Worth It? $10 vs. $2800 Fountain Pen

Goulet Pen Company
7 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 14, 2022
Hey there, Brian Goulet here of gouletpens.com and I get asked all the time about fountain pen
prices and if they're worth it and can you compare this pen to that pen and so on
and I normally shy away from it but today I'm just going to lean hard into it. So today we're
going to take a look at three different pens, one that is ten dollars, one that's eight hundred
dollars and one that's twenty eight hundred dollars. We're going to start out with the
This is a Chinese made fountain pen. It's metal, it's fairly utilitarian but it looks very pretty,
very glittery, very kind of shiny. It's a great kind of intro level pen for anybody getting into
fountain pens. It has a stainless steel nib, it's available in medium nib only so it's not a lot of
options but in terms of its writability it's a pretty decent all-around performing pen and it
gets a lot of love in the pen community just because it's a fairly reliable writer for the
price. It also has a number six size steel nib and you can swap that out with a few other brands nibs
which expands some of its utility. I don't actually know much about how this pen is made
but if I had to speculate it would probably be something not much more elaborate than what my
six-year-old daughter would do with a bunch of glitter glue because that's kind of what it looks
but there's something very satisfying about that to the eye and it doesn't come in any fancy
packaging or anything. You basically just get the pen so it's really the kind of thing that
you might just buy for yourself and use. Maybe give it to somebody else, give it to your kids
and you wouldn't really sweat it too much. All around it's a really good value pen but you know
you're not getting a ton of bells and whistles with this. So if we want to take a step up from
here, actually a rather big step because we're going to go from ten to eight hundred dollars,
we have the Pilot Vanishing Point Rodan Stripe. Now there's a couple different Rodan versions of
this pen and the Vanishing Point itself is a model that is available in the less expensive
versions. This is kind of the more top-of-the-line version for this particular pen but the first
thing you'll notice is that the pen comes in a box which is something you might expect of a pen in
this price range. The packaging is pretty clean, pretty straightforward. You know it's got this
nice kind of lining in here and the pen is just kind of nested neatly in here and it comes with
all the accoutrement that you might expect as far as cartridge and various such things. And the pen
itself is a step up for sure. So this pen comes with an 18 karat gold nib which is going to be
a little bit springier than the steel nib. It's going to have a consistent flow and write very
smoothly. It's also available in a variety of tip sizes so you can get a variation in the line width
that you would write with depending on the nib size that you have put into here. And they also
make the nibs available as separate units so you can change it out and mix up the utility of your
pen. And it's a click retractable nib which is something kind of unique to the Pilot Vanishing
Point model and again this is the higher end version of it. So whereas other models might just
be a painted version, this one uses a Rodan technique which is a Japanese technique that
actually you inlay abalone shell and then you use yurushi lacquer over top of it. And yurushi is
this specific type of lacquer that comes from a yurushi tree. It's one of the hardest natural
materials in the world and it takes months for it to properly cure. It's a technique that was
developed in Japan and it is something that takes a lot of time to do so part of what you're paying
for is a lot of the labor in producing this. They have to cut and position every single individual
piece of abalone shell in this very specific pattern and that takes time. There's expense in
the abalone shell, there's expense in the craftsmanship that these artisans use to develop
their skills over years and years, and then producing the individual pens takes a while
and there's a lot involved in doing it and that is part of why it immediately jumps up pretty
significantly in price. So where do we go from here? That's already a pretty dang nice pen and
one outside of the realm of what probably most people would consider in their pen budgets, but
we can go nicer so let's do it. We have the Namiki Yukari Nightline Moonlight. Now part of what you
might be paying for is the name because there's so much packed in there, but right off the bat you
can see it comes in a much larger box. The presentation itself is going to be part of the
experience and you open it up. It's got a nice little flap here so you can easily get to the
real wood box that you get with this thing. It's a really nice wooden box. I'm a huge fan of wood
myself and I think it makes for a great presentation. It makes it so that if you want to display this
thing or present it as a really high-end gift for somebody, it's going to be received quite well.
You got all kinds of goodies in here. You have a card from the individual artist because pens at
this level, the artist actually designs it and signs their name when they are working on it as
well as a letter saying, hey I hope you enjoy this rocking pen or something to that effect.
You get some nice foam in here to protect it. It comes with a bottle of ink and then the pen
itself is nestled in this nice red velvet kind of crushed interior. The pen itself is pretty
darn awesome. It's not an incredibly large pen. Some of these pens can go up even from here, but
this is one of the nicest full-rodden pens that I've seen. You see here the entire pen is covered
in rodden abalone shell as well as yurushi lacquer. Essentially a lot of what you're paying
for is the additional material and the additional time that went into the artisan's craftsmanship
when they were producing this pen. The shell, there's a lot of it. It's laid out in a kind
of a specific pattern, but I know specifically that the Namiki artists that are doing this
yurushi work, they're placing these shells in more or less a similar position from pen to pen,
but they do have some artistic liberty to change up the design a little bit from one pen to another.
Because they're working with a natural shell, the actual individual shell pieces are going to be
different on every single pen, so there's a lot of individuality that goes to it. Then of course
down here on the bottom the artist signs their specific name and characters down here so you
know that you're getting a pen made by the hands of that individual artist. So this pen also has
a gold nib, larger gold nib than what's on the Vanishing Point, and fits very comfortably in the
hand and it's made to write really well. Is it going to write significantly better than an $800
pen? No. There's going to be a law of diminishing returns. A pen can only write but so well. A lot
of the increased price that you're paying for is the craftsmanship of the actual piece, but it's
still a fantastic everyday writer. The nib is going to be springy, it's going to have good flow,
and it's going to perform really, really well. And the last note about pens in this price range is
these are not something that is mass-produced. It might take four to six months to produce a pen
of this caliber, and so it's going to be something that's extremely limited, which is going to add
to the scarcity which could also impact the price and availability of a pen like this.
Now no matter which one of these three that you consider, I personally think that they can be
justified for different reasons for their given price points. I think the Jinhao is going to be a
fantastic starter pen and kind of a good knock around pen for anyone who wants to just get into
fountain pens. I think the Vanishing Point is a fantastic everyday writer when you want a piece
of art in your hands that you're not afraid to use functionally, and I think if you're getting
more into the kind of collector grade pens, a real piece of artwork tied to an individual artist,
that's what the Yukari Nightline Moonlight is going to do for you. I think they're all fantastic
pens, and I really enjoyed showing them off to you here today. I would love to know which pen you
think is the most worth it and why down in the comments below. Be sure to like, comment, and
subscribe to this video if you like it, and if you want others, we got plenty of them. So be sure to
check out what we have going on, and you can see all three of these at GouletPens.com. Thanks so
much for watching, and write on!
