Wacom One - VS - Huion Kamvas 13 - Smackdown!

Tech Level
93 followers
6 Video Views·Dec 11, 2022
This video is sponsored by Squarespace.
In this episode of Smackdown,
I'm taking a look at the new Wacom One
and the new Huion Canvas 13.
They have a lot in common,
but which one of these is gonna get out of a chokehold?
Hello, my name is Brad,
and I review tech for creative professionals,
illustrators, designers, gangs of monkeys
fighting in the street.
That was not on my Apocalypse Bingo card.
At CES this year, Wacom and Huion
both showed off new 13-inch pen displays,
basically fancy monitors you can plug into your computer
and draw on using their pressure-sensitive pens
that they come with.
These two devices are incredibly similar,
not just in size, but in the features
they've added to them,
specifically their ability to be used
with Android phone and tablets.
They are so similar, in fact,
that we need to have a Smackdown.
Let's go.
Head to head, they both have 13.3-inch displays.
The resolution on both of these is full HD,
1920 pixels by 1080 pixels.
The width, the height, the thickness,
they vary a little bit, but they're pretty close.
The weight is 2.2 pounds for the Wacom
versus the 2.16 pounds for the Huion,
so roughly the same.
Color profiles are a little harder to judge
because they're listing these at different standards,
but we've got Wacom at an NTSC 72% color range
and the Huion at a 120 sRGB range.
You would think that 120 is better than 72,
but really, these are pretty comparable.
Pen pressure of the Wacom is 4,096 levels.
The pen pressure of the Huion is 8,192 levels.
Both of these pens have 60 degrees of pen rotation
and both screens have a 1,000 to one contrast ratio.
So all in all, these devices are very similar,
but they have some differences.
Let's get to those.
First up, we've got the pen pressure.
And what about that?
Huion's got twice as much.
Well, eh, I don't think that's such a big deal.
How much pen pressure you get into a pen
doesn't necessarily tell you how that pen performs.
What is a big deal here
is that this is not Wacom's Pro Pen 2
that comes with all of their other pen displays.
Instead, this is the same pen technology
that Wacom licenses out to other tablet companies
and manufacturers to use in their devices.
So when you see a pen
that comes with the Samsung phone or tablet, for example,
that's actually using Wacom's technology under the hood.
And the pen that's in the Wacom One is the same thing.
In fact, you can take that pen
and draw on an Android device if it's pen compatible.
Now, even though I don't like it
quite as much as the Pro Pen 2,
it's still really good.
Huion, on the other hand,
has cleaned up a lot of the problems
they've had with their pens in the past.
Both of these devices have a little bit of line hooking
when you're drawing faster lines.
But if you're looking for steady, smooth lines
with no wave or no jitter,
both perform extremely well.
And I personally would have killed for this three years ago.
And that's good news
because the number one thing you want in a drawing tablet
is the ability to draw.
Both of these do this very well.
So the winner of this round goes to Huion.
I guess this is really close to a tie.
You can't go wrong with either,
but I'm gonna give the Huion a little bit of an edge here.
The other big difference between these
is something called screen lamination.
Biggest difference in the experience here
you're gonna get in these devices
is that the Huion 13 comes with a laminated screen
and the Wacom One does not.
What Huion's doing here is reducing the amount of space
between the glass and the screen below it.
There's usually a little bit of an error gap there
and they are reducing that gap.
When your pen hits the glass above the screen,
there's gonna be no gap between where your pen tip is
and where that cursor appears below it.
This is a really nice upgrade.
It does make the Huion feel more like a modern device.
And overall, it makes the pen feel more accurate
when you're drawing.
In these days, we're all used to looking at our phones
and most phones made in the last four or five years
have these kind of laminated displays.
There isn't a big gap of air
between the glass and the screen below it.
So this feels so much more modern.
So this was an easy one.
The winner of this round is Huion.
Now, before we get too deep,
I wanna thank today's sponsor, Squarespace.
From websites to online stores
to marketing tools and analytics,
Squarespace is the all-in-one platform
to build a beautiful online presence and run your business.
I keep finding new features every time I look under the hood.
There's an entire section
that lets you add online booking and scheduling
for your classes or sessions.
It integrates right into Squarespace's websites.
Client can easily see your availability
and reschedule if they need to,
taking the hassle out of coordinating calendars.
Check out squarespace.com for a free trial.
And when you're ready to launch,
go to squarespace.com slash Brad Colbo
to save 10% on your first purchase of a website or domain.
Next up, we gotta talk about the stand.
The Wacom One doesn't come with a stand per se,
but instead, it has two feet that you can pull
out of the back and set up on an angle.
That angle's about 19 degrees.
It's pretty comfortable for me personally,
but if you want it to be a little bit higher,
you're gonna find this to be limiting,
and you're probably gonna wanna purchase
an adjustable stand separately.
The Huion doesn't come with a stand either.
Can be added on for another $25
if you're ordering from Huion's website.
Something worth pointing out is that many of the displays,
by the time they come over to the States
and they're listed on Amazon for you to buy,
are probably gonna have the stand packed in.
So if you're looking at another website
that's not Huion's and looking to buy one of these,
check those details to see if the stand comes with it.
The stand that mine came with isn't too bad.
You can set it at a couple different angles,
not a ton of variation here,
but I found that all the angles were pretty comfortable,
and overall, I like the stand.
It was pretty good.
This is a toss-up, I'm not sure who to give it to.
I think by a hair, I'm gonna give it to Wacom
because the Huion isn't guaranteed to have the stand,
whereas the Wacom will always have the feet.
The next category is shortcut keys.
Oh, we have a winner already.
It's Huion, because they actually have shortcut keys.
That was too easy.
Wacom's been removing these from their pen displays
the last couple of years,
and on their high-end Pro models,
I don't really mind so much
because the ExpressKey remote comes packed in.
I love those remotes.
You can place them anywhere, move them around.
It's really convenient,
but that remote is also really expensive.
Right now, you can pick one up for about $100,
and they don't pack those in
with these less expensive displays.
Some people don't care.
Personally, I'm a big fan of the shortcut keys.
It's just easier than keeping track
of your keyboard over here
and your drawing display over here
and shuffling between the two.
It also helps that the Huion keys are totally customizable.
Now, on the Canvas 13, there aren't a ton of them here,
but they work well.
You know, they're shortcut keys.
You can set them to zooming, change brush sizes,
anything you can think of.
So that award goes to, okay, I already announced it.
It was Huion.
The connection.
Both of these come with combo cables
for connecting to your computer,
and these cables both work well.
So why are you bringing it up, Brad?
Why are you bringing it up?
Because the new Canvas 13 supports USB-C,
and the Wacom one doesn't.
However, I need to put an asterisk by all of this.
I talked about my connection woes
in my Huion 13 review video.
Basically, the USB-C port is not flush
with the side of the device,
but it's sunk in a little bit.
So most USB-C cables, or the six that I personally own,
were all too wide to fit in there, except for one.
But that brought up a different problem,
because not all USB-C cables
actually can transfer data and power at the same rate,
which means you need a higher-end cable
in order to run this thing,
and the one cable that actually fit
wasn't powerful enough to actually run the display.
I bought a brand new cable looking online,
hoping that it would fit in my device.
That one was too wide, too.
I ended up taking some sandpaper to it,
and that's how I solved that problem.
I like the idea.
Most new laptops are coming with USB-C ports,
and being able to have one cord
makes the Huion Canvas 13 slightly more portable.
I mean, it's small enough that you can fit it in the bag.
If you need one cord and you don't have to worry
about plugging it into a power supply or anything like that,
that's really convenient.
But I think in the future,
they either need to pack in that USB-C cable
that will fit and that will work properly,
or there is no other or.
They should just pack in the cable.
So the winner here is, I guess it's Huion.
All right, we're getting to the big one.
How do these work on Android?
So the big new feature on both of these
is the ability to connect to Android phones or tablets
and use these as a drawing display on those devices.
Confession time.
First time I used the Wacom One
and I saw this Android connection thing,
I thought, wow, this is really pretty cool.
And I think I was a little bit blinded
by just the newness of it and how unique it was.
And I ended up overlooking many of the shortcomings.
The second time I used it, I was less impressed
because one, it just wasn't as novel.
And by the third time I used it,
I thought, you know, I kind of hate this now.
All right, so let's list out some of these issues.
First, this doesn't work on all Android devices,
only a handful of them.
And those that it works on tend to be higher-end,
more expensive phones or tablet.
And many of those already come with a pen.
So the real question here is,
is if you have a tablet that comes with a pen,
why would you wanna plug a second screen into it?
Maybe the size?
These are more comfortable to draw on
than a relatively small phone screen.
Two is that the connections are moody.
You plug in the device
and then you have to dig through the settings
to turn on Samsung DeX.
And for both of these, oftentimes I'll lose the signal.
I just have to reconnect and dig through the settings again
to reconnect to DeX.
The connections I'm using are just unreliable.
Neither of these devices comes with the cords
that you need to connect them to Android.
You have to bring your own,
which as I mentioned before in the connection settings,
is not the easiest thing to do.
This might be the reason why my connection keeps going out,
at least on the Huion.
In Wacom's case, there's a lot that can go wrong
because I had to purchase a separate adapter
in order to set this thing up.
On top of that, the drawing apps are built for touch.
So the basic things that you would do
in an Android drawing app,
like pinching and zooming
to get to different areas of the drawing,
yet you can't do that here
because neither of these are touch tablets.
And once you get over the novelty of this whole thing,
it's kind of a frustrating experience.
In fact, it's definitely a frustrating experience.
And if you're looking at either of these
and what you're really interested in
are these Android features,
I would say this year, hold off.
Let's let this stuff mature a little bit
and see if it gets better.
So the winner of this category is,
oh, I'm not declaring a winner.
One more thing to talk about here.
This category is price.
This is easy to see.
Oftentimes, Wacom devices can make the case
that you're getting more for your money.
Maybe you're getting a better pen,
maybe a higher resolution screen,
maybe some Bluetooth features.
But here we have a Huion device that's very comparable
and in some ways, better.
Maybe Wacom could make the case
that it's a more established, well-known brand,
but the prices still would be well off.
If you're charging 25 or $50 more,
I think you can make that case.
But right now, if you bought the Huion with a stand,
you would still have enough money leftover to buy a stand,
a Wacom ExpressKey remote,
and one of those water bottle thingies
that rabbits and gerbils drink from.
So the winner for this round goes to Huion.
All right, it's time to declare
the overall winner of this Smackdown.
I'm giving it to Huion.
Why?
Most of the folks who are gonna be using this
are going to be using it as a pen display
that they connect to a laptop or a computer.
They're not gonna be paying attention
to those Android features.
It's significantly cheaper,
the pen drawing quality is just as good,
and you have amenities like the optional adjustable stand
and the shortcut keys that are missing from the Wacom.
At the end of the day, I think the big thing for me
was the price that tipped it over.
If there was a little bit of a price difference
between these two, probably wouldn't matter too much.
But there's a big one,
and Huion's really improved their quality
over the last couple of years,
and this is where it shows.
So if you have any comments or questions
or just wanna check out the reviews
of the other things that I've done, here you go.
Thank you for watching,
and I'll talk to you in a couple of days.
