In many respects, Renaissance artists such as Michelangelo and Raphael crafted the image of the creative genius that we still hold today. But if we allow ourselves to look more closely at the artistic practices of these central figures, we find a number of apparent contradictions. Rather than fonts of continuously new and original ideas, springing freely from their heads as we might have been led to imagine, we find that both artists borrowed or stole a great deal from each other, repeated themselves prodigiously, and collaborated widely. Taking examples from painting, architecture, and drawing, the lecture suggests how the works of Michelangelo and Raphael suggest a distinct model for aesthetic invention and exploration.
The Sydney J. Freedberg Lecture on Italian Art features distinguished scholars presenting original research. This annual lecture series offered by the National Gallery of Art began in 1997 and is named after the great specialist of Italian art Sydney J. Freedberg (1914–1997). Professor Freedberg earned his Ph.D. from Harvard University in 1940, where he taught for 29 years until he was appointed chief curator of the National Gallery of Art in 1983.
It's an honor and a delight to be speaking at my favorite museum in the United States.
I don't say that merely out of flattery, but in the years that I was teaching at Virginia,
I often came to Washington, not only for the pleasure of listening to colleagues at
Casper, now known as the Center, but also for just wandering the fantastic galleries here.
Today, I'm going to be speaking from a slightly different vantage point,
more that of a critic and a teacher. The opportunity to write criticism for the Wall
Street Journal fell into my lap in 2010, a couple of years after my first book had been published
on Michelangelo. When Eric Gibson of the Wall Street Journal wrote to me to see if I might
be able to review a small exhibit on Michelangelo drawings at the Muscarelle Museum in Williamsburg,
Virginia. I was teaching then in Charlottesville, just down the road, so of course I was glad to do
it. More opportunities came from that, and although I've always kept my day job, it's been
a consistent source of pleasure to keep up with the creative work that curators are doing in
museums around the country and abroad. Many of the ideas that I'll present today have emerged
from the experience of seeing important exhibitions devoted to Michelangelo and Raphael over this past
several years, just a few of which I'm highlighting here. Another unrelated opportunity came up in 2018
when I was invited to guest teach for a semester at Harvard in the Department of the History of Art
and Architecture. I've spent my entire career teaching at schools of architecture, and I love
it, but I was educated as an art historian, and I jumped at the chance to teach Renaissance painting
and sculpture as well. The course I designed, Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Raphael, forced me to think about
these artists in relation to one another in ways that the monographic exhibitions I'd been seeing
usually do not. If I'm interested in all three of these artists, why focus today on Michelangelo
and Raphael in particular? In part, they make an amusing pair because they're so often pitted
against each other, both within their own lifetimes and beyond. From all accounts, their personalities
were opposed, the charmer and the introvert, the secretive artist and the expert disseminator of
his art. Mazzari's Life of Raphael, which I'll refer to a couple times, seems written as a kind
of riposte to his life of Michelangelo, balancing his heroization of Michelangelo against his
judgment that Raphael was better for the cause of art, and specifically for his goal of creating a
systematic way of training good artists. I should add that although Leonardo is not my subject, he
is in the background of what I will say about both artists because he was such an important model.
With regard to my use of the word genius in the title, you may be asking yourself one of several
questions. Michelangelo is obviously a genius, but does she mean that Raphael is a genius too?
This is potentially a controversial question, but has possibly become less so since around 2020
to 21, the years in which a flurry of exhibitions celebrating or marking 500 years since Raphael's
early death in 1520 were met with general acclaim from critics and the public alike. Nonetheless,
it's interesting that while the term is regularly used for Leonardo and Michelangelo, both prolific
artists who also left many works unfinished and were in their own ways very eccentric,
it's rarely applied to Raphael. By all accounts, a charming and delightful personality,
extraordinarily productive, collaborative, Raphael may just have been too well adjusted
for us to count him in this category. I first became interested in the particular associations
people have with the idea of genius when working on my first book on Michelangelo. I found that a
surprising number of people, including many professionally trained art historians, casting
no aspersions to any in the audience, could not for the life of them remember from one moment to
the next if I was working on Michelangelo or Leonardo. How's your book on Leonardo coming?
I got asked more times than I could count to the point that it started to feel like
a significant phenomenon, not just a random occurrence. Even after the book came out and
gained a little bit of notice, I'd hear things like, I've heard good things about your book
on Leonardo. What was the category to which Leonardo and Michelangelo so obviously both
belonged such that the two became indistinguishable even to specialists? Italian men born roughly 500
years ago? Of course, the category to which they both belong is genius. I should really have my
next book on Raphael just to prove a point, because no one unfortunately makes that mistake
about Giuliano da Sangallo, and I doubt Raphael either would have caused the same confusion.
Raphael typically meets with much less immediate interest to Michelangelo or Leonardo, at least
prior to these recent exhibitions. Peter Scheldahl, the longtime and excellent New Yorker
critic who recently passed away, provided in his review of the Raphael show from 2004 a catalog of
the typical resistance to the Urbino artist, essentially characterizing his art as saccharine
and simpering, attitudes that I've frequently encountered among art historians outside the
Renaissance. Scheldahl writes in his typical wonderful prose, for me, Raphael's vision of
the beautiful is the sublime of the pretty, sheer comeliness to the nth power. His paintings lack
the element of reverent awe. That phrase of Scheldahl's was interesting because it corresponds
a little bit to what Italian critics would have called terabilità, that informs beauty. They're
about liking, albeit intense liking, rather than love. In this, Raphael was less a creator of the
Italian Renaissance than its definitive human creation, a demigod whose capacities rivaled
those of the divine. There would never again be anyone like Raphael, he says, because there would
never again be a fully developed, energetic, urbane culture coast on a tide of such complacent
oblong. Scheldahl's only hope for Raphael was if he'd lived longer. He said, he had it in him to
outgrow the simpering allure for which we are obliged to remember him. I won't focus any further
on Raphael's reception today, but I think it's worth mentioning as a kind of context for how we
consider them. What interests me more, and the reason I use the word paradox in the title, is
that several aspects of Raphael and Michelangelo's practice that I see would seem at least superficially
to be antithetical to the terms we associate with them in particular and with genius or highly
creative slash original artists generally. These techniques specifically are repetition, in some
cases self-citation, and imitation, or what we more typically call copying. What I want to suggest is
that understood and described correctly, rather than undercutting our perception of these artists,
it allows further insight into how it was possible at all for them to be as productive and
prolific as they were. So what it suggests is not what either of these artists were doing, but what
we've expected of them or how we've construed it. Let's start with Michelangelo. Among the fascinating
indices of Michelangelo's success is his ability to craft an idea of genius around himself in such
a persuasive manner that almost 500 years after his death, we still believe it. How did he do this?
He exercised an enormous amount of influence on Gagno Candivi's biography of him, which then had
an impact on Vasari's second edition of his Life of Michelangelo. Among the main themes that the
biography takes up is that Michelangelo was natural-born talent, not a schooled one, that he
never repeated a single line, and that he varied constantly. Michelangelo manipulated some of the
Fortunately, a few survive already start to contradict the narrative that Michelangelo
wants to forward. For example, demonstrating how he learned from important early Florentine
painters such as Masaccio, as well as Giotto. It's well known that Michelangelo was overwhelmingly
concerned with the human figure over the course of his life, to the exclusion of almost everything
else. What's less well examined or acknowledged is the extent to which he returned repeatedly to
particular figurative motifs, poses, and solutions. His contemporaries already recognized this.
Ludovico Dolce, for example, in his dialogue, L'Arentino, remarked that when you've seen one
Michelangelo, you've seen them all. Precise translation is, whoever has seen a single
figure by Michelangelo sees them all. But despite this recognition, Michelangelo was idolized in his
time, even in the context of a culture that prized variety. And it's the seeming contradiction,
which is part of my subject. I want us to distinguish between two related ideas.
There's singular focus, and then there's repetition. No one is denying that Michelangelo had
a singular focus on the human body. And you might imagine that if you focus on the human body for
65 years of a career, you're bound to repeat yourself. But what I'm talking about is a little
bit more specific. I want to argue that he reused specific poses again and again in his life with
relentless efficiency, using the same life drawings to generate figures for compositions of unrelated
subjects. The key to understanding Michelangelo's reuse of motifs was undoubtedly his store of
drawings. He had a rich personal archive that he turned to again and again. From a certain point
of view, nothing could be more conventional. This was the function of the medieval and
renaissance model book. But by the early 16th century, the expectations for artists had shifted
and novelty was expected. This is concisely illustrated through a story Vasari tells in
The Life of Perugino. Vasari recounts that Perugino's work was much criticized by younger
artists because he had made use of figures that he had used elsewhere in his work. They implied
that he'd been lazy. Perugino reportedly was baffled, saying that he had put in the works
a figure that you admired at other times and to which you gave infinite praise. If now they
displease you and you do not praise them, what can I do? You have to feel some empathy. But poor Perugino,
it seems, found himself caught out by shifting expectations. What he recounts is a working
process based on the model book. He had certain figures on the ready and reinserts them. The story
is fascinating because it shows that the first decades of the 16th century, expectations had
radically risen of painters. Conventional treatments of religious narratives that would
have been praiseworthy before were now ridiculed. It also suggests that the reuse of figures could
be judged variously. In this case, it elicited mockery. But in Michelangelo's case, despite
the comment that I made before, his critics are rarely as harsh. It seems that Michelangelo
was able to vary them enough. They seem to represent new figures or his repetition was
rarely recognized. In the case of the criticism that I mentioned, it's actually slightly different.
Not there's a repetition of a particular figure, but that the figures were all the same to start
with. Before considering how Michelangelo's critics and champions weighed in on this subject,
it's important to see how it worked. One way of seeing this is through one of its most famous
instances in the drawing of Tidius, a rare drawing made for a personal purpose of a gift
to Michelangelo's friend, Tommaso di Cavalieri. On its reverse, rotating the sheet, Michelangelo
found the contour of the risen Christ, which he used in two subsequent more finished drawings of
the same subject, once as an isolated figure and once surrounded by an amazed crowd. It was a kind
of accidental discovery on the page related to his habitual practice of rotating and turning over
the sheet, parallel in some ways to one that I found in my research on Michelangelo's architectural
drawings, his studies for the Medici Chapel. But Tidius' Christ transformation is notable
because it involves not only a rotated orientation, but a change in subject matter
from the mythological and erotic and personal to the sacred. The Tidius figure is himself
a rotated version of Haman, one of the more ambitious figural inventions of the Sistine
Ceiling. It's impressive in part from the point of view of life study shown here in red chalk.
Earlier generations, such as the Filipino Lippi, had often drawn their assistants puttering around
the studio in their underwear, whereas Michelangelo found some strapping man to hold an excruciating
pose long enough for him to capture the play of light and shadow over his whole body. Once recorded,
Michelangelo made ample use of the study in multiple compositions. The lunette of Haman
is interesting. It has other lessons in repetitive practices. The recently awoken figure to the right
is derived from the figure of Adam, but in a transformation reminiscent of a children's game,
he's given the head of God. These are good examples of the way in which the circumstances
of Michelangelo's reuse of figural types would have made it challenging for contemporaries,
unneeded by photography, to detect. Without photography, they would have had to rely on
visual memory or their own drawings. For example, when Michelangelo reuses the striking
pose of the figure of Haman, a pose of the figure supporting the prophet Daniel's book,
it's unlikely detected because of the change in scale and significance. One figure is the center
of the composition, the other is completely auxiliary. By contrast, a relationship viewers
probably were meant to notice was to prestigious antique models, such as the Laocoon, which had
recently been discovered in 1506, identified by Giuliano da Sangallo. Michelangelo was also
present at its discovery. The imperative in the Sistine ceiling had been to come up with hundreds
of figural poses, and this inevitably made it a site for the reuse of poses, sometimes in
unexpected ways. For example, the figure of Adam in the ceiling's most famous image, the creation
of Adam, seems to be a younger, more vital version of drunken Noah. Noah's slouched pose
itself seems to have been a starting point for two later studies of reclining female bodies,
both the knight from the Medici chapel and the study of Leda, now lost but known through a copy.
This gorgeous red chalk study of Adam, on the other hand, may well have served as a model for
the sensuous figure of Dawn, also from the Medici chapel. Another context in which Michelangelo made
ample use of earlier figural inventions was the Last Judgment. Prior to this, he had had two
occasions that required him to design compositions of interlocking figures. One of his very first
were the Centaurs and the Battle of Cascina, now lost but known through copies. In both, subject
was secondary to his display of bodies. His technique for developing complex figural compositions
had developed substantially in response to Leonardo, in the context of their work side by side
for the unfinished Battle of Cascina and Battle of Anghiari, Florence's council hall. Despite the
existence of compositional drawings for the Battle of Cascina, most graphic evidence of the lost
fresco is found in single figures. The isolation of figures in preparatory studies also had
consequences for the way they were reused, allowed them to be isolated again in new context.
So we can see that, for example, this figure is pulled out by Marcantonio Raimondi in a print.
As in the ceiling, the Last Judgment required Michelangelo to generate a large number of new
figures. At this point in his career, he had a broad catalog from which to draw. The central figure
of Christ is drawn both from the figure of Haman and the risen Christ. Other figures are adapted
from the Battle of Cascina, isolating them and reusing them as Raimondi had, and also creating
two new figures from one through axial rotation. The Fall of Phaeton, another drawing made for
Tommaso de Cavalieri, is an important source of figural ideas because the theme, though mythological,
involves figures falling through space. The figure of Phaeton himself is a variation of poses of the
ignudi, which, and this is just a kind of graphic illustration of how many ignudi poses there were
to draw on, which is also seems to have been a model for the Saint Bartholomew. Looking at
Michelangelo's compositional studies, it appears that the wide-legged, torqued pose of Phaeton
was the basis for several variations. In addition, the falling figures inform analogous figures from
the damned. Of course, the Fall of Phaeton was a private drawing given to Tommaso de Cavalieri
and intended for his eyes only. Even though Michelangelo was remarkably aware of what his
artistic legacy might be, he couldn't have anticipated that a private drawing would be
anticipated in a room full of people and be examined comparatively with his monumental paintings.
So how did Michelangelo arrive at so many slight variations on a limited set of figural poses?
Some of his contemporaries provide a guide. For example, Leonardo da Vinci gives an account of
the relationship between studying nudes from life and manipulating them into compositions.
In the winter, he suggests artists take all the nudes you've done in the summer
and make a selection of the best limbs and bodies and put them into practice.
The next summer, he advised, find a good model and make graceful and gallant gestures. He specifies
that the model doesn't have to be perfect because you can correct the limbs. In other words,
he recommends artists build up a store of poses on paper that they can manipulate when they do
not have a live model to study. The procedures Leonardo describes may be hard to picture,
but as a point of reference, students in the course I was referring to from a few years ago
were given only three hours to make life drawings with no prior background. And this is the result.
If you imagine life drawing as a daily practice for Renaissance artists
over years, often beginning when they were 12 or 13 or 14, it becomes easier to imagine how
they could acquire the level of proficiency and facility to allow them to come up with
slightly varied poses even when a model was not immediately in front of them. And just as a
contrast, I also had students try their hand at stone carving with Simon Verity, a wonderful
stone carver based in Philadelphia. And I can assure you this would have taken much longer
to master. Thinking about the practice of drawing models allows some conception of how
Michelangelo moved from work with models to detailed drawings to manipulation on the page
without the model as I think these were. And just to give you a sense of scale, these are
thumbnail drawings. And having studied these in the original, they are actually roughly the size
of my thumb. If not, each of the figures is roughly the size of my thumb, not the nail, but almost.
An account of Michelangelo's method of varying figures is found in Armaniti's treatise from the
16th century. Although it's not the intent of his passage, this is what he writes.
The original form of any figure is altered greatly by a small change in any member,
as by reversing members, changing the head slightly, raising an arm, or in presenting them
differently, reversing the drawing or blurring it. All of these devices result so that it no longer
seems the same figure. Consider how such alterations can vary a figure and even greater change in a
composition of several figures. He concludes, and here's the kicker. Therefore, we sanction this
practice as giving great aid and power to an artist of very weak mind. The reference to a
weak mind suggests that Armaniti probably didn't mean Michelangelo, but in another passage he does
how Michelangelo arrived at the figures for The Last Judgment. He writes there,
who is there who does not recognize having before oneself a figure or two in full relief
that one can merely by turning them so that they face in different directions,
draw from them many figures for one's own painting and all differing from one another.
It's in this way that judgment of Michelangelo should be considered. It's artists having used
the means I'm relating. Some, in fact, say that he made certain figures of wax with his own hand
and that he twisted their members as he wished, first softening their joints in warm water or
so that re-softened they would come out well. It's well known that Michelangelo, like later
sculptors such as Bernini, used wax models and some survive as these at the Casa Buonarroti.
There's no verification that Armanini was speaking from knowledge rather than speculating,
but it's nonetheless interesting in terms of the reception, what other artists perceived
about Michelangelo's procedure. The problem Michelangelo posed to his contemporaries was
twofold. One, he focused entirely on the human figure in an era when subject matter was expanding
and required a complex exploration of multiple themes with multiple and varied aspects. And two,
his representation of those figures was highly repetitive. As I mentioned in Armanini's words,
the work of a weak mind. So his reliance on this strategy vexed his critics who tied themselves
in rhetorical knots, trying to condemn the practice while praising him. The tension surfaces
particularly in the biography of Condivi. He writes, Michelangelo has a most retentive memory
and although he has painted all the thousands of figures that are to be seen, he has never made
two alike or in the same pose. Indeed, I've heard him say that he never draws a line without
remembering whether he has ever drawn it before and erasing it if it appears in public. We have
this precious document of Michelangelo's marginal notes to one copy of Condivi's biography in
Calcagni's, one of his assistant's hands, but we understand is dictated by Michelangelo. And he
wrote, it's all true. If you want to do well, vary your work constantly. While it's undoubtedly true
that Michelangelo had an excellent memory, the second part of claim that he has never made two
figures alike or in the same pose is demonstrably false. The passage helps us understand that the
perception of Michelangelo's use of repetition was probably widespread among his contemporaries,
possibly through a kind of whisper network rather than stated outright because of his stature within
his own lifetime. Vasari's life of Michelangelo is mostly devoted to deifying him, but he does
take an interesting point of view about imitators of Raphael versus Michelangelo.
So in his life of Raphael, he indicates his knowledge of Michelangelo's limitations. He
writes in a fascinating passage, knowing however, that in this respect, he could never attain the
perfection of Michelangelo. He reflected like a man of supreme judgment, that painting does not
consist only in representing the nude human form, but has a wider field. Raphael resolved to seek
equal and perchance surpass him in these other fields, that he devoted himself not to imitating
the manner of that master, but the attainment of a Catholic excellence in other fields of art that
have been described. The next passage is about imitators of Raphael and reveals the heart of
his anxiety about Michelangelo. He writes that artists have chosen to pursue the study of
Michelangelo's work alone, but have failed and have achieved only a manner that is hard,
full of difficulty, wanting in beauty and coloring, and poor in invention. In other words,
Michelangelo offered a poor, even dangerous model for aspiring artists of lesser talents. As a result,
Vasari is torn between the desire to glorify Michelangelo and his need to set down principles
of art for others to follow. Another significant aspect of Vasari's life of Raphael is his account
of the way Raphael learned from other artists and changed his style over the course of his life in
response to them. We might consider this derivative, but the judgment is completely
anachronistic for the Renaissance. By 16th century standards, creativity was built on imitation,
and mastery of this art was key to originality. In various passages, Vasari describes how Raphael
first learned from Perugino, but then surpassed him, taking up instead the manner of Leonardo,
da Vinci, and Florence, as can be seen in this pretty striking comparison. He then describes how
during an interruption in the work on the Sistine Ceiling, Bramante, deviously, and to undermine
Michelangelo, allowed Raphael in to see it. And as a result, Raphael repainted his fresco of the
prophet Isaiah and St. Augustino in Vasari's word, making it immeasurably better and more grand.
Michelangelo seems to have recognized this too and saw it as an example of Bramante undermining him
to bring fame to Raphael. The Isaiah is, in fact, an amazing painting because it illustrates so
succinctly the principle of creative imitation that was key to 16th century ideas about originality.
It shows how Raphael was constantly making the gesture towards Raphael.
Yes, I can do that, but better and with feeling. A monumental, heroic figure, but one that has
emotional expression and the precise features of a portrait, both in the face of Isaiah and in the
angel. There are a number of examples of this also apparent in the drawings, ones that show
musculature and tension as Michelangelo's do, but also sensuality, human interaction, and
personality. In these passages about Raphael's ability to change, Vasari doesn't explicitly
mention Michelangelo. The contrast is striking. Raphael lived only 37 years. Michelangelo lived
89. Yet it was Raphael who remade himself over and over again, changing his approach to almost
everything in the course of his short life. For other critics, Raphael offered an even more
explicit counterpoint to Michelangelo, centering on the variation offered by Raphael and the
sameness of Michelangelo. In Ludovico Dolce's Dialogue of 1557, L'Aretino, the interlocutors
debate the relative virtues and limitations of the two artists. In one passage, Dolce writes,
in the critical voice of Aretino, I'm telling you that Raphael knew how to make all kinds of nudes,
and Michelangelo was only good at one. And the nudes of Raphael are much more delightful.
Michelangelo painted laborers and Raphael, gentlemen. Raphael made every kind of person,
pleasing, terrible, and complex, and poses both muscular and delicate. The comments are striking
for how well they hit the mark. Michelangelo had shifted the type of model he used in his life
studies in a way that involved not just the body but social class, as Dolce indicates. Similar
themes are taken up by Lomazzo in his Treatise of 1584. Nominally discussing Raphael's virtues,
Lomazzo alludes to Michelangelo's weakness indirectly. He writes that Raphael's old
people are shown bent over and young people full of grace according to their nature, as he does
for all. One can see that painters should not use a single proportion for all their figures because
it's not truthful and does not control the narrative. In this way, figures seem to be
And he then goes on in a passage clearly indicating Michelangelo, but he avoids
saying his name. He says there are many painters who I will not mention. And most of all,
one of the two best who I will not name because any expert can easily know seeing his figures,
which even though admirably shown in various positions, are all of the same proportion.
The critics had a point. Raphael's paintings, which show Michelangelo's influence, are also
a catalog of things that Michelangelo couldn't or wouldn't do. They don't only show the
musculature of human figures, but they show emotion. They show figures in relation to
one another. They depict landscape and spatial depth. The criticism of Michelangelo's focus
on the figure became more pointed in the context of counter-reformation Rome and the Last Judgment.
The counter-reformation and the imperative to do nothing other,
explicate the religious narrative, created an impossible situation for artists.
Giulio's Dialogue on the Errors and Abuses of Painters from 1546, he criticizes Michelangelo
specifically for infinite errors and for the fact that his first intention is to twist the head,
the arms, and the legs of the figures. The figures are sforzate is the word that he used,
kind of forced, and that it would be better for them not to be there. For the painters,
think little about doing the subject of their story if they consider it at all.
And the essential worry here is that the figures are for nothing except for it itself. To today's
ears, it sounds somewhat absurd that there would be a pre-modern critique about interest of art
for art's sake. In a counter-reformation context, after the Council of Trent, it essentially meant
that any artistic form that drew attention needlessly to itself was suspect, just an
example of this twisting that worried critics. Vasari and Giulio were less directly worried about
Michelangelo and more about his imitators, or in Giulio's sharp words, the apes of Michelangelo.
They had reason to worry because Michelangelo's work became a school of art as this drawing of
the Medici Chapel full of young architects and artists drawing it. In other ways, too,
their worst fears came to pass. Artists such as Montormo and Rosso, Fiorentino took Michelangelo's
ideas and transformed them in ways that changed the nature of religious painting. But Michelangelo
was also imitated by artists at all ends of the spectrum, and the results varied. Everywhere from
Rosso's fantastic Dead Christ at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston to this plate in Urbino,
also at the Museum of Fine Arts, showing how Michelangelo's figural types could cross
media and geography, or this macabre study after a drawing by Rosso Fiorentino that suggests how
exaggeration and distortion could point Michelangelo's legacy in an extreme direction.
An absurd example of how far that distortion could take us comes in this fabulous print by
Juste de Juste, which makes Michelangelo's figural type look like a circus act.
Reproduced in printed model books such as this Dutch example, magnified reproductions such as
in this Dutch example magnify the possibilities of a kind of senseless imitation of extreme
musculature for its own sake. While Michelangelo's pattern is one of citing himself subtly drawing on
his own prior inventions, Raphael's more dominant mode is of emulating and seamlessly incorporating
the work of other artists. His early work demonstrated the strong stamp of his first
teacher, Perugino, and is almost indistinguishable from it. His early Madonnas also reflect Perugino's
influence. But when he arrived in Florence from Urbino around 1504, his work dramatically changed.
He studied the work of Donatello, whose marble reliefs had brought a new tenderness and immediacy
to the theme, and Michelangelo, who's himself closely observant of Donatello, who introduced
greater movement and composition and an emphasis on the physicality of both the Virgin and the Child.
He was also exposed to the work of Leonardo, who in those years was working on the Council Hall
of Florence with Michelangelo. Raphael's absorption in these new models was most obviously seen in his
studies of the Madonna and Child, which transformed from relatively staid and static to intimate,
tender, and dynamic. A spectacular room at the London Raphael Exhibition documented this
transformation beautifully, and I can only provide a poor approximation. But in this sheet of loose
studies at the British Museum, you can see the key role drawing played in the process by which
Raphael arrived at variations on his theme, allowing him to create slight iterations of
similar poses across the page. It also suggests how much he'd learned about drawing from Leonardo.
With the series of Madonnas he made illustrates, above all, his remarkable openness outside
influences, not only Leonardo and Donatello, but also Michelangelo. Raphael's most dramatic
transformation of the Virgin and Child composition, embracing even greater movement among the figures
and more unusual poses, seems to arise directly from his study of Michelangelo, particularly the
marble relief of the Taddei Tondo and his painting of the Doni Tondo. Remarkably, a faint metal point
sheet of Raphael's studies has survived and shows us Raphael studying the precise horizontal
pose of the Christ that Michelangelo had employed in the Doni Tondo, self perhaps inspired by
Leonardo da Vinci. The rapid fire changes that Raphael instituted in his paintings of the Virgin
and Child in response to the new Florentine stimuli can be seen through any numbers of
examples painted here around 1508, and just the density of this slide is meant to give you some
broad idea of those changes. But in some ways the most fascinating is the relationship between
the National Gallery's own extraordinary Alba Madonna of 1510 and Michelangelo's Doni Tondo
of 1505-6. It's a perfect example of Renaissance emulation, emulation in which the source of
inspiration is clear but not in any way mechanical. In addition to the Doni Tondo, Raphael's painting
also probably reflects knowledge of Michelangelo's ignudi, seen in the bent knee pose of the child,
but primarily it demonstrates a full understanding of the implications of Michelangelo's composition
and its introduction of torsion and energy into the usually staid figures of mother and child.
Another gorgeous Raphael Madonna from just a few years later, the Madonna della Sedia,
shows Raphael could take a single idea from an earlier work, in this case physical intimacy,
and the immediacy of Donatello's Pazzi Madonna, and animate it even further. Another realm in
which Raphael had a great deal to learn from Michelangelo was in the study of the human figure.
Like Leonardo da Vinci himself, he made drawings of Michelangelo's David from 1504,
and from the early years of the 16th century took a greater interest in the muscular male nude.
How far this took Raphael from where he began can be seen, for example, in contemplating his early
St. Sebastian. Almost all other artists before him had used the martyrdom of St. Sebastian
as an occasion to display the writhing male nude body. They didn't need Michelangelo's
permission or precedent to do this. But before his introduction to Michelangelo, Raphael had
so little interest that he showed St. Sebastian as a well-dressed young man in a fancy tunic,
holding his arrow as daintily as if it were a teaspoon. The most decisive moment in Raphael's
study of the male nude and the monumental figural style came when, as I already recounted,
Bramante allowed him to see the Sistine ceiling. Vasari's account is fascinating. He suggests
his view of artistic influence is presented almost as if it's a kind of airborne disease,
but with a positive effect, infecting the artist upon contact. While Raphael took a range of
lessons from Leonardo about drawing, about the relationship between figures, what he learned
from Michelangelo was more specific and more to do with the monumentality of the figure and the
muscularity of the male nude. The effect could be seen immediately not only in the Isaiah that I
already showed you at San Agostino, but also in Raphael's Sybils in Santa Maria della Pace,
shown here. His drawings also show a consistent interest from these years in stretching or
straining and muscular figures. And he continued to use these models, especially of Michelangelo's
Sybils for years later, even in his transfiguration from just the last years of his life, 1516 to 20.
At times, Raphael's incorporations of elements borrowed from other painters can seem quite bold.
For example, his fresco of Galatea in the Villa Farnesina, Raphael gives Galatea the pose of
Leonardo's Leda, while in the winged Cupid, he found another use for the pose of the Christ
child in Michelangelo's Donni Tondo. It's in the Vatican stanza, however, that the impact of
Raphael's visit to Sistine became most obvious. In the Stanza di Eliodorio, the musculature of
the hanging male figure is so striking that some have speculated wrongly, I believe, that it was
not by Raphael. Raphael's cartoons executed in preparation for a tapestry series commissioned by
Leo X to hang in the Sistine ceiling, and thus directly in competition with Michelangelo,
demonstrates Raphael's full absorption of Michelangelo's models, but also everything else
that he could do. Create complex space with elaborate architectural backgrounds and widely
varied figural poses, as in the Sacrifice of Leistra at the Victoria and Albert Museum.
In works of varied subjects, such as the Entombment, Raphael continued to draw indirectly
examples of dynamic figural composition that Michelangelo had offered. An unusual drawing at
the British Museum shows him making use of anatomical and skeletal studies, so this is a
really bizarre compositional study, inspired, no doubt, by similar studies that Michelangelo and
indeed Leonardo had made, such as these sheets at the Tyler's Museum. In other works, from the 15
Teens, his cartoons and tapestries, Raphael demonstrated greater independence from
Michelangelo's models, as in its composition of Saint Paul preaching at Athens, a composition
that was widely influential and disseminated through Marcantonio Raimondi, passing to many
additional media as well. Now, I've focused so far on these artists' figural compositions and
the patterns that we find there, but as an architectural historian, as most of my scholarly
work can't let you go without at least mentioning, at breakneck speed, some of the parallels to
architecture, because both Michelangelo and Raphael were also architects. So, in Michelangelo's case,
there's an interesting contrast to the tradition represented by Giuliano da Sangallo, as well as
other contemporaries of studying ancient details from the antique. What Michelangelo does instead
is study them indirectly, so he copies another person's book, Bernardo della Volpaia. He then
takes single architectural details and varies them over the course of his entire career. So,
that can be seen in these hanging brackets, and as I said, this is going to be a very rapid survey,
which reappear then at Palazzo Medici in these windows. It can be seen in these volutes and
various details from different moments in his career, from Palazzo Farnese to the Porta Pia,
more volutes in wreaths, a number of examples from St. Peter's and the Medici Chapel, even in
highly abstracted architectural form. Repetitiveness that I'm identifying in Michelangelo's
architecture, you might say, is just part of classicism. Isn't it repetitive to begin with?
There are only so many possible variations, but Michelangelo's repetition is different because
it's fundamentally self-referential, and there, I think, is the parallel to his figurative work.
It's a kind of solipsism. It reached its apex in the Porta Pia, which is this highly idiosyncratic
catalogue of an inward-looking vocabulary. Just as Vasari and others had worried about
imitators of his figural style, his architecture was also difficult to imitate. Vasari was maybe
his only successful imitator, taming the most idiosyncratic elements of his style in the Uffizi
galleries, for example, but few were willing to follow Michelangelo's idea architecturally where
they might lead, with the possible exception of someone like Bernardo Bontalenti. Raphael,
on the other hand, was a totally different story architecturally, and again, I'm not going to begin
to do justice, but I just want to allude to a couple things. While Raphael followed Michelangelo's
work closely as a painter, as an architect, his path was totally distinct, and in fact,
his independence from Michelangelo was broad enough it might be considered a rejection.
It had partly to do with his close study of the antique, and this is just a rare surviving drawing
studying the Horse of the Dioscorides, another rare surviving drawing studying the Pantheon
interior. Raphael's original and inventive approach to the antique, his highly imaginative
reception of antique architecture, can be seen possibly most dramatically in some of his
architectural, imagined architectural backgrounds, for example, in the Stanze, the School of Athens
and the Stanze di Eliodoro, as well as in some of the fictive architectural elements. This is
Raphael and a few of, in the context of the School of Athens and some of Michelangelo's examples,
as well as in his executed architectural works, such as the Chichi Temple, a kind of early example
of a Gesamtkunstwerk, or a kind of altogether work of art. In the abstraction of his palaces,
such as Palazzo Pendolfini, and what I'm referring to is this kind of use of paneling, which raises
the question of where is the wall, and seen as well in Palazzo Branconio dell'Aquila.
And then the most dramatic example of Raphael's antique vision is that, realized, is that the
unfinished Villa Madama, where he chooses unusual antique motifs, such as this pulvinated ionic
frieze, again, a highly abstract and original interpretation of something like the Tabernacle.
And then his interior of Villa Madama is really the most extraordinary, demonstrating a kind of
wholesale vision of what an antique house would have looked like, based on the recent discovery
of the Golden House of Nero. Unlike what we saw with Michelangelo, who is hard to imitate,
Raphael's architecture offered wide vistas of imitation. And this is an example of Giulio
Romano, the wonderful Palazzo Macarani, with its famous cafe and its also highly abstract
use of paneling and architecture. We're almost at the end, and you may still be wondering,
where's the paradox? The paradox that I want to suggest is that the prolific inventiveness
that we see and perceive in Michelangelo and Raphael is possible because of their equally
prolific practices that were founded on strategies of repetition, either through self-citation or
copying of others. Now, despite recent critiques, both feminist and otherwise, the concept of genius
is alive and well in our times, as seen in this slightly provoking 2005 cover of the New York
Times. In Walter Isaacson's series, he's a writer I admire. He's made a career of profiling geniuses.
I was thinking, well, it seems to be there's a pattern, and in fact, there is a pattern,
because there's a box set of geniuses you can buy. There seems to be a small cottage industry
in publishing about how to become a genius. I actually had a student approach me one time
wanting to use one of these books as a foundation of a course, and I tried to be interested and
enthusiastic, but I was slightly dreading it, and was fortunately able to persuade her to study
Leonardo in a slightly different way. Despite the efforts of the McCarthy Foundation valiantly
trying to keep people from using the word genius in relation to its awards, it's always referred
to as such, as in this year's announcement in the New York Times. What's wrong with the concept?
Why does it matter? We're at the end of our time, and that would take a whole other lecture to
detail, but one hint that I would say is that the idea infects the way that we think about human
potential, talent, and achievement, and how we reward it. It's also related to ideas of
originality and copying. Speaking of copying, probably Andy Warhol is our most relevant
recent artist. He copied Raphael himself, and as some of you, this being a Washington audience,
undoubtedly know, the issue is recently, as recently as October 12th, come before the
Supreme Court, who heard oral arguments regarding copying practices in relation to Andy Warhol's
use of a photograph by Lynn Goldsmith of Prince. I don't think it's modesty to suggest that the
pleasing way that my career has progressed, that I'm unlikely to ever become a Supreme Court
justice. I think it's also unlikely that anyone's going to ask me to weigh in on this particular
case. I may be able to contribute tangentially just by suggesting in the period of the Renaissance
that we associate with enormous originality and invention, and arguably the invention of the very
idea of genius. Copying was everywhere and was foundational to creativity. Thank you.