WHICH BOOK IS THE ODD ONE OUT?? had so much fun making this video and would love to do it again if you like!! is your favourite fantasy author on this list?
You tell me. You hear something about Roger and Dodger and you're like, I'm getting rid of that.
Roger and Dodger, no way.
Hi everyone, welcome back to my channel.
Today we are starting a very exciting, well maybe it'll be a series, depends if everyone likes it or not,
called Odd Book Out.
Can I put the thing in now?
Go.
I brought together seven fantasy books.
One of them is a liar.
If Tom discovers which plot is fake, he wins.
If the liar survives, Megan wins.
Who is the odd book out?
So we have got seven fantasy books and Tom is going to have intervals where he gets to ask me questions about any of the books.
I have to tell him what the plots are, but one of these is a plot that I am completely making up
and he has to try and guess which of those it is.
After each round, he has to eliminate one of the books and at any point he can say,
I think I've got rid of the fake one and we can stop the game.
So we got this video idea, or Tom really came up with it,
from the channel Jubilee does videos where it's like six vegans and one non-vegan
and they have to claim, they have to all pretend that they're the vegan.
And so we've basically just ripped off their idea and using it as our own.
My approach to this is to go on with books that I haven't read yet because
A. Usually if I've read a book, you've heard me talk about it a bit and I don't want to give you that leg up.
And B. Some of these, I don't have the clearest idea on plot anyway.
And so you may think I'm making it up because I don't know a lot about it and think that it's the fake one.
We have got Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo.
I know who that is.
You do know who that is.
We've got Skyward by Brandon Sanderson.
We've got The Cruel Prince by Holly Black.
The Night Circus by Erin Morganson.
I know who that is.
Strange the Dreamer by Laini Taylor.
A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J Maas.
And we've got Middle Game by Seanan McGuire.
So you're allowed to look at the covers obviously but you're not allowed to look at the back or inside.
So you've got to work fairly fast. I think a minute and a half will go really quickly.
What's your approach for this?
I've heard of Erin Morganson and I've heard of Leigh Bardugo only because of your videos.
Yeah.
And I get the two of them mixed up because they've both got a book that's got blue and gold on it.
Erin Morganson and I just always thought she was a rip off of Leigh Bardugo.
They're not actually very similar.
Yeah, don't listen to me. That's absolutely founded on nothing.
A Court of Thorns.
A Court of Thorns and Roses, yeah.
It's really ---- front cover.
Mate, you should see the new ones they're releasing. Even worse.
Sanderson is going to be difficult for you to lie about.
Okay, why do you think that?
I'll just ignore the fact you must have spoiled something. I wasn't really listening.
You ready?
The Cruel Prince, when was this set?
So this is set in like a fae universe. Faerie.
Court of Thorns, when is it set?
That's also fae.
And what time period is it set in?
I don't, I get, it's a court, I think it's like a court book.
Sean and Maguire, middle game.
I don't know what time this is set in.
Is that why it's called the period?
No, I don't know.
What genre is it?
It's kind of like sci-fi, fantasy-ish.
That's suspicious if you ask me.
I found that comment to be very suspect.
Strange the Dreamer.
This is probably the most unique one out of all of them.
This is like set on a, in the clouds, in the sky, on a village in the sky.
Village in the sky, that sounds interesting.
Night Circus.
I just know that this is set in a circus.
Does it bear anything to do with her other books? Is it like in a universe or something?
No, not the same universe.
Is it also like fantasy type, faerie type stuff?
No, not faerie.
Faerie stuff, so fantasy circus.
In Night Circus, yeah.
Now, pause that though.
Do you remember those books that everyone liked when they were kids that were set in like a circus type thing?
Sanderson, have you read anything else by this person?
I haven't read any Sanderson before.
Is there any of these books that you've read from them before, other than, besides the obvious?
Megan, for God's sake, give to me.
No, only Leigh Bardugo and Erin Morgenstern.
Oh no, and Shawna Maguire I've read from before.
Time is up.
You've got to get rid of one.
I don't think you've made up Erin Morgenstern, for example.
Because, like, that's going to be harder to lie about because I'm aware of that author.
I wish I was just trying to get rid of a vegan.
Getting rid of a vegan would be far easier.
Shall we give you just that round as a free?
And then we do another round.
Because I don't feel like you've got to get into much detail.
No, it's tough, it's tough.
No, because we've only had a minute and a half anyway, so give me another minute and a half.
I think we'll start doing two minute rounds.
Now you have to get rid of one.
Are any of these books written by vegans?
I don't know if any of these books are vegans.
Well, we'll just have to wait and see.
You are so inquisitive, my darling.
The Cruel Prince.
Yeah.
Is one of the most suspicious of.
Are you aware of any of the main characters in it?
No, ma'am.
No.
No, ma'am.
I know that they are called Jude and Carden.
Jude and Carden.
The two lead characters.
Court of Thorns and Roses.
I know nothing about the main characters in that.
I know, I know her name begins with F.
It's like fair, fair.
She is kidnapped.
Because it's a Beating the Beast retelling.
And so she's like kidnapped into this fairy court.
You said that earlier.
Maybe I'm trying to trick you.
Maybe you are.
But you generally speaking make a pretty bad liar.
Sorry, I stopped recording.
Megan said that this sounds like the characters of Roger and Dodger.
Yeah.
Which to me sounds like bullshit.
I'm intrigued by this one.
This sounds like a really interesting book.
Setting Clouds.
Do you know where this author is from or where it gets the motivation from?
I think she's American.
But I don't know.
I don't know other than that.
It sounds anime like.
Brandon Sanderson.
I know that her dad was a pilot.
And she really wants to be a pilot.
But he like quit.
Like you know in military when they run away.
He did that.
And so he's seen as like a traitor.
And so she's not allowed to go into the pilot school.
Okay, that sounds quite interesting as well.
You have got to get rid of one now.
Okay, easy.
Caught Thorns and Roses is number one culprit at this moment in time.
Success.
A because Megan was putting on a typical face when she lies.
But then she could be aware of the fact that I know what that face looks like.
So it's really difficult to tell.
Beating the Beast retelling.
If you're going to make up a story.
It's really easy to make up a story like cover.
That it's just a retelling of something else.
Because then it doesn't involve much brain power.
Also it's got a ---- front cover.
And I just don't like the look of it.
So I'll go.
Shall we go again?
I feel pretty confident.
But I don't know.
Okay, Six of Crows.
You got this in the collector's edition.
I did.
You have it in the normal edition as well.
I don't.
How much does this relate to her kind of Discworld-y type universe?
It's set in the same universe.
But like that the Shadow and Bone trilogy is kind of set in like a fake Russia.
This geology is set in like a fake Amsterdam.
Fake Amsterdam?
Yeah.
I think somebody's trying to set me up.
I believe it.
Fake Amsterdam?
Yeah, fake Amsterdam.
Why would anyone want to fake Amsterdam?
It's already...
It's got a lot of canals.
So it doesn't bear any relation to the woman who beams light out of her chest?
No, but it's set in the same universe.
I believe...
Are they aware of each other?
I think some...
I don't know if she's aware.
But I think some of the characters in that book are aware of the characters in this book.
I think they appear.
Roger and Dodger.
Yeah.
One's good at language.
One's good at math.
The guy who created them wants to be gods and become a god with them.
Quickly, the Cruel Prince.
Yeah.
This is one of the most famous books.
Really?
This is the most famous?
Yeah, one of the most famous.
Because it's the weakest front cover left on the table.
Number one, please judge me.
Number two, please hate me.
Because number three, I love it.
I'm getting my head in the muddle because, to me, Roger and Dodger just don't scream
through this front cover.
But I can kind of get the whole kind of god-sting because it's got stuff at the top of his fingertips
in traditional art.
It's like God's touching man and stuff and he's creating life with his fingers.
At the same time, if you want to be a god, why the **** you calling anything Roger and
Dodger?
Is he some sort of Dennis the Menace fan or something?
So, I'm going to get rid of this one for that reason.
Because Roger and Dodger, and even if it is a real book, that's a crime, calling your
characters Roger and Dodger.
Sorry if you're called Dodger out there.
I'm going to up it to two and a half minutes so we can get a bit more in depth for some
of these, okay?
A bit more in depth, okay.
As you understand this book, how much does the front cover pertain to the actual plot?
I know that there are two magicians in the circus who are kind of like falling in love
but they are also battling against one another.
Of these books here, how many of them follow your traditional story arcs in that they're
like beginning, middle and end?
I think The Cruel Prince is a very typical book.
These are all series apart from The Night Circus.
Oh, so that's a standalone?
That's a standalone, the other four are all parts of series.
Okay, well that looks like it was part of a series.
That's interesting.
Like the culture of the sky people, is that based on any sort of culture?
I think it's kind of medieval.
They were like, from what I know, they were wiped out by a plague.
Not wiped out by a plague, but like the society has been really badly affected by a plague
in medieval times.
That sounds weird to me because if I'm thinking of making a book about sky people I'd think
they'd be like technologically advanced.
Well it's to do with dreams.
Oh, dreams.
Right, it's the dreamer.
So our protagonist believes that he can heal the society through dreams.
So through like collecting.
People writing weird stuff.
Through collecting.
He starts with insects and it's kind of him trying to get more power by getting the dreams
of more concept.
You're not lying about that.
That is nailed on true.
If you're lying about that, that's masterful.
The whole insect thing because there's bugs on the front.
Night Circus, I don't think you're lying about either.
Six of Crows, I don't think you're lying about either.
Cruel Prince is the suspect.
Okay, my logic is that if you've got like a really telling front cover.
So Six of Crows, telling front cover, at least for me anyway.
Night Circus, everything Megan described related to the front cover.
Sanderson, that makes loads of sense.
The Stranger Dreamer, that was one I was suspicious of because it's a slightly more vague front
cover until Megan managed to tie in the whole insect thing.
Maybe it's because I've lacked questioning of it, which is like, well, should I really
get rid of that?
But at the same time, I haven't questioned it much because I can't tell a lot from the
front cover because to me, like along with the Crown Thorns book, Court of Thorns and
Roses, it looks like a really generic front cover.
Maybe I'm a bit of a weird one for that, but it just looks like.
They're probably the most generic YA.
They're the most popular YA series.
So I might get rid of this because the other four seem like stories that hold water.
They're water type.
So for that reason, The Cruel Prince is out.
Okay.
And I am confident in those three that I have gotten rid of the mole.
Okay.
Is that your final answer?
That's me.
I'm sealing it shut.
You lost.
I lost?
You lost?
Right.
Okay.
Wait.
I won a contest.
Wow.
Maybe I just didn't try.
Okay.
I think I questioned The Six of Crows least.
And maybe I was intimidated by the fact it was by the most famous author, at least that
I'm aware of.
Yeah.
And that's why I was like, well, you're not going to pick the one that is the most author's
famous, the most famous author to lie about because that's giving you a harder job because
I'm more likely to be aware of the things she writes.
I'm like.
Yeah.
You're very aware of like what I've read.
So I'm going to assume that is the one, but if it's one of the bottom three, I'm very
impressed by your capabilities.
It's not Six of Crows.
I didn't lie to you about that.
Wow.
Do you want me to tell you which one I lied to you about?
Yeah.
Go on.
There's Strange the Dreamer by Laini Taylor.
You made that one up.
I made it up.
You spend all that time thinking you've won.
Turns out you've got nothing.
I was so certain it was the first book I got rid of.
I was like, she just said it begins with F. She was giggling.
You did really well on that.
Thanks.
Yeah.
I mean, it was a ******* weird thing you made.
Did you make up the whole Sky People?
Yeah.
No, I made it all up.
And I was like, that is such a bizarre story that no, she wouldn't have made that up, the
whole Cloud People.
Well, let's talk about the ones I got rid of.
Because they sounded more generic, Megan is surely going to craft a story which is more
generic and is easier to lie about, if that makes sense.
Don't underestimate me.
I didn't necessarily underestimate you.
I think if I was going to do it, I think what I'm saying is I probably underestimated your
gamble.
Because I'm actually thoroughly impressed with what you managed to come up with here.
You should be proud of yourself.
Thanks.
Because actually, once I got rid of Court of Thorns, I was pretty confident that-
You'd done it.
I'd done it.
And not only that, I was like, oh, this video is going to, we have to make a new one because
this is going to be three minutes long.
But that is actually quite cool.
Maybe you could do it over Skype or something with another booktuber and try and fool them
because it's easier for me.
Yeah, it's piss easier for you.
No, no.
You can pull out books that they've never heard of before.
I'm interested to see if you guys would have done a better job as well.
I think they would have done.
Well, they probably know-
They know all the books.
But surely.
Okay, right.
You tell me.
You hear something about Roger and Dodger and you're like, I'm getting rid of that.
Roger and Dodger, no way.
Maybe I was a bit hasty on the whole Cool Prince thing.
So which of these are you most looking forward to reading?
So, well, of course Thorns and Roses and the Cool Prince, I only earned per video.
I would not have any interest reading these necessarily otherwise.
So I only earned them per video.
That's maybe what came through to me, the fact that they were suspicious, the fact that
you didn't have the same sort of energy about them.
Of the two that I thought sounded the most interesting was The Night Circus and Strange
the Dream of Your Life.
If I was going to read any of them, I would have read that one.
Maybe that's what convinced me.
I would definitely read that.
That had the most interesting premise.
And this one interested me because it was a standalone.
I think, personally, I would always choose to read a standalone over a series.
Thank you very much for watching, everyone.
Let us know if you liked it and we'll do it again.
Yeah.
I just can't believe you won that.
I thought they had no chance of winning.
I can't believe it.
I can't.
Thank you very much for watching.
We hope you enjoyed and I'll see you very soon with another video.
Bye!