What's Gone Wrong For Conte At Spurs? | Explained

Football Daily
97 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 21, 2023
We may not yet be in the second half of the season thanks to the World Cup's explosion of
the football calendar, but no matter how you look at it, the view for Tottenham Hotspur is clear.
This is not where they're expected to be right now.
Of course, the Lily Whites are far from dead and buried. At the time of writing they're in fifth,
just one or two results away from pipping Man United or even a Newcastle having an all-timer
of a season to a spot in the Champions League. And their squad still compares favourably to
with World Cup winner Romero in the backline, a raft of competent ball winners in midfield
and attacking options of Kane, Son, Kulosevsky and Richarlison,
the best selection the team has enjoyed since the heyday under Pochettino.
But even with a sympathetic perspective, there's no avoiding the truth that this
was meant to be a much better year for Spurs, with some even tipping them for a title charge.
And their failure to consolidate their spot in the top four as predicted,
with only five of the 23 BBC pundits guessing they'd finish lower than third back in August,
has been soured further by the storming form of North London rivals Arsenal,
who have leapfrogged them handsomely in a matter of months.
Throw in Harry Kane's sparkling contribution with his 15 league goals,
making him the only Premier League player in touching distance of Erling Haaland,
and the drop-off feels even less explicable.
So why has the team not kicked on after pipping the Gunners to top four last term?
Why has serial winner Kante not got his team winning serially?
And why does Spurs go behind in seemingly every game they play?
On today's FD Explained, what has gone wrong with Antonio Kante's Tottenham?
If one man deserves no criticism at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium right now,
as so often over the last decade, that man is Harry Kane.
Despite what rival fans might like to claim, for the first time in his senior career,
Kane is a one-man band in 22-23, with no one in the squad contributing more than four league goals
and in particular, strike partner Heung-Min Son is starting to show signs of wear,
a concern given his contract was extended to 2025 just a year and a half ago.
Don't be fooled, it was predictable that Son would drop off.
Though two-footed and skillful, it's his pace and power which have made him one of the best
wide forwards in world football over the last half-decade,
and he's played over 3,000 league minutes in the last two campaigns,
missed just 26 of the last 246 available Premier League matches and turned 30 in July.
All the ingredients for a rapid downturn.
But six goal involvements in 16 appearances is still surprisingly awful stuff,
with his xG dropping from 0.7 to 0.5,
touches in the box falling from 4.3 to 3.1 and dribbles declining in both number and success rate.
A resurgence is possible, but as it currently stands,
the Kane-Son double act has become a solo performance.
That might not matter too much if Richarlison or more importantly,
Dejan Kulesevski could stay fit.
The Swedes match Son's goal and assist output in roughly half the number of minutes,
ranks first in the side for chances created for shot-creating actions
and narrowly second to Perisic for passes into the penalty area,
conjuring danger whenever he gets on the ball.
Son's drop by itself explains almost all of Tottenham's attacking slump from 1.7 xG per 90 to 1.5,
and that's largely where games have been lost.
A massive five of them to date, nearly a third of the Lillooites' total matches.
However, the defence has question marks too,
or at least the manner in which the team defends.
Believe it or not, by expected goals,
Tottenham are actually better on the back end this campaign than last,
going from allowing 1.2 a match to 1.1.
But there are factors that go beyond those raw numbers.
Last year Spurs allowed 12.9 shots per game,
which already wasn't great, ranking just 8th in the division.
But this year matters have seriously deteriorated,
with Conte's men giving up a whopping 14.3 shots per game
more than every Premier League club except for Everton, Brentford and Bournemouth.
They do a good job limiting the quality of those attempts,
with a second lowest shot quality against after Newcastle.
But nonetheless, if you give your opponents over 14 chances to score a game,
quite often players in the best league in the world are going to stick them in the net.
Which is why good teams simply do not give up this many shots,
no matter how bad those shots are.
That perhaps explains why Spurs have spent 30% of their game time trailing this season,
7th most in the Prem and 6 times more than Arsenal.
And when your attack has declined, getting out of that hole is that much tougher.
A big part of these awful shot stats is an incredibly conservative game plan,
which often sees all 11 men behind the ball.
Using Twitter user atmarkrstats' numbers for field tilt,
which indicates how often a team gets touches in the final third versus their opponent,
Tottenham rank 11th in the Prem, the opposition generally dominating territory.
And similarly their defensive line is also slightly deeper than average,
normally taking up a position about as high upfield as West Ham's.
These stats might be new to you, but the top three sides in field tilt
are City, Arsenal and Liverpool,
while the three highest defensive lines belong to City, Arsenal and Newcastle.
These things don't necessarily make you a good side,
but they are decent indicators of being a strong one,
as are high turnovers, the number of times you win possession in the opposition third.
By that metric, the Spurs are second bottom.
So it's pretty clear that Conte has his work cut out
if he truly wants to remain at Tottenham in the long term.
But the Italian has also shown his customary willingness
to complain about the support he's received,
and while Spurs have spent €231m since he took over,
he might have grounds to be disgruntled.
Constantly harring and firing the belief that the next guy will paper over every crack
is a recipe for disaster,
and as fans made clear during the club's 2-0 home loss to Aston Villa on January 1st,
chairman Daniel Levy also bears responsibility for Tottenham's inability to kick on.
The businessman did a phenomenal job in turning Spurs from a joke into a superclub,
adding a £50m training ground to its assets,
converting the century-old 36,000-seat White Hart Lane into a world-class 62,000-seat venue,
and growing the side's revenue from £133m in 2009 to £521m 10 years later.
Work which carried Spurs to second in the league,
and a Champions League final at their peak,
and put them in position to hire a world-class coach like Conte in the first place.
But while Levy has shown his skill in getting Tottenham into the highest echelon of the sport,
he hasn't taken the necessary steps to give the club the chance to edge out its rivals
and start winning serious trophies.
Before the appointment of Fabio Perattici as Football Director in 2021,
the club asked technical performance director Steve Hitchen to conduct a review of the club's
structure, only for Hitchen himself to depart shortly after.
And while much press coverage focused on the efficient way Perattici set about reshaping the
club, it's alarming that it took until 2021 for Spurs to revamp their recruitment and
development departments, as well as refining the pipeline from academy to senior squad.
And even now it's unclear who has the power to do what.
Conte critics have pointed out that this season's slide took place after a €170 million
summer transfer spree, but at least part of that money was spent on Jed Spence,
without much input from Conte or Perattici, with the coach labelling the move a club signing.
This slowness to address backroom issues might have deeper roots.
The Athletic reported last February that ownership company Eniq might be contemplating a sale in the
long term, which could explain why the focus seems to be on commercial concerns rather than
analytics or sports science.
Compare this muddled structure to Man City's exemplary system, or even Arsenal's setup,
recovering from a serious misstep post-Benga, and Tottenham clearly have catching up to do,
no matter who is in the dugout.
The question is whether they can fix things up on the fly with Conte and
only Kane holding the team together through a period of turmoil,
or whether they'll need to start again, with the manager more used to limited resources
and a patient building process, while hoping they can identify someone capable of filling
the England captain's shoes as he pushes into his 30s.
One way or another, Tottenham have some tough decisions to make,
and despite what some people would have you believe, the manager's future is only one of them.
