4.10 Lionel Messi meets Salvador Dali: A motivational story - Lalin Anik - Duke University

Irrational Behaviors
3 followers
2 Video Views·May 5, 2023
Hello, my name is Deli Nanak and I'm a postdoctoral fellow at the Center for Advanced Hindsight at Duke University.
Prior to starting my postdoc here, I received my PhD in Marketing from the Harvard Business School.
My PhD came in the expense of a lifelong hobby.
I was a swimmer for nearly two decades of my life, which is the majority of it.
And being a national swimmer meant that I swam 25 hours a day, 8 days a week.
And for such a long time, it's very hard to be constantly motivated.
At the beginning, when I started around age 6, I was motivated by the physical activity.
Later on, when I started competing, it was the adrenaline rush and winning that got me going.
But much later in my career, it was the mental aspect of swimming that I loved.
But when I look back, two decades of doing the same activity meant different types of motivation throughout.
To be motivated means to be moved to do something, to be energized towards an action.
And when you think about it, when you think about an 8-year-old doing one task, let's say swimming,
versus an 18-year-old swimming, you need to provide them with two different motivators.
And an 8-year-old kid will not be really motivated by money, which is the most common incentive we use.
If they win, we can give them a medal, but if we give them a $100 bill, they will not be swimming 5 hours a day with that $100 bill.
They might be happy at the beginning, but they'll forget that.
And I see this very similarly in life.
We might not be using money. We should not use money with adults for every type of task because it might not be the best incentive.
This becomes more obvious when we start thinking about the past 5 years and the global economic crisis.
Money is scarce, and we should start to think about money and incentives in different ways.
I think of this as similar to a car metaphor.
So historically, we use cars, and we use gasoline to fuel cars.
But as the population of the world increases, we're running out of our gasoline reserves.
And as a result, we need to find new environmentally healthy and friendly sources, fuels.
And same with ourselves.
Our bodies and our souls are vehicles to move towards aims in life.
And money might not be money like gas might not be the most sustainable incentive.
We need to find novel ways and psychologically healthy and more happiness friendly fuel for our vehicles.
So today, I'm going to talk about incentives other than money that we can use to motivate people and their labors.
In the first part, I'm going to try to answer this question.
What are some of the incentives other than money we can use to get people going?
So rather than fuel, let's think about electricity, wind and water energies.
And in the second part, I'm going to ask this question.
Can we use these novel types of incentives with every type of task?
Meaning, rather than cars, shall we move towards hybrids or shall we go back to bicycles?
Are all ways of moving around.
So let's start out with thinking about some of the ways, some of the incentives we can use other than money.
Historically, we have used money to reward individuals, their labors and performances.
And we have actually used individual incentives.
But as humans, we're social animals.
We spend 80% of our waking hours in the company of others.
So why not use this natural social disposition we have to motivate people?
And this way, we can move away from individual incentives towards more social incentives.
And what is called in the literature as social motivation.
What do I mean by social motivation?
It means this energy and fuel we get from the social context of our lives.
So with Dan Ariely and our collaborator Michael Norton, we partnered up with Global Giving to test this power of social motivation.
Global Giving is a non-profit that works with grassroots projects around the world and that connects them to donors.
And you can go on this website and find a charity that interests you and donate to this cause.
Whether these are hungry kids in Africa or earthquake victims anywhere.
And what we did is that we ran a bunch of experiments online with them.
So if you were a participant in these experiments, you would go online, pick a charity of your choice.
And we would tell you about the behaviors of everyone else who sees this charity.
And we would give you a percentage.
For example, we would tell you 10% of people who saw this charity donated to this cause.
Or you would hear 100% of people.
Everyone who saw this charity, this cause, donated.
And what we find is that providing people with this information about other people's behavior gives them the motivation to donate to this cause now as well as commit to donating in the future.
And what we find is that 70% is this key percentage, this point.
We're telling you that 70% of people, not 100, not everyone or not 50, but 70% of people donate to this cause.
That you are also going to commit to donating today and also you will sign up for recurring donations.
Why could this be happening?
Because knowing that 70% of people are joining the cause possibly legitimizes the act.
It tells you that this is a worthy cause and you should also join in this movement.
Let's take another example.
There's this website called kickstarter.com.
It's an American-based crowdfunding website where you can post up a project that you need funding for.
And you ask everyone around the world, and this is American-based, so the Americans, to donate to this cause.
And let me give you an example.
Let's say that there are two projects.
There are two painters and they both need funding to rent a space, a studio space, and they need money for paint, for canvas, so that they can do their art.
And then they can have exhibits and possibly make money, let's say, from their art.
And when you're visiting these two causes on Kickstarter website, on one project, you see that no one has donated, zero people, in over two weeks.
In the other project, you see that, let's say, 50 people have supported this painter.
Which project would you donate to?
If you're like most people, you would stay away from this cause that was supported by no one.
Because you would think, is this a legitimate cause?
Is this worthy of my money?
And why didn't everybody else donate?
But when you see 50 people donating to this cause, you will want to donate because there's this element of being a part of a community.
Let's think about another example.
So Wikipedia is an online encyclopedia that has open source, open contribution model.
So everyone around the world can come and sign up and they will contribute information with no monetary compensation in return.
But why do these people do it?
It's basically for this feeling of being a part of a community.
By giving information, sharing information and contributing to Wikipedia, they become a part of this group who shares interests and needs.
So it drives their behavior.
So far, we have talked about social motivation and being a part of community as potential incentives, other than money or besides money, to motivate people's labors and contributions.
Let's switch gears quickly and talk about some other motivators.
In this case, money is one currency we can use to motivate people.
Let's think about an alternative currency.
An alternative currency would be time.
Just like money, they say time is money.
It's a very significant aspect of our lives.
And when it's gone, it's lost forever.
If I lost $10 yesterday, I can probably get it back.
But when yesterday is gone, there's no turning back.
I need to move forward.
So rather than giving people money, why shouldn't we give them time?
Google got this right.
They have the 20% time program where they tell their employees that they can spend 20% of their time on projects that are unrelated to work.
3M did something similar.
They have a 15% culture where their employees can spend 15% of their time on initiatives and projects that are of their own choosing.
Why is this important?
By giving people time, their employees time, Google and 3M acknowledge that their employees are individuals who can control their time and who can have freedom and autonomy.
Autonomy is very important as a motivator.
Best Buy also understood this because they have this program where their employees can do whatever they want, whenever they want it, without any schedules and without any meetings.
As long as they get the work done.
And the idea here is again, giving their employees autonomy over their time and possibly over their happiness.
And this way, people can concentrate during the time that they're actually working and then be more creative and flexible during those 20% or 15% of their time.
So these are three of many variables we can use or incentives we can use besides money to incentivize employees or incentivize people and labor in general.
But can we use these incentives in every situation or in every task, every type of labor or is there something about certain types of labor that make these different types of incentives possible?
So we have a social disposition to be, we talked about the social disposition as a social motivator.
Let's take this to a different type of tasks and I'm going to give you the example of Lionel Messi who is arguably the best soccer player in the world and he plays for Barcelona.
If we take him, he's very good at soccer.
And if we take him to El Clasico, which is one of the biggest derbies in the world between Barcelona and Real Madrid, and we put him in a stadium of 80 to 100,000 people, he's probably going to perform really well.
And so will a lot of professional soccer players.
But what if we take Messi and get him into the stadium or in front of 80 or 100,000 people and get him to cook or knit or play curling?
This is conditional on the fact that he's not really good at these or he doesn't do these much.
How will he perform?
Will he perform beyond his baseline level?
The Polish psychologist, Zajac, in 1960s said that, talked about this idea of social facilitation paradigm.
And what he said is that having people around, the social presence of others will motivate us.
But what he showed is that if the task is something we're familiar with, having other people around will get us to do really well on that task.
But if the task is novel and if we're not familiar with it, getting other people around will provide an incentive and that will raise our adrenaline.
But that will also arouse us and that will actually disable our performance.
What I mean by this is the following.
If we take Messi, he's really good at soccer and he has automatic reactions.
He practiced it well.
So putting him in front of 80 or 100,000 people will get him to do this task, this task he's familiar with, much better.
But if we put him in front of that many people for a task he's not familiar with, curling or knitting, he's probably not going to perform at the level that he would if he were doing it alone.
So there's this aspect of social facilitation, having other people that will incentivize our labor and our behaviors.
Finally, I would like to talk about a certain type of task that is quite hard to incentivize.
And money might not work well in this scenario.
And that is creativity.
Creative tasks are very interesting and they're very hard to incentivize and motivate with in many different ways.
Let's think about this.
Possibly some of you are authors, painters, sculptors and writers yourselves.
And please think back to the time where you started this hobby.
It's probably you had a talent, you thought that it was enjoyable and it became your favorite pastime.
But as you moved on in life, as years passed and you came to a point where you needed to make a decision between this task that was intrinsically motivating for you.
And when you moved away from your family and you needed to pay for your bill, you probably had to make a decision whether this task that's intrinsically motivating will also pay for your bills.
So you came to a fork. Some of you have quit or put this hobby aside.
And other people thought that their intrinsic motivation to do it just overrode the pay that they were going to receive.
So this quandary between money and intrinsic motivation is not only experienced by individuals but organizations also go through it and they try to solve it.
Because they have a lot of employees and some of the employees do creative work.
So how should organizations motivate their employees to succeed at these creative jobs and just be more creative and innovative?
So Adam Grant and James Berry ran a series of experiments looking at creativity in organizations and what type of motivators should be used to get people to be creative.
And they actually approached the U.S. Army and they ran surveys with security force officers asking them about their job and asking them how pro-social they are.
This idea of caring about other people which I talked about previously about community in the Wikipedia case, in the charitable donations case, caring about other people is the main drive.
And they looked at that specific drive and they looked at its relation to creativity.
And what they found is that people or security officers who are intrinsically motivated were more creative.
But being intrinsically motivated about a creative task was not enough.
They needed to be pro-social.
They also needed to care about other people, their supervisors, their subordinates in order to take their perspective and see what they would care about in order to be productive and creative at the end.
So it again comes back to this idea of social motivation.
That's other than money, caring about other people, being a part of them, being a part of community or just if you're doing some creative job, caring about what other people would think and what other people will need.
And as a result what they found is that those security officers who are intrinsically motivated and also were more pro-social and caring about others' needs and were more benevolent had more access to new ideas.
And not only that, that when they had a bunch of ideas they were able to pick through them and work more thoroughly through these ideas.
So today I talked about two things.
One is I talked about these different incentives we can use other than money, social motivation, time, and being a part of community that get people going, get people energized.
And the second part talked about different types of tasks, simple versus complex tasks, tasks we're familiar with versus novel tasks.
And that's specifically about creative tasks that are very specific to think about in terms of different types of incentives.
So moving forward, how shall we proceed with these incentives?
And my question there, and this is something I wonder about, is with every new generation it seems like we get everything we want.
And these things we get are not dependent even on our labor.
They might be used as incentives by our bosses, by our parents, but when we have everything and when a generation has everything, how can you incentivize them?
How can you get them going and how can you keep them active for labors or for things that they need to do, for basic things?
It can be athletic activity, it can be school homework, or it can be just finding a career that they like.
So finally, I would like to part with a quote from a French novelist and memoirist, Georges Sand.
And she said, work is not man's punishment, it is his reward, his strength, and his pleasure.
I hope that all your endeavors and all your work is always pleasurable.
Thank you.
