Which Backpacking Shelter is the BEST

AROUND THE WORLD
406 followers
54 Video Views·Dec 9, 2022
Disclosure: There are Amazon Affiliate links in my gear lists and possibly in product links in this video description. As an affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Hey y'all, Dixie here. Today I want to talk to you about backpacking shelters,
more specifically tents, tarps, bivvies, and hammocks. I know when I first started
backpacking and I realized that there were several different types of shelters,
I was kind of confused on which one would work best for me. So today I'm going to give you a
rundown of each type of shelter, some of the pros and cons, and hopefully this video will help you
decide what works best for you and your personal preferences and the terrain that you'll be
backpacking in. First let's go over tents because they're the most commonly used on trail
and I feel like they have the best weight to price to ease of setting up ratio. Some of the
benefits of using a tent are, one, they are pretty roomy compared to other backpacking shelters. So I
like to be able to set up my tent, crawl inside, and just spread my gear out everywhere. I like
having that extra space to keep my gear in, especially if it's raining outside because
with some of the other shelters you may have to keep your pack and other things outside and try
to waterproof them. But with the tent, most of the time even in a one-person tent, you're going to
have enough room to squeeze in your pack and the rest of your gear. Also if it's raining and you
have a tent that has a vestibule, it's nice to be able to cook inside that vestibule so you're not
having to worry about trying to cook out in the rain and then get inside of your shelter. And
initially I feel like tents are the easiest type of shelter to set up. So they require the least
skill. You pretty much pull it out of the box, read the instructions, and set it up. There are
drawbacks to each type of backpacking shelter and tents are no exception. So with a tent, you have
to kind of make sure that you've got flat-ish ground. I have certainly set up on some ground
that is not ideal for tenting and then I end up tent surfing all night so my sleeping pad slides
or, you know, I've got a big root in my back or things like that. So you kind of want to make
sure that you have a relatively flat, clear spot for a tent. And even if you find a nice, beautiful,
flat spot, the ground still isn't always comfortable. Especially if you're a side sleeper like me,
your hip can kind of tend to dig in the ground even with an inflatable sleeping pad, although
those do help a lot. And finally, tents are a little bit heavier than some of your more
minimalistic options like a tarp. One of the main things I look for in a backpacking tent is the
weight because with any of these shelters, when you're having to tote something from point A
to point B, you obviously want it to be functional but as light as possible. So what I target with a
backpacking tent is anything under three pounds. There are some more traditional or, you know,
old-fashioned backpacking tents that can weigh around five pounds or maybe even more, but with
the technology today, even if you're on a tight budget, you can usually find something for around
three pounds or less that isn't going to completely break the bank. I prefer to go with a three-season
tent. You'll either see three-season tents or four-season tents. If you're just starting out,
chances are you're not going to be backpacking in the heart of winter, so a three-season tent
will generally be lighter and will cover you for what you need in the spring, summer, and fall. If
you're going to be backpacking alone like I do, I go with a one- to two-person tent. I prefer the
two-person because usually for not that much more weight, you get a decent amount of extra room,
again, to spread your stuff out or roll around, you know, whatever you want to do in your tent.
And then the final thing I look at is the vestibule slash door situation. So I definitely want a tent
that has a vestibule because, as I mentioned before, on rainy days I like to be able to cook
in the vestibule. Also, it just gives you room if you wanted to put something out there for some
reason and have it not get wet while it's raining. Now, if you're a couple that's going to go
backpacking together, I recommend having a tent that has two doors, one on either side, and two
vestibules, one on either side, because I have used the backpacking tents before that sleep two people
but only has one door and one vestibule on an end, and I feel like you're just going to disturb
your partner more getting up and going pee in the middle of the night. Also, if you're both
trying to cook in the vestibule, things can get a little tight with the elbows and stuff, so
I just think that's something to look for if you're going to have two people in one tent together.
Another variety that you'll see among tents is that some of them are freestanding, some of them
are what I call semi-freestanding, and then there are non-freestanding tents. A freestanding tent
is a tent that stands alone without staking. Now, of course, it could still blow away in heavy wind,
but it sets up and basically supports itself with its own designated tent poles. The good
thing about these tents is that if you're setting up on something like solid rock or extremely
loose sand, that you don't have to worry about, you know, having to stake it down for it to be
rigid and for it to be taut. Now, the issue is these tents are generally a little bit heavier
because they're more sturdily built, so it might be hard to find one that's three pounds or less,
and then also a lot of these don't have vestibules. You can purchase a vestibule sometimes to attach
to one, but then you're adding weight on an already not lightweight tent. An example of a sub-three
pound freestanding tent, though, is the Black Diamond First Light two-person. Next up is the
semi-freestanding tent. Basically, the body of the tent, so the part that's going to have, like, the
mesh and the part that you actually physically sleep inside of, sets up with designated tent
poles and that part is freestanding. Now, the rainfly, which goes over it and usually creates
the vestibule on the tent, will have to be staked out. So, I guess the negative side to this is that
you will have to use stakes to set this up properly, especially if you're going to be in a
rainstorm. Some examples of the semi-freestanding tents that I have used are the Big Agnes Fly Creek
UL 2 that I used on my through hike of the Appalachian Trail and then in Washington on the
Pacific Crest Trail, I used the Nemo Hornet one-person. And next up is the non-freestanding
tent. With these tents, they require guy lines and stakes and usually either trekking poles or limbs
if you get in a bind, but they do not typically have a designated set of tent poles, which saves
a lot of weight. If you want to learn more about trekking poles, I have a video that covers them
in detail on the channel, but trekking poles aren't a necessity for backpacking. It's just that most
people do use them, especially for longer trips. So, even though non-freestanding tents are typically
set up using trekking poles, most manufacturers have the option to buy dedicated poles for those
specific tents. I did notice when I used my first non-freestanding tent that they do initially take
a little more skill to set up, but once you get the hang of it, it's just as easy as anything else.
An example of a non-freestanding tent is the Zpax Duplex that I used on most of my PCT thru-hike
and my CDT thru-hike. The next thing to consider is whether you want a double-walled tent or a
single-walled tent. So, what I mean by double-walled tent is you have the mesh body of your tent and
then you have the rainfly over the top of it. So, that's one wall, two walls. One of the things that
I really liked about having a double-walled tent was being able to just sleep in the mesh body part
and look up at the sky and see the stars if it wasn't a rainy night and I still had protection
from bugs. Also, the double-walled tents are pretty well ventilated because the condensation that comes
from your body and the moisture in the air and all of that will collect on the rainfly of the tent
and then run down to the ground rather than collecting on the inside of the tent, you know,
on the only wall and then being a problem if you brush up against the side of the tent. Now, all
tents are going to have some kind of condensation but double-walled tents just do a little bit
better with that. Another benefit of a double-walled tent is that they are typically a little bit warmer
on the inside. They keep you more insulated and I kind of did an experiment with this not
intentionally on the CDT. Aaron, Perk, and I were all camped out in the same area and Aaron and I
both had single-walled tents. Well, Perk had a double-walled tent and it got surprisingly cold
that night and all of us slept with our water filter outside of our sleeping bag because we
just weren't expecting the temperatures to dip down low so we didn't protect them and Aaron's
filter froze and my filter froze but Perk's filter did not freeze. There are a lot of variables that
could be considered in this, you know, maybe Perk produces more heat or maybe that one certain spot
that Perk was at was magically a little bit warmer but, you know, I really do think that the fact that
he had a double-walled tent and we both had single-walled tents did play into that. They do tend to run a
little heavier than a single-walled tent made out of the same material because there is more material
and then also I find that the double-walled tents take a little longer to set up because you're
putting up two separate pieces rather than one piece, you know, all together at once and in the
rain if you set up the mesh body and then you have to take the time to pull out the rain fly and throw
it over, in my mind they can get a little bit more water on the inside while you're setting up than a
single-walled tent that is made out of a waterproof material that just goes up and you're not really
having the floor of the tent exposed as much. Most double-walled tents are made out of nylon or
polyester. Nylon is typically stronger and a little heavier than the polyester but that means it can
sag a little more and collect more water in heavy rains. You may also see tents made out of something
like sil-nylon or sil-poly which just means it's nylon and polyester that is impregnated with
silicon. Single-walled tents are basically constructed so that the mesh part and the rain fly are just
all together in one piece. So in general with having just a single wall, less material means
less weight. Also because they usually set up with trekking poles, you're going to save weight of
designated tent poles. And as I mentioned before, I think that they're a little bit better for
setting up in the rain. Now the negative aspects of a single-walled tent is you're going to deal with
more condensation because you don't have that mesh barrier and then the rain fly where the
condensation can collect. But you can mitigate this a little bit sometimes even if you're not
having a heavy rain but just a light rain or you're sleeping somewhere that feels a little
more damp you can leave one of your vestibule doors open for some added ventilation and then
you just have to be mindful when you're in the tent not to rub up all against the wall where the
condensation is collecting. Also as I mentioned before, they can be a little cooler in cold
weather and then because they're less ventilated they can also be a little warmer and hotter
weather. And also you really can't look at the stars like you can in a double-walled tent where
you just leave the rain fly off. I mean yes you can leave the door open and kind of lean out and look
but there was a specific meteor shower on the CDT where I was really wishing I could have that
double-walled tent. I opened the vestibule and you know kind of laid to where I could see out
but it just wasn't the same as sleeping in the mesh part of the double-walled tent with the
rain fly off. Single-walled tents can be made out of the same materials as double-walled tents but
the most lightweight option is going to be Cuban fiber known also as Dyneema. This material is
strong, it is waterproof, it is very lightweight, and it is also extremely expensive. One final
thing to keep in mind about using a tent is that some tents require a footprint to protect the
bottom of the tent. If your tent does require a footprint the manufacturer will definitely let
you know because of course they want to sell you some other piece of equipment. Now you can use the
footprint that is made specifically for your tent if it if it is suggested that you use a footprint
or you can use a piece of Tyvek which is going to be a little bit lighter and probably the lightest
option for a ground cloth is going to be polycryoplastic and you can just shape the ground
cloth to where it will go under your tent. You want to make sure that it does not stick out past
your tent because then if it gets rained on water will collect between the ground cloth and your
tent and you will probably find yourself in a swimming pool of water. Not only will the Tyvek
or polycryo options be a little more lightweight but they will also probably be cheaper than a
designated footprint that's sold specifically for a tent. Just a quick word on tent stakes.
I've used everything from a heavier tent stake to an extremely lightweight tent stake and really
I've used both in windy conditions, in hard ground, I've set up on a rock slab. You can use whatever
you're comfortable with. So if you want to go with a heavier larger tent state to make sure that
your tent is really anchored down well that's fine. Me personally I go with a very lightweight
hook-like stake from Zpacks. I'll put a link to that in the video description if you'd like to
check those out. But I found that even in very windy conditions or if I'm setting up on a rock
slab like I mentioned before I have found ways for like four to five thousand miles to make those
very lightweight tent stakes work and that's usually by taking some care when I put the stake
into the ground. You know making sure that I'm not just like killing it with a rock and and
hammering it into another rock and bending it. You know I'm just very careful when I put it in the
ground and if I for some reason can't get it into the ground then I just lay it down and stack rocks
on top of it. But if you're not comfortable yet with using a lightweight stake then go with the
ones you have to do what works for you. Next up I want to talk about tarps. Tarps are a more
minimalistic version of a tent basically. So they're going to be made usually out of the same
types of materials but because there is a lot less fabric you're going to have a more lightweight
option. Most people who use a tarp are going to use some sort of ground cloth under their sleeping
pad to again help with moisture and to kind of keep all of their stuff out of the dirt and also
to protect their sleeping pad from anything that could poke a hole into it if they're using an
inflatable sleeping pad. Tarps can set up being tied to trees or with branches. Also you can use
trekking poles. There is a lot of versatility with a tarp but with having that versatility
there's also some need for skill. So this is not something that you want to learn how to use in the
middle of a rainstorm. There are so many ways to set up a tarp that I'm not going to delve off into
that today because I could talk for hours and you could probably still suggest a different way.
What I would do is if you're interested in learning to backpack with a tarp is to check out some of
the ways that other people have preferred to set up their tarps and then see what works best for
you. Some of the benefits of using a tarp again are how lightweight they are, the versatility of them,
you can get some pretty good views, you also get to be you know more one with nature. There is a ton
of ventilation and also a tarp can act as a quick cover for quite a few people in a rainstorm if
necessary. Some of the cons of using a tarp as your backpacking shelter might be less protection from
bugs, less privacy if you're in a well-populated camping area. Sometimes you might want a break
from nature you know where a tent kind of gives you this little haven where you feel like you're
in a little den. A tarp is not going to provide you with that feeling quite as much as a tent will.
You're going to have less protection from the elements and again it requires a little more skill
than a tent and you're probably going to need to familiarize yourself with some knots which
isn't necessarily a negative thing because that's always a good skill to have. There is kind of an
extreme option in the world of tarping and that is the poncho tarp. Now I think that this is really
very efficient because you have your rain gear and shelter all in one so it definitely saves a lot of
weight but with this you're going to have even less protection from the elements. I think that
it would be an okay idea for somebody who already has like normal size tarping experience. It's also
a shelter that I think you have to be willing to kind of work with so if it's extremely windy and
rainy and you're up on a ridge then you're probably not going to want to stop and use this as your
shelter so you're going to have to be willing to put in longer days to find the right conditions
and the right setting for something like this. If you want your shelter to be something that you kind
of enjoy chilling out in at camp then the poncho tarp might not be for you. One way to get a bit
more protection if you're going to use a tarp especially the poncho tarp is to have a lightweight
water resistant bivvy. This will give you more protection from the elements also from bugs. It's
going to minimize drafts add some warmth to your bag and also protect your bag or quilt from back
splash so when it's raining and it hits the dirt and then splashes back onto you this will kind of
help keep you from getting soaked that way. A lot of these lightweight bivvies will have a waterproof
bottom so you could eliminate the ground cloth if you wanted to. Also there are the traditional
variety of bivvy bags so these are the ones that act as a standalone shelter and are also very
minimalistic so you have this bag that's waterproof and covers your sleeping system and then has a hoop
to keep the bag from laying on your face while you sleep at night. Some of the benefits of using a
traditional bivvy bag as your shelter is that they can be lightweight they're still going to
protect you from mosquitoes and the elements but the flip side of that is these bivvy bags
are pretty confined so you might deal with some condensation issues. Also I personally would feel
kind of claustrophobic in like a coffin like shelter and because they're so small you're
probably not going to have space to put your gear inside the shelter so it's going to be the
situation where you kind of have to waterproof your gear and set it outside. Now an option for
that is if you line your pack with a compactor bag then you can just put the pack inside that
compactor bag and roll it up and whatever gear you want inside there to be protected if it were
to rain outside. Well that is it for all of our ground dwelling shelters and next up we have
hammocks. The hammock community is ever increasing in size as time goes on and I've had a lot of
people tell me that their favorite thing about sleeping in a hammock is how comfortable the
hammocks are and how well they sleep at night. In fact I've had a lot of people say that they
thought that they were never going to be able to backpack again because sleeping on the ground just
wasn't an option for them anymore because of a bad back but after discovering hammock camping
then they were able to start backpacking again. Other than the comfort of sleeping it's also nice
to have a hammock after a long day of backpacking that you can just set up and lounge in at camp.
It's very convenient to have a hammock in an area that's extremely rocky or rooty as long as you
have some trees to set up in because it doesn't matter what the ground is like you're going to be
hanging out in the trees anyway. But on the negative aspect side of things you do have to
have trees to be able to set up your hammock. You're also not going to be able to spread out as much as
you would in a tent if you have a hammock and then there is going to be a little less privacy
associated with a hammock than with a tent. You got to make sure that your booty ain't hanging
out for everyone to see you while you're changing clothes. It's a little more difficult than say
with tents or tarps to reduce the weight while still protecting yourself properly from the
elements. The reason I say it's difficult to decrease the overall weight of a hammock setup
is there are a lot of components to this type of system. You'll have the hammock itself and then
some sort of suspension system whether that's straps or cords and then you've got to have a
tarp or rain fly to protect you from the rain. Potentially some bug netting to keep the mosquitoes
and flies out and then an over quilt and or under quilt depending on how low you should expect the
temperatures to be. Now when it's warm enough some folks might use just the hammock and a foam pad
but you have to keep in mind in a hammock because you're hanging up and there might be drafts of
wind coming under you, you won't have that insulation from the ground to help keep you warm.
Some hammock systems are sold as a one-piece type deal that covers all of your needs and then there
are others where you can piece them together separately if you choose. Like with tarps it's
going to take a little bit more skill to set up a hammock than it would with anything else when you
do something over and over you're going to get more efficient at it. I started out my through hike
of the Appalachian Trail with a very heavy and cheap hammock setup. I had no prior experience
so the whole needing a little bit of skill thing I was definitely lacking in that but I think that
I'm gonna give it another go. I've had a lot of folks say you know you should try it again don't
knock it until you try it properly. So pretty soon here in the future I am going to purchase a proper
hammock setup give it a spin for a couple of days and I will record that and let y'all know how it
goes. Kind of doing some research right now on what option I want to get so if any of you hammockers
have some suggestions please feel free to leave those in the comments below. I've always heard that
the Ultimate Hang is a great resource if you want to learn more about hammock camping and they have
an updated version the Ultimate Hang 2 available now so I will put that in the video description
if you want to check it out. For those of y'all who are just getting into backpacking I know that
this was a lot of information all at once to think about backpacking shelters but just as a summary
if you're looking for something that's relatively simple and light and reliable then you might want
to opt for a tent. If you're looking for something that's more minimalistic and as lightweight as
possible and you don't mind it requiring a little more skill then you might opt for a tarp. And
finally if you're truly looking for the best way to be comfortable while backpacking and to get the
best sleep at night then you might want to try out a hammock. Just like with all backpacking gear
your shelter is going to boil down to personal preference and for those of y'all who are
watching today who are more experienced with backpacking please feel free to share in the
comments what shelter you use and why you think it's the best option for you because
the folks who are just getting into backpacking can probably learn a lot from that especially
if they have preferences in common with you. Either way whatever shelter you choose you're
going to need to be warm and cozy inside when you sleep so tomorrow I'm going to be covering
sleep systems. If y'all enjoyed this video today do not forget to subscribe
and thank y'all again so much for watching and we will see y'all next time.
