Dr. Dawn-Elise Snipes is a Licensed Professional Counselor and Qualified Clinical Supervisor. She received her PhD in Mental Health Counseling from the University of Florida in 2002. In addition to being a practicing clinician, she has provided training to counselors, social workers, nurses and case managers internationally since 2006 through AllCEUs.com Metacognitive essentially means “thinking about thinking” and refers to the knowledge and regulation of one’s own cognitive processes. Please SUBSCRIBE and click the BELL to be notified when we upload new videos.
Sponsored by TherapyNotes.com Manage your practice securely and efficiently. Two free months of TherapyNotes with coupon code "CEU"
MCT agrees that prior experiences create schema which influence interpretation of events and our mood including anxiety and depression, however, MCT focuses not on the content of the thoughts but the what the person pays attention to. Metacognitive experiences are the reactions such as anger anxiety and depression people have as a result of their cognitive appraisals which negatively impact their mental health MCT focuses on disorder specific cognitive biases such as mood congruent memory. If you are depressed, you are typically going to notice things that make you sad, angry or anxious. If you are happy, you are likely to notice the positive aspects of your situation.
People can have millions of automatic cognitive distortions. Addressing each one may not be possible. Becoming aware of thought patterns, their function, their usefulness and alternatives underlies MCT. MCT moves from addressing the content of thoughts (What is being thought?) to the function of those thoughts (Why are the thoughts occurring and are they helpful?)
AllCEUs provides multimedia #counseloreducation and CEUs for LPCs, LMHCs, LMFTs and LCSWs as well as #addiction counselor
This episode was pre-recorded as part of a live continuing education webinar.
On-demand CEUs are still available for this presentation through All CEUs.
Register at allceus.com slash counselor toolbox.
I'd like to welcome everybody to today's presentation on metacognitive therapy.
As always, when we go over therapeutic techniques, what we're
doing or what I am doing today is just providing you a really
high-level overview.
You are not going to be an expert on metacognitive therapy by the time
you get out of today's one-hour webinar.
However, once you go through, if you learn about it and you think,
oh, that could be useful, that could be interesting,
then you can delve deeper into finding other resources and other trainings on it.
Today, we're basically going to learn about metacognitive therapy,
the multiple aspects of metacognition, and we're going to talk about what metacognition is.
How to apply metacognitive therapy to depression, pain,
learn helplessness, and other stressful situations.
This particular approach requires something of a paradigm shift in our thinking.
It may be a little challenging or it was for me, let me just put it that way,
a little bit challenging for me to wrap my head around initially
and separate it from cognitive behavioral.
I'm going to do my best to differentiate it from cognitive behavioral therapy
as we go through today's presentation.
Let's start at the beginning.
People come to therapy because they're in distress of some sort.
Distress is a signal that the person is trying to respond to threats to their well-being.
Anger, anxiety, depression, you know, those are our distress sort of emotions.
It is normally reduced by effective coping strategies,
but not everybody has effective coping strategies or there can be hiccups in the system.
Disorders result when the person's coping skills backfire.
You decide that in order to cope with this situation,
you're going to drink a bottle of wine or go to sleep and just get up tomorrow.
Well, both of those examples, while they may help in the very, very short term,
they may make the distress go away for the second,
when you wake up or when you sober up, that problem may still be there.
Then the person is left feeling hopeless and helpless because that problem is still there.
They tried to make it go away and they don't know how to make it go away.
Disorders also result when people believe they have no control over their thoughts,
when they believe that, you know, I keep having this thought or I keep telling myself this.
We have, you know, those automatic thoughts, those hecklers in our heads sometimes.
And when people believe that they have absolutely no control over their thoughts,
then they can feel somewhat helpless.
If they say, I can't stop worrying, then they're going to feel more helpless and more anxious.
They may also develop disorders when they believe it's in their best interest to keep ruminating.
Rumination often focuses on questions that have no easily identifiable answers.
What if this happens?
Think about, it's easiest to give examples of physical disorders.
If you have a pain in your stomach, a pain in your side, and you're thinking, well, it could be,
you know, I ate something wrong, or it could be irritable bowel, or, but what if?
What if it's cancer?
What if it's pancreatic cancer?
What if it's liver cancer?
Better get online and start looking and see what the symptoms of all that kind of stuff are.
If you go online to check out your symptoms, you're almost always going to come up with the
most catastrophic results possible, which is going to spin you up into anxiety.
When people are depressed, they may say, why do I feel this way?
They may be trying to rack their brain for why they feel depressed.
It could be cognition.
It could be environment.
It could be a neurochemical imbalance because of extended stress or inadequate quality sleep.
There's a lot of different reasons why people could feel a certain way.
And if they continue to think about it, why do I feel depressed?
Then they may get frustrated if they're not coming up with the answer.
Why me?
Why do I feel this way?
Why am I depressed?
Why am I anxious?
Why do I have bipolar disorder?
Why me?
Why did this happen to me?
And sometimes there are no easy answers.
You know, you have somebody, I worked with a gentleman early in my career who was a paranoid,
had paranoid schizophrenia and brilliant, brilliant man, literally was a nuclear physicist.
Brilliant man.
And he could have perseverated on why me?
Why do I have to have this diagnosis?
Because he could have theoretically done so many amazing things with his intellectual gifts.
But unfortunately, when he had his psychotic break, that kind of put an end to a lot of that.
And he could have sat there and perseverated on why me?
Why is this happening?
What did I do wrong?
And may not come up with an answer.
Or what does this symptom mean?
And we, I see this one a lot, again, with physical issues,
especially with people who have chronic pain.
Does this mean it's getting worse?
When people are perseverating or ruminating on these types of thoughts,
especially questions that have no answers, it gets frustrating.
It gets exasperating because if you can't come up with an answer,
then you can't come up with a solution.
Metacognition essentially means thinking about thinking
and refers to the knowledge and regulation of one's own cognitive processes.
Now, in cognitive behavioral therapy, we talk about the content.
We look at specifically these thoughts.
What thoughts are you having?
Let's take this individual thought.
Let's dissect it.
Let's look at whether it is accurate or not.
Let's look at any distortions that might be there, yada, yada.
Metacognitive goes more broadly.
And instead of saying, let's look at each example of overgeneralization,
metacognitive says, let's look and see if you have a thinking style
that is characteristic of overgeneralization.
Metacognitive therapy agrees that prior experiences create schema
that influence our interpretation of events.
So the past is influencing us now.
However, it focuses on not the content of the thoughts,
but what the person pays attention to.
If somebody has a negative thinking style,
a perseverative thinking style,
a overgeneralizing thinking style,
an overly personalized thinking style,
you get where I'm going with this.
Metacognitive experiences are the reactions people have
as a result of their cognitive appraisals.
So if I have a negative thinking style,
I just look at everything through a negative lens.
And then my reaction to that is going to probably be
to be anxious, angry, depressed.
Because everywhere I look, I'm seeing the negativity.
I'm seeing the negative stuff.
So metacognition encourages people to become more aware,
more mindful of their thinking styles
and not get caught up or down in the weeds
addressing every single individual cognitive distortion,
because we can have millions of those.
Metacognitive therapy says, you know,
okay, so when you're feeling depressed,
what is your thinking style that you're doing?
Metacognitive therapy focuses on disorder-specific cognitive biases,
such as mood congruent memory,
which is basically a researcher's way of saying
that metacognitive therapy says,
when you are in a particular mood,
when you are depressed, what things do you tend to notice?
It's a depressive thinking style.
When you are happy, what do you tend to notice?
You know, that's your happy thinking style.
And what are the results of those two different,
you know, approaches to viewing the same content?
You know, when you're going to work,
think about going to work.
We go to work, whether we're depressed,
we go to work, whether we're angry,
we go to work when we're happy.
Do you notice different things when you are in different moods?
Chances are, if you really sit down and think about it,
the answer is going to be yes.
Unless you intentionally say, okay, I'm in a bad mood,
I am going to try to see the good in things today.
But our knee-jerk response is to see,
to notice confirmatory stimuli in the environment.
One study on metacognitive therapy
indicated that the only mediator
between treatment and depression recovery was,
you know, if somebody went to treatment,
the only factor that really predicted recovery
was whether we were able to address
their feelings of lack of control.
Metacognitive knowledge.
Now, there are three components to metacognition.
We start out with knowledge,
just like we do in treatment plans.
Metacognitive knowledge refers to the declarative knowledge
of cognitive processes
and includes our personal knowledge.
So our ways of thinking, knowledge of how we think,
and our knowledge of our personal abilities and limitations.
And this is really what we would often call mindfulness.
Now, within personal knowledge,
we can have negative metacognitive beliefs
and positive metacognitions.
Let's not get too far down in the weeds with that.
The biggest issue,
I just wanted to throw those terms there
because if you start reading about metacognitive therapy,
these terms are going to come up.
Negative metacognitive beliefs
are basically what we have often called
distress intolerant thoughts.
And they focus on the uncontrollability of our thoughts,
rumination, and threat monitoring,
or constantly noticing the threat.
There are things that we don't wanna have.
We don't wanna have feelings of uncontrollability.
We don't wanna ruminate.
We don't want to feel like
we're constantly having to monitor for threats.
And we don't wanna have coping skills that backfire.
When that happens,
then we lose a certain amount of self-efficacy.
When we try to cope with something and it fails,
we start to feel that we're powerless
to control that situation.
So these are all negative beliefs about what's going on.
Positive metacognitions are beliefs
about the need to have a particular belief
to stay safe or prepared.
A positive metacognition,
when it comes to, for example, chronic pain,
would be I need to constantly scan
and be hypervigilant to changes in my pain
to make sure that it's not getting worse
and becoming cancer.
Another part of metacognitive knowledge
is task knowledge, such as how to do something.
And we have a lot of task knowledge,
such as we know how to cook in general.
You may not know how to make fricassee,
but you may be able to cook in general.
You may know how to meditate
or you may not.
And people are going to evaluate their task knowledge.
And if they don't feel confident to do it,
then they are going to have
more negative metacognitive beliefs.
So if you tell a client,
well, to deal with your anxiety,
why don't we try some meditation?
If they don't believe that they have the skills to do it,
if they don't have the confidence to do it,
then they are going to feel like it's too dangerous.
They've already tried other coping skills
that have backfired,
and they may not be wanting to try new ones.
We can address this task knowledge component
or task skills deficits with skills training.
So we look and we identify what strengths a person has,
what tasks can they already do
in order to cope with whatever it is
that they're presenting with.
And then what other skills might be helpful
and how can we help them learn those skills
and develop a sense of confidence
that they can implement that tool
and it will be effective.
And the third type of metacognitive knowledge
is strategic knowledge.
And that is the person's ability
to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages
of different responses.
When I am feeling this way,
what are the advantages and disadvantages
to reacting this way?
And the applicability of each strategy.
And this really goes to problem solving,
our ability to weigh the options
and figure out which choice
is going to best serve us in the moment.
Metacognitive experience
is the personal experience and perception of difficulty
that accompanies cognitive activity.
So we can think,
hey, I'm anxious.
One of those skills that I've learned
that might be helpful in dealing with this anxiety
is meditation.
And I feel fully confident
that I can implement that
because I've practiced it, I've rehearsed it
and that it will help me feel less anxious.
So great.
So what is the metacognitive experience
with those thoughts that we just had?
Probably pretty confident, pretty calm,
pretty motivated to try.
The third metacognitive component
is monitoring and control
and refers to the self-supervision and regulation
of the cognitive processes,
including planning, monitoring, evaluating
and regulating their cognitive activities
by adjusting task goals,
regulating attentional awareness
and selecting cognitive strategies.
Perfect example.
I am a great big old sissy
when it comes to getting a shot.
I hate needles beyond belief
but you gotta get your flu shot.
You gotta get shots occasionally
and I have to figure out how to deal with that.
So monitoring and control,
I'm going back through,
let's go back up here
so we can just follow it through.
Negative metacognitive beliefs,
the uncontrollability of thoughts.
I have this fear that of thoughts
or fear of shots that it's gonna hurt.
So I may ruminate on the fact that,
oh, I've got to go get that shot.
It's gonna hurt.
My arm's gonna hurt for the whole next day,
blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
And threat monitoring,
you know, looking around and wondering,
you know, is this particular practitioner
going to be one that's good at giving shots
or am I gonna feel like I just got stabbed
with a great big old butcher knife or something?
So those are the negative metacognitive beliefs
that may be going through my head
before I get a shot.
My task knowledge, how to do something.
I've gotten a shot before.
I've survived it before.
So I know that task knowledge.
And the advantages and disadvantages.
Well, I can evaluate and say,
you know what,
ruminating on the fact that this is gonna hurt
ain't gonna solve the problem.
Okay.
So my metacognitive experience
is telling me that,
okay, this was unpleasant before,
but I've gotten through it before.
Monitoring and control.
When you go to get a shot,
a lot of times they say, don't look.
Why?
Because if you look,
then you tend to tense up.
You tend to expect the pain.
You tend to focus on the pain.
If you're not looking,
then you tend to not tense up as much.
They also tell you to focus on relaxing.
Because if you tense up that muscle,
then you're probably going to have more bruising
and more soreness and more yada, yada, yada.
Well, so I know what the skills are.
I need to not look.
And I need to, you know, relax.
And that means engaging whatever skills I have
to help me relax.
So that's the best course of action.
That's the cognitive strategy I'm going to use.
If I continue to think about how much it's going to hurt,
I ain't going to relax.
So I need to think about anything else.
And that's one way, you know,
that's an example of metacognition.
I can focus on the negatives
or I can focus on what I can control in the situation.
What do you think is going to be more helpful?
What do you think is going to make me feel more efficacious?
Example application.
When we think about rumination,
sometimes people will ruminate on things.
You know, why me?
What's causing this?
Yada, yada.
And in their mind, in the back of their mind,
the metaconcepts or metacognition going along with this
is if I think about it long enough, I'll find the answer.
So one of the things we can posit is, okay,
you know, you've been thinking about this for a long time
and you've been telling me that you keep thinking about it
and you keep trying to find answers.
How long have you been at it?
And how much longer is it going to take
for you to find that answer?
And what if there is no answer?
You know, you might be going forever.
So encouraging people to look at the effectiveness
and of what they're doing and the consequences of it.
Another example would be people's belief
that they need to control my thoughts.
If I don't control my thoughts, I will do something bad.
And this struck me rather poignantly, if you will,
working with people who have postpartum depression
and particularly women with postpartum depression.
And I can tell you, I had this experience myself.
My postpartum depression was bad enough
that I would have images of doing very horrible things
to my child, completely egotistonic.
They scared the bejesus out of me,
which is the difference between postpartum psychosis
in which the person sees absolutely nothing wrong with that
and postpartum depression, having those thoughts
and it being terrifying.
So that was kind of the upside
to being terrified at my own thoughts.
But yeah, it was terrifying.
And I felt like I couldn't control those images sometimes.
And so in metacognitive therapy,
the practitioner would say,
how do you know which thoughts to control?
How do you know which ones are the ones
that you want to let through
and which ones you want to make sure
don't come through at all?
Who knows?
And what types of bad things have happened
by not controlling your thoughts
when you've had those thoughts?
What's happened?
What bad things have happened?
Have you followed through on any of it?
And obviously this is on a case-by-case basis.
If you're dealing with somebody
who's in a florid psychotic episode,
you're gonna have more difficulty
helping them with metacognition.
But it is important to help people recognize
that sometimes these thoughts will come
and they're transient and they are unpleasant.
But do they make you do something back?
And encourage them to really look at that.
Comparing cognitive behavioral
and metacognitive therapy.
In cognitive behavioral, something happens.
Somebody gets critical, unconstructive feedback.
Somebody is just nasty to them.
Okay, that's the activating event.
They get upset.
They feel anxious and helpless.
And they're like feeling out of control.
They're automatic beliefs.
This person hates me.
They don't consider other perspectives.
They feel entitled.
And they aren't accepting responsibility
for their part in this situation.
Okay, so there can be a lot of beliefs
that go along with it.
And in cognitive behavioral,
we would examine each one of those beliefs
for their validity.
You know, how accurate are they?
And for their effectiveness.
Even if they are valid,
is this thought helping me in some way?
In what way is this thought contributing
to helping me feel empowered?
In metacognitive therapy, same person.
Gets unconstructive feedback.
They feel anxious, helpless, powerless.
They're like, just everywhere I turn,
I'm always with this person.
I am never able to get it
through the goalposts.
You know, it's always not good enough
or it's never good enough.
Okay, so the metacognitive therapist would say,
what is the thought process
that is going on in your mind?
What characterized the beliefs
that you're having?
Instead of telling me each individual belief,
characterize the beliefs
and tell me why you're thinking about them.
Why are you going down this train of thought?
And the person may say,
I need to think about it.
I need to ruminate to identify
all the ways to defend myself
against this person's criticism.
Okay, so again, how many ways
do you need to think of?
And when will you have enough ways?
When will you have enough information
in your arsenal?
Will continuing to ruminate
change their opinion?
You know, anything that you think of
to defend yourself,
is that going to change
that person's opinion?
You know, sometimes no.
Sometimes people are just going to have
a differing opinion and nothing you say
is going to make any difference.
Is their opinion truly a threat to you?
There can be a colleague
could have a differing opinion
about how to treat a client.
Doesn't mean yours is wrong necessarily.
Doesn't mean theirs is wrong necessarily.
Is their opinion a threat
to your ability to practice?
Does it mean you're a bad therapist?
Well, no, you know,
it means that you have different approaches.
Imagine you have social anxiety
and you don't like going to parties
because you're worried
that you'll do something embarrassing
and humiliate yourself.
In metacognitive therapy,
again, we're not paying attention
to that specific thought content.
We're not having them identify
every automatic belief they're having.
Instead, we're challenging the process
that leads to the thought.
And the process for that person
might be worrying about this
prepares me in some way.
It keeps, it helps me be ready
for handling this.
And then they may go,
well, you know, I don't really see
the purpose in worrying about it.
So they may switch their thought process
to saying worrying about this
does not make it less likely to happen.
So I'm not going to spend the time worrying.
Or, and, I have the ability
to focus my thoughts on other things.
And in other approaches,
we may refer to this
as taming our monkey mind.
Encouraging people to recognize
that yes, worry may pop in,
but we don't have to greet it
with a handshake and give it a big hug
and not let it go.
We can let thoughts, just like clouds,
come in, make their pretty little picture
or devastating little picture
and then float out.
And that's all.
We don't have to hang on to them.
Remembering, you know,
a lot of people think about thoughts as,
oh my gosh, I'm having this thought
over and over and over again.
And it's stuck in my head.
And I encourage them to think about
other thoughts that they've had
that didn't stick.
You know, they got up from the living room
and went into the kitchen to do something
and before they even got to the kitchen,
they forgot what they got up to do.
We've all had those moments.
Well, that was a thought too.
So what's the difference
between the thoughts that stick
and the thoughts that
one ear and out the other?
Helping people recognize that
thoughts don't have to stick around.
And when they do,
a lot of times we're holding on to them.
And the question is,
why are we holding on to them?
Not what are the thoughts we're having,
but what is the benefit
to holding on to this thinking pattern?
In metacognitive therapy,
cognitive attentional syndrome or CAS
refers to a tendency to believe
thoughts are uncontrollable,
rely on ineffective coping skills,
ruminate and focus undue attention
on threat monitoring.
Constantly or nearly constantly
scanning for threats
and scanning for evidence
to support our feelings.
I feel anxious.
Therefore, it must be dangerous.
Therefore, I must find evidence
that it's dangerous.
That's kind of backwards.
We really want to see the evidence
before we have the feeling.
Cognitive attentional syndrome
focuses attention on sources
of potential threat,
which increases our sense of danger.
If we are intentionally
paying more attention to the threats,
we are going to feel more helpless,
more hopeless, more anxious,
more dysphoric.
It increases focus of thoughts
and awareness on sources of threats.
So not only do we have this
just general overriding sense
of anxiety and danger
and our HPA axis is on overdrive,
but we're noticing any indication,
including microaggressions,
that could contribute
or could support our feelings
instead of letting our feelings
be reactions to facts.
We are finding facts
to support our feelings.
It's a small difference.
It seems like a semantic difference,
but it makes a big difference
in the long run.
Focusing on threats
prevents noticing the safety features
or threat freeness of an environment.
You could be looking around,
and if you are hypervigilant,
then you may be noticing,
you know, the person that comes in
the door that has their hoodie on still.
You may notice, you know,
different sources of threat,
but you may fail to notice
the hundred other people
in the restaurant
that are pleasantly eating.
You may fail to notice
the police officers
that are on lunch break over there
that could probably handle anything
that happened, you know,
that was not anticipated.
We tend to focus on the things
that are uncontrollable
and things that are threat-related
instead of looking and going,
well, what resources
do I have in this area?
And focusing on threat
increases intrusions
such as memories, intrusive thoughts,
and potentially nightmares.
If we're regularly focusing on threats,
then we are noticing
more negative things.
That is going to remind us
of situations in the past
where unpleasant things have happened.
And when we go to sleep,
some of that stuff is still
bouncing around in our mind,
which can trigger
having nightmares and night terrors.
In the metacognitive assessment,
questions that you might ask.
Over the past month,
what emotional, behavioral,
and physical symptoms have you noticed?
Okay, that's a pretty standard question.
Has any thought or situation
made you feel worse?
Okay, now we're getting to triggers.
What thought or feeling
did you have when that happened?
So if you had a thought
that made you feel worse
and then you had another thought that
I'm so frustrated
that I can't stop thinking about that,
you know, so a thought follows a thought.
Or if a situation happened
and maybe your best friend
didn't call you back
when they said they would,
or they canceled plans on you.
That situation happened
and you felt bad.
You felt you were wondering
if you were being rejected,
if they were unhappy with you,
maybe they were mad.
So what thought or feelings
did you have that followed that?
And it's probably not one thought,
probably not one feeling.
It was probably a cascade of things
and rumination and looking back
and double checking over,
you know, the past week or month
to see, okay, let me look
for sources of threat.
Let me look for something that I did
that may have made this person mad at me.
When you had that experience,
what happened to your thinking?
Did you dwell on things for how long?
Did you dwell on the fact
that the person canceled
dinner plans with you?
Did you try to,
what did you do to try to control
the way you felt?
You know, did you have a glass of wine?
Did you call another friend
and decide to go out anyway?
What is it that you did?
Did you try to change your thoughts?
If so, how?
What are the advantages
to worrying or ruminating?
If did you sit there
and just continue to worry over,
you know, is this person mad at me
or ruminate over the fact
that how dare they cancel?
What was the advantage to that?
Are there advantages to focusing
on your thoughts and feelings?
Were there advantages to focusing
on how you were feeling
and how you were reacting
and then getting mad at yourself
for reacting the way you were reacting?
In acceptance and commitment therapy,
he calls this dirty discomfort.
It's our reaction to our reaction.
So sometimes people will feel angry
and that's what he calls
clean discomfort.
And then they start feeling guilty
that they got angry.
And then they start feeling angry
at themselves for getting angry
and angry at themselves
for feeling guilty.
So all of these other feelings
start arising out
of the initial experience.
We want to ask the person,
are there advantages to focusing
on these feelings
and, you know, holding on to them
instead of asking yourself,
what is a different strategy I can use?
What do you think will happen
if you continue to feel
or think like this?
And how much control do you have
over your thoughts?
Helping people recognize
that just like feelings are natural,
they'll come in.
It's what you do with them.
You can feel an unpleasant feeling.
You can feel anger.
Anger tells us there might,
doesn't mean there is,
there might be a threat.
Check it out.
See if there is.
If there is, handle it.
If there isn't, ask yourself
what you need to do
to improve the next moment.
If you have a thought
that comes into your mind,
the same sort of thing.
Asking yourself,
just recognizing
just like a feeling happens,
a thought happens.
It pops in your mind, okay?
You have a reaction to that thought.
You may get angry.
You may feel guilty.
You may be like,
crap, this thing again.
Whatever you feel, you feel.
But at that point,
you radically accept it.
And then you say, okay,
what is the best course of action?
Thoughts will come and go.
We can't turn our brain off
and say, I can't have this thought.
But we can,
there are all kinds of strategies
we can use to address thought patterns.
Metacognitions and pain.
Metacognitions about pain
related cognition.
So our thoughts about
our pain related thoughts
have been linked to pain intensity,
disability, emotional distress,
and greater physical dysfunction.
Going back to those positive
and negative metacognitions.
Negative metacognitions include,
I cannot stop thinking about the pain.
I can't focus on anything else
because I'm being distracted by my pain.
Everything comes back to my pain.
So we're thinking about the pain constantly.
Positive metacognitions,
why would I want to focus on the pain?
I need to continue to focus on my pain
to ensure it doesn't get worse.
That way, as soon as it starts to get worse,
I can tell the doctor.
How effective is that?
And in helping you live the kind of life
that you want to live,
sitting there and looking for
minute changes in your pain,
that takes a lot of time and energy.
Is that how you want to
spend your time and energy?
Participants who reported
greater levels of emotional distress
also tended to endorse
stronger negative metacognitive beliefs.
Interestingly, they did some
neuroimaging on these same patients
and found that catastrophic thinking,
specifically ruminating about their pain,
activated the brain in similar ways
to an anxiety disorder.
So these thoughts about pain
and the uncontrollability of pain
and focusing on the losses
as a result of the pain
triggered those emotional centers
in the brain that are the same as anxiety.
So what does that say?
That tells me that our HPA axis,
when we're focusing on pain,
our HPA axis is ramping up.
It's preparing us to fight or flee.
Pain application.
So personal knowledge,
our ways of thinking
and personal abilities and limitations,
going back to mindfulness
with negative metacognitive beliefs,
the person may be saying,
I can't stop thinking about the pain.
I may be ruminating,
often thinking about the pain
and its negative impact on life.
So things we want to challenge
when somebody says,
I can't stop thinking about the pain.
Asking them,
what is the effect of that?
When you are constantly
thinking about the pain
and encouraging them to notice
times when they have done
something different,
when they have thought
about something different,
not necessarily specific things
about the pain,
but when they've thought about
something completely different,
like going to Disney World,
threat monitoring,
constantly looking for things
that will increase pain
and scanning for signs
of worsening pathology.
You know, that's one of those
metacognitive beliefs
that can be really exhausting.
So how much time do you need
to spend scanning
and maybe encouraging them
to have a trial
of only scanning periodically,
instead of scanning
all the time for pain
and constantly noticing
small changes in their pain,
noticing twice a day,
when they get up in the morning,
when they go to bed at night
or something,
and then gradually weaning
down from there.
Unhelpful reactions that backfire
with people in chronic pain.
If I go to sleep,
I'll wake up and I'll feel better.
I've heard a lot of patients
who have chronic migraines
may use this particular strategy.
And a lot of times they wake up
and they don't feel better.
And then they feel even more helpless
because they're like,
I don't know how to make it go away.
Or a few beers will help me relax
and stop thinking about it.
Well, a few beers
may help you relax a little bit,
but a lot of times it's not going to
change your cognitions at all.
So again, somebody tries a strategy
to try to help themselves feel better
and it didn't work.
Positive metacognitions.
Again, I must stay alert
to changes in my pain.
Task knowledge for pain.
How to use guided imagery.
This is a strategy we know works
for non-pharmacological
intervention for pain.
If we tell somebody,
let's use, you know,
try using guided imagery.
Well, that sounds great.
But what is their skill level with it?
And what is their confidence
that it will work?
They need to have both
in order for it to be effective.
They need to have confidence
in their abilities
and confidence in the intervention.
Cued progressive muscular relaxation,
stretching techniques,
and how to evaluate their ergonomics
for, you know, chairs and beds
and things that might be
contributing to their pain.
These are all potential tasks
or interventions that could help
with their pain.
But if they don't have the belief
that it'll work
or the confidence in their ability
to implement these things,
they're not going to really change
the metacognitive picture.
And strategic knowledge.
Advantages and disadvantages
and applicability of each strategy.
For example, stretching techniques
might be really helpful.
But if you are on the metro,
probably not going to be able
to get a mat out and lay down
and do stretching.
That's obviously an exaggerated example.
But the person needs to have knowledge
of what works for them
in which situation.
Ice and heat, for example.
A perfect example.
I will have pain sometimes in my neck.
I have TMJ.
I grind my teeth a lot.
And a lot of times doctors will say,
you know, put heat on it
to help relax the muscles.
Heat for me doesn't seem to do
nearly as well as ice.
And ice is my friend.
So from a strategic point of view,
I know that one of the ways
to address pain is ice or heat.
And I know the types of pain
for me strategically
that ice works better.
So I have confidence in my ability
to choose the right intervention
and that that intervention will work.
Let's apply it to depression.
When people are depressed,
they may have uncontrollable thoughts
or seemingly uncontrollable thoughts.
I can't stop thinking
about all the things I have no control over
and how unfair the world is.
Just I can't stop thinking about it.
And we really need to help them
focus on the word can't,
you know, not necessarily
each specific thought,
but the fact that they feel
like they can't control
their thoughts at all.
It's challenging, you know,
learning to tame that monkey mind
takes a lot of practice,
but encouraging them to chart,
to notice when they're able
to stop that thought,
even for five minutes,
even for 10 minutes,
or to switch their thinking
to something, to an alternative
for a minute, five minutes, 10 minutes
and get some relief,
encouraging them to start noticing
positive small changes,
incremental changes.
We are not going to go help
have somebody go from being a person
who gets bad news
and just ruminates on it for hours
or days to somebody
who doesn't do that at all overnight.
What I want them to be able to do
is to notice when they're starting
to ruminate and feel like
they have some strategies
where they can identify
their thoughts, recognize them,
and then choose whether to keep
holding on to those thoughts
and keep ruminating
or choose alternate strategies.
Rumination for a lot of people
with depression,
they focus on things outside
of their personal control,
which contributes to their feelings
of hopelessness and helplessness.
For threat monitoring,
they're constantly looking
for things that confirm
that negative mood bias.
They're depressed,
so they're noticing things
that are depressing.
They're noticing the ads on TV
for the animal shelter.
They're noticing the fact
that it's raining outside today.
They're noticing, you know,
all of the things
that confirm their mood
instead of noticing other things.
Unhelpful reactions that backfire.
If I go to sleep,
I'll wake up and feel better.
A few beers will help
make me feel better.
A lot of people turn to alcohol
and sleep.
And with depression,
sleeping typically throws
that circadian rhythm
further out of whack,
which contributes to more
low energy and apathy.
And alcohol, we know,
also messes with
those neurotransmitters
and can contribute to worse
anxiety and depression.
From a task knowledge perspective,
we can help people develop
a greater toolbox,
if you will,
to handle depression
so they feel like they're going in
forearmed, if you will.
We can help educate them
about the importance of nutrition,
sleep hygiene,
distress tolerance skills,
and backwards training,
backwards chaining, for example,
in order to address their depression.
And again, they need to
not just know these things in concept.
They need to be able to explain them,
to apply them and have confidence
that using these strategies
will help them feel better.
And that's where we come in
as therapists to help them
develop these skills,
rehearse them in session,
practice them between sessions,
and then process it
the following session.
Less than a third of patients
with depression actually recover.
And relapse rates
for those who do recover
are estimated to be 50%
after two years.
So even the ones that do recover,
50% of them have already relapsed.
In metacognitive therapy,
it's understood,
depression is understood
as a consequence
of perseveratory thinking styles,
especially rumination and worry.
70 to 80% of patients
who went through metacognitive therapy
for depression
were recovered at post-treatment
and six-month follow-up.
So they hadn't gone out
for the full two years,
they had gone out for six months,
and people were still
maintaining their gains.
Interestingly, the treatment
was also associated
with a large reduction
in interpersonal problems.
So the question is why?
And when you think about it,
it really makes sense.
When you take somebody
out of that negative mindset,
constantly worrying,
constantly scanning for threats,
and in an apathetic
or dysphoric mood,
then they are probably going
to want to engage
with other people.
There's probably going
to be less withdrawal.
There's probably going
to be more positive
interpersonal interactions.
So yeah, it totally makes sense
that when somebody
starts feeling better,
it'll often have positive effects
on their relationships.
Some more examples.
When Sally fails at something,
she tends to ruminate on it.
She may focus
on those uncontrollable thoughts.
She thinks that she is a failure.
She thinks that nobody's
going to like her.
She thinks that she's
going to get fired.
She starts having
all of these thoughts
that just start
bombarding her brain.
One of the techniques
in dialectical behavior therapy,
as most of you
are probably aware,
is distress tolerance.
And one of the benefits
of distress tolerance
is helping people
switch their thoughts,
helping people start
thinking about something else.
So these thoughts
that keep bombarding them,
instead of noticing them
and hooking on to them
and nurturing them,
you're saying, yeah,
you know, that all that
stuff can go on over there.
I'm going to focus over here.
I'm going to focus on activities,
comparisons, contributing,
CC, emotions, the opposite.
Help me.
I can never do the
acronym in my own head.
Pushing away positive thoughts
and sensations
that can help you
quit thinking about
these thoughts that help
can help just chain,
move your attention,
turn your attention,
not address,
not addressing a particular thought,
but just completely
turning your attention
away from that worry
and threat rumination.
When John gets into a fight
with his partner,
he tends to ruminate on it.
We've probably had
clients like this.
The uncontrollability
of his thoughts,
wondering what's
going to happen,
getting angry that his partner
didn't see things
the way he did,
whatever it is.
With rumination,
we want to ask him,
what does he think about,
you know,
after they get into a fight?
Tell me what types of things
you were thinking about.
What types of things
do you tell yourself?
And let's listen to that
dialogue for a few minutes.
And then let's try to
characterize that dialogue.
Maybe it's an abandonment dialogue.
Maybe it is overgeneralization.
There are a lot of different
dialogues that we can have.
And our automatic beliefs,
you know, we can categorize
into those different kind of
bins, if you will.
So we want to look at those bins.
Those are the metacognitions,
abandonment, failure, loss,
that we want to evaluate
and help John recognize
this thinking style that he has
and where it's coming from.
If he has abandonment issues,
you know, from the past,
then when they get into a fight,
he may fear that this person
is going to abandon him as well.
And that may trigger
those ruminative,
ruminatory, whatever,
that may trigger a lot of rumination.
And we want him to recognize
how it makes sense in a certain way,
where this is coming from,
if we can identify it,
what the effects are,
how does this benefit you
to ruminate on
the possibility of abandonment?
What would be an alternate strategy
you could use?
You could use for your energy
instead of ruminating on,
you know, all the reasons
this person might abandon you
or how your life will be over
if this person abandons you.
What could you focus
your energy on doing
that might help improve
the next moment
and might help you improve
your relationship with that person?
Learned helplessness can also
be a metacognitive target.
When people have a sense
of learned helplessness,
they focus on the uncontrollability.
They may tell themselves things like,
no matter what I do,
the thoughts keep coming back
or the situation keeps reoccurring.
Well, that could be true.
However, does focusing on it
change the situation?
When I lived in Florida,
no matter what I did,
occasionally we'd have
a hurricane come through
and there was nothing
I could do about it.
Did sitting there worrying
about whether the hurricane
was going to hit
every time a hurricane
was headed towards Florida,
did that do any good?
Did that help me in any sort of way?
And the answer is no.
You know, I can say for me,
the answer was no.
We had our preparations in place.
We had all of our extra supplies.
You know, sitting there
and continuing to worry
did no good.
So recognizing that ruminating
on things that I had no control over
was not a good use of energy.
Focusing on all the things I tried
and in the past and have failed at
and the continuing presence
of the threat, you know,
well, getting a hurricane to turn
doesn't really help.
There's not much you can do there.
But rumination, coping
with different situations,
making sure that you have a plan
is going to be helpful
in certain situations
for the uncontrollable.
Threat awareness.
We've learned helplessness.
People often feel like everywhere
I turn, something bad is waiting.
Instead of confronting the content
and say, let's talk about
every bad thing you see,
evaluate the utility
of these beliefs.
Yes, there are bad things.
There are really crappy things
going on in the world.
All the time.
And I can focus on those.
But is that going to do me any good?
Is my worrying about it
going to change those events?
There was unfortunately
another mass shooting yesterday.
Does my worrying about
mass shootings do any good?
Does my ruminating
and perseverating on the fact
that there was a mass shooting,
does it change the fact
that it happened?
No.
Does it help me be any more prepared?
No.
So what is a better use of my energy?
50% of people at risk
in an at-risk mental state or arms
often engage in 30 hours or less
of structured activity per week
and are considered to be socially disabled.
Negative beliefs about
the uncontrollability of thoughts
and danger was found to predict
reductions in structured activity
through withdrawal and helplessness.
When people feel like
the world is dangerous,
their thoughts are dangerous,
they can't control anything,
they tend to withdraw,
not try, stay in their comfort zone.
Interestingly though, in this study,
age was found to significantly
predict social functioning
with younger people
having poorer social functioning
than older people.
So younger people had a less tolerance
for the distress,
which is a target or a benchmark
that we can work on for prevention,
helping people develop more
distress-tolerant cognitive strategies.
Individuals with good metacognition
are aware of fluctuations
in their task performance
and appropriately modulate
their confidence level.
They may start doing something,
they think they've got it,
and they start doing something
and they're like, crap,
I don't know what I'm doing here
or this isn't working.
And they can figure out at that point,
guess I better switch
and try a different strategy.
However, people with poor metacognition
don't recognize that
and they'll continue to keep trying to do it
even though they're not doing it correctly
or not doing it effectively.
People can have millions
of automatic cognitive distortions,
it just, it happens.
Addressing each one of these
may not be possible.
You can do ABC worksheets
till you're blue in the face.
But with metacognitive therapy,
instead of looking at
each individual cognitive distortion,
you're looking at themes
or modes of thinking.
Becoming aware of thought patterns,
their function, their usefulness,
and alternatives
are what underlie metacognitive therapy.
Metacognitive therapy moves
from addressing the content of thoughts,
the what is being thought,
to the function of those thoughts.
Why are these thoughts occurring
and are they helpful?
Okay, so I hope that made sense.
I know it was a big paradigm shift
to really get away from the content of thoughts
to thinking about just in general.
You know, are you having
a negative approach to your thinking?
Are you having, using overgeneralization?
A lot of people use
certain cognitive distortions
as a thinking style.
They overgeneralize most things
and it's important to help them see
that they're using that
or they're using a very external locus of control
or a very internal locus of control
to help them identify or characterize
helpful and unhelpful thought patterns for them.
There is a book on metacognitive therapy.
You can go on books.google.com
and take a look at that
to get a little bit more information.
They only have like 30 pages
that are available on Google Books.
There are several studies on PubMed,
most of which I link to in this presentation.
They don't get too far into the meat and potatoes
of actually how to do it.
They just talk about its effectiveness.
So if you're really interested in MCT,
check out that book.
I also have a couple of short videos
that'll be out on the website,
hopefully before the end of the week
that use some metacognitive strategies more practically
and provide you some activities
that you can use in individual or group therapy.
So keep a lookout on our YouTube channel
for those videos to be released
and I will see you on Tuesday.
Between writing notes, filing insurance claims
and scheduling with clients,
it can be hard to stay organized.
That's why I recommend TherapyNotes.
Their easy to use platform
lets you manage your practice securely and efficiently.
Visit therapynotes.com
to get two free months of TherapyNotes
by just using the promo code CEU
when you sign up for a free trial at therapynotes.com.
If this podcast helps you help your clients or yourself,
please support us by purchasing your CEUs
at allceus.com
or getting your agency to sponsor an episode.
A direct link to the on-demand CEUs for this podcast
is at allceus.com slash podcast CEUs.
That's allceus.com slash podcast CEUs.
To sponsor an episode of Counselor Toolbox
and reach over 50,000 clinicians per week,
go to allceus.com slash sponsor.
Thank you.