Apple Pencil Alternatives - A Roundup of the Best iPad Styluses

Tech Level
93 followers
5 Video Views·Dec 11, 2022
You asked for it.
We're doing it.
An iPad stylus roundup.
Hello, my name is Brad
and I review tech for creative professionals.
And today, was that the question?
Hey, Brad, have you heard of the future
mega stylus 8500 K?
It's for the iPad.
It's new and I'm wondering if it's any good
and you should do a review.
Ah, I get this question a lot
and I usually don't answer it
because people don't appreciate answers
that just are me screaming.
No.
So I shouted into the void instead.
No.
There are literally hundreds of iPad styluses out there
and it's impossible to review them all.
In fact, this video started with the idea
where I thought maybe I can go out there
and review every single iPad stylus ever made.
I don't really have the budget for that.
What I did wanna do was a roundup
where I talk about the type of styluses out there.
So when you see something,
you can look at it and say,
yeah, that's a smart stylus
or oh, that's a dumb stylus
or oh, that one has a lot of potential
but it doesn't do its homework
and it's failing now, stylus.
First, there's one important thing to know
and that is there's two eras of iPads
when we're talking about styluses.
There's older iPads
and there's iPads that have come out in the last two years.
You're gonna have a lot more luck
finding a stylus that works for you
if you have a newer iPad.
If you don't, I haven't forgotten about you.
I talk about options at the end of this video.
So go to the point that I'll link down below
if you wanna get that info.
Also in the description,
I'm gonna link to a bunch of these styluses
and what you're gonna see in the description
of these products are what generation of iPad
they work best with.
And you might wonder to yourself,
what generation iPad do I have?
It doesn't tell me.
Well, there is an easy way to know.
On the back of your iPad,
in teeny, tiny, itty bitty type,
you're gonna see a model number.
Write that down, type it into the Googles
and it's gonna be able to tell you
what generation of iPad you have.
Cool?
All right, let's get to the styli.
All right, so let's start at the top.
The Apple Pencil 1 and 2.
If you want the best, this is the best
as far as drawing experience, accuracy,
pressure sensitivity, palm rejection.
These are identical to each other
and they might be the best drawing experience
you're gonna find literally anywhere on any device.
These are great.
So Apple Pencil 2 currently only works
on the 2018 and 2020 iPad Pros.
If it's got that flat edge to it,
that lets it charge when it's connected
to the side of your iPad.
It connects magnetically.
The original Apple Pencil, however,
works on the original iPad Pros models,
but it's also going to work
on the newer, more inexpensive iPads.
This includes the 2019 iPad Mini and iPad Air
and the iPads with no other words
attached to the back of them.
The one that came out just last fall
and also the one that came out in the spring of 2018.
I believe this is the 6th and 7th gen iPads.
The main difference between the Apple Pencil 1
and the Apple Pencil 2 is how it charges.
That Apple Pencil 2 needs to be plugged
into a little adapter it came with
and then plugged into a lightning cable
or plugged into the back of the iPad.
Nice thing about the Apple Pencil
is it doesn't take long to charge.
If you're out and about and you run out of charge,
you can plug it into the back of your iPad
for a few minutes and you're gonna get
another half hour, 45 minutes of work out of it.
But why doesn't Apple let me use the Pencil on older iPads?
Great question.
The Pencil uses a combination of Bluetooth
and sensors under the screen of your iPad itself
to make the Apple Pencil work so well.
So this isn't just the stylus doing all the work,
it's the iPad working in conjunction
with the stylus.
So older iPads don't have the sensors under the screen,
they can't work with those Apple Pencils.
That's the secret sauce.
But Apple has been opening up the secret sauce a little bit.
We're gonna see that when I demo the next group of styluses.
But before I do that, I wanna talk a little bit
about drawing control on your iPad
and how to make it so much better
using today's sponsor, Paperlike.
I've always found that the iPad's smooth glass screen
to be a little bit too smooth.
I like having some texture there
to give me more drawing control,
cleaner lines, more stable lines.
It feels so much more natural like drawing on paper.
It also makes this really cool noise.
There is a link for Paperlike down in the description.
You can get one of these to fit any size iPad.
Also, I hear they're giving out
some free Procreate brushes as a promotion.
Check that link down below.
All right, time to look at some of the third-party styluses.
I have three over here to check out.
Things really started opening up with iOS 12.2
or iPadOS 12.2, no matter what you wanna call it.
This gave stylus makers a lot more tools to work with
and dramatically improve the accuracy
and performance of styluses on iPads.
And that's why you're seeing like on Amazon
so many new styluses coming out
because they're so much easier to make than they used to be.
So what I have here, this is the Logitech Crayon.
This is the first one I'm gonna be taking a look at.
And Apple originally opened up a little bit to Logitech
when they first announced these
for the base-level sixth-generation iPads.
These were originally built for the education market.
Let me turn this thing on.
It has an Apple Pencil-like tip,
but it's hard to take this top off, which is probably good.
You can't really fiddle with it
like you can an Apple Pencil, which is good for kids.
Also, it's kind of squarish,
so it's not gonna just roll off.
It might slide off your iPad,
but it's not gonna roll off a desk
like the round Apple Pencil,
even though the original Apple Pencil
is weighted for that sort of thing.
With kids, they'll make it roll.
And one thing that this has done really well
is that you get palm rejection.
So my palm is down on the canvas and I can draw.
Yay, that's fantastic.
That works great.
You also get accuracy.
You're gonna notice that as you draw,
you're getting great performance, great accuracy.
So this is, in many ways,
just as good as the Apple Pencil.
But there's one way that it isn't,
and that is pressure sensitivity.
And as you can see, I just get boring lines.
If I was going to sync my Apple Pencil to this and draw,
you'd see that the pen that I'm using
has a lot of flow to it.
It has a lot of pressure to it.
So that's the main thing that's missing.
So if you're looking to take notes
and you don't care about pressure sensitivity,
the Logitech Crayon is not a bad way to go.
This is actually a really good stylus.
The next one I wanna take a look at is this.
This is the Adonit Note Plus.
And I chose this one because this is one
of the more expensive Bluetooth styli out there.
And I'm gonna be honest,
I've never had a ton of luck with Adonit styluses.
And unfortunately, this one's kind of the same.
So this, I don't know if it's using the same technology
that Logitech is using,
but you get a lot of the same benefits.
For example, I get the same accuracy I'm looking for.
I get palm rejection, that works really well.
One thing I do notice is that even on medium speed strokes,
I am getting some kind of wobble to it.
So if I draw, maybe you can see a little bit more wave
than say, let's see if this still works.
The Logitech pencil, well, maybe they're about the same.
This feels a little bit more wiggly.
The thing that this, the reason this is more expensive
is that it's using Bluetooth
to emulate pressure sensitivity.
It doesn't work in all apps.
It should work in Procreate.
I'm not sure why it doesn't, so who knows?
Maybe if I do this live, it'll work.
I've tried many different things and it hasn't.
So I'm gonna connect my stylus,
I'm gonna go to Adonit and I tap and hold
and it says, none stylus, no.
I think that's pretty clear that this isn't going to work.
I'm gonna jump over to another painting program
where this should work.
Let's see if we have more luck there.
All right, so here I am in Medibang Paint.
I'm in the stylus section and it says,
turn on power and press with the stylus tip.
So I don't know if you can see that,
but the little blue light is on.
So I'll tap and hold and basically,
I get this for a very long time.
It never actually connects and I hate to say it,
but this is something, this is the third time
I've used an Adonit stylus and I just never
can get these dang things to work
and when they do, they're really clunky.
So my advice is if you have something
that works with an Apple Pencil,
you could save $20 with this,
but from what I've seen from other reviews
and my personal experiences, it's not really worth it.
It's really worth going with a good Apple Pencil
instead of going with something like the Note Plus.
All right, this one is called the U-ogic.
I'll spell it down below in the description.
So these things or things like these are all over Amazon.
There's literally hundreds of them.
They all look like the Apple Pencil.
I think it even connects magnetically.
No, it does not connect magnetically, my bad.
Some of them do.
These are all very similar and this is a kind of stylus
that's very similar to these two.
Let me go ahead and draw.
No pressure sensitivity, great accuracy,
very good palm rejection.
I have noticed with this one,
there is a ton of mechanical wave coming out across this.
So, you know, I guess if you're note taking
and you don't care about mechanical wave,
it's not that big of a deal.
However, for drawing, this probably isn't the best bet.
These usually run you about 30 or $40.
So if you don't care, you just want a stylus
where you can jot down notes and draw arrows on screenshots
and things like that.
You know, a $30 stylus, $35 stylus like this,
it's gonna work pretty well.
And there's a ton of them out there.
For drawing, not so much.
All right, in this section,
I'm talking about styluses out there
that are going to work on older iPads.
Now, one thing I do want to say
is that before the newer iPads came out
four or five years ago, there were Bluetooth styluses.
They weren't particularly good.
They were laggy.
They didn't have the accuracy that you were looking for.
They were really weird
and nobody really makes them anymore.
I went searching for one
to see if I could find one that was available.
I found some that were used, but there were none new.
So I didn't bother because basically
they're just not an option anymore
because they're not on the market.
The things you're gonna find are,
this is the dumbest of the styluses
that you're gonna get out there.
This is basically just a metal tube with a spongy tip.
And this is easier to draw with than say your finger
because your finger obscures a good chunk of the screen.
Whereas this makes it a little easier
to see what you're doing.
But that's about all you're gonna get.
This is like a big metal finger.
All right, the next stylus I want to take a look at
is this little guy.
This has a little wobbly tip on it, a little disc tip.
So it has the point of a pencil.
So when you look down,
this is obscuring a good portion of your canvas
when you're drawing.
This disc tip is clear and you can see through it.
So when I go to draw, it feels more accurate
and it's actually surprisingly accurate.
Now, as far as other things go,
it doesn't have palm recognition.
So like I went to draw there
and it's like, what's going on?
The canvas doesn't know what's going on.
For handwriting, oops,
it's very easy to accidentally touch the canvas.
You know, for handwriting, this isn't so good.
It's just not quite accurate enough.
The loops don't feel right.
I tried to draw the letter Y and it's just not,
I don't know, it's just weird.
It just feels off compared to the other styluses.
However, in a pinch, something like this will work.
All right, I'm getting rid of the new iPad Pro
so I can bring in the old seventh gen iPad here.
Actually, this is the new seventh gen iPad,
but I wanted to show you something.
See this goofy looking cord?
Yes, I'm using something called the Sonar Pen
and this works on older iPads
and I have no idea how it works,
but it's using some kind of information
that it's pulling from the headphone jack
or pushing to the headphone jack, probably pulling,
to actually do pressure sensitivity.
This one has a disc tip like the other stylus we saw
and when I draw with this,
I apply more pressure and I get more pressure.
I also get a surprising amount of accuracy
when I'm drawing with this.
Let me see if I can,
yeah, I'm getting pressure sensitivity.
How do I increase brush size in Medibang?
All right, let's try this.
There we go, apply more pressure.
I'm getting a thicker line, less pressure
and getting a thinner line, yeah.
So this works.
I wouldn't call it super responsive.
That is not something that this is, but it does work.
It's gonna get you further
than some of those other dumb styluses out there
and how much does this cost?
Forgot to look at the website when I was looking at this.
Let me decrease the size.
Palm rejection is so-so with this.
Let me see, yeah, this is gonna work with my palm on it.
No, that's not gonna work.
Okay, so palm rejection is horrible as expected.
So let's try just a little bit of handwriting.
It's okay, you know, like I expect the D to look like a D.
I expect the A to look like an A.
So, you know, when you start writing and drawing fast,
you're missing bits and pieces.
But this is definitely working better than the other ones.
Also, this is so annoying.
Like if you, this is like going to the bank
where they don't wanna steal your pens.
That's what this is doing
and this is not fun to just bang against your wrist all day.
But in a pinch, you got the Sonar Pen.
So that is our roundup of the styluses
that are available for the iPad.
If you have any questions or comments,
let me know down below in the comment section.
Thank you guys for watching
and I'll talk to you in a couple of days.
