Alberti, Façade of Santa Maria Novella, Florence

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
10 Video Views·Nov 22, 2022
We're in the piazza just in front of Santa Maria Novella
in Florence, and we're looking at a facade that
was redesigned by Alberti, the great Renaissance architect.
Santa Maria Novella is an important Gothic church
here in Florence.
One of the two mendicant churches in the city.
And by that we mean churches founded by the begging orders,
the orders of monks who begged for a living,
the Dominicans and the Franciscans.
And Santa Maria Novella is a Dominican church.
Now, Alberti is coming here in the mid-15th century,
and his patron is Giovanni Ruccellai,
for whom he also designed a palace just a few blocks away.
And Ruccellai inherited the patronage rights
to this church, but he inherited it
from a family that had already begun to design the facade.
Alberti had some serious problems here
because he was a classicist.
That is, he wanted his architecture
to conform to what he believed to be
the ideals of classical beauty, which
were based on perfect geometry and rational order
and proportion.
And copying of the rules of architecture
handed down from ancient Rome via the ancient Roman architect
Vitruvius.
And the problem is that this was a Gothic church,
and Gothic is anything but orderly.
So he took this Gothic church and on it
put a classical facade that also recalls
the Romanesque tradition of Italy,
specifically the Baptistry of Florence and also
the Church of San Miniato al Monte,
which is just outside the center of the city of Florence.
And we can see that, especially in the linear geometric
patterns that we see, the alternating
of the white marble and this green stone.
So Alberti had an issue.
Not only was he dealing with a Gothic church,
but there was a pre-existing facade that
was only partially complete.
We're not sure how much of it was there,
but we think that a number of tombs
had already been put in place, of which six remain.
As modern viewers, we hardly recognize
that those niches are, in fact, tombs, but that's what they are.
And just above them, we see those Gothic arches,
which we also think predate Alberti.
So what Alberti does with this lower story
is that he frames it.
On each end, he gives us a column accompanied by a pier.
The column has a Corinthian capital.
And in the center, he gives us a doorway modeled on the Pantheon.
So what had been there before was a small doorway.
And Alberti gives us a magnificent entryway.
In fact, it's easy to picture what that original doorway
would have looked like, because two earlier doorways still
exist.
So he defines the edges of the building for us.
He defines the center with plasters
with Corinthian capitals, a carvered vault
over the entrance.
We see these references to ancient Roman architecture.
But we also see a reference at the top
to an ancient Greek temple front.
It is clearly a temple front.
We have a pediment, just like we would expect
to see on the Parthenon in ancient Greece.
And we see squared attached columns,
plasters supporting it.
And that Greek temple front caused a problem for Alberti.
If you look at the four plasters that
support the pediment above it, those four plasters
are not aligned with plasters below them,
as would be appropriate in a classical building.
And of course, Alberti was all about following the rules
of classical architecture.
So what he does is he wants to distract us.
And he does that really well.
He creates this attic zone, and he fills it
with this decorative pattern of squares.
With patterned circles within them.
It creates a zone of isolation between the top and the bottom.
There is a sense of rigor and geometric order
here, aside from that one deviation.
In fact, the whole facade fits into a square.
And that square can be subdivided
into additional squares.
If you look at the bottom zone of the church,
you see that you have two of those squares.
And then above that, a single centered square.
So he's got yet another problem to solve,
which is that he's got this very tall nave inside the church,
and then the shorter aisles on either side.
So how do you unify those two?
And he comes up with an ingenious solution.
That is to use these S-shaped scrolls to unify
the top and bottom stories.
Now, he hadn't invented the idea of the scroll.
This time, he's borrowing it from the lantern
on Brunelleschi's dome, which is just
a couple of blocks away.
And then he also puts a rosette inside that scroll.
And so it echoes the round window
in the center of the building.
And that roundel is also repeated above,
in the pediment, where we see a child's face
in the middle of a sunburst, communicating
the idea of the resurrection of the afterlife.
Least we forget who was paying for all of this.
Just below that sun, we see Giovanni Rucellai's name
as patron.
We also see his family insignia in the wind-blown sails
that decorate the frieze.
Those sails are meant to reference the idea
that he hoped that, through his faith,
he might sail to salvation.
The Rucellai were a very wealthy family in Florence.
But the Rucellai were not as wealthy and powerful
as the Medici family.
We see the Medici crest, the diamond with three feathers
emerging from it, right over the central doorway of the church.
So we can see expression of the Rucellai's loyalty
to the Medici here.
And it's so easy to walk by this church and miss all of this.
But the 15th century is alive here in Santa Maria Novella
in Florence.
