What's Wrong with Arsenal? the Kai Havertz Dilemma FT @matissearmani

Deluded Gooner
9 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 19, 2023
But I think we're personally a bit stronger on the right hand side.
I know the goal ultimately came from Martinelli and against the City game,
Martinelli coming on kind of changed the trajectory of the game for us
with all the other subs.
So I think that is quite interesting, if I'm completely honest with you.
What do you make of Kai Havertz in an Arsenal shirt?
Because it is the Kai Havertz derby.
Me personally, you know, we're at where we're at in it.
He will have my support as long as you're an Arsenal player.
It does feel like a bit of karma, because as you know, he was a player
that whenever me and you were battling, first to call him dry, shy,
all of these sort of things, I can't see it in it.
Like, I can't see it.
He's one of those weird ones where you've got ability.
You're a decent player.
I do think you're scapegoated, but I can't see it.
I can't see it right now.
The left side is eight row.
I know you've performed as a false nine, but at the end of the day,
as you would have known, seeing him for a year as a false nine,
the end of the day, you've got to finish your dinner in it.
Like I hear it, physical play, hold up play, link up play, lovely assist against City.
But whether you're a false nine, a target man, a poacher,
the pool's got to be in the back of the net.
And I just feel with Kai Havertz now, even though I'm not advocating
scapegoating him, but you're like, what, 25, 24,
you know, coming into Arsenal's team, you're a big dog.
You're basically Tiago Silva in terms of experience, really.
You know, you're of the level,
in my opinion, of Gabriel Jesus, Zinchenko, to a degree,
Odegaard at the point of you walking in.
You've been that young G that needs to inspire the youngest sort of thing.
So what have you made of Kai Havertz?
Is it a thing where it's the same man in a different shirt?
Yeah, it is, bro.
Unfortunately, I'd love to go to sprinkle some
some extra confetti on it, but there is no difference.
Like, it's another player.
I was a big Kai Havertz supporter when he came in.
He was probably my favourite signing in terms of the attackers.
I didn't want Ziyech.
I wasn't 100% sold on Werner because of the style of his play
and the way that he scored his goals in Germany
as a comparison to what we face in the low blocks.
And then the lack of physicality as well, which was the difference
between him and Lukaku, even though Lukaku was a counter-attacking striker.
Lukaku had the physicality.
He could win the headers and the crosses come in, etc.
Werner was just weak.
And he said it himself, like he couldn't handle it.
That's why you didn't allow him, because he just came out with the pressure
and all these things. He just done the victim thing.
You're not like, well, allow him.
It's very hard to go up against somebody who's already told you they can't hack it.
Yeah, like you just want to allow him, like you don't want to come across as a bully.
Him and Lukaku is a complete difference in terms of personality.
Like, do you know what I mean?
And one was double the money and double the wages.
But in terms of Kai, I actually thought Kai was going to back Lukaku.
And I thought, yeah, this guy is in and out.
It's not a high line thing.
It's all about his technical ability and his ability to pass
and clip the ball into these channels.
And, you know, I just thought he's a technical player.
And he's wanted by Madrid.
And, you know, it's not just us and we all see it.
So when he comes in and it's like what what annoyed me more about
Havertz was not necessarily his performances, it's mentally.
It never seemed to click for him that he was not playing well enough.
Like at least it didn't come off that way.
It always felt like Havertz was just going to play in his own way, his own time.
And that was it.
It was like it's Kai Havertz's time or it's nothing.
Do you know what I mean?
It's like, where's your where's your kind of like
like kind of get up and go attitude of like urgency, urgency, like move through.
Like you are a bona fide flop at this current moment to get the Champions League goal.
Because when people talk about that, they say, oh, he's won us the Champions League.
I don't believe in that.
I believe in the team.
It was very much a team performance.
It was a team game.
There's 11 players out there.
He's the poster boy, but I'm sure there was some clearances
and whatever in that final that the game is not going the way it's supposed to go if they don't do that.
If he was Ronaldo for Real Madrid, fair enough.
You won us the Champions League, but you wasn't, bro.
Do you know what I mean?
Like, you need to remember that Rüdiger blocked Foden's shot.
You need to remember that we had the best defensive record
in the knockouts in Champions League history with Thiago Silva, with Christensen, with Rüdiger.
The guys that saved us multiple times and allowed,
funnily enough, allowed for people like Kai Havertz, like Pulisic to miss chances
repeatedly, knockout game after knockout game.
They missed so many chances against Real Madrid at the Bernabeu.
We should have easily been...
They should have cost us, really.
But because the defence stood strong and kept these clean sheets
and stopped these goals from going in and were just on record
one of the best defences in Champions League knockout history,
on record, forget individuals, these guys were allowed to get their goal.
And especially Thiago Silva, man.
I don't want Chelsea to win Champions League.
I was happy for him because obviously, you know, I'm biased to Brazilians.
And I just like the way Thiago handles himself.
And obviously, for him and Tommy Tuchel,
they bounced back from the disappointment at that point against PSG.
And they were both kind of harshly done by really, more so Tuchel when that happened.
Yeah, these guys were...
Yeah, a hundred percent.
These guys were allowed to miss their...
I mean, Kante was just ridiculous, bro.
And N'Golo as well.
You know, if you want to talk about who won us the Champions League,
you're better off saying Kante before saying Kai Havertz, do you know what I mean?
That guy picked up like four man in the matches in a row.
So, yeah, there's a lot of lack of clarity on that one.
But he played his part, he contributed, which is why I'll never have heat for him.
Like, I won't.
I want him to leave.
So, I am happy for the money.
I'm happy for his exit.
I'm happy to have him off the books.
I'm happy to have Paul Palmer in instead.
Like, I'm not, I don't wish he stayed.
I don't have any kind of, like, ill will or anything towards him because I'm happy.
So, I think for me, he's just what he was before,
which is just a player that is unfortunately very underwhelming,
has a lot of talent to unlock, but doesn't have any outstanding attribute.
No one can say he's a brilliant passer.
No one can say he's a brilliant dribbler, a brilliant shooter,
even a brilliant header of the ball for how tall he is.
You know, he doesn't have...
Crosser, nothing, bro.
Nothing stands out.
It's an half-decent movement, but it's like, it kind of goes back to what you said about
wanting the ball and wanting it.
And I do feel a bit sorry for Kai Havertz.
I think his languid movement and the fact that in the prem, he's not like a Gallagher,
for example, or Roy Keane.
He's not going to fly into tackles.
That's a somewhat angle to target him.
But he's one of these guys that can do a bit of everything.
But, like, what are you?
Like, as someone that watched him, like, what is his best position?
Because at Arsenal, it seems Arteta is fixated on making you a left-sided eight.
I say that.
Maybe it's just a City thing,
but he's played as a false nine against City and it's worked all right.
I'm not really convinced on consistently playing as a false nine.
I'm not currently convinced on you cutting the mustard as a left-sided eight.
The luxury I'll give you is that what you said with the managers,
is that they know more than football than me.
I'm hopeful there's an upturn in performances.
But at the end of the day, bro, there's got to be questions.
And it looks like 65 million could have been better spelt elsewhere.
So what's the best position then?
All right.
It definitely could have been spelt better elsewhere.
You look at Sobota.
A hundred percent, bro.
Like, Maddison, like, Maddison, bro.
Even the youth that can't even stay fit for you lot,
Lavia, that could have been part of his little bro or something like that.
Even Kovacic, you really are duly, like, City are the only ones,
even though Kovacic ain't done much, out of the three boys that went,
what, Arsenal, City and United, you know, I always say I like Kovacic.
I would have done with the Kovacic thing.
But the only luxury we have, Art, is Arteta, you know more about football than me.
You have shown me that you can make mistakes,
but I trust you because I like you as a manager.
When we signed Timba, I was like, cool.
Kai Havertz is like, are you sure about this, big bro?
We're in the Champions League.
We're trying to get closer to City.
I see how the other three, in their own ways, gets us closer to City.
Kai Havertz, I don't know, because I'll be honest,
Arteta, it looks like Captain Sabrehole.
It worked with Odegaard, you know, so by us, won an FA Cup.
It kind of worked to a degree with Granit Xhaka.
It don't mean you're Jesus and everything can happen, really.
So Kai Havertz, he looks a bit shaky.
For me, his best position, I said it when he signed, was Odegaard's position.
And you're not better than Odegaard, so you can't play there.
It's not possible.
That's the captain, he's proven, he's put up the stats from last year
in terms of, you know, one of the best goal-scoring midfielder seasons ever on record,
especially with no penalties.
You are not touching that position.
So then when I see Arsenal fans online saying,
oh, but he can...
We've figured it out, he's a false nine.
You are going through the very same...
Yeah, yeah, you might have had these conversations, but I don't participate.
You're going through the very same trauma that we went through.
Oh, he's a striker.
No, no, no, no, wait, wait, wait, wait.
He's a second striker.
No, no, he's a ten.
No, guys, he's an eight off the right half space.
No, he's a winger.
And this is where it starts to get techy.
And Arsenal fans, they don't even realise that they're in it.
Some of them, you know, but some of them don't even realise yet that they're doing it.
But they'll start to clock it soon.
Right now, it's early days, it's hope.
I get it.
I've had it with every signing I give a year.
So I'm not blaming Arsenal fans.
The only thing I will say is this guy's been kicking ball in the Premier League for three years, up close.
This is where, that's where it kind of runs out, bro.
If he was coming straight from Bayer Leverkusen, cool, go to the comps.
Enjoy those comps.
Take those comps in.
It's acclimatising to the league.
It's adapting.
It's getting used to England.
It's all these things.
But he's not doing that.
He's been in London, bro.
He's, he's, he hasn't even moved house.
This guy has been in the city.
This is it.
You've probably got an extra half an hour extended on your commute in the day.
Exactly, bro.
Just got a new fuma deal as well.
So you better get some score.
If there's some, if there's some traffic on the North Circular, this is all you,
this is all you've had to adapt to.
That's it, bro.
You are literally at home.
You've been here for free as you know the league.
There's no excuse.
So the only thing is getting used to the system.
But he's not playing where those Bayer Leverkusen comps have articulated that he will be.
Everybody's looking at the Leverkusen comps.
This is what we're getting.
He plays in the right half space over there a lot of the time.
Now, the reason why I'm not buying this striker hype is because A, he was playing striker for us.
He didn't take his chances.
He missed the most big chances last season.
He's not clinical.
Why do you spend £65 million on a striker that is playing false nine the same way Jesus does,
but doesn't do anything as good as Jesus?
Doesn't dribble, doesn't hold up, doesn't finish.
The only consistency is they both can't really, they're not really clinical.
But again, Jesus will get you 11 goals regardless of that.
I don't know.
Exactly.
So why would you sign a striker that's going to, that's going to play the striker role the
when really the only thing to do was to get an alternative to Jesus who bangs in goals
and goes the other way.
Havertz doesn't do that.
So even that doesn't make sense.
So now you've got a £65 million player.
Best position in my opinion is over guards because that's where he can shift onto his
left foot, open up his body, play those passes that we saw at Leverkusen,
make those, those little reverse balls.
Take those shots for Germany on the edge of the D cutting in West.
People are trying to pretend like as if they don't know this information.
For Germany, this is where he scored those goals in the top corner,
cutting in left foot, stick it in top corner from the edge of the area,
cutting in on the left foot.
How's he going to cut in on his left foot playing on the left?
The left half space, please.
Somebody tell me how.
It's just not going to happen.
So he's never played over there.
£65 million to replace Xhaka and play in this position.
Even Smith-Rowe, where is Smith-Rowe?
I don't know what's happening.
I don't know if it's the fitness.
So before I go off on a tangent, I don't understand what's going on with Smith-Rowe
because I think Smith-Rowe is way better in the left half space than Havertz.
The last point I'll make is up here.
Up here.
This is where Havertz, for me, is also not good enough.
Like, when he was in poor form for Chelsea,
instead of publicly taking it in and being like,
yeah, I'm not playing very well,
this guy, as soon as he got his one shameless goal,
he was shushing the fans.
I was like, who are you shushing, bro?
You're meant to be this, like, we're building the team around you almost.
I was going to be golden, but you would see, you know,
comparisons, which I definitely don't agree with,
and they're still there within Arsenal fan base.
The only thing I can see is that they don't smile.
He hasn't got, he cannot talk to Mesut Ozil in terms of
intelligence, maybe slightly, in fact, not even movement.
I do like Havertz's movement, but you can't talk to Ozil about movement.
I was just watching Ozil for Mourinho's Real Madrid with Pacquiao and Ronaldo.
Yeah, you're not talking to him at all.
You don't even, you're not even, you're not even going to be able to see.
You're both left footed, that's it.
Yeah, that's it.
You're not even sitting in the same restaurant to get the same table.
And then it's like, the last thing is, so the mental side, I'm not really,
I'm not really, he's a confidence player.
I don't think you can be a confidence player and play like the way he's playing.
Because on the next thing, on top of that as well,
is the way he plays is nonchalant.
You need to be a baller to play like that.
I'm sorry, like, if you're going to play like that, you need to be Ozil.
If you're going to play at your own tempo and...
The Berber Toss, the Ozil, the Bird Challenge, them kind of brothers there.
That's, that's the guys, bro.
That's the guys.
You have to be one of those guys.
If you're not going to be one of those guys, then I'm sorry, you better run.
You better run.
You better get stuck in and get winning them duels and winning them challenges
and being that midfield three and work your arse off.
And if you are going to be that kind of player, then I'm sorry,
you could have bought a player like that for 20, 25 mil, not 65.
So there is no way out for this guy, but to absolutely shell out.
And I mean, ball out like Odegaard levels.
If he doesn't do that, he's a flop.
And for me, I don't think he will be able to do that
because he doesn't have the mentality that Odegaard has.
He doesn't have the ability that Odegaard has currently.
And he's playing in the wrong position because that position that he wants,
he needs to play in Odegaard's position to even stand a chance for him.
There, you said it.
There, you know, I just think, I think in general,
Odegaard can play where Havertz plays,
like disregarding Havertz as a thing for a sec.
I've been very passionate about Odegaard potentially moving back.
I think you'd rob him of definitely the goals he's been scoring and stuff.
But I think our team would get better tempo and impetus,
and it would be not quite Santi Cazorla towards the end of his Arsenal career.
But I think you'd get that from Odegaard in that role.
But then again, there's a lot of moving parts.
Arteta has shown that he will tweak the system and do things.
Is Kai Havertz, at the end of the day, he spent 65 million on the man.
He's probably on a four or five year deal.
So you probably have to try it at one point.
But would I advocate moving Kai Havertz into 10 and moving Odegaard around
and at the detriment of whatever Arteta,
what I can see Arteta demands of the system?
And crucially, what I don't know,
them inner fine workings, I don't think quite such.
I think right now he looks like an impact player as a sub.
I mean, Chelsea could be the perfect platform to quote unquote,
prove yourself to Arsenal fans and prove Chelsea fans wrong.
But even if you, you know,
you've got a brace or a hat trick in a game like that,
I don't feel, you know, we're going to, you know,
you're going to shut everybody up.
I think you made a great point about his language movement.
For me, it's a thing where I think we're in a dangerous
scenario with Havertz in that I think when you, you know,
when we talk about watching games again,
defensive metrics and all of these things, and we overdo it,
I think players in central midfield should be doing that anyways.
That's the only real thing I have appreciation for Havertz.
He will make tactical fouls.
He does muck in, but that only goes to a certain point.
I don't want to have to keep watching games again to speak about him.
And to be honest with Kai Havertz,
as much as I love what Mikel Arteta is doing,
I need to place a blame at the feet of Mikel Arteta.
You know more about football than me.
You've shown that with, you know,
bringing in Xhaka and certain other things.
So I'm prepared to trust in you, even if I don't necessarily trust it.
But as you said, you spent 65 odd million pounds.
I can't see how Havertz ultimately makes our team better.
Obviously, you know,
what doesn't help Havertz's case is the void that Xhaka's left.
Just as a man, Xhaka would always face up to the music.
And obviously Xhaka's last season,
he became somewhat of a goal-scoring midfielder.
So it'd be an interesting one really and truly.
