Are Asians just too cheap sometimes?
When does frugal turn into cheap and cheap turn into just a bad decision?
Yeah, I mean, usually the older Asian generation is sort of the era that's
stereotyped to be cheap, Andrew, but this is coming from the youth.
Let's run the clip off TikTok.
How my frugal boyfriend saves money on his bananas.
Andrew, them Aussies saving for Bellboy always coming out with something viral,
No way, mate, this can't be real.
I would say this has got to be a joke, but it's based in some truth.
And why is it so believable?
Just because he's Asian, guys.
First of all, let me just break this down.
If you actually wanted to see savings on this banana peel tactic,
you'd have to buy like six bananas, peel all of them.
Then you really see that drop in weight by the economies of scale.
And then you'd have to chop it up, put them in a Ziploc bag and freeze them.
So then they could last longer.
They don't turn brown.
Anyway, guys, I mean, let's get into the comments section because,
you know what it was, Andrew, like you said,
I think that this was kind of a joke comedy hack from TikTok,
but it really sparked a much larger discussion, Andrew,
because a lot of Asians were triggered by their childhood,
where they felt like their upbringing may have been overly cheap.
No, I saw something like this when I was younger.
My mom did this.
No!
So make sure you like, subscribe, turn on your notifications.
Andrew, I think that this was a great entryway,
not just for the comments section, but for us to bring up the question,
what is the cheapest thing you have ever seen your Asian parents do, Andrew?
Like you said, is this an Asian parent thing or is it an immigrant parent thing?
I think it's a thing when your parents
or your family comes from like either war or struggle.
So I don't only want to say it's Asians.
I don't think Chinese people invented cheap.
I know Jewish people are also known to be very frugal too in their own way.
But kind of in a different way.
Yeah, but I think if you are coming from out of any sort of like civil war,
revolution, war, right?
If you're a refugee, if your family's refugees,
there is some chance you're going to do some cheap stuff.
Say the truth though.
Say the truth.
Do you think the Chinese have the stereotype of being the cheapest,
even amongst the already frugal Asians?
Let me tell you this.
I think that there's a lot of Chinese people and Chinese people are very frugal.
So yes, I do think the stereotype of being cheap
is particularly typified by Chinese people in media.
That's how it feels.
Obviously, China creates and builds a lot of like cheap items too.
But that's not really their fault.
Anyways, guys, let's get into it, man.
Because there is quite the discussion.
Andrew, there's so many topics we got to get through.
How cheap is too cheap?
Is frugal versus cheap versus value minded versus being smart with money different?
Should you just focus on earning more instead of spending less
so you can have a better life?
Should immigrants avoid such embarrassing behaviors?
And when does extreme cheapness almost slip into cultural deviancy
and become uncool?
Yeah, or illegally cheap.
All right, let's get into the comment section first, Andrew.
Somebody said all that just for it to expire quicker.
That technically would be illegal.
Do you think it's illegal to peel the banana before you weigh it?
I think it's stealing or destruction of property, I would say.
Somebody said, how would you like it if I just took all the pits out of the peaches
or if I slap all the water out of the fish before I weigh the fish?
Right, what if you start cutting over open avocados and taking out the pits?
Other people, Andrew, were like, wow, he is so smart for that.
Jealous, I didn't think of that.
I mean, what do you think it is, Andrew?
Do you think some people, and obviously we're particularly pointing at
a segment of Chinese people, all Asians can be like this,
where they just love saving money even if they got money?
Yeah, I feel like the idea, like there's such a dopamine rush of saving money.
And even me right now, I buy a lot of stuff on sale.
I will look at the sale items extra hard.
Are you saying that some people, because in the American sense, Andrew,
you would get a dopamine rush when you spend money to get the thing that you want.
You're saying it's inverse.
They get the dopamine rush when they save the money.
Yeah, but it's not about you releasing dopamine by getting a worse product.
You just release dopamine by getting a good deal on a good product.
Right, right, right.
And I think that this is where it's cheap versus frugal versus value-minded.
You know what it is?
It's kind of that thought that crosses your mind, David.
It's like, he, he, he.
Yeah, I just bought this for 20% off.
Other people are buying it for full price.
Somebody said, the weight of the plastic bag and the cost it added
must be giving him sleepless nights.
Yeah, some people hate that.
Somebody said, dude, this guy will have more money than all of us.
Very smart.
And someone said, I don't know, because one of these days he's not going to wash his hands
and he's going to have to spend $5,000 on a doctor's visit.
Other people said, dude, this is frugal.
But man, to be honest, he will have money in the bank,
but this mindset will keep him limited in terms of upside.
Somebody said, that's a man who clearly comes from a culture that loves money more than anything,
but has no idea how to make more of it.
Yes.
That was a way to put it.
What a way.
I'd never heard this quote before.
I think what you see is the Eastern and Western mindset.
And the Western mindset, especially in America, is just make more and spend more
versus in the Asian mindset, it's like make more and just spend less.
Would you say, though, that this is especially true from an older generation,
maybe 60, 70, 80 years old?
Yeah.
When do you start to see a change amongst the, you know?
I feel like parents who are in their 50s, I'm starting to see it change.
Because 50s, if your parents are in their 50s,
that means you are in your young 20s, probably, if not like your teens,
where then they are a little bit more removed from like the war time.
And, you know, all the wars from Asia.
I mean, cultural revolution.
There was just an era when all that stuff was happening.
You mean all the rationing, the lack of like,
there was no growth mindset at that time?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
No, I mean, let's be honest, like, I don't know the exact dates,
but all that stuff happened in Asia within a span of like 25 years.
Yeah.
Andrew, growing up, we're going to get into the stories, Andrew.
Growing up at church, man, there was some families that were definitely cheap
at the 10 out of 10 level.
And to be honest, I'm not going to lie, Andrew,
that is not that fun of a childhood for their kids.
Right.
No, no, not fun.
Very embarrassing.
Very embarrassing, actually.
But other people are going to argue about this point.
Somebody said, I'd be more, I'd be less embarrassed if he just stole the banana.
Somebody else came through and said, yeah, I'd rather steal than do this.
And somebody said, not even my Asian mother who grew up poor would do this.
Where does he draw the line?
And other people said, extreme cheapskates.
Of course, in the TikTok comment section, and I'm not going to lie,
the white Aussies are just the white looking people.
They were even more embarrassed than any Asian comments.
Like white people hate being seen as cheap.
Oh, man.
No, I think being cheap is such a diss, but I think being cheap to Asians, man,
it's not like it's not the worst thing.
I was not the worst thing.
No, but I do think there is a point, David, where being cheap becomes just a bad decision.
You end up wasting time, wasting effort, and you getting an inferior product.
Yeah.
No, that's true.
It's true.
If you're cheap enough, long enough, you will run into those things
and you have to balance it out.
Yeah.
Honestly, I mean, I wouldn't say 100 out of 100 times you get what you pay for in life.
But honestly, it's probably more than 50% of the time.
It's more true than it's not, to be honest.
David, what is a cheap thing that you saw recently in your life that someone did that you know,
or that you do?
Oh, my goodness, man.
I got to say, you know, I think there's the obvious things.
A lot of people were pointing out that their Asian parents had a nice house,
but maybe cheap furniture, maybe spent a lot on education, but the car was maybe 50-50.
You know how, like, I feel like a lot of Asian families, Andrew,
it depends, because some are, like, 10 out of 10 cheap, right?
And some are, like, 5 out of 10.
But, like, some people will spend on luxury bags,
as long as those luxury bags maintain the asset value.
Yeah, but also, I mean, I think, I guess, you know, to be honest,
if you're going to spend money on a house, buy it, and own it, and have property,
that is better than spending a bunch of money on cars, which are not necessarily an asset.
Right, because you're saying the house can appreciate, depending on the market trends.
Yeah, the cars, like, 99% of them don't appreciate.
Would you agree with me, Andrew?
Everybody at church was probably, at the most luxurious, at the time we were growing up,
maybe the most loosest family with money was maybe a 6 out of 10 cheap,
which is still pretty high on the American scale, and then all the way to, like, 10 out of 10.
Yeah, I would say, like, I've definitely seen parents, like, return fruit to the supermarket,
which you technically can, depending on the supermarket's policy, you can return fruit.
But I would say sometimes that's almost, like, depending on what your opportunity's
cost is, that's just a waste of time.
Right, they're not thinking about the time, and the effort, and the,
you can't do something else if you go spend, and return, or haggle over a $2 item.
Or, obviously, the cheaper product you buy, the more likely something goes wrong,
or you don't like it, so then you feel like you want to return it,
and then that takes up more time out of your life, versus paying just a little bit more
for a better product that you're just happy with.
Yeah, let's say, so I said, at church, people were probably fluctuating between 6 out of 10,
and 10 out of 10 frugality cheapness.
I'm just going to go ahead and say the middle class white kid is, like,
is, like, a 2 out of 10, maybe a 1 out of 10.
Yeah.
They like to spend.
Andrew, do you think it's true that, like, Canto people might even...
I'm talking about Cantonese.
Cantonese people from the villages, I would say, might be more, from my experience of what I saw
at a very, you know, multi-provincial Chinese church,
they're moving towards the 8, 9, and 10 out of 10 level.
I do, I don't, I guess, yeah, I would say so.
Maybe they feel like they're a little bit more frugal than even other groups of people.
Like, I know, for example, comparing Southern Chinese to our Vietnamese friends,
my Viet friends were more likely, I can't speak for all of them,
but more likely to just focus on hustling and making more money
than saving money and penny-pinching.
Right.
But they would also spend the money to get the dopamine,
to use the dopamine to feel more motivated.
Yeah.
People get dopamine from different things,
so if you are a penny-pincher and you love that,
then you're gonna be a penny-pincher for the rest of your life.
But if you get dopamine from buying nice things,
well, then you have to just make more money.
Yeah.
Ultimately, I think you gotta focus more on growing it,
but it is a different skill set and it's a different muscle, Andrew.
Some of the cheapest things I've seen, Andrew.
Andrew, one time we were playing video games with a Cantonese friend of ours, Andrew,
and he refused to even spend the money in the video game
to upgrade his gun to kill the zombies.
But we're supposed to be on a team and he won't upgrade his gun,
so he's using the gun they give you at default,
but we need to get the bigger guns.
Hey, man.
He worked hard for those dollars.
But I'm saying, I guess like...
But I'm saying that goes to show you how deep the mindset coaching was
that it transferred over even to video games, fake money spending.
You know what you can't underrate is that
some people still just like looking at that number grow.
But that number means it's in your bank or in your wallet.
It's not being spent.
So you like to see that number grow,
but you just sit there and the number grows,
but you're not doing anything with your life.
It also depends on how much you enjoy life.
If you enjoy life, you have to spend money.
No, you really do.
Because to what?
To go out to eat with your friends at nicer restaurants,
with better ambiance, better service.
I mean, just to go watch movies constantly,
you have to spend money.
You know what I mean?
Um, Andrew, I knew a guy who tore his ACL
and a pair of basketball sneakers, Nike GT Run, I'm gonna call it out.
And those shoes, if you guys know sneakers,
do not have very good Achilles support.
Okay.
He tore his Achilles.
I'm sorry, not his ACL, his Achilles.
And then he went back and started wearing the Nike GT Runs again.
You're saying if you tore your Achilles
and that costed you a surgery and a bunch of time,
why would you go back to that shoe?
What was his explanation?
He goes, yeah, well, you know,
I already spent a lot of money on my surgery.
So I don't want to spend the money again on another pair of shoes.
But he was underestimating the fact
that he could sell those shoes.
And he could recoup some of the value
and then just buy like some KD-14s on sale
or something with better Achilles support.
Exactly, exactly.
See, that I would say is not being smart with your money.
That's just being cheap.
David, there is a difference between frugal, cheap,
and being smart with your money.
No, for sure, for sure.
I mean, would you say that only using,
I mean, I think there's parts where it blurs the line.
Let's say, for example,
you're from a very Asian family, traditional, old school.
You guys don't want to buy taco sauce.
So you guys have a bunch of taco sauce packets from Taco Bell
as your taco sauce substitute.
I don't think it's wrong
as long as those taco bell packs are in season.
Like they're not expired.
I could see that being valid
because you're like a traditional Asian family.
You know, why would you have taco sauce?
I mean, I would say being smart with money
would be more like knowing how to use your credit cards, right?
And knowing when things are on sale
and using your mileage for flights and things like that.
Being smart with money,
making sure your subscriptions aren't going overdue
and you're not paying late fees
or that you're not subscribed to too many frivolous things
that you don't actually want to be subscribed to, right?
You know, and being frugal is just like,
I'm only going to spend money on the things
that I really like and need.
And I know those five things in my life that I really like
and I'm going to super be frugal about everything else.
And then cheap is to the point where you're out with friends
and it pisses them off.
That's being cheap, right?
And you're getting crappy products.
That is being cheap, for sure.
I mean, overall, how do people get better with money
to understand that they can get what they want for cheap?
Because one thing I noticed is like,
if you already have the thinking
to get a lot of good items for cheap,
it's almost like you probably,
it's like everybody who doesn't have a lot of money,
they could get nice things
if they knew that method of getting nice things for cheap.
But that's the whole point is that they'll never know.
Right, because honestly, it takes some learning.
I think being cheap is very simple-minded mindset.
It's not very clever.
Being frugal and smart with your money,
that takes learning,
but that's going to stick with you for a lifetime.
So if you learn to be smart with your money
when you're young,
it's going to help you throughout your life.
Right. Like we said, guys,
there's things that you can buy.
Sometimes when you buy name brand things,
let's say for example, Andrew,
you cheap out and you get the bootleg Dyson vacuum.
You cannot sell the bootleg Dyson vacuum
and it probably won't be as good as,
you know, whatever the pop in Dyson vacuum
is the cordless one that everybody's using.
Dyson's are great vacuum.
The V11 Cyclone.
Those are amazing vacuum.
Dude, they're like on V14.
Yeah, you can resell it.
It works great.
Makes you want to clean more.
I mean, like we said, man,
there's so many different things,
but you ultimately learn a lot of your money attitude
from your parents.
But I definitely would say read books,
you know, follow some people
that are really good with money on TikTok.
They know how to spend it,
but they know where to save it too.
And let us know what you think
in the comment section below.
What is the cheapest Asian parent thing
that you've ever seen
or cheap from your immigrant parents?
And until next time, we're the Hot Paw Boys.
We out.
Peace.