The Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 is a grail watch for many. It was a grail watch for me. The 5711 is nearly impossible to get at retail and about two years ago, I got VERY lucky when I got a call from my local AD that he had a blue dial Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 and it was mind if I wanted it. If you've seen my watch collection video, you've heard this whole story--which, if you haven't, I recount here (good on a second listen too!)--but what you hadn't known until today is that I did in, fact, sell my Patek Philippe 5711. Why did sell it? How much did I sell it for? It's a great story. Enjoy!
So what's funny is that on the He Spoke Style website,
or well, in the dashboard section of WordPress
on the He Spoke Style website,
there is a draft of a post that I started writing
on August 22nd, 2018.
So just over two years ago.
And the title of that post is
The Unbelievable Story of How I Got a 5711 at Retail.
I never finished writing that post,
and if you consider the title of this video,
you're probably wondering, what happened?
You're watching He Spoke Style.
I'm Brian Sacawa.
If you are new to this channel,
here at He Spoke Style, you will find all the tips,
knowledge, and inspiration you need to dress well,
feel more confident, and unlock your potential.
So everyone knows that the Blue Dial 5711
is an almost impossible watch to find at retail.
It's extremely desirable.
Everyone wants it.
If you haven't watched my watch collection video already,
and you don't know the story
of how I came by a 5711 at retail,
I'll just kind of recap here really quickly.
So when my wife and I bought our house
about two and a half years ago,
there's a Patek AD just around the corner.
So the first time I went in there,
the owner asked me what I wanted.
I told him what everyone wants.
He laughed at me.
I said, go ahead, put my name on the list.
And by the way, I live pretty much right around the corner.
Some time goes by, I stop in occasionally
just to remind him that I'm interested,
and that I do live pretty much right around the corner.
Some more time goes by, like maybe two or three months,
and then I'm driving and I get a phone call.
He's got the watch and it's mine if I want it.
There was a little agonizing going on
because A, it's a lot of money,
and B, we were going on our honeymoon not long after that.
So long story short, I did the deal.
I traded a couple of watches and paid the rest in cash.
I love that watch.
I wore it a lot, very versatile.
And I know a lot of people are probably wondering,
weren't you worried about wearing it
and scratching it up and stuff like that?
And honestly, no.
I feel like if you don't wear your watches,
regardless of the price, I think that's the wrong approach.
I think you should enjoy the things you have and use them.
Of course, take care of it,
but I never really had any fear when I was wearing it.
So, okay, yeah, I loved it.
I had this crazy watch that nobody could get their hands on.
So what exactly happened to prompt me
to consider selling it?
Well, I'll tell you.
So I have the Chrono24 app,
and in that app, it has a section
where you can put in your watch collection.
You choose the exact watch you have,
and you put in the purchase price.
Then what it does is it basically tracks the market,
the demand for that particular watch,
as well as what they are trading
or selling for on the secondary market.
And then it will show you the percentage increase
or decrease in value based on all of those factors.
So I had put the 5711 in my collection,
in that app, pretty soon after I bought it,
and that was kind of the last I thought of it,
until one day in mid-2019,
when I happened to open up the app
and look at how much this watch had appreciated.
I knew that secondary market prices
were really high for the 5711,
but I guess I wasn't aware of just how kind of
out of control that it had gotten.
Now, I want you to understand
that I do not buy watches as investments.
I buy them because I love them,
and I buy them because I want to wear them.
Having said that, when I saw what that watch was going for,
don't worry, you will find out the price.
For the first time, I started to consider selling it,
and here are three reasons why.
As I mentioned, I had been kind of peripherally aware
of the value of the 5711 on the secondary market.
It had been going up and up and up,
and literally from the day I bought mine,
people were trying to buy it right off my wrist.
It's kind of insane, the hysteria around this watch.
And the price that was valued on the secondary market,
I thought, there can't be any way
that this thing goes any higher.
A basically brand new steel sports watch,
and if I ever wanted to sell it, now was the time.
So I checked around with some collector friends of mine,
and they basically shared the same opinion.
Second, the watch started to take on
kind of a different persona in, let's call it,
the broader watch universe.
Because it is so ridiculously impossible
for just a normal person without a huge history
of spending a lot of money at an 80 to get one,
there was a lot of negative energy,
not directed at me personally,
but just for the watch in general.
So it became this sort of really ultra elite
middle finger to the world,
and I just didn't really like that whole connotation.
I love the watch.
I don't choose things based on what people think of them,
but that was just a little something that I had in my mind.
Third, there was a lot we could do with that money.
As you'll remember, we had just moved into this house,
and there were definitely some improvements
we wanted to make.
We had probably a year or so left on our vehicle loans,
so we could pay those off.
Any little credit card debt we had,
we could just get rid of.
So between the timing,
the negative sentiment around the 5711,
all of the things that we could do with the profit,
and the fact that I didn't really have
any kind of sentimental attachment to the watch
really kind of helped me make the decision.
The craziest part about this whole story
is how this deal went down.
Now, what I want you to know about me
before we get into this part of the story
is that I am not fabulously wealthy.
I've worked very hard for the things that I have,
probably spent a little too much money
on things I shouldn't have, like 5711.
So what I want to say is that if you are shocked
by the numbers you're going to see, I am too.
This is not just another day in the life of Brian Sacawa.
Anyway, so understanding the timeline here is important.
It's a Saturday.
It's about 10 o'clock in the morning.
I'm at the gym.
I texted my friend, Eric Wind of Wind Vintage.
He's a vintage watch dealer.
Told him the deal, told him the price,
and asked if he'd be interested.
It's not really his market
because he's more in the vintage watch world,
and this is a modern watch,
but he said he'd definitely help broker the sale.
So just so happened that he had a client
who was looking for a 5711 blue dial,
and he was gonna reach out to him for me.
Literally 30 minutes later, I'm still at the gym.
Eric texts me back and says he got one yesterday,
but I might have someone else
that I can reach out to on Monday.
So I text another friend,
really big figure in the watch world,
tell him what I'm doing, what I'm selling it for.
Would he be interested?
Definitely had some friends who'd be interested,
but he didn't feel comfortable offering it to them
for what I was asking.
Okay, so now it's noon.
I'm sitting at the pool,
and I reach out to a guy
who's been trying to buy this thing off my wrist
since I got it.
Again, here's the deal.
It's yours for this price.
Of course, I tried to rip his eyes out a little bit.
He countered.
It wasn't insulting.
It was actually more than a fair price, and that was it.
Within a two-hour time span,
sitting at the pool, I sold this watch.
All right, so what everyone wants to know,
what did I sell it for?
Let's go over the numbers.
So the price of the 5711 at retail was $29,980.
I traded a couple of watches,
and I got $5,000 for the trade,
which made the final purchase price $24,880.
I know it's ridiculous and a ton of money for a watch.
So I sold the watch for $68,000,
which gave me a total profit of $43,120.
Do I miss it?
Sometimes, but not really.
Do I regret selling it?
Not at all.
And honestly, it was one of the best investments
I ever made, even though I did not approach
buying this watch as an investment.
I wore it a lot, had my fun with it.
It was quite an experience,
and my collection continues to evolve.