Dr. Balfanz testifies at a hearing on the GOP's partisan ESEA reauthorization bills - 2.16.2011

Committee on Education & the Workforce Democrats
56 followers
Feb 16, 2012
At a hearing with the full House Education and the Workforce Committee on the Republicans' highly partisan legislation to reauthorize the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, Dr. Robert Balfanz, Co-Director of the Everyone Graduates Center at the Johns Hopkins University's School of Education, testifies.
For more information, visit: http://go.usa.gov/QFx and http://go.usa.gov/QFF
Dr. Balfanz.
Chairman Klein, Ranking Member Miller, members of the committee, thank you for inviting me
to testify today.
My remarks today are based on 15 years of experience working as a researcher and practitioner
with high poverty, middle and high schools. And what this experience tells me is that
the nation is at a crossroads. Right now, there is no work in the 21st century to support
a family if you don't have a high school diploma and some post-secondary schooling
or training. Yet every year, we are continuing to produce one million young adults. We are
propelling them into young adulthood without a high school diploma, for which there is
really little future. And we are also about 25 percent of our graduates from high school
are not prepared for post-secondary success.
No business can survive when it only works half the time. No nation can be economically
competitive under the same conditions. The good news is some progress is being made.
Graduation rates are actually up. Achievement is up. And the low-graduation-rate high schools,
those high schools that produce half our nation's dropouts, called dropout factories, have actually
declined from 2,000 to 1,500. The number of students passing AP exams has doubled.
We have also learned a lot more about what works. And we have also learned the early
warning signs of dropping out. So now it is much more—we are much more able to intervene
early and effectively. But this progress has not been fast enough, deep enough, or wide
enough. And that is why today's hearing is so important. We have to get this right. We
have to figure out how we can combine local energy and initiative and choice with federal
guideposts, guardrails, and catalysts so we can have—so we can step on the gas. We have
got to step on the gas. We have got to have much higher outcomes at the end of this decade
than we do now.
So there is an important federal role here that I just want to give three ideas on for
my work in the field. First, we do need federal guideposts. We have had a great natural experiment
in the past decade. And what happens when we leave it to states alone to set targets
and goals? NCLB let all states figure out how they wanted to measure graduation rates,
set their own goals, set their own targets. And what happened? About a dozen states stepped
forward, put forward comprehensive plans, and saw double-digit gains in their graduation
rates. New York and Tennessee were the leaders. Another dozen states, quite frankly, took
a pass. They used inflated graduation rates. They said any progress matters, even if we
go from 50 to 50.5 percent. And actually, 10 states now have lower graduation rates
than they did in 2001.
So we have got to find a way to build upon the work done by the National Governors Association
with the Grad Rate Compact and the Department of Ed 2008 regulations, which means that this
year we finally have grad rate accountability in the nation. And the reauthorization can't
go backward. It needs to build on that and add college readiness.
A second area where we need a federal role is with guardrails. Put yourself in the place
of a principal of a high-poverty middle or high school. You have 1,000 to 2,000 students.
You have 100 adults to manage. Most of your students enter the building below grade level.
Most have waning motivations. Many are chronically absent. Add several years of budget cuts now.
Enter Title I dollars. This is a lifeline. It is the only discretionary dollars you have.
And you are now under tremendous pressure from all quarters to spend that money in all
kinds of different ways. Giving some guardrails will give principals the cover and the support
they need to do what they know is right. And that is why we need at least some separate
protected funding streams for principals doing comprehensive evidence-based reform and bringing
in external partners with proven track records of success to help build capacity. And in
these regards, the bills put forward today have good guidance.
The final area we need a federal role is to be a catalyst. We need to basically zoop up
the engine. We've got to go faster to get where we need to go. And that's about R&D.
It's about innovation. But it's also about better dissemination. Because when I'm in
schools, I always see at least one great local innovation that's really powerful and really
strong and they almost all have very short shelf lives. They last as long as the developer
of that innovation is in the school, in the district, in the state. So there's very little
cumulative learning and we have very low educational productivity because of that.
So we have to rethink how we disseminate good local ideas by building learning networks
and having some funding to support local and state dissemination efforts so we can really
spread evidence-based and practice-validated educational improvements.
In closing, we need to combine local energy, innovation, and wisdom with federal guideposts,
guardrails, and catalysts to accelerate our educational outcomes and graduate all our
students prepared for adult success. If at the end of this decade we are still debating
how to do this, and some nations have built more universities than we have fixed failing
schools, we will be on the wrong track. It is only by learning from the past decade's
successes and struggles that we can effectively build a partnership between the federal government,
states, and local schools and teachers to provide all our students with a pathway to
high school graduation, college, and career ready. Thank you.
