Why reusable rockets are important for the future - 8.31

TMRO Space News
221 followers
1 Video View·Oct 25, 2015
This week we look at why reusable rockets are not just for getting the cost of space flight down, but essential for the future of human colonization of the cosmos.
In Space News we have:
* Space Launch System Design Review Completed
* NASA Provides Daily Views of Earth Online (http://epic.gsfc.nasa.gov)
* Orbital ATK ramps up Booster production for Space Launch System maiden flight
* Snooze your way to Mars
TMRO Live is a crowd funded show. If you like this episode consider contributing to help us to continue to improve. Head over to http://www.patreon.com/tmro for information, goals and reward levels. Don't forget to check out our Space Pod campaign as well over at http://www.patreon.com/spacepod
Coming up, the Space Launch System.
And pretty pictures of Earth.
Plus, we're going to be talking about rocket reusability and why it matters more than just
reducing the cost of spaceflight.
Stay tuned.
Tomorrow Begins Right Now.
And welcome to Tomorrow for Saturday, October 24th, 2015.
My name is Benjamin Higginbotham.
With me as always, the beautiful, lovely, wonderful, and talented Gary N. Higginbotham.
And we'll be your hosts for this episode.
No space mic this particular week.
Now, before we get started with some space news, I did want to give a huge shout out
to all of the patrons of Tomorrow who helped make this specific segment of this episode
happen.
These are the people who've contributed $10 or more to this show.
You can find out more information on how you can help crowd fund the shows of Tomorrow
over at patreon.com slash tmro.
All right, let's go ahead and get started with some space news.
It is actually, in all fairness, a fairly light space news week.
Yeah, ironically.
But it's like light.
There aren't a lot of stories, but the stories that did come out are kind of a big deal.
So let's start out with, speaking of big, the Space Launch System.
So here is an artist's rendition of the Space Launch System.
You'll actually notice it changed a little bit.
That's because its design review has been completed.
That design review milestone clears the way for engineers to start full-scale fabrication
of the entire Space Launch System.
Now of that, you may have noticed that we've previously said, oh, such and such part was
being built, or they're working on such and such a thing with the Space Launch System.
That's because many of the components are, in fact, already being built and have already
been started, that building process.
What you're looking at there, that's a 20-story core stage of the Space Launch System in the
middle, that orange section.
You're also noting that it's orange now, just like the old Space Shuttle external tank,
right?
They did, in the final review, they're like, all right, dude, do we really need to paint
this thing?
Because if you remember, right, back in the, and I actually think we have a second picture
as well.
Yeah, there you go.
So there it is on the crawler-transporter.
That looks kind of badass.
Yeah, it does look kind of awesome.
Now back in the day, the very first two Space Shuttle flights, the external tank was actually
painted white, and then they determined, oh, we don't need to paint it white.
Well, before we ever flew Space Launch System, they determined, eh, we don't need to paint
it white.
That's going to save them about, right?
It's going to save them about 1,000 pounds or so, and that's extra payload that they'll
then be able to get going up into space.
So that illustration that you saw, okay, sorry, Duda, go back.
Illustration you see, it was, in all fairness, that was a good cut point.
It was.
It was awesome.
If I wasn't about to say.
You can see here.
As you can see.
You are the destroyer of all segways.
Yes.
It's totally fair.
As you can see on the solid rocket boosters, they kind of have that new paint job.
This is actually a really great photo, because the other one you can't really see it as well.
So the solid rocket motors on either side, they kind of have that swooping paint.
Yeah, that white-gray kind of stuff on them.
That looks cool and is not finalized.
So maybe that will happen.
Maybe it won't happen.
Don't know.
So the NASA official said they're still deciding whether they're going to add the paint job
on the finished product.
I hope they do.
I think it looks pretty cool.
I hope they do something.
Whether it's that paint job or a paint job, something that makes it look distinctly just
awesome.
Yeah.
Our chat room is sort of 50-50 on that one.
Yeah.
Some of them like the old way.
Some of them like the new way.
Yeah, I can see.
I mean, there is something beautiful and elegant about just the pure white boosters.
Actually, I think it looked cooler with them painting the orange foam.
It's actually more of a green foam that turns orange in sunlight.
I thought it looked cooler white with that old kind of Saturn V look.
I thought that was way more awesome.
But you know, 1,000 pounds is 1,000 pounds.
There was somebody that compared that paint job to the Moonraker paint job that the space
shuttle got in the Bond film and showed an image of it, and it was actually pretty close.
It was kind of humorous.
That's cool.
Interesting.
Or funny, I suppose.
All right, so...
Art imitates life.
And life imitates art.
That's just the way it goes.
The vehicle is about 321 feet tall.
The Block 1, which is what we're going to be launching in November 2018-ish, that's
going to be able to take 77 tons, which is 70 metric tons, up to low Earth orbit.
If you combine Earth and orbit, you get Orth.
So low Orth.
Low Orth.
You're welcome, Internet.
The first mission in November 2018 will be taking the uncrewed Orion module around the
Moon, actually.
So that will be kind of a neat little mission, going back around the Moon and heading back
home.
And then after that, that's Exploration Mission 1.
Exploration Mission 2, after that, a couple years later, will actually have a crew.
Space launch system is done.
It is no longer just a paper rocket.
They are building the thing, which means Dave Mastin is about to owe me a dollar.
Was it a dollar or a steak dinner?
Does anyone remember?
A dollar.
It was a dollar.
Dave Mastin is about to owe me a dollar.
Well, if Dave loses, he's definitely going to say it was a dollar.
I don't know.
You might want a steak dinner.
I don't know.
Or what we'll do is we'll just go out and get a steak dinner.
We'll split it, and he'll put an extra dollar into the dinner.
That's what we'll do.
That'll work.
Oh, goodness.
Speaking of NASA.
So yes, more NASA news.
That's a great segue there.
That was awesome.
More NASA news.
NASA is releasing pictures of Earth, which sounds really boring, but it's really, really
cool.
Here.
Take a look.
What's going on is this is from the DISCOVER, or Deep Space Climate Observatory, satellite
that was a conjunction of NASA National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or NOAA, and
the U.S. Air Force.
And this launched aboard the SpaceX Falcon 9 in February 11, 2015.
And these are pictures that we're getting, which they're coming in every single day now,
which is really cool.
NASA's going to be releasing a bunch of images every day, like I said, that were anywhere
between 12 and 36 hours old.
So they're fresh, hot, off the presses, if we will.
The DISCOVER satellite is about a million miles away, which sounds like an exaggeration,
but that's really where it is, which I thought was kind of funny.
And it's using, I have to read this, it's using what they're calling an EPIC camera,
which is also an acronym of Earth Polychromatic Imaging Camera.
Which is confusing because there's a red camera called EPIC.
There we go.
We've moved on.
That's it.
We're done with that story now.
No more Earth!
Da-da!
Yep, there it is.
So what the camera does is it's a four megapixel CCD camera and telescope.
I don't actually, I didn't write down what CCD was, but it takes color photos in three
separate single color images so that when you combine them, you've got the equivalent
of a 12 megapixel image.
And the effective resolution is anywhere between 10 and 15 kilometers.
That's how, like, how small they can get down to or, you know, how detailed they are.
And if you want to see these pictures, you know, if you're interested in these pictures
or going back to the archive of any of the pictures that they've been taking, you can
hit up epic.gsfc.nasa.gov and you can see all of them and they're really quite fantastic.
I don't remember what the CCD actually stands for.
I don't either and I apologize, I didn't write it down.
But it's a type of sensor on a camera.
Okay.
You have fundamentally two types of sensor.
One is CCD and one is CMOS.
You'd think that I know what each acronym stands for, but I've used the acronym for
so long, I don't actually know what it means.
It means nothing now.
Yay.
I know the differences between the two, but I don't know what each one means.
It is a little interesting that they used a CCD as opposed to a CMOS sensor because
CMOS tends to fare better in space with radiation.
Yo no se.
That can all be shielded, so there you go.
Cool.
Speaking of NASA, Orbital ATK is ramping up their booster production for the Space Launch
System.
This is what you saw earlier, destroying the Earth, is actually one of the solid motor
tests.
That's kind of what it looked like, right?
There was an Earth and all of a sudden this giant flame coming.
Yes.
So this is a solid motor test.
I keep the audio really low on this, so I'll just talk over it.
So this is one of the five-segment solid rocket boosters that's going on the Space Launch
System.
This is slightly increased from the four-segment solid rocket, well not slightly increased,
it is very increased from the four-segment solid rocket motors that were on the Space
Shuttle.
Now, to give you an idea of how much this has increased, each one of these solid rocket
motors, boosters, will weigh 1.6 million pounds and will give off 3.6 million pounds of thrust
at sea level per, which means that combined, these two solid motors will actually give
us 400,000 pounds more thrust than the entire Space Shuttle system, which was the two motors
themselves plus the three main shuttle engines themselves.
So just these two motors are more powerful than the entire Space Shuttle was.
And these are, of the thrust for the Space Launch System, this provides about 75% of
it on the first two minutes of flight.
So yeah, these things are awesome.
They're 177 feet tall and 12 feet in diameter.
To give you an idea as to how large that is, there's an eight booster, yeah there you go.
Nice.
Cool, right?
I didn't realize that they were like that, I mean I knew they were big, but you just
don't get a concept of scale in any of the pictures.
I think that helps a little bit because what you're looking at is they're applying a coating
on the inside of one of the solid rocket boosters.
This is one of those five segment solid rocket boosters that they're putting, obviously there's
no fuel in it right now, they're just applying it to one of the test motors.
This is going to feature a new nozzle design that accounts for the increased performance.
It has new avionics and a new non-destructive test evaluation before it actually leaves
their plant in, ATK's in Utah, Utah.
Couple other big changes.
These are single use now.
So before it used to be that we would take the solid motor, it was four segment solid
motor, they'd attach from the space shuttle, we'd dump them in the ocean, we'd get some
ships, we'd go out, we'd recover them, put them back on the ship, refurbish the whole
thing, put fuel back in it, put it back on the rocket and off you go.
And that process, in fact, cost more than actually just building a new one.
And in fact, with the Space Launch System's low launch rate of once every three years,
they were like-
They just don't care.
Yeah, they're like, this does not make sense to do, we're just going to build a new one.
So that's what they're going to do.
So additionally, for the Block 2 Space Launch System, which will be even more powerful than
Block 1, they're coming up with some modifications to it to give even more power, less overall
weight and just be more badass in general.
So production of those motors has already started for that Exploration Mission 1 test
flight coming up in November of 2018.
So rock, rock on, Orbital ATK.
Still want jewelry made from the glass, from the sand that the fire was on.
Oh yeah, that'd be cool.
Oh yeah, because when you fire a solid rocket motor sideways, like you saw, it basically
will melt the sand underneath it into glass.
And that's what they have.
They have like these glass shards underneath there.
That would be very cool to have some solid rocket motor jewelry made from that glass.
So if anyone from Orbital ATK is watching, Carrie Anne would like some solid rocket motor
glass, please.
There you go.
All right.
And finally-
Speaking of not NASA.
Speaking of not NASA?
No, that's not NASA.
I don't know.
There's no segue for this one.
There really isn't.
And I just happen to love the title of this one, which is Snooze Your Way to Mars.
So last week or the week before-
All that solid rocket motor glass, wouldn't that make a nice warm glass of milk?
That's what you have for before bedtime, right?
Oh, I see what you're doing.
So of the-
I see how you're trying to-
No.
So you're saying you make a glass-
That holds the milk.
Right.
That is a way complicated segue.
It is not worth the effort.
All right.
So, Snooze Your Way to Mars.
At the International Aerospace Conference in Israel 2015, which was, I believe, last
week.
If it wasn't last week, it was the week before.
There was an interesting presentation.
There were a lot of many interesting presentations, but this one sort of caught my ear, eye, nose,
and throat.
They didn't call it Snooze Your Way to Mars, but it's a company called Spaceworks, if I
remember correctly.
Yes.
Good.
I wrote it down correctly.
That said, they think that the best way to get a human colony to Mars is to put them
in a stasis.
That's really what it comes down to.
Well, you don't consume as much.
Right.
Nearly as much, right?
It's called TORPOR.
T-O-R-P-O-R.
And it's a hibernation state for those of you who don't know what stasis is.
The idea being that, exactly as you're saying, that people in stasis are not consuming as
much.
You don't have to worry about ... It reduces the amount of food and water and oxygen needed,
which reduces the amount of weight needed.
You can go from a regular crew of 100 needing about 700 tons, I can't speak, to get to Mars,
but in the same amount of time.
In the Spaceworks way, you can take out 100 crew and reduce that to 200 tons.
This is a really kind of a cool visual.
One pod, out of 100 crew, you would have 96 people in stasis and four people who are essentially
the caretakers.
The pod all the way to the one side is the caretaker's pod.
It might be hard for you to see, but there's only four people in there.
It looks like they've got plenty of room to sort of move around and do whatever it is
that they need to do.
The next pod over, you can see the little cross section there is a bunch of little people
in stasis, which is still kind of creepy, it reminds me of the Matrix a little bit.
And then the next pod is just more people in stasis.
I figured the pod bay doors were the ones kind of in the middle.
Those are the doors that Hal would open.
So the Torpor hibernation state is characterized by decreased physiological activity and reduced
metabolic rates.
So they're lowering the patient's body temperature in order to induce the Torpor, and then there's
a medical treatment that the way they are fed is essentially the way that babies get
fed.
It's intravenous and nutritional fluids.
Tasty.
Well, but the thing is that you don't have to go through digestion, then you're not producing
any waste.
Your body's automatically getting everything that it needs and only as much as it needs.
So you don't have to worry about any of that part of it.
Would it be a good diet program, too?
Would they be able to?
Yeah, but you have to be in the hibernation state in order to take it in the correct way,
if that makes sense.
Because if you're expending more, then it doesn't matter.
Anyhow, it was a really interesting idea, and I thought it was kind of a cool presentation,
and it's available online.
We actually got the links through parabolicarc.com, but they're available, they're out there.
Spaceworks.
And, I don't know, I thought it was really cool.
It was an interesting way of looking at it, and sort of an easy way of transporting a
hundred people to Mars, but much, not faster, but with much less effort, I guess.
Now, before we go to break, there was a question from Mindco that asked, this is regarding
the solid rocket motors from Orbit Lake ATK, are the solid rocket motors non-recoverable
because they make it higher out of the atmosphere?
They're non-recoverable because they decided to not make them recoverable, ultimately.
It saves about 9,000 pounds in the recovery, removing all the recovery stuff.
You don't need the parachutes or the avionics and all the pyro stuff.
That just means that they have, you know, it's lighter so they can lift more up into
space.
And, you know, it's very, very expensive to make something like that that hits saltwater
recoverable.
Now, if they landed it back on land, it would be a different story.
And speaking of, we're going to talk about recoverability efforts and some of these next
generation vehicles that are designed to be flown more than once in the next segment
of our show.
So stay tuned.
We'll be right back.
Welcome back to Tomorrow, and I'm a
before we get into our main topic of recovery and rockets, I'd like to give a huge shout
out to all the producers of Tomorrow who have helped to make this specific segment of this
episode happen. These people have contributed $5 or more to this specific show. If you'd
like to find out how you can help crowdfund the shows of Tomorrow, head on over to patreon.com
slash tmro. And a huge thank you to all of our supporters for making this happen, because
we couldn't do this without you week after week. And you know, one of the neat, harping
on that even more. One of the really neat things about the Patreon stuff that we do
is that if we don't do a show, you don't pay, right? It's per episode. So if we're off for
two weeks, you're not paying for two weeks in which we're not doing anything, or not
doing anything, right? So it's a very fair system. And if you don't think that it's worth
$5 or $2 or $1, you contribute whatever value you think it is worth. And then you can set
a maximum value. So you know, don't don't spend more than $10 per month or whatever,
whatever that number is for you, whatever you think this show is worth and what you
think it is, is viable in your world. I don't know what a coworker said, whatever you think,
whatever value you put on seeing your name in those different segments. Yes. And how
many times? How many times? Right? The more the more you put in the more, the more times
you see more time to see your name in the side of the show. Absolutely. You get other
things too. But that's the big one. That's the big one. All right. So I wanted to talk
about reusability. You know, I think a lot of people realize that there is reusability
going on. And you think SpaceX, right? And I created a really quick list here. It's not
just SpaceX, right? You've got these are the companies that are working on reusable rockets
or reusable spacecraft in some some form or another. We've got SpaceX, Blue Origin, Masten
Space Systems, who's kind of like the de facto standard of reusability right now. United
Launch Alliance, Arion Space, kind of, someday, maybe. Stratolaunch, X-Core Aerospace, Virgin
Galactic, Reaction Engines, Firefly Space, Dutto, I forgot at least one. Who did I forget?
Airbus. Airbus, right? They're working on some stuff. And that's what's active right
now. There were programs like the DCX and other past programs that were kind of doing
some of the reusability kind of thing. And I guess the point of this particular episode
is to talk about not just who's doing what. I mean, everyone kind of has a general idea
of that. It's not the specific technology. It's the why reusability is important. And
we can kind of break this into, I think, two different areas. The first is bringing the
cost of space down. And we look at the Space Shuttle, and the Space Shuttle was reusable.
I actually reference it not as reusable, but refurbishable. The Space Shuttle was supposed
to bring the cost of space down from the Apollo era, which was...someone refresh my memory.
Apollo was 500 pounds...$500 per pound to a low Earth orbit. Is that correct? Something
like that. I'm sure the chat room will know. It was a fairly low number. The Space Shuttle
more than doubled that. And it was supposed to reduce it. Well, here's what happened.
They were never able to fly at the rate that they thought they were going to fly. The design
got tweaked when the Department of Defense kind of got their hands in it, and what it
needed to do changed. And it wasn't really reusable. It was refurbishable in that every
heat tile had to be checked. The engines basically had to be disassembled, checked, and reassembled
between flights. You had to do these 9 million point inspections throughout the entire vehicle.
And it was just too complex of a machine to actually make it fully, truly reusable. The
companies I mentioned, for the most part, there were a few exceptions in that list,
but most of the companies are not working towards refurbishability. They're working
towards reusability in that...they're trying to do what Masten does today. Everyone wants
to do what Masten's doing today, which is you take it, you fuel it up, you fly it, you
land it, you fuel it up, you fly it, you land it, you fuel it up, you fly it, you land it.
You don't do it...I mean, I think he does that in one day. Northrop Grumman Lunar Lander
Xpress Challenge? Yeah, just up, down, over, up, down, right? Just up, down, up, down.
That's what companies are striving towards. Because if you can do that, now it's more
like an airliner. Now it's more like a space plane, essentially, or space airliner. A plane
is bad because it can do vertical landing. And in doing that, instead of taking this
$100 million vehicle and dumping it in the ocean... You're saving time. You're saving
money. You're saving...I mean, you're saving time across the board. You're saving time
in how fast you can get up and be flying again. Because if you just have to do a couple
of spot checks, much like an airplane, for instance, you just have to do a couple of
spot checks, you make sure it's good, and then you just continue on. And then you don't
have to go through and check every single little thing. You don't have to employ more
people to check every single little thing. You don't have to have systems that have to
check every single little thing. And then if you do have an issue, you can just deal
with that one little issue, as opposed to having to take the entire thing apart, go
through, double check, absolutely. Yes, it's just like, it's this compound issue of time
and money saved. It just makes sense, really. So that's phase 1, part 1, of why you want
to do it. It will reduce the cost of space. Now there are a few engineers, actually, from
some of these companies that are working on it, that don't think that you can really fully
do reusability, that the savings, because you take a hit in doing this, right? Because
you have to bring fuel up that you're going to use to come back, which is payload that
you can't bring up with you. And then you're taking extreme stresses, right? We like it
to an airplane, but the stresses that these vehicles are taking are far greater than what
an airplane is going to do. Right, for sure, for sure. So it is actually far more complex
than something like airline travel. So there are some companies that say, hmm, this may
not be possible. But I'm in the camp of, yeah, this is possible, slash, look at Dave.
But that, well. But then there's a second side of this, which isn't, what we just talked
about, that's talked about a lot. I think that's generally known. But what a lot of
people seem to be forgetting, even in the aerospace industry, even in our kind of market,
is that we need this if we're going to be going to Mars. Okay, why? Right. So right
now, how do you land on Mars? You use a Sky Crane. Sure, Sky Crane, or the bouncy ball
thing. The big bouncy ball thing, right? Yeah, I like that one. Right. Impact crater. Or
an impact crater. That's 50% of the time of Orso, we make an impact crater, absolutely.
So that works great for things that are about those sizes, which is going to be an itty
bitty car, like a VW Bug, or smaller. Right, a Mini Cooper. Mini Cooper, that was it. Mini
Cooper or smaller. Sure. The old Mini Cooper. The old Mini, sure. But what happens when
you want to send a human? You send one human. Not in something that small, there's not going
to be enough life support. Exactly, you don't have the mass, you don't have the landing
capability to send a human down to Mars. Okay. We need to do propulsive landing. Well, propulsive
landing is basically the same thing as reusability, right? Sure. So when you're taking these rockets,
flipping them around and bringing them back down in the atmosphere, you're essentially
learning how to land on Mars. So Dave Mastin has a vehicle today that could potentially
go to the moon and land on the moon. He has a vehicle that could go to Mars and land on
Mars. And he has all the autonomous stuff that allows you to go anywhere he needs to
go in the universe and land on most surfaces, as long as it's a solid surface, right? That's
fair. Right? So, I mean, there are a few examples. Venus, questionable. I mean, he could probably
land, he could land, whether, I'm not sure. And then melt immediately? And then immediately
like get crushed slash melty. But, you know, the point is still there. The point is still
there, our point. And so as we're looking to extend our legs in the solar system, this
is going to be a technology that is necessary. And so this is where the propulsive landing
stuff is kind of important. What'd you got from the chat room? Somebody made, they were
making a joke, but it is an interesting idea. They said we send Felix Baumgartner, which
if those of you who were paying attention, it was Red Bull, right? Where he came down
sort of launched from the edge of space. It wasn't the right. So that's what we'll do.
We'll just we'll do these flybys of Mars and we'll just push everyone out. Go, go, go.
They skydive slash parachute down. No problem. Also, whatever parachute he uses will only
slow him down to about a thousand miles an hour. That's another valid point. Parachutes
don't work either. Yeah, because the atmosphere is I mean, the size of the parachute would
be so large. There are other technologies being developed, which you can use in conjunction
with propulsive landing. But ultimately, what we're going to be landing humans on Mars will
be propulsive landing. And that's the low density supersonic decelerator. LSDS. Is that
right? Low density super LDSD. LDSD. LDSD. There you go. The low. Yeah. Yeah. That which
is basically a balloon that inflates and increases the air surface area of the vehicle so that
there's more atmosphere that compress against it. But again, the atmosphere on Mars is so
thin and wispy that it helps, but it doesn't help as much as we need to actually land humans
on Mars. And that's the second big thing with reusability is that we need these technologies
if we're going to be landing humans on Mars. And so you can look at some of these companies
and actually see, you know, what the technology they're developing today is and where they're
going to go with it and how they can extrapolate that into future, future landing sites. And
you can also see other companies where you look at that and you go, well, hmm, like Strato
launch. I mean, it's neat. It's reusable and that will reduce the cost of space. Maybe
I think pretty sure it'll be reusable for the most part. OK, but that's it. Right. It's
not doesn't propulsively land really. I mean, it lands like an airplane. So, yeah, but you
can definitely look at, again, a company like Masten Space Systems and you can see, oh,
they are developing the technologies now. It's not just the the the propulsive landing,
but also the autonomous landing. It's like a Tesla and a rocket where autopilot V1 where
you have to you have to push back on the little stick twice, go bing bing, and the vehicle
starts to automatically land itself. That would be cool. Yeah, it would be kind of like
I don't see the lane anymore. So sorry, Tesla joke. So, yeah, where it'll it'll be able to
land itself and kind of go from there. So I just that's the main topic is that's why it's
important. That's why it's important because we need to get off this planet because we
do need to get off this planet and make all that stuff. And actually, the the other part
of it. Right. So looking at some of these vehicles, again, we have some how this is
Phil Valls Marinus with Jello and just aim well. So we can suggested a gigantic net and
that's a good net. That's got to be really springy, like a trampoline. Yes. Oh, we could
take that. Wasn't it like a ULA trampoline joke? Yes. Oh, yeah. Right. You could take
that trampoline. Oh, no, it was to meet you. It goes in from Roscosmos. It said that NASA
is going to need a trampoline in order to be able to get the space. Yeah. So we'll take
NASA's trampoline. We'll move it to Mars. No problem. And that's how we'll land. There
you go. So there you have it. So those were the company. So we've got SpaceX. They're
working on a vertical takeoff, vertical landing Blue Origin. They're like they're just kind
of out of nowhere. Right. They came out of nowhere. Also working on vertical takeoff,
vertical landing very slowly. Masten Space Systems has vertical takeoff, vertical landing
autonomous flying. At this point, he's working on that DARPA contract where it's going to
be rapid reusability into low Earth orbit. So kind of that next step forward. And then
from there, you can kind of see where all those pieces go together. You go, oh, he's
pretty far along. You got United Launch Alliance. Usability kind of. Right. They're going to
jettison their the power plant, the engines, and then they're going to take a helicopter
of unknown origin, come by, swoop and pick up the engines and drop the engines into a
new vehicle. So that's not going to help you really for Mars landing or anything else other
than Earth. But it does certainly help maybe reduce the cost of Earth, assuming they can
find a helicopter that will work. Arianespace, same kind of general concept of jettisoning
things. Oh, no, wait. No, they got to what it flies down by itself. That's right. It
needs at least a landing like it's a vertical takeoff, horizontal landing. So that really
won't work on Mars either. Stratolaunch, giant airplane, not really going to work on
Mars. XCOR, also horizontal landing. So that may not work on Mars very well, but they
might be able to do something cool in like a future design where it kind of does
something. Virgin Galactic, a smaller version of Stratolaunch. So, yep, yep. Reaction
engines. That's the that one's not getting us to Mars, but that one's interesting. They
are building essentially a jet engine. I don't want to call it. They're building a
reaction engine that you stick on, essentially an airplane that can go all the way to
space. It is a single orbit to space airplane. Single stage to orbit. Single stage to
orbit. What did I say? Single orbit to space. That that doesn't make any sense. Single
stage to orbit space plane. Yes. And you get up to it's a plane. It's like you remember
it back in like not that any of us remember. You remember back in the 60s, though, that
like the TWA space liner, like airplane thing that would go up. Right. It's that. But for
real. So that would be pretty cool. That won't get you to Mars, but it can get you to
the flying. All of these. Well, eventually, if they size them up, but that gets you to
like a space station orbiting Earth where you then take your ticket to Mars. So that's
where you help. Helps you there. And Firefly Space. Let's not forget about them. Also
working on stage recoverability. So really cool stuff. It was Victor J in the chat room
and then Lassie H who agreed with Victor saying you could just poke a hole in your
spacesuit and fly like Iron Man. You're flying like Iron Man. That is a reference to the
Martian for anyone who didn't get that. All right. That's funny. That's our main topic
this week. Why reusability is important, especially if you want to get to Mars. We need
reusability so we can learn those lessons here on Earth before we go to Mars. Try to
figure out how we're going to land over there. If you have any comments, I know that
like I don't even talk about DCX, which was a an old school reusability program. I'd
love to know your comments. What reusability programs am I forgetting that are active
today? Because I know I've missed some. And what are some of the reusability programs
that we tried yesterday that haven't actually either made it off the drawing board or
maybe they made it to a flight stage like a DCX, but then we kind of canceled the
program. And then what are your thoughts? What are some other uses for reusability
that we're not thinking of that really makes this make a ton more sense than taking
the vehicle and throwing it in the ocean every time? Leave your comments on Facebook,
leave them on YouTube, on Twitter, wherever you want. We always love hearing from you.
And speaking of comments, we'll be talking about comments from last week's show when
we come back.
Hi, welcome back to the show. We were ready to come back. We were totally ready. We were
totally ready. We were totally ready. I don't know what was going on. Now, before we get
into... See, the best part is, had we not said anything, no one would have been like,
oh, this is an extra second of black. We were ready. No, no, we were ready. Duh-duh! Duh-duh!
I blamed duh-duh for that. Before we get into the comments from last week's show, I do want
to give a huge shout out to all of the patrons of Tomorrow, who helped make this specific
segment of this episode happen. These are the people who have contributed $2.50 or more
to this specific episode. And by contributing $2.50 or more, you get your name in the show,
plus you're going to get access to After Dark as soon as it is available. Oh, but wait,
there's more. If you can't afford or don't think the show is worth $2.50, you can contribute
as little as one penny to the show, and that gets your name in the show. So thank you to
everyone here who has contributed to the show to help make this happen week after week.
You can find out more information on how you can crowdfund the shows of Tomorrow over at
patreon.com slash t-m-r-o, and I wonder how many times, more times, I can say show. Show.
Show. Alright, let's go ahead and get started with some comments from last week's show.
Show. First up is Wicked Works, Tawikid. It's Tawikid. Yeah, okay. This is Tawikid Works
off of YouTube. He came up with the, Tawikid came up with the main topic last week. Yes.
He said, hey, what should we do for a main topic? And there you go, that was Tawikid.
He says, and just to clarify, the internet.com boom didn't destroy the internet, duh, but
most of the companies did die, and it took a while for things to get back to normal.
Yeah, and I, so last week's topic being, are we in a kind of a, is the small sat launcher
bubble about to burst? Right. Right. And so if that happens, there are, this kind of happened
earlier in the 80s, I think it was, maybe 90s, where there were a bunch of launches
and we're starting to see commercial space take off, and then the market for the satellites
just dried up because they didn't need them anymore, and the whole kind of commercial
market kind of crashed, and those companies went away, and that's probably what will happen.
If that's the case with the small sat, nano sat, pico sat kind of payloads, if that happens
to be the case, it's probably the same thing that will happen. These companies will just
go away. Unlike the dot com boom, where it was in these huge mega companies that were
tied into everything, and it caused the markets to just crash around them, I don't think we'll
see that happen. This industry is too small for that to happen. At least this part of
this industry is too small for that to happen. So, it simply would be, I think, companies
going away, and then some apprehension in the future of the industry of doing things
like this. Right. Alright, next up. That's fair enough. From Steven Thompson, also off
of YouTube. The tubes. Right now, if you have a small sat, you can get into space as a secondary
payload or kicked out from the space station. If those orbits don't work for you, you can
just... So, there is a need for at least one dedicated small sat launcher. Yeah, and yes.
Probably more than one. You probably need a couple so that you can compete. You don't
want to just have... Well, and just strategically, you want them placed in different areas of
the world, right? So, if I'm a company in Brazil, I don't want to have to travel all
the way to India in order to get my small sat launched, or have to ship it there, or
anything along those lines. I would prefer something in the Americas, right? Or, I'm
just saying, just simply based on that. Yeah, I mean, well, I mean, we've made travel so
cheap and easy across the entire planet now. Yeah, but if it's my baby, I don't want to
have to try and get it all the way across to a completely different continent. Just
check it on the luggage. You know what I'm saying. Know what I'm saying. Just check it
with the airline. You also need to be able to launch in the inclination that works for
your particular satellite. Yeah, and that makes sense. Like, launching from a, like
a Vandenberg here in the U.S. versus a Cape Canaveral, you're going to have a polar launch
in Vandenberg, or a low Earth orbit launch, geosynchronous, whatever. Equatorial? Yeah,
yeah, exactly. You could do different launches from different places. Now you can have, actually,
any type of launch you want from anywhere. It just takes more fuel to get to whatever
you want if you launch from an improper location. So, there you go. Alright, next up. Alright.
It comes from Stuart Woods, also off of YouTube. Goodness. I think this is a new comment. New
first time on the show comment. Stuart. Stuart. Mr. Stuart. My view is that the small satellite
launchers will serve as a foot in the door for new players just as Falcon 1 did for SpaceX.
The fact that SpaceX ditched Falcon 1 when Falcon 9 was flying suggests that they didn't
see a big market for that class of rocket. Maybe. I mean, we really don't know what SpaceX
was thinking or why they did that. So, maybe, maybe not. I mean, maybe the timing was wrong
too, right? I mean, you look at all these smallsats and nanosats and picosats and all
the things that are generally secondary or even tertiary payloads on these rockets and
there are times when it might make more sense for them to be primary payloads. Right, well
because Falcon 1 was flying in, like, 06-ish, right? Yeah, somewhere in there. Like, smallsat,
cubesat, that stuff wasn't really, I mean. It was, but it wasn't. Right, but Vax Hadrum
said that the cubesat market is currently about 450 a year, increasing about 10% per
year. So, if you run those numbers essentially backwards in the same way, it just wasn't
that big of a market at that time. So, whether or not they saw it as being something that
they wanted to do or could do, I mean, you can never predict the future in that way.
And SpaceX's ambitions. So, if you just look at it and go, cool, that's neat, but, you
know, how many of these things are we really going to fly anyhow? And, yeah, you're right.
Their ambitions have been fairly clearly stated of getting to Mars and getting humans to Mars.
And that doesn't necessarily always include the smallsat. Yeah, and Vax brings up a question,
you didn't get to watch the show, but did we talk about the current smallsat launch
backlog? No, because it's more of a, will this bubble burst? And I think the idea being
is once we get through launching everything, then what? Is there enough demand to meet
the supply? And will there continue to be enough demand? Right, to meet the supply levels
inside of the industry. Because, you know, we're seeing more and more of these launchers
spin up, which means we're going to be able to take more and more of them up. And we're
probably going to be able to take up more. As these launchers come online, we may be
able to take more up than the 10% growth year over year, which means some of these companies
just simply will not survive. It's impossible for us to have that many launchers. All right,
next up. From U5KO, also off of YouTube, I hate to be a buzzkill, but I can't bring myself
to care about micro launchers. I simply don't see how they could ever have any implications
beyond low Earth orbit. This is far from the frontier. May as well just be taking up, or
talking about weather balloons. No, I disagree. So low Earth orbit is important as well. Just
because we've done it for a long time doesn't mean that A, it's easy, or B, there isn't
stuff, cool stuff that we can do there. Right, let me equate that. Well, we even talked about
the small sets learning from each other and being able to communicate and. Skynet. Right,
exactly. But, think about the cell phone market. Before the iPhone came along, you had, or
smart phone market, you had the Palm Pre and the Trios and the. Right. Right, and they
all sucked. They really sucked, and they were awful, but we had smart phones forever prior
to that. Forever, right. I mean, for a really long time prior to that, and then we started
seeing some innovation in that market space, and we started getting like the iPhone and
the Android phones, and, yeah, those two. I was going to say Windows Mobile, but, you
know, whatever. So, and you see, and the, I figured I'd just jab, no good reason to
jab Windows Mobile, it was fun. But now, I mean, now look at your phones. They're truly
amazing and remarkable, but, you know, back in the day, they really, you couldn't imagine
anything that was awesome and awe-inspiring. Well, I can make the same argument for low
earth orbit. Low earth orbit's kind of like the smart phone era of yesterday, the Palm
Pre and the Trio, where we haven't done really, we haven't figured that out. We haven't cracked
that nut. We haven't done that thing that makes it just really freaking awesome, and
when we do, it's going to be like that huge shift from that to an iPhone, and so it doesn't
seem exciting right now today, but it can be, and it will be. Right. Even with these
small sats, these Nano and Pico launchers, we can do some really cool things, be it with
internet access, communication, imagery, imagine live, real-time imagery, video of
the entire earth, streaming 24-7. You can zoom into whatever area you want that's getting,
I mean. So instead of watching the webcams of Patricia, you can see it from space? Sure,
but you could actually be able to zoom in and out, and, I mean, there's some really
cool things you can do from lower altitudes, or even higher altitudes, as long as you have
a lot of them, and you don't need these huge vehicles or spacecraft that we're using today.
All right, next up. All right. You're done with that one. Everyone gets it. I made my
point, and whether they agree or disagree, they get my point. This one comes from Horn
and Hoof Records off of Twitter. Horn and Hoof Records. Exactly. I wanted to say that.
Hashtag TMRO, hashtag TMROCon needs to happen. So I said that in jest, the TMROCon, the Con
of Tomorrow, at, like, Epcot or something like that. Right. It'd be fun. I think we
need to be bigger before we can do it. We just passed, by the way, congratulations to
the Community of Tomorrow. When we moved from the Spacevidcast YouTube channel over to the
TMRO YouTube channel, we lost, we started from zero. We lost, like, everybody. We lost
everyone. We started from zero, so we went from 20,000 subscribers to zero subscribers.
We've just now crossed the 5,000 subscriber mark, so congratulations, Community of Tomorrow.
We've made it back up one quarter of where we were before. Now, I'm sure a lot of those
were, like, bots and other weird things that don't actually count. It was a good culling.
Yeah, yeah. Good culling. You are the chosen few, as it were. By the way, if you're watching
the show and you haven't subscribed to our YouTube channel, please subscribe. The subscription
helps us. Helps us with advertising revenue and everything else and showing that we're,
you know. Legit. Legit. Legit. So, yeah, YouTube likes to see those numbers. So, yeah, I think
we need to be bigger before we do a Con of Tomorrow. If you guys disagree and if we can
get, like, 100 or 200 people to get together, then I think it makes sense. Yeah, see, that
number's too big. The number's too big. Challenge accepted. I think, I don't think there are
100 or 200 people that would get together for something like that. Yeah, because there's
not, like, 100 people watching the show live right now at all. Oh, you know, there might
be. Yeah. I don't know, there's, look at that. Yeah, that was exactly my point. I'm so glad
you picked up on that. But what I'm saying is, would they all be willing to travel to
Florida? Right. Yeah, I don't think so. That I don't know. I bet it'd be 1% of this whole
list, so I bet it'd be, like. Well, willing or able. Those are two different things. Irrelevant.
They are, I mean, they're two different things, but would they go to Florida, whether they're
willing or able. Interesting. All right. And finally. We're done with this, and finally.
This one comes from Sarah Hill, also off of Twitter. Is it a tradition now to get mad
at Dutta in every episode? Yes, because in every episode, he screws something up. Says
the man who screwed up first. That's irrelevant. I didn't. And so we only get mad at Dutta
when, not if, but when. Note how Dutta doesn't get mad at Ben when he screws up. He's screwing
up my show. Note how Dutta does not get mad at Ben. You don't know. Yes, I do, because
I know Dutta. No, he's throwing up his arms. He's like, aw, Ben, aw, he screwed up again.
See, look, look, he's mad. You can tell. Look how upset he is. That poor man. Look at that.
Look at that. You can tell. How does he do it? I don't even. Day after day, week after
week. It's a good thing we pay him, because otherwise he wouldn't stick around. Seriously.
He's laughing. Yeah, no. We only give him trouble when he screws up the show and wipes
to black or does something. He did that last show. He didn't wipe to black. He did a DVE,
a digital video effect. Yeah, he did that. Yes. He did that, but to black. It's very
Star Wars. Which is why I said in that quote, Dutta, which he will get any time he screws
up the outgoing part of the show. On that note, let's see how he takes us out of this
particular show. I'd like to thank everyone so much for watching. After Dark is up next.
If you're a Patreon plus subscriber or higher, that's available on demand as soon as it's
posted, at least. For everyone else, it'll be available in about four weeks. Now, just
as a housekeeping note, I said I wasn't going to do it this episode, but I'm going to. I'm
seeing this now. Two weeks from now, on November 5th, I think it is. 6th? 7th? November 7th.
There we go. I had to go the other direction. On November 7th, there will be no show. So
we have one more show, and then no show on November 7th. And as we start getting towards
the end of the year, quite frankly, the shows are going to get a little bit more sporadic.
We may show one week, not the next week. On and off, on and off. So check our Twitter
account over at twitter.com slash tmro for our show schedule and whether we be live that
particular week. I'd like to thank everyone so much for watching, and we'll see you next
