, Fridays became Vegan Fridays,
meaning only vegan food is served on Fridays to all the kids throughout the 1,800 different schools.
Now, the alleged reason for this is that New York City Mayor Eric Adams,
he is promoting an effort to serve, quote-unquote, healthier food in city schools,
with the underlying presumption there being that meat in and of itself is just not a healthy option.
Therefore, it must be eliminated.
And that sort of rhetoric is not confined only to New York City.
In fact, at the international level, you have the United Nations,
who's been beating the war drum in the battle against meat for well over a decade.
They've been putting out statements, reports, guidance directives,
urging countries across the whole world to stop eating meat for a myriad of reasons.
In order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, to stop global warming,
to save the world from hunger, to live a happier and healthier life, and so on and so forth.
This type of a guidance at the international level,
then gets trickled down into actual concrete policy at the national level in countries around the world,
such as over in the Netherlands,
just pushing to get rid of about 40% of the farmers in order to, quote-unquote, save nature.
And of course, we have the case here in New York City as well.
But is all this really the case?
Because what you have here is a very nicely, tightly packaged story that's perfect for marketing.
Meat is bad for the water supply, it's bad for land use, it's bad for the environment,
and hey, at the end of the day, it's not even good for your health.
It's a well-crafted message that millions across the developed world have bought into.
When you dig into the specifics of each one of those claims, it's not that simple,
with many of the claims being made against meat being downright false when you actually look into them.
And so, in order to unpack what the actual facts are, what the truth is behind the scenes,
well, I took the opportunity to sit down and speak with Ms. Diana Rogers,
who is both a registered dietitian, and she's also the author of the book,
as well as the director of the movie Sacred Cow, the case for better meat.
And during the interview, she exposed the truth behind many of these different claims
being made by the, let's say, anti-meat lobby.
I hope you enjoyed the awesome interview.
All right, Diana, thank you so much for joining the program.
So, I wanted to start with addressing some of the main, sort of, big criticisms
that people lobby against meat right now.
So, the four main criticisms are it takes up too much land, it takes up too much water,
it emits too much carbon, and also, at the end of all that,
it's not even that healthy for you to start with.
So, it's like you might as well just be smoking cigarettes
even after it does all these bad things to the environment.
So, let's unpack that a little bit, maybe starting with the health aspect.
What if someone came up to you and said,
hey, listen, you know, I've been hearing all these studies
and all these directives coming down from these international bodies,
meat is just not healthy.
What would you tell that person?
So, meat is a food that we have evolved to who we are today because we've eaten meat.
So, our brains require the nutrients that can only be found in animal source foods,
like B12, DHA, and a bunch of other nutrients that are really hard to access in plants
that are best found in meat.
So, the studies that are coming out showing that there's an association
between eating meat and poor health are really just that, they're associations.
So, just because one thing is associated with something else,
it doesn't necessarily mean it caused that reaction.
So, just like cheese consumption can be associated with, you know, a variety of things,
it doesn't necessarily mean that cheese caused that or that beef caused that.
And so, when you break out these studies, a lot of times what they're doing
is they're looking at a typical vegetarian versus a typical omnivore in the US.
So, we know that people who are vegetarians tend to have healthier lifestyles.
They're more likely to exercise.
They're less likely to smoke and...
They're more likely to smoke and drink.
And a variety of different lifestyle factors that are associated with things
that we know are health-promoting.
And when those lifestyle factors are adjusted for,
what we see is absolutely no difference in overall health span
between vegetarians and omnivores.
So, I mean, that makes sense to me, to account for those differences
in order to kind of normalize the data so you can really have like a graph
you can look at and make sense of.
Is it the fact that when you look at the papers,
the scientists do that process and normalize it,
but then the media just spins the conclusion in a way, like through their headlines?
Or is it that the scientists are not normalizing it,
and so it's kind of poisoned at the well?
It's actually epidemiologists also thinking that observational studies can sort of...
They're reporting it as if it's showing cause, when it's just an observation.
So one group that eats meat might be less healthy than this other group that doesn't eat meat.
Therefore, it causes, and then the media grabs onto that and reports it as truth.
And, you know, there can be very little difference only in processed foods,
so foods like bacon.
Some studies have shown an increase in colorectal cancer incidences,
but it is a very, very small increase,
and that would be at five slices of bacon for the whole rest of your life,
your chance of getting colorectal cancer goes from about 5.5%,
which is the general population's risk factor, to about 6.5%.
So it's only one percentage factor higher,
but because that can also be spun as an 18% increase,
the media will grab onto that because headlines get eyeballs.
But then also, it's not just the sort of the top line media headlines,
because these things actually translate into policy directives from international bodies,
which then get trickled down into school lunch programs, for instance, right?
So it kind of works that way too.
Yes.
You know, the Meatless Mondays campaign, and now in New York City, we have Vegan Fridays.
That's really unfortunate because there's never been any study to show pulling meat away,
especially from at-risk kids, and in New York City,
70% of the student population there is low-income, 10% are homeless.
There's never been a study showing that pulling meat away from at-risk kids
will actually improve health outcomes.
We only have one randomized control trial, so that's like an experimental trial,
where you look at a control and then, you know, the different experiments,
and there was only one study that looked at a meat snack in schools
versus milk or just extra calories,
and the students that received the meat snack are the ones that did better
in their test scores, in physical ability, and also in behavior.