Masaccio, Holy Trinity

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
16 Video Views·Dec 3, 2022
We're in Santa Maria Novella, and we're
looking at the left wall of the nave inside the left aisle.
About midway down is Masaccio's The Holy Trinity.
This is a painting that is often credited
as being the earliest known example
of true scientific one-point linear perspective.
Right, which had only been discovered by Bunaleschi
a few years earlier.
So it's really exciting to see it.
It is.
And it's an incredibly realistic illusion of space.
And these days, instead of entering
from the front door of the church,
you enter actually through the cloisters.
And this fresco is directly opposite the entrance.
It really looks as though this is an actual space and not just
an illusion.
It's funny to think that many wealthy families commissioned
an actual chapel.
In this case, it's a more modest commission,
which is the illusion of a chapel.
Let's talk a little bit about what's being represented,
what's actually going on here.
Well, down the center of the fresco,
we see the Holy Trinity.
And by Holy Trinity, we mean the three-part nature of God.
As understood in Catholic tradition.
At the top, we have God the Father.
Below, in the form of a dove, we have the Holy Spirit.
Now, that's a little hard to see.
And I think that sometimes people mistake
that white as a kind of collar.
Yeah, it looks a little like God's collar.
But if you look very closely, you
do see that there are two wings, a tail,
and the head of a bird.
And the head of a bird actually is
looking down towards Christ.
And also has a halo.
That's right.
It has a little radiating gold.
And so below the dove, which is the Holy Spirit,
we see Christ on the cross.
We have the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.
Now, this is an extraordinary rendering
of the human body, pulled and tortured
and really affected by gravity.
This is so far from the medieval treatment of the human body.
It's hard to imagine that Masaccio could have painted
this without actually stringing someone up on a cross
so he could observe what happened
to the muscles of the body and the way
that they would be pulled in this position.
It creates such a great sense of sympathy, at least in me
and I think in many viewers, to see the hollow of the abdomen.
Christ is bleeding.
His pain feels real and emotional in a way that
feels very direct and is such a great illustration of the way
in which the early Renaissance is
able to marry deep faithfulness with scientific observation.
So the other figures in the sacred space
within the room that's depicted are Mary in the dark cloak.
She's presenting her son to us.
I'm not sure that I can remember a more mournful Virgin Mary.
She's pointing up at Christ, showing us that Christ
is the path to salvation.
And on the opposite side, we see St. John's.
Mary and St. John are the two figures
that we often see in images of the crucifixion.
This isn't a narrative of the story of the crucifixion,
but rather a devotional image, an image
that would be an aid to prayer.
So the figures on the outside of the sacred space in a prayerful
position, kneeling, looking in and witnessing
as we're looking in and witnessing are the donors.
But there's even more to this painting
because below those steps is a representation of a tomb that's
been exposed, that's been opened for us.
And on that sarcophagus, we see a skeleton.
And an inscription in Latin.
And in rough translation would read,
as I am now, so you shall be.
As you are now, so once was I.
So the message is that death is inevitable,
that the skeleton is what we all will be.
And what the skeleton was was us, alive.
It's a memento mori.
It's a reminder of the imminence of our death,
even though we walk in our day-to-day lives
taking for granted our ability to wake up
the next morning.
Very soon, we will.
And at a time when we can't predict.
We will look like this skeleton.
I think there's a tendency in our modern era
to think about this as a reminder of death
and therefore to live life to its fullest.
But I think in the 15th century, the meaning was different.
It was a reminder of death.
Therefore, prepare now for your salvation
so that you can have eternity in heaven.
And the way to an eternal life in heaven
is indicated up above through Mary's gesture,
through Christ's sacrifice on the cross
for the sins of mankind.
Let's go back to the point that we
made at the very beginning, which is the innovation
of linear perspective here.
Because what Masaccio has done is
to create an incredibly convincing deep space.
Masaccio has created a very specific viewpoint
for the viewer.
As we stand in front of the painting,
we look up at the barrel vault created for us.
It's a wonderful classical ceiling, isn't it?
It is.
The whole architecture that Masaccio has created here
is based on the architecture of ancient Greeks and Rome.
We have a barrel vault with coffers.
So hold on.
Because it's so interesting.
If you're thinking that you're just
going to be tentatively exploiting
this new technique of linear perspective,
you might want to do something straightforward,
like a nice tiled floor.
But he's really showing off here.
He's really showing off.
He's showing off with the architecture,
with the linear perspective.
He's showing off with the figures.
Embracing humanism that's happening in Florence
in the early 15th century.
So the architecture looked modern.
The figures looked incredibly believable.
Because Masaccio is using modeling
to make the figures appear round and three dimensional,
we can really see it in the drapery of the figures
and in the body of Christ articulating his muscles.
So the figures looked, I think, radically new and real.
And the space looked radically new and real.
So he's creating this emphasis on the humanity
of this experience, on the emotion of this experience,
on the lifelikeness and proportional accuracy
of the bodies themselves.
And then, of course, he needs to have an accurate space in which
to place those human figures.
And so he's giving us both.
This very convincing sense of mass and volume and proportion
and anatomy, as well as emotion.
And then he's placing those figures in a space
that makes sense to us.
And one of the things that art historians have sometimes
asked is, why is a linear perspective developing here
in Florence in the 15th century?
And there's so many answers to this.
But one of the ways you might begin
to think about this is that here we have a culture of trade
where there really is a kind of mathematics
that underlies the economy of the city.
People are trained to be able to buy and sell.
They think about fractions.
They think about space volumes.
They think about commodities.
And so this is a very analytic and a very rational culture.
And in a sense, art had to respond to that.
To follow that thought forward, what Masaccio has done
is given us an interior that is rational,
that we could enter it.
And from the information that he's given us,
even from this limited view, we could
do a very accurate drawing and really determine its depth,
its width, and its internal decoration.
Masaccio is doing in painting what
Donatello has already done in sculptures,
create figures who are deeply human and real.
The humanism that inspires this is something
that's here in Florence, in that sculptors
were able to respond to earlier because they
had the example of ancient Greek and Roman sculpture.
So Donatello in sculpture is responding
to this revival of interest in the classical Greece and Rome.
And then we have Masaccio following not long
after with a kind of illusionism that
allows for the same sets of issues.
It's, to a large extent, Brunelleschi as well.
Some people have suggested that Brunelleschi had worked
with Masaccio on the architectural setting.
We have Corinthian plasters, attached columns
with ionic capitals.
There's the coffered vaulting.
The round arch.
The architecture that Masaccio represented here
would have looked startlingly modern,
I think, to anyone looking at it in the early 15th century.
It would have looked very different, for example,
than the architecture we see around us in this church.
So in Florence, in the 15th century, you have sculpture,
you have architecture, you have painting,
all responding to this revival of interest in humanism.
This notion that man can observe, understand,
and to some extent control his world,
and that this is and can be in the service of God.
