RANKING EVERY PREMIER LEAGUE LOAN PLAYER THIS SEASON! | #WNTT

Football Daily
97 followers
12 Video Views·Feb 23, 2023
Welcome back to Football Daily, where today, we're talking about loanees.
That's right, we're looking at every single Premier League loan player today.
Now, there's 30 of them, and we're going to be putting them into five different categories.
I've seen a lot of people online, a lot of football fans online,
either moaning or being quite joyous about their loan players.
The categories we've got, PermaSign, very obvious.
If they're absolutely smashing, this is a player that should be made permanent.
Playing well, too early.
It's probably going to feature a lot of January signings,
a lot of loan players signed late in the January window.
Somebody's playing badly and sack it off.
Quite frankly, this loan move is not working.
Let's start with Tottenham Hotspur, where somehow
Dejan Kulishevsky is still on loan.
He's a two year loan.
Now, this one obviously is going to be made a permanent signing.
It's an obligation to buy at the end of it.
And quite frankly, it's a sensational signing, isn't it?
However you look at it, he's had his injury problems this season.
He's only scored one Premier League goal since the opening day of the season.
But he is a sensational player.
Tottenham look a totally different team when he's not in the side, don't they?
I think without him in there, they lose all of the penetration down the right.
They lose all of the ball carrying ability.
They lose all of the chance creation.
And when Son's not playing well, it's a disaster.
So he is a definite PermaSign.
Pedro Porro obviously goes in that category, too,
because this is kind of an obligation to buy.
And there's a few players in this list that are obligations.
So Pedro Porro is a five million euro loan in January
with a 40 million euro obligation to buy in the summer.
I think they also wrote off 15 percent of the sell on fee
for Marcus Edwards at Sporting as well.
Tim Sherwood, though, opening day killed him.
I don't want to keep picking on the kid, but he needs to be relieved of his duties
at the moment.
I'm giving the benefit of the doubt because it's his debut.
But Pedro Porro is so bad.
It's unbelievable.
His positioning is absolutely disgusting.
I mean, Barnes and Madison have destroyed him down the left hand side.
Now, I'm not with Tim on this one.
Surely he's got to give him more time than 90 minutes on his debut against Leicester.
I think Porro is going to be a really good signing.
He's still very young.
Give him some time.
Next up, we have got Mr.
Flipflop himself on out Dan Juma, a man who did his medical Everton,
did his media Everton, did his interviews at Everton and then joined Tottenham.
I think it's too early to tell, quite frankly, though,
because, look, this player has a £27 million option to buy.
But do I see him featuring regularly enough
across the second half of the season for them to trigger that?
I'm not convinced.
Look, he's 26.
He's probably third choice, you would say, on that left hand side.
You know, if Son was to get injured, I think they'd play Richarlison there.
If Richarlison's get injured, then I think you'd see Dan Juma.
Do I see him having big enough impact in games
that he fits in as a starter in this side?
No. Therefore, I think they're probably more likely to take that £27 million,
put it into a bigger pot to sign a younger player
who can have more of an impact across a larger space of time.
So for me right now, too early.
But I will be surprised to see this one made permanent.
Next up, we've got Clemen Longley.
Hmm. Now, I feel like he's actually not playing that well.
I feel like he's I feel like he's playing badly, to be honest with you.
He's played quite a number of games.
I think it's 18 appearances for Tottenham this season.
But he's not really displaced Ben Davies in the back line, has he?
And I don't think Spurs' back line has been rock solid.
One of the best in the league.
You're looking at and thinking, how do you penetrate that back three?
And he still doesn't really nail down the starting berth there.
There's no option. There's no obligation.
Do I see them going back to Barcelona and saying,
we are definitely taking this player?
He's been magnificent for us.
No, it's not too early.
He's not playing well, but he's not been bad enough that you would say
this, cut it now, cancel it.
So I'm going to I'm going to put him in the playing badly category.
Chelsea, Joao Felix.
Woohoo. I mean, from Chelsea's perspective,
it has to be perma signed, doesn't it?
Because he looks like their best player.
It's quite jokes.
They've spent 600 million euros and their best player
is someone who's leaving in the summer.
But yeah, just a magnificent footballer.
He is so technically gifted, so silky.
Do I think they're going to be able to sign him on a permanent?
Is another question.
The answer is no.
I think that Atletico Madrid,
given that they managed to get him to sign a contract extension
before he went to Chelsea on loan, didn't put an option
and didn't get an obligation to buy.
And they'll be looking at Chelsea and going,
we spent 100 million euros on Madrid.
We've done 120 million euros on Enzo Fernandez.
Joao Felix is your best player.
He's still in 23.
He's got four years after his contract.
We'll have 200 million.
They are going to have Chelsea's pants down.
If Chelsea want to make this permanent,
I think it's nearly impossible for it to happen
unless the fee is just astronomical,
which, of course, I don't know about.
So never say never.
But if they can, they should.
Next up, we've got Dennis Zakaria.
And you know what?
I actually think Dennis Zakaria was playing well.
I actually think he was playing well before his injury.
He was, for me, Chelsea's best midfielder of the last month or so.
I think he finally developed into a player
that found his position in the team.
He was carrying the ball really well.
And then yet again, he got injured.
And this has really been the story of Dennis Zakaria's career, hasn't it?
Ever since that really bad knee problem at Mönchengladbach in 1920,
it's just been constant strains and issues and pulls and illnesses.
And I think that's probably the reason it won't be made permanent at Chelsea,
because the fee isn't small either.
Is it £30 million to make it permanent?
For me, it's not going to happen.
But I actually think he's playing OK.
And I don't think the loan move has been a disaster.
There's 30 players to get through.
So I'm going to have to fly through some of these and we can fly through Wolves.
Mateus Kunja, that is an obligation that is going to be made permanent,
of course, for about 40 mil, I think.
And Boubacar Traore has already been made permanent, I believe.
I actually think that Wolves have already done that deal.
So we can swing straight through Wolverhampton and on to the next club,
which is Manchester United, Wout Weghorst in here.
OK, where do we put Wout Weghorst?
Because for me, I think he's actually playing well.
And this is probably the bias in me because I love the big six foot six monster.
His goal scoring record hasn't been great at Manchester United,
but I don't think the service has been amazing for him.
Whenever he comes off, we seem to put more balls into the box,
which is a bit bizarre.
He is doing exactly what he was bought for, which is a facilitator role
for players like Marcus Rashford to get off.
I think Rashford looks a lot better with him in the side.
And, you know, it's been very cheap.
I don't think United are going to make it permanent.
And I don't think he's playing badly.
So playing well is the right category for me.
Marcel Sabitzer, I think probably too early.
We've only seen him play two games, two starts against Leeds,
and they aren't really in his best position.
You know, he's been playing in the Casemiro role because of Casemiro's ban.
I want to see him alongside Casemiro before I make any decision.
There's certainly signs there that he is an exceptional player.
Some of his passing ability,
long range and cross field and diagonal is absolutely sensational.
And he's definitely got a heart battling performance,
especially in the second game at Ellen Road.
But two starts is too early.
Likewise, I mean, Jack Butler just hasn't played a game, has he?
He's been brought in there really as the third choice goalkeeper.
So it is too early to tell.
Let's go to Connor Cody, who's a definite permanent signing.
£4.5 million option.
What were we all thinking when they put £4.5 million in here?
That feels so cheap now.
Now, I'm not saying Connor Cody is the best centre back in the league,
but under Sean Dyche, he's perfect for Sean Dyche.
He's going to be a leader in the team.
He's been one of Everton's better players this season.
That option to buy is criminally low.
At the other end of the spectrum, I think we may as well just sack this one off.
Ruben Vinagra, £37 million option to buy.
It ain't happening.
I don't see him as a Sean Dyche player.
I don't think he's going to play many games at all across the second half of the season.
He didn't play barely any games across the first half of the season.
Sack it off at this stage.
Let's go to Brighton with Levi Colwell,
and I think they should try and make this one a permanent signing.
Do I think they're going to be able to?
I actually think they might.
I don't think this is an impossible task,
given the volume of centre backs that Chelsea currently have at the club.
You know, they've bought Benoit Ballet-Chillet,
who, like Levi Colwell, is a left-footed, left-sided centre back.
Probably usurps him in that position.
Kalidou Koulibaly is there until 2026.
Thiago Silva signed a contract extension.
Wesley Pofana coming back.
Trevor Chaleber is still there.
Koukou Rea can play on a left-sided centre back role in a back three.
I think this might be a possible signing.
I don't think it's going to be cheap.
Probably more expensive than when, you know, AC Milan signed for K-1
for about £30 million, didn't they?
Mark Gehy went, I think, for a bit less than that, about £20 million.
I think if they can get Levi Colwell for like £35 million,
it's a brilliant bit of business for Brighton.
Still only 19.
I think he's played about 10 games this season.
Every time I've watched him, I've been really impressed.
This is a really nice fit.
Let's go to Fulham, where our resident cottager, Henry Hill,
informs me that he wants Manar Solomon kept.
Of course, he's had his injury problems, hasn't he?
But he has looked good, Solomon.
When he's been able to get on the field,
he just hasn't been able to get on the field loads.
Not a huge option to buy, though.
So he wants that move made permanent.
I think Dan James, you could almost sack it off at this stage.
It's just not worked.
Marco Silva prefers other wide options, doesn't he?
Very little impact at Leeds.
I think Kazawa, I think you could sack it off as well.
The wages are monumental coming from PSG.
It's he's been I mean, he's been OK.
He's not been terrible, but I think it's just the wages for me
that means that that went off.
And then Cedric Suarez has been there about two days.
Of course, that move took 16 years to get done from Arsenal.
It's too early.
Let's go to Nottingham Forest, where I'm sure they would love
to permanently sign Dean Henderson.
Do I see it happening?
No, I don't.
I think he's playing well, though.
He's playing really well.
And I know he's injured at the moment.
But I think if Forest could get that deal done, they would love to.
My issue is that I think Dean Henderson thinks he can play at a higher level.
He's a really good goalkeeper.
I think Manchester United might be willing to sell him in the summer,
given that, you know, he just hasn't really had a look in there, has he?
However, you know, teams like Tottenham potentially wanting a goalkeeper.
Are Leicester going to want a goalkeeper in the summer?
I think there are, yeah, levels above Forest that will want Dean Henderson.
Keylor Navas.
I mean, it's too early to say, isn't it?
Because we've not really seen him in a Forest shirt.
I would be surprised to see them make this one permanent,
given he's going to be on massive wages.
He's 36 years old.
And does he want to spend his career fizzling out in Nottingham?
I would be surprised.
This is a short term one, isn't it?
If we're all honest.
Next up, we've got René Lodi, who's one of the harder players to rank for me.
They've got a 30 million euro option, which seems quite expensive,
especially as he's under contract until 2026.
Atletico, his wages are not cheap.
He's playing OK.
He's not playing badly.
I wouldn't say he's absolutely smashing in that left back slot.
I wouldn't say sack it off.
Or would I?
I think at the end.
Do you know what? I think he's playing OK.
I think he's playing. I think he's playing OK.
I'm just going to put him in playing well.
Not sure where else to place René Lodi. Forest fans,
let me know where you would have placed him, because I'm a bit unsure on René Lodi.
Chris Wood, obviously too early to tell.
I'm intrigued to see how Cooper views him in this system,
because I think at their best, Forest front line, for me,
is Awniyi, Morgan Gibbs, White and Brennan Johnson.
Much more fluid, you know, much more pacey, much more direct.
Whereas Chris Wood, a little bit more of a hold up man,
a little bit more isolated, you would expect from a number nine.
Let's see how he gets on there. Ainsley Maitland-Niles.
I think this is probably one I would sack off.
Don't really think it's worked there.
Yet again, played too many positions.
I think it's just 10 appearances this season in a multitude of positions.
He's not been helped by the fact Southampton have been absolute garbagio.
So, yeah, I mean, he signed a contract extension at Arsenal until 2024,
at least, didn't he?
So he's going to have options in the summer, you'd think.
Arsenal will probably look to get some money for him.
Surely it's last chance to learn.
Brentford's Hamid Traore.
Now that one is an obligation that's going to be made permanent.
He's looked really exciting in the two appearances I've seen of him so far.
Mateusz Wienia couldn't get a look in at Roma.
He really couldn't get a look in at Roma.
The issue here, though, is, you know, it's too early to start with
because he's only just joined.
But the issue here is he's not going to join the club in the championship.
Like, it's not going to happen.
So if they go down, I think that one will be.
Jack Stephens at Bournemouth, he's just not really playing.
I think it's four appearances this season, three starts.
I think it's probably one to sack off.
I think Bournemouth have got better central defensive options
right now than Jack Stephens.
And he's got a contract with Southampton at Southampton until 2024.
So literally, he's just moving five minutes down the road, isn't it?
Weston McKennie, I actually think I'm going to put in playing well, you know.
In his three appearances, the two he gets matches tonight,
I think he's been pretty exceptional for Leeds.
Do I think they're going to be able to make that move permanent?
Pretty unconvinced.
You know, it's a 37 million euro option to buy.
It is not cheap.
I think part of the reason, a large part of the reason
probably that he joined the club in the first place
was because Jesse Marsh was there.
Jesse Marsh has now left the club.
If they go down, there's zero percent chance.
If they stay up and they get the right manager, you never know
because he has a really nice partnership with Tyler Adams in there.
They work really well together.
But the next managerial appointment, I can't stress this enough,
is so crucial for Leeds because there's so much talent in that team.
Weston McKennie is another one of them.
But unless they get it right, I can't see him wanting to stay.
Sambi Lukonga is obviously too early.
He is going to be a really interesting watch
across the second half of the season.
I think Sambi Lukonga, because when he was at Arsenal,
I think he was probably a step up too much for him.
I don't think the parte role that he was being utilised in is his ideal role.
So I'm interested to see how Patrick Vieira utilises him.
Is it going to be alongside a player like Cenk Dikure?
Is it going to be a backup to Cenk Dikure?
Is it a defensive midfielder?
Let's see. Let's wait and see.
But at the moment, it's far too early.
Same can be said of Kevin Sharder.
I haven't really seen enough of him.
And then we see Kenny, to be fair, Kenny Tete.
I think he's really lively when he's playing.
I really like this signing.
Playing very well.
Let's put him in there.
He has played very limited minutes.
You know, he also could easily go in the too early category.
But finally, Leicester have got a right winger.
That's an exciting signing.
Scored in his debut.
I like it. I have to say I like the Tete move.
It's quite a complicated transfer, though, because obviously Shakhtar,
he was allowed to leave to Lyon because of the problems with the war.
Then he's kind of gone back from Lyon, gone to Leicester.
It's all quite complicated.
I'm not sure what happens with the options or the obligations,
but I'm pretty sure Leicester have been tracking him for quite a long time.
Would like to make this one permanent.
He could be in any three of these categories, couldn't he?
Either way, it's a good signing.
So that was my list of Premier League loanees.
Let me know what you think of it in the comments below.
Obviously, if you are a fan of Forrest, I want to hear from you
about your loan signings.
If you enjoyed this video, hit the like button, hit subscribe.
Thanks very much for watching.
We'll see you later. Auf Wiedersehen.
