5.4 The Importance of Self-control- The Individual and the Environment

Irrational Behaviors
3 followers
2 Video Views·May 11, 2023
There's some other questions you might ask about self-control,
in particular about individual differences.
So I'm talking about a few of those things.
First, there's a very, very interesting set
of experiments and results done mostly by Walter
Michel and his colleagues.
And this has to do with how self-control behaves
as a trait over time.
And what they did was what's commonly
known as a marshmallow test.
They took a kid at age 3, 4, 5, 6, and so on,
and they put them in a room.
And they said, hey, kid, you could
have this little marshmallow right now, a little cookie.
But if you wait for 10 minutes, a nice lady
will come with two of those things.
And they basically looked at the kid.
And what was interesting is that the kids who
were able to resist temptation did better in college.
Why?
Because resisting temptation is this general ability.
It's something that if we could do with cookies,
we might be able to do with friends
going to party, drinking too much, procrastination,
and all kinds of other things.
There's some other similar research done at Duke recently
showing that this also connects to health care
outcomes and criminal records, and also
to the ability to maintain good standing
in terms of financial health.
So self-control, even at a young age,
seems to be highly predictive of the ability
to have self-control in later age.
Now, what's also interesting is that if you
look at the videos from Walter Mischel's experiment,
it's not as if the kids were able to just look at the cookie
and not care about it.
They played all kinds of tricks for themselves.
They sat on their hands.
They looked up.
They sang songs to themselves.
They basically found ways to distract themselves.
Now, think about those two paths.
Where is this self-control coming from?
Is it about a skill, some trait?
Or is it about the ability to play tricks on ourselves?
Maybe it's a combination of the two.
In religious terms, you can think about,
is it real or is it grace?
Is it something that we're just born with?
We just don't care about cookies?
Or is it something that we can force ourselves to do
by actually distracting ourselves?
I think that right now, the results point more
into the distracting part, which means
that even if we don't think we have self-control,
we might still have a future because we
might be able to create tricks that
would let us bypass those temptations that
lie in front of us.
So that's the first thing about this skill
and about where is it coming from, this ability
to resist temptation.
The other thing is that there's a really interesting set
of results by Baumeister, Roy Baumeister and his colleagues,
about what's called ego depletion.
And what they're saying is that as you go ahead and resist
temptation throughout the day, it's
becoming harder and harder to resist temptation.
So you see something you want to buy, and you don't buy it,
and you resist temptation.
And you see a muffin, and you want it,
but you resist temptation.
And you go ahead, and you do more and more.
There's YouTube, and there's email,
and saying something nasty for your boss.
And as you resist temptation all the time,
your willpower dwindles.
And Roy is thinking about it like a weight.
You resist temptation, and you resist temptation,
and you resist temptation.
And slowly, slowly, you wear it at your ability
to resist temptation.
And eventually, we fail.
So this, by the way, suggests that if you have tasks that
require self-control, maybe it's good to do them early
in the morning rather than do them late in the afternoon,
when you would be perhaps more depleted.
There's one more really interesting result.
And it's about the fact that religious Jews who
are smokers don't seem to be tempted
by smoking on the Sabbath.
And this is kind of very strange,
because if you think to yourself that smoking
is a physiological reaction, how can it
be that on the Sabbath they are not tempted?
And the idea is that there are some things that we know
are outside of our consideration.
There's this theory in religious thought
that it's about the decision point.
It says that if you get people from the non-religious
to the religious, what changes is what people consider
as an option or not.
If you're an Orthodox Jew, you're
not going to think about smoking on the Sabbath.
Is it all possible?
In the same way that you would not
think about eating a cheesecake after you ate a steak.
It's just not possible.
And once those things are not possible,
they don't seem to tempt us in the same way.
And now the question for us, of course, in society
is, where do we want to have this decision?
The more freedom we have, the more ability
to be tempted we have, and the more potential for failing.
And the less freedom we have, the more restricted
our choices are, but the less chances
there are that we will fail.
So when we think about those issues in terms of personality,
what is our inherent ability for self-control,
and how much of it comes from pure ability
versus ways in which we taught ourselves to have tricks that
trick ourselves.
Think about what happened to self-control and our ability
to resist temptation throughout the day
and as we fight temptation.
And think about what is the role of the rules around us
and what we find is acceptable and not acceptable.
It's both tempting us and also weighing at our ability
for self-control.
So what does all of this tell us about self-control?
First of all, we need to recognize
that we have lots of Adam and Eve problems.
And not only we have them, but they're
going to get more and more over time.
Think about it.
The world around us, the commercial world around us,
wants our time, attention, and money right now.
Who wants us to do something that is good for us
in the long term?
Maybe long-term financial savings,
and maybe preventative health.
But of course, in most cases, we don't have preventative health.
The other thing to realize is the environment
in which we're being placed has a lot to do with our decision.
And what is the commercial environment around us?
It's all about tempting us to behave
in a way that is good for them right now
and not necessarily for us.
So this means that not only do we
have lots of Adam and Eve problems,
we're probably going to have more of them.
As the commercial world around us become more sophisticated,
we're probably going to be tempted to a higher degree.
The next version of the donut, donut 2.0.
Is it going to be more tempting or less tempting
than the donut we have right now?
Most likely more tempting.
The next version of Facebook is going
to tempt us more or less to go into Facebook all the time
and check our profile and messages and so on.
Probably more likely because Facebook
wants us to come back and back and back all the time,
and they control the environment in which we make decisions.
Is the next version of the smartphone
going to tempt us more or less to text while driving
or to check our messages while driving?
Probably more.
So not only do we have self-control problems,
they're likely to get larger and larger over time.
And because of this, things like Ulysses contracts
are incredibly important.
It would be nice if all of us could design
our own reward substitution and our own Ulysses contracts,
but the reality is that it is incredibly hard.
It's incredibly hard to imagine
that we could design those mechanisms
for every one of the many, many temptations
that we face in our daily life.
But instead, I think the hope is in the red button.
The hope is that people would design software
and hardware and reward substitutions
that would help us deal with the world as it is.
Now, this is, again, tremendously important.
There was a very sad analysis that looked about,
that looked at why people die,
and specifically at how many death
can be attributed to bad decision-making.
And we look at the statistics and we try to estimate
many, many years ago, like 100 years ago,
what was the percentage of human mortality
that was caused by bad decision-making?
And it's about 10.
You can think about 100 years ago,
what mistakes could you make in decision-making
that would lead to some death after all?
Not that bad.
The percentage more recently, when you try to estimate it,
is over 40%.
Why?
Because as we invent new technologies,
we also invent ways to kill us.
Think about it.
Obesity, diabetes, smoking, texting and driving.
As we invent these new technologies,
the challenge of decision-making
to be at a much higher level,
we have much more opportunity to fail.
If you text and walk, what can happen?
Not much.
You text and drive at 70 miles per hour
with other cars doing the same thing,
now you're in real danger.
So as we advance in technology
and as we don't take our cognitive limitations into account,
we create more and more opportunities for us to fail.
And because of that,
we need to understand self-control problem
and think very carefully about how to solve it.
The final thing I want to talk about
is the challenges of self-control mechanisms,
particularly for Ulysses contracts,
in terms of our ideology.
And there's a story
that talks about the Denver drug program.
And the data is very sketchy,
but here's how the story goes in general.
This was a drug program that took heroin addicts
and asked them, heroin addicts,
do you want to be a heroin addict?
And the heroin addict said, no, not a good life,
not really interested in living my life.
And they said to them,
why don't you, the heroin addict,
write a self-incriminating letter about your drug habit
and address it to the person you fear most,
who will find out about your drug addiction.
People wrote this letter.
If it was me, I would write,
dear mom, really, really sorry to tell you
I have a drug habit, love, Dan.
And then this not-for-profit would take the letter,
they would fold it, they would put in an envelope,
they would put a stamp, they would address it,
but they would hold it in trust.
And they would come from time to time
and they would do blood tests
and searches in the person's apartment.
And if they ever, ever, ever found traces of drugs,
they will mail the letter away.
Now, this is the Ulysses Contract.
This is saying that when I'm in a cold state,
not interested in being a drug addict,
I'm doing something so big and so powerful
that would hopefully influence my future self
from taking drugs.
I'm basically trying to bind my ability in the future
to behave badly and not pay dramatic, painful cost for that.
What happened?
Lots of people signed up.
These were people who were not craving drugs at the moment.
But then people started craving drugs.
So what happened?
They came to this not-for-profit and say, we want out.
And what is this not-for-profit said?
Fine, in three weeks.
But for now, we're going to test you every day.
We know you're in a craving state,
so we're going to test you every day.
And three weeks are a substantial amount of time
to get over initial stages of drug addiction.
And they said it after that immediate time.
Very few of those people wanted to get out.
Now, eventually this program had to be canceled
mostly because of reasons of violation of human rights.
And that's kind of the issue with Ulysses contracts.
Think about it.
I can probably get you to sign a contract that
would create tremendous damage to yourself if you misbehave.
But the only way this contract is going to be effective
is if you can't get out of it.
Because if you can get out of it,
how is it ever going to be effective?
And because of that, we really have to ask ourselves,
how do we deal with this complexity of human freedom
on one hand and human ability to get
into trouble on the other hand?
Where do we stand on those cases?
There is no question that Ulysses contracts,
particularly big ones, can get people to promise
and actually commit for the future self to behave well.
But these incredible punishments can also
be incredibly damaging if people fail.
And how do we think about it?
And this is also, by the way, why we as researchers
have a very hard time studying Ulysses contracts.
Because the way we do experiments basically
require us to allow people to get out
of the experiment at each point in time.
So the issue is that we really have to think about
what do we care about in terms of human freedom
and how much are we willing to impose on that?
What kind of mistakes are we willing to take
as so important we can override human freedom?
And what mistakes are we willing to let people
continue with in the name of freedom?
So that's it for today.
And as you go throughout the rest of your,
the next hour, day, maybe week,
think about all the cases in which you're tempted
to misbehave and try to think about
how you're going to overcome those right now
and what kind of tools would help you
to overcome those temptations in the future.
