As we battle this pandemic and seek to prevent the next, we might look to history for lessons. The worst disease that has ever afflicted humanity is also the only one we’ve ever eradicated. Dr. Larry Brilliant lived this history as part of the global campaign to end smallpox. In this video, he reflects on the long history of humanity’s battle against smallpox and how the world finally found the public will to defeat its old foe at the end of the twentieth century.
Like what you see? This video is part of a comprehensive social studies curriculum from OER Project, a family of free, online social studies courses. OER Project aims to empower teachers by offering free and fully supported social studies courses for middle- and high-school students. Your account is the key to accessing our standards-aligned courses that are designed with built-in supports like leveled readings, audio recordings of texts, video transcripts, and more. Register today at oerproject.com!
An invisible enemy stalked our species for thousands of years.
It killed three out of ten people it touched. Those who survived were left scarred for life.
The killer's name? Smallpox.
Among the many diseases that have plagued human history,
few are so deadly or so enduring as the smallpox virus.
It brought mighty empires to their knees, killing king and commoner alike.
In the 20th century alone, smallpox killed more people than World War I,
more than the Spanish flu, and more than World War II combined.
All this long terrible history and you probably never think about smallpox, do you?
Why not? Because it's gone.
Eradicated, humanity declared victory against its old enemy on May 8th, 1980.
Today, in the year 2022, we look back on over two years of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Many questions about our future remain unanswered.
When will the pandemic end? Can we eradicate COVID-19 virus altogether,
like we did with smallpox?
As we confront this uncertain future, we might look to history for guidance.
History won't help us predict the future, but as the only human infectious disease
we've ever eradicated, the long history of smallpox holds important lessons for today
and for tomorrow as we seek to prevent the next pandemic.
To understand this history, I turned to someone who lived it, Dr. Larry Brilliant.
An epidemiologist.
In the 1970s, Dr. Larry joined the WHO in India as part of a global effort to eradicate smallpox.
Smallpox is the worst, the most lethal disease in history.
It has that combination of how rapidly it spreads and how many people it kills
to make it the worst disease in history.
One case of smallpox would lead to four or five or six other cases.
It's very transmissible.
But unlike COVID or flu, instead of killing one person out of a thousand, out of a hundred,
one out of every three people who got smallpox died.
And they were usually little children.
90, 95 percent of the time, it was spread by respiration like the flu or like COVID.
But when it got into your body, it attacked all of the mucous surfaces,
the inside of your nose, the inside of your mouth, the inside of your throat,
your intestinal system, all throughout your body.
And every place on your skin, you would get pustules and boils.
And in some of the worst cases that I saw, there wasn't a single piece of skin that was normal.
You could put your finger, it was covered with boils.
Human societies in every part of the world have suffered from smallpox outbreaks for centuries.
It traveled with us, spreading between societies.
But as the disease spread, so too did methods of fighting it.
First in China and India, and then spreading through
the Islamic world to Europe and West Africa.
Physicians experimented with variolation, a method of giving people a tiny bit
of smallpox virus from another person's pustules
in the hope of provoking a milder infection and lifelong immunity.
It wasn't a safe procedure by today's standards.
One out of every 10 who got variolated would die.
But it's far better if you think about the mathematics of survival,
to risk one out of 10 dying than the inevitable three or four out of 10 dying.
To this day, we don't have a treatment for smallpox,
which is why, in the end, we had to prevent it and eradicate it.
In 1796, a country doctor in Berkeley, England, named Edward Jenner,
sparked a major innovation in the fight against smallpox, the first vaccine.
And this country doctor couldn't understand why one community didn't have pox, didn't have scars.
And he noticed a milkmaid named Sarah Nelms, who was milking a cow named Blossom.
That was the name of the cow.
And Blossom had an infection on her udders that were like pox marks.
And when Sarah Nelms was milking Blossom, the disease spread from the cow to her fingers.
And somehow Edward Jenner thought, that must be it.
If you have a pox on your finger, you won't get pox on your face.
And he, and it has to be considered a great leap of imagination,
a great belief that there could be special transmission of immunity.
Using material from a cowpox store on milkmaid Sarah Nelms' hand,
he inoculated the eight-year-old James Phipps, later exposing him to smallpox as an experiment.
Thankfully for young James, and for us, the vaccine worked.
And that was the moment that the idea that you could prevent a disease.
Now remember, this was before germ theory.
Nobody knew about viruses, bacterias.
We didn't have microscopes then.
And with that breakthrough came the idea that by getting the cowpox,
you could prevent the more deadly smallpox.
That was the first vaccination.
Armed with the new tool of vaccines, wealthy nations launched programs
to vaccinate their citizens against smallpox, often facing anti-vaccination protests.
By the end of the Second World War,
most of the world's wealthiest nations had eradicated smallpox within their borders.
But smallpox was far from defeated.
Let's vaccinate everybody.
We call that mass vaccination.
And some countries were able to push smallpox out of the country by vaccinating everybody.
Countries like Burma and China, which had more strict governments, could accomplish that.
Countries like the United States, which were wealthy,
could accomplish that by having routine vaccination,
mandatory, of all kids before they went to school and all travelers.
But for most of the world, it didn't work.
We had that smallpox vaccine for 200 years, and we weren't able to eradicate smallpox.
After the Second World War, humanity had a new tool in its fight against smallpox.
The United Nations, more specifically, the World Health Organization,
enabled international cooperation of a scale and efficiency never seen before.
In 1967, the organization launched the Intensified Smallpox Eradication Program,
led by scientists and doctors like William Fagey and D.A. Henderson.
The organization set out on an ambitious mission to rid the world of smallpox.
In 1972, Dr. Larry Brilliant joined their ranks.
So Bill Fagey, who was this wonderful epidemiologist working in Nigeria
during the civil war in Nigeria in the 60s, the Igbo Civil War, Bill was a missionary doctor
and he was working in a little village and he had only a little bit of smallpox vaccine
and there was a big outbreak.
And Bill, who was a very moral person, asked himself,
what do I do with this little bit of vaccine? Who do I save? Who do I protect?
And, you know, usually that may have been, in a different scenario, the richest person
or only women or only children or something like that.
Bill said, I guess the most important person that I need to vaccinate
is the one who's going to give the disease to five other people.
And so he located those people who were surrounding, living near somebody who had smallpox
and those are the people that he vaccinated.
And suddenly the entire epidemic stopped.
So Bill came up with the idea of surveillance and containment.
People later on called it ring vaccination.
That strategy was what broke through the centuries of difficulties that
populous countries like India had who couldn't do mass vaccination.
Now we go far away from the realm of science.
We have to understand that the most important thing to eradicate a disease is public will.
With public will, you can do anything.
Without public will, you can't do anything.
At the time that the smallpox eradication campaign began in the 70s,
there was public will to eradicate smallpox.
It was a Russian professor who came to the World Health Organization
and said, we must eradicate smallpox.
The whole world assembly voted to have a campaign.
They hired an American, D.A. Henderson, to run it.
People came from 50 different countries to work together.
We had every language spoken.
Our meetings, you would see people with every color of skin.
You had people who were Islamic, Jewish, Protestant, Catholic, Shinto, Hindu, Buddhist.
Every religion you could think of, speaking dozens of languages.
But the horror, the agony of this disease and the fear that it would spread
made us forget about our differences and look at what we cherished together.
And what we cherished was a world free of this damn disease.
It was, it evoked such a hatred for the disease.
We thought of it as the demon.
We thought of it as our enemy.
And we considered that we were at war with smallpox.
Incredibly, despite civil wars and a global cold war, the campaign succeeded.
In October 1977,
was the last person to be naturally infected with smallpox.
He survived and later became a vaccination campaigner himself, promoting the polio vaccine.
On May 8, 1980, the WHO officially declared smallpox eradicated.
I hope that polio joins smallpox as the second disease to be eradicated.
Because those of us who worked in the smallpox program,
we call ourselves smallpox warriors, we're very lonely.
We don't want to be in a world where only one disease has been eradicated.
And the next one is going to be polio.
In fact, I think this year there've only been about 15 cases of polio in the whole world.
There're only three or two or maybe even one countries that has not eradicated polio.
So polio will be eradicated in our lifetimes.
And that's magic and wonderful.
After that, it gets harder.
People talk about a measles eradication program.
They talk about a malaria eradication program.
We've tried to eradicate three other diseases.
Yaws is one of them.
I'm hopeful that we can do it.
I don't think we have that feeling for COVID.
It's unfortunate because in its own way, COVID is a horrible disease.
And how many more will there be like that?
We haven't done very well in trying to stop COVID.
A lot of great science and creating vaccines, antivirals, treatments.
But the guts of it, the program, the communications,
people working together as friends and not bringing politics in it,
haven't done a very good job.
So we've missed the public will part.
And so we have smallpox.
We will soon have polio.
They should inspire us.
They should make you want to go into public health.
They should make you get excited about global health.
But it isn't clear that the best science in the world is enough.
And so a lot of times you hear public health people saying,
I don't want to get politics into it.
Yes, we do.
We have to bring politics into it
and set another way we have to bring public health into politics.
And that's my hope.
That's my hope for one of the great lessons of smallpox eradication.
The long history of humanity's struggle against smallpox
and the story of its eradication is evidence
that we have the knowledge, resources, and ability
to eradicate diseases and prevent future pandemics before they start.
Dr. Larry has said before that outbreaks are inevitable,
but pandemics are optional.
Humanity can eradicate diseases.
We can prevent future pandemics.
We need only to find the willpower
to work together across borders and differences
and use the tools we already have.