Ever get to an old hanger while climbing, clipped it, and wonder how strong it is? Bobby got his hands on recalled hangers, death hangers, niche hangers, discontinued hangers and we broke them all. A total of 27 tests. Some were old hangers that have never that had been installed and others that have been on the wall for 44 years. These include SMC Death hangers and recalled Leeper Hangers because they were so susceptible to SCC (stress crack corrosion) and could break under body weight. We have learned as a community that stainless steel hangers, made of thicker stock, are way better.
00:00 SMC Death Hangers 03:45 Metolius 1st stainless on market 05:01 Climbtech hangers burnt in house fire 06:37 Recalled leeper hanger 08:07 Cam Smith's SMC replicas 09:33 Moses Hanger 10:10 Mammut 10:51 Petzl Aluminum 12:03 Send us your stuff
You've been stoked all morning.
Welcome.
This is an episode I am super excited about.
We're going to be testing old, weird hangers, something I'm super interested
in, and I know a few of you are interested in it as well.
It's stuff you might come across on a climb.
It's not the stuff that's being put in anymore, but it makes you
wonder, is that going to hold me?
So what's the first one?
SMC death hangers.
I don't know if anybody actually died.
They were victim to fast corrosion, so they stopped making them.
This is one that I know for a fact was installed in 1978 and I took it off in
2022, so it was on the wall for 44 years.
This is one that has been sitting in somebody's closet.
Broke like a hanger.
There is a piece missing there.
Super consistent.
Very consistent.
Let's see what the new ones break at.
SMC death hanger, new old stock.
These have not been exposed to the elements.
That's exactly the same result as we've got on the other two.
Just in case you were thinking we were showing you the same footage over and over again.
This is a SMC hanger, not the death hanger.
They have a vertical logo and they are thicker and some variety of stainless steel.
This corrosion here is mostly from the bolt, which was bad, so I removed it.
Generally thicker material means stronger.
Three to four kilonewtons stronger than we were getting on SMC death hangers.
This has a vertical logo based on stuff we've broken before.
My guess is this is some type of stainless because we see very stretchy results.
I am very skeptical that this is stainless because it didn't stretch as much and a chunk
broke off like we were seeing on the SMC death.
It is slightly thicker.
The logo is a different orientation, but I do not think this is stainless.
Well, so that's our lowest result with these SMC hangers.
That stretched quite a lot, debating whether to test it again or not.
But I think this solved my problem for me because I can't easily get that out.
This is so narrow now, it's hard to clip stuff into, so I'm going to say it failed.
These, I believe, were the first readily commercially available stainless steel hanger.
These are Metolius.
I've always thought they were 304, though I don't know for sure.
There's a lot of these that I've removed that were on bolts that were just rusting out of the rock.
Do they make them anymore?
Metolius still makes hangers.
They're not exactly this.
Personally, absent any testing, I believe they're perfectly fine.
So I've been reusing them.
But we'll see after today.
Very bent out of shape like stainless.
Very little corrosion to cite being in the rock for 30 years, maybe, maybe more.
27.69 kilonewtons, which I believe is perfectly acceptable for a modern hanger.
These bolts went through my house fire when all my stuff burned.
These are Klimpek bolts, 304 stainless.
They were new.
Okay.
They'd just been through your fire.
Yeah.
They were sitting in my collection of gear, which I have salvaged a, like a five gallon bucket full of stuff that was new, that was going to go out on routes.
It's now rusting in a bucket.
It looks like the corrosion resistance, at least on the surface layer, has been damaged.
I am doubtful that the strength has been damaged by the heat.
Spots of the fire got to 1,800, 2,000 degrees because I had a silver melting, like the silver in my safe started melting.
In your fireproof safe.
In my fireproof safe.
Failure of the bolt that I'd already taken up a couple of times.
Ryan's going to find a stronger bolt.
Talk about a bolt buster.
Um, we're going to stop testing these until we can find a stronger bolt.
That's about the result we've seen before.
Concern is corrosion resistance.
This is a leaper hanger for sure, because it says leaper.
Many of them aren't marked, but they're exactly the same style.
Leaper issued a recall for these because they were corroding and failing fairly quickly.
These were the first commercially available or widely commercially available hanger.
You'll see these all over the place.
A climber just decided to make them and I mean, it was better than a beat on or any good intentions.
It just like at the time they didn't, they didn't know as much as I know now.
And now we use stainless on almost everything.
So if you watch our interview with Doug Robinson, uh, he talks about, uh, how neat it was to have leapers with quarter inch bolts and how that would bomber.
We don't think that today.
So this is one I removed.
These are from Chris Williams.
Fun fact about leaper hangers.
Unlike most hangers, uh, they are left-handed if you will, instead of right-handed.
These are hangers that our friend, Pam Smith sent to us.
He fabricates his own that uses on Alpine routes all over the world.
I believe he's put up some stuff in Mexico and Madagascar and he wants very light stuff because he's carrying it in for dates.
These ones are reproductions of the, uh, cam made of the SMC hangers.
This was an interesting result that I didn't expect.
I expected either the hanger or the bolt to break in it.
Oh, it, it, what?
No, I had a washer there and you can see what's left of it.
I'm learning more about washers than I thought I would.
Oh, it's just a really tiny bolt.
Yeah.
Stop breaking my bolts, Cam.
Apparently not breaking the bolt was too much to ask for.
So I believe that's a grade eight bolt.
I think that's a five sixteenths.
Um, and the hanger is stronger than that.
This is a Moses hanger.
Um, Moses makes a lot of aid gear, right?
Big wall gear, uh, hooks, rivet hangers.
Um, some of that specialty, big wall gear.
These are lightweight.
This aluminum?
No, it's stainless.
It's lightweight though.
Yeah.
Very small hole.
The price one's kind of high.
All right.
The bolt broke again.
Um, yeah, I mean, you can make your hanger as strong as you want, but if you don't make the hole big enough to fit a strong bolt in there, um, I don't know what to tell you.
These are labeled Mahmood.
Um, I don't know anything more about them than that.
I assume they're made by Mahmood, who makes, uh, lots of cool clothing and ropes and stuff.
Now they look very old.
They could be stainless.
They have marks here.
Like they came off of a bolt.
I believe, uh, Chris Williams sent these to us.
The way it broke leads me to believe it's probably not stainless.
Slightly different result.
These are some new old stock Petzl, uh, aluminum hangers, which I think are cool.
What's wrong with the aluminum hangers?
They are lighter for those who have to install them.
They experience weird corrosion when left out.
Is it because it's mixed with a steel or is it because it's left outside?
Um, you know, I'm not a metal,
metallurgists are super rare.
I've only seen these ones, so I've never seen one in the wild.
Um, and this is old enough to have a, uh, rating in kilograms versus kilonewtons.
Keep in mind that kilogram is a measurement of mass and kilonewtons is measurement of force.
Slightly over the converted MPS of 1800 kilogram.
It is interesting how many ways you can bend a piece of metal after punching two holes in it,
which is basically what a hanger is.
This is more or less a hanger that hasn't been bent yet.
It looks more or less like this when it is knocking off hangers.
This doesn't matter.
It's fine.
Wow.
Is it still fine, Ryan?
It is.
Wow.
Jingle bells over here.
We do have a thing on our website called send us your stuff.
You can submit what gear you have and send it to us in picture form.
And we'll tell you if that's something that would be interesting for a lot of people to see.
And then we could possibly break that.
Yeah.
Of course we don't have infinite time and resources, so I have to be selective about that.
If you like this style of video where we talk about each one, break it, and then talk about the next,
let me know in the comments.
If it's a thing that looks like this, please subscribe.
See you later.