Trangia Head Space Side by Side comparison in the Firebox Nano Ultra Light Stove.

Firebox Stove
469 followers
Dec 10, 2013
Trangia Head Space Side by Side comparison in the Firebox Nano Ultra Light Stove.
Contact us: [email protected]
Purchase products here: https://www.fireboxstove.com/index.php?route=common/home
I have heard Hiram Cook mention that one inch seems to be the best amount of head space for the Trangia Spirit burner so I thought I would do a side by side test to see exactly what performance differences to expect depending on alcohol stove placement in the Folding Firebox Nano.
Hello everybody, Steve here from Firebox Stove. I wanted to test to find out how much difference
changing the headspace on the Trangia alcohol stove makes. Let me show you what I mean here.
If you open up a Trangia and just drop that into the Firebox Nano, if I measure the headspace from
the top of the Trangia to the bottom of the pot, it's almost exactly one and three quarters of an
inch. Okay, so what I'm going to do is leave one set up that way and then I'm going to set up
another one with the lid of the Trangia, spacering it up. Now, Hiram Cook has done a lot of testing
and he has a lot of experience with alcohol stoves and he really feels that the sweet spot
on the Trangia alcohol stove is approximately one inch. Well, adding that cap underneath the Trangia
changes the headspace to from one and three quarters to one and an eighth, so that's really
close to having the perfect sweet spot, the perfect headspace for the Trangia alcohol stove.
So, I'm going to set these up this way and just see how much of a difference it makes. I'm going
to zero these out so I have exactly two ounces of fuel in each one and then we'll just do a boil
test. Okay, so there's two ounces for that one. We'll get two ounces in this one. 2.1, so I'm just
going to put a teeny bit more in this one. It's kind of going and moving around. Anyway, so that
should be pretty close. I want those to be the same so that they'll come to a blossom at about
the same rate. I'll go ahead and move my scale out of the way and we'll set these nanos up. I'm going
to center that cap down there. So, this one is a one and an eighth headspace and this one over here
is one and three quarters of an inch headspace. I'm going to go ahead and get these both lit.
I have identical pots in the back that have the identical temperature and the amount of water.
Everything is the same and we'll let these kind of, they're both, they both have come to a bloom now
and I'm just going to move this camera a little bit closer.
I might change the angle just a little bit on that and let's go ahead and start the timer.
And put our pots on and let's see where this goes. I'll go ahead and turn off the light so you can
kind of maybe see a little bit of what's going on with the frame. I'll just take this camera off so
I can give you a little better. Okay, so this is the one and three quarters of an inch headspace
and this is closer to one inch headspace. This is about one and one eighth headspace right there.
So you can see the flame is quite a bit different and I think what happens when the headspace is
closer is the alcohol burner itself gets a little bit more heat feedback. So the alcohol reaches a
higher temperature and it in turn it basically turns the alcohol burner to a higher level,
a higher output because it's running a little bit hotter. Okay, we're at four minutes and 30
seconds. I'm going to lift the lids. Here, I'll turn on the light here. We'll get a little more,
shed a little more light on the subject and I'm going to lift these lids at the same time
so you can see the progress for yourself and see where we're at.
Okay, this one is actually starting to rise and this one is not. So let's let them make a
little more progress here, hopefully without me giving one or the other any kind of an advantage.
I want this to be a, I want this to be a good test. It sounds like this one may actually be
boiling now. Okay, so this one is actually boiling and this one is not. And what Hiram may be
thinking of as far as that sweet spot is maybe that's the most efficient way of
using the stove is at a one inch height. And that's, I kind of wondered that because I have
gotten really good boil times with the inch and three-quarter headspace. And so that,
I wondered exactly what he was taking into consideration when he said that. Oh, I forgot
to call out the time when this one was boiling, but hopefully you could see that there in the
video. It's six minutes now and this one is now coming to a boil at about six minutes.
So this last portion of the video I will leave or keep uncut so that you can kind of judge the
time by the timer on the video itself. So I'm going to go ahead and snuff these both out. They
both come to a boil and this will be allowing them both to run for approximately the same amount
of time. So it won't really necessarily be the amount of fuel used to get it to a boil,
but it'll rather be how much fuel to run it for this duration of time, I guess.
So I'm going to set these both aside and make sure I'll be able to get those snuffers on there.
Go ahead and put these out and then I'll let those cool a little bit and we'll weigh them.
Okay, here's an empty trangea that we can zero this out with. Okay, so we're all zeroed out.
So this will be the one inch headspace. So 1.8 ounces remain according to that.
And this will be the one and three quarters of an inch headspace.
This is 1.7 ounces. So this one did use more fuel.
So anyway, there's the information. You can use it however you would like.
But it does show us that the deeper headspace does work really well for a high temperature.
And maybe if you want to slow the burn down, then a closer temperature. And so maybe I had
it backwards. There's actually less feedback potentially with it being closer rather than
more feedback that I originally had assumed. So anyway, I hope you all learned something
from this test. I think I have. And we'll just take that and use it however we can.
And I thank you all for watching and I hope you all have happy holidays.
