The rumor is that wet ropes are significantly weaker. The instructions that come with the rope say that it is dangerous. Climbing magazine advises not to use a wet rope. UIAA supposedly got 3 falls instead of 7 like normal, before it broke. What are we supposed to think and do when we end up with a wet rope?
00:00 Measuring and Weighing Wet Ropes 05:30 Dry treated rope Slow Pull 11:01 Standard rope slow Pull 17:15 Drop Tower
Are climbing ropes weaker when they are wet? According to a climbing.com article,
a climbing rope can lose up to 70% of its dynamic properties and even a dry rope up to 40%.
But what happens when a curious YouTuber puts it to the test?
Oh it looks like it's raining.
Hi I'm Ryan Jinks and welcome to my lab where we are going to figure out once and for all
if wet ropes break lower. In the research I did do I found out they stretch lower
and so they don't they lose their elongation and so if you were to take a whipper on a wet rope
it's going to give you a higher peak force because it's not going to stretch as much and it's not
going to absorb the fall as much and you might break sooner but does the rope break sooner?
We're going to slow pull test it we're also going to drop test it but first I want to know a little
bit more about wet ropes. So I'm going to take this 70 meter rope I'm going to cut it in half
and I'm going to find out after a couple minutes how much water it absorbed and we're going to
keep putting in the water until it stops getting heavier. The ends are relaxed and they are the
same length on this side. It's got a middle mark that's not exactly in the middle that's funny.
Super super close enough five it decided on five this is going to be our wet sample and we're going
to put it in this bin but before we do that let's measure the other one they're both five pounds.
Start there's a lot of air bubbles that's pretty cool 60 seconds 6.26 four minutes
boom so after a total of five minutes we got 6.9 pounds now I'm going to leave it in there for
an hour. Okay it's been an hour this thing is waterlogged it is no longer floating about 7.3
that is a uh that's a big difference. I don't think you want your ropes wet just because
they're heavier. I'm now going to let that sit for three more hours and I want to rant real quick
quite a few comments in our frozen rope video that we didn't soak the rope long enough.
How long do you think it takes for a bottle to freeze? Like this has sat in the water for an
hour and it's very saturated. Those blocks of ice took at least that long to harden up enough like
that stuff was sitting in water basically all night until until the ice formed. So while I
wait for those ropes to finish soaking I thought I'd search a little bit more for an answer to see
if ropes break lower when they're wet. Oh this guy doesn't look very smart let's see if we can
get an answer from him. Excuse me sir do ropes break lower when they're wet? Well everything's
better when it's wet. Well that's not helpful I need to go. So it's been four hours since I put
this in here 7.26. So it really hasn't changed much from one hour to four hours so I think it's
super wet enough to start testing. Let's see if it changed length and lay it back down on the ground
over there. Did you calibrate that scale? Yeah to zero. Oh my god stop at the end of the driveway
or when you get to the end of this rope. He's on belay right now. Oh my god speed climbing rope.
Let's find out if this is the same length and we're gonna find out how many comments I get for
laying this on the ground before break testing it. As if it's going to obscure our numbers.
Comments are good for the algorithm good or bad so just leave them below. There you go step on it
that's good for it. All right hold both ends. What are you doing? That the wet one is longer.
Isn't that the whole point of the experiment? It was supposed to get shorter. It was shorter until
you pulled on it it's that's not enough of a difference for me to consider any conclusive
evidence here. So what you're saying is that the wet rope really doesn't matter? It hasn't mattered
up to this point other than I wouldn't want to carry one. There you go. Weird a 9.8 rope is
approximately 9.8 who would have thought 10.3 10.1 it's not that much of a difference depends what
like earlier I did get 10.8 legitimately 10.8 millimeters a full millimeter thicker.
Wet ropes get longer and fatter huh? Definitely not typical. No? No. What do they normally do?
Mine always get shorter. Yours get shorter when it's wet? The water's cold. Now I'm not saying
that nylon properties don't change when they're wet they absolutely do. Nylon loves to
absorb water even if it's just humid out and it will swell and it'll lose its dynamic properties
which means it will catch you not as softly and I think that's what we're trying to explore here is
if that part matters. What I was shocked about is the dry treated rope where the core and the sheath
of this sterling rope are treated to not absorb water as easily and it actually got 145 percent
of its weight absorbed in water. I was also surprised that Rocky Talky is giving a 24 percent
off discount for 24 hours. How is that for a smooth transition? They actually are super cool.
This is one of their biggest discounts they've done. These aren't flash sales on crap you don't
want. This is actually a really good Rocky Talky. I hit them up to promote them because I liked it
so much. The discount code is going to be on extremegear.org in the dry treated rope sections.
Go through all those ropes in one of them underneath the specs you're going to find the
discount code and anything you buy on extremegear.org is going to help support this channel
10 percent. The full price items are and these are available but now we're going to break test this
wet and dry sterling rope to see if there's a difference. A couple fun facts we're going to
learn. We're going to learn if this short tail matters. We're going to find out that backup knot
matters. We're going to find out if our freedom units piss people off. We're going to measure
how much distance it travels in order to break because this rope has supposed a 28 elongation
but that is only at a specific force not at its breaking strength. When you pull one strand
it deforms the knot drastically. All right so now I hit 4.3 and you can see how much
it's going down as it settles so that's also some bonus material for you. Look at how bad
these knots are. That is not a recognizable figure eight if you ask me and this is only at 4.4
kilometers. Let me disappoint you. Are you ready? If you're here in the lab with me you actually
don't get to enjoy the break test. You have to stand around the corner. You can watch the episode
later to find out what happens. Oh really? I bet even hard is easy couldn't untie this guy.
Look at that. It looks like a rope. Oh is that our tail doing just fine over here?
Oh my gosh the rope broke in the knot. Whoa wow this is sure exciting. So it's kind of fun. It
goes up quickly and then doesn't. 15.5. So one strand was left behind and it's part of that knot
and it comes all the way over here to the core that came out after the sheath broke
and scrunchied up on me and I can't really unscrunchy it not much and that knot is rock
hard. What's really cool is we had a pop our first pop and for like a whole nother second
continued up and then finally came down. We're all getting consistent enough results between
14.7 and 15.5. What do you think's gonna happen with the wet rope? It's gonna break.
Wet or frozen ropes will be seriously weakened. Wait what? Wet or frozen ropes will be seriously
weakened and may stretch more. It is best to not use a wet rope. What? Wait a minute.
Do you get that on your canyon ropes instruction manuals that say don't get this wet? I really
want to look now. Oh oh that's juicy literally and we're gonna change the slow-mo because the
slow-mo is the most important thing not the science because if you're not gonna do real
science you gotta look good doing it. It broke right here in the knot and it went around here
and through and we got some wet fibers here got some scrunchy action the number is lower
and we've got that double break thing going. If you're ever wondering how to untie your knots
quickly just finish pulling them harder. Oh that thing's pissing all over my slack stamp machine
just the way I like it.
It was kind of a weak pop compared to the other ones. It's because it's wet it's extremely
dangerous didn't you read the instruction manual? I do like the fact that the core gets
like left behind while the sheath breaks first that's that's pretty cool. Any
profound thoughts about wet ropes? I bet you this rope doesn't weigh as much anymore.
Apparently that was a dry rope we tested and I can already read the comments before I even
post the video oh that was a dry rope of course it didn't absorb enough water of course it didn't
break low enough but I have a Edelrid 9.8 meter boa from REI it's a gym rope so they don't dry
treat gym ropes because well hopefully you're climbing inside if you're in a gym. It's interesting
what you have to do to make the mob happy but then again a manufacturer can calculate a theoretical
strength that everybody's like all right cool uh-huh all right 47 feet I'm gonna stick in the
water and we're gonna weigh occasionally and do the percentage difference and how much it
calculates and yada yada it's late let's go do this we're at zero pounds this is 2.02 pounds
one minute oh look at Bobby Bobby's here we're gonna have a party
a science party yeah what are we doing oh we're we're getting things wet oh two one can you hold
that all right you want me to stop it dinging sure that would be great okay after one minute
a very wet non-dry non-dry rope that started at about two pounds it's 2.96
50 percent in a minute that is pretty fast it's not much more it's 3.14 it absorbed the water
pretty quick so let's leave it in for an hour and see if it actually retains even more water
been an hour we're sitting at 3.2 pounds so more more than 50 percent I think we started about two
pounds so we'll we'll see if it breaks a lot different in the slow pull machine and then we
have this that we can use on the drop tower our slow pull samples are already in here and we're
just going to leave it in overnight I don't think it's going to absorb more water and I even put the
dry rope which is now very wet in here so we have something for the drop tower as well
and it stays wet so we'll put the lid on it so it doesn't get wet what I'm gonna do
let's go to bed so you can see here that the non-treated rope got 155 percent of its weight
absorbed in water as opposed to the dry treated rope got 145 percent and it's not actually that
much of a difference you can see all these graphs and data and chart in the blog which we will link
in the description below which I will update if new and important information comes in or research
papers I never found before making this video I can't update an update video but I can update the
blog so make sure you check that out also sign up for the emails if you want me to tell you about
these videos when they come out in case you're missing these splash sales the YouTube algorithm
isn't always going to tell you it's out and keep in mind that this whole video is based on nylon
ropes there are polyester ropes technor and dynema and those are completely different animals or
materials speaking of different materials our shirts come in different materials how's that
for a smooth transition this is a cotton shirt we have nice polyester shirts and you can go to
hownottoswag.com you can grab all sorts of designs that the cute girl behind the camera is making
and if you hashtag how not to swag then I will go to Instagram pull those off when I'm done editing
a video and throw you at the end of our videos and maybe even on our store as a model now we're
going to break test this non-treated rope that is going to be dry and wet to see how much different
it really is broke here it went around this way and came through that is a rock hard knot
16.17 that's actually kind of cool it goes up quite quickly
same result same side very very same result
finally it broke on this side I don't know why it rarely does that
okay this thing's been sitting in here all night let's grab these three samples and see what they
break at yes yes wet ropes are weaker is a myth okay doing its thing breaking like it does
no I closed that damn it oh I think this this hits this all right 13.91 it's a little weaker
it's a little weaker now I think it's a little ironic that the non-treated standard rope didn't
break as low as the dry treated wet rope and I don't think we broke enough things for that to
I'm not saying that dry treated ropes break lower if we did a hundred of each with the variations
knots bring to the table I think they may have broken the same and I'm drawing all those
conclusions off of only three tests take it for what it's worth now they did all technically break
lower but was it enough to put a danger warning on my instruction manual to scare the out of me
well tying a figure eight reduces the strength of my rope 50 percent they didn't put a warning
label there I would like to see more context or somewhere I can go explore this that I can see the
context in what they're talking about why they are making these claims so I can make judgment calls
on the fly when I might not have a choice whether or not I need to keep going when my rope is wet
now keep in mind the ropes we're talking about in this video are all nylon polyester technor
dyneema ropes they all have different things going on this doesn't really apply to those
but we also have different materials in these shirts I keep changing into
trying to be as smooth as I can with these plugs and this is a soft shackle that's pretty rad but
I do want to bring up the fact on extremegear.org we just got hundreds of discontinued colored
trango carabiners which means we can discount those 10 until they run out this is not a flash
sale and we can mix and match draws for you so you can make alpine draws or just buy the carabiners
and if you do buy something on extreme gear you can get stickers now which we include
free with your order right now we have these super good enough stickers available
that you can stick on your Nalgene bottle that you're not going to clip to your harness anymore
because you saw our other video like to introduce you to my new buddy Decker so you don't have to
we've got a bad bolts kill shirt yellow pants because that's what we do around here
and we've got some information here for you so this is a 90 pound dummy that has clothes on a
harness and that's not 90 pounds nothing's ever what the label says interesting what's interesting
is we've been using these things and they're 75 pounds so I mean we're just trying to figure out
the force on our non-dry dry rope and we're going to drop this a couple times and then do the wet
Decker's first fall so you don't have to oh you nailed the distance on that thing
Brent just pulled this out of the water like it's still quite wet
Brent what do you think it's going to do no I think it's just going to squeeze out all the water
and it'll be way less heavy this is the moment of truth
does our wet non-dry rope get a much higher force
oh it looks like it's raining oh it looks like it's raining
Decker you're doing great down there bud look 205 that's like the same
on this one it looks like we did get some slippage that's the knots closer to the
than it was you're saying is the wet rope had more lubrication so it slipped possibly it didn't
didn't slip all the way into the jam so the conclusion is this whole video is for nothing
nothing's dangerous uh this whole video is to stop all the pointless fear-mongering
wait we're breaking gear fear we're gonna do the non-wet dry dry rope first wow that's confusing
so it slipped a little bit one finger yeah yeah i thought it was going to be jammed up but um
watching this this totally like un-cammed because he was weightless for a minute as he was falling
two one
right in the range 3.19 it's the same that's uh less for me guys do wet ropes absorb more force
or do they slip in the greegrees more no it didn't slip at all oh but oh you just took away at least
100 comments i would have gotten about the greegree slipping and throwing our tests off
2.25 what we did have happen is this did slip and got jammed now as you can see from our
sexy bar graph here that there wasn't much of a difference granted decker is not that heavy
but where does this gear fear come from that wet ropes are like dangerous well the uia a years ago
i believe tested a wet rope and instead of getting the seven falls before the rope breaks they got
three falls but i think it's important to understand the context in how they did that
they're taking an 80 kilogram weight that's heavy by the way it's steel which means it
absorbs nothing and it's technically the equivalent of more than 80 kilograms and they
drop it from with a 1.8 factor fall and that is 1.8 times more falling than they have rope in the
system not attached to a greegree eights to eights and then it snaps that's pretty much the worst case
scenario you could ever ever ever get in a fall but does that apply to us they got three falls
instead of seven that's a huge difference but we didn't really get much of a difference at all in
this situation so there's got to be something in between you're gonna die and there's no difference
it might just be super good enough but what's better than super good enough is this hat sorry
i'm trying to plug too many things in one video but this is seriously a good deal with the rocky
talky thing it really does help support this channel if you use the link in the description
below to buy these after the sale since i'm still not making any money on affiliate links because we
keep giving away all our profit uh with all the money you save buying this feel free to donate
it really does go all back into this channel as you can see we are trying to make an effort to
make this content better we're trying to give you graphs and data and blog it and i'm running this
by a bunch of people before i even post it not to get too nerdy in the weeds but just make sure that
i'm not saying too many stupid things and trying to give more of a balanced approach if you
appreciate all that effort please hit the subscribe button because that actually gives me
more opportunities to do bigger and bigger and better videos even if you smash the bell notification
so it tells you when i put out a video it doesn't actually always do that so make sure you sign up
for email i'll post when i post a video so you know videos are out especially ones with flash sales
so you don't miss it and a little bit behind the scenes which be kind of where the monday update
videos are kind of morphed into more written content go check out our blog go check out our
website and buy stuff cheers