Rui and David share that galvanized bolts are being used in limestone climbing crags near the ocean in Portugal. A place that 304 stainless have dangerously corroded within 5 years. Usually, titanium is required to have a reliable bolt, but they explain in this video that it's not just the chlorine induced "stress crack corrosion" but also sulphide stress cracking coming from BACTERIA??? Galvanized bolts apparently are not susceptible to either problem! They still have a much shorter life span compared to Titanium but it's fascinating to learn about the nerdy metallurgy details of what we trust our life to. For an in-depth dive into how limestone by the seashore eats 304 stainless check out David Reeve's awesome work at https://cragchemistry.com/
We tested the galvanized eye bolts that are used at their crag and also Steve Glotfelty's galvanized eye bolts in this episode. We also got to test a few 316SS eye bolts. Thanks to Colin Milas at https://www.colin-milas.com/ for providing the samples for these tests and for supporting the climbing community during the past 4 decades. If the single-piece 316L forged eye bolts struck your interest reach them out via email: [email protected]
We are going to be testing eye bolts in this episode.
Now zinc plated bolts are not going to last as long as stainless
except in this very unique situation. I'll let my friends in Portugal explain.
David here, I'm Rui, nice to meet you and we are going down there to Fojo
and we will talk about this. We are right next to the sea
as we know the seashore can provide a pretty harsh environment for all the
bolts and we are quite amazed with the durability of these ones.
These are the Cozyrock glue-ins. They are a single piece
of forged mild steel. These bolts have been used since the late 1980s
in sport climbing routes all over Portugal, Spain,
France and Italy. In Portugal we have a lot of crags by the seashore
on limestone formations and in these conditions the austenitic stainless steel
can get corroded quite easily like in five years or less.
The 304 wedged bolts, we have dozens of registered failures
as well for the 304 glue-ins. In the case of the 316
wedged bolts they seem to hold better but they will still rust.
The biochemical process, yes biochemical process responsible for such quick
corrosion of stainless steels is finally being unraveled by a lengthy
research carried out by David Reeve. It isn't just the chloride induced
stress corrosion cracking that we are used to
but also and more importantly a sulfide stress cracking
caused by sulfate reducing bacteria that live
in tiny oxygen depleted cracks inside the stainless steels and this is
all helped by the fact that the austenitic
stainless steels are quite brittle and develop a lot of
tiny cracks. So long story short since 2015
there has been a countrywide effort in Portugal to replace
stainless steel bolts by titanium. Titanium can be really expensive as such
the root centers around this area kept using what they knew that were safe
the quasi rock bolts. We have them by 300s and we don't have any registered
failures on them. You will either find them with a lot of
rust to a point where no sane person will climb on them
or they will look just fine unlike the stainless steel that can develop
cracks that are not possible to see with the naked eye. When correctly
applied they can last 20 years until they start to show signs of rust
these ones in particular have six years and they look
as new unlike the 304 that you saw back there. Let's clarify that plated steel is
a thin coating of zinc which is the sacrificial
coating that corrodes instead of the steel
but once gone will rust quickly. Now this had no zinc on it but you can see what
happens if there's nothing to sacrifice. Now this galvanized
eye bolt has a lot more zinc on it which is why it's
lasting longer than let's say Thonsai, Thailand
where they had zinc plated bolts breaking under six months
you can think of this as lightly buttering a piece of chicken before
grilling it versus deep frying it. Taking into
account a 20-year lifespan for the quasi rock
bolts and 70 years for titanium they are neck to neck in terms of
durability per price. The lower upfront costs and just plain
habit are enough to convince the old school
root setters to keep using them. Sure due to the more frequent
replacements they will have a higher long-term cost
but the point is they are still being employed on new
and refurbished roots around here. Now it is hard to break a habit and a culture
of people using a specific bolt and there's no doubt that
titanium lasts longer. For a little math experiment here let's assume
four times longer. Now a galvanized bolt such as this is going to cost me around
six dollars and this certified titanium bolt is
going to cost me between 11 and 13 dollars. Now when you consider
the time to install it, the glue that it takes which is expensive,
the time to install it, the additional holes that you would get
putting this in the rock four times versus
once, the time to install it and then the time to uninstall and
reinstall it four times versus once all to save five
dollars today? Now crags don't just bolt
themselves so make sure you are supporting your local bolting fund.
Cravi Bolting Fund has support from their local community and they are
installing titanium and we actually just put out a
episode recently about what they're using and we tested it.
These bolts here have been used for climbing for at least 40 years
although they have not been certified and there are no publishing tests about
them. We are really curious to see how they will break, how they will
handle your pullout tests. We know that you are not a certified body
and we are not trying to get any mbs number we are just really curious to see
how they will break. Our guess is that these ones the 10 millimeter
will break around 45 kilonewtons and these ones the 12 millimeter
will break around 55 kilonewtons. We came to Nevada and we installed this
into the sidewall into the best rock we could
and put our hydraulic in the back of this thing and we're going to be pulling
away from us to be safe. I guess we're already in a mind
that we're not going to be in it while we're breaking. Oh that's true
but after it breaks we're going to run in there and go wow after every break
test. So we have a forged eye bolt connected to our hydraulics here we're
going to start with the stainless and stainless
and then we're going to go with the zinc plated and zinc plated and this
liquid rock 500 is cured installed about 13 hours ago which is
super good enough for the temperatures we're in which is
Ryan and a light puffy steel carabiner to soft shackle bigger soft shackle to
our big yellow span set that's we did the
we have our slower downer blanket thing so that just doesn't go flying
everywhere. The thing I'm really excited about is this is the first
session of tests we're doing where we actually have this load cell that gives
us a graph and so we have to be kind of careful
with the cable. This red rope keeps the hydraulic from flying
back when this releases all of its tension
instantly and then we have a cascading sliding x system over there where it's
just sliding x's on sliding x's on sliding x's because
our anchor has failed so many times on this trip we've spent more time
installing bolts over there than we have over there we have our
hydraulic pump which is usually under our slack set machine
the battery and the charger that's connected to a generator out there when
we need to charge it for science
yes that's kind of what I guessed these are short bolts
oh yeah oh that's that is pretty cool
oh yeah I guess it can spin inside that carabiner
36.53 and we stopped here for the slow motion
it looks like a p-bolt dude yeah huh wonder how much more life it had in
that a lot it does definitely give that vibe
you use forged die bolts as well right yes half inch forged dies up to
eight inches in length because the rock's back yeah
the 10 inch ones were like uh 11 11 dollars
oh so they're not cheap but can but compare it for the for the size you're
getting oh it would cost a lot do they make
glue-in bolts that are they're forged super long
not forged jim at bolt products will make long
hmm he'll do custom if you want it
yeah it smells funky doesn't it 33.32 so the rock did not fail first and it
still pulled out so it's definitely going to be a length
versus the glue adhesion issue yeah it doesn't have deep enough
grooves I think a longer boat would definitely
have done better but 33 kilonewtons is adequate for most of what I
do so this would be the same result in
granite with this yeah because the rock did not fail at all
yeah you use long eye bolts yeah oh that's even like a half inch
if if this stayed intact this would be breaking north of 50 kilonewtons
what are you doing over here cheryl data entry where can people find all this
data on your website bolting bible has the book of numbers
i've organized everything i've color-coded everything you need to see
this spreadsheet is no longer like useful to anybody because it's kind of
like great notes for me but like hard for
you to understand but the book of numbers is super helpful
because it shows you how this bolt compares to this bolt or if we did wet
sandstone regardless of the bolt or if we tested
like if we twist p-shaped bolts just go right to it and
see everything we've done whether it's granite limestone or sandstone
donations are super helpful how is our anchor failing
dude i just want to break two more bolts and go have lunch
the hot dip galvanized is a little bit rougher coating than the
stainless steel so it's grabbing the glue
we broke the eye bolt i wondered how it would happen
if it would be at the the neck or there and it's a p-shaped bolt now
13.69 kilonewtons the first was there and then it took
only five and a half kilonewtons and then
about eight or nine to pull it out yeah it really was in the calcite vein
yeah yeah we've got it in calcite yeah this is the vein right here
it's definitely bent because the rock was just giving wind
the eye still looks like an eye so it's not deforming into a p
no until like 30s or 40s like this one did
put that long big one in this same vein and see what we get
put big brother in five eighths bit for the half inch galvanized forged eye
same hole they go in the same hole a little bit of cinnabar right there
did you just hit better rock feel a little bit better but i'm also getting a
little bit of binding too so i'm going to
clean out the hole sometimes i notice in limestone it can be a little damp and it
starts taking up
being longer larger diameter you just have that much more surface area
oh my gosh so much glue yeah your glue cost is as much as your
bolt cost i i just think the anchor's gonna break
that's all if you don't have a cotter pin you can tape your pin shut
wow it's smoking in there oh this was like the calcite right yeah
so this was like this is pretty bad rock yeah
57.58 that's pretty impressive for that glue
i guess tape is not as good as a cotter pin whoa
check this out the glue just it slid right out of the glue where
it didn't have threads when you say slid right out
um at 10 000 pounds 10 000 pounds of force
so let's see how that long one does without any glue
10 slow-mos to capture that 7.3 so the first time it went down was
seven that's a cool graph that's why the graph is helpful
you're gonna try to put it back in trying to make a u-bolt
it's a really long this is how they make u-bolts if you'll notice
here this started engaging in the rock oh
my thought is people should use glue so we're gonna test the
next size up of eye bolts that we got from portugal those are 12 millimeters
and we're gonna reuse the holes that we already uh
had the really good rock that it didn't really fail we'll find out how much
more force the 12 millimeter eye gets
well it's gonna be hard to figure out the mbs of this if the glue is failing at
30 something i mean the rock was great 35.15
35 kilonewtons is in a climbing context which these are used in a climbing
context is amazing
what does it smell like in here you guys like um burned
something burnt plastic burned 54.8 wow this is where we slow down for the
slow motion um because it takes a minute to trigger
finished pulling well so like same length same glue
same everything which hole was this it's also got a fracture
it's a little bit of a rock failure i'm just surprised like we got so much more
out of this one was that as good for you as it was for
you're just laying on barbed wire well it's a
suspension yes you are super not helpful what do you think of the data there z
20 more kilonewtons with basically the same everything the same everything
it's wild i'm going to be using this sore mat
resin that i got from europe bolt buster setup
to a new spot so we can pull straight out of this wall glue comes out of the
when it's cold out whereas liquid rock 500
really sucks when it's cold you can heat up
the tube by keeping it in your jacket or something but it's
you have to be mindful of that so no glue came out when i pushed that in
and i like having all that glue around the bolt
so i know that's going to be in all those grooves i can always stick this
back in and add more glue i don't have any air
bubbles just a little bit of glue on the outside
there that i can wipe off nice and neat
yeah i pulled the threads on this thing aren't really thick
kind of a more oval shape oh some of the rocks bald
36.87
didn't even deform that much it's just like these grooves just aren't
and that's the stainless steel too yeah yeah the galvanized i think engages more
like the with the glue but i mean that's pretty bummer i mean this eye is not
going to break before the glue it's 36.51
oh that was galvanized yeah the texture or the chemistry
of the galvanized likes yeah the galvanized the glue
rougher coating 51.36
pulled out of the hole just like the other ones you can see the scratch marks
it's consistently higher being galvanized as opposed to stainless but
stainless technically lasts longer well they last
longer everywhere except near the ocean if installed in
limestone now david guessed 45 kilonewtons for the
10 millimeter eye bolts and they broke when we broke could break
them at 53 but what's interesting is the glue was the
weakest link and they would pull out before they'd
break which i don't know if they were expecting that
i wasn't expecting that obviously you don't just go
up a size with a bolt for its strength but as you saw
you could get more strength out of the rock
if you have a longer bolt or a fatter bolt for surface area
there's a lot that goes into this and you should check out the bolting bible to
learn more about stuff before you put in bolts check it out
if you just trust your life to them so you know what you're clipping to now in
case you don't know it's pretty rare for a bolt to see more than
four kilonewtons and the gear that you're clipping to it
is rated for 20 ish kilonewtons so if you're getting over 25 kilonewtons
on a bolt it's technically super good enough we are
not only trying to break gear fear on this channel but promote long-term
thinking when considering what you're going to bolt because you
never know what the future is going to hold
there's a wilderness area at joshua tree that no bolting
is allowed anymore there are bolts they're dangerous but we can't even
replace them and otherwise that stuff could be
so it would be amazing if they actually use stainless
back in the day and that's a desert where sink plate is okay
no it's not our bolting bible is now available again in its pdf form
so please share this video with anybody who trusts their life to bolts