You're watching a feedback session for the Spungella Animation Workshop. Topics that are covered: body mechanics, maya animation.
What experience do I offer? ✔️ Animation Director at Paramount/Nickelodeon, formerly Warner Brothers Animation and Industrial Light & Magic (18 years) ✔️ Teacher at Animation Mentor/Academy of Art University/my workshops (15 years) ► IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1940902/
Need tips and help with your animation at an affordable price? ► Sign up for my Spungella Animation Workshop! $499! No minimum level requirements! From beginner animation up to advanced acting pieces!
You get unlimited planning discussions and 16 video reviews, which can be weekly or every other week or whenever you want/can submit, they never expire! Example reviews are available here on my channel.
All righty, let's play this in full.
Nice, okay, okay, okay, let's see.
Okay, so you are, I'm checking your mail, talking about the keys around and this is all
very successful. There's one little moment where you're still a bit pose to pose
and I think the only other thing is, I don't know if you need this,
this is purely subjective. I don't know, because he has that moment of,
I really like this and to me it could end there. It's almost like after all of this,
that's your biggest contrast, right? He starts up here and he ends down there. That's his whole
journey through this shot, like whatever happened, he's disappointed. But then suddenly he goes,
and that to me is almost the beginning of a new idea where he's going to do something,
stand back up and walk out this way. So, I think from a super subjective storytelling
point of view, I would just leave it like that and not do that. The other thing is,
I know you talked about this being in the reference and that's how kids do it. I still
feel this is just a weirdly awkward pose, just because the fingers are so even. It just feels
like it's lightly placed there and it doesn't, this feels like he got hurt. Imagine that arm
would be somewhat dangling with the hand here and you would have some blood running down,
like he just got shot or something or punched. Maybe like, okay, it's a kid, he didn't get
shot, but maybe he got punched by another kid on the playground and he's just mad at that.
It's like a classroom or something, or this is the principal's office, right? And he goes,
that's kind of what this feels like. So, generally, I'm not saying you have to fix
it because I think we're pretty much done with the shot. Just thinking in terms of what does
this pose tell us and how do we feel about this, if that makes sense. And the biggest thing is,
for me, that moment of he turns and then this is almost vampire-like. Imagine he's in a coffin
here and he goes, I must sleep now. And it kind of ends at the same time. I know those arms go
here before the head, but it's so close together. But then everything kind of stops
and then he goes forward and it's, I feel like the whole body starts to go down. So, what I would do
just for that moment might be this. And again, watch out, you got your chest. Imagine there's
an arrow pointing this way and the head arrow pointing this way. And then as you do this,
fancy here, this points and this points. See how they're pointing the same way?
And this feels too locked at that point. I think everything else is, it's really working a lot
better. That's just like your remnants of pose to pose or just the stiffness. It's not really
pose to pose at this point, it's more the stiffness. So, have this and then turn your head
two, three frames earlier. Then the body catches up. Then you do this and then both arms stopping
at the same time. Again, it's the two hitting that pose. I know there's a bit more in the head,
but you want to put, imagine you're, is this going underneath? No, it's holding the elbow.
Just think in terms of this might go there first, clenching with the fingers. And then a couple
of frames later, this arm finishes and the fingers adjust and grip. So, it doesn't feel
like this is a pose. See how your fingers are already curled and then you get into this. And
once you hit that, there's nothing else in the fingers. There's no adjustment, there's no gripping,
there's no nothing. So, that's now the extra level step you need to put into your animation. So,
you get out of that blocky feel, pose to pose feel or that stiff feel. And then don't forget
at the very end, you end up being very one axis in this rotation there. So, this is all going to
help you where you have that coming to a stop at a different point. That rotation, it might still be,
you know, maybe not completely turned. Like he starts, it leads with that head more.
Maybe it overshoots or maybe it doesn't go as far, right? He leads that turn before the,
before the chest, but doesn't go as far with the head. And then during that move,
you finish also in a wide rotation. So, it's not just one axis. And then we have all of that.
And I think on such a strong sit, then it's a bit more in terms of mechanics of
one, two, three. During this time, the shoulders will have a little kick down and
the hands will go down. It might be slight adjustment again in the hand. It might
move down a bit, changing the fingers because that's a big stoppage of the roots. So, that
downward momentum continues in everything else in the body. And not seeing the ears would flop
down, but you know, would it be something more floppy like on a hat? That would flop down. So,
I think in terms of, so it doesn't just go down and then that's it here. Because here, I like
when you go up, that is not one axis because you're turning slightly in wide to look at us a
little bit. Love all this. And same thing here. You're not going down in one axis. You're going
down with a slight rotation over, which is great. So, that's the stuff you want to put really
everywhere. And then in the end, like I said, it's kind of a subjective thing. If you would do this,
then it could be something where you do that and this, actually the arms go out
and they hold on maybe to the chair. Because again, this to me seems like a new idea. It's a
new thought and that will be represented in everything. So, maybe, you know, like the legs
come closer to the chair. He's just stiffer. It's like, I have made a decision. But again, this is
to me feels like this leads to a new idea. So, generally, I would say, when you do have a change
in a pose, like even this disappointed, imagine that's the ends. Again, I would loosen the grip
in this and maybe the knees go out a bit more. This goes from, I'm feeling one way and I'm
feeling another way. And what if this is like ultimate disappointments? How do you show this
not only in the spine and the head, but in the rest of the body? That's definitely something
you need to add and think about in your future animations, like the overall body language when
you go from pose to pose. And then little things like not having things end at the same time,
one axis movement or stiff movement here. You got to think about what body part
leads, right? And then spacing things like that arm goes forward and it kind of has a bit of a
stopping point here. Right there, you can see where these frames kind of locked in screen space here.
Then you go back and then it goes back to here and then it's kind of locked again and then
suddenly going to the right and that arc is okay here. So, just little clean up things in terms of
spacing and all that good stuff. All righty, but definitely better. I think you're always improving,
which is great. So, anything, you know, that my bullet point list of things is for this shot,
but it's also a general note for upcoming shots. All right, thanks.
All right, there's an email. You can sign up. You can start whenever you want. You can submit
whenever you want. You get 16 submissions. Either way, a like and subscribe would be awesome. All
right. Thank you.