Virgin of the Rocks

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
5 Video Views·Nov 23, 2022
We're in the National Gallery in London,
and we're looking at the second version by Leonardo da
Vinci of The Virgin of the Rocks.
There's another version in Paris.
This, they think, is the second version, perhaps some
of it completed by Leonardo's assistants.
And we should remember when we read that, that that's
how artists worked, right?
That was normal.
It was not a big deal.
They had a workshop.
They had assistants.
Assistants sometimes helped to complete
the work of a painting.
And the idea, of course, is that the work of a painting
is really not the actual painting,
but it's also the idea.
Especially important for Leonardo.
So why is it that there are two versions?
And why such a long period for this painting?
It was started in 1491.
It wasn't finished until 1508.
And you can actually argue that it was never finished.
The commission was started, and Leonardo was promised a bonus
when he completed it.
But the bonus that he got didn't live up to what he expected.
And he sold it to somebody else.
He apparently gave the painting to someone else,
and then he had to work on a second version.
And that's what this is.
The Virgin of the Rocks is an interesting subject.
Because for me, I normally think about Mary
seated on a throne in heaven.
Here we have another way of presenting Mary,
which is Mary seated on the ground,
as a type of image of Mary called the Madonna of Humility,
showing Mary's humility seated on the ground.
Also means that the natural world
has become a kind of throne.
Or is it more exalted than it would have previously
been understood?
In other words, I think in the Renaissance,
nature itself is given a kind of respect
and a kind of attention.
But that's quite a landscape.
This is not just a meadow, as we might see in a Raphael.
So maybe we should actually just focus for a moment
on who everybody is and what's going on here.
We have the Virgin Mary, who's the primary figure
and really functions at the top of that pyramid of figures.
She's embracing with her right arm
a child, a baby, slightly larger of the two,
slightly older of the two.
And that would be John the Baptist,
who in turn is praying to the figure that
is in turn blessing him.
And that is the Christ child.
And then over to the right is an archangel.
And we can barely make out her wings behind her.
Mary's gestures and the position of her body
are incredibly graceful.
She tilts her head to the right, kind of shifts her shoulders
over.
Her hips move in the other direction.
The way the right arm reaches out,
the left hand comes forward, the position of her body
is very complex.
And to me, that's really the signal
we're in the high Renaissance.
And of course, that's what Leonardo develops
is this new high Renaissance style where
we have bodies that move very gracefully in very complex ways
and compositions which are unified.
As you said, this one, where all the figures make up
the shape of a pyramid.
It's interesting.
As I'm looking at it, it seems as if Mary's hand
on John's shoulder is actually a fairly stern one,
almost as if she's directing John to Christ.
And look at the painting virtuosity here.
Look at the way in which her other hand, her left hand,
is foreshortened.
It seems to encapsulate the space that Christ exists in,
but is in no way directing him.
And then, of course, there's that angel,
which looks on with a kind of beauty and a kind of elegance
that is breathtaking.
That speaks of the divine and this heavenly space
that they occupy.
And you're right, if you think about it
the way you just described it, which
is that Mary's sort of ushering John toward Christ,
and Christ existing in a space unto himself
in a kind of extra-divine realm within this divine realm.
It really helps to make sense of those gestures.
And remember that in the foreground
is a very still body of water, which
can have a kind of double reference, both to Mary's
purity, that undisturbed water, but at the same time
a kind of foreshadowing of the baptism of Christ
by John many years later.
And of course, this is an apocryphal story
of their meeting as they both flee
the massacre of the innocents.
And we know that this was commissioned
by the confraternity of the Immaculate Conception in Milan.
And that may have a sort of secondary set of references
referring to her purity again, and the way
in which this painting seems to really emphasize that.
You've got the purity of the water.
You've got the protected garden, all metaphors.
And then you've got that flash of yellow
across her waist, which really draws attention.
And the fact that all these figures and their faces
and their arms are all surrounding
that sort of oddly empty central space.
And sort of revolve around that space of her womb.
The atmospheric perspective is gorgeous.
And the darkness of the painting is striking,
especially as you look around at other Renaissance paintings.
And this is a technique that Leonardo
developed called sfumato, which means
a kind of smoky haziness, where figures
seem to emerge from the darkness of the background.
And they don't have any of those hard lines around them.
And I think this is also part of that high Renaissance
softness and grace.
There's a kind of accuracy to the anatomy of the figures,
to the botanical specimens, and even to the geology here,
that I think also reminds us that Leonardo was not just
a painter, but was somebody who understood the natural world,
was fascinated, and studied the natural world.
And painting was one part of that series of professions.
Leonardo took that to an extreme.
But that was also true of so many Renaissance artists
that interest in anatomy and science,
although Leonardo is the quintessential Renaissance man.
