- 여러분의 후원은 큰 힘이 됩니다. 하나은행 (주)에포크미디어코리아 415-910022-14004
중국은 지구상에서 가장 인구가 많은 국가이자 성행하는 장기이식 산업의 본거지이기도 하다. 하지만, 지난 10년 간 대부분의 장기들이 기증에 의한 것이며 사형수에게서 적출한 것이 아니라는 당국의 발표와는 달리 필요에 따라 양심수들을 살해해 적출한 것이라는 보고들이 등장했다. 전 세계의 연구자들은 새로운 증거를 찾아내 인권 유린의 실체와 규모를 폭로하고 있다. 2016년 6월, 세 명의 독립 조사자들은 반박 불가능한 증거를 담은 680쪽 짜리 보고서를 발간했다. 제가 알기로 중국은 세계에서 유일하게 정부 주도 산업으로 사람을 죽이고 장기를 판매하는 국가입니다. 보시게 되면 병원들의 목록이 아주 자세히 나와 있죠. 무수히 많은 대형 병원들이 무수히 많은 이식 팀을 통해 이식을 실시하는데... 얼마나 많은지 보고 정말 놀랐습니다. 한 두 군데가 아니었어요. 공식 발표로만 해도 6~10곳에 달했죠.
China is the most populated nation on earth and home to a booming organ transplant industry.
However, over the past decade, reports have emerged that the majority of organs are not
sourced from death row prisoners and donations, as stated by officials, but rather from innocent
prisoners of conscience murdered on demand. Researchers across the globe are uncovering
new evidence that shows the true nature and scale of these abuses. In June 2016,
three independent investigators jointly published a 680-page report of irrefutable evidence.
China, to my knowledge, is the only country in the world where the government
run industrial program, kills people and sells their organs.
Endless hospitals in here. We go into them in great detail. We're talking about a large
hospital, endless amounts of transplant surgeries and transplant teams.
I was really surprised how high the number was. I mean, as I say, it's
multiple, between six and 10 are the official figures.
Hearings were held by the U.S. Congress, the British Parliament, the European Parliament,
and the Canadian Parliament. The U.S. House of Representatives unanimously passed a resolution
condemning the systematic state-sanctioned organ harvesting from non-consenting prisoners
of conscience. China's killing for organs is making a major appearance across media outlets
all over the world. In 2006, it first came to light that prisoners of conscience were being
killed on demand for organ transplants in secret detention facilities throughout China.
The first two researchers to investigate were David Kilgore,
former Canadian Secretary of State for Asia-Pacific, and David Matus, an international
human rights lawyer. When we started in 2006, I mean, I didn't know where the trail would lead
or what the conclusion would be. The initial surprise and disappointment was that this was
true, that it was happening throughout China, and it was happening from 2001 to the date of our
report. Kilgore and Matus released their first report in July 2006 and later published the book
Bloody Harvest. Around the same time, Ethan Gutman, an independent investigative journalist
based in London, spent seven years doing his own research before publishing The Slaughter in 2014.
We made the point that it was really prisoners of conscience, we believe,
are making up the bulk of these organs that are out there. And we came, as David Kilgore and David
Matus and I, came to this same conclusion using very different procedures, but we did come to
that conclusion. The investigators joined forces, researched hundreds of transplant hospitals in
China, and released their new report in 2016. The three investigators were nominated for the Nobel
Peace Prize for their work. Discovering exactly how large the transplant industry is in China
and how many victims there have been is difficult. The researchers spent a decade
piecing together the evidence. For example, in September 2013, Director Zhu Jie of the
Liver Transplant Center at the People's Hospital of Peking University told China Economic Weekly,
our hospital conducted 4,000 liver and kidney transplants within a particular year.
So we had to cross-check everything. So when we had posted volume numbers,
we cross-checked it against staff, against beds, against research publications, against
media reports, against the purchase of immunosuppressive drugs. I mean,
every which way we could. And what we were able to do by all this cross-checking is develop a
consistent picture. And in that particular case, we came to the conclusion that, yes,
this claim of 4,000 was real. Shenzhen Central Hospital, they have 500 beds. It's actually over
that now. 500 dedicated transplant beds. Now, they were claiming in their internal communications at
several points to be doing 131% occupancy. What that means, again, 20 to 30-day stay,
what it suggests is they're doing about 5,000 transplants per year.
These examples show that China's official claim of 10,000 transplants per year is easily surpassed
by just a few hospitals. But these two hospitals are just the tip of the iceberg. The investigators
found that more than 1,000 transplant hospitals applied for permits from the Ministry of Health
in 2007 to continue doing transplants. That suggests these hospitals met the Ministry's
minimum capacity requirement for transplant centers it certifies.
169 were eventually selected. If you assume hospitals just operating at the minimums,
never mind actual, our actual estimate is closer to 100,000 a year.
The researchers found other evidence of a massive transplant system,
some of it from Chinese officials themselves. He Xiaoshun, a member of the expert committee
of the Human Organ Donation Commission stated, the number of transplants increased by 10 times
between 1999 and 2000, and further tripled by 2005. That's a 30-fold increase in six years.
Wu Mengchao, known as the father of liver surgery in China, told the media in 2011,
China now performs the most liver transplants in the world. Since 2000, the entire United States
has performed an average of about 6,000 liver transplants a year. This could be matched by
just a few hospitals in China. They had this endless supply of organs available on demand,
and the only limit was capacity. And so what you saw after 2001 was this huge building boom,
new beds, new wings, new hospitals focused on transplants. And so that the volume,
when the system's operating at capacity, increased year by year.
The report shows that just the 169 hospitals approved by the Ministry of Health could have
performed over one million transplants since the year 2000. Many more hospitals were also
doing transplants despite not having been certified. Organ transplantation has been
continuously incorporated into the national five-year plan and has become a high priority
in China's national strategy. A large number of organ transplant research and training projects
are funded under the major national programs and funds. The investigators found that China
International Transplantation Network Assistance Center, CITNAC, listed transplant prices for
foreigners on its archived website. It was bringing in about nine or ten billion dollars a year.
This industrial transplant operation going on across China now, it's a lot of money, a lot of
hospitals are financing a lot of their activities through that. They're watched very, very closely
indeed by the top leadership, so they're fully aware of this. As well as the fact that Wang Lijun,
one of the, the Bo Xilai was a contender for the Chinese presidency. This was his right-hand man.
He was the most famous policeman in all of China. Here he is directing organ trafficking. I mean,
he had a center which did this. He was given an award for doing this and specifically for coming
up with a new lethal injection method. He did thousands of transplants by his own admission
in the award ceremony. He talks about that. CITNAC website stated, we need to give all of
the thanks to the government for the support extended for our completing such a large number
of organ transplants every year. This is a one of a kind in the world. Researchers were particularly
struck by one aspect of these transplants. Unlike anywhere else in the world, they were being done
on demand. In countries with advanced organ donation and allocation systems, patients must
usually wait years for a donor to become available. Yet in China, waiting times are
commonly in weeks. The 2006 liver transplant registry report showed that 27 percent of samples
were emergency transplants. That means they found a new liver within days or even hours.
It was back in 2005 when a patient of mine who has been on the top list of patients for human
heart transplantation came to me one day and told me that he was told by his insurance company,
his Israeli insurance company, to go to China in two weeks time as he was scheduled to undergo
heart transplantation. And when I asked him how come such a surgery can be scheduled ahead of
time, you know somebody has to die on the very day of the operation, he said he didn't know and
he went to China and got his heart transplantation exactly on the date that he was promised.
One hospital in southwest China claimed to have donors seeking matched recipients and also
promised, in case of failure, we will continue to perform transplants until one is successful.
In 2006, a chief surgeon of the organ transplant center at a traditional Chinese medicine hospital
published a study of 50 patients at his hospital who had each received kidney transplants two,
three or four times. Another example that I can't get out of my head is a man from a country who
went twice to China. First time he went, they brought him four sets of kidneys and none of
the four was compatible with him. Three months, four months later he came back and they gave him,
bought him four more sets of kidneys until finally the eighth kidney worked and when we saw him he
was doing fine but eight human beings have been killed. In northeastern China, the International
Transplantation Network Assistance Center stated on its website, China carries out kidney transplants
from living sources. It's completely different from cadaveric kidney transplants in Japan.
Because they have a bank of live donors waiting to get a match on the computer.
Some like some horrible restaurant where you go in and see a lobster and say,
I want that lobster and the lobster is killed. It's a crime against humanity.
The Chinese government claimed that the vast majority of organs came from death row prisoners
and later donations. However, international organizations estimate that the number of
death row executions at thousands each year since 2000 and decreasing. Chinese tradition
requires that bodies remain whole after death. There was no organ donation system in China before
2010. Even today there are very few donations. Therefore, these two sources combined account
for only a tiny fraction of all transplants performed in China. China started performing
transplants with organs harvested from executed prisoners at a small scale in the 70s. In the
following years, it also started using organs from prisoners of conscience.
In 1999, the crackdown of Falun Gong starts. That is the largest action of scale
by the Chinese Communist Party since the Cultural Revolution. And by 2000, 2001,
that's when you have this explosion of transplant activity. We see continuity in the numbers over
time. Falun Gong is a, as I call it, it's kind of a Buddhist revival group. It doesn't have
churches and so forth. It doesn't have temples. What it has is sort of common beliefs. These
shared beliefs revolve around self-improvement based on the values of truthfulness, compassion,
and tolerance. By the end of the 1990s, the Chinese government estimated that over 70 million
of its citizens were practicing Falun Gong. Jiang Zemin, the head of the Communist Party
at the time, saw Falun Gong's popularity and revival of traditional values as a threat to
his rule and launched a violent campaign to eradicate it in July 1999. Hundreds of thousands
of Falun Gong practitioners from all over China traveled to Beijing to appeal to the central
government, only to be arrested and tortured. When many refused to disclose their identities
to protect their families and friends, they became part of a large anonymous population
held captive by the state. More practitioners were rounded up all across China. This is when
large numbers of them started disappearing without a trace. The official line in terms of repression
of Falun Gong by the party is bankrupt them financially, ruin their reputations, destroy
them physically. So that the vilification is destroying their reputations, the organ
transplants is destroying them physically. There's the physical examinations, the blood testing,
the organ examination, which have no other explanation than suitability for a transplant.
It was like convert or die. Convert or die. Turn in your friends or die. And it's state-sponsored
genocide. We did not expect after the Holocaust to see this kind of medical corruption come around
again. How can doctors, people trained to heal, harvest organs from living people for transplants?
Educated and raised in China, Enver Toti is an ethnic Uyghur surgeon,
currently living in London. He was told to extract the organs from a living prisoner in 1995.
They made you disabled to think yourself. My whole body just become a robot, just
performed to do what I have been programmed to do. So anybody, if they label it themselves,
other than communism, communist party or member, then they will be treated as an
enemy of the state. Therefore, they are not even qualified as human being.
And therefore, they are subject to whatever punishment is available.
They made you genuinely believe what you are doing is for a good cause.
It is little later, I realized I shortened this man's life. That is equal to a killer.
I killed him. These things haunting me. I have to tell the world to release
and the things inside my heart to get a little relief.
In February 2017, Freedom House, an international human rights watchdog, published its own report
on religion in China. It noted that a review of available information regarding organ transplants
had found credible evidence suggesting that beginning in the early 2000s, Falun Gong
detainees were killed for their organs on a large scale. It added that the large-scale
disappearance of young Uyghur men, accounts of routine blood testing of Uyghur political
prisoners, and reports of mysterious deaths of Tibetans and Uyghurs in custody should raise
alarm that these populations may also be victims of involuntary organ harvesting.
I think, Gina, the first thing before you believe or you decide whether or not you want to believe
is you have to learn the facts. The facts are there. The books are there. The research is there.
Read it. Once you read it, I'm sure there will be no other way for you but to believe it. And we
have to, we, I'm talking about the physician, have all to be together in order to stop it immediately.
Until 2005, we didn't have no law. I found out that Israeli insurance companies and HMOs have
been providing reimbursement, full reimbursement, for these transplants of Israelis who went to
China and got these illegal organs. So together with my friends, we sat down with our parliament,
the Knesset, and in 2008, the Israeli parliament has enacted the organ transplant law,
which totally bans any reimbursement of illegally obtained organ transplantation
anywhere around the world. And since then, not a single Israeli patient went anymore to China.
In addition to Israel, Spain, Italy, and Taiwan have passed laws restricting their citizens from
traveling to China to receive an organ transplant from an illicit source. The systematic government
sponsored harvesting of organs is a monstrous crime. I strongly believe that the 17-year
campaign to eradicate Falun Gong will be seen as one of the great shames of recent Chinese history.
Since I've been a student of the Holocaust, I feel that to a certain extent what we're seeing
is just a continuation of what we saw there in another form, which is the endless and bottomless
depravity of human nature. I mean, there's no limit to the form of evil that people can sink.
When I was writing The Slaughter, I sometimes said, though, I'm writing history, and then at
the end of it, I realized I wasn't. It was actually still going on.
This is a new form of genocide, and it's using the most respected members of society to implement it.
This is one of the central tests of our time. We can't avoid this any longer.